<<

Reflections on Improvements in the Use of Vertebrate Pesticides in New Zealand: 1996 - 2006 CharlesEason LandcareResearch,Auckland,NewZealand DavidMorgan,PennyFisher, and BrianHopkins LandcareResearch,Lincoln,NewZealand PhilCowan LandcareResearch,PalmerstonNorth,NewZealand ABSTRACT : VertebratepesticidesforwildanimalcontrolinNewZealandcameunderscrutinyinthe1980sand1990s,which engenderedconsiderableresearchtoupdatethetoxicologydatabasesofoldercompounds,suchas1080ordiphacinone,tomeet currentinternationalregistrationstandards.Inparalleltherewasafocusonidentifying“usepatterns”andformulationsthatare effectiveatkillingpestsandlesshazardoustootherwildlife.Improvedbaitqualityandreducedsowingratesfor1080baitfor possum control in New Zealand, down from 10-15 kg of bait per hectare to 1-3 kg, has been accompanied by increased effectivenessandreducednon-targetrisk.Thishasbeencoupledwithanimprovedunderstandingof1080toxicologyandrisk communicationamongstpestcontrolprofessionalsandwiththecommunity.Inaddition, invivo metabolismandpersistencestudies coupledwithfieldsurveyshaveimprovedunderstandingofthetoxicokineticsandnon-targeteffectsofdifferent. This enabled improved choice of tools for island versus mainland use in New Zealand. The risks associated with “one-off” applications of baits containing second-generation anticoagulants for rodent eradication on islands are considered to be very substantially outweighed by the potential benefits to their ecosystems. On the mainland, contamination of wildlife and game species and risk of secondary poisoning have been substantially reduced by switching from second- to first-generation anticoagulants.Finally,thesedevelopmentswerecoupledwiththeidentificationofimprovedbaitsforgroundcontrolofpossums androdents,suchasencapsulatedandgelbaitscontaining,whichinturnreducedanover-relianceon1080 and anticoagulants alone. Nevertheless, safer use patterns, improved formulations and target specificity, and new vertebrate pesticidesarestillrequired,andthiswillbeamajorchallengeforthe21 st Century. KEY WORDS : 1080,anticoagulants,NewZealand,non-targets,regulatorytoxicology,toxicokinetics,vertebratepesticides Proc.22 nd Vertebr.PestConf. (R.M.TimmandJ.M.O’Brien,Eds.) PublishedatUniv.ofCalif.,Davis. 2006. Pp.406-412. INTRODUCTION haveremainedlargelyunchanged(Eason etal .2000),the Thechemicalsusedforcontrollingvertebratepestsare waytheyareusedhasimprovedconsiderably. classified as 1) anticoagulants, which include , Inthe1990s,concernswerefrequentlyexpressedby , diphacinone, , , thecommunitywithregardstotheuseof1080andother , , flocoumafen, and toxins, and there were different concerns amongst pest difethalione,or2)non-anticoagulants,whichincludeany controloperatorsaboutthecontinuedavailabilityoftools substancethatdoesnotfallintheformercategory,such for conservation and Tb control (Seawright and Eason as , cyanide, zinc phosphide, sodium mono- 1994). It is timely to reflect on the improved use of fluoroacetate(1080),cholecalciferol,andcalciferol. vertebrate pesticides and improvement in community Vertebrate pest control in New Zealand principally support for endangered species protection and disease targets rodents, possums, mustelids, and rabbits and is controlinNewZealand. undertakenusingbaits,usuallycerealpelletscontaininga poison.Thepoisonsmostwidelyusedinclude1080,and Achievement1:QualityAssurancetoEnableReduced anticoagulants and cyanide, with increasing use of AerialSowingRates cholecalciferol.Itislikelywewillneedthesetoolsfor Aerialcontrolusing1080(sodiummonofluoroacetate) the foreseeable future for control of disease and baitshasbeenwidelyusedinNewZealandsincethelate conservationpurposes. 1960s for the control of introduced brushtail possums The risk to non-target wildlife, livestock, pets, or (Trichosurusvulpecula ).Asrecentlyastheearly1990s, humans from baits containing vertebrate pesticides will high application rates of up to 15 kg/ha of 1080 baits be determined in part by the animal’s intrinsic werebeingused.Consideringthatonly1or2baitswere susceptibility,thepropertiesofthepoisonsused(suchas required to kill a possum, these sowing rates were their toxicokinetics), bait design and their deployment excessive.Thiswasprimarilyaconsequenceof1)bait methods, and the site-specific complexities of the food being of highly variable size, toxicity, and palatability, websinareasinwhichtheyareused,whichmaylimitor and 2) baiting coverage being as much as 48% incom- exacerbatetheexposureofnon-targetspecies.Whilstthe plete(Morgan2004).Sincepossumsloseappetite30-60 poisonsusedforvertebratepestcontrolinNewZealand minutes after eating a 1080 bait, it was essential that 406 (a) (b) 20 65 35 55

