Slavery and the Context of Ethnogenesis: Africans, Afro-Creoles, and the Realities of Bondage in the Kingdom of Quito, 1600-1800

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Slavery and the Context of Ethnogenesis: Africans, Afro-Creoles, and the Realities of Bondage in the Kingdom of Quito, 1600-1800 SLAVERY AND THE CONTEXT OF ETHNOGENESIS: AFRICANS, AFRO-CREOLES, AND THE REALITIES OF BONDAGE IN THE KINGDOM OF QUITO, 1600-1800 DISSERTATION Presented in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree Doctor of Philosophy in the Graduate School of The Ohio State University By Sherwin Keith Bryant, M.A. ***** The Ohio State University 2005 Dissertation Committee: Approved by: Professor Kenneth J. Andrien, Adviser Professor Stephanie J. Shaw ___________________________ Professor Stephanie Smith Adviser Department of History Graduate Program © Copyright by Sherwin K. Bryant 2004 ABSTRACT Exploring the emergence of African slavery in the Kingdom of Quito, this dissertation argues that Quito was not only typical of large Spanish American slave societies, was in many respects the quintessential Spanish American slave society. Similar to New Spain and Peru, in Quito, African slavery emerged first within the urban center of Quito, and extended almost immediately to the kingdom’s rural periphery. A region dominated by a strong indigenous presence, the areas of modern-day Ecuador and southern Colombia were thought, until now, not to possess significant numbers of African-descended slave laborers. Nevertheless, the region was marked by slavery and possessed three principal slaveholding regions—Popayán, the north-central highlands, and the district of Guayaquil. Similar to other Spanish American slave societies, throughout Quito, Afro-Creole slave laborers commingled always with diverse racial and ethnic pools of coerced laborers. Although African slavery represented only one of several ways Spaniards chose to divide labor in the kingdom, enslaved Africans and their Afro-Creole descendants formed the critical quadrant of Quito’s work sector. Without them Spaniards would not have been able exploit the region’s natural resources on the scale witnessed over the course of the colonial era, as Andeans represented a highly visible, yet unstable labor source. Elites employed slave laborers as bodyguards, auxiliaries in conquest campaigns, and as a mobile supplemental labor force when Andeans proved unavailable due to death, migration, and resistance. Nevertheless, the role of the enslaved was not always auxiliary. From the earliest moments of the colony’s history, enslaved rebels and fugitives helped to order and reorder the colonial regime. Through flight, rebellion, and violent confrontation, the enslaved forced slaveholders into an array of arrangements, creating, at times, a context of fear that even judicial officials could not afford to ignore. The crown and its American surrogates responded to early colonial anxieties over slave flight and rebellion through a series of pragmatic ordinances and control measures, meeting out ii harsh punishments to incorrigible rebels and fugitives while maintaining a juridical space for slave laborers who complied with social norms and comported themselves as subjects of the Spanish King. Intended as a first attempt at providing the field with a comprehensive analysis slavery and slave life in the North Andes, this work looks comparatively at the realities of bondage in two of Quito’s three principal slaveholding regions—Popayán and Quito, while exploring Quito’s unique context for African and Afro-Creole identity formation. Unlike late sixteenth- and early seventeenth-century Mexico City, eighteenth-century Louisiana, and eighteenth- and early nineteenth-century Virginia and South Carolina, all of which held ethnically diverse slave populations, Quito’s enslaved population did not feature sizable clusters of any one or two African ethnic groups that might have allowed for endogamous unions or the formation of communities based upon ethnic or socio-linguistic affinities. Consequently, the socio-cultural matrix was always polyethnic and polycultural. Thus, African-descended people in Quito engaged in at least two inter-related, ethnogenic processes occurring simultaneously. There, formerly discrete peoples from the interior of the Upper Guinea Coast, the Lower Guinea and West Central Africa were not only brought into contact with others from within their “culture zones,” but were also connected to individuals who fell outside of their culture zones. Arrival in the North Andes, then, precipitated two additional processes that ran concurrently with the previous two—intermarriage with Andeans and Afro-criollos (people of African descent born within the empire, both in Iberia and the Americas), and unions with the offspring of those unions and with Europeans; that is, the spawning and engagement of the so-called “castas” (e.g., pardos, mulattos, zambos, mestizos, morenos, etc). Ultimately, this study suggests that returning to the world that work, geography, and demography made is not only necessary, but also essential to understanding identity formation within the African Diaspora. Engaging