Arxiv:2009.14053V3 [Math.GR] 24 Jun 2021 1.1
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
COARSE INJECTIVITY, HIERARCHICAL HYPERBOLICITY, AND SEMIHYPERBOLICITY THOMAS HAETTEL, NIMA HODA, AND HARRY PETYT Abstract. We relate three classes of nonpositively curved metric spaces: hierarchi- cally hyperbolic spaces, coarsely injective spaces, and strongly shortcut spaces. We show that any hierarchically hyperbolic space admits a new metric that is coarsely in- jective. The new metric is quasi-isometric to the original metric and is preserved under automorphisms of the hierarchically hyperbolic space. We show that any coarsely in- jective metric space of uniformly bounded geometry is strongly shortcut. Consequently, hierarchically hyperbolic groups—including mapping class groups of surfaces—are coarsely injective and coarsely injective groups are strongly shortcut. Using these results, we deduce several important properties of hierarchically hyper- bolic groups, including that they are semihyperbolic, have solvable conjugacy problem, have finitely many conjugacy classes of finite subgroups, and that their finitely gen- erated abelian subgroups are undistorted. Along the way we show that hierarchically quasiconvex subgroups of hierarchically hyperbolic groups have bounded packing. 1. Introduction A principal theme of geometric group theory is the study of groups as metric spaces. This includes studying groups via the types of metric spaces they act on. In this vein, the study of groups acting on spaces satisfying various forms of nonpositive curvature conditions has been especially fruitful. In this article, we are concerned with three classes of spaces exhibiting nonpositive curvature: hierarchically hyperbolic spaces, coarsely injective spaces, and strongly shortcut spaces. 1.1. The setting. The first of our three classes is that of hierarchically hyperbolic spaces, which were intro- duced by Behrstock, Hagen, and Sisto in [BHS17b]. These spaces exhibit hyperbolic-like behaviour, and there is a growing body of interesting examples, including many quo- tients of mapping class groups [BHMS20] and all known cubical groups [HS20], amongst others. The theory has had a number of successes, such as proving Farb’s quasiflats con- jecture for mapping class groups [BHS17c] and establishing uniform exponential growth for many cubical groups [ANS19]. We postpone describing the hierarchy structure until arXiv:2009.14053v3 [math.GR] 24 Jun 2021 Section 3.1. The next class we consider is that of coarsely injective spaces. A metric space is said to be coarsely injective if there is a constant δ such that for any family tBpxi, riq : i P Iu Date: June 25, 2021. 2020 Mathematics Subject Classification. 20F65, 20F67, 51F30. Key words and phrases. hierarchically hyperbolic, coarsely injective, strongly shortcut, semihyper- bolic, hierarchically quasiconvex, bounded packing. 1 of balls with dpxi,xjqď ri ` rj for all i, j P I, the δ–neighbourhoods of those balls have nonempty total intersection. This property was first considered by Chepoi and Estellon in [CE07]. As the term suggests, this notion is closely related to that of injective metric spaces. A metric space is injective (also called hyperconvex) if for any family tBpxi, riq : i P Iu of balls with dpxi,xjqď ri ` rj for all i, j P I, the balls have nonempty total intersection. In other words, it amounts to taking δ “ 0 in the definition of coarse injectivity. (There are multiple equivalent ways to define injectivity of a metric space, by a theorem of Aronszajn and Panitchpakdi [AP56].) A construction of Isbell [Isb64], which was later rediscovered by Dress [Dre84] and by Chrobak and Larmore [CL94], shows that every metric space has an essentially unique injective hull. More precisely, the injective hull of a metric space X is an injective metric space EpXq, together with an isometric embedding e : X Ñ EpXq, such that no injective proper subspace of EpXq contains epXq. For convenience, we will often identify X with its image epXq. A nice description of the construction of the injective hull is given by Lang in [Lan13, §3]. The classes of coarsely injective spaces and injective spaces are tied together by the following useful fact, the proof of which is identical to that of [CCG`20, Proposition 3.12]. A subset Y of a metric space X is coarsely dense if there exists r such that every x P X is r–close to some y P Y . Proposition 1.1. A metric space is coarsely injective if and only if it is coarsely dense in its injective hull. Moreover, if a group acts properly and coboundedly on a coarsely injective space, then it acts properly and coboundedly on the injective hull of that space (see Lemma 3.10). Here and throughout the paper, a group G is said to act properly on a metric space X if tg P G : gB X B ‰ Hu is finite for every metric ball B of X. This is sometimes referred to as a metrically proper action. Injective metric spaces satisfy a