DOCSLIB.ORG

The Weimar Constitution: Important Articles

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text

Load more

THE WEIMAR CONSTITUTION: IMPORTANT ARTICLES. (bold added) CHAPTER ONE: ORGANIZATION AND FUNCTIONS OF THE REICH SECTION I: THE REICH AND THE STATES Article 1. The German Reich is a republic. The political power emanates from the people. Article 2. The territory of the Reich consists of the territories of the German states. Other territories may be incorporated in the Reich by a national law, if their populations so desire by the right of self-determination. Article 3. The national colors are black, red, and gold. The commercial flag is black, red, and white, with the national colors in the upper-inside corner. [the former colors were of the Frankfurt Parliament of 1848; the latter of the Second Empire of 1871-1918.] Article 4. The universally recogniZed rules of international law are accepted as integral and obligatory parts of the law of the German Reich. [Articles 6 to 11 were long lists of the broad categories and specific items of legislation that the Reich government was empowered to enact. The power of taxation was given in detail, and the relationship between national and state powers of taxation described.] Article 12. As long as, and in so far as, the Reich does not make use of its powers of legislation, the states shall retain the power of legislation. Article 13. National laws are superior to the laws of the states. [in case of a conflict the matter will be decided by “a superior judicial court of the Reich.”] Article 17. Every state must have a republican constitution. [i.e. none of the traditional monarchies of the länder survived.] [Article 18 described in great detail how the alteration of state boundaries and the creation of new states were to be done.] SECTION II: THE REICHSTAG Article 22. The deputies [of the Reichstag] shall be elected by the universal, equal, direct, and secret suffrage of all men and women over 20 years of age, according to the principles of proportional representation. Election day must be a Sunday or public holiday. Article 23. The Reichstag shall be elected for a four-year term. A new election shall take place no later than 60 days after the expiration of its term. The Reichstag shall assemble for its first meeting no later than the 30th day after election. Article 25. The President of the Reich may dissolve the Reichstag, but only once for the same cause. A new election must be held no later than the 60th day after the dissolution. [Articles 26-40 spelled out the internal officers of the Reichstag and its legislative procedures; also the rights and obligations of members. Article 35 tried to guard the rights of the Reichstag against executive interference during the period between sessions and after the end of a legislative term.] SECTION III: THE PRESIDENT OF THE REICH AND THE NATIONAL MINISTRY Article 41. The President of the Reich shall be elected by the whole German people. Every German who has completed his 35th year is eligible [to serve as President]. Article 43. The term of office of the President shall be seven years. Reelection is permissible. Before the expiration of his term the President may be removed from office by popular vote on resolution of the Reichstag. The resolution of the Reichstag requires a 2/3 majority vote. If the popular vote fails to remove the President, such vote shall be regarded as a new election of the President and a dissolution of the Reichstag shall follow. The President may not be subjected to criminal prosecution without the consent of the Reichstag. Article 44. The President of the Reich may not at the same time be a member of the Reichstag. Article 45. The President of the Reich represents the Reich in international relations. Declaration of war and conclusion of peace shall be made by national law. Alliances and treaties with foreign states which relate to subjects of national legislation require the consent of the Reichstag. Article 47. The President of the Reich shall have supreme command over the entire military forces of the Reich. Article 48. If a state fails to carry out the duties imposed upon it by the national constitution or national laws, the President of the Reich may compel performance with the aid of armed force. If public order and safety be seriously disturbed or threatened within the German Reich, the President of the Reich may take necessary measures to restore public safety and order; if necessary, with the aid of armed force. For this purpose he may temporarily suspend in whole or in part the fundamental rights enumerated in Articles 114, 115, 117, 118, 123, 124 and 153. The President of the Reich must immediately communicate to the Reichstag all measures taken by virtue of paragraph 1 or 2 of this Article. On demand of the Reichstag these measures must be abrogated. Article 50. All orders of the President of the Reich, including those