New Left Notes Mexican Movement Fights Continued Repression

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

New Left Notes Mexican Movement Fights Continued Repression Students for a Democratic Society 1608 West Madison Chicago, Illinois -Agitators- The Man let it be known through official "leaks* this week that indictments are about NEW to be issued against several "professional agitators" who travel to campuses to incite rebellion. The Justice Department claims to have "substantial evidence" and dossiers LEFT against such people—who presumably will be prosecuted under the Stokely Carmichael interstate riot act. People are reminded not to do the Man's work by giving him NOTES any information at all. Vol. 4, Number 11 LET THE PEOPLE DECIDE March 13, 1969 Mexico has a long history as a colony, first under the Mexico Spanish, then the French. Today, American business dominates the country. Last fall, more than 50 persons were murdered when they demonstrated for reforms: the struggle continues. For a look at Mexico's history and present situation, see page 2. Modern Greece exemplifies Greece the development of U.S. cold-war policy and its anti-communism. Litton Industries and the CIA helped make it that way. See story on page 2. Oil interests Middle East are strong here, where Al-Fatah is leading the struggle for National Liberation. For the third in a series, see page 4. O - -rm 5, Ö0Q O zSw5 3 .3 & w h s S The Berkeley strike is now in its seventh week. For an Z tri O Q analysis of what's going on (and not going on), see Page 8. 2 March 13,1969 New Left Notes Mexican movement fights continued repression by Bob Stewart marriage, confiscation of church lands, (In Mexico all schools of higher learning, By toe end of August, the struggle Chairman, Chicago and toe beginnings of agrarian reform. including vocational schools, are had begun to acquire toe characteristics Revolutionary Contingent However, because of the degeneration supposedly autonomous.) In response to of a mass movement, and toe largest of the Mexican government into a this incident the students at toe demonstration in toe history of Mexico To understand fully the events of last complete dictatorship of the moneyed Polytechnic Institute called a protest was held. On August 27, 700,000 people year in Mexico, as well as events in the classes under Porfirio Diaz and the demonstration for the 26th of July to gathered in toe Zocalo (the main square) future, it is essential to understand the growing influence of U.S. imperialism coincide with one called bythe university across from toe National Palace in history of Mexico. Unlike toe history (oil, textiles, mining, railroads), another in support of Cuba. Both demonstrations support of toe student demands. This we're taught in the U.S., it is not an upheaval was in toe making. And in 1910 were attacked by toe Granaderos. Two was the high point of the movement. abstract string of events seemingly the dam broke,ledbyFrancisco(Pancho) students were killed, 200 injured, and By this time 500,000 students were out unrelated to present-day activity, but Villa and Emiliano Zapata on toe left many were arrested. on strike throughout the country and rather an accumulation of experiences (peasants) and Francisco Madero, Comités de Lucha (struggle committees) that are manifested in Mexican political Alvaro ObregonandVeustanzioCarranza Demands, August Action wito a revolutionary perspective were life in a very direct way. Present-day on the right (bourgeoisie). Eight years The students responded by: 1) forming being formed not only in schools but Mexicans can relate political questions of civil war took place, first against the National Strike Council, 2) going out also in factories and workers' to events that took place centuries ago, the Diaz regime, and then between toe on strike (200,000 students), 3) drawing neighborhoods, and among peasants. and so have a sense of continuity wito left and right forces as well as against up six demands calling for freedom for history that makes political struggles U.S. invasions in 1914 and 1917. Though political prisoners, disbanding of toe Naturally, the government wasn't seem toe natural course of events the forces of the left lost, toey left Granaderos, etc., 4) setting up political happy. The Olympics were approaching rather than being unusual. a mark toat still remains, giving the brigades to get their side of the story fast and no amount of intimidation struggle an anti-feudal, anti-imperialist out to toe people, and 5) intensifying seemed to slow the movement down. Imperialist Invasion and anti-clerical character. Where toe the struggle in toe streets. Diaz Ordaz went on TV and radio revolutionary armies had not instituted During August there was at least one pledging to defend toe Mexican equivalent While Mexican history goes back over it themselves, toe government began of "Law and Order," but to no avail. 