DOCSLIB.ORG

A Flight to Quality

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
A Flight to Quality Boom or bust A flight to quality for IP’s status as a steady, conservatively The developed world is slipping into valued and uncorrelated asset class. recession and established investment vehicles are crashing A new focus on IP portfolios C-suite executives have long tended to into disrepute. What will be the overlook the untapped financial value of knock-on effect for IP assets − and intangibles. But as market firestorms ebb those tasked with their management and smouldering recession takes hold, many and monetisation? industry professionals believe that this is set to change. John Squires, chief IP counsel at Goldman Sachs, explains: “Certainly, By Nigel Page where the financial crisis is concerned, we will see companies seeking to generate With the financial crisis continuing to wrap greater returns from their portfolios. If they its tentacles around the world, sparking a already have exclusivity, then it will be global liquidity crunch and massive risk incumbent on them to ensure that their aversion among investors, few patents can be relied upon to continue to commentators are prepared to make firm provide this.” Steve Lozan, VP of predictions about eventual outcomes. investments at Oppenheimer & Co, agrees: But there is no shortage of speculation. “Without doubt, some companies’ Calls for a new Bretton Woods-style valuations have been killed over the past agreement to reform global economic weeks. And so, if they can sell their IP or governance are seldom out of the press and a license it, then they may now be much more prospective maelstrom of financial and happy to do so.” capital markets regulation haunts banks, Fire sales of patents are widely hedge funds and private equity firms anticipated in the short term, as executives worldwide. Meanwhile, institutional in cash-strapped companies begin to view investors are taking stock of massive losses their IP as a source of operating capital − sustained from what were, until recently, capital that can usefully be deployed to considered to be safe havens for their capital. appease shareholders by compensating for Against this backdrop, the nascent IP dramatic drop-offs in revenues. Nir monetisation communities are seeking to Kossovsky, chief executive of Steel City Re establish themselves. Given what has LLC, believes that this could be the case: happened over the past few months, you “We should expect to see a lot more supply could be forgiven for thinking that than demand. The whole notion of selling IP intermediaries and financiers alike are is more widely accepted than it was, so feeling pretty depressed. But, in fact, that companies will seek to dispose of their IP does not seem to be the case. Although via the markets. But I can’t identify any real everyone acknowledges that these are driver of increased demand. At the same difficult and uncertain times, the general time, greater uncertainty over asset-based view is that IP and intangibles in general and cashflow-based valuations will likely may not only survive the storm, but may result in overall reductions in net present actually prosper. In fact, some predict this values of IP.” That said, Kossovsky could be the beginning of a brave new world continues: “The value of the intangible www.iam-magazine.com Intellectual Asset Management January/February 2009 41 Boom or bust Challenging for new entrants substantial realisations. Historically, IP exploitation has been counter-cyclical as IP assertions have increased in recessionary environments. In addition, a variety of models have emerged for investment in IP. Their emergence shows an increased awareness in the market of the standalone value of IP. However, during times of great dislocation, investors often flock to liquidity and perceived safety. Given the opaque nature of the asset class, IP will be challenging for new investors. The overall deleveraging of the financial system will result in the elimination of many hedge funds and other financial institutions’ tolerance for risk will be curtailed for the foreseeable future. Rather than invest in a new and illiquid asset class, with the public equity markets down approximately 40% year to date, investors may find liquid investments more attractive relative to other investment opportunities. At Altitude, we have positioned ourselves Though investment in IP as an asset class as a well-capitalised liquidity provider that can has grown meaningfully over the last five serve the needs of many different stakeholders years, it is still nascent in its evolution. in the IP ecosystem. In these uncertain times, Analysis of historical returns remains difficult, we expect to be more productive than ever given limited data. Therefore, it is challenging before. Our crystal ball suggests that in the to predict how the current financial crisis will next six to 12 months, capital formation will be impact on attitudes of institutional investors considerably more challenging for new and the development of the asset class. entrants. If it flows at all, it will be directed to IP is viewed as uncorrelated to the rest of players which have demonstrated their the financial market, making it an opportune capabilities and infrastructure to succeed in a area for investment by institutions that seek world that is changing daily. diversification and reduced volatility. In fact, over the last nine months – during the eye of Amar K Mehta, partner, Altitude Capital the storm − our fund has had three Partners asset ‘integrity’ will become hugely inflated. result of the financial crisis: “Derivatives So IP that has integrity will maintain and investors thought that by continually increase its value, being seen as less risky transferring risk they would be spreading it. and more secure. In many ways, this