DOCSLIB.ORG

UKRAINE LOCAL GOVERNANCE PROJECT WHOLE-OF-PROJECT EVALUATION Final Report

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
UKRAINE LOCAL GOVERNANCE PROJECT WHOLE-OF-PROJECT EVALUATION Final Report PHOTO CREDIT: ALEXANDER GROUSHEVSKY UKRAINE LOCAL GOVERNANCE PROJECT WHOLE-OF-PROJECT EVALUATION Final Report UKRAINE LOCAL GOVERNANCE PROJECT WHOLE-OF-PROJECT EVALUATION Final Report Submitted August 1, 2019 USAID Ukraine Task Order No. AID-OAA-M-13-00011 Contract No. GS-10F-0294V This publication was prepared by Social Impact for USAID/DRG and USAID/Ukraine by Social Impact as part of the Democracy, Rights, and Governance – Learning, Evaluation, and Research (DRG-LER) activity. Contact: Social Impact, Inc. 2300 Clarendon Blvd., Suite 1000 Arlington, VA 22201 (703) 465-1884 Program Manager: Sierra Frischknecht, [email protected] DISCLAIMER The authors’ views expressed in this publication do not necessarily reflect the views of the United States Agency for International Development or the United States Government. USAID.GOV UKRAINE LOCAL GOVERNANCE PROJECT EVALUATION | ii TABLE OF CONTENTS Abstract v Acronyms vi Executive Summary vii Evaluation Purpose and Questions .................................................................................................................. vii Background and Context ................................................................................................................................... vii Evaluation Methods and Limitations ............................................................................................................... viii Findings and Conclusions .................................................................................................................................. viii Recommendations ................................................................................................................................................xi I. Evaluation Purpose and Questions 1 Evaluation Purpose ................................................................................................................................................1 Evaluation Questions ............................................................................................................................................1 II. Project Background and Context 2 III. Evaluation Methodology and Limitations 4 Methodology ...........................................................................................................................................................4 Analysis .....................................................................................................................................................................5 Risks and Limitations.............................................................................................................................................6 IV. Findings and Conclusions 7 Findings for EQ 1 ...................................................................................................................................................7 Conclusions for EQ 1 ........................................................................................................................................ 12 Findings for EQ 2 ................................................................................................................................................ 12 Conclusions for EQ 2 ........................................................................................................................................ 17 Findings for EQ 3 ................................................................................................................................................ 19 Conclusions for EQ 3 ........................................................................................................................................ 22 Findings for EQ 4 ................................................................................................................................................ 23 Conclusions for EQ 4 ........................................................................................................................................ 24 Findings for EQ 5 ................................................................................................................................................ 25 Conclusions for EQ 5 ........................................................................................................................................ 27 V. Recommendations 30 Recommendations for EQ1 .............................................................................................................................. 30 Recommendations for EQ2 .............................................................................................................................. 