DOCSLIB.ORG

What Is the Liberal International Order?

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
What Is the Liberal International Order? Policy Essay | Liberal International Order Project | 2017 | No.17 What is the Liberal International Order? By Hans Kundnani In the last five years or so, U.S. and European foreign policy think tanks have become increasingly preoccupied with threats to the set of norms, rules, and institutions known as the liberal international order, especially from “revisionist” rising powers and above all authoritarian powers like China and Russia. But even more recently it has also become increasingly apparent that support for the liberal international order Although Western analysts and policymakers in Europe and the United States is declining as well. often to refer to the “liberal international order,” the This has become particularly clear since the British phrase is far from self-explanatory. In particular, it is vote to the leave the European Union last June and the not obvious in what sense the liberal international U.S. presidential election last November — not least order is “liberal.” The lack of precision about what is because the United Kingdom and the United States meant by the liberal international order is a problem are two of the countries historically most associated with liberalism and were generally thought to be most because it obscures the complexities of the concept committed to it. and inhibits self-criticism by Western policymakers, especially Atlanticists and “pro-Europeans” who seek However, although the phrase “liberal international to defend the liberal international order. order” is widely used, it is far from self-explanatory. The liberal international order has evolved Theorists of the liberal international order understand since its creation after World War II and has different it as an “open and rule-based international order” that is “enshrined in institutions such as the United elements — some of which are in tension with each Nations and norms such as multilateralism.”1 But this other. It is also perceived quite differently outside still leaves big questions unanswered (in what sense the geographic West than within it. Western analysts it is “open” and what are the “rules”?) that tend to be and policymakers need not just to defend the liberal glossed over. One particular ambiguity is around the international order but also to think about how to sense that the liberal international order is “liberal.” reform it — and perhaps even reverse elements of the Does this refer to political liberalism (in opposition evolution of it since the end of the Cold War — in order to authoritarianism)? Or economic liberalism (in to save it. opposition to economic nationalism or mercantilism)? Or liberalism in the sense that international relations theorists use it (in opposition to realism and other theories of international relations)? 1 G. John Ikenberry, “The Future of the Liberal World Order.” Foreign Affairs, May/June 2011, pp. 56-68, here p. 56. Policy Essay The easy answer is that it refers to all three — because how to reform it — and perhaps even reverse some they go hand in hand. But the relationship between elements of the evolution of it since the end of the the three senses of liberalism is not as straightforward Cold War — in order to save it.4 as this implies. Though the history of each of these strands of liberalism is closely related, and they may have gone together seamlessly in the minds of thinkers Evolution of Liberal International Order in Victorian Britain, it is not clear that it is always and everywhere the case — as recent debates about As John Ikenberry has shown, the current international authoritarian capitalism and the “Beijing Consensus” order is actually a kind of fusion of two distinct order- illustrate.2 Moreover, there may also be tensions building projects: firstly the modern state system, a between the three senses of liberalism. For example, project dating back to the Peace of Westphalia in Dani Rodrik argues that “hyperglobalization” is 1648; and secondly the liberal order, which over the undermining democracy — in other words, that the last two centuries was led by the United Kingdom and particular form of economic liberalism the West has the United States and which in the twentieth century pursued and promoted was aided by the “liberal ascendancy” — that is, rise during the last thirty years There was of liberal democratic states.5 The Westphalian order or so is undermining no document was based on the concept of the sovereignty of states. political liberalism.3 “ that laid out The “liberal vision” of Western democracies, on the the basis for other hand, included “open markets, international This essay explores the institutions, cooperative security democratic tensions within the concept a specifically community, progressive change, collective problem of the liberal international liberal solving, shared sovereignty, [and] the rule of law.”6 order. It argues that the international lack of precision about order that In other words, what we think of as the “liberalism” what is