those seemingly marginal Spanish American slave societies is fundamental to a greater understanding of black life and the formation of creole consciousness throughout the Americas. iii To Aliyah and Naiyah iv ACKNOWLEDGMENTS Before I could aspire to do academic work or even come to appreciate the importance of telling stories, my parents and grandparents emphasized the importance of history by ensuring that I understood my family’s legacy of struggle and hard work. One of my first history teachers was my paternal grandmother, Bessie Mae Bryant. Like her, I learned to appreciate the importance of the past during some of life’s most intimate and personal moments. For grandma Bessie and her sister, aunt Beulah, the moment came when they were washing the back of their grandmother—Katherine Hazard. There, they encountered the scars she bore as a result of a whipping she had received during “slavery days.” Reputedly an ex-slave of the “Bellamy Woods Plantation,” grandma Katherine recounted the horrors of slavery to her young granddaughters on that day. That story, told, sometimes with a little prodding but, usually in the context of grandma Bessie’s many admonitions that I hold dear our family’s legacy, left an indelible impression upon me. In many ways, writing about enslaved African and Afro-Quiteño grandmothers and grandfathers, and the children they reared, freed, and otherwise worked to shield from the masters’ lash, has been a rather personal endeavor. Consequently, this privilege and responsibility has been both wonderfully fascinating and, at times, extremely weighty. In addition to grandma Bessie’s many admonishments, my maternal grandfather, William Clemmons, provided me with a trust fund that will never run out—a glimpse of what hard work was really all about. A master carpenter and builder in his own right, granddaddy Billy employed me in his many housing construction and renovation projects throughout the Cape Fear River Valley in North Carolina. He taught me the trade just as he did his own sons, and for this I will be ever grateful. My memories of crawling under houses, tearing off and replacing shingles on the hot rooftops in mid-July and August while renovating and/or building houses are lasting impressions of the rewards of hard work and the centrality of perseverance in all of life’s endeavors. v In addition to grandma Bessie and granddaddy Billy, I benefited from the love and influence of several other senior family members, namely my maternal grandmother, Essie Mae Clemmons, and my two great-grandmothers—Bell Robbins and Laura Clemmons Kennedy. Although I did not interact with one of grandma Bessie’s first cousins—cousin Katie—much as a child, she also reinforced the importance of history and legacy just before I left for graduate school. It was cousin Katie who helped me as I began to reconstruct the Bryant family history in a more meaningful way, filling in some of the gaps in grandma Bessie’s stories while telling a few of her own. Learning about the experiences of certain family members during the Wilmington race massacre of 1898 was truly fascinating. Finally, the life of my paternal grandfather, Owen Hill, Jr., who entered the military as a young man in order to “learn to read and write, and get three square meals per day,” remains a source of inspiration. The professionalism and charisma that this soldier and gentleman displayed during his life was infectious and evident to all from the moment he entered a room, even as he suffered from severe dementia in his final years. As inspiring as my grandparents were, I would not have valued fully the importance of our family’s history and tradition, or the centrality of hard work in success without the guidance of my parents—Joe H. and Connie C. Bryant. Had they chosen to abandon the principles of faith and family—faith in our ability to bring about a better day through hard work, thrift, and the collective ingenuity of the family unit—I might have missed many of the important lessons that allowed me to value deeply the sacrifice that they and previous generations had made. Saying thank you is but small recompense for the tremendous amount of worrying, strategic thought, sacrifice and perseverance that each of you invested in me. I thank you mom especially for your emphasis upon social graces, right thought and right action. And Dad, I thank you for your many sermons on the importance of higher education. In addition to my parents and grandparents, I enjoyed the good fortune of having a host of aunts, uncles, older cousins, and community members supporting me along the way. I thank aunt Barbara for the biscuits from Biscuitville and for caring for me as if I were her very own son. The fellowship of my uncles Gregory, Wayne, Anthony, Curtwright, and Landon helped make me the man that I am. I thank them for coming to my basketball games and for reminding me that my performance in the classroom was what really mattered. In addition to her wonderful cooking, I thank aunt Laura Mae for her love and support. vi Thanks also for taking Earlene and I to “Sportsworld,” even if we did have to leave just before the party “got started.” I thank my late aunt Janice V.
