Chinampa Agriculture: the Operation of an Intensive Pre Industrial Resource System in the Valley of Mexico
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
CHINAMPA AGRICULTURE: THE OPERATION OF AN INTENSIVE PRE INDUSTRIAL RESOURCE SYSTEM IN THE VALLEY OF MEXICO by ALASTAIR J. ROBERTSON B.A., The University of British Columbia, 1976 A THESIS SUBMITTED IN PARTIAL FULFILLMENT OF THE REQUIREMENTS FOR THE DEGREE OF MASTER OF ARTS in THE FACULTY OF GRADUATE STUDIES (Department of Geography) We accept this thesis as conforming to the required standard THE UNIVERSITY OF BRITISH COLUMBIA October 1983 © Alastair J. Robertson In presenting this thesis in partial fulfilment of the requirements for an advanced degree at the University of British Columbia, I agree that the Library shall make it freely available for reference and study. I further agree that permission for extensive copying of this thesis for scholarly purposes may be granted by the head of my department or by his or her representatives. It is understood that copying or publication of this thesis for financial gain shall not be allowed without my written permission. Department of G&OCrgflPHV The University of British Columbia 1956 Main Mall Vancouver, Canada V6T 1Y3 Date (3/81) ABSTRACT During the 14th and 15th Centuries the complex of marshes and shallow lakes that occupied the low elevations of the Valley of Mexico were thoroughly modified by the construction of thousands of small agricultural platforms known as chinampas, and of an elaborate network of dykes, canals and aqueducts. A quantified model of the hydrological systems of the Valley indicates that under natural conditions water levels fluctuated to such an extent that the productivity of chinampa platforms would have been limited. The larger hydraulic installations smoothed these fluctuations in the upstream portions of the lake complex and so permitted the agricultural exploitation of these areas. On the platforms seedbedding and other intensive horticultural techniques were employed which allowed the maximum utilization of the controlled hydrau• lic environment. Canals were exploited not only for irrigation water but also as reservoirs for plant nutrients, which promoted a conserva• tive use of materials in the system as a whole. Communities of non- crop plants were maintained on the platform border and these protected crops from climatic extremes, and may also have been important in regu• lating populations of insect pests. The hydraulic installations were managed by high-ranking officials of the Aztec state, while the chinampa platforms were to a large extent managed by their cultivators. Although managerial decisions were made by individuals of widely different rank, there was a tendency for decision-making to occur at the lowest hierar• chic level compatible with the ability of the manager to command the ii labour and materials necessary to implement the decision. This allowed managers to respond rapidly and efficiently to small variations in the conditions of the physical systems that they managed. The available data indicate that the chinampas produced high and sustained yields per unit area and did so without requiring large subsidies of energy and materials. The physical, ecological and managerial principles of chinampa agriculture are therefore relevant to the design of modern agricultural systems that seek to exhibit these general properties. i i i TABLE OF CONTENTS Page ABSTRACT i i LIST OF TABLES vii LIST OF FIGURES ix ACKNOWLEDGEMENT xi i i CHAPTER I. INTRODUCTION 1 CHAPTER II. THE HYDROLOGY OF THE BASIN OF MEXICO 9 CHAPTER III. THE COLONIZATION OF THE LAKE COMPLEX 44 Chinampa Agriculture without Water Level Control 44 Chinampa Agriculture and Water Level Control in Limited Areas 59 Chinampa Agriculture and Water Level Control in Large Areas 65 Late Aztec Hydraulic Installations 73 CHAPTER IV. THE ECOLOGY OF CHINAMPA AGRICULTURE 92 The Chinampa Platforms 92 Flora and Fauna 101 Seedbeds and Transplanting 120 Weeding and Pest Control 126 Material Cycles 130 Agricultural Calendar 136 iv Paje Yields and Energy Ratios 145 The Principles of Chinampa Agriculture 150 CHAPTER V. THE MANAGEMENT OF CHINAMPA AGRICULTURE The City State 158 The Confederation and the Tribute State 162 The Lake Aztec State 166 The Construction of Hydraulic Installations 172 The State and its Hydraulic Installations 178 The Management of Agriculture 183 The Evaluation of Aztec Management 188 CHAPTER VI. SUMMARY AND CONCLUSIONS 198 APPENDIX. RECONSTRUCTION OF THE 16TH CENTURY HYDROLOGY OF THE BASIN OF MEXICO 211 Part I. The Use of Modern Data in Reconstructing 16th Century Conditions 212 Part II. Derivation of Mean Annual Values for the 16th Century Hydrological System 222 1. Drainage Basins 222 2. Physiographic Regions 222 3. Precipitation 222 4. Evapotranspiration 223 5. Agricultural Evaporation Supplement 224 v Page 6. Surface Discharge 225 7. Undifferentiated Runoff 226 8. Lake Discharge 226 9. Mean Annual Totals 226 Part III. Estimation of Mean Monthly Distributions 229 1. Monthly Distribution of Precipitation 229 2. Monthly Distribution of Surface