Committee Report
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Report Precis Report of the Assistant Director Planning and Regulatory Services To the Planning Regulatory Board Date: 26/02/2013 Subject Applications under Town and Country Planning Legislation. Purpose of Report This report presents for decision planning, listed building, advertisement, Council development applications and also proposals for works to or felling of trees covered by a Preservation Order and miscellaneous items. Access for the Disabled Implications Where there are any such implications they will be referred to within the individual report. Financial Implications None Crime and Disorder Implications Where there are any such implications they will be referred to within the individual reports. Human Rights Act The Council has considered the general implications of the Human Rights Act in this agenda report. Representations Where representations are received in respect of an application, a summary of those representations is provided in the application report which reflects the key points that have been expressed regarding the proposal. Members are reminded that they have access to all documentation relating to the application, including the full text of any representations and any correspondence which has occurred between the Council and the applicant or any agent of the applicant. Recommendation(s) That the applications be determined in accordance with the recommendations set out in the main report which is attached. Background Papers These are contained within the application files listed in the following schedule of planning applications. They are available for inspection at Barnsley Connects, The Civic Centre, Eldon Street, Barnsley, S70 2JL. 1 INDEX 2013/0144 Refusal Page 4 Erection of a single micro scale wind turbine (15m to hub and 17.8m to blade tip) Cheese Bottom Farm, Cheese Bottom, Thurgoland, Sheffield, S35 7AH 2012/1211 Approval Page 13 Use of site and building for a materials recycling facility including scrap metals. Station Road Industrial Estate, Valley Road, Wombwell, Barnsley, S73 0BS 2012/1201 Approval Page 23 Importation of scrap metal for sorting and bulking up and end of life vehicles for decontamination prior to further off site processing. Laurence Works, Sheffield Road, Springvale, Penistone, Sheffield, S36 6HF 2013/0078 Approval Page 33 Formation of overspill car park. Wentworth Castle, Lowe Lane, Stainborough S75 3ES 2013/0161 Approval Page 42 Alterations and installation of steps to existing public entrance on Lancaster Gate. Barnsley Town Hall, Church Street, Barnsley, South Yorkshire, S70 2AE 2013/0162 Approval Page 42 Alterations and installation of steps to existing public entrance on Lancaster Gate. (Listed Building Consent) Barnsley Town Hall, Church Street, Barnsley, South Yorkshire, S70 2AE 2012/0980 Approval Page 48 Change of use of detached agricultural building to ancillary domestic use in connection with existing dwelling Huthwaite Bank Farm, Old Mill Lane, Thurgoland, Sheffield, S35 7EG 2 2013/0082 Approval Page 54 Erection of 1.8 m high green powder coated paladin boundary fencing and 1 m high fencing increasing to 1.8m above existing stone wall facing Roy Kilner Road to Bowling Club. Darfield and Mitchell Bowling Club, Roy Kilner Road, Darfield, Barnsley. 2013/0085 Approval Page 58 Fell Ash Tree T1 within TPO 1/1951. Cannon Hall Country Park, Bark House Lane, Cawthorne, Barnsley, S75 4AR 2013/0104 Approval Page 62 Removal of 1 no. overhanging branch to Oak Tree (T1) within TPO 1/1953 Hay Green Plantation, Hay Green Lane, Birdwell, Barnsley, S70 5XA 3 2013/0144 Mr Nigel Dowkes Erection of a single micro scale wind turbine (15m to hub and 17.8m to blade tip) Cheese Bottom Farm, Cheese Bottom, Thurgoland, Sheffield, S35 7AH 3 letters of objection. Councillor Barnard objects Councillor Wilson objects Site Location and Description The site is located just to the west of the settlement of Thurgoland. The proposed turbine site lies on a south facing steeply sloping field and lies approximately 105m to the north east of and on a much higher level than the applicant’s dwelling. Above the site at the top of this sloping field runs the B6462 road. The nearest non-involved property, Valley House, lies approximately 104m to the south-west of the proposed turbine Generally the area comprises rolling open agricultural land divided by dry stone walls. On the upper slopes, within the turbine site area, the landscape comprises grassland and occasional small trees. The turbine site is separated from the host property by a substantial belt of trees and an agricultural field which lies below the turbine site. A footpath passes approximately 70m to the south east and east of the site, running up the hillside, and the Trans Pennine Trail runs