concerning armed force, require for their validity the counter-signature of the Chancellor or of the competent national minister. Article 52. The National Ministry shall consist of the Chancellor and the national ministers. Article 53. The Chancellor and, upon his recommendation, the national ministers shall be appointed and removed by the President of the Reich. Article 54. The Chancellor and national ministers must have the confidence of the Reichstag for the exercise of their offices. Any one of them must resign if the Reichstag withdraws its confidence by express resolution. [Articles 55-59 spell out in general terms the powers and responsibilities of the Chancellor and national ministry for legislation and related matters. Article 59 introduced a clumsy procedure for the impeachment of the President of the Reich, the Chancellor, or any minister by a resolution by a 2/3 vote of the Reichstag presented to the Supreme Judicial Court for decision.] SECTION IV: THE REICHSRAT [Articles 60-67 established a state council which met most of the demands of the states for a role in national legislation and mean that Weimar would be a federal government. However the role of the Reichsrat in national legislation was mainly consultative. It was to be kept informed of legislation, it could dissent, but its dissent could be overridden by the national ministry in agreement with the Reichstag or by a 2/3 vote of the Reichstag. To prevent the domination of Prussia, no state was entitled to more than 2/5 of the representatives in the Reichsrat.] SECTION V: NATIONAL LEGISLATION. Article 68. Bills shall be introduced by the National Ministry, or by members of the Reichstag. National laws shall be enacted by the Reichstag. [Articles 69-72 set out the roles of the President, the national ministry, the Reichstag, and the Reichsrat in legislation.] [Article 73. Described the complicated provisions for referenda. The President could initiate a popular referendum on a bill passed by the Reichstag; one-third of the members of the Reichstag could request a popular referendum on a bill if the referendum were also requested by 1/20th of eligible voters; 1/10th of voters could petition for referendum on a a bill that was being proposed by the ministry or Reichstag.] [Article 74 was another complicated provision for a referendum to be called by the President to resolve a dispute between the Reichsrat and Reichstag that couldn’t be overridden by a 2/3 vote of the Reichstag.] [Article 76 provided that the constitution could be amended by 2/3 of the Reichstag or the Reichsrat and by popular referendum requiring a simple majority. ] SECTION VI: NATIONAL ADMINISTRATION. [Articles 78-101. Described the methods by which the Reich government administered the constitution and laws.] SECTION VII: JUSTICE [Articles 102-107. Provided that judges for “ordinary jurisdictions” shall be appointed for life. Prohibited extraordinary courts and military jurisdictions in time of peace. (note: during Weimar most judges had begun their careers during the Second Empire.)] Article 108. A Supreme Judicial Court shall be established for the German Reich in accordance with a national law. CHAPTER TWO: FUNDAMENTAL RIGHTS AND DUTIES OF GERMANS SECTION I: THE INDIVIDUAL Article 109. All Germans are equal before the law. Men and women have in principle the same civil rights and duties. Privileges or discriminations in public law based upon birth or rank are abolished. The state may not confer orders and decorations. Article 110. [assured all Germans of equal rights under state law.] Article 111. All Germans shall enjoy freedom of movement throughout the whole Reich. Article 112. Every German has the right to emigrate to non-German countries. All German citiZens within and without the boundaries of the Reich have the right of protection by the Reich against foreign countries. No German may be extradited for prosecution or punishment by a foreign government. [note: this last provision implicitly denied the Allied right to try Germans for war crimes.] Article 113. The foreign language parts of the population of the Reich may not be interfered with by legislative or administrative action in their free racial development, especially in the use of their mother tongue in education, as well as in the communal administration and the administration of justice. [note: even in this formal context, “race” appears where ethnicity or nationality is meant.] Article 114. Liberty of the person is inviolable. Persons who have been deprived of their liberty must be informed no later than the following day by what authority, and upon what grounds, the deprivation of liberty was ordered; without delay they shall have the opportunity to lodge objections . [i.e., the premise of habeas corpus] Article 115. The dwelling of every German is his sanctuary and is inviolable.
Recommended publications
  • Hitler's Speech to the Reichstag, 1 September 1939