30 16 55 45 45 25 35 12 20 35 15 8 25 Cost ($/ha) 25 Cost ($/ha) 10 15 4 15 Mean sowing rate (kg/ha) Mean sowing rate (kg/ha) 5 5 0 0 5 1973-77 1978-82 1983-87 1988-92 1993-97 1998-2002 1973-77 1978-82 1983-87 1988-92 1993-97 1998-2002 Years Years Figure1.Meanbaitsowingratesfora)pelletandb)carrotbaitsfrom1973to2002.CPI-adjustedcost(NZ$/ha)forthese controloperationswashighlylinearlyrelatedtoapplicationrate,sothecorrespondingcostforeachapplicationrateis indicatedbytheright-handaxis.Pointsonthegraphsrefertosowingrate (fromMorgan2004) . aerial distribution of small, sublethal baits should be detoxification or breakdown) of 1080 and fluorocitrate avoided, not only to achieve high mortality but also to has been demonstrated in animals and other living avoid the creation of bait-shy surviving populations organisms(Eason etal .1993b). (Morgan et al . 1996) and to reduce the risk to Theearliestreportsonratssuggestedthatsome1080 invertebratesandbirdsthatmayfeedonsmallfragments wasretainedfor1-4days.Inamorerecentstudyusing of bait (Harrison 1978, Notman 1989). Bait specifica- mice, 1080 concentrations in plasma, muscle, and liver tions were therefore developed that converted scientific decreased by half after less than 2 hours. Prolonged understanding of key parameters (e.g., susceptibility to persistenceof1080inanimalsaftersublethalexposureis 1080)intopracticalmanufacturingadvice. unlikely,andthishasbeenconfirmedforlargeranimals, Oncebaitofhigherqualitybecameavailable,itwas suchasrabbits,goats,possums,andsheep(Eason etal . possible to further reduce sowing rates. Field studies 1994). The highest concentrations occur in the blood, were undertaken to assess the coverage achieved in withmoderatelevelsinthemuscleandkidneys,andthe normalaerialbaitingoperations.Largegaps,upto400m lowestconcentrationsintheliver.Alltracesofthetoxin inwidth,wereoftenfoundbetweenbaitingswaths,and arethereforelikelytobeeliminatedwithin1week.The these were potentially refuges in which possums could significance of comparatively rapid metabolism and survive.Sowingbaitsat3kg/hawasaseffectiveasat10 excretionisthat1080isunlikelytobioaccumulateinthe kg/ha, indicating the potential for substantially reducing foodchainandthe“withholdingperiod”forlivestockthat operationalcostsbyusingmachinerycapableofdistribut- aresuspectedofhavinghadcontactwith1080baitscan ing baits uniformly at low rates (Morgan 1994). bedefined(Eason etal .1994). Navigationalguidancesystemswereevaluatedandfound However, for some reason in the 1990s rapid to improve the accuracy of bait distribution such that eliminationof1080wasconfusedwithsafetyandlower complete coverage could be achieved. These findings risk of toxicity. As we all know, 1080 is extremely encouraged the reduction in bait sowing rates that had poisonous, with an LD 50 of 1 mg/kg or less for many beguntooccurasaresultofgrowingexperienceamong species(Atzert1971,Eisler1995). pestmanagers(Figure1),andby1997averagekillshad increasedfrom70%(duringthe1970s)toover90%ata ToxicologyandPathology reducedcostofaroundNZ$9millionannually(Morgan Known affected sites in animals following 1080 et al . 1997) and with reduced non-target mortalities exposure include the heart, lungs, liver, kidneys, and (Spurr2000). foetus.Pathologicalchangescanbeproducedbysingle lethaldosesorprolongedsublethalexposure. Achievement2:ImprovedUnderstandingof1080 In the mid-1990s, a study showed that lesions Toxicology associated with 1080 exposure in sheep included FateinAnimals scattered foci of fibrous tissue in the myocardium and Absorption, metabolism, and excretion studies in mild degeneration in the striatum, hippocampus, and laboratory animals since the 1950s have shown that nucleus tractus solitarius in the brain. However, ewes sublethalamountsof1080areexcretedbothunchanged that survived exposure to 1080 (including single and and as a range of non-toxic metabolites. In laboratory repeateddosesfor5days)didnotexperienceanyadverse rodents dosed with sublethal doses, 1080 is rapidly long-term effects (Wickstrom et al . 1997). Although absorbed and distributed through the soft tissues and 1080 itself is not cumulative, studies in sheep and organs.Thiscontrastswiththeactionofcommonlyused laboratoryratsdemonstratethatcumulativedamagetothe , such as brodifacoum, which heartorotherorganscanoccurfromrepeatedexposureto are extremely persistent. Sodium monofluoroacetate is sublethal doses of 1080 (Wickstrom et al. 1997, Eason excreted as unchanged fluoroacetate and a range of and Turck 2002). Obviously, livestock must not be metabolites including fluorocitrate. Defluorination (i.e., allowedaccesstotoxicbaits,andevenpartiallydegraded