will be Instead, they hid it. There is now a better analogous to the way Treasuries are viewed awareness in the asset-backed markets that as less risky and more secure credit scrutiny of ownership is a good thing. instruments in a financial crisis.” Patents subject to sale or investment are Ron Laurie, managing director of highly scrutinised and conservatively Inflexion Point Strategy LLC in Silicon valued. This will translate into a new-found Valley, believes that demand for high quality respect for the in-depth analysis and patents will help to safeguard their value, caution that IP investors bring to bear.” but he is less sure about those further down Berman says he believes that prospects for the scale: “In the new financial the IP industry generally are good. “There’s environment, high quality patent properties no sense of panic that I’m aware of and IP as will continue to command eight figure an asset class is still very much in growth prices, while patents in the mid-range mode. As markets continue to plummet, portion of the quality spectrum will be investors will be forced to focus on heavily discounted and demand at the maintaining their holdings, not flipping bottom end of the market will likely them,” he explains. It will, he continues, be disappear altogether.” much less about income statements for the For his part, Bruce Berman, CEO of foreseeable future, and more about asset Brody Berman Associates in New York, values. “Although IP is still being swept believes that there will be deeper into ‘goodwill’ in the US, we may well see understanding and respect for IP assets as a this re-focus on asset stewardship leading 42 Intellectual Asset Management January/February 2009 www.iam-magazine.com Boom or bust No collapse in the market proving painful. And while this question There’s no sense remains, companies are asking how they can for ideas outperform competition, maintain value, of panic that I’m protect market share and generate a return on their investments. Unlike typical tangible aware of and IP as assets, patents, trademarks and know-how are the only form of true protection against a an asset class is drop in value. The collapse in tangible valuations leaves still very much in only one asset class available for a reliable collateral backstop – protectable intangible growth mode assets. Regardless of the path taken by the financial markets, there is no decline in the supply of, or demand for, ideas. Moreover, companies still need to borrow and investors still want to earn a return. Therefore, market demand will encourage monetisation strategies that include more IP-backed lending, licensing and auction and private sales than in the past. In addition to an increase and evolution in these strategies, there will also be revolutionary new strategies that investors What we are witnessing today is the popping will utilise. I believe we will see the rise of of an asset bubble and the associated such things as transparent trading platforms worldwide unwinding of highly levered for technology bundles and investment positions by entities across the investor vehicles focused on using intellectual spectrum. Banks, insurance companies and property as a signal of company value. investment funds built their businesses in Regardless of which strategies dominate part on the belief that many hard assets – in the future, it is clear that companies rich in most notably real estate, the ultimate intellectual property are best positioned to tangible asset – would never suffer a drop in take advantage of the changing financial pricing. Now that this faith has been broken landscape. the question on everyone’s mind is: what is the value of tangible assets? The market is Andy Carter, managing director, trying to find an answer, but doing so is Ocean Tomo to IP being shifted onto the balance sheet – invent has not fundamentally changed.” where it belongs,” Berman concludes. Licensing activity is set to pick up too, If predictions of increased patent sales many believe. “Companies that rely more on as a result of the crisis are proved right, a licensing model will want to work their then Ocean Tomo’s auctions should benefit.
Load more

Recommended publications
  • CHAPTER 16 ESTIMATING EQUITY VALUE PER SHARE in Chapter 15, We Considered How Best to Estimate the Value of the Operating Assets of the Firm
    1 CHAPTER 16 ESTIMATING EQUITY VALUE PER SHARE In Chapter 15, we considered how best to estimate the value of the operating assets of the firm. To get from that value to the firm value, you have to consider cash, marketable securities and other non-operating assets held by a firm. In particular, you have to value holdings in other firms and deal with a variety of accounting techniques used to record such holdings. To get from firm value to equity value, you have to determine what should be subtracted out from firm value – i.e, the value of the non-equity claims in the firm. Once you have valued the equity in a firm, it may appear to be a relatively simple exercise to estimate the value per share. All it seems you need to do is divide the value of the equity by the number of shares outstanding. But, in the case of some firms, even this simple exercise can become complicated by the presence of management and employee options. In this chapter, we will measure the magnitude of this option overhang on valuation and then consider ways of incorporating the effect into the value per share. The Value of Non-operating Assets Firms have a number of assets on their books that can be categorized as non- operating assets. The first and obvious one is cash and near-cash investments – investments in riskless or very low-risk investments that most companies with large cash balances make. The second is investments in equities and bonds of other firms, sometimes for investment reasons and sometimes for strategic ones.
