CITY of BOROONDARA Review of B-Graded Buildings in Kew, Camberwell and Hawthorn
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
CITY OF BOROONDARA Review of B-graded buildings in Kew, Camberwell and Hawthorn Prepared for City of Boroondara January 2007 Revised June 2007 VOLUME 3 DATA SHEETS FOR CAMBERWELL AND HAWTHORN TABLE OF CONTENTS VOLUME 1 Main Report VOLUME 2 Individual Building Data Sheets – Kew VOLUME 3 Individual Building Data Sheets – Camberwell and Hawthorn VOLUME 4 Individual Building Data Sheets for buildings not recommended for the Heritage Overlay LOVELL CHEN 1 Introduction to the Data Sheets The following data sheets have been designed to incorporate relevant factual information relating to the history and physical fabric of each place, as well as the analysis and assessment supporting the recommendation for the application of the overlay. The following table contains explanatory notes on the various sections of the data sheets Section on data sheet Explanatory Note Name Original and later names have been included where known. In the event no name is known, the work House appears on the data sheet Reference No. For administrative use by Council. Building type Usually Residence, unless otherwise stated. Address Address as advised by Council and checked on site. Survey Date Date when site visited. Noted here if access was requested but not provided. Grading Grading following review (A or B). While the reviewed gradings are broadly in line with the general approach of the earlier studies, they do not always reflect the detail of the definitions in the earlier studies. In general, a B grading reflects a local level of significance, while an A grading reflects a higher level of significance (either state or municipal, refer to the statement of significance for clarification). It is noted that the City of Boroondara is currently working on a review of its local heritage policy framework which would seek to develop categories of ‘Significant’ and ‘Contributory’ buildings (these categories to be defined with reference to the grading systems used in the earlier municipal studies). Date Date of construction. Previous Grading Grading in earlier study. Photograph Photographs were taken by the consultants in 2005-6. Extent of overlay As recommended in this Review. Most commonly the recommendation is to title boundaries as this is accepted practice in the application of planning scheme overlays. In a small number of cases this recommendation varies. Intactness Where possible, an assessment of intactness has been made. This assessment (Good, Fair or Poor) is intended to refer only to visible external fabric and is not intended in most cases to 2 LOVELL CHEN consider rear or otherwise non-visible fabric or interiors. Heritage Status Indicates any listing on the Victorian Heritage Register, the Register of the National Estate or the National Trust Register. The recommendation for inclusion in the Boroondara Planning Scheme is noted here. History The history section incorporates in most cases material prepared by other consultants in the earlier municipal heritage studies. This material has been revised and in many cases expanded (though in others material considered to be of limited significance equally has been deleted). Footnotes from the original studies have been included (though these have not been verified). The authors of the earlier studies have been acknowledged by the note at the end of the history section. Description & Integrity This section is based on the site inspection, in most cases combined with other documentation such as drawings and planning and building file information. The objective in this section is to describe the fabric and identify alterations and additions. Refer to Section 2.4 in Volume 1. Historical Context This brief note is intended to help to place the building in its historical context. In some cases it includes information on the historical development of the surrounding area; in others it is simply a note about the building stock existing in the area. Comparative Analysis This section helps to place the building in its architectural and typological contexts, making reference to stylistic sources in some cases, and to other comparable buildings. Refer to section 2.6 in Volume 1 for further discussion. Assessment Against Criteria For a discussion of the criteria and their application in this Review, refer to section 2.7 in Volume 1 of the report. Statement of Significance The statement of significance summarises the results of the assessment against criteria. It is a concise and brief statement noting the level of significance (local, municipal or state/national) and the nature of the significance. It does not repeat historical or descriptive material or list all significant fabric. Note that in all cases, buildings have been noted as being of historical significance even where not assessed against the relevant criteria (A or G). This is in recognition of the fact that all the buildings contribute in a general sense and at a local level to the historical framework of the area. Refer to discussion at section 2.7 of Volume 1. Grading Review Comments on