407 baits should be regarded as hazardous. Furthermore, does it cause birth defects (i.e., is it a developmental humanexposureatanysignificantlevelmustnotoccur. toxicant?). Results of 3 different, complementary tests We have ensured this is the case in New Zealand by indicatethat1080isnotmutagenic.Resultsofdevelop- regularmonitoringandimprovedhandlingpractise.Our mentaltoxicitystudiesinratsshowedthatasingledose improved understanding of these risks and potential hadnoeffect.However,whenfemaleratswereexposed effectshasallowedmanagerstocontinuetoimprovepest torelativelyhighdoses(0.33and0.75mg/kg)forabout controlpractisetoensurehumanexposureamongstthose 30% of their gestation, mild skeletal effects were involvedinpestcontroldoesnotoccur. detected. The NOEL for development effects was 0.1 mg/kg/day based on observations of bent ribs at 0.33 Achievement3:RegulatoryToxicology mg/kg/day(Eason etal. 1999). Laboratory-basedregulatorytoxicologystudiesallow TheNOELforratsadministered1080viaoralgavage for the characterisation of a chemical in terms of its for90dayswas0.075mg/kg/day.Microscopicchanges potentialtocausegeneticmutations,foetalabnormalities, in the testes and heart were seen in males dosed with and target-organ toxicity, as well as defining no- 1080at0.25mg/kg/dayfor90days.Adverseeffectsofa observable-effect levels (NOELs) on which drinking single large dose and repeated 1080 doses have been water standards are set. The NOELs are needed for describedinmanystudiesinratsconfirmingthatduring setting rigorous acceptable daily intakes (ADI), which sublethal exposure to 1080 the most sensitive sites for can form the basis for determining a maximum toxicity are the heart, epididymides, testes, and foetus acceptablevalue(MAV)indrinkingwater. (EasonandTurck2002). Abatteryoflaboratory-basedtoxicologystudieswere In conclusion, at high doses 1080 causes death. At completedintheUSAbefore1995.Theseincluded17 substantialsublethaldosesaboveNOEL,1080mayaffect studies on product chemistry, 6 studies on wildlife a number of organs, predominantly those with high hazards, and 4 studies relevant to human health. The metabolic activity, e.g., the heart and testes. The results from these studies were summarised in the sublethaleffectontestesisdistinctfromthosemediated proceedingsofascienceworkshopon1080(Fagerstone by“classical”endocrinedisruptors.Effectsonthetestes et al . 1994, Seawright and Eason 1994) (see Table 1). arelikelytooccurthroughinhibitionoftheKrebsCycle– Themostrelevantofthesestudiestothehealthofthose adifferentmechanismtothewell-recognized“endocrine involved in pest control in New Zealand was on acute disruptors” like DDT, which have specific actions dermaltoxicityof1080inrabbits.Inthistest,5maleand mediatedbyhormonereceptors. 5 female rabbits were treated dermally with each of 4 Toxicology studies have defined the NOELs for dose levels of 1080 paste. The estimate LD 50 was sustained exposure. As mentioned in the previous approximately300mg/kgversus0.4mg/kgwhenorally section,theresultsareofgreatestrelevancetoworkersin ingested. It had long been known that 1080 can be the pest control industry (at the plants manufacturing absorbed through the gastrointestinal tract, but was less baits), who work with 1080 on a day-to-day basis. readily absorbed through the intact skin. However, the Clearlytheyunderpintheuseofstrictsafetyprocedures result of this study demonstrated that poor dermal at these factories and when 1080 baits are used in the absorption of 1080 does not imply no absorption, and field. They do not indicate risk to the general public there were obviously implications with regards to undernormalandcarefuluse. enforcing strict codes of practise and appropriate protectiveclothingforthoseinvolvedinthemanufacture Achievement4:ImprovedCommunityInteraction orhandlingof1080baits–whicharefullyunderstoodand Increaseduseof1080inthe1980sand1990sinNew enforced,asmentionedintheprevioussection. Zealandhasbeenmetbyincreasedopposition.Several In addition to toxicity data, it is now necessary to anti-1080 organisations emerged, and subsequently a provideanswerstothefollowinggeneralquestions:Does national network was formed in 1993 called the “1080 1080 alter genetic material (i.e., is it mutagenic?), and ActionNetwork New Zealand(TANNZ)”tocoordinate Table1.Toxicologystudiesrequiredtosatisfyregulatoryrequirements. Studytypesrequiredforregistrationofanewpesticide Statusof1080database

Acutetoxicity Extensivedatabseintheliterature(seeRammellandFleming1978, SeawrightandEason1994,Eisler1995) Skinandeyeirritation Completed(seeFagerstone etal .1994) Skinsensitisation Completed(seeFagerstone etal .1994) Mutagenicitystudies Completed(seeEason etal .1999) Three-monthfeedingstudies Completed(seeEasonandTurck2002) Developmentaltoxicity(teratogenicity,reproductivetoxicity) Completed(seeEason etal .1999) Metabolism/pharmacologystudies Extensivepublisheddatabase Environmentalstudies Extensivepublisheddatabase(seeParfitt etal .1994,Eason2002)but GoodLaboratoryPractisestudiestoEPAspecificationsstillnot completed.