2000 years, the period of conquest is major demonstration a week, involving land reform. Where the foreign bosses tens, then hundreds of thousands of regarded as the beginning of modern had not already left, the government Repression Hits Hard history. Mexicans regarded toe conquest participants. While the demonstrations nationalized foreign enterprises. Today built solidarity and spirit among the period around 1520, when toe Aztec in Mexico all mining, petroleum, On September 19, toe government capital of Tenochtitlan was destroyed students and provoked bloody, but railroads, electricity, telephones and expensive, battles with the police made its most serious act of repression; by Cortez, not as the beginning of an telegraphs, as well as sections of the Mexican troops occupied the university, era of enlightenment and civilization, (Mexican students burn buses as a chemicals and metals industries, are means of hurting the government arrested everyone, including employees, but as toe opening battle in toe Mexican nationalized. and surrounded toe Polytechnic Institute, people's struggles against western financially). Political brigades worked painting slogans on wall s and distributing This was a serious blow to toe imperialism. Cortez, far from being movement, as it meant toe loss of more a hero, is regarded as a degenerate Popular Struggles Continue leaflets to workers. Students would jump on a bus (few Mexicans have cars) activists as well as the loss of a place and a thief, while Cuauhctemoc and The Mexico of today, however, is a of refuge and base of operations. Four Quitlac, two Indian chiefs who fought without paying, distribute leaflets, get far cry from toe revolutionary off at toe next stop, and get on another days of street fighting between students Cortez, are looked on as the first in expectations of Mexicans in toe 20's and and soldiers, wito many workers and a long line of resistance heroes. bus. In this manner the whole city was 30's; and the "revolution" which covered with leaflets in a short space working-class youth helping the Mexican schoolchildren are taught today Mexican politicians talk so much about students, followed the occupation. how their ancestors fought to toe last of time with a minimum of contact with has been abandoned in the face of U.S. the cops. Also, street meetings were Students used rifles and Molotov man against toe rifles and cannons of economic influence. U.S. factories like cocktails, and workers' wives helped the Spaniards. held in a sort of guerrilla-like fashion, General Motors, Ford, GJE., and since toe cops by raining down on toe cops various While toe Spaniards may have won Goodyear dot the landscape; Coca Cola would break up objects such as bottles, bricks, and the first round, toe Mexicans still signs cover storefronts, and Mexican any meeting tubs of ' hot water from apartment resisted. Uprisings by various Indian agricultural productivity has been very quickly. windows. Motorists would stop and allow groups, slave rebellions, and resistance increased (a benefit of the revolution)— students to siphon off gas. The to land seizures and feudal dues went on not to make Mexico self-sufficient in self-igniting Molotov cocktail was born for the next 300 years, the Spaniards food, but to provide cheap tomatoes, in the chemistry labs of toe Polytechnic livingparasitically off the sweat of toe oranges, lettuce, and cotton for the Indians and contributing nothing to toe U.S. markets. development of the country. It should also be understood that Mexican Resistance popular struggles have not stopped. In 1958 there was nearly a general Finally, about 1810, a Catholic priest strike, and toe Mexican peasants have named Hidalgo Gater excommunicated) put up a continual struggle for more started an uprising in the small town of land, modernized production, and higher by Stephanie On Dec. 3, 1944, the Athens EAM prices. In toe last four years there have Dolores, which, though defeated, sparked Rugoff and Beth called a demonstration in support of been four major peasant struggles in off a struggle that was finally able to Lyons, NYU SDS a larger voice for toe Resistance in throw «sut the Spanish. This struggle different parts of the republic. This is toe new government. 500,000 men, the setting for the student uprising of had a characteristic that is common to April 21, 1969 marks women, and children poured into the last year. all progressive struggles in Mexico: the second annivers - streets. The demonstration began it had a mass base of workers, peasants, In mid^July, 1968, a group of youths ary of toe Greek junta. peacefully. The demonstrators were slaves, artisans, and lower sections of from Vocational School Number 5 had The right-wing colonels attacked from hidden positions by the the clergy. This was not just a struggle a fight in which toe police intervened. seized control using police (some of whom had held toe same for a change in control; the struggle A battle between cops and students NATO weapons and the positions under the Nazis).
