Refugee Review Tribunal AUSTRALIA
RRT RESEARCH RESPONSE
Research Response Number: IND32459 Country: India Date: 31 October 2007
Keywords: India – Andhra Pradesh – Telugu Desam Party – Congress Party
This response was prepared by the Research & Information Services Section of the Refugee Review Tribunal (RRT) after researching publicly accessible information currently available to the RRT within time constraints. This response is not, and does not purport to be, conclusive as to the merit of any particular claim to refugee status or asylum. This research response may not, under any circumstance, be cited in a decision or any other document. Anyone wishing to use this information may only cite the primary source material contained herein.
Questions
1. Is Hyderabad in Andhra Pradesh state? 2. Is the Congress Party in power in Andhra Pradesh or Hyderabad? 3. Please provide background to the Telegu Desam Party 4. What is the relationship between the Telegu Desam and the Congress Party?
RESPONSE
1. Is Hyderabad in Andhra Pradesh state?
According to the National Informatics Centre, Andhra Pradesh State Centre (Department of Information Technology), Hyderabad is located in Andhra Pradesh. http://www.ap.nic.in/DistCents.htm - Accessed 29 October 2007 – Attachment 1. A map has also been provided showing Hyderabad is located in Andhra Pradesh (ENCARTA – Attachment 2)
Warangal is about 130 km North East of Hyderabad (ENCARTA – Attachment 3).
2. Is the Congress Party in power in Andhra Pradesh or Hyderabad?
According to the Indian Elections website, the Congress Party (INC) won the elections for Andhra Pradesh in 2004 http://www.indian-elections.com/assembly-elections/result-ap- 11may.html#inc Accessed 29 October 2007 – Attachment 4.
3. Please provide background to the Telegu Desam Party. 4. What is the relationship between the Telegu Desam and the Congress Party?
A search of the Tribunal’s resources found scant contemporary information regarding the relationship between the Congress Party and the Telugu Desam Party. The Telegu Desam Party is actually spelt Telugu Desam Party. Rediff.com provides the following information about the party;
Full Name Telugu Desam Party
President Nara Chandrababu Naidu
How did the party come into being? After a long and successful reign as the Telugu film industry's most popular actor Nandamuri Taraka Rama Rao -- or simply NTR -- was keen to do something for the people. He resolved to dedicate his life to social work after he turned 60. While filming Sardar Paparayudu in October 1981, he suddenly announced plans to float a political party.
When was it formed? In March 1982. NTR turned 60 on May 28, 1982.
A film star in politics. How did he fare? NTR built his Telugu Desam Party with the support of media baron Ramoji Rao, who owns Eenadu, the largest circulated newspaper in the state, and Congress dissident Kotla Bhaskara Rao, who later staged a coup against NTR in August 1984, with Indira Gandhi's help, and became chief minister for a while. Both stalwarts were members of NTR's Kamma community.
How did the party fare? In January 1983, the TDP was catapulted to power with an absolute majority, winning 198 of the 294 assembly seats.
Was he that popular? Have no doubt of that! NTR was a hugely popular actor, especially owing to several mythological roles which gave him the status of a demi-god in the minds of people. But that was not the only reason.
What was the other reason? Andhra Pradesh was a Congress stronghold. In 1982, T Anjaiah was the chief minister but NTR was unhappy because he felt the government was being run from Delhi. The state had seen three chief ministers in five years.
The final straw came when Rajiv Gandhi, then a Congress general secretary, publicly rebuked Anjaiah at Hyderabad's Begumpet airport. There was an outcry and NTR decided he had had enough. He decided to contest the assembly election in January 1983.
What was his slogan? Telugu atmagauravam (Telugu self respect)
Where did he get candidates from? He invited applications from educated people to contest the elections.
Did he get any support from other parties? He allied with Maneka Gandhi's Rashtriya Sanjay Manch.
Who runs the party now? NTR's younger son-in-law Nara Chandrababu Naidu.
Who is Chandrababu Naidu? He used to be a Congress leader till he lost the assembly election in 1983. He then joined the TDP. The nuts-and-bolts man, he helped build the party organisation and also served as minister under NTR till he rebelled in August 1995.
