DOCSLIB.ORG

Arxiv:1212.0736V1 [Cond-Mat.Str-El] 4 Dec 2012 Non-Degenerate Polarized Phase

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Arxiv:1212.0736V1 [Cond-Mat.Str-El] 4 Dec 2012 Non-Degenerate Polarized Phase Disorder by disorder and flat bands in the kagome transverse field Ising model M. Powalski,1 K. Coester,1 R. Moessner,2 and K. P. Schmidt1, ∗ 1Lehrstuhl f¨urTheoretische Physik 1, TU Dortmund, Germany 2Max Planck Institut f¨urkomplexe Systeme, D-01187 Dresden, Germany (Dated: August 10, 2018) We study the transverse field Ising model on a kagome and a triangular lattice using high-order series expansions about the high-field limit. For the triangular lattice our results confirm a second- order quantum phase transition in the 3d XY universality class. Our findings for the kagome lattice indicate a notable instance of a disorder by disorder scenario in two dimensions. The latter follows from a combined analysis of the elementary gap in the high- and low-field limit which is shown to stay finite for all fields h. Furthermore, the lowest one-particle dispersion for the kagome lattice is extremely flat acquiring a dispersion only from order eight in the 1=h limit. This behaviour can be traced back to the existence of local modes and their breakdown which is understood intuitively via the linked cluster expansion. PACS numbers: 75.10.Jm, 05.30.Rt, 05.50.+q,75.10.-b I. INTRODUCTION for arbitrary transverse fields providing a novel instance of disorder by disorder in which quantum fluctuations The interplay of geometric frustration and quantum select a quantum disordered state out of the classically fluctuations in magnetic systems provides a fascinating disordered ground-state manifold. There is no conclu- field of research. It gives rise to a multitude of quan- sive evidence excluding a possible ordering of the kagome tum phases manifesting novel phenomena of quantum transverse field Ising model (TFIM) and its global phase order and disorder, featuring prominent examples such diagram remains unsettled. So far, the only known Ising as spin-ice, spin-glass and spin-liquid phases. This rich system featuring such an unusual disorder by disorder behaviour originates from the frustration of microscopi- scenario is the one-dimensional sawtooth chain [8]. As cally competing magnetic interactions. This can lead to a candidate for disorder by disorder in two dimensions a huge number of quasi-degenerate ground-state configu- the kagome TFIM hence is a subject of great theoretical rations and a suppression of magnetic order even at zero interest. temperature. The macroscopic ground-state manifold of The central objective of this paper is the analysis of simple model systems is extremely sensitive to perturba- the gapped paramagnetic phase for the kagome TFIM to tions. Arbitrary linear combinations of the degenerate check whether it indeed persists for arbitrary field val- states may form novel ground states, yielding the great ues providing an instance of a disorder by disorder sce- variety of unusual effects some of which are not fully un- nario in two dimensions. For this purpose, we investigate derstood to date. the energy gap by high-order series expansions about the Perhaps the simplest and hence most tractable mod- high-field limit. Additionally, we determine the gap of els featuring such behaviour are the fully-frustrated Ising the corresponding low-energy mode for an infinitesimal systems in a transverse field [1]. On lattices like the tri- transverse field by means of a Lanczos based algorithm angular and the kagome lattice, the frustration results performed on appropriate finite clusters. Our findings from the incompatibility of the antiferromagnetic bonds suggest that high- and low-field gaps are indeed adiabat- in a single triangular plaquette. These systems exhibit ically connected implying that the kagome TFIM realizes a classical ground-state manifold with a macroscopic de- a disorder by disorder scenario. generacy which is lifted in the presence of an infinitesimal The analoque problem on the triangular lattice is dif- transverse field inducing quantum fluctuations. ferent. Here, series expansion of the one-particle gap In the limit of high transverse fields all lattices realize a about the high-field limit clearly indicates a second-order phase transition in the 3d XY universality class between arXiv:1212.0736v1 [cond-mat.str-el] 4 Dec 2012 non-degenerate polarized phase. The situation for weak transverse fields however is much less trivial. A large the polarized and an ordered phase realized at low fields. class of these frustrated transverse field Ising systems ex- Our results are in quantitative agreement with quantum hibits a nontrivial quantum ordered phase arising from Monte Carlo simulations [9]. classical disorder, a scenario which is also known as order Finally, we show that a major difference between the by disorder [2{4]. In contrast, the kagome lattice plays triangular and the kagome TFIM lies in the existence a distinguished role as it seems to be very reluctant to of a localized low-energy mode for the kagome lattice order [5{7]. It is believed to be a quantum paramagnet that is completely flat up to order eight perturbation theory.p In thisp order a specific momentum corresponding to the 3 × 3 structure is energetically favored. The emergence of this local mode and its disappearance at re- ∗Electronic address: [email protected] markably high orders in perturbation theory can be un- 2 derstood via the linked cluster expansion. Furthermore, (a) (b) w[2h] we generalize our findings to a larger class of systems. 