meant by the was agreed of the current international system is based on an liberal international order by all the older foundation of “order” — what might be called is a problem because it a “realist” rather than a “liberal” international order. obscures the tensions world’s The post-World War II liberal international order within the concept and powers.” did not simply replace the previous order but rather inhibits self-criticism by developed on top of it. Thus, Ikenberry suggests, Western policymakers, especially Atlanticists and the liberal international order can be thought of in “pro-Europeans,” who as a result tend to become terms of a geological metaphor of layers or “strata”: uncritical defenders of the status quo. The liberal the Westphalian system is a kind of “bedrock” on international order has evolved since its creation after top of which various forms of order have developed World War II and has different elements. Western that have become gradually more liberal over time.7 analysts and policymakers need not just to defend Moreover, within the liberal international order there the liberal international order but also to think about is a tension between “liberalism” and “order,” which can be seen most clearly by examining the evolution of the liberal international order since the end of World War II. 2 The phrase “Beijing Consensus” was originally used by Joshua Cooper Ramo in a report published in 2004. See Joshua Cooper Ramo, “The Beijing Consensus, Foreign 4 For a similar argument about the need to reform the liberal international order in to Policy Centre,” May 2004. See also Stefan Halper, The Beijing Consensus: How China’s save it, see Jeff D. Colgan and Robert E. Keohane, “The liberal order is rigged.” Foreign Authoritarian Model Will Dominate the Twenty-first Century. New York: Basic Book, Affairs, May/June 2017. 2012. Halper writes that states outside the West are “learning to combine market 5 G. John Ikenberry, Liberal Leviathan: The Origins, Crisis, and Transformation of the economics with traditional autocratic or semiautocratic politics in a process that American World Order. Princeton: Princeton University Press, 2011, here p. 1. signals an intellectual rejection of the Western economic model.” 6 Ikenberry, Liberal Leviathan, p. 2. 3 See Dani Rodrik, The Globalization Paradox: Democracy and the Future of the World Economy. New York: Norton, 2011. 7 Ikenberry, Liberal Leviathan, p. xii. G|M|F April 2017 2 Policy Essay Western analysts These institutions: they aspired to be global but were sometimes see the documents dominated by Western powers and to some extent Atlantic Charter — a “ reflected Western economic interests. joint declaration between based on President Franklin D. liberal After the end of the Cold War, the liberal international Roosevelt and Prime principles order evolved further. In some respects, it is Western Minister Winston were signed democracies rather than authoritarian, non-Western, Churchill signed in August only by or rising powers that have been the “revisionist” 1941 — as the founding Western powers during this period. In particular, they drove document of the liberal the creation of the International Criminal Court international order.8 The powers.” (ICC) (though the United States has not joined it) and principles set out in the developed the ideas of a “responsibility to protect” charter included peace and security (including the (R2P), which was adopted by the United Nations in right to self-defense and the preservation of the 2005, and of “humanitarian intervention.”10 These territorial status quo), self-governance (self-rule, innovations have qualified the sovereignty of states in open societies, the rule of law), economic prosperity important and controversial ways. If state sovereignty (economic advancement, improved labor standards, is an essential element of the liberal international social welfare), and free trade and the preservation of order (and some would argue that it is its essence), the global commons. The Atlantic Charter drew on sovereigntist powers such as China and Russia have the “four freedoms” — freedom of speech, freedom a point when they argue that it is they rather than of worship, freedom from want, and freedom from Western powers that are defending the principles fear — that Roosevelt had outlined in his State of the of the liberal international order — albeit the 1945 Union Address earlier in 1941.9 It in turn informed version of it. 11 the U.S. commitment to the postwar recovery and security of Europe through the Marshall Plan and the Seen against the background of this evolution, current North Atlantic Treaty. arguments between the West and authoritarian powers such as China and Russia are not so much However, these documents based on liberal principles about the liberal international order itself but about were signed only by Western powers. There was no different versions of it and in particular about the way document that laid out the basis for a specifically Western powers have sought to change it since the end liberal international order that was agreed by all the of the Cold War.