408 newsletters and fund protest activity and court cases. (Nelson and Hickling 1994). Bullard et al . (1976) re- TANNZandmostotheranti-1080groupsorindividuals portedthatcowsdosedwithdiphacinonehaddetectable recognizethethreatTbposestoNewZealand’sfarming liver residues 90 days after dosing. None of these industry and agree that possum numbers need to be previous studies allow the accurate definition of reduced to protect forests. They believe that ground persistence of any of the anticoagulants in tissues for huntingmethodsbasedaroundtrapping,cyanide,andthe comparative purposes and selection of tools for best use of bait stations are environmentally, culturally, and managementpractise. socially much more acceptable methods than aerially- Comparative pharmacokinetics is an important basis sown1080.Thoseinfavorofaerialsowing1080baits forassessmentofrisktonon-targetspecies.Thehepatic believe that it is the most cost-effective option for persistence of second-generation anticoagulants, such as inaccessibleterrain. brodifacoum,intheliverofmammalswaswellcharacter- Therewere>800newspaperarticlespublishedinNew ized in comparison to first-generation anticoagulants, Zealand on 1080 during 1994 (Chong Press Clipping althoughestimatesofplasmaretentionforthelattergroup Bureau).Occasionally, misinformationorconfrontation are available in the literature. Recommendations on resulted in sensational media stories (Eason 1995). In preferred anticoagulants for field use in New Zealand contrast,articleson1080inthemediaareararityin2005 weremadeonestimatesoftheirpersistenceintheliverof and2006. a range of mammal species, based on relatively few In the late 1980s, a technical response to this published studies. This literature suggests low-single- oppositionhadbeentodeclare1080as“safe”,andeven dose-potency anticoagulants such as warfarin and on occasions swallow a bait at a community meeting. pindonepersistintheliver for0.5-1 months, moderate- Whilstthisapproachhadimpact,itwascounter-intuitive single-dose-potency anticoagulants such as diphacinone tomany,andearlyinthemid-1990swedevelopedamore andcoumatetralylpersistintheliverforapproximately6 interactive approach discussing the issues at stake– the months, and high-single-dose-potency anticoagulants pros and cons of different approaches. Special efforts such as bromadiolone, brodifacoum, and flocoumafen were madetobeinclusive, andtoclearlyindicatewhat persistintheliverformorethan12months(Eason etal . we knew and what we did not. Any discussion started 2002). withadeclarationthatwewouldnotdescribepoisonsas Thepersistenceofsublethal(approximateLD 15 )oral “safe”and“notshieldfromrisks”. doses of brodifacoum, warfarin, pindone, and diphaci- This approach has been extended in the last decade noneintheliversoflaboratoryratswascomprehensively and, coupled with the greater success of control compared more recently to determine whether earlier operations,communitysupporthasimproved.Commu- recommendations were appropriate. At one end of the nityengagementisparamountandnewapproachestothe spectrum, retention of brodifacoum in liver was discussionofriskwiththecommunityarecontinuingto characterizedbyarelativelylonghalf-lifeof113.5days, evolve(ShaunOgilvie,LincolnUniv.,Canterbury,N.Z., comparedwithhalf-livesof26.2daysforwarfarin,and3 pers.commun.). and 2 days for diphacinone and pindone, respectively (Fisher et al . 