30 Recommendations for EQ3 .............................................................................................................................. 31 Recommendations for EQ4 .............................................................................................................................. 32 Recommendations for EQ5 .............................................................................................................................. 32 VI. Lessons Learned 33 VII. Annexes 34 iii | UKRAINE LOCAL GOVERNANCE PROJECT EVALUATION USAID.GOV TABLES AND FIGURES Table 1: Interviews by Respondent Category (not including survey respondents) 4 Table 2: Most Important Factors for LGP Framework by Survey Respondents 7 Table 3: Changes Occurred as a Result of Decentralization Reform by Survey Respondents (%) 9 Figure 1: LGP Activities and Intended Results 3 Figure 2: Data Collection Locations, April 2019 5 Figure 3: LGP Hypothesis 7 USAID.GOV UKRAINE LOCAL GOVERNANCE PROJECT EVALUATION | iv ABSTRACT This final whole-of-project evaluation of the Local Governance Project (LGP) examines the soundness of the LGP theory of change, collaboration among USAID implementing mechanisms, and possible adjustments to USAID/Ukraine’s approach to supporting local governance in Ukraine. LGP was launched in 2015 with three activities: Policy for Ukraine Local Self-Governance (PULSE), Decentralization Offering Better Results and Efficiency (DOBRE), and Municipal Finance Strengthening Initiative-II (MFSI-II). Using a mixed-methods approach, the evaluation team reviewed relevant documents, surveyed key informants and residents of assisted municipalities, and interviewed 156 key informants during three weeks of fieldwork in 21 municipalities across seven oblasts. The evaluation concluded that the development hypothesis is largely valid and could be further refined. LGP helped to strengthen local governance in Ukraine through its three activities and made significant progress toward realizing expected results. USAID/Ukraine provided support for creating a legal basis for consolidation; providing technical advice for central, regional, and local authorities; and introducing practical models and tools at the municipal level. However, there was not close cooperation between the two main activities, PULSE and DOBRE, in helping local governments manage resources and services effectively. Additional support in development and adoption of the local governance strategy is needed, and the evaluation identifies five areas for future assistance. This report concludes with 17 recommendations for future USAID support for local governance in Ukraine, including further support for decentralization legislation and municipal capacity development; better coordination between USAID implementers and with other donors; and expanding LGP support to more municipalities. v | UKRAINE LOCAL GOVERNANCE PROJECT EVALUATION USAID.GOV ACRONYMS ACTC Associations of Consolidated Territorial Communities AUC Association of Ukrainian Cities CDCS Country Development Cooperation Strategy CMU Cabinet of Ministers of Ukraine CSO Civil society organization CTC Consolidated territorial community DDRU Decentralization Delivering Results for Ukraine DESPRO Swiss-Funded Support to Decentralization in Ukraine DOBRE Decentralization Offering Better Results and Efficiency Project EITI Extractive Industries Transparency Initiative EQ Evaluation questions EQUI Evaluation Quality, Use, and Impact ET Evaluation team FSLD Foundation in Support of Local Democracy GC Global Communities GoU Government of Ukraine GSI Gender and social inclusion IBSER Institute for Budgetary and Socio-Economic Research IDP Internally displaced person IREX International Research & Exchanges Board KII Key informant interview LGP Local Governance Project LM Line ministry MFSI Municipal Finance Strengthening Initiative Project MoF Ministry of Finance MRD Ministry of Regional Development, Construction and Municipal Services of Ukraine MSAP/UEK Małopolska School of Public Administration at the Kraków University of Economics PEA Political economy analysis PAD Project Appraisal Document PD Project Description PLEDDGE Partnership for Local Economic Development and Democratic Governance PPB Performance program budgeting PULSE Policy for Ukraine Local Self-Governance Project PwD Person with disability SBO Social Boost SI Social Impact SME Small and medium enterprise SOW Statement of Work VRU Verkhovna Rada of Ukraine (Ukrainian Parliament) UAH Hryvnia (Ukrainian Currency) UCMC Ukrainian Crisis Media Center U-LEAD Ukraine–Local Empowerment, Accountability, and Development Programme UNDP United Nations Development Programme USAID U.S. Agency for International Development WOPE Whole-of-Project Evaluation USAID.GOV UKRAINE LOCAL GOVERNANCE PROJECT EVALUATION | vi EXECUTIVE SUMMARY EVALUATION PURPOSE AND QUESTIONS
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Urgently for Publication (Procurement Procedures) Annoucements Of