parallel to the bottom of the valley. Roper House and Stable Range are both Grade II Listed buildings which lie approximately 280m to the south east of the proposed development. Thurgoland Bridge (Grade II) is located approximately 613m to the northwest of the site. The nearest Local Wildlife site (Black Moor) is approximately 600m away. Proposed Development The proposal involves the erection of a single, three-bladed 5 kw wind turbine measuring 15m to the hub with a rotor diameter of 5.6m. The overall height from the base to the blade tip would be 19.8m, the whole painted in matte grey with white blades. The proposal includes a helical pile foundation. The cable run is proposed to be buried in a 600mm deep and 150-175mm wide trench running across the field to the nearest field boundary and then following field boundaries. There will be no ancillary buildings to house electrical equipment. Access to the site is proposed to be gained from an existing field gate from the B6462. The proposed development is on a working farm and the represents a form of farm diversification. It is intended to provide between 7,500KWh and 11,000 kWh renewable electricity per year equating to approximately £500pa saving, and fairly modest CO2 reductions. Policy Context The site lies within the Green Belt in the adopted Core Strategy 4 National Planning Policy Framework The Government attaches great importance to Green Belts. The fundamental aim of Green Belt policy is to prevent urban sprawl by keeping land permanently open; the essential characteristics of Green Belts are their openness and their permanence. When located in the Green Belt, elements of many renewable energy projects will comprise inappropriate development. In such cases developers will need to demonstrate very special circumstances if projects are to proceed. Such very special circumstances may include the wider environmental benefits associated with increased production of energy from renewable sources. When determining planning applications, local planning authorities should: - not require applicants for energy development to demonstrate the overall need for renewable or low carbon energy and also recognise that even small-scale projects provide a valuable contribution to cutting greenhouse gas emissions; and - approve the application if its impacts are (or can be made) acceptable. Once suitable areas for renewable and low carbon energy have been identified in plans, local planning authorities should also expect subsequent applications for commercial scale projects outside these areas to demonstrate that the proposed location meets the criteria used in identifying suitable areas. Core principle 5 of the NPPF requires as well as protecting the Green Belt, we recognise the intrinsic character and beauty of the countryside. Other parts of the NPPF relevant to this planning application are as follows: Supporting a prosperous rural economy. • A positive approach should be taken to sustainable new development. Conserving and enhancing the natural environment. • The planning system should contribute to and enhance the natural and local environment by (amongst other things), protecting and enhancing valued landscapes. Requiring good design • Good design is a key aspect of sustainable development, is indivisible from good planning, and should contribute positively to making places better for people. • Planning policies and decisions should aim to ensure that developments (amongst other things) will function well and add to the overall quality of the area, respond to local character and history and are visually attractive. • Permission should be refused for development of poor design that fails to take the opportunities available for improving the character and quality of an area and the way it functions. Planning Policy Statement 22 (Companion Guide) – is still a relevant material consideration. Provides technical guidance on renewable energy projects including wind turbines. 5 Barnsley Local Development Framework Adopted Core Strategy (CS) The Council has also produced a Consultation Draft of the Development Sites & Places Development Plan Document, which shows possible allocations up to 2026 and associated policies. The document is a material consideration but the weight afforded to it is limited by the fact that it is at an early stage in its preparation. The site is allocated as Green Belt within this document. CSP6 - Development that Produces Renewable Energy - we will allow development that produces renewable energy as long as there is no significantly harmful effect on; • The character of the landscape and appearance of the area • Living conditions • Biodiversity, geodiversity and water quality • Heritage assets, their settings and cultural features and areas • Highway safety and • Infrastructure including