Between Land and Lake: Michigan's Great Lakes Coastal Wetlands
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Between Land and Lake: Michigan’s Great Lakes Coastal Wetlands E-2902 • New • December 2003 Between Land and Lake: Michigan’s Great Lakes Coastal Wetlands by Dennis A. Albert Michigan Natural Features Inventory www.msue.msu.edu/mnfi ISBN 1-56525-018-4 Albert, Dennis A. 2003. Between Land and Lake: Michigan’s Great Lakes Coastal Wetlands. Michigan Natural Features Inventory, Michigan State University Extension, East Lansing, Mich.: Extension Bulletin E-2902. 96 p. Design by Alicia Burnell, Michigan State University Communication and Technology Systems. © 2003 Michigan State University, all rights reserved. Dedication and Acknowledgments any of us will remember MTed Cline for his tireless dedication to conserving Michigan’s special places. Ted’s aerial photography helped pro- tect important biodiversity sites from Drummond Island to the tip of the Keweenaw Peninsula, as well as in New Mexico. In this book, his photos provide us an important landscape perspective. Acknowledgments I would like to thank Dr. Edward Bonanno, John Brazner, Tom publication. Konrad Schmidt’s Voss, who introduced me to Burton, Pat Chow-Fraser, Sue photos came from Minnesota’s Great Lakes marshes in 1980, Crispin, Eric Epstein, Mike Fishes of Minnesota Web site. allowing me to join him in his Grimm, Tom Hart, Bud Harris, The gracious staff of the Monroe long-term marsh studies at Joel Ingram, Carol Johnston, Archives provided access to its Cecil Bay. Shari Gregory, Dave Kenyon, historic photography collection. Janet Keough, Elizabeth LaPorte, This study represents the efforts Michigan Sea Grant (www.mi- James McCormac, Rich Merritt, of many. Individuals participating seagrant.umich.edu) provided Mary Moffett, Glenn Palmgren, in the field studies include Larry access to its digital graphics col- Mary Rabe, Dave Rutkowski, Brewer, William Brodowich, lection, as did The Nature Thomas Simon, Steve Patrick Comer, Tim Garlock, Conservancy and the Michigan Sutherland, Todd Thompson, Chad Hess, Michael Kost, Will DNR. Ken Fettig, Leslie Johnson Don Uzarski, Howard Wandell, MacKinnon, Michael Penskar, and Alicia Burnell of MSUE’s Doug Wilcox, Leni Wilsmann, Ursula Peterson, Gary Reese, Gill ANR Publications turned a rough Earl Wolf and Gene Wright. Starks and Dan Wujek. Leah idea into a finished publication. Michael Kost, Rueben Goforth, Minc provided data analysis and Michael Penskar, Todd White and Funding for this publication was literature review; her contribu- Michael Monvils provided edi- provided by the National Oceanic tion cannot be overstated. toral comments that improved and Atmospheric Administration I especially appreciate text con- the accuracy and the flow of the through the Coastal Zone tributions by Vanessa Lougheed, text. Lyn Scrimger, Sue Ridge Management Program of the Sheila McNair, Rich Merritt, and Laraine Reynolds provided Michigan Department of Greg Soulliere and Todd White. administrative assistance. Cathie Environmental Quality. John Schafer’s photographs of Ballard, Dave Kenaga and Michigan’s field office of The the St. Clair flats inspire all of us. Maureen Houghton helped Nature Conservancy and the administer the project for Great Lakes Area of Expertise A number of others have provid- Michigan’s Department of Team of Michigan State ed valuable information, insights Environmental Quality, University Extension provided and commentary incorporated additional matching funds. into this work. These contribu- Many thanks to numerous pho- tors include Ted Batterson, Sandy tographers who allowed me to include their photos in this 2 Table of Contents Introduction. 4 The Natural Setting: The Environmental Context of Coastal Wetlands. 7 Aquatic Environments along the Great Lakes Shoreline . 8 Shoreline Configuration . 10 Wetland Site Types of Lacustrine Systems . 11 Wetland Site Types of Barrier-protected Lacustrine Systems . 12 Wetland Site Types of Riverine Systems . 14 Fluctuations in Great Lakes Water Levels . 17 Wetland Plant Response to Water Level Fluctuations . 20 Bedrock Geology . 22 Climate . 24 Human Land Use and Anthropogenic Stress. 25 The Diversity of Great Lakes Coastal Wetlands . 29 Zonal Wetland Vegetation . 30 Great Lakes Coastal Wetlands of Northern Michigan. 32 Northern Great Lakes Marsh. 32 Plankton: The Hidden World of the Marsh . 37 Northern Rich Fen. 39 St. Marys River Marshes . 42 Macroinvertebrates in Michigan’s Coastal Wetlands . 45 Lake Superior Poor Fen. 47 Fish in Great Lakes Coastal Wetlands . 49 Great Lakes Coastal Wetlands of Southern Michigan. 53 Lake Michigan Drowned River Mouths . 53 Saginaw Bay Lakeplain Marsh . 56 Lakeplain Prairie . 60 St. Clair Lakeplain Marsh . 62 Waterfowl Use of Michigan’s Coastal Wetlands. 67 Lake Erie Lakeplain Marsh . 