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Analyzing Change in International Politics: the New Institutionalism and the Interpretative Approach
    Analyzing Change in International Politics: The New Institutionalism and the Interpretative Approach - Guest Lecture - Peter J. Katzenstein* 90/10 This discussion paper was presented as a guest lecture at the MPI für Gesellschaftsforschung, Köln, on April 5, 1990 Max-Planck-Institut für Gesellschaftsforschung Lothringer Str. 78 D-5000 Köln 1 Federal Republic of Germany MPIFG Discussion Paper 90/10 Telephone 0221/ 336050 ISSN 0933-5668 Fax 0221/ 3360555 November 1990 * Prof. Peter J. Katzenstein, Cornell University, Department of Government, McGraw Hall, Ithaca, N.Y. 14853, USA 2 MPIFG Discussion Paper 90/10 Abstract This paper argues that realism misinterprets change in the international system. Realism conceives of states as actors and international regimes as variables that affect national strategies. Alternatively, we can think of states as structures and regimes as part of the overall context in which interests are defined. States conceived as structures offer rich insights into the causes and consequences of international politics. And regimes conceived as a context in which interests are defined offer a broad perspective of the interaction between norms and interests in international politics. The paper concludes by suggesting that it may be time to forego an exclusive reliance on the Euro-centric, Western state system for the derivation of analytical categories. Instead we may benefit also from studying the historical experi- ence of Asian empires while developing analytical categories which may be useful for the analysis of current international developments. ***** In diesem Aufsatz wird argumentiert, daß der "realistische" Ansatz außenpo- litischer Theorie Wandel im internationalen System fehlinterpretiere. Dieser versteht Staaten als Akteure und internationale Regime als Variablen, die nationale Strategien beeinflussen.
    [Show full text]
  • 1 “The Insular Advantage: Geography and the Durability of American
    “The Insular Advantage: Geography and the Durability of American Alliances” John M. Schuessler Bush School of Government and Public Service, Texas A&M University Joshua R. Shifrinson Frederik S. Pardee School of Global Studies, Boston University October 2018 Abstract: President Donald Trump has not been shy about playing hard-ball with close allies. This has led to concerns that Trump poses a unique threat to American alliances. Theoretically, these concerns are consistent with an influential line of argument that points to strategic restraint and reassurance – via binding institutions - as what sets American alliances apart. The fact of the matter is that Trump is not the first American president to play hard-ball with close allies, which leads to a two-part puzzle: What explains the United States’ track record of alliance coercion? And how has its alliance network remained so robust, given this track record? Our argument centers on geography, specifically the fact that the United States is the insular power par excellence. Insularity, we argue, affords the United States two strategic advantages. First, it is free to roam. Second, it is an attractive security provider for states in geopolitically crowded neighborhoods. Together, these advantages account for the United States’ track record of alliance coercion, as well as the limited damage that has been done to core alliances in the process. We demonstrate the value-added of our argument with a case study from the early Cold War, during NATO's formative period. From his election campaign onward, President Donald Trump has not been shy about playing hard-ball with even close allies.
    [Show full text]
  • Liberal Vision Lite: Your Mid-Monthly Update of News from Liberal International
    Liberal Vision Lite: your mid-monthly update of news from Liberal International Thu, Apr 15, 2021 at 6:59 PM Issue n°5 - 15 April 2021 SUBSCRIBE TO OUR NEWSLETTER "We have a chance to re-think & re-invent our future", LI President El Haité tells Liberal Party of Canada Convention. In an introductory keynote, President of Liberal International, Dr Hakima el Haité, addressed thousands of liberals at the Liberal Party of Canada‘s largest policy convention in history. WATCH VIDEO CGLI’s Axworthy tells Canadian liberals, "To solve interlinked challenges, common threads must be found." On 9 April, as thousands of Candian liberals joined the Liberal Party of Canada's first-ever virtual National Convention, distinguished liberal speakers: Hon. Lloyd Axworthy, Hon. Diana Whalen, Chaviva Hosek, Rob Oliphant & President of the Canadian Group of LI Hon. Art Eggleton discussed liberal challenges and offered solutions needed for the decade ahead. WATCH VIDEO On World Health Day, Council of Liberal Presidents call for more equitable access to COVID vaccines Meeting virtually on Tuesday 7 April, the Council of Liberal Presidents convened by the President of Liberal International, Dr Hakima el Haité, applauded the speed with which vaccines have been developed to combat COVID19 but expressed growing concern that the rollout has until now been so unequal around the world. READ JOINT STATEMENT LI-CALD Statement: We cannot allow this conviction to mark the end of Hong Kong LI and the Council of Asian Liberals and Democrats released a joint statement on the conviction of LI individual member & LI Prize for Freedom laureate, Martin Lee along with other pro-democracy leaders in Hong Kong, which has sent shockwaves around the world.
