WOMEN's PARTICIPATION in the WORLD COUNCIL of CHURCHES 1948-1991 by Janet Estridge Crawford Submitted to the V
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
ROCKING THE BOAT: WOMEN'S PARTICIPATION IN THE WORLD COUNCIL OF CHURCHES 1948-1991 by Janet Estridge Crawford submitted to the Victoria University of Wellington in fulfilment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy Victoria University of Wellington 1995 CORRECTIONS and ALTERATIONS Page 35, footnote 64, delete last sentence. Page 55, footnote 46, line six, "Carey Hall" not "College". Page 63, second line from bottom, close quotation mark after "come". Page 72, line thirteen, "Ecumenical", not "Economical". Page 85, footnote 6, the last sentence should be attached at the end of footnote 7. Page 87, footnote 10, line eight, "was" before "a consultant". Page 119, line eleven, Muelder, not Meulder. Page 121, footnote 11, line three Dogmatik. Page 123, footnote 15, line two, "image", line ten, "Barth's". Page 124, line one, "insights". Page 126, third line from the bottom, "one woman". Delete italics in title. Page 130, footnote 34, line three, "the" for "those". Page 136, line seventeen, "one woman". Page 144, footnote 69, add: The word "confess" replaced "accept". Page 162, line two of quotation 13, "difficult" not "difficulty". Page 165, footnote 19 cont., line two. Dr. Gibson Winter should be listed once only. Page 169, footnote 32, comma after "May". Page 172, quotation 41, line two, "places" not "placed". Page 179, line eleven, omit "at the" at the end of the line. Page 181, five lines from bottom, omit [sic]. Page 182, line five from the bottom, "theirs" not "their's". Page 192, line four, omit "the" before "theological". Page 201, line eleven, "the" instead of "to". Page 202, footnote 132, line two, "Florentin-Smyth", line three, "European". Page 212, line eight, omit "was" at beginning. Page 223, line four, "harmonizations". Page 224, line four from the bottom, "practical". Page 226, line four from the bottom, omit "the" before "World War II". Page 227, line ten, omit "normally". Page 238, line six, "concern", line sixteen, delete [sic] and insert missing bracket at the end. Page 240, footnote 95, "Fairfax". Page 241, line eight, "Chester House". Page 246, line fourteen, "woman", not "women". 2 Page 263, line eight, insert quotation mark at end. Page 266, footnote 191, insert quotation mark before "vice-chairman". Page 275, line twelve, "questions", last line, "be" not "by", footnote 216, "WCC" not "Wcc". Page 284, line eighteen, "Ortega" not "Orfega". Page 291, line four, insert "many" before "personal". Page 322, line five from the bottom, "most" not "moist". Page 343, footnote 100, line one, "predominance of women" not "men". Page 361, line 10, "equality" not "quality". Page 366, footnote 168, line six, "fifty-fifty" not "fifty-fifth". Page 371, footnote 180, line two, "of" not "or". Page 384, line four, insert "of" after "community". Page 389, line seven, "Berlin" not "Berlini". Page 392, line three from the bottom, "their" for "the" at the end. Page 409, line thirteen, "woman" not "women". Page 434, line three, "woman" not "women". Page 451, line three, "1985" not "1958". Page 455, line twelve, "patriarchal" not "partriarchal". Page 476, last line, comma after "Redeemer", full stop after "Sanctifier". Page 481, line thirteen, insert colon after "emphases", semi-colon after "participation". Page 485, line twelve, "priests" not "priets". Page 487, line five, "past", not "part". Page 496, footnote 149, line three, "volumes" not "columes". Page 505, line three from the bottom, separate "one" from "commissioner". Page 514, line fifteen, omit "often". Page 531, line thirteen, insert "was" after "which". Page 548, footnote 306, "Kässmann". Page 549, line twelve, insert "which" and omit "for" before and after "had". Page 550, line twelve, "Reaction"; line four from the bottom, replace comma after "assemblies" with full stop, begin new sentence "Of .." Page 551, line fourteen "Hyun" not "Hung". Page 552, footnote 315, "Kässmann". Page 553, quotation 319, last line "Hyun" not "Hung". Page 559, line eight, "relate" not "related"; last line, "divisions" not "diversions". Page 560, line eight, insert "work" after "section". Page 561, footnote 348, "Kässmann". 3 Page 563, line fourteen, "the report" not "this report". Page 575, line three, omit "are". Page 577, line nine, capital letter for "Women". Page 611, under BAROT add "d. December 1995" Page 612, under BARROW add "d. December 1995". ABSTRACT When the inaugurating assembly of the World Council of Churches (WCC) met in 1948 questions about women's participation in the life and work of the churches, including the ordained ministry, were already on the agenda, placed there by women even though few women participated in any official capacity in the assembly. Since 1948 women's participation has become an increasingly important issue within the life and work of the WCC itself. This thesis, which is based on extensive primary research, documents and discusses women's participation in the WCC from that first