Recommended publications
  • Spanish Heritage.Pages
    Heritage in Micronesia SPANISH PROGRAM FOR CULTURAL COOPERATION with the collaboration of the GUAM PRESERVATION TRUST and the HISTORIC RESOURCES DIVISION, DEPARTMENT OF PARKS AND RECREATION Spanish Spanish Program for Cultural Cooperation Conference Spanish Heritage in Micronesia Inventory and Assessment October 16, 2008 Hyatt Regency, Tumon Guam Spanish Program for Cultural Cooperation with the collaboration of the Guam Preservation Trust and the Historic Resources Division, Guam Department of Parks and Recreation Table of Contents Spanish Heritage in Micronesia: Inventory and Assessment 1 By Judith S. Flores, PhD Spanish Heritage Resources In The Mariana Islands 5 By Judith S. Flores, PhD The Archaeology of Spanish Period, Guam 11 By John A. Peterson Inventory and Assessment of Spanish Tangible Heritage in the Federated States of Micronesia 32 By Rufino Mauricio Heritage Preservation And Sustainability: Technical Recommendations And Community Participation 44 By Maria Lourdes Joy Martinez-Onozawa Historic Inalahan Field Workshop 52 By Judith S. Flores, PhD Spanish Heritage in Palau 61 By Filly Carabit and Errolflynn Kloulechad Spanish Heritage in Micronesia: Inventory and Assessment Introduction By Judith S. Flores, PhD President, Historic Inalahan Foundation, Inc. The second in a series of conferences funded by the Spanish Program for Cultural Cooperation (SPCC) opened in the Hyatt-Regency in Tumon, Guam on October 16, 2008. The first conference sponsored by SPCC was held the previous year in Guam on Nov. 14-15, 2007, entitled “Stonework Heritage in Micronesia”, organized by the Guam Preservation Trust. It brought together and introduced technical experts in Spanish stonework and Spanish heritage architects to a gathering of historic preservation officials and scholars who live and work in Guam and Micronesia.
    [Show full text]
  • The Royal African: Or, Memoirs of the Young Prince of Annamaboe
    This is a reproduction of a library book that was digitized by Google as part of an ongoing effort to preserve the information in books and make it universally accessible. http://books.google.com THE Royal African? MEMO IRS ; OF THE Young Prince of Annamaboe. Comprehending A distinct Account of his Country and Family ; his elder Brother's Voyage to France, and Recep tion there ; the Manner in which himself was confided by his Father to the Captain who sold him ; his Condition while a Slave in Barbadoes ; the true Cause of his being redeemed ; his Voy age from thence; and Reception here in England. Interspers'd throughout / 4 With several Historical Remarks on the Com merce of the European Nations, whose Subjects fre quent the Coast of Guinea. To which is prefixed A LETTER from thdr; Author to a Person of Distinction, in Reference to some natural Curiosities in Africa ; as well as explaining the Motives which induced him to compose these Memoirs. — . — — t Othello shews the Muse's utmost Power, A brave, an honest, yet a hapless Moor. In Oroonoko lhines the Hero's Mind, With native Lustre by no Art resin 'd. Sweet Juba strikes us but with milder Charms, At once renown'd for Virtue, Love, and Arms. Yet hence might rife a still more moving Tale, But Shake/pears, Addisons, and Southerns fail ! LONDON: Printed for W. Reeve, at Sha&ejpear's Head, Flectsireet ; G. Woodfall, and J. Barnes, at Charing- Cross; and at the Court of Requests. /: .' . ( I ) To the Honourable **** ****** Qs ****** • £#?*, Esq; y5T /j very natural, Sir, /£æ/ ><?a should be surprized at the Accounts which our News- Papers have given you, of the Appearance of art African Prince in England under Circumstances of Distress and Ill-usage, which reflecl very highly upon us as a People.