2p This paper is organized as follows. In Sec.II we briefly 1.5 introduce the TFIM and discuss the physics of the low- p field and high-field regime. In Sec. III we present the e1 e2 k2 0 derivation of the effective one-particle Hamiltonian in the high-field limit using the method of perturbative contin- -p uous unitary transformations (pCUTs) which is imple- 0.8 mented via a linked graph expansion. The one-particle -2p -p 0 p 2p k1 gap for the triangular and the kagome TFIM is analyzed in Sec.IV and in Sec.V. The more technical part dis- cussing the existence of flat bands and their breakdown FIG. 1: (a) Countour plot of the one-particle dispersion !tr(~k) is placed in Sec.VI. Finally, Sec. VII provides a conclud- as a function of the momentum ~k = (k1; k2) on the trian- ing summary. gular lattice for x = 0:1. The red (solid) line corresponds to the first Brillouin zone. (b) Illustration of the complex phase of the eigen state corresponding to the one-particlep p ~ 2 2 II. MODEL gap at kmin = ( 3 π; − 3 π). The state exhibits a 3 × 3- structure. Note that the structure forp thep second gap mo- ~ 2 2 We study the two-dimensional Ising model in a trans- mentum kmin = −( 3 π; − 3 π) is also a 3× 3-structure with verse magnetic field on kagome and triangular lattices. a different orientation. We stress that the displayed arrows The corresponding Hamiltonian is given by do not represent spins. X z z X x H = J σi σj + h σi (1) <i;j> i order scenario. For the first case the elementary gap α should close at the quantum critical point separating the with Pauli matrices σi acting on site i, the antiferromag- netic nearest-neighbour exchange J > 0, and the strength polarized phase from the ordered phase present at low of the transverse magnetic field h. fields. In contrast, disorder by disorder implies the con- For the zero-field case h = 0, the Hamiltonian de- tinuance of the disordered quantum paramagnet for ar- scribes a classical antiferromagnet. The energy of a sin- bitrary transverse fields which requires the ground state gle bond is minimized by an antiparallel alignment of the to be adiabatically connected to the low-field limit such two neighbouring spins. However, there exists no state that the high-field gap never closes. We therefore aim with all bonds satisfying the antiferromagnetic condition at a precise determination of the excitation gap in the due to the frustrated geometry of the lattice. Conse- high-field phase for which we use a high-order series ex- quently, a ground state is given by a configuration where pansion. every triangle has only two antiferromagnetic bonds of which there are infinitely many combinations in the ther- modynamic limit. The resulting extensive ground-state degeneracy gives rise to a finite entropy density at zero III. HIGH-FIELD EXPANSION temperature [1], which is a main characteristic of highly frustrated systems. Let us also mention that the classical Ising antiferromagnet on the kagome lattice is disordered Starting from the high-field limit h J , we use a for any temperature. pCUT [10, 11] to derive a quasi-particle conserving effec- Next, consider the introduction of a small transverse tive Hamiltonian up to high order in perturbation. For field h J which induces quantum fluctuations by flip- this purpose, it is expedient to interpret the elementary ping the z-components of the spins. For any infinitesimal excitations corresponding to single spin flips as quasi- field the macroscopic ground-state degeneracy is lifted particles above the vacuum which is given by the fully to some degree giving rise to a discontinuity in the en- polarized state. The spin flips are then described in terms tropy at zero field h = 0 and zero temperature T = 0. of hardcore bosons represented by creation and annihi- y An interesting question is whether the perturbed system lation operators bi and bi . Besides the usual bosonic continues into a quantum disordered phase (disorder by commutation relations these operators meet the hardcore disorder) or whether quantum fluctuations are selecting constraint a quantum ordered state (order by disorder). We approach this question for the kagome and the tri- b b = byby = 0 (2) angular TFIM by considering the high-field limit (h J) i i i i which provides an ideal setting for a perturbative ap- proach giving also access to the low-field regime.
