Nuclear Research and Technology: Breaking the Cycle of Indecision
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
SCIENCE AND TECHNOLOGY SELECT COMMITTEE Nuclear research and technology: Breaking the cycle of indecision Oral and written evidence Contents AMEC Foster Wheeler (AMEC FW) – Written evidence (PNT0044) ................... 4 Atkins – Written evidence (PNT0015) ....................................................... 14 Atomic Acquisitions (AA) – Written evidence (PNT0040) ............................. 23 Professor Colin Boxall, Lancaster University – Written Evidence (PNT0051) ... 31 Bristol University/SW Nuclear Hub – Written evidence (PNT0043) ................ 37 Professor Grace Burke, University of Manchester, Centre for Nuclear Engineering, Imperial College London and Nuclear Advanced Manufacturing Research Centre (Nuclear AMRC) – Oral evidence (QQ 1-8) ........................ 42 Cambridge Nuclear Energy Centre, University of Cambridge – Written evidence (PNT0056) ............................................................................................ 43 Centre for Nuclear Engineering, Imperial College London – Written evidence (PNT0054) ............................................................................................ 58 Centre for Nuclear Engineering, Imperial College London, Nuclear Advanced Manufacturing Research Centre (Nuclear AMRC) and Professor Grace Burke, University of Manchester – Oral evidence (QQ 1-8) .................................... 66 Dalton Nuclear Institute, University of Manchester – Written evidence (PNT0018) ............................................................................................ 67 Mr Simon Dawson – Written evidence (PNT0002) ...................................... 74 EDF Energy – Written evidence (PNT0039) ............................................... 75 EDF Energy, Nuclear Decommissioning Authority (NDA) and Office for Nuclear Regulation (ONR) – Oral evidence (QQ 20-30) .......................................... 86 Energy Technologies Institute (ETI) – Written evidence (PNT0012) .............. 87 Professor Martin Freer, University of Birmingham – Written evidence (PNT0058) ............................................................................................ 92 GE Hitachi Nuclear Energy – Written evidence (PNT0030) ..........................101 Government – Department for Business, Energy and Industrial Strategy (BEIS) – Written evidence (PNT0029) ...............................................................106 Government – Professor John Loughhead OBE, Chief Scientific Adviser, Craig Lucas, Director of Science and Innovation for Climate and Energy and Jesse Norman MP, Minister for Energy and Industry, BEIS – Oral evidence (QQ 31- 37) .....................................................................................................112 Government – Craig Lucas, Director of Science and Innovation for Climate and Energy, Jesse Norman MP, Minister for Energy and Industry and Professor John Loughhead OBE, Chief Scientific Adviser, BEIS – Oral evidence (QQ 31-37) .113 Government – Jesse Norman MP, Minister for Energy and Industry, Professor John Loughhead OBE, Chief Scientific Adviser and Craig Lucas, Director of Science and Innovation for Climate and Energy, BEIS – Oral evidence (QQ 31- 37) .....................................................................................................114 Government – Department for Business, Energy and Industrial Strategy (BEIS) – Supplementary written evidence (PNT0060) ..........................................133 Gwynedd Council – Written evidence (PNT0011) ......................................134 Professor Neil Hyatt, University of Sheffield – Written evidence (PNT0028) ..147 Dame Sue Ion, NIRAB – Written evidence (PNT0031) ...............................153 Dame Sue Ion, NIRAB and the Nuclear Industry Association (NIA) – Oral evidence (QQ 50-59) ............................................................................165 Mr Robin H Jones, Reactor Physicist, Wylfa Nuclear Power Station – Written evidence (PNT0003) .............................................................................182 Professor William E Lee, Imperial College London – Written evidence (PNT0004) ...........................................................................................184 Mr Piers Manson and Mr R Nash – Written evidence (PNT0023) ..................187 Dr Leslie A Mitchell FREng – Written evidence (PNT0007) ..........................191 Moltex Energy – Written evidence (PNT0037) ...........................................195 National Nuclear Laboratory (NNL) – Written evidence (PNT0046) ..............199 National Nuclear Laboratory (NNL) and UK Atomic Energy Authority (UKAEA) – Oral evidence (QQ 38-49) ......................................................................210 