Did NTR court controversy? When NTR was out of power between 1989 and 1994, he married Lakshmi Parvathi, his second wife
Who is Lakshmi Parvathi? She met NTR while writing his biography. When he suffered a stroke and was bedridden, his family is alleged to have all but deserted him. At that time, Lakshmi Parvathi stood by him. Once he recovered, he offered to marry her.
Why didn't Naidu get along with her? Not only Naidu, none in NTR's family is said to have liked her. After NTR regained power in 1995, she is reported to have become an extra-constitutional authority, which made her even more unpopular. Naidu, presumably worried that he was no longer NTR's heir apparent, rebelled once he was certain such a mutiny would get the support of NTR's family and TDP MLAs.
What did NTR do? He could do nothing when Naidu took over the party and the chief minister's post with almost all the TDP MLAs backing him. Naidu was sworn in as chief minister on September 1, 1995.
What happened to NTR? He died soon after, in January 1996.
How has the party fared since then? Naidu is absolutely no match for NTR in charisma, but retained power in the 1999 assembly election on the plank of good governance. Since then he has made a widely publicised effort to develop and modernise his state. Naidu's critics say much of this initiative is make believe; the fruits of development have not passed on to most of the state's people.
How is the party governed today? It does not have an elaborate organisational structure. Its apex decision-making body is a 14- member politburo headed by Naidu.
Its Parliamentary strength? With 29 MPs, it has the largest number of members in the Lok Sabha among all the regional parties. Naidu formed an alliance with the Bharatiya Janata Party before the 1999 general election, this after being convener of the United Front, which ruled India between 1996 and 1998,
Strengths? Nara Chandrababu Naidu
What is his contribution? He has strengthened the TDP network and is credited with making the party a major player in Indian politics. After the 1996 general election, he declined to lead the United Front government and instead preferred to be the kingmaker. His alliance with the BJP has paid off -- he has secured many sops for his state, more than any other BJP ally, even though he supports the the National Democratic Alliance only from outside.
Naidu's motto? Fight problems, not people in politics.
Weaknesses? Naidu is the TDP's only leader. There is no second-rung leadership. It is doubtful if his policies have made a positive impact in rural Andhra Pradesh. The farmers' suicides may come to haunt the TDP this election. What makes the TDP different from other parties? It was the first political party in India that issued a Vision 2020 document, which foresees an Andhra Pradesh where poverty is eradicated; where every citizen has access to not just the basic necessities but to all opportunities that will help him lead a happy and fulfilling life.
Its unique appeal? Naidu is seen as a progressive leader. He enjoys the image of an IT-savvy chief minister, one who performs and delivers. He is the darling of the Westernised business class. Naidu is now the longest serving chief minister of Andhra Pradesh. No mean feat that, when you consider some of the notables who have occupied that chair before him -- Neelam Sanjeeva Reddy, P V Narasimha Rao, Kasu Brahmananda Reddy, Jalagam Vengal Rao, Marri Chenna Reddy, and, of course, NTR. Also see: Telugu Desam Party web site (Iype, George & Jafri Syed, 2004, ‘Know the Telugu Desam Party,’ Rediff.com website, 14 April http://www.rediff.com/election/2004/apr/14espec3.htm - Accessed 29 October 2007 - Attachment 5.)