Recommended publications
  • Fighting Injustice
    Fighting Injustice by Michael E. Tigar Copyright © 2001 by Michael E. Tigar All rights reserved CONTENTS Introduction 000 Prologue It Doesn’t Get Any Better Than This 000 Chapter 1 The Sense of Injustice 000 Chapter 2 What Law School Was About 000 Chapter 3 Washington – Unemployment Compensation 000 Chapter 4 Civil Wrongs 000 Chapter 5 Divisive War -- Prelude 000 Chapter 6 Divisive War – Draft Board Days and Nights 000 Chapter 7 Military Justice Is to Justice . 000 Chapter 8 Chicago Blues 000 Chapter 9 Like A Bird On A Wire 000 Chapter 10 By Any Means Necessary 000 Chapter 11 Speech Plus 000 Chapter 12 Death – And That’s Final 000 Chapter 13 Politics – Not As Usual 000 Chapter 14 Looking Forward -- Changing Direction 000 Appendix Chronology 000 Afterword 000 SENSING INJUSTICE, DRAFT OF 7/11/13, PAGE 2 Introduction This is a memoir of sorts. So I had best make one thing clear. I am going to recount events differently than you may remember them. I will reach into the stream of memory and pull out this or that pebble that has been cast there by my fate. The pebbles when cast may have had jagged edges, now worn away by the stream. So I tell it as memory permits, and maybe not entirely as it was. This could be called lying, but more charitably it is simply what life gives to each of us as our memories of events are shaped in ways that give us smiles and help us to go on. I do not have transcripts of all the cases in the book, so I recall them as well as I can.
    [Show full text]
  • The First Domestic Trial Against Terrorism
    Click here for Full Issue of EIR Volume 4, Number 51, December 19, 1977 II. How The Support Networks indicted and became known as the "Seattle 8." (2). Protect Terrorism Thomas Michael Justensen, one of the "8," went un­ derground and was arrested last month in Los Angeles 12 The six to remammg criminals-turned­ for conspiracy to conduct bombings and assassinations. "revolutionary" terrrorists of the George Jackson The FBI has identified Justensen as a member of the Brigade have succeeded in eluding federal, state and law "Revolutionary Committee" of the Weatherun­ enforcement officials for over two years only with the derground. support of an extensive proterrorist milieu that has At the same time, other members of the SLF were 1969, festered in the Seattle area since when a faction of indicted and tried for direct terrorist acts: John Van­ the Weathermen led by recent Democratic Party City Veenendal, Jan Tissot, and police informant Jeff Council candidate Charles "Chip" Marshall chose the Desmond were charged with bombing a Seattle Post area as a base of operations. Office; Silas Trim Bissell and his wife Judith Emily The top level of protection for the Brigade operations Bissell became fugitives after posting $50,000 bail on a comes from the King County Democratic Party, whose charge of planting a dynamite bomb at the University of political endorsement of "reformed" Weatherman Washington Air Force ROTC building. Judith Bissell was Marshall has served the interests of terrorism in two arrested with Justensen last month in Los Angeles. critical ways: first, by insulating Marshall's political VanVeenendal and Roger Lippman, who is presently a associates, many of whom are presently involved in fugitive from charges filed against him by the U.S.
