Masterarbeit
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
MASTERARBEIT Titel der Masterarbeit „Ethnic Policies Toward People of Chinese Descent in Indonesia and Malaysia“ Verfasserin Mag. phil. Anna Gabriella Szabó angestrebter akademischer Grad Master of Arts (MA) Wien, 2015 Studienkennzahl lt. Studienblatt: A 066 864 Studienrichtung lt. Studienblatt: Masterstudium Wirtschaft und Gesellschaft Ostasiens Betreuer: MMMMag. Dr. Lukas Pokorny, MA 1 Acknowledgments Penang: Joann Khaw for being a great guide. Semarang: Bustanul Bokir Arifin for emotional intelligence and precious research skills. Harjanto Kusuma Halim for bringing the right people together. Rukardi Achmadi, Widjajanto Dharmowijono, Michael Deo, and Paulus Sandjaja Nagata for generous help and support. Jongkie Tio for sharing his deep knowledge and precious time in the joint quest to track the city’s most intriguing Chinese heritage. Vienna: Ulrich Lee and Erk Ucman for concise and crucial feedback, leading to the realization that an obese textual body can possibly be saved by a sound structural skeleton. Beyond time and space: my partner Alphis for his seemingly endless patience, my mother Helene for her meticulous check-ups, my father Mátyás for his constant reminder: “Pester your brain!” And last but not least, my outstanding supervisor Dr. Lukas Pokorny, for his professionalism and extensive support. 2 Table of Contents Acknowledgments ........................................................................................................................................................1 1 Introduction ..................................................................................................................................................... 4 1.1 Aim of Research ................................................................................................................................. 5 1.2 Benefits of Study ................................................................................................................................ 7 1.3 Limitations of Study ......................................................................................................................... 8 2 Research Methods .......................................................................................................................................... 9 2.1 The Art of Fieldwork ......................................................................................................................... 9 3 Theoretical Framework ............................................................................................................................ 12 3.1 Terminology ....................................................................................................................................... 13 3.2 Modalities of Ethnic Oppression ............................................................................................... 18 3.3 Ethnic Policies targeting People of Chinese Descent in Southeast Asia ................... 23 3.3.1 Ethnic Policies toward People of Chinese Descent in Indonesia ............................. 24 3.3.2 Ethnic Policies toward People of Chinese Descent in Malaysia ............................... 25 4 First Chinese Contacts with Indonesia and Malaya ...................................................................... 26 4.1 The Chinese in Indonesia during the Colonial Era ............................................................ 28 4.2 The Chinese in Malaya during the Colonial Era .................................................................. 31 5 The Difference within: Baba-Nyonya, Peranakan, and Totok .................................................. 33 6 Turmoil of War and Independence ..................................................................................................... 38 6.1 Sukarno, Integration, and Chinese Inspiration ................................................................... 38 6.2 Five fundamental Pillars of the Indonesian Nation? ........................................................ 40 6.3 The Incident of September 30th ............................................................................................... 42 6.4 Suharto, Assimilation, and the “Chinese Problem” ........................................................... 43 6.4.1 Assimilation Policies in the Era of Suharto ....................................................................... 44 6.5 The Riots of 1998 ............................................................................................................................. 47 6.6 The Chinese in Malaya prior to Japanese Invasion ........................................................... 47 6.7 The Japanese Invasion and the Years prior to Independence ...................................... 48 6.8 New Policies following the Malayan Independency ......................................................... 49 6.9 The Riots of 1969 and the New Economic Policy .............................................................. 51 7 The City of Semarang from a Chinese Perspective ....................................................................... 55 7.1 The Chinese History of Semarang ............................................................................................ 56 3 7.2 The History of Pecinan .................................................................................................................. 59 7.3 The Icon of Pecinan: Boen Hian Tong ..................................................................................... 60 7.3.1 Initial Phase .................................................................................................................................... 60 7.3.2 The Golden Era .............................................................................................................................. 62 7.3.3 Occupation and Oppression ..................................................................................................... 63 7.3.4 The Era of Gus Dur ....................................................................................................................... 68 8 The City of George Town, Penang ........................................................................................................ 74 8.1 The Chinese History of Penang .................................................................................................. 76 8.2 The NGO Penang Heritage Trust ............................................................................................... 83 8.2.1 PHT prior to UNESCO Heritage Listing ............................................................................... 85 8.2.2 PHT after the UNESCO Heritage Listing ............................................................................. 93 9 Conclusion ................................................................................................................................................... 100 Literature .......................................................................................................................................................... 107 Abbreviations and Definitions ................................................................................................................ 116 Appendix 1 ....................................................................................................................................................... 117 Appendix 2 – Curriculum Vitae ............................................................................................................... 118 Abstract ............................................................................................................................................................................ 119 4 1 Introduction With the research focus set on the Chinese cultural heritage in Indonesia and Malaysia, this thesis intends to add new knowledge to the field of overseas Chinese studies.1 As Indonesia and Malaysia gained independence in the middle of the twentieth century, people of Chinese descent became increasingly targeted by different ethnic policies. In the case of Indonesia, the implemented policies went beyond political and economic aspects and aimed at a complete eradication of the Chinese cultural heritage. What did these policies imply? Which consequences thereof can presently be discerned? What differences and similarities can be identified when comparing the outcome of the political agendas targeting the citizens of Chinese descent in Indonesia and Malaysia? To understand the historical context in which these questions are posed, the reader will be provided with a short yet comprehensive introduction to the main social, cultural and political issues that can be regarded as making up the backbones of the overseas Chinese culture in Indonesia and Malaysia. The first substantial wave of Chinese migration to Southeast Asia took place in the twelfth century.2 It was however not until the colonial era, with its imposed divide-and-rule policies, that a system of ethnic segregation was put into practice. This system was to a certain extent both backed by and perpetuated with the help of anti-Chinese sentiments, which were accentuated during the formative years of nation building in Indonesia and Malaysia. As the concept of the nation state was completely new to the Southeast Asian region, where Indonesia and Malaysia came into existence in the middle of the twentieth century, the question of belonging turned out to be volatile. In his often cited seminal work “Imagined Communities”,