The Political Handbook of the World 2000 – 2002 stated the following;
Telugu Desam Party (TDP). An Andhra Pradesh-based party, Telugu Desam (Telugu Nation) was reported to have been disbanded in March 1992, with six of its Lok Sabha members indicating that it would support the Congress (I) government on certain issues. However, a revitalized party, led by former film star Nandmuri Tarak (N.T) Rama RAO, swept into power in Andhra Pradesh at the state election of December 1994. Subsequent divisions between supporters of Rao and those of the reform-minded Chandrababu Naidu saw the latter replace the former as chief minister in September 1995, with the leadership of the Rao faction passing, after Rao’s death in January 1996, to his widow, Lakshmi Parvathi. In the 1996 national election the TDP-Naidu (or TDP-Babu) won 16 lower house seats as a member of the United Front. In 1998 the Parvathi faction, having organized separately as the NTR Telugu Desam Party, won no seats, while the Naidu faction slipped from 16 to 12. In March 1999 the TDP leadership voted to leave the United Front, in part because the alliance’s central committee had decided to support a Congress Party candidate for speaker of the Lok Sabha. Under Naidu the TDP achieved major gains in 1999, winning 29 Lok Sabha seats and extending its support to the NDA government without, however, joining the Council of Ministers. Parvathi’s group was again unsuccessful at the polls (Banks, A.S & Muller, T.C (eds) 2000 – 20002, Political Handbook of the World, CSA Publications, pg 494, New York (Tribunal Library) – Attachment 6.
An article which appeared in The New Indian Express Group (2007) appears to indicate that the Congress Party and the Telugu Desam Party are rivals. The paper stated;
NEW DELHI: Embarrassed with the snub by the Prime Minister Dr Manmohan Singh by not granting audience, Telugu Desam Party President and former Chief Minister of Andhra Pradesh Chandrababu Naidu on Wednesday vowed to teach befitting lesson.
Chandrababu, who became the Convener of the United National Progressive Alliance (UNPA) made it clear that he would not take the issue of refusal of Prime Minister to give appointment lightly.
Reminding that Telugu pride once taught the lesson to Congress Government, Chandrababu said, “We are not weak. As a former Chief Minister and leader of the opposition, I have a right to meet Prime Minister to bring his notice of the problems of farmers. Refusing appointment to me is nothing but insult to the paddy growers in the country”.
Taking strong exception to the non-response of Prime Minister, Chandrababu described it as negligence towards the problems of farmers. He said, “It is very sad. I condemn it. People will not forgive. It’s a democratic right of the people’s representatives to meet Prime Minister”.
TDP leader said that he sought appointment of Prime Minister to highlight the plight of farmers and addressed two letters to him 14 days back. He said that there was no response from the Prime Minister at all…. (‘PM snubs Candrababu by refusing audience’, 2007, The New Indian Express Group, 25 October, FACTIVA – Attachment 7).
List of Sources Consulted
Internet Sources: Government Information & Reports State Election Commission, http://secharyana.nic.in/ Region Specific Links The Tribune, Chandigarh http://www.tribuneindia.com Haryana News http://www.haryananews.in Hindustan Times http://www.hindustantimes.com Indian Newspapers Links & India News http://www.indiapress.org/ The Times of India http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/ The Hindu http://www.thehindu.com/ The Statesman http://www.thestatesman.org/ The Pioneer http://www.dailypioneer.com/ The Deccan Chronicle www.deccan.com Search Engines Google search engine http://www.google.com.au/ Copernic search engine Databases: FACTIVA (news database) BACIS (DIAC Country Information database) REFINFO (IRBDC (Canada) Country Information database) ISYS (RRT Country Research database, including Amnesty International, Human Rights Watch, US Department of State Reports) MRT- RRT Library Catalogue
List of Attachments
1. National Informatics Centre, Andhra Pradesh State Centre (Department of Information Technology) http://www.ap.nic.in/DistCents.htm - Accessed 29 October 2007.
2. Map of Hyderabad in Andhra Pradesh. (ENCARTA)
3. Map of Warangal in Andhra Pradesh. (ENCARTA)
4. Indian Elections website, http://www.indian-elections.com/assembly-elections/result-ap- 11may.html#inc - Accessed 29 October 2007.
5. Iype, George & Jafri Syed, 2004, ‘Know the Telugu Desam Party,’ Rediff.com website, 14 April http://www.rediff.com/election/2004/apr/14espec3.htm - Accessed 29 October 2007.
6. Banks, A.S & Muller, T.C (eds) 2000 – 20002, Political Handbook of the World, CSA Publications, p 494, New York. (Tribunal Library)
7. ‘PM snubs Candrababu by refusing audience’, 2007, The New Indian Express Group, 25 October. (FACTIVA)