    [Show full text]
  • Growth, Profitability and Equity Value
    Growth, Profitability and Equity Value Meng Li and Doron Nissim* Columbia Business School July 2014 Abstract When conducting valuation analysis, practitioners and researchers typically predict growth and profitability separately, implicitly assuming that these two value drivers are uncorrelated. However, due to economic and accounting effects, profitability shocks increase both growth and subsequent profitability, resulting in a strong positive correlation between growth and subsequent profitability. This correlation increases the expected value of future earnings and thus contributes to equity value. We show that the value effect of the growth-profitability covariance on average explains more than 10% of equity value, and its magnitude varies substantially with firm size (-), volatility (+), profitability (-), and expected growth (+). The covariance value effect is driven by both operating and financing activities, but large effects are due primarily to operating shocks. One implication of our findings is that conducting scenario analysis or using other methods that incorporate the growth-profitability correlation (e.g., Monte Carlo simulations, decision trees) is particularly important when valuing small, high volatility, low profitability, or high growth companies. In contrast, for mature, high profitability companies, covariance effects are typically small and their omission is not likely to significantly bias value estimates. * Corresponding author; 604 Uris Hall, 3022 Broadway, New York, NY 10027; phone: (212) 854-4249; [email protected].
    [Show full text]
  • Intangible Asset Monetization the Promise and the Reality
    Working Paper #03 Intangible Asset Monetization The Promise and the Reality Kenan Patrick Jarboe Roland Furrow Athena Alliance April 2008 About Athena Alliance Athena Alliance is in the vanguard of identifying, understanding, analyzing, and educating on the information, intangibles, and innovation (I 3 or I-Cubed) economy. Information, knowledge, and other intangibles now power economic prosperity and wealth creation. Intangible assets—worker skills and know-how, informal relationships that feed creativity and new ideas, high-performance work organizations, formal intellectual property, brand names—are the new keys to competitive advantage. Intangibles and information drive our innovation process, a combination of formal research and informal creativity. These elements combine to produce productivity and improvement gains needed to maintain prosperity. While the economic rules have changed, public policy has not caught up. Governments are struggling with ways to utilize information, foster development of intangibles, and promote innovation and competitiveness in this new economy. Policymakers are grappling with the urgent need to frame policy questions in light of the changing economic situation. Issues of developing and utilizing information, managing intangibles, and fostering innovation underlie discussions on a variety of subjects, such as intellectual property rights, education and training policy, economic development, technology policy, and trade policy. Crafting new policies in these areas requires infusing a better understanding
    [Show full text]
  • Careers in Quantitative Finance by Steven E
    Careers in Quantitative Finance by Steven E. Shreve1 August 2018 1 What is Quantitative Finance? Quantitative finance as a discipline emerged in the 1980s. It is also called financial engineering, financial mathematics, mathematical finance, or, as we call it at Carnegie Mellon, computational finance. It uses the tools of mathematics, statistics, and computer science to solve problems in finance. Computational methods have become an indispensable part of the finance in- dustry. Originally, mathematical modeling played the dominant role in com- putational finance. Although this continues to be important, in recent years data science and machine learning have become more prominent. Persons working in the finance industry using mathematics, statistics and computer science have come to be known as quants. Initially relegated to peripheral roles in finance firms, quants have now taken center stage. No longer do traders make decisions based solely on instinct. Top traders rely on sophisticated mathematical models, together with analysis of the current economic and financial landscape, to guide their actions. Instead of sitting in front of monitors \following the market" and making split-second decisions, traders write algorithms that make these split- second decisions for them. Banks are eager to hire \quantitative traders" who know or are prepared to learn this craft. While trading may be the highest profile activity within financial firms, it is not the only critical function of these firms, nor is it the only place where quants can find intellectually stimulating and rewarding careers. I present below an overview of the finance industry, emphasizing areas in which quantitative skills play a role.
