Guise and Excess in the Poetry of Barry Macsweeney
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
`I am Pearl': Guise and Excessin the Poetry of Barry MacSweeney Paul Batchelor NEWCASTLE UNIVERSITY LIBRARY ---------------------------- 207 32642 2 ---------------------------- PhD in English Literature Newcastle University September 2008 Abstract Barry MacSweeney was a prolific poet who embraced many poetic styles and forms. The defining characteristics of his work are its excess (for example, its depiction of extreme emotional states,its use of challenging forms, and the flagrancy with which it appropriates other writers and poems) and its quality of swerving (for example, the way it frustrates the reader's expectations, and its oppositional identification with literary antecedents and schools). I argue that MacSweeney's poetic development constitutes a series of reactions to a moment of trauma that occurred in 1968, when a crisis in his personal life coincided with a disastrous publicity stunt for his first book. I chart MacSweeney's progress from 1968 to 1997 in terms of five stages of trauma adjustment, which account for the stylistic changes his poetry underwent. In Chapter One I consider the ways in which the traumatic episode in 1968 led to MacSweeney embracing the underground poetry scene. In Chapter Two I examine the ways in which his 1970s poetry exhibits denial. In Chapter Three I look at Jury Vet and the other angry, alienated poetry he wrote in the early 1980s. In Chapter Four I look at 1984s Ranter, an example of poetic bargaining in which MacSweeney alludes to mainstream poetry in return for what he hopes will be a wider readership. In Chapter Five I consider Hellhound Memos, the collection that resulted from a period of depression MacSweeney suffered 1985- 1993. In Chapter Six I look at his most successful work, Pearl and The Book of Demons, in which he confronts and accepts the roots of his trauma. Using a combination of close reading, literary theory and biographical research, I explicate and evaluate MacSweeney's development in terms of his literary and cultural contexts. While accounting for the various styles and approachesMacSweeney undertook, this study shows his oeuvre to be remarkably consistent in its structure, imagery and poetic techniques. ii Contents Abstract ii Acknowledgements v List of Abbreviations vi Introduction Chapter One: How to Disappear Completely: 1967-71 13 On Kicking a Sacred Cow Up the Arse 13 Early Influences: The Boy From the Green Cabaret Tells of His Mother (1968) 16 Growing Up In Public: The Last Bud 28 Chapter Two: The Barry MacSweeney Hall of Fame: 1971-78 53 On Not Being Thomas Chatterton: Brother Wolf (1972) 53 On Not Being Jim Morrison: Just Twenty Two and I Don't Mind Dying (1971) 66 Chairman Bar and the Rat-bags Down at Earl's Court 74 An Unknown Legend in His Own Time: Odes (1978) 81 Chapter Three: Every Day I Write the Book: 1965 - 1983 95 Politics and Journalism 1965- 1979 95 An American Psycho in Newcastle:Jury Vet (1981) 108 All the Broken Dollpeople: `Wild Knitting' (1983) 118 Chapter Four: Desperate for Attention: 1984.86 123 Ranter's Bargain (1984) 124 Alias Smith: Fox Running and Ranter 132 The GreaterNorthumbrian Kingdom of Literary Excellence: 137 Briggf latts and Ranter The Pride of Fingal's Clan: `Finnbar's Lament' and Ireland (1986) 145 Ranter and Politics 151 iii Chapter Five: At the Crossroads: 1986-93 160 `No Mercy' (1986) 160 Hellhound Memos (1993) 164 Black Sun and the Poetry of Depression 181 Chapter Six: Victory Over the Black Sunne: 1994 - 2000 188 `I am Pearl' (1994) 188 The Questfor Redemption in Pearl 198 Bunting, Wordsworth, Perle and Pearl 205 'Forgive me for my almost unforgivable delay': The Book of Demons (1997) 211 On the Dangersof Finding One's Voice: `Daddy wants To Murder Me' 216 The Quest for Redemption in The Book of Demons 222 Conclusion 236 Bibliography 238 iv Acknowledgements I would like to thank the Arts and Humanities ResearchCouncil for the funding that enabled me to undertake this thesis; Newcastle University and the family of Barry MacSweeneyfor the use of the Barry MacSweeneyPapers; my tutor ProfessorW. N. Herbert; Andrew Duncan, Terry Kelly, Peter Riley and especially Jackie Litherland for granting interviews and/or sharing their collections of MacSweeneypapers with me; and my partner Rachaelfor all her encouragementand support. V List of Abbreviations Texts by Barry MacSweeney Cabaret The Boy From The Green Cabaret Tells of His Mother (London: Hutchinson, 1968) Boulevard Our Mutual Scarlet Boulevard (London: Fulcrum Press, 1971) Just 22 `Just Twenty Two - And I Don't Mind Dying' in Wolf Tongue pp.20-23 [first publ. as Just 22 and I Don't Mind Dyin': The Official Poetical Biography of Jim Morrison, Rock Idol, Curiously Strong, 19711 Memos Hellhound Memos in Wolf Tongue, pp. 186-192 [first publ. London: The Many Press, 1993] Demons The Book of Demons in Wolf Tongue, pp. 218-284 [first publ. Newcastle upon Tyne: Bloodaxe Books, 1997] South East Arts Review `The British Poetry Revival, 1965-1979' in South East