    [Show full text]
  • Early Colonial History Four of Seven
    Early Colonial History Four of Seven Marianas History Conference Early Colonial History Guampedia.com This publication was produced by the Guampedia Foundation ⓒ2012 Guampedia Foundation, Inc. UOG Station Mangilao, Guam 96923 www.guampedia.com Table of Contents Early Colonial History Windfalls in Micronesia: Carolinians' environmental history in the Marianas ...................................................................................................1 By Rebecca Hofmann “Casa Real”: A Lost Church On Guam* .................................................13 By Andrea Jalandoni Magellan and San Vitores: Heroes or Madmen? ....................................25 By Donald Shuster, PhD Traditional Chamorro Farming Innovations during the Spanish and Philippine Contact Period on Northern Guam* ....................................31 By Boyd Dixon and Richard Schaefer and Todd McCurdy Islands in the Stream of Empire: Spain’s ‘Reformed’ Imperial Policy and the First Proposals to Colonize the Mariana Islands, 1565-1569 ....41 By Frank Quimby José de Quiroga y Losada: Conquest of the Marianas ...........................63 By Nicholas Goetzfridt, PhD. 19th Century Society in Agaña: Don Francisco Tudela, 1805-1856, Sargento Mayor of the Mariana Islands’ Garrison, 1841-1847, Retired on Guam, 1848-1856 ...............................................................................83 By Omaira Brunal-Perry Windfalls in Micronesia: Carolinians' environmental history in the Marianas By Rebecca Hofmann Research fellow in the project: 'Climates of Migration:
    [Show full text]
  • Shipboard Insurrections, the British Government and Anglo-American Society in the Early 18Th Century James Buckwalter Eastern Illinois University
    Eastern Illinois University The Keep 2010 Awards for Excellence in Student Research & 2010 Awards for Excellence in Student Research Creative Activity - Documents and Creativity 4-21-2010 Shipboard Insurrections, the British Government and Anglo-American Society in the Early 18th Century James Buckwalter Eastern Illinois University Follow this and additional works at: http://thekeep.eiu.edu/lib_awards_2010_docs Part of the African American Studies Commons, African History Commons, European History Commons, and the United States History Commons Recommended Citation Buckwalter, James, "Shipboard Insurrections, the British Government and Anglo-American Society in the Early 18th Century" (2010). 2010 Awards for Excellence in Student Research & Creative Activity - Documents. 1. http://thekeep.eiu.edu/lib_awards_2010_docs/1 This Article is brought to you for free and open access by the 2010 Awards for Excellence in Student Research and Creativity at The Keep. It has been accepted for inclusion in 2010 Awards for Excellence in Student Research & Creative Activity - Documents by an authorized administrator of The Keep. For more information, please contact [email protected]. James Buckwalter Booth Library Research Award Shipboard Insurrections, the British Government and Anglo-American Society in the Early 18th Century My research has focused on slave insurrections on board British ships in the early 18th century and their perceptions both in government and social circles. In all, it uncovers the stark differences in attention given to shipboard insurrections, ranging from significant concern in maritime circles to near ignorance in government circles. Moreover, the nature of discourse concerning slave shipboard insurrections differs from Britons later in the century, when British subjects increasingly began to view the slave trade as not only morally reprehensible, but an area in need of political reform as well.