    [Show full text]
  • Global Trends in Mid-Market Private Equity Investing
    Investment Perspectives MARCH 2021 GLOBAL TRENDS IN MID-MARKET PRIVATE EQUITY INVESTING GLOBAL TRENDS IN MID-MARKET PRIVATE EQUITY INVESTING | 1 We are delighted to share our aspects in the management of There are macro developments that perspective and insights on some of portfolio companies: workers’ give us reason to be optimistic. In the major industry trends influencing safety, cost control, and supply chain December 2020, within days of the our private equity business, and what maintenance. In particular, managers, transition period deadline, a new this means for 2021 and beyond. with the support of a banking Brexit deal was agreed between the system that showed more flexibility EU and the UK, removing significant As we reflect on 2020, it is clear that compared to the last recession along uncertainty and volatility from the this was a year of two halves. Private with a greater role of private credit market. As the global vaccine rollout equity deal-making fell sharply as capital as a buffer, particularly in the gathers pace and life returns to the pandemic took hold. Sponsors middle market, ensured portfolio some form of normality, increased quickly turned their attention to their companies implemented important consumer spending will have a portfolios rather than commit to new measures aimed at safeguarding direct benefit on consumer-facing investment opportunities. Indeed, liquidity. In addition, managers businesses, albeit gradually, which there were winners, such as tech and have taken full advantage of simulates the performance of healthcare companies that benefitted programs made available by national companies coming out of a recession. from healthy capital markets and the governments, including tax breaks, History shows that this is an excellent IPO window, and losers, such as travel social security safety-nets and other time to invest.
    [Show full text]
  • IP Management | Ipdigit 8/11/13 20:24
    IP Management | IPdigIT 8/11/13 20:24 ! Navigation $ ARTICLE % COPYRIGHT/RELATED RIGHTS, MEDIA IP Management By Paul Belleflamme & 16 November 2011 ' 35 In their book ‘Information Rules‘ (1999), Carl Shapiro and Hal Varian write the following: ) “The important thing is to maximise the value of your intellectual property, not to protect it for the sake of protection.“ Picture by gurdonark I would like you to express your views about this sentence, based on two articles that Alain Strowel and myself have recently posted on this site. 1. In “Bayer’s aspirin: a lasting success without patent and strong trademark protection“, Alain Strowel explains how trademark protection can usefully supplement patent protection once patents have expired. 2. In “LEGO: Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde?“, I try to rationalize the seemingly ambivalent attitude of LEGO with respect to intellectual property. About Paul Belleflamme Paul Belleflamme is professor at Université catholique de Louvain. He is attached to the Center for Operations Research and Econometrics (CORE) and to the Louvain School of Management, where he teaches courses in the fields of Industrial Organization and Managerial Economics. More info & contact View all posts by Paul Belleflamme → ( Tags: IP management ∠ What to think of ‘patent trolls’? The return La CJUE dit non à la « big-brotherisation » des réseaux peer to peer. ∠ 35 Responses to IP Management Franck Cipolla 17 December 2012 at 12:37 # Edit Creativity and innovation are critical to the success of companies. In a nutshell, “innovation is the process through which new ideas are generated and ultimately put into the marketplace” (Eric Burkhard).