    [Show full text]
  • And I Heard 'Em Say: Listening to the Black Prophetic Cameron J
    Claremont Colleges Scholarship @ Claremont Pomona Senior Theses Pomona Student Scholarship 2015 And I Heard 'Em Say: Listening to the Black Prophetic Cameron J. Cook Pomona College Recommended Citation Cook, Cameron J., "And I Heard 'Em Say: Listening to the Black Prophetic" (2015). Pomona Senior Theses. Paper 138. http://scholarship.claremont.edu/pomona_theses/138 This Open Access Senior Thesis is brought to you for free and open access by the Pomona Student Scholarship at Scholarship @ Claremont. It has been accepted for inclusion in Pomona Senior Theses by an authorized administrator of Scholarship @ Claremont. For more information, please contact [email protected]. 1 And I Heard ‘Em Say: Listening to the Black Prophetic Cameron Cook Senior Thesis Class of 2015 Bachelor of Arts A thesis submitted in partial fulfillment of the Bachelor of Arts degree in Religious Studies Pomona College Spring 2015 2 Table of Contents Acknowledgements Chapter One: Introduction, Can You Hear It? Chapter Two: Nina Simone and the Prophetic Blues Chapter Three: Post-Racial Prophet: Kanye West and the Signs of Liberation Chapter Four: Conclusion, Are You Listening? Bibliography 3 Acknowledgments “In those days it was either live with music or die with noise, and we chose rather desperately to live.” Ralph Ellison, Shadow and Act There are too many people I’d like to thank and acknowledge in this section. I suppose I’ll jump right in. Thank you, Professor Darryl Smith, for being my Religious Studies guide and mentor during my time at Pomona. Your influence in my life is failed by words. Thank you, Professor John Seery, for never rebuking my theories, weird as they may be.
    [Show full text]
  • THOUSAND MILE SONG Also by David Rothenberg
    THOUSAND MILE SONG Also by David Rothenberg Is It Painful to Think? Hand’s End Sudden Music Blue Cliff Record Always the Mountains Why Birds Sing THOUSAND MILE SONG Whale Music In a Sea of Sound DAVID ROTHENBERG A Member of the Perseus Books Group New York Copyright © 2008 by David Rothenberg Published by Basic Books, A Member of the Perseus Books Group All rights reserved. Printed in the United States of America. No part of this book may be reproduced in any manner whatsoever without written permission except in the case of brief quotations embodied in critical articles and reviews. For information, address Basic Books, 387 Park Avenue South, New York, NY 10016–8810. Books published by Basic Books are available at special discounts for bulk purchases in the United States by corporations, institutions, and other organizations. For more information, please contact the Special Markets Department at the Perseus Books Group, 2300 Chestnut Street, Suite 200, Philadelphia, PA 19103, or call (800) 255–1514, or e-mail [email protected]. Designed by Linda Mark Set in 12 pt Granjon by The Perseus Books Group Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Rothenberg, David, 1962- Thousand mile song: whale music in a sea of sound / David Rothenberg. p. cm. Includes bibliographical references and index. ISBN 978-0-465-07128-9 (alk. paper) 1. Whales—Behavior. 2. Whale sounds. I. Title. QL737.C4R63 2008 599.5’1594—dc22 2007048161 10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 CONTENTS 1 WE DIDN’T KNOW, WE DIDN’T KNOW: Whale Song Hits the Charts 1 2GONNA GROW
    [Show full text]
  • William Jennings Bryan and His Opposition to American Imperialism in the Commoner