    [Show full text]
  • W. Arthur Lewis and the Dual Economy of Manchester in the 1950S
    This is a repository copy of Fighting discrimination: W. Arthur Lewis and the dual economy of Manchester in the 1950s. White Rose Research Online URL for this paper: http://eprints.whiterose.ac.uk/75384/ Monograph: Mosley, P. and Ingham, B. (2013) Fighting discrimination: W. Arthur Lewis and the dual economy of Manchester in the 1950s. Working Paper. Department of Economics, University of Sheffield ISSN 1749-8368 2013006 Reuse Unless indicated otherwise, fulltext items are protected by copyright with all rights reserved. The copyright exception in section 29 of the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988 allows the making of a single copy solely for the purpose of non-commercial research or private study within the limits of fair dealing. The publisher or other rights-holder may allow further reproduction and re-use of this version - refer to the White Rose Research Online record for this item. Where records identify the publisher as the copyright holder, users can verify any specific terms of use on the publisher’s website. Takedown If you consider content in White Rose Research Online to be in breach of UK law, please notify us by emailing [email protected] including the URL of the record and the reason for the withdrawal request. [email protected] https://eprints.whiterose.ac.uk/ Sheffield Economic Research Paper Series SERP Number: 2013006 ISSN 1749-8368 Paul Mosley Barbara Ingham Fighting Discrimination: W. Arthur Lewis and the Dual Economy of Manchester in the 1950s March 2013 Department of Economics University of Sheffield 9 Mappin Street Sheffield S1 4DT United Kingdom www.shef.ac.uk/economics 1 Fighting Discrimination: W.
    [Show full text]
  • From Scattered Data to Ideological Education: Economics, Statistics and the State in Ghana, 1948-1966
    The London School of Economics and Political Science From Scattered Data to Ideological Education: Economics, Statistics and the State in Ghana, 1948-1966 Gerardo Serra A thesis submitted to the Department of Economic History of the London School of Economics for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy. London, January 2015. Declaration I, Gerardo Serra, certify that the thesis I have presented for examination for the MPhil/PhD degree of the London School of Economics and Political Science is solely my own work other than where I have clearly indicated that it is the work of others (in which case the extent of any work carried out jointly by me and any other person is clearly identified in it). The copyright of this thesis rests with the author. Quotation from it is permitted, provided that full acknowledgement is made. This thesis may not be reproduced without my prior written consent. I warrant that this authorisation does not, to the best of my belief, infringe the rights of any third party. I declare that my thesis, including footnotes but excluding references, consists of 97,090 words. 2 Abstract This thesis analyses the contribution of economics and statistics in the transformation of Ghana from colonial dependency to socialist one-party state. The narrative begins in 1948, extending through the years of decolonization, and ends in 1966, when the first postcolonial government led by Kwame Nkrumah was overthrown by a military coup d’état. Drawing on insights from political economy, the history of economics and the sociology of science, the study is constructed as a series of microhistories of public institutions, social scientists, statistical enquiries and development plans.
    [Show full text]
  • Nike and the Pigmentation Paradox: African American Representation in Popular Culture from ‘Sambo’ to ‘Air Jordan’
    Nike and the Pigmentation Paradox: African American Representation in Popular Culture from ‘Sambo’ to ‘Air Jordan’ by Scott Warren McVittie A Thesis presented to The University of Guelph In partial fulfillment of requirements for the degree of Master of Arts in History Guelph, Ontario, Canada © Scott McVittie, May, 2016 ABSTRACT NIKE AND THE PIGMENTATION PARADOX: AFRICAN AMERICAN REPRESENTATION IN POPULAR CULTURE FROM ‘SAMBO’ TO ‘AIR JORDAN’ Scott McVittie Advisor: University of Guelph Professor Susan Nance Martin Luther King Jr. once remarked: “The economic highway to power has few entry lanes for Negroes.” This thesis investigates this limited-access highway in the context