    [Show full text]
  • Download Supporting Investment in Knowledge Capital, Growth And
    Supporting Investment in Knowledge Capital, Growth and Innovation Contents Introduction and overview Supporting Investment Chapter 1. Knowledge-based capital, innovation and resource allocation Chapter 2. Taxation and knowledge-based capital in Knowledge Capital, Chapter 3. Competition policy and knowledge-based capital Chapter 4. Measuring knowledge-based capital Growth and Innovation Chapter 5. Knowledge-based capital and upgrading in global value chains Chapter 6. Knowledge networks and markets Chapter 7. Corporate reporting and knowledge-based capital Chapter 8. Exploring data-driven innovation as a new source of growth: Mapping the policy issues raised by “big data” Supporting Investment in Knowledge Capital, Growth Innovation and Capital, Knowledge in Supporting Investment Consult this publication on line at http://dx.doi.org/10.1787/9789264193307-en. This work is published on the OECD iLibrary, which gathers all OECD books, periodicals and statistical databases. Visit www.oecd-ilibrary.org for more information. is BN 978-92-64-19309-3 92 2013 02 1 P -:HSTCQE=V^XU^X: Supporting Investment in Knowledge Capital, Growth and Innovation This work is published on the responsibility of the Secretary-General of the OECD. The opinions expressed and arguments employed herein do not necessarily reflect the official views of the Organisation or of the governments of its member countries. This document and any map included herein are without prejudice to the status of or sovereignty over any territory, to the delimitation of international frontiers and boundaries and to the name of any territory, city or area. Please cite this publication as: OECD (2013), Supporting Investment in Knowledge Capital, Growth and Innovation, OECD Publishing.
    [Show full text]
  • The Option to Stock Volume Ratio and Future Returns$
    Journal of Financial Economics 106 (2012) 262–286 Contents lists available at SciVerse ScienceDirect Journal of Financial Economics journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/jfec The option to stock volume ratio and future returns$ Travis L. Johnson n, Eric C. So Stanford University, Graduate School of Business, 655 Knight Way Stanford, CA 94305, United States article info abstract Article history: We examine the information content of option and equity volumes when trade Received 15 November 2010 direction is unobserved. In a multimarket asymmetric information model, equity Received in revised form short-sale costs result in a negative relation between relative option volume and future 11 November 2011 firm value. In our empirical tests, firms in the lowest decile of the option to stock Accepted 28 November 2011 volume ratio (O/S) outperform the highest decile by 0.34% per week (19.3% annualized). Available online 17 May 2012 Our model and empirics both indicate that O/S is a stronger signal when short-sale costs JEL classification: are high or option leverage is low. O/S also predicts future firm-specific earnings news, G11 consistent with O/S reflecting private information. G12 & 2012 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved. G13 G14 Keywords: Short-sale costs Options Trading volume Return predictability 1. Introduction creates additional incentives to generate private informa- tion. In this way, trades in derivative markets may provide In recent decades, the availability of derivative secu- more refined and precise signals of the underlying asset’s rities has rapidly expanded. This expansion is not limited value than trades of the asset itself.
    [Show full text]
  • Fitting the Intangible Pieces Together: a Call to Arms
    Slip of the tongue Fitting the intangible pieces together: a call to arms most do not understand intangibles. This is If intangibles are ever to achieve the a problem because knowledge intangibles prominence they should in business, are the key to the future of our firms, our a common language that describes communities and our national economies, what they are and how they are as well as the general one. Each kind of intangibles specialist has something to deployed needs to be developed bring to the table. But we must all come together and create a holistic view that By Mary Adams and Michael Oleksak makes sense of the confusing picture facing businesspeople when they try to figure out If you are reading this magazine, then at one what we are talking about. time or another your interest in intangibles This article describes the perspective of will have put you in the following situation. five of the principal kinds of professional that You are at a business event and make a new influence how intangibles are understood acquaintance. The two of you start chatting today: accountants, lawyers, investors, risk about intangibles. The other person tells managers and business managers. Each you enthusiastically that, yes, they work perspective is examined individually and then with intangibles too. But within a few a suggestion is outlined of how to pull them minutes, you realise that they have a all together. The goal is to develop a holistic completely different perspective. They don’t view of intangibles management that can see the field in the same way that you do.
