Architectsnewspaper 16 10.5.2005
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
ARCHITECTSNEWSPAPER 16 10.5.2005 NEW YORK ARCHITECTURE AND DESIGN WWW.ARCHPAPER.COM $3.95 JURORS PRIORITIZE SOCIAL AND ENVIRONMENTAL RESPONSIBILITY Carl Krebs of C/0 iJavis Brody Bond QUEENS GOES GREEN o o ARCHITECTURE'S DEMILITARIZING POWER 17 GEHRY, READY FOR LMDC WORKSHOPS FOCUS ON MUSEUM'S PROGRAMMING HIS CLOSE-UP IMAGINING SHOULD ARCHI• TECT'S DESIGN A MEMORIAL FURNITURE? OPEN STUDIO VISIT MUSEUM DIARY CLASSIFIEDS "Bedrock is not ADA-compliant," observed Lower Manhattan Development At 5:00 p.m.on September 19, calls fell so close to the wire Bronx Charter School for Corporation (LMDC) exhibition consult• RAFAEL MONEO DESIGNS the phone lines at New York due to the unprecedented the Arts by weisz + yoes ant leff Howard at a September 15 presen• HISTORIC CAMPUS' LAST PLOT City's Center for Architecture number of submissions (above) and William Clinton tation on the World Trade Center Memorial Presidential Library by were a flurry: The jury, which received this year—roughly Museum, which will occupy the space Polshek Partnership (below). convened only for one day 460, whereas past years have beneath Reflecting Ahxcnce,M'Khae\ Arad's Columbia to premiate the annual averaged 380. Divided into memorial design. The workshop, sponsored AIA New York City chapter three categories—architec• by New York New Visions and the AIA New awards, had just released its ture, interiors, and projects, York chapter, was part of a series of forums Hires Moneo choices for honors and mer• which includes unbuilt, tem• planned this fall by the WTC Memorial Rafael Moneo has been chosen to design its and staffers were franti• porary, and theoretical pro• Foundation, the Civic Alliance to Rebuild a new science building that Columbia cally corralling winners to posals—all submissions are Downtown, and the LMDC, to discuss the University is planning on the northwest race down to the Center in either the product of New subterranean memorial-museum—and corner of its Morningside Heights campus. time for the 6:00 p.m. awards York City-based architects perhaps thereby to spare it the fate of the The new building, expected to between presentation. Perhaps the or a re continued on page 4 adjacent and now- continued on page 6 150,000 and 200,000 square feet, will house research facilities, faculty offices, and classrooms for chemistry, biology, casino barqe now sites on Since Hurricane Katrina hit the Gulf Coast, Warehouse in Williamsburg, engineering, and physics departments. s Ohr O'Keefe local architects have been juggling personal designed by Cass Gilbert in 1913 The science building will also serve an responsibilities while trying to dig their clients important symbolic function, filling the and their practices out of the rubble. New m ui uj III m. II, remaining gap in the historic campus Orleans-based Wayne Troyer Architects, Sn M mi HI III <' and serving as a gateway to Columbia's partnered with Lloyd Bray Architects of Manhattanville campus. Atlanta, had just put the finishing touches on While Columbia would not provide Zemurray Residence Hall, an addition to the details about the selection process, Mark Tulane University campus. Students began Wigley, dean of the Graduate School of moving in the Saturday morning before the storm hit. By 6:00 that same evening, they Architecture, Planning, and Preservation, was explicit about why Moneo was cho• were told to leave. Troyer also evacuated and WILL CASS GILBERT BUILDING sen: "The original campus is stone and, is now sharing office space with Jack Ford of STAND IN THE WAY OR BE A PART Ford/Dickson Architects in Baton Rouge, but like so many Spanish architects, Rafael OF WILLIAMSBURG WATERFRONT GULF COAST ARCHITECTS he and his eight-person office are ready for thinks in terms of masonry." RENEWAL? PREPARE TO REBUILD a rapid homecoming. Wigley also noted the dichotomy of placing the university's most cutting- "Although the staff is from all over, they all edge scientists in a building designed DAMAGE CONTROL fell in love with the city and want to come HELL-BENT for a historic context. "Every architect in back to New Orleans," continued on page 6 the world thinks that he or she can make old and new operate well together, but ON KENT Moneo actually can, as is evidenced by his Prado Museum extension," he noted. The battle overthe future of the Williams• The school's last significant architectural burg waterfront rages on. Among the addition is Bernard Tschumi's (1999) many hotly contested properties in the Lerner Student Center, which married area is 184 Kent Avenue, a massive indus• three masonry facades with one of glass. trial building designed in 1913 by Cass One literal way the building will bridge Gilbert. The building, formerly a warehouse old and new is that it will float in part over for a beverage distributor, is currently used an existing gymnasium. Completion is as a