    Bulletin No�1 (180) January 7, 2014 Urgently for publication Annoucements of conducting (procurement procedures) procurement procedures 000162 000001 Public Joint–Stock Company “Cherkasyoblenergo” State Guard Department of Ukraine 285 Gogolia St., 18002 Cherkasy 8 Bohomoltsia St., 01024 Kyiv–24 Horianin Artem Oleksandrovych Radko Oleksandr Andriiovych tel.: 0472–39–55–61; tel.: (044) 427–09–31 tel./fax: 0472–39–55–61; Website of the Authorized agency which contains information on procurement: e–mail: [email protected] www.tender.me.gov.ua Website of the Authorized agency which contains information on procurement: Procurement subject: code DK 016–2010 (19.20.2) liquid fuel and gas; www.tender.me.gov.ua lubricating oils, 4 lots: lot 1 – petrol А–95 (petrol tanker norms) – Procurement subject: code 27.12.4 – parts of electrical distributing 100 000 l, diesel fuel (petrol tanker norms) – 60 000 l; lot 2 – petrol А–95 and control equipment (equipment KRU – 10 kV), 7 denominations (filling coupons in Ukraine) – 50 000,00, diesel fuel (filling coupons in Supply/execution: 82 Vatutina St., Cherkasy, the customer’s warehouse; Ukraine) – 30 000,00 l; lot 3 – petrol А–95 (filling coupons in Kyiv) – till 15.04.2014 60 000,00; lot 4 – petrol А–92 (filling coupons in Kyiv) – 30 000,00 Procurement procedure: open tender Supply/execution: 52 Shcherbakova St., Kyiv; till December 15, 2014 Obtaining of competitive bidding documents: 285 Hoholia St., 18002 Cherkasy, Procurement procedure: open tender the competitive bidding committee Obtaining of
    [Show full text]
  • 1 Introduction
    State Service of Geodesy, Cartography and Cadastre State Scientific Production Enterprise “Kartographia” TOPONYMIC GUIDELINES For map and other editors For international use Ukraine Kyiv “Kartographia” 2011 TOPONYMIC GUIDELINES FOR MAP AND OTHER EDITORS, FOR INTERNATIONAL USE UKRAINE State Service of Geodesy, Cartography and Cadastre State Scientific Production Enterprise “Kartographia” ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Prepared by Nina Syvak, Valerii Ponomarenko, Olha Khodzinska, Iryna Lakeichuk Scientific Consultant Iryna Rudenko Reviewed by Nataliia Kizilowa Translated by Olha Khodzinska Editor Lesia Veklych ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ © Kartographia, 2011 ISBN 978-966-475-839-7 TABLE OF CONTENTS 1 Introduction ................................................................ 5 2 The Ukrainian Language............................................ 5 2.1 General Remarks.............................................. 5 2.2 The Ukrainian Alphabet and Romanization of the Ukrainian Alphabet ............................... 6 2.3 Pronunciation of Ukrainian Geographical Names............................................................... 9 2.4 Stress .............................................................. 11 3 Spelling Rules for the Ukrainian Geographical Names....................................................................... 11 4 Spelling of Generic Terms ....................................... 13 5 Place Names in Minority Languages
    [Show full text]
  • Improvement of the Methodology for The
    Eastern-European Journal of Enterprise Technologies ISSN 1729-3774 3/10 ( 111 ) 2021 UDC 504.064:004.942:631.81 The study of the components of the balance of DOI: 10.15587/1729-4061.2021.235845 biogenic elements in anthropogenic ecosystems has been carried out and the mechanism for calculating the balance of biogenic elements has been determined. The necessity of IMPROVEMENT OF THE improving the existing methodology is proved, which consists in preliminary modeling of the METHODOLOGY FOR THE catchment area using geoinformation methods. On the example of the mouth of the river, a drainage area was modeled in Oril, during ASSESSMENT OF SOIL which the boundaries and total catchment area were determined, which is 39.7 thousand BIOGENIC POLLUTION hectares. Experimental studies have determined the area of land according to their types of nature use (industrial, residential, forestry THROUGH THE USE and agricultural, etc.). It has been established that only 15 % of the investigated lands have OF GEOECOLOGICAL agricultural use, however, it is this type of nature management that most contributes to biogenic pollution of this ecosystem. According APPROACHES AND THE to the results of calculations, it is determined that up to 10 thousand tons of nitrogen and USE OF INFORMATION phosphorus, respectively, are accumulated in the soil due to the excess use of mineral fertilizers. The results obtained indicate the TECHNOLOGIES feasibility and practical attractiveness of the proposed approach for calculating the Iryna Omelych balance of nutrients. Improvements include Postgraduate Student* the application of digital elevation model and Natalia Neposhyvailenko normalized vegetation index geodata obtained Corresponding author using ArcGIS Desktop software.