National Skills Academy for Nuclear (NSAN) – Written evidence (PNT0048) .227 North Wales Economic Ambition Board – Written evidence (PNT0059) .........232 NSG Environmental Ltd – Written evidence (PNT0050) ..............................236 Nuclear Advanced Manufacturing Research Centre (Nuclear AMRC) – Written evidence (PNT0026) .............................................................................239 Nuclear Advanced Manufacturing Research Centre (Nuclear AMRC), Professor Grace Burke, University of Manchester and Centre for Nuclear Engineering, Imperial College London – Oral evidence (QQ 1-8) ...................................245 Nuclear Decommissioning Authority (NDA) – Written Evidence (PNT0036) ...261 Nuclear Decommissioning Authority (NDA), Office for Nuclear Regulation (ONR) and EDF Energy – Oral evidence (QQ 20-30)............................................268 Nuclear Industry Association (NIA) – Written evidence (PNT0041) ..............284 Nuclear Industry Association (NIA) and Dame Sue Ion, NIRAB – Oral evidence (QQ 50-59) ..........................................................................................289 Nuclear Institute (NI) – Written evidence (PNT0033) ................................290 Nuclear Skills Strategy Group – Written evidence (PNT0014) .....................296 2 NuScale Power – written evidence (PNT0049) ..........................................299 NuScale Power, Sellafield Ltd and Rolls-Royce Nuclear – Oral evidence (QQ 9- 19) .....................................................................................................308 Office for Nuclear Regulation (ONR) – Written evidence (PNT0024) .............309 Office for Nuclear Regulation (ONR), EDF Energy and Nuclear Decommissioning Authority (NDA) – Oral evidence (QQ 20-30) ...........................................314 Penultimate Power UK – Written evidence (PNT0013)................................315 Plaid Cymru – Written evidence (PNT0042) ..............................................321 Prospect – Written evidence (PNT0019) ...................................................326 Mr Chris Rogers – Written evidence (PNT0009) ........................................329 Rolls-Royce plc – Written evidence (PNT0006) .........................................330 Rolls-Royce Nuclear, NuScale Power and Sellafield Ltd – Oral evidence (QQ 9- 19) .....................................................................................................340 Sellafield Limited – Written evidence (PNT0052) .......................................341 Sellafield Ltd, Rolls-Royce Nuclear and NuScale Power – Oral evidence (QQ 9- 19) .....................................................................................................346 Snowdonia Enterprise Zone (SEZ) Advisory Board – Written evidence (PNT0055) ...........................................................................................360 Mr Gary Swift – Written evidence (PNT0001) ...........................................365 Terrestrial Energy Inc. – Written evidence (PNT0057) ...............................366 Rory Trappe, Prospect Union Representative, Trawsfynydd site – Written evidence (PNT0008) .............................................................................375 TUV SUD Nuclear Technologies – Written evidence (PNT0021) ...................378 U-Battery – Written evidence (PNT0047) .................................................379 UK Atomic Energy Authority (UKAEA) – Written evidence (PNT0035) ..........384 UK Atomic Energy Authority (UKAEA) and National Nuclear Laboratory (NNL) – Oral evidence (QQ 38-49) ......................................................................390 UK Boiling Water Reactor (BWR) Research Hub and Network – Written evidence (PNT0020) ...........................................................................................391 UK Nuclear Data Network (UKNDN) – Written evidence (PNT0016) .............393 University College London (UCL) Nuclear Centre – Written evidence (PNT0025) ..........................................................................................................395 University of Leicester – Written evidence (PNT0022) ...............................397 University of Oxford – Written evidence (PNT0034) ..................................402 Weinberg Next Nuclear – Written evidence (PNT0045) ..............................405 Westinghouse UK – Written evidence (PNT0027) ......................................407 3 AMEC Foster Wheeler (AMEC FW) – Written evidence (PNT0044) AMEC Foster Wheeler (AMEC FW) – Written evidence (PNT0044) Introduction This evidence is being presented by Clean Energy business of AMEC Foster Wheeler (AMEC FW) to the Select Committee on Science and Technology in response to the Call for Evidence for ‘Priorities for Nuclear