2003). These results suggest that the Achievement5:UnderstandToxicokineticsinRisk indandinone anticoagulants diphacinone and pindone Assessment present a shorter-term and, therefore, reduced risk of In the 1990s, we identified a need to select suitable secondarypoisoningtopredatorsandscavengersthanthe toxicantsforfieldusethatareeffectivebutlesspersistent anticoagulants warfarin and brodifacoum than second-generation anticoagulants and therefore (Fisheretal .2003).Thishasallowedformoreconfident likelytobelesshazardoustonon-targetspecies(Eason et recommendations and selection of less persistent al .2002).Thetendencyforanticoagulantstopersistin anticoagulantsforfielduse. mammalian liver is influenced by the magnitude of the dose ingested and the relative affinity of the compound Achievement6:AppropriateUse“Patterns”of for receptors in the liver, which determine the hepatic Anticoagulants elimination half-life and the proportion of the dose New Zealand has many islands that are actual, or retained (Parmar et al . 1987). Accordingly, liver tissue potential,refugesforendangerednativebiota.Startingin has been the focus for most investigations of the 1980s and gaining momentum in the 1990s, pest anticoagulant persistence, although there were few data invasion on islands have been actively managed, and on the comparative hepatic persistence of anticoagulant islands once occupied by rodents are being reclaimed. rodenticides in mammals where either compounds or Untilthemid-1980s,therewereveryfewislandsentirely species have been compared. The hepatic half-life of free of animal pests. Large, more easily located brodifacoum has been reported as 130 days in rats mammalssuchaspossums,pigs,andgoatswerethefirst (Parmar etal.1987),252daysinpossums(Eason etal . tobetargeted,andsomewereeradicatedfromislandsin 1996 b), and >250 days in sheep (Laas et al . 1985). the early 1900s. These restoration programs involved Thijssen(1995)estimatedahepatichalf-lifeof7-10days hard work and diligence, particularly as the last few forwarfarininrats,whileresiduesintheliverofpigsthat individualsofanyspecieswerealwaysthemostdifficult survived a dose of warfarin had declined to near the tolocateandkill. analytical limit of detection by 30 days (O’Brien et al . Aseriesofrodenteradicationattemptsonislandsin 1987). The persistence of pindone in mammalian liver thepast25years,usingbaitinstationsandappliedfrom has been described for dogs (Fitzek 1978) and sheep the air, has been spectacularly successful (Taylor and 409 Thomas 1989, 1993; Towns et al . 1993, Empson and used in the early 1990s liberated cyanide gas, which Miskelly1999).Todate>45islandshavebeenclearedof deterred possums and was hazardous to operators. rodents,andbrodifacoumusehashadanobviousbenefit WorkingwithasmallprivatecompanyinAuckland,we onvaluableislandecosystems.Theuseofbrodifacoum developed Feratox ® in 1997, an encapsulated pellet for to protect populations of indigenous birds, reptiles, and possumcontrol(Gregory etal .1998).Thishasgreatly invertebratesendangeredbyratsandmiceisadeparture enhancedgroundcontrolofpossums. fromthenormalpatternofusethathasgainedincreasing Muchofthepublicdisapprovalof1080resultedfrom favorinmanycountries(Eason etal .2001). theaccidentalpoisoning(primaryandsecondary)ofdogs, In parallel to its use to eradicate rats from islands, anunfortunateconsequenceofdogsbeing25timesmore therewasanincreaseduseofbrodifacoumbaitsdelivered sensitiveto1080thanpossums.Intheearly1990s,there from bait stations for possum and rodent control on wereintenseeffortstoidentifysaferalternativesto1080 mainlandNewZealand(EasonandSpurr1995,Innesand (Eason1991,Eason etal .1993 a).Determinationofthe Barker 1999), raising concerns about contamination risks presented to dogs through use of cholecalciferol effects on other fauna. Although second-generation showedthatitwasmuchlowertopetsandbirds(Eason et anticoagulantssuchasbrodifacoumareusedextensively al . 