    [Show full text]
  • Annoucements of Conducting Procurement Procedures
    Bulletin No�1(127) January 2, 2013 Annoucements of conducting 000004 PJSC “DTEK Donetskoblenergo” procurement procedures 11 Lenina Ave., 84601 Horlivka, Donetsk Oblast Tryhub Viktor Anatoliiovych tel.: (0624) 57–81–10; 000002 Motor Roads Service in Chernihiv Oblast tel./fax: (0624) 57–81–15; of State Motor Roads Service of Ukraine e–mail: [email protected] 17 Kyivska St., 14005 Chernihiv Website of the Authorized agency which contains information on procurement: Martynov Yurii Vasyliovych www.tender.me.gov.ua tel.: (0462) 69–95–55; Procurement subject: works on construction of cable section КПЛ 110 kV tel./fax: (0462) 65–12–60; “Azovska – Horod–11 No.1, 2” and cable settings on substation 220 kV e–mail: [email protected] “Azovska” Website of the Authorized agency which contains information on procurement: Supply/execution: Separated Subdivision “Khartsyzk Electrical Networks” of the www.tender.me.gov.ua customer (Mariupol, Zhovtnevyi District, Donetsk Oblast), April – August 2013 Website which contains additional information on procurement: Procurement procedure: open tender www.ukravtodor.gov.ua Obtaining of competitive bidding documents: at the customer’s address, office 320 Procurement subject: code 63.21.2 – services of transport infrastructure for Submission: at the customer’s address, office 320 road transport (maintenance of principal and local motor roads in general 23.01.2013 12:00 use and artificial constructions on them in Chernihiv Oblast) Opening of tenders: at the customer’s address, office 320 Supply/execution:
    [Show full text]
  • Impact Evaluation of Participatory Budgeting in Ukraine
    See discussions, stats, and author profiles for this publication at: https://www.researchgate.net/publication/337783495 Impact Evaluation of Participatory Budgeting in Ukraine Research · December 2019 DOI: 10.13140/RG.2.2.11468.36485 CITATIONS READS 0 229 2 authors, including: Dmytro Khutkyy University of California, Riverside 16 PUBLICATIONS 19 CITATIONS SEE PROFILE All content following this page was uploaded by Dmytro Khutkyy on 06 December 2019. The user has requested enhancement of the downloaded file. Impact Evaluation of Participatory Budgeting in Ukraine Dmytro Khutkyy, Kristina Avramchenko Kyiv 2019 Reference Khutkyy, D., & Avramchenko, K. (2019). Impact Evaluation of Participatory Budgeting in Ukraine. Kyiv. Authors Dmytro Khutkyy, PhD in Sociology, independent expert www.khutkyy.com, [email protected] Kristina Avramchenko, independent expert [email protected] Acknowledgements Reviewing Kateryna Borysenko, Product Manager, Tech NGO “SocialBoost” Oleksandra Ivanenko, Business Analyst, Tech NGO “SocialBoost” Serhii Karelin, E-democracy Component Coordinator, the Swiss-Ukrainian program E-Governance for Accountability and Participation (EGAP) Kostiantyn Ploskyi, PhD in Public Administration, Deputy Director, Polish-Ukrainian Cooperation Foun- dation PAUCI Proofreading Orysia Hrudka Design Denys Averyanov Funding This research has been conducted with the support of the Open Society Foundations. All thoughts, conclusions and recommendations belong to the authors of this publication and do not necessarily reflect the opinions of the project donor. Copyright Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 license. https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-sa/4.0/ Contents Summary 4 1. Introduction 6 1.1 National context 6 1.2 Impact model 7 1.3 Research methodology 12 2. The overall impact of participatory budgeting in Ukraine 15 2.1 Participatory budgeting trends 15 2.2 The factors of participatory budgeting impact 18 3.
    [Show full text]
  • Viva Xpress Logistics (Uk)