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Order and Disorder: Poetics of Exception
    Order and disorder Página 1 de 19 Daniel Innerarity Order and disorder: Poetics of exception “While working, the mind proceeds from disorder to order. It is important that it maintain resources of disorder until the end, and that the order it has begun to impose on itself does not bind it so completely, does not become such a rigid master, that it cannot change it and make use of its initial liberty” (Paul Valéry 1960, 714). We live at a time when nothing is conquered with absolute security, neither knowledge nor skills. Newness, the ephemeral, the rapid turn-over of information, of products, of behavioral models, the need for frequent adaptations, the demand for flexibility, all give the impression that we live only in the present in a way that hinders stabilization. Imprinting something onto the long term seems less important that valuing the instant and the event. That being said, thought has always been connected to the task of organizing and classifying, with the goal of conferring stability on the disorganized multiplicity of the manifestations of reality. In order to continue making sense, this articulation of the disparate must understand the paradoxes of order and organization. That is what has been going on recently: there has been a greater awareness of disorder and irregularity at the level of concepts and models for action and in everything from science to the theory of organizations. This difficulty is as theoretical as it is practical; it demands that we reconsider disorder in all its manifestations, as disorganization, turbulence, chaos, complexity, or entropy.
    [Show full text]
  • Order and Disorder in Liquid-Crystalline Elastomers
    Adv Polym Sci (2012) 250: 187–234 DOI: 10.1007/12_2010_105 # Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg 2011 Published online: 3 December 2010 Order and Disorder in Liquid-Crystalline Elastomers Wim H. de Jeu and Boris I. Ostrovskii Abstract Order and frustration play an important role in liquid-crystalline polymer networks (elastomers). The first part of this review is concerned with elastomers in the nematic state and starts with a discussion of nematic polymers, the properties of which are strongly determined by the anisotropy of the polymer backbone. Neutron scattering and X-ray measurements provide the basis for a description of their conformation and chain anisotropy. In nematic elastomers, the macroscopic shape is determined by the anisotropy of the polymer backbone in combination with the elastic response of elastomer network. The second part of the review concentrates on smectic liquid-crystalline systems that show quasi-long-range order of the smectic layers (positional correlations that decay algebraically). In smectic elasto- mers, the smectic layers cannot move easily across the crosslinking points where the polymer backbone is attached. Consequently, layer displacement fluctuations are suppressed, which effectively stabilizes the one-dimensional periodic layer structure and under certain circumstances can reinstate true long-range order. On the other hand, the crosslinks provide a random network of defects that could destroy the smectic order. Thus, in smectic elastomers there exist two opposing tendencies: the suppression of layer displacement fluctuations that enhances trans- lational order, and the effect of random disorder that leads to a highly frustrated equilibrium state. These effects can be investigated with high-resolution X-ray diffraction and are discussed in some detail for smectic elastomers of different topology.
