A STUDY OP the EXCHANGE of IODINE BETWEEN ETHYL IODIDE and SODIUM IODIDE in FORMAMIDE by Led Ay CATHARINE ELIZABETH WORSFOLD
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Led Ay Ca -I A STUDY OP THE EXCHANGE OF IODINE BETWEEN ETHYL IODIDE AND SODIUM IODIDE IN FORMAMIDE by CATHARINE ELIZABETH WORSFOLD A THESIS SUBMITTED IN PARTIAL FULFILMENT OF THE REQUIREMENTS FOR THE DEGREE OF MASTER OF ARTS in the Department of CHEMISTRY We accept this thesis as conforming to the standard required from candidates for the degree of MASTER OF ARTS. Members of the Department of Chemistry THE UNIVERSITY OF.BRITISH COLUMBIA April, 1951 Abstract The exchange system G0H_I — 1* was studied in ethyl alcohol solution. <• 5 The average rate constant for this reaction was 29.9 x 10 ^ moles litre sec at 50.1°C, The exchange of iodine between ethyl iodide and iodide ion was found to be complicated by a reaction of ethyl iodide with the solvent.. The kinetics; of the simultaneous reaction of ethyl iodide with formamide and the exchange reaction were treated theoretically. Experi• mentally the ethyl iodide - formamide reaction was found to be of a complex nature. The measured exchange rate constant was approximately -2 -1 -1 o 1 x 10 mole litre sec at 25 C which is greater than the rate constant of the same reaction in alcohol solution. The exchange system I - IO^ was also studied and k for this reaction was approximately 1 x 10*""* -1 -1 o moles litre sec at 30,8 C. Acknowledgment I wish to express my most sincere gratitude to Dr. Milton Kirsch for his inspiring guidance, patience, and untiring assistance throughout this research project. Thanks are due also to the National Research Council for financial aid and to the Atomic Energy Project at Chalk River for prompt deliveries of radioactive sodium iodide (I ) used in this investigation. April, 1951 Catharine Elizabeth Worsfold TABLE OP CONTENTS INTRODUCTION Exchange Reactions. .... 2 Halogen Exchange Reactions 3 KINETICS OF EXCHANGE REACTIONS Derivation of the Rate Constant Expression 8 EXPERIMENTAL I. Ethyl Iodide-Iodide Ion Exchange in Ethyl Alcohol. ... 11 Preparation of Materials 11 Procedure -. 11 Results ..... 12 II. Ethyl Iodide-Iodide Ion Exchange in Formamide. ..... 14 Preparation of Materials. 14 Preliminary Investigation of the Behaviour of Sodium Iodide, Ethyl Iodide, and Silver Nitrate in Formamide ............... 15 (1) Solubilities . 15 (2) Separation of Ethyl Iodide from Sodium Iodide 16 (a) Distillation 16 (b) Solvent Extraction 17 (c) Oxidation . 19 (3) Precipitation of the Silver Iodides 20 The Use of KIO^ for the Separation of Ethyl Iodide,? from Sodium Iodide 21 Theoretical Consideration of the Kinetics of the Reaction between Ethyl Iodide and Formamide with the Simultaneous Exchange of Ethyl Iodide with Radioactive Iodide Ion ..... 22 The Rate of Reaction of Ethyl Iodide with Formamide. 25 Measurement of the Exchange Rate Constant ...... 26 The Exchange of Iodide Ion with Iodate Ion in Aqueous Formamide. ................ 28 The Exchange between I2 in CCl^ and Ethyl Iodide in Formamide 30 DISCUSSION OF RESULTS AND SUGGESTIONS FOR FURTHER RESEARCH BIBLIOGRAPHY APPENDIX INTRODUCTION Fefore artificially produced radioactive isotopes became readily available there were many processes of interest to the chemist which could not be studied simply because there was no means whereby a particular element could be "tagged." With the possible exception of the lightest elements, where the percentage mass difference between the isotopes of an element is the greatest, there is no chemical means of distinguishing between isotopes. Thus, the isotopic composition remains essentially constant throughout a chemical or biological process. Only Tl, Pb, and Bi (and several other elements in the middle of the periodic table whose radioactive isotopic content is very small) possess both stable and naturally radioactive Isotopes which could be used to investigate reactions. By means of a mass spectrograph it is possible, though often tedious, to follow reactions with stable tracers. Even with the great increase in production of radioactive tracers from nuclear piles there is still a definite limitation on their use since some elements do not possess radioactive isotopes of suitable half-life. Among these are oxygen, nitrogen, helium, lithium, and boron for which the use of separated stable isotopes as tracers is a very valuable technique (1). Deuterium has found many applications as a hydrogen tracer and oxygen and nitrogen enriched with 0^ and N*-5 respectively are essential for many important purposes. However, a great number of elements do possess artificial radioisotopes of suitable half-life for chemical studies and with these it is possible to trace a "marked* atom by the radiations it emits. EVen a brief survey of the literature on tracers and radio chemistry that has accumulated in the space of the few years that radioactive indi• cators have been available is far beyond the scope of this work. (2) This discussion will be concerned only with one phase of tracer