    VIVA XPRESS LOGISTICS (UK) Tel : +44 1753 210 700 World Xpress Centre, Galleymead Road Fax : +44 1753 210 709 SL3 0EN Colnbrook, Berkshire E-mail : [email protected] UNITED KINGDOM Web : www.vxlnet.co.uk Selection ZONE FULL REPORT Filter : Sort : Group : Code Zone Description ZIP CODES From To Agent UA UAAOD00 UA-Ukraine AOD - 4 days POLISKE 07000 - 07004 VILCHA 07011 - 07012 RADYNKA 07024 - 07024 RAHIVKA 07033 - 07033 ZELENA POLIANA 07035 - 07035 MAKSYMOVYCHI 07040 - 07040 MLACHIVKA 07041 - 07041 HORODESCHYNA 07053 - 07053 KRASIATYCHI 07053 - 07053 SLAVUTYCH 07100 - 07199 IVANKIV 07200 - 07204 MUSIIKY 07211 - 07211 DYTIATKY 07220 - 07220 STRAKHOLISSIA 07225 - 07225 OLYZARIVKA 07231 - 07231 KROPYVNIA 07234 - 07234 ORANE 07250 - 07250 VYSHGOROD 07300 - 07304 VYSHHOROD 07300 - 07304 RUDNIA DYMERSKA 07312 - 07312 KATIUZHANKA 07313 - 07313 TOLOKUN 07323 - 07323 DYMER 07330 - 07331 KOZAROVYCHI 07332 - 07332 HLIBOVKA 07333 - 07333 LYTVYNIVKA 07334 - 07334 ZHUKYN 07341 - 07341 PIRNOVE 07342 - 07342 TARASIVSCHYNA 07350 - 07350 HAVRYLIVKA 07350 - 07350 RAKIVKA 07351 - 07351 SYNIAK 07351 - 07351 LIUTIZH 07352 - 07352 NYZHCHA DUBECHNIA 07361 - 07361 OSESCHYNA 07363 - 07363 KHOTIANIVKA 07363 - 07363 PEREMOGA 07402 - 07402 SKYBYN 07407 - 07407 DIMYTROVE 07408 - 07408 LITKY 07411 - 07411 ROZHNY 07412 - 07412 PUKHIVKA 07413 - 07413 ZAZYMIA 07415 - 07415 POHREBY 07416 - 07416 KALYTA 07420 - 07422 MOKRETS 07425 - 07425 RUDNIA 07430 - 07430 BOBRYK 07431 - 07431 SHEVCHENKOVE 07434 - 07434 TARASIVKA 07441 - 07441 VELIKAYA DYMERKA 07442 - 07442 VELYKA
    [Show full text]
  • ANNALES OLEKSANDR D. SUKHOMLYN Russian Military
    10.17951/f.2019.74.183-212 ANNALES UNIVERSITATIS MARIAE CURIE-SKŁODOWSKA LUBLIN – POLONIA VOL. LXXIV SECTIO F 2019 National Academy of Sciences of Ukraine OLEKSANDR D. SUKHOMLYN ORCID: https://orcid.org/0000-0002-0864-8560 [email protected] Russian Military Presence and Colonisation of Zaporizhian Host (Orel-Samara Region) in the Age of New Sich (1734–1775)* Obecność wojsk rosyjskich i zasiedlenie terytorium Zaporoża (regionu między rzekami Orelą i Samarą) w okresie Nowej Siczy (1734–1775) SUMMARY This article considers general course of the region’s settlement and the process of creating slobodas in the vicinity of Russian strongholds, and the colonisation efforts (state and private) undertaken by the Russian administration on the basis of micro-historical approach. Analysis of documents on the census proves that it was the Zaporizhian elites, and not the Russian strongholds, that had a fundamental impact on the process of settlement of Zaporizhia in the 1740s and 1760s. Attempts to control the slobodas, situated near the strongholds, by the Russian administration and attempts to extend power to Zaporizhian subjects were not successful. Keywords: Zaporizhian Host; Southern Ukraine; sloboda; colonisation; confessional census; Russian strongholds INTRODUCTION The period of New Sich is significant for the history of Southern Ukraine. It is important that an active settlement of areas which belonged to the Zaporizhian * This article was prepared as part of a research project “Unification and Integration of Eu- ropean Frontier: Comparative Research of Imperial Incorporation Policies in Danubian and Pontic Regions (17th–19th centuries)”, financed by the Scholarship Programme of the Visegrad Fund (Viseg- rad Scholarship Program, for post-masters).
    [Show full text]
  • Of the Public Purchasing Announcernº6 (185) February 11, 2014
    Bulletin ISSN: 2078–5178 of the public purchasing AnnouncerNº6 (185) February 11, 2014 Urgently for publication (procurement procedures) � � � � � � � � � � � � � � 2 Announcements of conducting procurement procedures � � � � � � � � � 3 Announcements of procurement procedures results � � � � � � � � � � � � 52 Bulletin No�6 (185) February 11, 2014 001902 Urgently for publication Road Facilities Administration (procurement procedures) of Odesa City Council 22 Henerala Petrova St., 65078 Odesa Dieliierhiev Hennadii Heorhiiovych 001820 tel.: (048) 784–08–42; United Motor Transport Fleet of Health Care tel./fax: (048) 784–08–42; Establishments and Institutions of