The Pre-Conquest Roman Penetration of South-Eastern Britain
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
THE PRE-CONQUEST ROMAN PENETRATION OF SOUTH-EASTERN BRITAIN by Roderick J. 0. Millar B.Sc.(Eng), The University of London 1950 Banff School of Advanced Management, 1966 B.A., The University of British Columbia, 1987 A THESIS SUBMITTED IN PARTIAL FULFILMENT OF THE REQUIREMENTS FOR THE DEGREE OF MASTER OF ARTS in THE FACULTY OF GRADUATE STUDIES Interdisciplinary Studies (Anthropology/Classical Studies) We accept this thesis as conforming to the required standard THE UNIVERSITY OF BRITISH COLUMBIA April 24 1991 (c). Roderick J. 0. Millar, 1991 In presenting this thesis in partial fulfilment of the requirements for an advanced degree at the University of British Columbia, I agree that the Library shall make it freely available for reference and study. I further agree that permission for extensive copying of this thesis for scholarly purposes may be granted by the head of my department or by his or her representatives. It is understood that copying or publication of this thesis for financial gain shall not be allowed without my written permission. (Signature) R.3.0. Millar Department of Graduate Studies The University of British Columbia Vancouver, Canada Date May 1 1991 DE-6 (2/88) ii AESIEACI This thesis is concerned with an examination of the interaction between a state level society, that of Rome in the period of the Late Republic and Early Empire, and a neighbouring group of chiefdoms, those in the south-eastern part of Britain. In this period the social, economic and political systems in southern Britain appear to have gone through processes of major stress and change. The study tests the general hypothesis that in the period between the expeditions of Caesar in 55 and 54 BC and the final Claudian conquest in AD 43, the south-east of Britain went through an evolution from a number of small independent chiefdoms competing with each, other to a proto-state. This evolution was triggered and accelerated by the interaction with Rome. To test this hypothesis the published archaeological reports on the excavations in three areas of south-eastern Britain were analyzed. The areas around St. Albans, Braughing and Skeleton Green, and Colchester were used. The analysis compares a number of specific types of artifacts, certain features, and burials from all three areas. The general weight of the evidence, despite some minor inconsistencies, shows that in the approximately ninety years between 55 BC and AD 43 power shifted from several centres: the St. Albans area, Braughing, Welwyn and Hertford to one centre at Colchester. Under the dominance of Colchester, St. Albans and probably other formerly independent chiefdoms, became iii satellite centres to Colchester. This shift in the power centre was accompanied by a marked increase in social stratification, demonstrated in the elite burials, the increasing range of elite goods, and larger and more complex features. iv ABSTRACT ii List of Tables vi List of Figures vii ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS viii Chapter I. INTRODUCTION 1 Chapter II. THE BACKGROUND 6 Chapter III. A REVIEW OF THE THEORETICAL CONCEPTS 14 1. The Historical Background in Southern Britain. 2. Alternative Theoretical Concepts. Chapter IV. THE SITUATION IN SOUTH-EASTERN BRITAIN FROM THE EARLY FIRST CENTURY BC TO AD 43...23 Chapter V. RESEARCH QUESTIONS, HYPOTHESES AND THEIR IMPLICATIONS: A MODEL 28 1. General Research Questions. 2. General Hypothesis for this Thesis. 3. Specific Hypotheses to Test the Validity of the General Hypothesis. 4. Implications of the Specific Hypotheses. 5. Specific Archaeological Research Questions. 6. A Theoretical Basis for the Model. 7. The Model. 8. Specific Implications from the Model. Chapter VI. THE SOURCES OF THE DATA . 52 1. The Literary Sources. 2. The Archaeological Record. 3. Archaeological Source Material (Monographs, Articles and Publications). Chapter VII. THE ANALYSIS OF THE DATA 57 1. Problems with the Data. 2. Selection of the Data. 3. Analysis and comparison of the Tabulated Data. 4. The Literary Sources. 5. Statistical Analyses. Chapter VIII. ANALYSIS OF THE POTTERY 67 V Chapter IX. ANALYSIS OF THE AMPHORAE. 84 Chapter X. ANALYSIS OF THE COINS 89 Chapter XI. ANALYSIS OF THE BROOCHES 99 Chapter XII. ANALYSIS OF THE BURIALS 102 Chapter XIII. ANALYSIS OF THE FEATURES AND BUILDINGS 114 Chapter XIV. THE LITERARY AND NUMISMATIC EVIDENCE 124 Chapter XV. THE TRADING PATTERNS 128 Chapter XVI STATISTICAL ANALYSIS 132 Chapter XVII. DISCUSSION AND CONCLUSIONS 137 Chapter XVIII AN EVALUATION AND PROPOSALS FOR FURTHER RESEARCH 151 Glossary 1. List of Site Names and Areas 156 Glossary 2. Names of British Tribes and Rulers 157 Glossary 3. Technical Terms Used in this Thesis 158 Bibliography, and References Cited 160 Appendix A. References to Britain in Classical Literature 183 Appendix B. Burial Sites 185 vi LIST OF TABLES Table 1. Imported Pottery, Arretine 72 Table 2. Imported Pottery, South Gaulish 72 Table 3. Imported Pottery, Gallo-Belgic 73 Table 3a. Summary, Imported Pottery, Gallo-Belgic...73 Table 4. Native Pottery 77 Table 4a. Summary, Native Pottery 78 Table 4b. Summary, Gallo-Belgic and Native Pottery Types for the Key Sites 79 Table 4c. Gallo-Belgic and Native Types in % for the Key Sites 79 Table 5. Amphorae 85 Table 5a. Summary, Amphorae 86 Table 5b. Origin, Contents and Dates of Amphorae.... 