    [Show full text]
  • The Weather Underground Report Committee on The
    94TH CoNobasg let eeio#8 00MMITTEN PRINT THE WEATHER UNDERGROUND REPORT OF TH7 SUBCOMMITTEE TO INVESTIGATE THE ADMINISTRATION OF THE INTERNAL SECURITY ACT AND OTHER INTERNAL SECURITY LAWS OF THn COMMITTEE ON THE JUDICIARY UNITED STATES SENATE NINETY-FOURTH CONGRESS FIRST SESSION JANUARY 1975 U.S. GOVERNMENT PRINTING OF110 39-242 WASHINGTON : 1975 For sale by the Superintendent of Documents U.8. Government Prnting Office, Waohington, D.C. 2040a Pice $1.60 jJ54QC~ -.3 COMMITTEE ON THE JUDICIARY JAMES 0. EASTLAND, MIsisppi, Chbaimon JOHIN L. McCLELLAN, Arkansas ROMAN L. 71 It USKA, Nebraska PHILIP A. HART, Michigan III RAM L. FONO0, Hawali EDWARD M. KENNEDY, Mamaohusmtts H1UOH SCOTT, Pennsylvania BIRCH BAYH, Indiana STROM TiUItMON D, South Carolina QUENTIN N. BURDICK, Nmth Dakota CIJA RLES McC. MATHIAS, JR., Maryland ROBERT C. BYRD, West Virginia WILLIAM L. 8('OTT, Virginia JOHN V. TUNNEY, California JAMES ABOUREZK, South Dakota SUnCOMMiTTIv To INVKSTIOATH TIe ADMINISTrATION o0 THE, INTERNAL SECURITY ACT AND OTHER INTERNAL SECURITY LAWS JAMES 0. EASTLAN ), MAisissdppi, Chairman JOHN L. McCLELLAN, Arkanras STROM TIHURMOND, South Carolina BIRCH BAYJI. Indiana J. 0. SOURWINH, Chief Cownsel ALYONUO L. TARADOCHIIA, Chief InIVtesgalor MARY DOOLEY, Adcng Director of Research RESOLUTION Resolved, by the Internal Security Subcommittee of the Senate Committee on the Judiciary, that the attached report entitled "The Weather Underground," shall be printed for the use of the Com- mnittee on the Judiciary. JAMES 0. EASTLAND, Chairman. Approved: January 30, 1975. (n) CONTENTS Pan Foreword ......................................................... v The Weatherman Organization 1 Overview ......................................................... 1 Weatherman Political Theory-----------------------------. 9 Weatherman Chronology ........................................... 13 National War Council .....---------------------------- 20 The Faces of Weatherman Underground ............................
    [Show full text]
  • The Case of the George Jackson Brigade
    Click here for Full Issue of EIR Volume 4, Number 51, December 19, 1977 COUNTERINTELLIGENCE The Case Of The George Jackson Brigade On June 20, 1976, the Seattle Police Department raided immediately dismantled. As documented here, the very a Seattle appartment as part of their ongoing in­ same organizations backing the suit against the vestigation into the terrorist George Jackson Brigade, Seattle Police Department are up to their ears in finding components of timing devices, diagrams of bankrolling the George Jackson Brigade, providing the public buildings, and a "hit list," which included names printing presses, legal defense funds, and, in some cases, of U.S. Labor Party members and others. With this the "safe houses" for Brigade members that ensure the evidence in hand, the entire Brigade, but especially the existence of terrorism in this country. above-ground support networks that protect the terror­ The Coalition on Government Spying (CGS) is itself ists, of which the apartment's occupants, Paul ZiiseJ, part of the national organization under a similar name, Helene Ellenbogen and Wayne Parker are top figures, the Campaign to Stop Government Spying. The CGS in could have been dismantled. Seattle works in conjunction with the Institute for Policy They weren't, and the prospect of continued terrorist Studies of Washington, D.C., the Center for National attacks by the Brigade looms even larger. In the past 12 Securities Studies. Locally the Coalition is composed of months, the Brigade has been directly responsible for the the Seattle Left Bank Collective, the National Lawyers I.c,'. deaths of two policemen, two Brigade members, the Guild, EI Centro de la Raza, and the American Friends wounding of one policeman and numerous innocent .