    [Show full text]
  • Calculating the Configurational Entropy of a Landscape Mosaic
    Landscape Ecol (2016) 31:481–489 DOI 10.1007/s10980-015-0305-2 PERSPECTIVE Calculating the configurational entropy of a landscape mosaic Samuel A. Cushman Received: 15 August 2014 / Accepted: 29 October 2015 / Published online: 7 November 2015 Ó Springer Science+Business Media Dordrecht (outside the USA) 2015 Abstract of classes and proportionality can be arranged (mi- Background Applications of entropy and the second crostates) that produce the observed amount of total law of thermodynamics in landscape ecology are rare edge (macrostate). and poorly developed. This is a fundamental limitation given the centrally important role the second law plays Keywords Entropy Á Landscape Á Configuration Á in all physical and biological processes. A critical first Composition Á Thermodynamics step to exploring the utility of thermodynamics in landscape ecology is to define the configurational entropy of a landscape mosaic. In this paper I attempt to link landscape ecology to the second law of Introduction thermodynamics and the entropy concept by showing how the configurational entropy of a landscape mosaic Entropy and the second law of thermodynamics are may be calculated. central organizing principles of nature, but are poorly Result I begin by drawing parallels between the developed and integrated in the landscape ecology configuration of a categorical landscape mosaic and literature (but see Li 2000, 2002; Vranken et al. 2014). the mixing of ideal gases. I propose that the idea of the Descriptions of landscape patterns, processes of thermodynamic microstate can be expressed as unique landscape change, and propagation of pattern-process configurations of a landscape mosaic, and posit that relationships across scale and through time are all the landscape metric Total Edge length is an effective governed and constrained by the second law of measure of configuration for purposes of calculating thermodynamics (Cushman 2015).
    [Show full text]
  • Order and Disorder in Nature- G
    DEVELOPMENT OF PHYSICS-Order And Disorder In Nature- G. Takeda ORDER AND DISORDER IN NATURE G. Takeda The University of Tokyo and Tohoku University, Sendai, Japan Keywords:order,disorder,entropy,fluctuation,phasetransition,latent heat, phase diagram, critical point, free energy, spontaneous symmetry breaking, open system, convection current, Bernard cell, crystalline solid, lattice structure, lattice vibration, phonon, magnetization, Curie point, ferro-paramagnetic transition, magnon, correlation function, correlation length, order parameter, critical exponent, renormalization group method, non-equilibrium process, Navier-Stokes equation, Reynold number, Rayleigh number, Prandtl number, turbulent flow, Lorentz model, laser. Contents 1. Introduction 2. Structure of Solids and Liquids 2.1.Crystalline Structure of Solids 2.2.Liquids 3. Phase Transitions and Spontaneous Broken Symmetry 3.1.Spontaneous Symmetry Breaking 3.2.Order Parameter 4. Non-equilibrium Processes Acknowledgements Glossary Bibliography Biographical Skectch Summary Order-disorder problems are a rapidly developing subject not only in physics but also in all branches of science. Entropy is related to the degree of order in the structure of a system, and the second law of thermodynamics states that the system should change from a more ordered state to a less ordered one as long as the system is isolated from its surroundings.UNESCO – EOLSS Phase transitions of matter are the most well studied order-disorder transitions and occur at certain fixed values of dynamical variables such as temperature and pressure. In general, the degreeSAMPLE of order of the atomic orCHAPTERS molecular arrangement in matter will change by a phase transition and the phase at lower temperature than the transition temperature is more ordered than that at higher temperature.
    [Show full text]
  • Equilibrium Phases of Dipolar Lattice Bosons in the Presence of Random Diagonal Disorder
    Equilibrium phases of dipolar lattice bosons in the presence of random diagonal disorder C. Zhang,1 A. Safavi-Naini,2 and B. Capogrosso-Sansone3 1Homer L. Dodge Department of Physics and Astronomy, The University of Oklahoma, Norman, Oklahoma ,73019, USA 2JILA , NIST and Department of Physics, University of Colorado, 440 UCB, Boulder, CO 80309, USA 3Department of Physics, Clark University, Worcester, Massachusetts, 01610, USA Ultracold gases offer an unprecedented opportunity to engineer disorder and interactions in a controlled manner. In an effort to understand the interplay between disorder, dipolar interaction and quantum degeneracy, we study two-dimensional hard-core dipolar lattice bosons in the presence of on-site bound disorder. Our results are based on large-scale path-integral quantum Monte Carlo simulations by the Worm algorithm. We study the ground state phase diagram at fixed half-integer filling factor for which the clean system is either a superfluid at lower dipolar interaction strength or a checkerboard solid at larger dipolar interaction strength. We find that, even for weak dipolar interaction, superfluidity is destroyed in favor of a Bose glass at relatively low disorder strength. Interestingly, in the presence of disorder, superfluidity persists for values of dipolar interaction strength for which the clean system is a checkerboard solid. At fixed disorder strength, as the dipolar interaction is increased, superfluidity is destroyed in favor of a Bose glass. As the interaction is further increased, the system eventually develops extended checkerboard patterns in the density distribution. Due to the presence of disorder, though, grain boundaries and defects, responsible for a finite residual compressibility, are present in the density distribution.