71 Case History of a Marsh: River Raisin Delta. 73 Restoration and Recovery . 79 Appendices. 86 Appendix A: Marshes in Michigan . 87 Appendix B: Referenced Species. 93 Appendix C: Suggested Readings . 96 3 Introduction Introduction J. Schafer magine flying over the Ishoreline of western Lake Erie and seeing a mile-wide swath of grasses and bulrushes rippling in the winds. As the plane passes, thousands of waterfowl rise and take flight to a distant edge of the marsh. We could also be in a canoe, paddling through shallow, meander- ing channels at the mouth of the River Raisin, gliding through an open bed of wild rice, with broad meadows of blue-joint grass and bulrush sur- rounding us in all direc- tions. The channel splits again and again before we reach the open waters of Aerial view of St. Clair River delta. the lake. One hundred and fifty broad coastal marshes nificent bird’s-foot delta of years ago, as the Michigan lined western Lake Erie, the St. Clair River, and territory was being settled, Lake St. Clair and the mag- many other river mouths and shallow bays of the D. Albert Great Lakes. Such marshes could be found on all of the Great Lakes, from the western tip of Lake Superior to the upper reaches of the St. Lawrence River and its countless trib- utaries. Early surveyors and historians described Canoeing in a slough of the St. Clair River delta. 5 Introduction D. Albert and mapped many of the largest wetlands. These descriptions invariably include uncountable flocks of waterfowl or abundant spawning and feeding fish. For centuries, Native American villages had con- gregated on the shoreline, attracted by the abundant fish and wildlife. Annual spawning of lake sturgeon, whitefish and suckers and Rock-armored mouth of the Menominee River, previously a large wetland. the presence of many other wildlife species pro- vided a bountiful harvest as factory or docking sites, wetland types with charac- to these original settlers of requiring the wetlands to teristic assemblages of Michigan. be filled. Ship access plant and animal species. required dredging, We identify the natural But as the number of straightening and stabiliz- processes that occur with- European settlers to the ing of the lower stream in the various types of Great Lakes region channels. Rapidly the coastal wetlands and make increased, these protected seemingly limitless marsh- Great Lakes wetlands eco- waters took on other val- es along the Great Lakes logically different from the ues that conflicted with and their connecting chan- smaller, inland wetlands the ecological values so nels began to disappear. familiar to many of us. important to the Native Finally, we discuss the American settlements and In this book, we define and impacts of human develop- the fish and wildlife of the describe the diversity of ment and land use on marsh. The river mouths coastal wetlands found coastal wetlands and dis- and bays provided refuge along the Great Lakes cuss ways in which we can to commercial boats and shoreline and connecting protect and restore this ships. The waters became waterways. Throughout important natural resource important for industrial the region, a series of envi- for future generations. processes such as steam ronmental factors con- power or cooling. The verge to create distinctive shorelines were developed wetland environments and 6 The Natural Setting: The Environmental Context of Coastal Wetlands reat Lakes coastal wetlands occur along the GGreat Lakes shoreline proper and in portions of tributary rivers and streams that are directly affected by Great Lakes water regimes. These wet- lands form a transition between the Great Lakes and adjacent terrestrial uplands and are influenced by both. Though multiple environmental factors are at work in structuring these systems, the most important factors appear to be: • The aquatic environment. • Shoreline configuration. • Water level fluctuations. • Bedrock geology. • Climate. • Human land use. These factors — some regional, some local — create the context for Great Lakes coastal wetlands and provide a broad classification framework for under- standing their diversity, distribution and species composition. Aquatic Environments along the Great Lakes Shoreline S. Kogge ater flow character- Wistics define distinc- tive aquatic environments within the Great Lakes. In lacustrine environments along the Great Lakes shoreline, water flow in the adjacent wetlands is controlled directly by waters of the Great Lakes; Lacustrine environment: along western Saginaw Bay. the wetlands are strongly affected by littoral (along- land. Barrier-protected shore) currents and storm- Along the most exposed wetlands are strongly driven wave action. shorelines, wetland habitat influenced by the water Lacustrine habitats gener- is rare, but wetlands fre- levels of the neighboring