    [Show full text]
  • COINTELPRO.S.Pdf
    COINTELPRO, FBI Counterintelligence, Covert Operations, Black Bag Jobs, Church Committee COINTELPRO http://www.icdc.com/~paulwolf/cointel.htm (1 of 7) [9/3/2001 11:33:41 AM] COINTELPRO, FBI Counterintelligence, Covert Operations, Black Bag Jobs, Church Committee COINTELPRO was the FBI's secret program to undermine the popular upsurge which swept the country during the 1960s. Though the name stands for "Counterintelligence Program," the targets were not enemy spies. The FBI set out to eliminate "radical" political opposition inside the US. When traditional modes of repression (exposure, blatant harassment, and prosecution for political crimes) failed to counter the growing insurgency, and even helped to fuel it, the Bureau took the law into its own hands and secretly used fraud and force to sabotage constitutionally - protected political activity. Its methods ranged far beyond surveillance, and amounted to a domestic version of the covert action for which the CIA has become infamous throughout the world. The COINTELPRO Papers: Documents from the FBI's Secret Wars Against Dissent in the United States by Ward Churchill & Jim Vander Wall Preface - The Face of COINTELPRO HTML Index to the Documents Introduction - A Glimpse Into the Files of America's Political Police Chapter 1 - Understanding Deletions in FBI Documents Chapter 2 - COINTELPRO - CP/USA Chapter 3 - COINTELPRO - SWP Chapter 4 - COINTELPRO - Puerto Rican Independence Movement Chapter 5 - COINTELPRO - Black Liberation Movement Chapter 6 - COINTELPRO - New Left Chapter 7 - COINTELPRO
    [Show full text]
  • Daily Iowan (Iowa City, Iowa), 1970-11-12
    'Bye, Clouds Deer_ing cloudineu ThurllllY .l1li cooler east. Highs in tht mid 40 •. F.lr • Thursday night with low. Igaln in the upper 201 nerth to low.r 3.. lOUthtast. rs Incr... ing cloudiness Iglin Frldly with oil a chance of rain we.t. High, in mlcl Serving the University of Iowa and the People 01 Iowa City the ~~: \J to upper .os. spack. l.t.bU.h... I. 1868 low. City, low. S2240-'.ur.... y, Nov. 12, 197. e•• t •• Cop, pted for I. ~a rd via ,"ounce· to U :cepted. ['Seattle Seven/ Auto Negotiators s , Trial Scheduled' Agree on Pact TACOMA, Wash . 1m - Seven young filed agains~ Marshall, Dowd, Kelly and people go on trial here Monday on feder· Abeles. DETROIT (All - The United Auto tng was adjourned UIlttJ ' :311 a. m. Thursday to give union officials al conspiracy charges stemming from Lerner came to Seattle from Berkeley, Workers and General Motors reached a more vandalism at a U.S. building in Seattle CatiL , and spent a year as a visiting pro· tentative agreement Wednesday on a time to write up an explanation 01 the estmenl last winter. The defendants and the gov­ fessor of philosophy at the University of new three-year labor contract which olIer. could set the strike-crippled auto giant ' rappin~ ernment already are arguing the case's Washington . His contract was not renew­ Bargaining table sourc~, however, lre safe significance. ed. Marshall , a political science gradu­ towards full prodUction by the end of said the pact Included these Items: The defendants, who call themselves ate of Cornell University, KeUy , Ms.