1996 a,b), and this underpinned the development of throughouttheworld,theyaremostlyemployedforthe cholecalciferolbaitsthatcanbeusedpreferentiallyclose controlofcommensalrodents(i.e.,thoselivinginclose to habitation where dog risks are higher. Additionally, associationwithmanandhisdomesticanimals)(Colvin baitshavebeendevelopedwithextremelylongfieldlife. etal .1991).Whileprimaryexposureofnon-targetfauna For example, cholecalciferol gel bait remains palatable may be reduced by the use of effective bait stations, and toxic to possums for 26 months under field secondary exposure is more difficult to manage. We conditions(Morgan2006),andsuchbaitsareexpectedto detected brodifacoum residues in game animals such as substantially reduce the cost of sustained control of pigs and deer and a range of avian species including vertebratepests. weka, morepork, harrier, pukeko, grey duck, mallard duck, black-backed gull, robin, saddleback, chaffinch, CONCLUSIONS mynah, magpie, and blackbird (Eason et al . 2001). Of Inthispaper,wehavesummarisedsevenareaswhere lessconcernwasthedetectionofbrodifacoumincatsand substantial gains have been made in the last decade in stoats, introduced species regarded as pests and largely mammalpestcontrolinNewZealand: responsibleforthedeclineofnativebirds,suchaskiwi. 1. Improvedqualityassuranceofbaitsandreduce Because of the potential for contamination of wildlife, sowingratesof1080forpossumcontrol broadscalefielduseofbrodifacouminNewZealandwas 2. Improvedunderstandingof1080toxicologyand discontinuedinthelate1990s.Nevertheless,limiteduse managementpractise ofbrodifacoumbaitsinbaitstationsisextremelyvaluable 3. Experimentalandregulatorytoxicologydatabase forcontrollinglocalizedpopulationsofpossumsthathave tomeetregistrationrequirements developed entrenched bait shyness. This sometimes 4. Improvedcommunitysupportforwildlife occurs where acute pesticides (1080, cyanide, or management cholecalciferol)havebeenusedineffectivelyduetopoor 5. Improvedourunderstandingoftheimportanceof bait quality, climatic effects, or repeated usage of the toxicokinetics samebaittype.Thebaitshynessisovercomewhenthe 6. Arationaleforthechoiceofanticoagulantsfor pest animal initially samples a small quantity of bait differentuses containing an anticoagulant, experiences no ill effects, 7. Improvedformulationsandchoice. and continues to consume baits eventually ingesting a lethalquantity(MorganandRoss2001). Thesearejustsomeoftheexamplesthathaveenabled Switching from brodifacoum to alternative second- improveddeliveryandmoreeffectivepestcontrolofthe generation anticoagulants, with similar toxicokinetic highest standard, delivering disease control and profiles, would not reduce the risk of exposure and conservationoutcomeswithminimalsideeffects.There bioaccumulationinnon-targetspecies,althoughtherisk areopportunitiesforusefulproducts,basedonresearchin oftoxicosesmightbeless(dependentonthepotencyof the 1990s on alternatives to 1080 (Eason et al . 1993 a), the alternative , the amount of active and more recent work that has enabled us to be more ingredientinbaittypes,theamountofbaiteaten,orthe selective in our choice of anticoagulants (Fisher et al. amount ingested by scavengers eating poisoned 2003). Further research is also underway to improve carcasses). Currently, first-generation anticoagulants targetspecificityandprovidemorespecies-specificbaits (whicharelesspersistent),aloneorincombinationwith andpoisons. cholecalciferol and encapsulated cyanide, and traps are being used in preference to brodifacoum on mainland ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS sites. These toxicokinetic assessments have been im- TheauthorsacknowledgethefundingsupportoftheNewZealand provedbyanincreasingunderstandingoftheproperties Animal Health Board, the Department of Conservation, and the ofdifferentrodenticides. FoundationforResearch,ScienceandTechnology. Achievement7:ImprovedChoiceforGroundControl LITERATURECITED Humane fast-acting poisons such as cyanide have ATZERT ,S.P.1971.Areviewofsodiummonofluoroacetate manyadvantages(Gregory etal .1998);however,pastes (compound 1080), its properties, toxicology, and