The Heritage Gazette of the Trent Valley Volume 19, Number 1, May 2014
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Heritage Gazette of the Trent Valley, volume 19, number 1, May 2014 1 ISSN 1206-4394 The Heritage Gazette of the Trent Valley Volume 19, number 1, May 2014 President’s Corner: Going, Going Gone ….…………………………….…….…………..……………… Susan Kyle 2 The Dummer Murders: Jane Payne and David Doughty, 1872 …………………………………… Elwood H. Jones 3 From Pontypool to Peterborough: continuing the memoirs of Thomas Alvin Morrow: The Light of Other Days Around Me, part 3 …………………….………………….. Thomas A. Morrow 8 Turnbull Disaster ……………………………………………………………….………….………….. F. H. Dobbin 17 Hazelbrae Barnardo Home Memorial 1910-1911 ……………………………….…………… John Sayers, Ivy Sucee 18 Awareness about Samuel de Champlain in 1615 ……………………………………………………………………… 23 Champlain Was Here ……………………………………………………………………………… Elwood H. Jones 23 The Orenda: First Nations and Champlain ………………………………………….. Peter Adams and Alan Brunger 25 Biographical Sketches in Mulvany’s 1884 history of Peterborough County …………………………………………. 26 Big Island in Pigeon Lake ……………………………………………………………………………… Grace Barker 34 Big Island Stock Farm ……………………………………………………………………………George J. Johnson 36 Queries ………………………………………………………………………… Heather Aiton Landry, Pat Marchen 37 Hidden for a Century; Windover; Maher; Fleming Trent Valley Archives …………………………………………………………………………………………. Editor 38 Grosse Isle Trip, 38; Rice Lake Tour, 38; Annual General Meeting of TVA, 38; 2014 June Callwood Award Recipients, 39; June Callwood Outstanding Achievement Award to TVA, 39; Keith Dinsdale Award, 39; Land Records Indexing Project Volunteers Win Cultural Heritage Award, 40; We Need Your Assistance, 41; Books Available from Trent Valley Archives Bookshelf, 41; TVA and SPARK, 42; World Wars Commemoration, 42; John M. Turner Honoured, 42; From a 1936 Scrapbook, 43; Other Recent Additions to Our Holdings, 43; Aerial View of Canada Packers, c. 1947, 44 Look to our webpage for the latest developments around Trent Valley Archives. www.trentvalleyarchives.com Cover picture: Little Lake Sunset, by Pat Marchen. Fairview Heritage Centre 567 Carnegie Avenue Peterborough Ontario Canada K9L 1N1 705-745-4404 [email protected] www.trentvalleyarchives.com Heritage Gazette of the Trent Valley, volume 19, number 1, May 2014 2 Trent Valley Archives Fairview Heritage Centre Peterborough Ontario K9L 1N1 (705) 745-4404 [email protected] www.trentvalleyarchives.com Reading Room open Tuesday to Saturday 10am to 4pm Board of Directors Peter Adams Ivan Bateman Ron Briegel President’s Corner Alan Brunger Pauline Harder, Past President Karen Hicks, Secretary In this issue of the Heritage Gazette I am Elwood Jones, Treasurer signing off as your President. My term has come to Susan Kyle, President an end; however, I will still be around as Past Wally Macht President. It has been a privilege to serve all of you. Rick Meridew I wish to thank with much gratitude the Shelagh Neck many volunteers who show up regularly to help us Diane Tedford with a variety of tasks and our wonderful staff for Guy Thompson, Vice-President their help and support. A special congratulations to Don Willcock, Heritage Gazette of the Trent Valley Elwood Jones, editor Alice Mackenzie, Gina Martin and Elwood Jones for [email protected] receiving the Ontario Heritage Trust Volunteer Dorothy Sharpe, typist Award for their digitizing of the County land records. The award was presented to them by Dr. Tom Trent Valley Archives Trust Fund Symons at the April 22 Selwyn Township Council Peter Lillico, Michael Bishop, meeting. Dr. Symons is the current chair of the Tom Robinson Ontario Heritage Trust and widely admired for his advocacy and support of heritage issues. Trent Valley Archives Congratulations also to Andre Dorfman for [email protected] Elwood Jones, Archivist being named the Keith Dinsdale Volunteer of the Heather Aiton Landry, Assistant Archivist year Award for 2012 and to Jeannette Cooper, winner Pat Marchen, Assistant Archivist, Photos of the 2013 Award. The award honours the late Amelia Rodgers, Archival Assistant Keith Dinsdale, a tireless volunteer; both Andre and Carol Sucee, Librarian Jeannette have done invaluable work over the past 15 years. Trent Valley Archives Events Chair Forgive me for “Blowing our Horn”, but Ruth Kuchinad [email protected] Trent Valley Archives has been the recipient of the Trent Valley Archives Publications Chair June Callwood Award for Outstanding Acheivement Elwood Jones [email protected] by a Volunteer Organization. This prestigious award The information and opinions expressed are those of the is given annually by the Government of Ontario to contributors and not necessarily those of the Trent Valley Archives approximately 20 individuals or organizations. We or its directors. Unless otherwise noted, illustrations are from the are truly proud to have been chosen. collections of the Trent Valley Archives. ©1998-2013 Trent Valley