    [Show full text]
  • Weather Underground—Things That Happened to Me When I Was a Kid
    William Morrow An Imprint of HarperCollinsPublishers Mark Rudd My Life with SDS and the Weathermen Contents Preface vi PART I: COLUMBIA (1965–1968) 1 A Good German 3 2 Love and War 27 3 Action Faction 38 4 Columbia Liberated 57 5 Police Riot: Strike! 85 6 Create Two, Three, Many Columbias 104 PART II: SDS AND WEATHERMAN (1968–1970) 7 National Traveler 119 8 SDS Split 141 9 Bring the War Home! 154 10 Days of Rage 171 Photographic Insert v | CONTENTS 11 To West Eleventh Street 187 12 Mendocino 204 PART III: UNDERGROUND (1970–1977) 13 The Bell Jar 219 14 Santa Fe 233 15 Schoolhouse Blues 250 16 WUO Split 270 17 A Middle-Class Hero 285 Epilogue 301 Acknowledgments 323 Appendix: Map of Columbia University Main Campus, New York City, 1968 325 About the Author Credits Cover Copyright About the Publisher Preface or twenty-five years I’d avoided talking about my past. During that time I had made an entirely new life in Albu- Fquerque, New Mexico, as a teacher, father of two, inter- mittent husband, and perennial community activist. But in a short few months, two seemingly unrelated events came together to make me change my mind and begin speaking in public about my role in Students for a Democratic Society (SDS) and the Weather Underground—things that happened to me when I was a kid. First, in March 2003, the United States attacked Iraq, beginning a bloody, long, and futile war of conquest. What I saw, despite some significant differences, was Vietnam all over again.
    [Show full text]
  • Executive Intelligence Review, Volume 4, Number 51, December
    Dec. 19, 1977 Vol. IV No. 51 EXECUTIVE INTELLIGENCE REVIEW New Solidarity International Press Service five dollars [THIS PAGE IS INTENTIONALLY BLANK] Dec. 19, 1977 Vol. IV ISSN 0146-9614 No. 51 EXECUTIVE INTELLIGENCE REVIEW P.o. Box 1972 GPO New York, N.Y. 10001 TABLE OF CONTENTS INTERNATIONAL COUNTERINTELLIGENCE 1 Foreign Exchange: British Coup Against Dollar 1 The Case Of The George Jackson Brigade LaRouche Denounces Treason In High U.S. Circles 2 ' 3 - The Traitors And Their Orders 4 - Europe Worried... U.S. Bankers Equivocate EUROPE 5 U.S. Leaders Consider Exim Bank Expansion, To Halt$ Crash 1 Portugal: Shakeup Draws Int'I Policy Lines 4 EEC: Decision Postponed On Davignon Plan 5 W. Germany: Will Bonn's New Economics Minister SPECIAL REPORT Last? 1 The Interim Strategic Situation. Part I MIDDLE EAST U.S. REPORT 1 Begin's Visit To U.S. 1 Support From Europe For Comprehensive Settle- 1 The Administration: 'Coup' Against Carter ment 2 Energy: Bill on the Rocks. Schlesinger Policy Intact 4 - France Offers Helping Hand 3 Georgia Business Meet: Demand Expanded Ex- 5 Syria: Assad Maintains Opposition To Cairo Meet ports 6 Israeli Press: Begin And Dayan Disagree 'Over Everything' ECONOMICS 1 Banking: Investment Banks Start Eurodollar Panic ASIA 3 World Trade: London's Protectionist Push 4 Japan: Currency Panic Grows 1 India: Seeks' Atoms For Peace' 5 Steel: Alperovitz On How To Dismantle Steel PRESS ENERGY 1 St. Louis Newspapers Draw Battle Lines 1 OPEC Behind Oil Price Freeze 2 The British Invasion Of U.S. Media 2 Administration Environmentalists Out To Destroy 3 NBC's New Smear Job Exim Bank 3 Soviet Scientist Urges Readying Fusion LABOR 1 Special Report: AFL-CIO Convention Falls Behind Plan To Wreck U.S.