    The Uncommon Commoner: William Jennings Bryan and his Opposition to American Imperialism in The Commoner by Dante Joseph Basista Submitted in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree of Master of Arts in the History Program YOUNGSTOWN STATE UNIVERSITY August, 2019 The Uncommon Commoner: William Jennings Bryan and his Opposition to American Imperialism in The Commoner Dante Joseph Basista I hereby release this thesis to the public. I understand that this thesis will be made available from the OhioLINK ETD Center and the Maag Library Circulation Desk for public access. I also authorize the University or other individuals to make copies of this thesis as needed for scholarly research. Signature: Dante Basista, Student Date Approvals: Dr. David Simonelli, Thesis Advisor Date Dr. Martha Pallante, Committee Member Date Dr. Donna DeBlasio, Committee Member Date Dr. Salvatore A. Sanders, Dean of Graduate Studies Date ABSTRACT This is a study of the correspondence and published writings of three-time Democratic Presidential nominee William Jennings Bryan in relation to his role in the anti-imperialist movement that opposed the US acquisition of the Philippines, Guam and Puerto Rico following the Spanish-American War. Historians have disagreed over whether Bryan was genuine in his opposition to an American empire in the 1900 presidential election and have overlooked the period following the election in which Bryan’s editorials opposing imperialism were a major part of his weekly newspaper, The Commoner. The argument is made that Bryan was authentic in his opposition to imperialism in the 1900 presidential election, as proven by his attention to the issue in the two years following his election loss.
    [Show full text]
  • Was American Expansion Abroad Justified?
    NEW YORK STATE SOCIAL STUDIES RESOURCE TOOLKIT 8th Grade American Expansion Inquiry Was American Expansion Abroad Justified? Newspaper front page about the explosIon of the USS Maine, an AmerIcan war shIp. New York Journal. “DestructIon of the War ShIp Maine was the Work of an Enemy,” February 17, 1898. PublIc domain. Available at http://www.pbs.org/crucIble/headlIne7.html. Supporting Questions 1. What condItIons Influenced the United States’ expansion abroad? 2. What arguments were made In favor of ImperIalIsm and the SpanIsh-AmerIcan War? 3. What arguments were made In opposItIon to ImperIalIsm and the SpanIsh-AmerIcan War? 4. What were the results of the US involvement in the Spanish-AmerIcan War? THIS WORK IS LICENSED UNDER A CREATIVE COMMONS ATTRIBUTION- NONCOMMERCIAL- SHAREALIKE 4.0 INTERNATIONAL LICENSE. 1 NEW YORK STATE SOCIAL STUDIES RESOURCE TOOLKIT 8th Grade American Expansion Inquiry Was American Expansion Abroad Justified? 8.3 EXPANSION AND IMPERIALISM: BegInning In the second half of the 19th century, economIc, New York State Social polItIcal, and cultural factors contrIbuted to a push for westward expansIon and more aggressIve Studies Framework Key UnIted States foreIgn polIcy. Idea & Practices Gathering, Using, and Interpreting EVidence Geographic Reasoning Economics and Economic Systems Staging the Question UNDERSTAND Discuss a recent mIlItary InterventIon abroad by the UnIted States. Supporting Question 1 Supporting Question 2 Supporting Question 3 Supporting Question 4 What condItIons Influenced What arguments were
    [Show full text]
  • FROM the G7 to a D-10: Strengthening Democratic Cooperation for Today’S Challenges
    FROM THE G7 TO THE D-10 : STRENGTHENING DEMOCRATIC COOPERATION FOR TODAY’S CHALLENGES FROM THE G7 TO A D-10: Strengthening Democratic Cooperation for Today’s Challenges Ash Jain and Matthew Kroenig (United States) With Tobias Bunde (Germany), Sophia Gaston (United Kingdom), and Yuichi Hosoya (Japan) ATLANTIC COUNCIL A Scowcroft Center for Strategy and Security The Scowcroft Center for Strategy and Security works to develop sustainable, nonpartisan strategies to address the most important security challenges facing the United States and the world. The Center honors General Brent Scowcroft’s legacy of service and embodies his ethos of nonpartisan commitment to the cause of security, support for US leadership in cooperation with allies and partners, and dedication to the mentorship of the next generation of leaders. Democratic Order Initiative This report is a product of the Scowcroft Center’s Democratic Order Initiative, which is aimed at reenergizing American global leadership and strengthening cooperation among the world’s democracies in support of a rules-based democratic order. The authors would like to acknowledge Joel Kesselbrenner, Jeffrey Cimmino, Audrey Oien, and Paul Cormarie for