of American culture by analyzing the merger of sports celebrity branding and racial liberalism through a case study of Nike and the Air Jordan brand. As a spokesman for Nike, Michael Jordan was understood as both a symbol of “racial transcendence” and a figure of “racial displacement.” This dual identity spurred an important sociological debate concerning institutional racism in American society by unveiling the paradoxical narrative that governed discourse about black celebrities and, particularly, black athletes. Making use of archival research from the University of Oregon’s Special Collections Department, this study sheds light on the “Nike perspective” in furnishing an athletic meritocracy within a racially integrated community of consumers. Positioning this study within the field of African American cultural history, this thesis also interrogates representations
    [Show full text]
  • Who Is Afro-Latin@? Examining the Social Construction of Race and Négritude in Latin America and the Caribbean
    Social Education 81(1), pp 37–42 ©2017 National Council for the Social Studies Teaching and Learning African American History Who is Afro-Latin@? Examining the Social Construction of Race and Négritude in Latin America and the Caribbean Christopher L. Busey and Bárbara C. Cruz By the 1930s the négritude ideological movement, which fostered a pride and conscious- The rejection of négritude is not a ness of African heritage, gained prominence and acceptance among black intellectuals phenomenon unique to the Dominican in Europe, Africa, and the Americas. While embraced by many, some of African Republic, as many Latin American coun- descent rejected the philosophy, despite evident historical and cultural markers. Such tries and their respective social and polit- was the case of Rafael Trujillo, who had assumed power in the Dominican Republic ical institutions grapple with issues of in 1930. Trujillo, a dark-skinned Dominican whose grandmother was Haitian, used race and racism.5 For example, in Mexico, light-colored pancake make-up to appear whiter. He literally had his family history African descended Mexicans are socially rewritten and “whitewashed,” once he took power of the island nation. Beyond efforts isolated and negatively depicted in main- to alter his personal appearance and recast his own history, Trujillo also took extreme stream media, while socio-politically, for measures to erase blackness in Dominican society during his 31 years of dictatorial the first time in the country’s history the rule. On a national level, Trujillo promoted
    [Show full text]
  • Osorno Y Su Condado El Señorio Y El Condado De Osorno
    OSORNO Y SU CONDADO EL SEÑORIO Y EL CONDADO DE OSORNO Por Sara Rodicio García EL SEÑORIO Y EL CONDADO DE OSORNO . (II) 339 La época de máximo esplendor en la trayectoria histórica de Osorno es también una de las mejor documentada; desde los orígenes mismos del Con- dado sus titulares conservaron cuidadosamente los documentos justificativos de sus privilegios, que además habían de ser la base para racionalizar en alguna medida la administración de sus amplios dominios . Tras algunas generaciones los fondos reunidos fueron tan considerables, que, en referencia a ellos, los cronistas de la época empezaron a hablar del "Archivo de Osorno" y a utilizarlos como materia e instrumento de estudio . Por eso, aun cuando como a su tiempo veremos ese cúmulo documental desaparece en "la francesada", han podido llegar hasta nosotros, en copias y en referencias detalladas a su conte- nido, tantos de ellos, que se elevan a más de un centenar los que en el siglo XVII maneja Don Luis de Salazar y Castro para sus estudios genealógicos y en su mayor parte incorpora a la colección que él reúne y lega a la iglesia madrileña de Montserrat, desde donde finalmente pasaron a la Real Academia de la Historia. Cuando en 1668 los Duques de Alba heredan la titularidad del Condado de Osorno, respetan sus archivos, que siguen en su anterior localización ; pero incorporan a sus propios fondos algunos de los documentos particularmente significativos, como la colección de doce cartas que los reyes Felipe III y Felipe IV habían dirigido personalmente a los Condes de Osorno ; el privilegio que les concedió en 1483 el Emperador de Constantinopla Andrés Paleólogo después de la caída de Bizancio; la documentación de interés americanista, que pasó más tarde a la Casa del Duque de .Veragua.