use in 410 predator androdent control. UnitedStatesDepartmentof monofluoroacetate(1080),brodifacoum,andcholecalciferol the Interior Fish and Wildlife Services Special Scientific inpossums.Proc.Vertebr.PestConf.17:54-58. Report–WildlifeNo.146.34pp. EISLER ,R.1995.Sodiummonofluoroacetate(1080)hazardsto BULLARD , R. W., R. D. THOMPSON , AND G.HOLGVIN .1976. fish, wildlife and invertebrates: a synoptic review. U.S. (diphacinone) residue in tissue of cattle. J. Department of Interior National Biological Service, Agric.FoodChem.24:261-263. BiologicalReport27.47pp. COLVIN , B.A., W. B. JACKSON , AND P. L. HEGDAL . 1991. EMPSON ,R. A., AND C. M. MISKELLY .1999.Therisks,costs Secondary poisoning hazards associated with rodenticide and benefits of using brodifacoum to eradicate rats from th use.Proc.11 Inter.CongressonPlantProtect.,pp. 60-64. KapitiIsland,NewZealand.NZJ.Ecol.23:241-254. EASON ,C. T.1991.Cholecalciferolasanalternativetosodium FAGERSTONE , K. A., P. J. SAVARIE , D. J. ELIAS , AND E. W. th monofluoroacetate(1080)forpoisoningpossums.Proc.4 SCHAFER . 1994. Recent regulatory requirements for WeedandPestCont.Conf.,pp.35-37. pesticide registration and the status of compound 1080 EASON , C.T.1995.Sodiummonofluoroacetate(1080)–an studies conducted to meet EPA requirements. In : A. A. update on recent environmental toxicology data and Seawright and C. T. Eason (Eds.), Proceedings of the communityconcerns.Proc.14 th Aust.Vertebr.PestCont. ScienceWorkshopon1080.RoyalSoc.NZMisc.Ser.28. Conf.,pp.39-43. FISHER ,P., C. O’C ONNOR ,G. WRIGHT ,AND C. T. EASON .2003. EASON , C. T. 2002. Sodium monofluoroacetate (1080) risk Persistenceofpooranticoagulantrodenticidesintheliverof assessmentandriskcommunication.Toxicology181-182: rats. NZ Dept of Conservation, Science for Conservation 523-530. 139:19. EASON , C. T., C. M. FRAMPTON , R. HENDERSON , M. D. FITZEK , A. 1978. Pharmacokinetics of 2-pivaloylindan-1,3- THOMAS , AND D. R. MORGAN . 1993 a. Sodium dioneindogs.ActaPharmacol.Toxicol.42:81-87. monofluoroacetate and alternative toxins for possum GREGORY ,N. G., L. M. MILNE ,A. T. RHODES ,K. E. LITTEN ,M. control.NZJ.Zool.20:329-324. WICKSTROM ,AND C. T. EASON .1998.Effectsofpotassium EASON , C. T., R. GOONERATNE , H. FITZGERALD , G. WRIGHT , cyanide on behaviour and time to death in possums. NZ AND C. FRAMPTON. 1994. Persistence of sodium Vet.J.46:60-64. monofluoroacetateinlivestockanimalsandrisktohumans. HARRISON ,M.1978.1080-Wildlife.Pp.48-53 in: Review HumanandExper.Toxicol.13:119-122. No. 9, Wildlife Service, Dept. of Internal Affairs, EASON ,C. T., R. GOONERATNE ,G. R. WRIGHT ,R. PIERCE ,AND Wellington,NewZealand. C. M. FRAMPTON .1993 b.Thefateofsodiummonofluoro- INNES ,J., AND G. BARKER .1999.Ecologicalconsequencesof acetate(1080)inwater,mammals,andinvertebrates.Proc. toxinuseformammalianpestcontrolinNewZealand–an NZPlantProtect.Conf.46:297-301. overview.NZJ.Ecol.23:111-127. EASON , C. T., L. MIEKLE , AND R. J. HENDERSON . 1996 a. LAAS , F. J., D. A. FORSS , AND M. E. R. GODFREY . 1985. Testing cats for secondary poisoning by cholecalciferol. Retentionofbrodifacouminsheeptissuesandexcretionin Vetscript,NZ9:26. faeces.NZJ.Agric.Res.28:357-359. EASON ,C. T., E. MURPHY ,G. WRIGHT ,C. O’C ONNOR ,AND A. MORGAN , D. R. 1994. Improving the efficiency of aerial BUCKLE . 2001. Risk assessment of broad-scale toxicant sowingofbaitsforpossumcontrol.NZJ.Agric.Res.37: applicationforrodenteradicationonislandversusmainland 199-206. use.Pp.45-58 in:H.-J.Pelz,D.P.Cowan,andC.J.Feare MORGAN ,D.R.2004.Maximisingtheeffectivenessofaerial (Eds.),Proc.2nd EuropeanVertebr.PestManage.Conf.