Discharge 230 3. Primary and Secondary Evaporation 233 4. Monthly Distribution of Evaporation 238 5. Monthly Distribution of Surplus 238 6. Monthly Distribution of Undifferentiated Runoff 244 7. Lake Tlahuac and Lake Chalco 251 . Part IV. Estimates of Variation in Lake Stage 262 1. Assumptions 262 2. Estimated Variations of Lake Stage with Normal Precipitation 262 3. Estimates of Variations of Lake Stage with Precipitation at Exceptionally High or Low Values 264 BIBLIOGRAPHY 266 vi LIST OF TABLES Page TABLE I. Absolute Chronology and Period Designations for the Valley of Mexico 45 TABLE II. Widths of Canals in the Chinampas of San Luis and San Gregorio 99 TABLE III. Common Aquatic Plants of the Chinampas 103 TABLE IV. Edible and Medicinal Plants of the Chinampas 108 TABLE V. Common Highland Mesoamerican Crops 112 TABLE VI. Consumptive Use of Water in Centimeters for Localities at Low Elevations in the South of the Valley of Mexico 132 TABLE VII. Nutrient Content of Organic Fertilizers 134 TABLE VIII. Aztec Agricultural and Ritual Calendars 139 TABLE IX. Yields of Shelled Corn, Mixquic 146 TABLE X. Yields of Saleable Portions of Selected Vegetables, Mixquic 147 TABLE XI. Summary of Estimates of 16th Century Mean Annual Water Balance, Basin of Mexico 227 TABLE XII. Stations Used in Calculating Monthly Values of Climatic Variables 231 TABLE XIII. Primary Evaporation as a Proportion of Total Evaporation 237 vii Stations Used in Estimation of Distribution of Secondary Evaporation Estimated 16th Century Mean Monthly Water Balance, Basin of Mexico Assumed Areas and Elevations of the Antique Lakes viii LIST OF FIGURES No. Page 1. The watershed of the Basin of Mexico in the 16th Century 10 2. Estimated annual water transfers in the Basin of Mexico during the 16th Century 13 3. Subsidiary drainage basins and physiographic regions in the Basin of Mexico in the 16th Century 15 4. Mean annual isohyets in the Basin of Mexico, 1920-1959 17 5. Mean monthly precipitation averaged for seven stations throughout the Basin of Mexico 19 6. Average mean isotherms in the Basin of Mexico, 1920-1958 20 7. Average monthly temperatures, Moyoguarda, 1951-1975 21 8. Average monthly potential evaporation, Moyoguarda, 1951-1975 21 9. Estimated monthly variation in stage of Antique lakes 21 10. Average minimum isotherms in the Basin of Mexico, 1920-1958 22 11. Maximum, mean and minimum temperatures, Moyoguarda, 1951-1975 24 12. Frequency of frosts, Moyoguarda, 1951-1975 25 13. Mean adjusted potential evaporation in the Basin of Mexico 27 14. Daily discharge of Rio Amecameca, 1947 30 ix No. Page 15. Schematic section of spring in Sierra Ajusco 32 16. Annual precipitation at Tacubaya, 1878-1975 36 17. Variability and precipitation for selected stations in the Basin of Mexico 37 18. Annual values for adjusted potential evaporation and precipitation at Moyoguarda, 1951-1975 40 19. Estimated variations in stage of Lake Chalco for varying annual precipitation values 50 20. Estimated variations in the extent and location of the inundated margins of Lake Chalco 52 21. Length to area ratios of hypothetical dykes in Lakes Xochimilco and Chalco 64 22. Chinampa platforms in the vicinity of Xochimilco 67 23. Chinampas of San Gregorio Atlapulco, on the southern shore of Lake Xochimilco 69 24. Lake Aztec hydraulic installations 74 25. Reconstructions of 16th Century aqueducts 76 26. The effects of dyking on normal variations in the stage of the Central and Southern Lakes 81 27. Estimated normal variations in the stage of the Southern and Central Lakes with water levels controlled 84 28. Estimated interannual variations of stage in the controlled lake complex, without centralized management 85 x No. Page 29. Estimated interannual variations of stage of the controlled lake complex, with centralized management 89 30. Schematic representation of nutrient transport in chinampa agriculture 137 31. Principal settlements of the Valley of Mexico during the 16th Century 159 32. Changing lake levels and precipitation in the Basin of Mexico, 1600 B.C. to present 213 33. Geological sections of the Basin of Mexico 218 34. Location of meteorological stations in the Basin of Mexico 232 35. Precipitation and discharge for Xochimilco and Chalco basins 234 36. Water balance diagrams for selected stations in the Basin of Mexico 240 37. Surplus and discharge for the Basin of Rios Magdalena and Esclava, Basin of Mexico 242 38. Surplus and Discharge for Xochimilco and Chalco basins, Basin of Mexico 243 39. Estimated mean monthly discharge of Rios de la Compana and San Francisco, Valley of Mexico 245 40. Estimated mean monthly discharge of Rio Amecameca, Chalco basin 246 xi No. Page 41. Observed yields of springs in the Xochimilco and Chalco basins, 1903-04 248 42. Graphs used for estimates of monthly distributions of infiltrated flows (I) and indirect flows (J) 250 43. Estimated monthly distribution of surplus and runoff, Chalco basin 250 44. Observed stage of Lake Tlahuac and estimated inputs of Lake Chalco 261 xii ACKNOWLEDGEMENT I would like to thank the many individuals who have helped me in the course of this work.