    [Show full text]
  • Los Sigchos, El Último Refugio De Los Incas Quiteños. Una Propuesta Preliminar
    Bulletin de l'Institut français d'études andines 40 (1) | 2011 Varia Los Sigchos, el último refugio de los incas quiteños. Una propuesta preliminar Tamara Estupiñán Viteri Edición electrónica URL: http://journals.openedition.org/bifea/1684 DOI: 10.4000/bifea.1684 ISSN: 2076-5827 Editor Institut Français d'Études Andines Edición impresa Fecha de publicación: 1 abril 2011 Paginación: 191-204 ISSN: 0303-7495 Referencia electrónica Tamara Estupiñán Viteri, « Los Sigchos, el último refugio de los incas quiteños. Una propuesta preliminar », Bulletin de l'Institut français d'études andines [En línea], 40 (1) | 2011, Publicado el 01 octubre 2011, consultado el 01 mayo 2019. URL : http://journals.openedition.org/bifea/1684 ; DOI : 10.4000/bifea.1684 Les contenus du Bulletin de l’Institut français d’études andines sont mis à disposition selon les termes de la licence Creative Commons Attribution - Pas d'Utilisation Commerciale - Pas de Modification 4.0 International. IFEA Bulletin de l’Institut Français d’Études Andines / 2010, 40 (1): 191-204 Los Sigchos, el último refugio de los incas quiteños. Un avance preliminar Los Sigchos, el último refugio de los incas quiteños Una propuesta preliminar Tamara Estupiñán Viteri* INTRODUCCIÓN Estudiar a Rumiñahui, el hombre más leal a Atahualpa y el principal líder de la resistencia del Quito-Inca contra los conquistadores españoles, ha sido un desafío para mí. Durante casi una década he pasado escudriñando en distintos archivos y bibliotecas, transcribiendo documentos y analizando las diferentes lecturas acerca de su proceder. También he buscado de montaña en montaña otras pistas que me ayuden a descifrar por qué Rumiñahui, sin ser un inca de nobleza pero sí de privilegio, en un momento de drama, desesperación y caos, pudo organizar un ejército compuesto por incas y por varias naciones locales de poco más o menos 50 000 hombres para enfrentarse a los conquistadores españoles y los indios aliados, con lo cual evitó, además, la segmentación política inmediata de esos territorios.
    [Show full text]
  • Environmental Faust Succumbs to Temptations of Economic Mephistopheles, Or, Value by Any Other Name Is Preference
    ENVIRONMENTAL FAUST SUCCUMBS TO TEMPTATIONS OF ECONOMIC MEPHISTOPHELES, OR, VALUE BY ANY OTHER NAME IS PREFERENCE Carol M. Rose* THE ECONOMY OF THE EARTH: PHILOSOPHY, LAW, AND THE ENVI- RONMENT. By Mark Sagoff. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. 1988. Pp. x, 271. $29.95. In several of the chapters to his new book, Mark Sagoff begins by telling some story to frame the remainder. One of these is particularly significant for the book: Sagoff retells a New Yorker joke in which the Devil tells the new entrants to Hell that they are leaving right and wrong behind, and entering a world of mere preferences (p. 99). The Devil signifies for Sagoff the economics-oriented policy analyst, and the story is prophetic because by the end of the book, that old prefer- ence-counting Devil has caught up with Sagoff. The word "environment" appeared in the titles of several of the earlier essays on which-the book is based,' but the book has wisely subordinated that E-word to a subtitle; despite the frequent invocation of natural wonders and scenic areas, the book doesn't really focus on the environment until the last chapter. Nope, this book is about that other E-word, Economics, which is so favored by the Devil. More specifically, at least until that last chapter, the book is about how dev- ilishly daffy economists are when they talk about the environment. Sagoff thinks their clever confusions are at best distracting and at worst antidemocratic (pp. 10, 95-97), and if we don't watch out, they are going to lead us off the ethical path and straight down the road to perdition.
    [Show full text]
  • What Is Causation?
    What is Causation? Stathis Psillos INTRODUCTION When we philosophers think about causation we are primarily interested in what causation is what exactly is the relation between cause and effect? Or, more or less equivalently, how and in virtue of what is the cause connected to the effect? But we are also interested in an epistemic issue, viz., the possibility of causal knowledge: how, if at all, can causal knowledge be obtained? The two issues are, of course, conceptually distinct but to many thinkers, there is a connection between them. A metaphysical account of causation would be useless if it did not make, at least in principle, causal knowledge possible. Conversely, many philosophers, mostly of an empiricist persuasion, have taken the possibility of causal knowledge to act as a constraint on the metaphysics of causation: no feature that cannot in principle become the object of knowledge can be attributed to causation. As we shall see, though philosophers have thought about causation for ages, there is hardly an agreement as to what causation is. Perhaps, this is reason enough to be sceptical about the whole prospect for a single and unified metaphysical account of causation. Perhaps, what we are trying to figure out causation is not one single condition with a determinate nature. But this crisis in the foundations of causation is no reason for despair. After all, we can know a lot about what causes what without knowing what causation is or better, without being committed to the view that causation is one single thing in the world. Causation is too precious to be given up.
    [Show full text]