number of properties reminiscent of nonpositive cur- vature, and in particular of CAT(0) spaces. For instance, they admit a conical geodesic bicombing [Lan13], and proper injective spaces of finite combinatorial dimension have a canonical convex such bicombing [DL15]. Also, every bounded group action on an injective metric space has a fixed point, and the fixed point set is itself injective [Lan13]. These properties are what allow us to draw our conclusions for hierarchically hyperbolic groups. Although it will not be needed here, it is interesting to note that injective spaces are also complete [AP56] and contractible [Isb64]. The strong shortcut property was introduced by the second named author for graphs [Hod18] and then generalized to roughly geodesic metric spaces [Hod20b]. A Riemannian circle S is the circle S1 endowed with a geodesic metric of some length |S|. A roughly geodesic metric space pX,σq is strongly shortcut if there exists K ą 1 such that for any C ą 0 there is a bound on the lengths |S| of pK,Cq–quasi-isometric embeddings S Ñ X of Riemannian circles S in pX,σq. A group is strongly shortcut if it acts prop- erly and coboundedly on a strongly shortcut metric space. Many spaces and graphs of interest in geometric group theory and metric graph theory are strongly shortcut, includ- ing Gromov-hyperbolic spaces, 1–skeletons of finite-dimensional CATp0q cube complexes, Cayley graphs of Coxeter groups, and asymptotically CATp0q spaces. Despite being such 2 a unifying notion, it remains possible to draw conclusions about strongly shortcut groups, including that they are finitely presented and have polynomial isoperimetric function, and so have decidable word problem. 1.2. Comparison of the classes. Our main result is the definition of a new metric on hierarchically hyperbolic spaces, and more generally on coarse median spaces satisfying a nice approximation property of median intervals by CAT(0) cube complexes. Our construction is directly inspired by work of Bowditch (see [Bow20]), in which he constructs an injective metric on any finite rank metric median space. Indeed, if one endows a finite-dimensional CAT(0) cube complex with the piecewise ℓ8 metric, it becomes an injective metric space. The new metric we construct is weakly roughly geodesic and has the property that balls are coarsely median-convex; see Theorem 2.13. We then prove a hierarchical generalisation of a very nice result of Chepoi, Dragan, and Vaxès [CDV17] about pairwise close subsets of hyperbolic spaces. Combining this with work of Russell, Spriano, and Tran [RST18] enables us to deduce a coarse Helly property for balls. Theorem A (Proposition 2.16, Corollary 3.6). Let pX, Sq be a hierarchically hyperbolic space with metric d. There exists a metric σ on X such that pX,σq is coarsely injective and quasi-isometric to pX, dq. Moreover, σ is invariant with respect to the automorphism group of pX, Sq. Our second result relates the class of coarsely injective spaces to that of strongly shortcut spaces. A metric space has uniformly bounded geometry if, for any r ą 0, there exists a uniform Nprq P N such that every ball of radius r contains at most Nprq points. Theorem B (Theorem 4.2). Every coarsely injective metric space of uniformly bounded geometry is strongly shortcut. Huang and Osajda proved that weak Garside groups of finite type and Artin groups of FC-type are Helly [HO19], so we have the following corollary of Theorem B. Corollary C. Weak Garside groups of finite type and Artin groups of FC-type are strongly shortcut. Combining Theorem A with Theorem B, we deduce the following. Corollary D. Every hierarchically hyperbolic space admits a roughly geodesic metric in its quasi-isometry class that satisfies the strong shortcut property. In fact, in the case of hierarchically hyperbolic groups, the metric we construct is equi- variant, by the “moreover” statement of Theorem A (also see Remark 3.9). We therefore have that every hierarchically hyperbolic group acts properly cocompactly on a coarsely injective space, and any group admitting such an action is a strongly shortcut group. Moreover, these three classes can be distinguished. Indeed, the p3, 3, 3q Coxeter trian- gle group is strongly shortcut but not coarsely injective [Hod20a]; and type-preserving ` uniform lattices in thick buildings of type Cn are coarsely injective [CCG 20], but they cannot be hierarchically hyperbolic groups, because they do not admit any nonelementary actions on hyperbolic spaces [Hae20]. 3 1.3. Metric consequences. We now describe some of the consequences of Theorem A for hierarchically hyperbolic spaces. Recall that a quasigeodesic bicombing on a metric space pX,σq is a map γ : X ˆ X ˆ r0, 1sÑ X such that, for each distinct pair a, b P X, t the map r0,σpa, bqs Ñ X given by t ÞÑ γa,b σpa,bq is a quasigeodesic from a to b with uniform constants. ´ ¯ There are various fellow-travelling conditions that a bicombing may enjoy.