The Necessary Inversion of Enacting Justice in The
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
THE NECESSARY INVERSION OF ENACTING JUSTICE IN THE HARRY POTTER SERIES __________________ A University Thesis Presented to the Faculty of California State University, East Bay __________________ In Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree Master of Arts in English __________________ By James L. Koponen September, 2009 Table of Contents Chapter One. The Value of Children’s Literature ...............................................................1 Introduction ..............................................................................................................1 The Necessity of Inverted Justice .............................................................1 Genre Explanation ....................................................................................2 Benefits of the Subversive Nature ...........................................................................6 The Role of Justice...................................................................................................9 The Escape of Fantasy ...........................................................................................10 The Once and Future Wizard .................................................................................12 Chapter Two. Contributing Antecedents ..........................................................................20 Engaging the Hero .................................................................................................20 Involving the Individual ......................................................................... 20 The Plight of the Hero.............................................................................26 The Connection to the Hero ....................................................................27 The Idea of Solo Work Versus Group Work ........................................................33 Forced Separation ...................................................................................33 The Concept of Real Unity .....................................................................36 Philosophy and Justice ...........................................................................................40 Cicero’s Reasoning .................................................................................40 Defining Justice ......................................................................................44 Practical Application ..............................................................................................46 Examining the Laws in Place ..................................................................46 The Idea of Play ......................................................................................48 Chapter Three. Criticisms and Responses .........................................................................51 Overview ................................................................................................................51 Faculty Review ......................................................................................................51 Institutional Review ...............................................................................................57 Faulty Legalities.....................................................................................................59 Originality ..............................................................................................................66 Plausibility .............................................................................................................67 Length and Murkiness............................................................................................69 Harmful Evidence in Harry Potter ........................................................................70 iii Chapter Four. Close Analysis ............................................................................................73 Overview ................................................................................................................73 Life’s Early Stages .................................................................................................74 Weapons of Justice ................................................................................................76 In Regards to the Outsider .....................................................................................80 Handling Bigger Problems .....................................................................................82 Increasing Injustices...............................................................................................87 Chapter Five. Summary .....................................................................................................89 The Duplicity of the Hero ......................................................................................89 The Hero’s Privilege ...............................................................................89 The Hero’s Restrictions ..........................................................................90 The Failure to Acquire Proper Judicial Techniques ..............................................91 Final Thoughts .......................................................................................................94 Works Cited .......................................................................................................................97 iv 1 Chapter 1 The Value of Children’s Literature Introduction The Necessity of Inverted Justice Anyone directly following the depicted examples of exacting justice in fictional literature has a fairly good chance of winding up in prison, especially since a good number of stories and novels have (notably ones involving archetypal heroes) the protagonists enabled to take matters into their own hands and carrying out their own justice—from rescuing a kidnapped princess to saving the universe. This falls in stark contrast to what Western society considers acceptable, in terms of legal standards, for readers may cheer the vigilante who finally avenges his father’s death; however, the legal system frowns upon individuals circumnavigating the laws to administer justice. Thus, there exists an inversion in principals: people are instructed to let the courts do the work and yet are presented with virtually countless examples of exactly the opposite. Certainly, this is not a new theme in literature, for even around 800 BCE, Homer had Odysseus carrying out his own version of justice as he violently slew dozens of men who had usurped his home and had ill intentions toward his wife. While this phenomenon may not be problematic for adults, some may consider it unwise for growing children to be exposed to such a radical inversion in teachings. Young adults are in a transition, or initiation, phase, having to learn important lessons to utilize throughout life. Why complicate matters by inverting justice for them? Should not the hero simply be calling the authorities or filing a complaint and allowing the judicial system time for due 2 process? While it would not likely be very entertaining, there are other reasons for this inverted justice to be considered beneficial: while the methods of solving problems differ in fiction, other lessons can be obtained—children can learn to evaluate whether justice is being properly upheld and they can see that individuals may disagree and take steps to fix or improve the system, though the methodology changes in real life. The inversion of justice as it shifts from societal to individual is necessary in young adult fiction because it demonstrates helpful steps for assisting future adults in life: vicariously through the individual, one learns to observe justice, to evaluate whether or not it is functioning properly, and to see that each can make contributions in correcting the inadequacies or problems. With all this in mind, a prime example worth exploring is the Harry Potter series, where the hero continually makes decisions regarding justice and fairness; however, the genre itself should first be explored more thoroughly. Genre Explanation When first hearing the words “children’s literature,” a person may immediately have a denigrating or dismissive viewpoint, resulting from the assumption that that genre of literature does not have a serious place in academic study. Perhaps even the words “children” and “literature” seem odd or awkward being combined together. A children’s story sounds fine; a children’s book is commonly accepted. Despite this, the genre of children’s literature does exist and may be very useful for deeper analysis into what children learn on their journey to adulthood, and what necessary lessons help mold their transition into becoming adults contributing effectively to society, especially when it 3 comes to weighing justice, utilizing the court system, and voting on laws pertaining to judicial matters. Admittedly, the classification of children’s literature may require broadening, thus allowing or even necessitating further division as the upper realm of children’s literature can be better grouped into young adult literature. This proves to be especially helpful as many would not think of “children” immediately entering adulthood, but rather undergoing an intermittent step—where the old ways are put aside and new ways are learned, a concept more embraced in contemporary ideology. Establishing exactly what age range this pertains to would be difficult as various factors affect the beginning and ending of this transition; however, considering