    Hitler's Speech to the Reichstag, 1 September 1939

    Hitler's Speech to the Reichstag, 1 September 1939 ...If I call the Wehrmacht, if I now demand the German people to sacrifice, and if necessary, I demand to sacrifice everything, I have the right to do so. Because I am ready today, as I did in the past, to bring any personal sacrifice, I do not demand of any German man to do anything I was not prepared to do myself for four years. There should be no deprivation in Germany that I will not share. My entire life belongs from this moment on to my people. I want nothing else now than to be the first soldier of the German Reich. I have now put on the same uniform that was once my dearest and holiest. I will only take it off after the victory, or else I will not live to see that end. Should something happen to me in this battle, my first successor will be party member Goering. Should something happen to party member Goering, the next in line will be party member Hess. You would then be bound by blind loyalty to them as Fuehrers , as you were to me. Should something happen to party member Hess, I will enact a law that the senate will then elect the worthiest, i.e. the bravest from their midst. As National Socialist and as a German soldier I am going into this battle with a brave heart. My whole life was nothing but one continuous battle for my people, for its renewal, for Germany. This battle was always backed by the faith in this people.
  • Paper 3 Weimar and Nazi Germany Revision Guide and Student Activity Book

    Paper 3 Weimar and Nazi Germany Revision Guide and Student Activity Book

    Paper 3 Weimar and Nazi Germany Revision Guide and Student Activity Book Section 1 – Weimar Republic 1919-1929 What was Germany like before and after the First World War? Before the war After the war The Germans were a proud people. The proud German army was defeated. Their Kaiser, a virtual dictator, was celebrated for his achievements. The Kaiser had abdicated (stood down). The army was probably the finest in the world German people were surviving on turnips and bread (mixed with sawdust). They had a strong economy with prospering businesses and a well-educated, well-fed A flu epidemic was sweeping the country, killing workforce. thousands of people already weakened by rations. Germany was a superpower, being ruled by a Germany declared a republic, a new government dictatorship. based around the idea of democracy. The first leader of this republic was Ebert. His job was to lead a temporary government to create a new CONSTITUTION (SET OF RULES ON HOW TO RUN A COUNTRY) Exam Practice - Give two things you can infer from Source A about how well Germany was being governed in November 1918. (4 marks) From the papers of Jan Smuts, a South African politician who visited Germany in 1918 “… mother-land of our civilisation (Germany) lies in ruins, exhausted by the most terrible struggle in history, with its peoples broke, starving, despairing, from sheer nervous exhaustion, mechanically struggling forward along the paths of anarchy (disorder with no strong authority) and war.” Inference 1: Details in the source that back this up: Inference 2: Details in the source that back this up: On the 11th November, Ebert and the new republic signed the armistice.
  • Power Distribution in the Weimar Reichstag in 1919-1933

    Power Distribution in the Weimar Reichstag in 1919-1933

    Power Distribution in the Weimar Reichstag in 1919-1933 Fuad Aleskerov1, Manfred J. Holler2 and Rita Kamalova3 Abstract: ................................................................................................................................................2 1. Introduction .......................................................................................................................................2 2. The Weimar Germany 1919-1933: A brief history of socio-economic performance .......................3 3. Political system..................................................................................................................................4 3.2 Electoral system for the Reichstag ..................................................................................................6 3.3 Political parties ................................................................................................................................6 3.3.1 The Social Democratic Party of Germany (SPD).....................................................................7 3.3.2 The Communist Party of Germany (Kommunistische Partei Deutschlands – KPD)...............8 3.3.3 The German Democratic Party (Deutsche Demokratische Partei – DDP)...............................9 3.3.4 The Centre Party (Deutsche Zentrumspartei – Zentrum) .......................................................10 3.3.5 The German People's Party (Deutsche Volkspartei – DVP) ..................................................10 3.3.6 German-National People's Party (Deutsche
  • Introduction to the Weimar Republic

    Introduction to the Weimar Republic

    Handout Introduction to the Weimar Republic Directions: Write a D next to information about the Weimar Republic that represents characteristics of a democracy and an X next to information that describes problems or challenges for a democracy. From Monarchy to Democracy D X After World War I, Germany’s political leaders sought to transform Germany from a monarchy to a democracy, called the Weimar Republic (1918–1933). The Weimar Constitution divided power into three branches of government. Elections were held for the president and the Reichstag (the legislature), while the judicial branch was appointed. The Weimar Constitution D X Adopted on August 11, 1919, the new Weimar Constitution spelled out the “basic rights and ob- ligations” of government officials and the citizens they served. Most of those rights and obliga- tions had not existed in Germany under the kaiser, including equality before the law, freedom of religion, and privacy. Despite the inclusion of these rights in the Weimar Constitution, individual freedom was not fully protected. Old laws that denied freedoms continued, including laws that discriminated against homosexual men and “Gypsies” (the name, considered derogatory today, used to describe two groups of people called the Sinti and Roma). The Reichstag D X Germans voted for a party, rather than a candidate, to fill the Reichstag (the German legisla- ture). The elections determined the percentage of seats each party received in the Reichstag, but the parties themselves selected the individuals who filled each allotted seat. For example, if a party received 36% of the vote, they would get 36% of the seats in the Reichstag.
  • Lesson 8: Handout 1 Timeline: Hitler’S Rise to Power