    [Show full text]
  • Dangers of Dissent : the FBI and Civil Liberties Since 1965 / Ivan Greenberg
    THE DANGERS OF DISSENT 110_503_Greenberg_Finals.indb0_503_Greenberg_Finals.indb i 99/23/10/23/10 88:18:18 AAMM 110_503_Greenberg_Finals.indb0_503_Greenberg_Finals.indb iiii 99/23/10/23/10 88:18:18 AAMM THE DANGERS OF DISSENT The FBI and Civil Liberties since 1965 Ivan Greenberg L EXINGTON BOOKS A division of ROWMAN & LITTLEFIELD PUBLISHERS, INC. Lanham • Boulder • New York • Toronto • Plymouth, UK 110_503_Greenberg_Finals.indb0_503_Greenberg_Finals.indb iiiiii 99/23/10/23/10 88:18:18 AAMM Published by Lexington Books A division of Rowman & Littlefield Publishers, Inc. A wholly owned subsidiary of The Rowman & Littlefield Publishing Group, Inc. 4501 Forbes Boulevard, Suite 200, Lanham, Maryland 20706 www.lexingtonbooks.com Estover Road, Plymouth PL6 7PY, United Kingdom Copyright © 2010 by Lexington Books All rights reserved. No part of this book may be reproduced in any form or by any electronic or mechanical means, including information storage and retrieval systems, without written permission from the publisher, except by a reviewer who may quote passages in a review. British Library Cataloguing in Publication Information Available Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Greenberg, Ivan, 1962– The dangers of dissent : the FBI and civil liberties since 1965 / Ivan Greenberg. p. cm. Includes bibliographical references and index. ISBN 978-0-7391-4938-6 (cloth : alk. paper) — ISBN 978-0-7391-4940-9 (electronic) 1. United States. Federal Bureau of Investigation—History. 2. Criminal investigation— United States—History. 3. Undercover operations—United States—History. 4. Internal security—United States—History. 5. Intelligence service—United States—History. 6. Civil rights—United States—History. 7. Abuse of administrative power—United States—History.
    [Show full text]
  • Learning from Thucydides: an Ancient Historian Writes Contemporary History *
    Histos () – LEARNING FROM THUCYDIDES: AN ANCIENT HISTORIAN WRITES CONTEMPORARY HISTORY * Abstract : Ancient writers of history such as Thucydides and Polybius had to depend mostly on eye-witness testimony, collected in personal interviews. Thucydides was explicit about the problems inherent in this method: eyewitnesses were biased, unaware, forgetful. In –, I had a unique experience for a modern historian of antiquity: while writing a book about radical guerrillas of the late s and early s, I personally interviewed many actual participants in dramatic historical events. I found that Thucydides’ warnings about the pitfalls of the interview method were more than affirmed by my own direct experience. Keywords : Thucydides; Polybius; eyewitness testimony; Weatherman; Tom Hayden; ‘Days of Rage’ ll three of our greatest preserved Greek historians depended primarily on oral informants. Herodotus makes this clear right from the Aintroductory chapters of Book (..– ). 1 Polybius indicates that he chose the main period of his work—covering events from BC onwards— because this was the period when eyewitnesses were available (..). Polybius depended on written narratives, too—for instance, on Fabius Pictor and Philinus of Agrigentum for the First Punic War (.)—but was harshly critical of historians whose work depended solely on other written narratives (see Book , passim ). 2 As for Thucydides, in a famous passage (..–), he not only acknowledges his dependence on oral informants in constructing his narrative of the Peloponnesian War, but he also articulates the serious problems he encountered in depending mostly on eyewitnesses. In trying to construct an accurate account of events on the basis of oral testimony by informants, Thucydides says: … far from permitting myself to derive it from the first source that came to hand, I did not even trust my own impressions, but the narrative rests partly on what I saw myself, partly on what others saw for me, the accuracy of the report being always tried by the most severe and detailed tests possible.
    [Show full text]