loft building for continued on page 3 expected by 2010. aaron seward 3 o THE ARCHITECT'S NEWSPAPER OCTOBER 5, 2005 Sorkin proposes a stadium C/D A game we have played in the office goes something like this: Diana Darling 0^ on Governors Island, dub Name ten world-class works of architecture in New York City. tthe Frepdoni Bowl EOITORI O Cathy Lang Ho h- People usually manage to name about five buildings-the l-H William Menking Guggenheim, Lever House, the Seagram building, the TWA LU Terminal, the Chrysler Building, Grand Central Terminal- Martin Perrin before pooping out. If, like Corbusier, you count the Brooklyn Anne Guiney Bridge and Central Park as major design works you might get connection between reach and evil. But the ASSOCIATE EDITOR closer to a top ten. New York is unparalleled as a city with a attempt to brand critics of these big plans as Andrew Yang great street life, unique urban culture, and a great concentration narrow-minded obstructionists of progress (like of financial and intellectual talent, but it is easier to find ten that dreadful Jacobs!) is pure Moses. And here Daniii Alexandrov great buildings in Chicago or even Los Angeles. we come to the larger point. The Republican Christine Koroki Bloomberg Administration, in matters of devel• EDITORIAL ASSISTANTS However there is a perception—we hear it all the time— opment, measures progress with a single metric: Gunnar Hand that New York is becoming receptive to great architecture. real estate prices. Opposition to giant schemes Jaffer Kolb promulgated on Bloomberg's watch—Ground Stephen Martin Local architecture boosters point, for example, to the recent Zero, West Side, Ratner City, Greenpoint/ SALES AND MARKETING DIRECTOR design initiatives at various city agencies, such as the Parks Williamburg waterfront upzoning—has never Karen Begley Department, the Department of Design and Construction, and questioned the logic of doing something sub• the Department of City Planning under the Bloomberg admin• stantial on these sites of dramatic opportunity; CONTRIBUTORS istration. There's also been a flood of foreign star architects it questions the profit. The widespread use of MARISA BARTOLUCCI/ALAN G.BRAKE/ condemnation and other public review-evading ARIC CHEN / DAVID D'ARCY / MURRAY FRASER / opening offices or establishing collaborations here. And of instruments, the limited and sterile mix of uses, RICHARD INGERSOLL/JULIE V. lOVINE / JOE KERR/ LIANE LEFAIVRE/LUIGI PRESTINENZA PUGLISI/ course, the process of rebuilding the World Trade Center site the insensitivities of scale (not density), and the KESTER RATTENBURY/CLAY RISEN / has brought phenomenal attention to design and public process. massive engorging of fat-cat developers and D.GRAHAME SHANE/ PETER SLATIN/ architects, are what is being opposed. What the KATSU TANAKA/GWEN WRIGHT/PETER ZELLNER Regardless, the recent 2005 AIA New York City Design heirs of Jacobs seek is not to thwart develop• EDITORIAL ADVISORY BOARD Awards seem to belie this perception. The AIA's top Honor ment but to include a meaningful system of PAOLA ANTONELLI/RAUL A. BARRENECHE/ prize gave out five citations but only one (weisz -F yoes' Bronx public checks and balances, not simply the kind M. CHRISTINE BOYER / PETER COOK / that go into the pockets of Bruce Ratner, Larry WHITNEY COX/ODILE DECQ/TOM HANRAHAN/ Charter School for Art) was for a building actually in the five Silverstein, and David Childs. SARAH HERDA/CRAIG KONYK/JAYNE MERKEL/ boroughs. The rest were for buildings by New York architects LISA NAFTOLIN/SIGNE NIELSEN / Finally, both Brown and Chakrabarti astutely HANS ULRICH 08RIST / JOAN OCKMAN / in places like Arkansas and Bridgehampton, Long Island. noticed that one of the ten sites I suggested tor KYONG PARK/ANNE RIESELBACH/ TERENCE RILEY/KEN SAYLOR /MICHAEL SORKIN The AIA's 12 merit awards only gave four to buildings in New a stadium—Governor's Island—was somewhat exceptional in terms of access. Although I've GENERAL INFORMATION: INFOSfARCHPAPER.COM York City. As one might expect, the interior awards went over• published a more detailed argument for the site EDITORIAL: EDIT0Ri-fARCHPAPER.COM whelmingly to commissions in the five boroughs. But the DIARY: DIARYS>ARCHPAPER.COM elsewhere, perhaps the image above will clarify ADVERTISING: SALES^ARCHPAPER.COM AIA New York State Honor Awards only recognized a single another, more symbolic, reason for its inclusion. SUBSCRIPTION: SUBSCRIBE(!iARCHPAPER.COM building in the city (the New York Hall of Science in Queens Let's ditch that stupid Freedom Tower and build PLEASE NOTIFY US IF YOU ARE RECEIVING by Polshek Partnership Architects, which cropped up several the Freedom Bowl! DUPLICATE COPIES. MICHAEL SORKIN THE VIEWS Of OUR REVIEWERS AND COLUMNISTS 00 NOT times on both lists). Despite the perception of a new architec- MICHAEL SORKIN STUDIO, MANHATTAN NECESSARILY REFLECT THOSE OF THE STAFF OR ADVISORS OF THE ARCHITECTS NEWSPAPER.