    Lesson 8: Handout 1 Timeline: Hitler’S Rise to Power

    Lesson 8: Handout 1 Timeline: Hitler’s rise to power 1. 1919 — Weimar Constitution is adopted. The constitution creates separate executive, judicial, and legislative branches of government so that one group or person cannot hold all of the power. It also includes articles protecting civil liberties (freedoms) such as freedom of speech, freedom of assembly (freedom to meet in public), and freedom of religion. The constitution also protects privacy so that individuals cannot be searched without the court’s permission. 2. 1919 — The constitution includes Article 48. This article suspends the constitution in times of emergency, allowing the president to make rules without the consent of the parliament and to suspend (put on hold) civil rights, like freedom of speech, in order to protect public safety. Many people thought this article was a good idea because there were so many political parties in Germany that sometimes it was difficult for them to agree enough to pass any laws. At times of crisis, like the inflation Germany suffered in 1923 or the depression in 1929, it was important for government to respond quickly and not be held from action by politicians who can not agree. Thus, many Germans thought it would be wise to have a clause in the constitution that would allow the president to take over and make quick decisions in times of emergency. 3. July 1932 — The Nazi Party wins 37% of the votes. For the first time, the Nazis are the largest and most powerful political party in Germany. Still, over half of the German citi - zens do not vote for the Nazis and they still do not have enough seats in the Reichstag (parliament) to be able to pass laws without getting additional votes from representa - tives from other political parties.
  • Die Deutsche Nationalhymne Und Die Flagge Einigkeit Und Recht Und

    Die Deutsche Nationalhymne Und Die Flagge Einigkeit Und Recht Und

    Transkript des Podcasts Slow German www.slowgerman.com Die deutsche Nationalhymne und die Flagge Einigkeit und Recht und Freiheit für das deutsche Vaterland. So beginnt die deutsche Nationalhymne, über die ich Euch heute etwas erzählen möchte. Lange Zeit hatte Deutschland keine eigene Hymne. Es gab verschiedene Lieder, die bei wichtigen Ereignissen gespielt oder gesungen wurden. 1922 einigte man sich auf eine neue Hymne: Das Lied der Deutschen. Der Text des Liedes stammt von August Heinrich Hoffmann von Fallersleben, es ist ein Gedicht von 1841. Heute heißt es auch das Deutschlandlied. Es hat drei Strophen. Auf slowgerman.com findet Ihr den gesamten Text. Während der Nazizeit wurde nur noch die erste Strophe gesungen, die wir heute nicht mehr singen. 1949 suchte man eine Hymne für die neu gegründete Bundesrepublik Deutschland. Es wurde das Lied der Deutschen - allerdings die dritte Strophe. Die Hymne singen wir heute bei Fußballspielen und Staatsempfängen. Sonst sind die Deutschen eher vorsichtig mit patriotischen Liedern und Symbolen, anders als viele andere Länder. Die Musik der Hymne stammt übrigens von Joseph Haydn. Er komponierte das Kaiserquartett 1796/97. Und wie sieht es mit der deutschen Flagge aus? Ihre Farben sind schwarz, gelb und rot. Wir sagen aber "Schwarz-Rot-Gold" dazu. Wieso nun gerade diese Farben? Dazu gibt es eine schöne Legende, wer weiß, ob sie stimmt... Angeblich gehen die Farben auf das Jahr 1152 zurück. Damals wurde Barbarossa zum deutschen Kaiser gekrönt. Sein Weg führte ihn bei der Krönung über einen schwarz-rot-goldenen Teppich. Nach der Krönung wurde der Teppich in kleine Stücke geschnitten, als Souvenir für die Bürger.