their efforts and contributions to this report. This report is written and published in accordance with the Atlantic Council Policy on Intellectual Independence. The authors are solely responsible for its analysis and recommendations. The Atlantic Council and its donors do not determine, nor do they necessarily endorse or advocate for, any of this report’s conclusions. © 2021 The Atlantic Council of the United States. All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced or transmitted in any form or by any means without permission in writing from the Atlantic Council, except in the case of brief quotations in news articles, critical articles, or reviews.
    [Show full text]
  • El Gato Negro Menu December 2018
    PARA PICAR CHARCUTERIE Matrimonia: marinated and salted anchovies and piquillo pepper on tostada ..........6.5 Black truffle salchichón with cornichons ..........................................................................6 Padrón peppers with Halen Môn sea salt .........................................................................5 Ibérico chorizo with caperberries ..................................................................................5.5 Our own-recipe marinated olives with chilli, lemon, garlic and rosemary ..................4 Teruel lomo (sliced, cured pork loin) with celeriac rémoulade .....................................6 Roasted Valencia almonds..................................................................................................4 Jamón serrano with celeriac rémoulade 50g ....................................................................6 Catalan bread with olive oil, garlic and fresh tomato .....................................................4 Cecina (cured, smoked beef) with shaved Manchego and pickled walnuts ...............8 Catalan bread with olive oil, garlic, fresh tomato and jamón serrano .......................5.5 Acorn-fed jamón ibérico de bellota 50g ..........................................................................13 Sourdough bread with olive oil and Pedro Ximénez balsamic ...................................3.5 Picos Blue cheese with caramelized walnuts................................................................5.5 Bikini (toasted sandwich with jamón serrano, Manchego &
    [Show full text]
  • Why the Liberal World Order Will Survive G
    ROUNDTABLE: RISING POWERS AND THE INTERNATIONAL ORDER Why the Liberal World Order Will Survive G. John Ikenberry he international order built and led by the United States and its part- ners is in crisis. In the Middle East, East Asia, and even in Western T Europe, long-standing regional orders are in transition or breaking down. Global international agreements and institutions—across the realms of trade, arms control, environment, human rights—seem to be weakening. For seventy years the United States has stood at the center of a Western-oriented, liberal international system, organized around openness, rules, and multilateral cooperation. After the cold war this American liberal hegemonic order spread outward and seemed to offer the world a universal logic for global politics. But that unipolar moment has now passed. Today, the United States and the Western industrial democracies, roiled by nationalist and populist upheavals, have turned inward and appear less committed to their own post-war liberal international project. The crisis of the American-led international order would seem to open up new opportunities for rising states—notably China, India, and other non-Western developing countries—to reshape the global order. But in what ways are rising states seeking to reform or reorganize the rules and institutions of the post-war era? Do they seek to rise up and integrate into the existing international order or do they seek to transform it? Are they “stakeholder” or “revisionist” states? Over the past decade, these questions have stood at the center of debates about the future of the global system. Indeed, the Obama administration placed the chal- lenge of integrating rising states at the center of its foreign policy.