    [Show full text]
  • Entropy (Order and Disorder)
    Entropy (order and disorder) Locally, the entropy can be lowered by external action. This applies to machines, such as a refrigerator, where the entropy in the cold chamber is being reduced, and to living organisms. This local decrease in entropy is, how- ever, only possible at the expense of an entropy increase in the surroundings. 1 History This “molecular ordering” entropy perspective traces its origins to molecular movement interpretations developed by Rudolf Clausius in the 1850s, particularly with his 1862 visual conception of molecular disgregation. Sim- ilarly, in 1859, after reading a paper on the diffusion of molecules by Clausius, Scottish physicist James Clerk Boltzmann’s molecules (1896) shown at a “rest position” in a solid Maxwell formulated the Maxwell distribution of molec- ular velocities, which gave the proportion of molecules having a certain velocity in a specific range. This was the In thermodynamics, entropy is commonly associated first-ever statistical law in physics.[3] with the amount of order, disorder, or chaos in a thermodynamic system. This stems from Rudolf Clau- In 1864, Ludwig Boltzmann, a young student in Vienna, sius' 1862 assertion that any thermodynamic process al- came across Maxwell’s paper and was so inspired by it ways “admits to being reduced to the alteration in some that he spent much of his long and distinguished life de- way or another of the arrangement of the constituent parts veloping the subject further. Later, Boltzmann, in efforts of the working body" and that internal work associated to develop a kinetic theory for the behavior of a gas, ap- with these alterations is quantified energetically by a mea- plied the laws of probability to Maxwell’s and Clausius’ sure of “entropy” change, according to the following dif- molecular interpretation of entropy so to begin to inter- ferential expression:[1] pret entropy in terms of order and disorder.
    [Show full text]
  • REVIEW Theory of Displacive Phase Transitions in Minerals
    American Mineralogist, Volume 82, pages 213±244, 1997 REVIEW Theory of displacive phase transitions in minerals MARTIN T. DOVE Department of Earth Sciences, University of Cambridge, Downing Street, Cambridge CB2 3EQ, U.K. ABSTRACT A lattice-dynamical treatment of displacive phase transitions leads naturally to the soft- mode model, in which the phase-transition mechanism involves a phonon frequency that falls to zero at the transition temperature. The basic ideas of this approach are reviewed in relation to displacive phase transitions in silicates. A simple free-energy model is used to demonstrate that Landau theory gives a good approximation to the free energy of the transition, provided that the entropy is primarily produced by the phonons rather than any con®gurational disorder. The ``rigid unit mode'' model provides a physical link between the theory and the chemical bonds in silicates and this allows us to understand the origin of the transition temperature and also validates the application of the soft-mode model. The model is also used to reappraise the nature of the structures of high-temperature phases. Several issues that remain open, such as the origin of ®rst-order phase transitions and the thermodynamics of pressure-induced phase transitions, are discussed. INTRODUCTION represented in Figure 1. In each case, the phase transitions involve small translations and rotations of the (Si,Al)O The study of phase transitions extends back a century 4 tetrahedra. One of the most popular of the new devel- to the early work on quartz, ferromagnets, and liquid-gas opments in the theory of displacive phase transitions in phase equilibrium.
