S/03/704 Proposal: Full Planning Permission for Erection of 8 No
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Gail Dent From: Judith Eastham REDACTED BY YDNPA Sent: 25 June 2020 21:26 To: Planning Subject: S/03/704 Dear Ms Clowes and Mr R Graham Planning Application Reference: S/03/704 Proposal: Full planning permission for erection of 8 No. dwellings, associated accesses, parking and landscaping. Address: Land opposite Derry Cottages, Millthrop, Sedbergh We are writing regarding the above planning application and wish to bring to your attention recent issues with the drains that have affected Derry Cottages, Millthrop. As you will be aware Derry Cottages is situated opposite the land for the proposed development of 8 dwellings. In our previous correspondence of 20 May 2020, we raised a question over sewage disposal as the proposed plans are non-committal as to which method will be used; our concern being that the existing sewage disposal system in the hamlet will be unable to cope with a further 8 properties. Our property, No. 1 The Derry had significant problems with the sewerage on 16 June 2020, as well as the properties at No.3 on 3 and 4 June 2020 and No.4 on 15 June 2020. The property at No.2 is presently unoccupied. It is these issues that we wish to bring to your attention as it further highlights the concerns that we raised on 20 May 2020. We have been unable to identify the cause of these blockages, but we have identified what appears to be a collapsed drain at the entrance to Blandses farm, which, we believe may be causing the problem as we did retrieve stones and debris from the blockage. Indeed, Mrs Stacey of Rivermead, stated in her response to the planning application on 4 April 2020, that it was evident that the existing sewerage system is inadequate. She stated that her garage had on occasions been very badly flooded with raw sewage, as had her garden, apparently owing to drains blocked at Blandes Farm itself. We would ask that United Utilities, undertook a full survey of the drains prior to commencement of any proposed building works, with the costs bourne by the developer, to ascertain the suitability of the current foul drainage and possible impact on the rest of the hamlet. Yours Sincerely Joe Dawson and Judith Eastham 1 Gill Allinson From: Yvonne Cervetti REDACTED BY YDNPA Sent: 21 May 2020 11:15 To: Planning Subject: Comment on application: S/03/704 Dear Ms Clowes With reference to the application number S/03/704 for planning development on the land opposite Derry Cottages, Millthrop, we are writing to register our objection on the following grounds: 1) Existing road - the whole length of Frostrow lane is already unsuitable for current traffic which includes heavy farm vehicles, heavy delivery wagons (many of which have to reverse to go down the section of road adjacent to the land proposed for development) as well as domestic transport. The existing single track road is narrow with badly damaged surface, no designated passing places and high pedestrian traffic. Visibility along the road is limited due to blind bends and there are already issues with congestion at the ‘T’ junction in the middle of the hamlet. During recent closure of Millthrop bridge the road through the hamlet was heavily burdened with traffic, many of whom ignored the 20 mile an hour sign and chose to use it as a ‘race track’ causing several accidents. A further 16 cars would massively increase the burden on this road. 2) This road is popular amongst locals as a recreational means to enjoy the local flora and fauna from Spring through to Autumn whether walking, cycling or pushing prams and for all abilities for which local footpaths may not suitable. Our concern is for the the long term ecological damage and imbalance that the proposed development will bring. 3) In recent years climatic changes have resulted in increased flooding not only along Frostrow lane, which becomes impassable, but also in the proposed field for development. Building and tarmacking on this plot would surely result in the water coming down from the fell and further flooding not only the road but the houses which lie lower than the proposed development. During the floods over the last few years the drive up to Blandses farm became a fast flowing river resulting in large quantities of debris being washed down the road, causing potential danger to vehicles. This debris still remains on Frostrow lane and is still a potential hazard. 