  • Weimar Constitution

    Weimar Why was the new government called the “Weimar Republic”? Weimar Constitution LO: To evaluate the strengths and weaknesses of the Weimar Constitution Political Spectrum • Despite the unrest, the Provisional Government moved towards establishing a permanent institutions in Germany, and elections for the Constituent Assembly were scheduled for 19th Jan 1919. • There were many political parties that cover the range of ideologies. KPD USPD SPD ZP DDP DVP DNVP (NSDAP) • Copy and complete the table below, showing the main beliefs of these political parties (pg 5+7) Name Foundations Aims Support Lesson 1.1.2 To evaluate the strengths and weaknesses of the Weimar Constitution 1919 elections • Women were allowed to Party Number of seats vote for the first time. SPD 163 • SPD secured the largest ZP 91 share of the votes (38%) DDP 75 the largest number of DNVP 44 seats (163) in the USPD 22 Assembly. DVP 19 • However, they failed to Others 7 reach an overall majority so had to compromise • Ebert was elected the first with other parties to President govern and establish a • Scheidermann was new constitution. appointed Chancellor Lesson 1.1.2 To evaluate the strengths and weaknesses of the Weimar Constitution Weimar Constitution Create your own diagram for the Weimar Constitution. Must include explanations of: President, Chancellor, Reichstag, Landtag/Lander and the voting system. (Pg 7) Strengths and Weaknesses of the Constitution • Create a table showing the strengths and the weaknesses of the Weimar Constitution. Lesson 1.1.2 To evaluate the strengths and weaknesses of the Weimar Constitution Plenary essay question – conclusion • ‘The Weimar constitution was not democratic nor did it provide the basis for stable government.’ • Assess the validity of this view.
  • On the Commander-In-Chief Power

    On the Commander-In-Chief Power

    Georgetown University Law Center Scholarship @ GEORGETOWN LAW 2008 On the Commander-In-Chief Power David Luban Georgetown University Law Center, [email protected] Georgetown Public Law and Legal Theory Research Paper No. 1026302 This paper can be downloaded free of charge from: https://scholarship.law.georgetown.edu/facpub/598 http://ssrn.com/abstract=1026302 81 S. Cal. L. Rev. 477-571 (2008) This open-access article is brought to you by the Georgetown Law Library. Posted with permission of the author. Follow this and additional works at: https://scholarship.law.georgetown.edu/facpub Part of the Constitutional Law Commons ON THE COMMANDER IN CHIEF POWER ∗ DAVID LUBAN BRADBURY: Obviously, the Hamdan decision, Senator, does implicitly recognize that we’re in a war, that the President’s war powers were triggered by the attacks on the country, and that [the] law of war paradigm applies. That’s what the whole case was about. LEAHY: Was the President right or was he wrong? BRADBURY: It’s under the law of war that we . LEAHY: Was the President right or was he wrong? BRADBURY: . hold the President is always right, Senator. —exchange between a U.S. Senator and a Justice Department 1 lawyer ∗ University Professor and Professor of Law and Philosophy, Georgetown University. I owe thanks to John Partridge and Sebastian Kaplan-Sears for excellent research assistance; to Greg Reichberg, Bill Mengel, and Tim Sellers for clarifying several points of American, Roman, and military history; to Marty Lederman for innumerable helpful and critical conversations; and to Vicki Jackson, Paul Kahn, Larry Solum, and Amy Sepinwall for helpful comments on an earlier draft.
  • Elections in the Weimar Republic the Elections to the Constituent National

    Elections in the Weimar Republic the Elections to the Constituent National

    HISTORICAL EXHIBITION PRESENTED BY THE GERMAN BUNDESTAG ____________________________________________________________________________________________________ Elections in the Weimar Republic The elections to the constituent National Assembly on 19 January 1919 were the first free and democratic national elections after the fall of the monarchy. For the first time, women had the right to vote and to stand for election. The MSPD and the Centre Party, together with the German Democratic Party, which belonged to the Liberal Left, won an absolute majority of seats in the Reichstag; these three parties formed the government known as the Weimar Coalition under the chancellorship of Philipp Scheidemann of the SPD. The left-wing Socialist USPD, on the other hand, which had campaigned for sweeping collectivisation measures and radical economic changes, derived no benefit from the unrest that had persisted since the start of the November revolution and was well beaten by the MSPD and the other mainstream parties. On 6 June 1920, the first Reichstag of the Weimar democracy was elected. The governing Weimar Coalition suffered heavy losses at the polls, losing 124 seats and thus its parliamentary majority, and had to surrender the reins of government. The slightly weakened Centre Party, whose vote was down by 2.3 percentage points, the decimated German Democratic Party, whose vote slumped by 10.3 percentage points, and the rejuvenated German People’s Party (DVP) of the Liberal Right, whose share of the vote increased by 9.5 percentage points, formed a minority government under the Centrist Konstantin Fehrenbach, a government tolerated by the severely weakened MSPD, which had seen its electoral support plummet by 16.2 percentage points.
  • The Anschluss Movement and British Policy