Arts Review (Spring 1979) pp.33-46 Archive Material Archive: BM: 1/... Material from the `published' Barry MacSweeney Papers, Robinson Library Special Collection, NewcastleUniversity. Archive: BM: 2/... Material from the `unpublished' Barry MacSweeney Papers, Robinson Library Special Collection, Newcastle University. Archive: Boxes 1-30 Correspondence,review clippings and miscellaneous material from the Barry MacSweeneypapers, Robinson Library Special Collection, NewcastleUniversity. Secondary Texts Poetry Information Mottram, Eric., `MacSweeney/Pickard/Smith:Poets from North East England interviewed by Eric Mottram', Poetry Information No. 18 (Winter/Spring 1977-78) pp.21-39. The interview was recorded 14.12.74. V1 Unpublished texts Jackie Litherland interview An interview by the author. Terry Kelly interview An interview by the author. Duncan/MacSweeney A three-day interview undertaken in 1996 by Andrew Duncan. interview Most of the tapeswere later accidentally destroyed.Only the first two tapesremain. I have used a transcript of the interview, provided by Andrew Duncan. Barry MacSweeneyreading A transcript by the author of a tape recording of a reading given by MacSweeney, which includes lengthy introductions to the Hellhound Memos. vi' Introduction Principles When Barry Patrick McSweeney published his first poems at the age of 17 in Stand, ' he did so under his birth name of `McSweeney'. Every subsequent publication appeared under the variant spelling `MacSweeney'. Mc/Mac is from the Gaelic for `son of ,2 and this initial qualification (it is not quite repudiation) of the Name of the Father was re-enacted compulsively by MacSweeney in his poetry, which is full of part-identifications, appropriated identities, surrogate selves and self-applied names and titles. For more than thirty years, the emperor, rather than his new clothes, remained invisible; and in `Sweeno, Sweeno', one of the highlights of MacSweeney's last major work The Book of Demons, the poet informs us 3 that he is `two people - at least'. Most of his readers have been happy to concur, interpreting the range and diversity of MacSweeney's oeuvre as a sign of a fundamental lack of continuity and coherence: here surely is a poet who pursues multiple lines of enquiry; a poet who writes in various modes for confused reasons; a poet who has lost his way. However, as I became more familiar with MacSweeney's work, I noticed motifs, symbols, image clusters and phrases that, although they appeared decades apart, bore a striking similarity. Might incorporate MacSweeney's restlessness - his drive to master more styles and more voices into his repertoire - have distracted readers from a consistent underlying symbolic system? I began to conceive of MacSweeney's life's work as a series of reactions to a single moment of trauma. The trauma occurred in 1968, with the convergence of several events that MacSweeney related to his concern with fatherhood: the commercial success (but artistic failure) of his first book; the ridicule he suffered following a disastrous publicity stunt; and his girlfriend having an abortion. These events led to the writing of MacSweeney's first great poem, `The Last Bud', which enacts the traumatic moment in the form of an encrypted image his literary influences, complex and by pairing up main Basil Bunting and Jeremy Prynne. This thesis offers a chronological account of how MacSweeney's career develops in the wake `Six Poemsby Barry McSweeney',Stand, Vol 8, No 2 (1966)pp. 6-9 2 'Mc' is simply a variant form of 'Mac'; however, MacSweeneymay have held the widespreadbut erroneous Irish. opinion that one is Scottish and the other 3 `Sweeno,Sweeno', p.269 1 he of the trauma, as embracesexperimental poetics, carrying forward the successfulelements and rejecting the rest. In my early chaptersI refer to Bloom's theories on poetic influence, and in my later chaptersI make use of Kristeva's theorieson the link betweendepression and the compulsion to write poems.However, I have not attempteda purely theoretical approach,for I wanted to consider the impact of the social and literary contexts in which MacSweeneyworked: Bloom denigrate and Kristeva tend to these aspectsof a writer's life. To this end, I include a brief biographical sketch with each chapter. I am aware that biographical interest and speculation has often dominated the reception of this poet. I am also aware that, despite his complaints about critics focusing on his sociological significance, MacSweeney aided this process. Nevertheless,MacSweeney's self-mythologising demandssome consideration of how he uses biographical detail in his work, and I have focussed on the ways in which he transforms details of his private life in his art. MacSweeney is a poet of excess, and his finest moments occur when his poetry is all but overwhelmed by musical effects, by emotion, by allusion or by circumstantial details. One of MacSweeney's most distinctive characteristics is the alert, speedy responsiveness of his poetry: as soon as he became aware of a new voice, style or subject, he would appropriate it.