    [Show full text]
  • Biochemical Thermodynamics
    © Jones & Bartlett Learning, LLC. NOT FOR SALE OR DISTRIBUTION CHAPTER 1 Biochemical Thermodynamics Learning Objectives 1. Defi ne and use correctly the terms system, closed, open, surroundings, state, energy, temperature, thermal energy, irreversible process, entropy, free energy, electromotive force (emf), Faraday constant, equilibrium constant, acid dissociation constant, standard state, and biochemical standard state. 2. State and appropriately use equations relating the free energy change of reactions, the standard-state free energy change, the equilibrium constant, and the concentrations of reactants and products. 3. Explain qualitatively and quantitatively how unfavorable reactions may occur at the expense of a favorable reaction. 4. Apply the concept of coupled reactions and the thermodynamic additivity of free energy changes to calculate overall free energy changes and shifts in the concentrations of reactants and products. 5. Construct balanced reduction–oxidation reactions, using half-reactions, and calculate the resulting changes in free energy and emf. 6. Explain differences between the standard-state convention used by chemists and that used by biochemists, and give reasons for the differences. 7. Recognize and apply correctly common biochemical conventions in writing biochemical reactions. Basic Quantities and Concepts Thermodynamics is a system of thinking about interconnections of heat, work, and matter in natural processes like heating and cooling materials, mixing and separation of materials, and— of particular interest here—chemical reactions. Thermodynamic concepts are freely used throughout biochemistry to explain or rationalize chains of chemical transformations, as well as their connections to physical and biological processes such as locomotion or reproduction, the generation of fever, the effects of starvation or malnutrition, and more.
    [Show full text]
  • PHASE DIAGRAM of the ORDER-DISORDER TRANSITION in Ni3fe J
    PHASE DIAGRAM OF THE ORDER-DISORDER TRANSITION IN Ni3Fe J. van Deen, F. van der Woude To cite this version: J. van Deen, F. van der Woude. PHASE DIAGRAM OF THE ORDER-DISORDER TRANSITION IN Ni3Fe. Journal de Physique Colloques, 1980, 41 (C1), pp.C1-367-C1-368. 10.1051/jphyscol:19801138. jpa-00219622 HAL Id: jpa-00219622 https://hal.archives-ouvertes.fr/jpa-00219622 Submitted on 1 Jan 1980 HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci- destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents entific research documents, whether they are pub- scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, lished or not. The documents may come from émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de teaching and research institutions in France or recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires abroad, or from public or private research centers. publics ou privés. JOURNAL DE PHYSIQUE Colloque Cl ,suppl&ment au n O 1, Tome 41,janvier 1980,page Cl-367 PHASE DIAGRAM OF ME ORDER-DISORDER TRANSITION IN Ni3Fe J.K. Van Deen and F. Van Der Woude Solid state Physics Laboratory, Materials Science Center, University of Groningen, GRONINGEN, The Netherlands. 1. Introduction. - The phase diagram of the Ni-Fe binary alloy system in the region around the 3: 1 composition has been investigated by means of MES. .The NigFe system is a well known example of an al- loy, ordering in the LIZ structure, a superstructure of the fcc-lattice. The transition temperature rea- ches a maximum at 789 K and 27 at.% Fe, slightly away from the stoichiometric 3:l composition.