Poltava Oblast 7 Kotsiubynskoho St., 36039 Poltava e–mail: [email protected] Denysko Victor Anatolyovych Website of the Authorized agency which contains information on procurement: tel.: (05322) 7–31–34; www.tender.me.gov.ua tel./fax: (05322) 2–96–26; Procurement subject: current repair of street and road network of Odesa, e–mail: [email protected] Square of asphalt concrete surface, which is under current repair is 19 574,5 m2 Website of the Authorized agency which contains information on procurement: (details are specified in the competitive bidding documents – addition No.1) www.tender.me.gov.ua Supply/execution: Odesa; during 2014 Procurement subject: code 19.20.2 – Liquid fuel and gas, lubricating oil 5.2. Procurement procedure: open tender Number of products or volume of works or services – 1 lot – petrol A–92 – Obtaining of competitive bidding documents: at the customer’s address,
    [Show full text]
  • Year 1 Work-Plan
    Year 1 work-plan YEAR 1 WORK-PLAN HIV REFORM IN ACTION COOPERATIVE AGREEMENT- HEALTH SYSTEMS STRENGTHENING FOR A SUSTAINABLE HIV / AIDS RESPONSE IN UKRAINE (HSS SHARE) QUARTER 3 REPORT April 1, 2018 – June 30, 2018 AWARD NUMBER: AID-121-A-13-00007 MODIFICATION NO. 08 DELOITTE CONSULTING, LLP This report is made possible due to the funding provided by the U.S. President’s Emergency Plan for AIDS Relief through the United States Agency for International Development (USAID) under the terms of the HIV Reform in Action project, award number AID-121-A-13-00007. The content of this report is the sole responsibility of Deloitte Consulting LLP and its implementing partners and does not necessarily reflect the opinion of PEPFAR, USAID, or the United States Government. Contents LIST OF ACRONYMS ........................................................................................................................ 3 GENERAL PROJECT INFORMATION .............................................................................................. 6 CURRENT AND CUMULATIVE PROGRESS .................................................................................... 7 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY .................................................................................................................... 8 OVERALL PROJECT PERFORMANCE .......................................................................................... 12 SECTION 1. HIV REFORM SUPPORT ............................................................................................ 12 Objective 1:
    [Show full text]
  • GEOLEV2 Label Updated October 2020
    Updated October 2020 GEOLEV2 Label 32002001 City of Buenos Aires [Department: Argentina] 32006001 La Plata [Department: Argentina] 32006002 General Pueyrredón [Department: Argentina] 32006003 Pilar [Department: Argentina] 32006004 Bahía Blanca [Department: Argentina] 32006005 Escobar [Department: Argentina] 32006006 San Nicolás [Department: Argentina] 32006007 Tandil [Department: Argentina] 32006008 Zárate [Department: Argentina] 32006009 Olavarría [Department: Argentina] 32006010 Pergamino [Department: Argentina] 32006011 Luján [Department: Argentina] 32006012 Campana [Department: Argentina] 32006013 Necochea [Department: Argentina] 32006014 Junín [Department: Argentina] 32006015 Berisso [Department: Argentina] 32006016 General Rodríguez [Department: Argentina] 32006017 Presidente Perón, San Vicente [Department: Argentina] 32006018 General Lavalle, La Costa [Department: Argentina] 32006019 Azul [Department: Argentina] 32006020 Chivilcoy [Department: Argentina] 32006021 Mercedes [Department: Argentina] 32006022 Balcarce, Lobería [Department: Argentina] 32006023 Coronel de Marine L. Rosales [Department: Argentina] 32006024 General Viamonte, Lincoln [Department: Argentina] 32006025 Chascomus, Magdalena, Punta Indio [Department: Argentina] 32006026 Alberti, Roque Pérez, 25 de Mayo [Department: Argentina] 32006027 San Pedro [Department: Argentina] 32006028 Tres Arroyos [Department: Argentina] 32006029 Ensenada [Department: Argentina] 32006030 Bolívar, General Alvear, Tapalqué [Department: Argentina] 32006031 Cañuelas [Department: Argentina]
