Perceptions of Religious Music in a Southern U.S. Public Middle School
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Louisiana State University LSU Digital Commons LSU Doctoral Dissertations Graduate School 3-30-2018 Perceptions of Religious Music in a Southern U.S. Public Middle School: A Case Study Emily Marie Mercado Louisiana State University and Agricultural and Mechanical College, [email protected] Follow this and additional works at: https://digitalcommons.lsu.edu/gradschool_dissertations Part of the Music Education Commons, and the Other Religion Commons Recommended Citation Mercado, Emily Marie, "Perceptions of Religious Music in a Southern U.S. Public Middle School: A Case Study" (2018). LSU Doctoral Dissertations. 4526. https://digitalcommons.lsu.edu/gradschool_dissertations/4526 This Dissertation is brought to you for free and open access by the Graduate School at LSU Digital Commons. It has been accepted for inclusion in LSU Doctoral Dissertations by an authorized graduate school editor of LSU Digital Commons. For more information, please [email protected]. ! PERCEPTIONS OF RELIGIOUS MUSIC IN A SOUTHERN U.S. PUBLIC MIDDLE SCHOOL: A CASE STUDY! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! A Dissertation! Submitted to the Graduate Faculty of the Louisiana State University and Agricultural and Mechanical College in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy in The College of Music and Dramatic Arts ! by Emily Marie Mercado B.A., Oregon State University, 2005 M.A.T., Oregon State University, 2007 May 2018 ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS ! ! I would like to thank my advisor Dr. Ann Marie Stanley for guiding me through this rewarding process. Her expertise, calming presence, and “get it done” attitude kept me sane and on track to complete a successful dissertation. To the rest of my committee Dr. Daniel Isbell, Dr. Trey Davis, and Dr. Gundela Hachmann for encouraging me to consider multiple perspectives in my research. And to my parents and sister who always encouraged me to accomplish my goals and never stop learning. To my husband Mike and our two sons Trent and Drew, I offer my most sincere gratitude. I thank my sons for the patience, love, and joy they exude. To my husband, I thank him for taking on the majority of the meals, cleaning, and kids, all while working a full-time job. But mostly, for his genuine and unwavering encouragement. ! ! ! ! ii TABLE OF CONTENTS ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS ..................................................................................................ii ABSTRACT ..........................................................................................................................v CHAPTER 1. INTRODUCTION .........................................................................................1 Personal Vignette ........................................................................................................1 Florey v. Sioux Falls (1980) .......................................................................................3 S.D. v. St. Johns Country School District, 2009 ........................................................6 Stratechuk v. Board of Education, 2009 ......................................................................7 Beyond Case Law ........................................................................................................9 CHAPTER 2. REVIEW OF LITERATURE .........................................................................11 History .........................................................................................................................11 Policy ...........................................................................................................................14 Perceptions ..................................................................................................................16 A Multicultural and Culturally Competent Music Classroom ....................................21 Intercultural Competence Literature ...........................................................................24 Main Themes from the Literature ...............................................................................29 Research Questions and Purpose Statement ................................................................32 CHAPTER 3. METHOD .......................................................................................................35 Design ..........................................................................................................................35 Data Collection ............................................................................................................50 Analysis of Data ..........................................................................................................60 CHAPTER 4. FINDINGS ......................................................................................................65 Research Question One ...............................................................................................65 Research Question Two ...............................................................................................69 Research Question Three .............................................................................................76 God and Politics: An Unexpected Day ........................................................................82 Conclusion of Findings ...............................................................................................84 CHAPTER 5. DISCUSSION .................................................................................................86 Research Problem ........................................................................................................86 Purpose statement ........................................................................................................86 Method .........................................................................................................................86 Summary of Major Findings .......................................................................................87 Limited Limitations: Unlimited Perspectives ..............................................................88 Organization of Discussion Section ............................................................................90 Considering Perspectives of Programming Through Related Research .....................90 Considering Perspectives Through Case Law .............................................................98 Considering Perspectives Through Intercultural Competence Theory .......................102 Unsettling and Informing Present Practice ..................................................................107 Future Research ...........................................................................................................127 iii CHAPTER 6. GOD AND POLITICS ...................................................................................130 An Unexpected Day ....................................................................................................130 Perceptions of Politics in Schools ...............................................................................131 Patriotic Music ............................................................................................................132 The National Anthem ..................................................................................................133 Considering Context ....................................................................................................135 Moving Forward ..........................................................................................................137 Final Thoughts .............................................................................................................138 REFERENCES ......................................................................................................................141 APPENDIX A. LOUISIANA STATE UNIVERSITY IRB APPROVAL FORM ...............152 APPENDIX B. PARENT/GUARDIAN PERMISSION FORM ...........................................153 APPENDIX C. CHILD ASSENT FORM .............................................................................155 APPENDIX D. ADMINISTRATOR CONSENT FORM .....................................................156 APPENDIX E. ADULT CONSENT FORM .........................................................................158 APPENDIX F. LETTER TO REQUEST PARENT INTERVIEW .......................................160 APPENDIX G. PERMISSION OF USE FORM ...................................................................161 VITA ....................................................................................................................................162 ! iv ABSTRACT ! ! Intercultural experiences can result in increased knowledge of and positive attitudes towards unfamiliar cultural groups (Neto, Pinto, & Mullet, 2016; Vuoskoski, Clarke, & DeNora, 2017). Deardorff’s (2006) intercultural competence process framework provides a method for exploring and categorizing elements of intercultural competence including attitudes, knowledge/skills, internal outcomes, and external outcomes. This narrative instrumental case study examined the perceptions of one middle school choir teacher, choir students, the student teacher, the parents, and the vice principal when implementing a researcher-designed unit titled: Religious Choral Music from the Christian, Jewish, and Muslim Worlds. The choir teacher offered a unique perspective as an atheist amongst a large Christian majority. However, her training, solely in the Western classical