(6-8 1080 control of possums ( Trichosurus vulpecula ). Ph.D. September1999,Braunschweig,Germany). thesis,LincolnUniversity,NewZealand.187pp. EASON , C. T., E. C. MURPHY , G. R. G. WRIGHT , AND E. B. MORGAN , D. R. 2006. Long-life baits for enhancing SPURR .2002.Assessmentofrisksofbrodifacoumtonon- maintenance control of possum populations. Pp. 193-210 targetbirdsandmammalsinNewZealand.Ecotoxicol.11: in : C. J. Feare and D. P. Cowan (Eds.), Advances in 35-48. Vertebrate Pest Management, Vol. IV. Filander Verlag, EASON ,C. T.,AND E. B. SPURR .1995.Reviewofthetoxicity Fürth. andimpactsofbrodifacoumonnon-targetwildlifeinNew MORGAN , D. R., G. MORRISS , AND G. J. HICKLING . 1996. Zealand .NZJ.Zool.22:311-379. Induced1080bait-shynessincaptivebrushtailpossumsand EASON , C. T., AND P. TURCK . 2002.A90-daytoxicological implicationsformanagement.Wildl.Res.23:207-211. evaluationofcompound1080(sodiummonofluoroacetate) MORGAN ,D. R., AND J. ROSS .2001.Useofbrodifacoumbaits inSpagne-Dawleyrats.Toxicol.ofScience69(2):439-447. in relation to the development and mitigation of bait- th EASON , C. T., B. WARBURTON , AND R. HENDERSON . 2000. shynessinthebrushtailpossum.Proc.12 Aust.Vertebr. Toxicantsusedforpossumcontrol.Pp.154-163 in :T.L. PestConf.,pp.185-189. Montague(Ed.),TheBrustailPossum:Biology,Impact,and MORGAN , D. R., M. D. THOMAS , D. MEENKEN , AND P. C. Management of an Introduced Marsupial. Manaaki NELSON .1997.Less1080baitusageinaerialoperationsto WhenuaPress,NewZealand. control possums . Proc. 50 th NZ Plant Protect. Conf., pp. EASON , C. T., M. WICKSTROM , P. TURCK , AND G. R. G. 391-396. WRIGHT . 1999. A review of recent regulatory and NELSON ,P. C., AND G. J. HICKLING .1994.Pindoneforrabbit environmental toxicology studies on 1080: results and control: efficacy, residue, and costs. Proc. Vertebr. Pest implications.NZJ.Ecol.23(2):129-127. Conf.16:217-222. EASON , C. T., G. R. WRIGHT , AND L. MEIKLE . 1996 b. The NOTMAN , P. 1989. A review of invertebrate poisoning by persistence and secondary poisoning risks of sodium compound1080.NZEntomol.12:67-71.

411 O’B RIEN ,P. H., J. A. BECK ,ANDB. S. LUKINS .1987.Residue tissue levels of warfarin and 1080 in poisoned feral pigs. Unpubl. report: working paper presented at the Aust. Vertebr.PestCont.Conf. PARFITT ,R. C., C. T. EASON ,A. MORGAN ,G. R. WRIGHT ,AND C. M. BURKE .1994.Thefateofsodiummonofluoroacetate insoilandwater.Pp.59-66inA.A.SeawrightandC.T. Eason (Eds.), Proceedings of the Science Workshop on 1080.RoyalSoc.NZMisc.Ser.28. PARMAR ,G., H. BRATT ,R. MOORE ,AND P. L. BATTEN .1987. Evidenceforacommonbindingsite invivo fortheretention ofanticoagulantsinratliver.HumanToxicol.6:431-432. RAMMELL ,C. G.,AND P. A. FLEMING .1978.Compound1080: properties and use of sodium monofluoroacetate in New Zealand.MinistryofAgricultureandFisheries,Wellington. 137pp. SEAWRIGHT , A. A., AND C. T. EASON (E DITORS ). 1994. ProceedingsoftheScienceWorkshopon1080.RoyalSoc. NZMisc.Ser.28:1-178. SPURR ,E.B.2000.Impactsofpossumcontrolonnon-target species.Pp.175-186 in :T.Montague(Ed.),TheBrushtail Possum,Biology,ImpactandManagementofanIntroduced Marsupial.ManaakiWhenuaPress,Lincoln,NewZealand. 292pp. TAYLOR , R. H., AND B. W. THOMAS . 1989. Eradication of Norway rats ( Rattus norvegicus ) from Hawea Island, Fiordland,usingbrodifacoum.NZJ.Ecol.12:23-32. TAYLOR , R. H. AND B. W. THOMAS . 1993. Rats eradicated from rugged Breaksea Island (170ha), Fiordland, New Zealand.Biol.Conserv.65:191-198. THIJSSEN ,H.H.1995.Warfarin-basedrodenticides:modesof actionandmechanismofresistance.PesticideSci .43:73- 78. TOWNS , D., I. MCFADDEN , AND T. LOVEGROVE . 1993. Offshoreislandsco-operativeconservationprojectwithICI GroupCareDivision:Phaseone(StanleyIsland).Dept.of Conservation, Wellington, Science and Research Internal Report138.24pp. WICKSTROM , M., L. MILNE , C. T. EASON , AND D. ARTHUR . 1997.Theshortandlong-termeffectsofasingleexposure of1080insheep:finalreport.LandcareResearchContract Report LC9798/040, Landcare Research, Lincoln, New Zealand.9pp.

412