    [Show full text]
  • Flint Artefacts of Northern Pontic Populations of the Early and Middle Bronze Age: 3200 – 1600 Bc
    FLINT ARTEFACTS OF NORTHERN PONTIC POPULATIONS OF THE EARLY AND MIDDLE BRONZE AGE: 3200 – 1600 BC Serhiy M. Razumov ½ VOLUME 16• 2011 BALTIC-PONTIC STUDIES 61-809 Poznań (Poland) Św. Marcin 78 Tel. 618294799, Fax 618294788 E-mail: [email protected] EDITOR Aleksander Kośko EDITORIAL COMMITEE Sophia S. Berezanskaya (Kiev), Aleksandra Cofta-Broniewska (Poznań), Mikhail Charniauski (Minsk), Lucyna Domańska (Łódź), Elena G. Kalechyts (Minsk), Viktor I. Klochko (Kiev), Jan Machnik (Kraków), Vitaliy V. Otroshchenko (Kiev), Ma- rzena Szmyt (Poznań), Petro Tolochko (Kiev) SECRETARY Marzena Szmyt SECRETARY OF VOLUME Karolina Harat Danuta Żurkiewicz ADAM MICKIEWICZ UNIVERSITY INSTITUTE OF EASTERN STUDIES INSTITUTE OF PREHISTORY Poznań 2011 ISBN 83-86094-16-8 ISSN 1231-0344 FLINT ARTEFACTS OF NORTHERN PONTIC POPULATIONS OF THE EARLY AND MIDDLE BRONZE AGE: 3200 – 1600 BC (BASED ON BURIAL MATERIALS) Serhiy M. Razumov Translated by Inna Pidluska ½ VOLUME 16• 2011 c Copyright by BPS and Authors All rights reserved Cover Design: Eugeniusz Skorwider Linguistic consultation: Ryszard J. Reisner Printed in Poland Computer typeset by PSO Sp. z o.o. w Poznaniu Printing: Zakłady Poligraficzne TMDRUK in Poznań CONTENTS Editor’sForeword ...................................................... 5 Introduction ........................................................... 7 I. Historiography, Source Base, Research Methodology ................. 10 I.1. The Issue: Research History and Current Status . ............. 10 I.2. TheSourceBase ........................................
    [Show full text]
  • Page 1 Okhtyrka Vovchansk Zinkiv Zolochiv Bohodukhiv Derhachi
    UKRAINE, Plannned CASH activities for 2017 (Donetska and Luhanska oblasts) Okhtyrka Vovchansk Zinkiv Zolochiv Bohodukhiv Derhachi Velykyi Kotelva Krasnokutsk Burluk Myrhorod Kharkiv Troitske Shyshaky Velyka Pechenihy Dvorichna Dykanka Kolomak Valky Chuhuiv Bahachka Nova Chutove Vodolaha Zmiiv Shevchenkove Kupiansk Poltava Reshetylivka Bilokurakyne Novopskov Markivka Mashivka Karlivka Balakliia Svatove Novi Krasnohrad Pervomaiskyi Borova Milove Sanzhary Kehychivka Starobilsk Kozelshchyna Zachepylivka Izium Bilovodsk Kobeliaky Sakhnovshchyna Kremenchuk Kreminna Lyman Novoaidar Tsarychanka Mahdalynivka Onufriivka Lozova Barvinkove Sloviansk Blyzniuky RUSSIAN Petrykivka Yurivka Oleksandrivka Slovianoserbsk Stanytsia FEDERATION Luhanska Verkhnodniprovsk Novomoskovsk Popasna Bakhmut Luhansk Pavlohrad Kostiantynivka Dnipro Dobropillia Petropavlivka Perevalsk Piatykhatky Lutuhyne Krynychky Synelnykove Pokrovsk Sorokyne Mezhova Solone Vasylkivka Yasynuvata Antratsyt Shakhtarsk Dovzhansk Sofiivka NGCA Romanky Kryvyi Vilniansk Marinka Donetsk Rih Novomykolaivka Velyka Zaporizhzhia Novosilka Tomakivka Amvrosiivka Starobesheve Apostolove Huliaipole Volnovakha Legend Nikopol Orikhiv Vysokopillia Novovorontsovka BELARUS Polohy 'Contact line' as of June 2016 (OCHA) Kamianka-dniprovska Vasylivka Boikivske Rozivka Bilmak POLAND Velyka RUSSIAN Planned MPC in 2017 Verkhnii FEDERATION Kyiv Bilozerka-1 Mykhailivka Tokmak Velyka Rohachyk Chernihivka Nikolske Cluster Lepetykha SLOVAKIA Novoazovsk Manhush Shelter HUNGARY Vesele Hornostaivka MOLDOVA WASH Nyzhni Beryslav Sirohozy Melitopol SEA OF ROMANIA Oblast Centres Kakhovka Berdiansk AZOV Pryazovske Prymorsk Ivanivka Yakymivka SERBIA Raion Centres BULGARIA 50km The boundaries and names shown and the designations used on this map do not imply official endorsement or acceptance by the United Nations. | Feedback: [email protected] | Document: 3W_CASH_planned_2016 Creation date: 11/01/2017.
    [Show full text]