assembly in 1948 to the seventh in 1991. By women's participation I understand both the inclusion of women among the representatives of the member churches who participate with some authority in the various policy and decision making bodies within the Council and the contribution of women's experiences, insights and perspectives to its policies and programmes. I argue that although women's participation in the WCC has increased significantly in the period 1948-1991 this increase has occurred only as a result of considerable struggle by women themselves, and that the ongoing pressure from women for their full and equal participation with men gives rise to serious tensions and problems within the WCC today. The basic approach is chronological, with documentation and discussion organised around the seven WCC assemblies held in the period 1948-1991. The slow processes of bureaucratic change through which women's participation has increased are documented in some detail, with particular attention given to their participation in assemblies and on the central committee, these being the two most powerful bodies in the governance of the WCC. Significant changes in the policies and programmes of the WCC resulting from women's participation are discussed, with particular attention paid to the "women's department" which, although its title and mandate have changed more than once, has consistently been the locus of advocacy for women's participation, and the commission on Faith and Order which has addressed theological questions raised by and about women's participation. The conclusion drawn from this study is that women's participation offers a number of significant challenges to the WCC and its member churches in their quest for unity. In Memory of Frances Nancy Crawford LIST OF ABBREVIATIONS AND ACRONYMS AACC All Africa Conference of Churches AFT Apostolic Faith Today BBC British Broadcasting Corporation BCC British Council of Churches BEM Baptism, Eucharist and Ministry CICARWS Commission of the Churches on Inter-church Aid, Refugee and World Service CIMADE Comité Inter-Mouvements Auprès Des Evacués CMC Christian Medical Commission COPECIAL Permanent Commission for International Congresses of the Lay Apostolate CWU Church Women United CWMC Community of Women and Men in the Church CWME Commission on World Mission and Evangelism DEA Division on Ecumenical Action DEM Dictionary of the Ecumenical Movement EATWOT Ecumenical Association of Third World Theologians EPS EPS: Ecumenical Press Service ER The Ecumenical Review IMC International Missionary Council JPIC Justice, Peace and the Integrity of Creation JWG Joint Working Group LWF Lutheran World Federation NCC National Council of Churches NCCCUSA National Council of the Churches of Christ in the USA iii NGOs Non-Governmental Organisations PAWM Pre-Assembly Women’s Meeting PCR Programme to Combat Racism PTE Programme on Theological Education RC Roman Catholic RCC Roman Catholic Church SACC South Africa Council of Churches SCM Student Christian Movement SEG Staff Executive Group SODEPAX Joint Committee on Society, Development and Peace SPCU Secretariat for Promoting Christian Unity TD Typewritten document TL Typewritten letter TLS Typewritten letter signed UCA Uniting Church of Australia UN United Nations WCC World Council of Churches WCCE World Council of Christian Education WCW Women in a Changing World WELG Women’s Ecumenical Liaison Group WSCF World Student Christian Federation WUCWO World Union of Catholic Women’s Organisations YMCA Young Men’s Christian Associations YWCA Young Women’s Christian Associations iv PREFACE The subject of this thesis is women's participation in the World Council of Churches (WCC) 1948-1991. Although I have written this as a work of academic research my interest in the subject is not wholly academic for I am myself a woman who has participated in the work of the WCC. My first contact with this institution occurred in 1979 when as a newly- ordained Anglican clergywoman in a provincial New Zealand town I organised and led a group which responded to the WCC study on the Community of Women and Men in the Church (CWMC) and subsequently sent a brief report to the WCC office in Geneva. An unforeseen consequence of this was that in August 1980 I went to Geneva where I worked for a year as consultant to the CWMC study programme. Originally employed to analyse and edit the reports sent in by groups around the world, I later became responsible for organising the conference held at Sheffield in July 1981 which was the culmination of the four year CWMC study process. After this I left the WCC and the editorial work was completed later, with a colleague, and published as In God's Image: Reflections on Identity, Human Wholeness and the Authority of Scripture. 1 In 1983 I returned to Geneva where I spent ten months working as a consultant to the WCC Sub-unit on Women in Church and Society, involved in 1 Janet Crawford and Michael Kinnamon, eds., In God's Image: Reflections on Identity, Human Wholeness and the Authority of Scripture (Geneva: World Council of Churches, 1983).