    The Anschluss Movement and British Policy

    THE ANSCHLUSS MOVEMENT AND BRITISH POLICY: MAY 1937 - MARCH 1938 by Elizabeth A. Tarte, A.B. A 'l11esis submitted to the Faculty of the Graduate School, Marquette University, in Part ial Fulfillment of the Re­ quirements f or the Degree of Master of Arts Milwaukee, Wisconsin May, 1967 i1 PREFACE For many centuri.es Austria. bad been closely eom'lect E!d \'lieh the German states. 111 language and eulture. Austri.a and Germany had always looked to each other. AS late as the t~tentieth century. Austria .st111 clung to her traditional leadership in Germany . In the perlod following the First World War, Austria continued to lo(!)k to Germany for leadership. Aus tria, beset by numerous economic and social problems. made many pleas for uni on with her German neighbor. From 1919 to 1933 all ;novas on the part of Austria and Germany for union, -v.71\ether political oreeon01;n1c. were th"larted by the signatories of the pea.ce treaties. Wl ,th the entrance of Adolf Hitler onto the European political stage, the movement fQr the Anschluss .. - the union of Germany and Austria .- t ook on a different light. Austrians no longer sought \.Ulion with a Germany v.ilich was dominated by Hitler. The net"l National $Gclalist Gertna,n Reich aimed at: the early acq'U1Si ,tiQn of Austria. The latter "(vas i mportant to the lteich fGr its agricultural and Batural reSources and would i mprove its geopolitical and military position in Europe. In 1934 the National Soci aU.sts assaSSinated Dr .. U.:. £tlto1bot''t Pollfuas, the Aust~i ..\n Cbaneellot'l in ,an 8.'ttcmp't to tillkltl c:ronet:Ql or his: eountry.
  • The Weimar Constitution

    The Weimar Constitution

    The Weimar Constitution Was the Weimar Constitution a source of strength or weakness for a successful democratic Germany? What is a constitution? A constitution is a set of unchangeable rules about how a country is to be governed and what rights the people should have. The President ● Elected every 7 years by everyone in the country. ● In charge of the German Army and Navy ● Appointed the Chancellor ● Had special powers in an emergency (Article 48). What was Article 48? Article 48 gave the President the power to pass laws - called decrees - without the support of the Reichstag in an emergency. This was good because…. …it meant that laws could be passed and actions could be taken even if the Reichstag couldn’t reach an agreement in an emergency situation. This was bad because… …a President could abuse this power because the Constitution didn’t specify what an emergency was or how long it could last. The Chancellor ● The equivalent of our Prime Minister. ● He was appointed and dismissed by the President. ● Without the support of the Reichstag, he would be unable to pass laws. ● He was usually a member of the Reichstag. The Reichstag ● It was voted for by all men and women over the age of 20 by a system called Proportional Representation ● It had the power to vote for or against laws put forward by the Chancellor Proportional Representation ● This was Germany’s voting system between 1919 and 1933 ● The number of seats in the Reichstag a party was given would match the proportion of votes they recieved in elections.
  • Brief Amici Curiae of 37 Appellate

    Brief Amici Curiae of 37 Appellate

    Nos. 16-1436 and 16-1540 ================================================================ In The Supreme Court of the United States --------------------------------- --------------------------------- DONALD J. TRUMP, PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES, ET AL., Petitioners, v. INTERNATIONAL REFUGEE ASSISTANCE PROJECT, ET AL. --------------------------------- --------------------------------- DONALD J. TRUMP, PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES, ET AL., Petitioners, v. STATE OF HAWAII, ET AL. --------------------------------- --------------------------------- On Writs Of Certiorari To The United States Courts Of Appeals For The Fourth And Ninth Circuits --------------------------------- --------------------------------- BRIEF OF AMICI CURIAE 37 APPELLATE LAWYERS SUPPORTING RESPONDENTS --------------------------------- --------------------------------- CHARLES A. BIRD Counsel of Record 4182 Ingalls Street San Diego, CA 92103 (619) 699-2406 [email protected] Counsel for Amici Curiae [Additional Counsel Listed At End Of Brief] ================================================================ COCKLE LEGAL BRIEFS (800) 225-6964 WWW.COCKLELEGALBRIEFS.COM i TABLE OF CONTENTS Page TABLE OF CONTENTS ...................................... i TABLE OF AUTHORITIES ................................. iii BRIEF OF AMICI CURIAE 37 APPELLATE LAWYERS SUPPORTING RESPONDENTS ... 1 INTEREST OF THE AMICI CURIAE ................. 1 SUMMARY OF ARGUMENT .............................. 2 ARGUMENT ........................................................ 4 I. How a Society