Archives Yours truly, Any copying, downloading or uploading without the explicit consent of the editor is prohibited. Classroom use is Susan Kyle, encouraged, but please inform the editor of such use. President, Trent Valley Archives Heritage Gazette of the Trent Valley, volume 19, number 1, May 2014 3 The Dummer Murders: Jane Payne and David Doughty, 1872 Elwood H. Jones I People locally were shocked by the double murder of hanged in 1933. The first, second and fifth executions were Jane Payne, the wife of Jeremiah Payne, and their cousin, the for murders of excessive violence. young David Doughty. The local press described the victims The murders were reported in fair detail and it is as “foully butchered” or killed by a “blood thirsty murderer.” possible therefore to get glimpses of everyday life in our area. The process seemed slow to observers in the 1870s, and It is also clear that the murder was solved by circumstantial certainly it was not uncommon to see murder cases proceed evidence as these were still the days before sophisticated through inquest, trial and execution in a matter of weeks. This police techniques and modern criminology. one was protracted by that standard. The murders occurred on Jeremy and Jane Payne lived in North Dummer, Thursday, November 14, and his trial was held in the Spring concession 7 lot 30 on Gilchrist Bay just west of the Stoney Assizes, April 12, 1873. The convicted murdered, William Lake settlement. Their house was on the west side of the lot, Brenton, alias James Fox, appealed the decision on grounds about 70 yards north of the road, and faced south. Jeremy was of insanity, and the appeal was heard on November 28, and 24, Jane, 22 and their young son Samuel was less than two the jury confirmed the verdict of wilful murder. Some people when his mother was murdered. The young couple was were able to have a special commission of doctors established married in March 1870; Jan e was the daughter of Frederick to confirm whether the jury had erred, and so the scheduled and Eliza Miles of Belmont. Jeremiah was the son of Edward execution was postponed. He was executed in the and Sarah Ann Payne. Their near neighbor, James Sutton, Peterborough County Court yard on December 26, 1873; it farmed just south of the Paynes, across the Stoney Lake was Peterborough’s first execution. Road; the house was not visible from Payne’s house as it was This was a story that was followed closely and built on the east side of the lot. In 1871, Jane Payne’s family became part of the local memory for some time. It would be was living just the other side of the Stoney Lake settlement, nearly forty years before another execution in Peterborough about two miles away, in concession 9, lot 31. county; only five were executed by the time the last was David Doughty, 14, was a second cousin to Jeremiah Payne, “and not overly strong.” He was staying at the farm Heritage Gazette of the Trent Valley, volume 19, number 1, May 2014 4 because both Paynes were not comfortable with Brenton passing along the road; 3rd- that he came to Payne, at Sutton's around. at about one o'clock; 4th-that he was met on the road to William Brenton, alias James Fox, was around 50, with Peterboro', about two o'clock, by three men who knew him as white hair but a brown beard. He was about 5’ 9” tall with a Payne's man perfectly well; and 5th-that on Payne's return solid build. He was recently from Sidney Township near home, between three and four o'clock, he found his wife and Belleville. In the 1869 Belleville and Hastings County Doughty murdered.” directory, a William Brenton was a carpenter in Belleville. I Brenton was seen at taverns and tea houses in Dummer found this Brenton, and a brother who was a contractor, and but was not apprehended in Peterborough until midnight of two years older, in both the 1861 and 1871 censuses. the following day, Friday, November 15, at a tavern on However, this William Brenton had a wife and two children, Hunter Street. about 20 and 15 in 1872. The local papers, when discussing Mary Jane Munro thought Brenton was a murderer the Dummer murders, described Brenton as single, working even before coming to the Paynes. She said at the coroner’s as a hired hand with experience as a carpenter. At the inquest, inquest that “he looked like a criminal and would never Brenton said he was single, lived on the fourth concession of answer any questions, tell his name or where he came Sidney township, and that his parents were deceased. Brenton from…” Jane Payne’s parents confirmed that Jane was afraid was, however, deliberately vague about his background. He of Brenton, and that Brenton had worked for her father, apparently was active in a Baptist or Methodist church during Frederick Miles, for about forty days before going to the his first 17 years. daughter’s. Miles hired Brenton because he felt sorry for him William Brenton had worked for Jane’s parents before as he complained no one would hire him.