the revised grading. LOVELL CHEN 3 Recommendations Recommendations for the inclusion in the overlay. In some cases, additional recommendations are made. Identified By Reference to the earlier municipal study in which the building was identified. References General and specific references. Refer also to the Select Bibliography in Volume 1 (4.0) This volume of the report includes data sheets for the following buildings: Camberwell and surrounding suburbs 24 Albion Street, Surrey Hills 15 Alma Road, Camberwell 25 Alma Road, Camberwell 33 Alma Road, Camberwell 36 Alma Road, Camberwell 78 Athelstan Road, Camberwell 2 Beatrice Street, Burwood 87-87A Bowen Street, Camberwell 930 Burke Road, Balwyn 458 Camberwell Road, Camberwell 29 Canterbury Road, Camberwell 136 Canterbury Road, Canterbury 138 Canterbury Road, Canterbury 169 Canterbury Road, Canterbury 24 Chaucer Crescent, Canterbury 44 Currajong Avenue, Camberwell 33 Deepdene Road, Balwyn 119 Doncaster Road, North Balwyn 10 Fitzgerald Street, Balwyn 177 Glen Iris Road, Glen Iris 32 Hortense Street, Burwood 30 Howard Street, Glen Iris 27 Inglesby Road, Camberwell 6 Kitchener Street, Balwyn (provisional) 4 LOVELL CHEN 11 Luena Road, North Balwyn 7-9 Mangarra Road, Canterbury 91 Maud Street, North Balwyn 51 Mont Albert Road, Canterbury 65 Mont Albert Road, Canterbury 137 Mont Albert Road, Canterbury 158 Mont Albert Road, Canterbury 1 Montana Street, Glen Iris 7 Muriel Street, Glen Iris 622 Riversdale Road, Camberwell 626-8 Riversdale Road, Camberwell (provisional) 660 Riversdale Road, Camberwell 11 The Avenue, Surrey Hills (provisional) 899 Toorak Road, Camberwell (provisional) 931 Toorak Road, Camberwell 1292 Toorak Road, Glen Iris 1293 Toorak Road, Burwood 1297 Toorak Road, Burwood 89 Union Road, Surrey Hills 286 Union Road, Surrey Hills 7 Victoria Avenue, Canterbury 13 Victoria Avenue, Canterbury 12 Vincent Street, Surrey Hills 26A Wandsworth Road, Surrey Hills 50 Wandsworth Road, Surrey Hills 294 Warrigal Road, Burwood 452 Warrigal Road, Ashburton 125 Wattle Valley Road, Camberwell 136 Whitehorse Road, Balwyn 199 Whitehorse Road, Balwyn 127 Winmalee Road, Balwyn 150 Winmalee Road, Balwyn LOVELL CHEN 5 41-45 Yarrbat Avenue, Balwyn Hawthorn 173 Auburn Road, Hawthorn 7 Elphin Grove, Hawthorn 26 Lisson Grove, Hawthorn (provisional) 1 Neave Street, Hawthorn 61 Wattle Road, Hawthorn 149 Victoria Road, Hawthorn 6 LOVELL CHEN Boroondara Heritage Review B Graded Buildings Lovell Chen 2005 Building Citation Name Thule Croft Reference No Address 24 Albion Street, Surrey Hills Survey Date 20 September 2005 Building Type Residence Grading B Date 1911 Previous B Grading Extent of Overlay Refer Recommendations Intactness 9 Good Fair Poor Heritage Status HV AHC NT Rec. BPS Heritage Overlay History Harrison Rotherham acted as builder and C M Rotherham as owner to construct this nine-room, two- storied concrete dwelling in 1911.1 To date, no architect has been associated with the project. Curiously, an image of this house or an identical house is reproduced in the Camberwell Conservation Study 1991 (vol. 2, p. 55), where it is described as being the home of SH Wilson, Albion Road, Canterbury. No date is given but the source of the image is identified as the Real Property Annual.2 Harrison Rotherham and his family lived there until c.1925. Rotherham resided in Leopold Crescent, Surrey Hills, at the turn of the century and later at 435 Kent Street, Surrey Hills.3 His business lay with Rotherham Wood & Co., manufacturers agents, Elizabeth Street, Melbourne.4 Within a generation he had reputedly shifted his interests to the Dominion Brace and Garter Co. Pty Ltd, Hawthorn. Rotherham, Wood & Co. represented among others: Josiah Parkers, makers of locks; Geo Salter & Co., spring balance (scales) and iron manufacturers; Summerscales Mangles; Newman door springs; the Wyoming Shovel Co.; and Adshead and Smellie, art-metal makers. They were wholesale only but displayed all of the makers’ samples and could be contacted by telegraph from any government or Reuter office. Rotherham attended the Philadelphia Commercial Congress, as Melbourne’s delegate, in 1899.5 Thule Croft had minor (and unspecified) additions in 1935 and 1947, and was converted into flats and had a carport constructed in 1960.6 More recently it was returned to use as a single dwelling, and alterations were undertaken to the front fence and the rear of the house (at ground and first floor levels) in 1999-2002.7 (G Butler, Camberwell Conservation Study 1991, additional research by Lovell Chen, 2005) Boroondara Heritage Review B Graded Buildings Lovell Chen 2005 Building Citation Description & Integrity Thule Croft, at 24 Albion Street, Surrey Hills, is a two-storey attic-roofed house evidently with stone footings,8 and concrete masonry ground floor walls and chimneys, a return verandah facing north and east, and a shingle covered upper storey, formed from several attic wings. The shingles at the upper level appear possibly to have been replaced more recently in an atypical pattern of 30 cm squares. The attic wings and dormers are original other than for the small dormer in the main roof form, which has been added.