    [Show full text]
  • Entropy and Art: Essay on Disorder and Order
    ENTROPY AND ART AN ESSAY ON DISORDER AND ORDER RUDOLF ARNHEIM ABSTRACT. Order is a necessary condition for anything the hu- man mind is to understand. Arrangements such as the layout of a city or building, a set of tools, a display of merchandise, the ver- bal exposition of facts or ideas, or a painting or piece of music are called orderly when an observer or listener can grasp their overall structure and the ramification of the structure in some detail. Or- der makes it possible to focus on what is alike and what is differ- ent, what belongs together and what is segregated. When noth- ing superfluous is included and nothing indispensable left out, one can understand the interrelation of the whole and its parts, as well as the hierarchic scale of importance and power by which some structural features are dominant, others subordinate. 2 RUDOLF ARNHEIM CONTENTS Part 1. 3 1. USEFUL ORDER 3 2. REFLECTIONS OF PHYSICAL ORDER 4 3. DISORDER AND DEGRADATION 7 4. WHAT THE PHYSICIST HAS IN MIND 11 5. INFORMATION AND ORDER 13 6. PROBABILITY AND STRUCTURE 17 7. EQUILIBRIUM 21 8. TENSION REDUCTION AND WEAR AND TEAR 22 9. THE VIRTUE OF CONSTRAINTS 25 10. THE STRUCTURAL THEME 27 Part 2. 32 11. ORDER IN THE SECOND PLACE 32 12. THE PLEASURES OF TENSION REDUCTION 35 13. HOMEOSTASIS IS NOT ENOUGH 39 14. A NEED FOR COMPLEXITY 40 15. ART MADE SIMPLE 43 16. CALL FOR STRUCTURE 46 References 48 ENTROPY AND ART AN ESSAY ON DISORDER AND ORDER 3 Part 1.
    [Show full text]
  • 'Order to Disorder' for Entropy Change
    24 Chem. Educator 2005, 10, 24–25 “Order-to-Disorder” for Entropy Change? Consider the Numbers! Evguenii I. Kozliak*,† and Frank L. Lambert‡ †Department of Chemistry, University of North Dakota, Grand Forks, ND 58202-9024, [email protected] and ‡Professor Emeritus, Occidental College, Department of Chemistry, Los Angeles, CA 90041, [email protected] Received June 8, 2004. Accepted November 16, 2004. Abstract: Defining entropy increase as a change from order to disorder is misleading at best and incorrect at worst. Although Boltzmann described it this way in 1898, he did so innocently in the sense that he had never calculated the numerical values of W using ∆S = kBln (W/W0) (because this equation was not stated, kB was not known, and W0 was indeterminable before 1900–1912). Prior publications have demonstrated that the word “disorder” is misleading in describing entropy change. In this paper, convincing evidence is provided that no starting system above ca. 1 K can be said to be orderly so far as the distribution of its energy (the fundamental determinant of entropy) is concerned. This is supported by a simple calculation showing that any system with “a practical state of zero entropy” has an incomprehensibly large number of microstates. Recently, Lambert showed examples of how beginning explanation via change in the number of accessible microstates students can be seriously misled by the long-accepted for the energy of the system [1a, 2b, 3]. In this paper, we shall definition of entropy as disorder [1a] and urged that entropy show that the first part of this old definition of entropy change change be measured by the change in dispersal of motional is also misleading.
    [Show full text]
  • Revised Information Theory, Similarity Principle and Ugly Symmetry
    The Nature of the Chemical Process. 1. Symmetry Evolution – Revised Information Theory, Similarity Principle and Ugly Symmetry Shu-Kun Lin Molecular Diversity Preservation International (MDPI), Sangergasse 25, Basel CH-4054 Switzerland. Tel. ++41 79 322 3379, Fax: ++41 61 302 8918, E-mail: [email protected], http://www.mdpi.org/lin Abstract: Symmetry is a measure of indistinguishability. Similarity is a continuous measure of imperfect symmetry. Lewis' remark that “gain of entropy means loss of information” defines the relationship of entropy and information. Three laws of information theory have been proposed. Labeling by introducing nonsymmetry and formatting by introducing symmetry are defined. The function L ( L=lnw, w is the number of microstates, or the sum of entropy and information, L=S+I) of the universe is a constant (the first law of information theory). The entropy S of the universe tends toward a maximum (the second law law of information theory). For a perfect symmetric static structure, the information is zero and the static entropy is the maximum (the third law law of information theory). Based on the Gibbs inequality and the second law of the revised information theory we have proved the similarity principle (a continuous higher similarity-higher entropy relation after the rejection of the Gibbs paradox) and proved the Curie-Rosen symmetry principle (a higher symmetry-higher stability relation) as a special case of the similarity principle. The principles of information minimization and potential energy minimization are compared. Entropy is the degree of symmetry and information is the degree of nonsymmetry. There are two kinds of symmetries: dynamic and static symmetries.
    [Show full text]