4) The proposed house designs do not follow the integrity of a Yorkshire Dales hamlet. The designs show opulent dwellings which are not in keeping with current properties in Millthrop. People walking through Millthrop along the Dalesway comment on and appreciate the bucolic nature of the hamlet. A large, estate-like development will damage the current, positive impact. We would like to take this opportunity to thank you for allowing our objections to be noted. Your sincerely, Mykola Hrynyk & Yvonne Cervetti Stonerigg Millthrop Sedbergh LA10 5SJ 1 Gill Allinson From: Judith Eastham REDACTED BY YDNPA Sent: 20 May 2020 22:05 To: Planning Subject: S/03/704 Proposed housing development opposite Derry Cottages Millthrop Sedbergh Cumbria LA10 5SN From: Judith Eastham REDACTED BY YDNPA Dear Ms Clowes, Upon studying the plans for the proposed development we wish to make the following observations and comments. 1. The road infrastructure from the turn off into Millthrop on the Sedbergh/Dent Road to the development site is very narrow, 2.8 metres at the brow of the hill and the same width at 1 to 4 Derry Cottages. The maximum width is 4.4 metres at Hillside House. This makes the road mainly single tracked, with no road markings and limited /no lighting. Additional dwellings will only add to the increased degradation of the road surface, increase the risk of accidents and add to the problem of road congestion. Currently HGV’s to Mr.P.Hoggarths Builders Yard, within the perimeter of Blandses Farm and to Blandses Farm itself from Sedbergh/Dent road as they turn left at Stonerigg to come down the lane either reverse down or reverse out as there is nowhere to turn on the lane. This applies to refuse collection and other delivery firms ,not just to the farm but also properties approaching it. Access for emergency vehicles is also compromised, this will be exacerbated with, and within a new development. Three vehicular entrances to the proposed site from a single track lane is not ideal an alternative would be to go down Blandses farm lane and into the rear of the site giving prospective occupants more privacy, safety and reducing the collision hazard in the lane for the length of the site. The recessed areas outside 1 and 2 Derry Cottages, 1 Hillside, Hillside House and just past Stonerigg are privately owned land and not passing places as could be interpreted from the plans. 2.Within the hamlet of Millthrop,there is already a significant issue over a shortage of car parking spaces with many vehicles parked on the roadside and in lay-bys/gateways.The proposal of 2 parking spaces, per property is potentially insufficient and will lead to additional vehicles parked on the roadside/ in lay-bys which will effectively prevent tourists and visitors to the area using these spaces- thus affecting the local economy. Currently in rural villages and hamlets 59% of houses own 2 or more cars or vans.(source Statista 2020). To illustrate this problem last night (19.05.2020 )I walked through the hamlet and there were a total of 9 vehicles parked on the highway which is already narrow. There were a further two vehicles parked down on the lay-by on the Dent/Sedbergh road. This is in a period of time when we are living in lockdown and second homes and holiday lets are unoccupied, none of the vehicles belonging to them. 3.The make up of the current dwellings in the hamlet of Millthrop is approximately; * 8 private lets (providing a home). * 4 Holiday Lets * 9 Second Homes * 1 Semi-Derelict cottage. 1 * The rest are owner occupied. Since March 2018 there have been seven property sales within Millthrop of which * 2 purchasers have a local connection. * 2 purchasers moved in from out of the area. * 2 purchased as second homes. * 1 purchased to be added to a holiday let portfolio by persons from out of the area. Based on the above is there really a need for 8 new houses in Millthrop? 4.Based on 8 additional properties, our crude figures suggest an increase of 17% of dwellings within the hamlet which is too much in our view, especially with the current vacant properties. It is a known fact that a high percentage of vacant properties will attract crime and vandalism to the area. 5.Within the hamlet there are no local amenities-playground, shop , pub, nursery ,school or place of worship. This means there is a heavy reliance on cars or public transport. It is possible to catch a bus on the Dent /Sedbergh road on a Wednesday or Saturday to the nearest large town of Kendal. The nearest of the above amenities are found in Sedbergh, however all the banks and building societies have closed ,there is no provision for post 16 state education, the over 16s travel further afield if they continue in education the nearest place being Kendal. Despite the significant lack of public transport in term time buses leave Sedbergh around 8am and return around 5pm to take these pupils to school or college. 6.There is no public footpath from the development to Sedbergh.