Policy Essay Reconstructing Justice: Race, Generational Divides, and the Fight Over “Defund the Police” Michael Javen Fortner Assistant Professor, Political Science CUNY Graduate Center October 2020 Key Takeaways ► The fate of defund measures in Minneapolis, Atlanta, and New York City document the ways in which the fight over “defund the police” is as much a conflict between young and old and left and center as it is between Black and white. ► The expansion of the carceral state was a bipartisan affair. Interpretations that put all the weight on white political interests unduly minimize the impact of violence on Black communities. The younger generation, however, bore the brunt of aggressive, discriminatory policing. ► National polls demonstrate that there is a great deal of confusion around the word “defund,” and most African Americans see it as something other than completely ridding cities of cops. ► Most Americans, especially Blacks, see room for community groups and non-law enforcement professionals, such as social workers and doctors, in a broader public safety strategy. The evidence recommends the same. The Niskanen Center is a 501(c)3 issue advocacy organization that works to change public policy through direct engagement in the policymaking process. NISKANEN CENTER | 820 FIRST ST. NE, SUITE 675 | WASHINGTON, D.C. 20002 www.niskanencenter.org | For inquiries, please contact
[email protected] Reconstructing Justice October 2020 Contents Introduction ......................................................................................................................................3 Part I: Violence, punishment, and Black public opinion ....................................................... 6 Part II: Black Lives Matter and the evolution of crime politics .......................................... 15 Part III: Race, generational divides, and the politics of “defunding” the police .......... 24 Conclusion .....................................................................................................................................