    [Show full text]
  • New Order Ghost Gigs a Disruption 002
    New Order Ghost Gigs A Disruption 002 ORIGINALLY RECORDED FRIDAY 6 DECEMBER 1985 1.15pm, Thursday 6 December 2018 The Hive, New Cavendish Street hursday 6 December marks the anniversary of SETLIST New Order playing at our New Cavendish Street site. It is in fact the 33rd anniversary, which seems appropriate given the musical relevance of 331/3 RPM. 1985 marked the midpoint of a curious and eclectic musical 1 decade. On one level the era of Phil Collins and Paul Young, of Band Aid ATMOSPHERE Tand Bryan Adams, of Stock Aitken & Waterman and Stars Stars on 45. However outside of this superficial view the period was an amazingly diverse one. The 2 beginning of the decade saw the end of the post punk and new wave period, the DREAMS NEVER END emergence of the much maligned new romantic scene and the critically acclaimed two tone movement. At the same time rap music began to enter the mainstream 3 and later came the House Sound of Chicago and stirrings from Detroit, the PROCESSION second summer of love and the high water mark of rave culture, with the end 4 of the decade seeing guitar music enter centre stage again through the rise of SUNRISE grunge. Seminal albums were released throughout that still stand the test of time. 5 For New Order 1985 was the year of Lowlife, LONESOME TONIGHT the Festival of the Tenth Summer. Formed in 1980 from the ashes of Joy Division after the 6 untimely death of Ian Curtis, New Order were WEIRDO a groundbreaking band. Signed to Factory Records, and very much the Factory band, the 7 group had by this point released three critically 586 acclaimed albums and a batch of unassailable 8 singles, including Ceremony (A Joy Division THE PERFECT KISS song, and the first New Order single neatly seguing past and future), Temptation (the 9 first dance infused glimpse of what was to FACE UP come) and the groundbreaking Blue Monday 10 (allegedly the best selling 12" single of the time, but which lost money due to the AGE OF CONSENT technical aesthetic requirements of its sleeve).
    [Show full text]
  • Smoking Gun Proof That Illuminati Planned
    SMOKING GUN PROOF THAT ILLUMINATI PLANN...S AGO TO BRING DOWN OUR CULTURE: Part 3 Title: "SMOKING GUN" PROOF THAT ILLUMINATI PLANNED TERRIBLE EVENTS MANY YEARS AGO TO BRING DOWN OUR CULTURE: Part 3 Subtitle: Events are occurring now, weakening the Old World Resources to aid your Order so the New can be established. You will be surprised to Understanding learn how many of the recent events of our society are designed to enhance the new global dictatorship of which Antichrist will take control. It is later than you think! Events foretold In The 1995 Illuminati Card Game -- "Stage Being Set" The New World Order is coming! Are you ready? Once you understand what this New World Order really is, and how it is being gradually implemented, you will be able to see it progressing in your daily news!! Learn how to protect yourself, your loved ones! . Stand by for insights so startling you will never look at the news the same way Attorney-General John again. Ashcroft’s Concentration Camp Program— Audio Tape YOU ARE NOW ON THE CUTTING EDGE INTRODUCTION - BACKGROUND We have covered the background of Steve Jackson and his S.J. Games in NEWS1753, and strongly urge you to read it so you will understand the implications of the attempt of the government to shut Jackson down before he could get his Panopticon -- Big Brother's Eye Are Watching Us - Illuminati Card Game to the market. Jackson knew Audio Tape the specific plans of the Illuminati by which they could slowly dissolve the Old World Order -- based largely on Christian principles in Western Societies -- and replace it with the New World Order, complete with the appearance of Antichrist.
    [Show full text]