appli• cations-—their use in exchange reactions in general and halogen exchanges in particular. References 1 to 9 include general background material on isotopes and their uses. Exchange Reactions An exchange reaction is, as the name implies, a replacement reaction in which the reactants and products are chemically identical. Because of this chemical identity exchange reactions can be studied only by means of tracers. Consider a simple exchange of the type ABV+ B^ ^ AB£ f m Jk where an asterisk indicates a radioactive nuclide. Since the products are the same as the reactants (except for the small mass difference of the added isotope) the rate constants of the forward and reverse reactions are practically equal. Kinetic data may be used to show the mechanism of reactions, to study the character and stability of bonds, and to establish the effect of solvent on reaction rates. The following discussion is not intended to be a complete resume of attempted exchange reactions but is designed to indicate briefly the nature of the experiments which have been done cm exchange systems. In fact, with few exceptions, only halogen exchanges will be considered. One of the earliest exchange experiments was performed by Hevesy in 1920 By means of ThB; (pb2-1-2) he demonstrated the rapid exchange of lead ions between PbCl2 and Pb(1103)2 in aqueous solution. He also showed the rapid exchange of lead atoms between Pb(Ac)2 and Pb(Ac)^ in acetic acid solution. In the first case one would expect exchange since both these salts: give rise to chemically identical Pb ions. In the case of the acetates: the exchange presumably occurs through a reversible interconversion of plumbous and plumbic ions. (3) With the increased production of radionuclides in the 1930"s, very many exchange reactions were studied. In 1935, the mechanism of the Walden inversion was investigated fa*-5). It was shown that the rate of substitution of iodide for the iodine in secondary octyl iodide and the velocity of racemization under similar conditions are the same. This gave direct confirmation that Walden inversion involves substitution. In 1937, Wilson and Dickinson ^) calculated the rate of oxidation and reduction of iodine from the exchange which takes place at equilib• rium between radioactive pentavalent arsenic (As76) and trivalent arsenic. The reaction was carried out in acid solution in the presence of iodide ion and free iodine. Using the assumption that the exchange occurs through the oxidation and reduction of iodine the rates were found to agree with the kinetic expression given by Roebuck for the same reaction remote from equilibrium. While these and many other experiments indicate the utilization of exchange reaction in the study of the mechanisms of other reactions, many exchange reactions have been studied with the hope of reaching a better understanding of the mechanism of the exchange itself. In parti• cular, the exchange of halogens with corresponding halides has been studied in a variety of solvents under different conditions. Halogen Exchange Reactions Hull, Schiflett, and Lind studied exchanges of radioiodine and reported that: l) I2 and I~ exchange freely in aqueous solution presumably by the formation of Lj*", 2') I2 and I0^~ in IN sulphuric acid do not exchange at an appreciable speed, but in 20N hot H2S0^ 10rl5$ of the radioactive iodine appears in the 10^" suggesting oxidation-reduction at a measurable rate, 3) no exchange occurs between C2H5I or CH3I and active I2 even after 15 minutes at 90°C but if active Nal and inactive C2H5I are dissolved in alcohol and heated to 100°C, exchange does occur, L) I2 and iodoform do not exchange in ether solution, and 5) iodoform does not exchange with active Nal in alcohol. Bromine-bromide exchange in aqueous solution was studied by Grosse and Agruss who concluded that the exchange is fairly slow, being governed by the rate of hydrloysis of bromine. Roginski and Gopshtein however, stated that this exchange was rapid. Dodson and Fowler inves• tigated both bromine-bromide and iodine-iodide exchanges and found that both reactions were practically complete in 60 seconds. Long and Olson reported that the exchange between C.I2. and Cl" was immeasurably fast. Juliusberger, Topley, and Weiss showed that appreciable exchange takes place in 1 - 2. minutes between CH3I and active Nal in alcohol solu• tion at room temperature. McKay reported qualitative exchange data for the reaction between several aliphatic and aromatic iodides, and sodium iodide. At room temperature allyl and methyl iodides exchange with active Nal in alcohol or acetone solution. Tinder the same conditions no exchange was found with ethyl, propyl, isopropyl, and methylene iodide, nor does iodoform exchange in acetone solution. However, at 100°C, methylene, propyl, isopropyl, and isoamyl iodides exchange in approxi• mately 15 minutes. Nal*-ethyl iodide exchange was practically complete after 15 minutes at 50 - 55°G. No exchange between active Nal and phenyl iodide, p-nitroiodobenzene, or p-iodoaniline could be detected at 100°C.