87 Table 5c. Chart of Amphorae Dates 87 Table 6. Coins 90 Table 6a. Summary Table of Coins 90 Table 7. Brooches 99 Table 8. Rich Burials 109 Table 9. Grave Goods from Intermediate and Plain Burials 110 Table 9a. Intermediate and Plain Burials. Presence or Absence of Grave Goods Ill Table 10. Statistical Tabulations 135 vii LIST OF FIGURES Figure 1. South-Eastern Britain, Showing the Principal Sites 187 Figure 2. Tribes of Southern Britain 188 Figure 3. The Colchester Area 189 Figure 4. The Braughing Area 190 Figure 5. The St. Albans Area 191 Figure 6. Burial Sites in the St. Albans, Welwyn, Wheathampstead, Hertford and Braughing Areas 192 Figure 7. Relative Chronology of the Sites 193 Figure 8a. Cluster Diagram, 17 Variables. Wheathampstead, Prae Wood, Skeleton Green, Camulodunum 194 Figure 8b. Cluster Diagram, 17 Variables. Prae Wood, Skeleton Green, Camulodunum..195 Figure 8c. Cluster Diagram, 15 Variables. Prae Wood, Skeleton Green, Camulodunum..196 viii ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS On the theoretical aspects my heartfelt thanks go to Professor Michael Blake for his unfailing patience and help in assisting me to clarify my thoughts on the theoretical parts of the thesis. In developing a clear presentation of the theoretical alternatives both Dr. Blake and Dr. Richard Pearson made invaluable criticisms and suggestions. Dr. Blake also acted as my advisor for the first three years of my M.A. programme. Dr. Pearson gave me many valuable hints on possible cross-cultural comparisons and similarities. Professor E. Hector Williams served on my committee throughout, and took over as advisor for the last year, while Dr. Blake was absent on sabbatical leave. Dr. Williams, as well as giving me a very solid background on the Graeco-Roman world, also provided me with four long seasons of excavation at his site at Mytilene. This practical field experience, while the data was not directly applicable to my thesis, greatly helped in my analysis of other excavators' reports. Professor Anthony Barrett, the external examiner, provided a most helpful critique on the nomenclature that I used for the British tribal groups in south-eastern Britain. Professor R.G. Matson, who chaired the committee at my oral defence of the thesis, made a number of helpful suggestions on the presentation and layout of the material in the tables and statistical work. 1 I.INTRODUCTION This thesis explores the interaction between a state level society, that of Rome in the period of the Late Republic and Early Empire, and a neighbouring group of chiefdoms, those in the south-eastern part of Britain. At the same time the thesis is concerned with the interaction among this group of chiefdoms, in contact with, and affected by, the Roman presence in Gaul. The time period examined is from about 120 BC to AD 43, the year of the Claudian invasion and conquest of the southern part of the island. A particularly detailed study has been made of the almost ninety years from the first invasions and withdrawals made by Julius Caesar in each of the years 55-54 BC to the final conquest in AD 43. The interaction and relationship involved trade, politics and diplomacy, dynastic struggles in Britain, warfare, and finally in AD 43 the conquest of the southern and eastern parts of the country. During this period the British political and socio• economic systems were going through processes of major stress and change1. In Britain this culminated in the 1 The name Catuvellaunl for the dominant tribe in eastern and southern Britain is widely used in published works. There is, however, very little evidence for its use at the time of the Roman conquest. Caesar and Tacitus do not mention the name. Dio uses the name for the tribe in the area (LX 20,2), and Ptolemy mentions Salinae a polls of the Catuvellaunl (II 3, 21), but locates it near the Wash, outside the area normally assigned to the Catuvellaunl. Two inscriptions from Hadrian's Wall mention clvitate Catuwellaunorum and natione Catvallauna respectively. In this thesis Catuvellauni is used, as in other published 2 establishment of the hegemony of the Catuvellaunian kingdom over much of southern and eastern Britain. The specific object of the paper is an examination of the social, political and economic changes in south-eastern Britain, from the late second century B.C. to the conquest by Rome in A.D. 43, and an investigation of the forces and stresses, internal and external, that caused the changes. Both the historical and archaeological records suggest major upheavals and restructuring in the political organization of south-eastern Britain at this time.