    [Show full text]
  • The Effect of Portfolio Size on the Financial Performance of Portfolios of Investment Firms in Kenya
    THE EFFECT OF PORTFOLIO SIZE ON THE FINANCIAL PERFORMANCE OF PORTFOLIOS OF INVESTMENT FIRMS IN KENYA PRESENTED BY MBOGO PETER KIMANI: D61/61748/2010 A Research Project Submitted in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree of Master of Business Administration (MBA), School of Business, University of Nairobi. AUGUST 2012 DECLARATION This research project is my original work and has not been submitted for the award of a degree in any other university. Signed: …………..……………………………….. Date: ………………………… Mbogo Peter Kimani Reg. No.: D61 /61748/2010 This research project has been submitted for examination with my approval as university supervisor. Signed: …………………………………………… Date: ………………………… Dr. Josiah Aduda Lecturer, Department of Finance and Accounting ii DEDICATION I dedicate this work to my wife and my children for their support during its preparation. Your patience and encouragement as I stayed away for long, either in class throughout the weekends, or in the field was really touching. iii ACKNOWLEDGEMENT A major research project like this is never the work of anyone alone. The contributions of many different people, in their different ways, have made this possible. First, I would like to thank God for the wisdom and perseverance that HE has bestowed upon me during this research project, and indeed, throughout my life. Second, I offer my sincerest gratitude to my supervisors; Dr. Josiah Aduda and Mr. Mirie Mwangi who have supported me throughout this research project with their patience and knowledge whilst allowing me the room to work in my own way. I appreciate the odd hours we spent discussing the reports. I wish to thank the respondents who participated in this study.
    [Show full text]
  • COMMON FACTORS in CORPORATE BOND RETURNS Ronen Israela,C, Diogo Palharesa,D and Scott Richardsonb,E
    Journal Of Investment Management, Vol. 16, No. 2, (2018), pp. 17–46 © JOIM 2018 JOIM www.joim.com COMMON FACTORS IN CORPORATE BOND RETURNS Ronen Israela,c, Diogo Palharesa,d and Scott Richardsonb,e We find that four well-known characteristics (carry, defensive, momentum, and value) explain a significant portion of the cross-sectional variation in corporate bond excess returns. These characteristics have positive risk-adjusted expected returns and are not subsumed by traditional market premia or respective equity anomalies. The returns are economically significant, not explained by macroeconomic exposures, and there is some evidence that mispricing plays a role, especially for momentum. 1 Introduction predict returns in other markets, yet researchers have not studied the viability of all these charac- Corporate bonds are an enormous—and grow- teristics to predict returns in credit markets. The ing—source of financing for companies around characteristics are carry, quality, momentum, and the world. As of the first quarter of 2016, there value (Koijen et al., 2014 for carry; Frazzini and was $8.36 trillion of U.S. corporate debt out- Pedersen, 2014 for quality; Asness et al., 2013 for standing, and from 1996 to 2015 corporate bond momentum and value). Our contribution includes issuance grew from $343 billion to $1.49 trillion (i) applying these concepts to credit markets; (ii) (Securities Industry and Financial Markets Asso- studying them together in a way that shines light ciation). Surprisingly little research, however, has on their joint relevance or lack thereof; (iii) eval- investigated the cross-sectional determinants of uating their economic significance by examining corporate bond returns.
    [Show full text]
  • Do Investors Trade Too Much?
    Do Investors Trade Too Much? By TERRANCE ODEAN* Trading volume on the world’s markets should be in real markets, it is difficult to test seems high, perhaps higher than can be ex- whether observed volume is too high. plained by models of rational markets. For ex- If trading is excessive for a market as a ample, the average annual turnover rate on the whole, then it must be excessive for some New York Stock Exchange (NYSE) is currently groups of participants in that market. This paper greater than 75 percent1 and the daily trading demonstrates that the trading volume of a par- volume of foreign-exchange transactions in all ticular class of investors, those with discount currencies (including forwards, swaps, and spot brokerage accounts, is excessive. transactions) is roughly one-quarter of the total Alexandros V. Benos (1998) and Odean annual world trade and investment flow (James (1998a) propose that, due to their overconfi- Dow and Gary Gorton, 1997). While this level dence, investors will trade too much. This paper of trade may seem disproportionate to inves- tests that hypothesis. The trading of discount tors’ rebalancing and hedging needs, we lack brokerage customers is good for testing the economic models that predict what trading vol- overconfidence theory of excessive trading be- ume in these market should be. In theoretical cause this trading is not complicated by agency models trading volume ranges from zero (e.g., relationships. Excessive trading in retail broker- in rational expectation models without noise) to age accounts could, on the other hand, result infinite (e.g., when traders dynamically hedge in from either investors’ overconfidence or from the absence of trading costs).
    [Show full text]