THE MYSTERY of CONSCIOUSNESS Exploring the Question of Human Consciousness – P.15 President’S Message Promoting Excellence Now and in the Future
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
IN CONVERSATION FEATURE FEATURE ARTICLE Childhood well-being – p.11 Healthy oceans – p.23 The secret of our success –p.33 Circles in the sky – p.41 IDEAS TO CHANGE THE WORLD—SPRING 2016 THE MYSTERY OF CONSCIOUSNESS Exploring the question of human consciousness – p.15 President’s message Promoting excellence now and in the future The breadth and the depth of research being The Secret of Our Success, which suggests that it’s carried out by CIFAR fellows is truly impressive not our overall intelligence, but our ability to learn – from the action of tiny particles in fractions of from one another, that has led to human success. a second, to the behaviour of the universe over Finally, I want to point out the conversation billions of years. From the effects of stress on a among three of our fellows – Megan Gunnar, child, to the development of entire societies and Charles Nelson and Michael Kobor. They discuss the institutions that make them work. what research has taught us about the importance Fascinating as CIFAR research is, it’s not of early experience to the well-being of children, undertaken merely out of curiosity. When we’re what questions still need answered, and how our deciding on what programs to bring together, research findings can be translated into policy and we ask ourselves a few simple questions. Is the practice that actually help vulnerable children. question important? Can answering it make The conversation is especially interesting a real and enduring difference? Will CIFAR’s because the issues it raises will be addressed in involvement make a difference? November by the CIFAR Forum on the Well- Only when we can answer yes to all of these Being of the World’s Children in London, questions do we decide to put together a pro- England. In the forum, CIFAR will bring to- gram of research. It’s an approach that has led gether more than a hundred researchers, prac- to amazing successes. You’ll read about a few of titioners, organizations and other stakeholders them in this issue of Reach magazine, in which to discuss what research questions need to be we highlight some of our many pre-eminent re- answered to help us help children. It’s a massive searchers and the important work they are doing. effort by CIFAR to tap into the expertise of an en- In our cover feature, you’ll read about how tire community, and it’s one we think will play an researchers in our Azrieli Program in Brain, important role in setting new research directions. Mind & Consciousness are using the latest I’d also like to take the opportunity to men- tools of science and philosophy to tackle the tion that we are launching the CIFAR Azrieli puzzling questions raised by consciousness – Global Scholars program. This new program what is it, exactly? What is it good for? Where will provide young researchers with oppor- does it come from, and how do we recognize if tunities to develop the cross-disciplinary and someone or something has it? Those questions cross-sector knowledge, skills and perspec- are interesting in themselves, but they also have tives they need to become research leaders important implications for our understanding within academia and agents of change beyond of basic human psychology, cognitive function academia. The program is just launching, but and mental health. It’s exactly the sort of re- please go to cifar.ca to read about it and other search problem that CIFAR’s interdisciplinary developments at CIFAR. approach is intended to solve. I hope you enjoy this issue of Reach maga- You’ll also see how the fellows in our In- zine. It tells some of our stories, but there are tegrated Microbial Biodiversity program are many more than we can fit into its pages. I’d tackling fundamental questions about the in- encourage you to go to our new IdeasExchange credible diversity of microbial life in the oceans website, cifar.ca/ideasexchange, to keep up on that have major implications for the health of all of our news. • coral reefs, the oceans and our world’s climate. And you’ll read about Joe Henrich’s new book Alan Bernstein, President & CEO 1 CONTENTS 4 Advances News from our research networks. 11 Childhood well-being In advance of the CIFAR Forum on the Well-Being of the World’s Children, three Child & Brain Development fellows talk about what we know, and what we still have to learn, about early childhood and well-being. 15 15 The mystery of consciousness What is consciousness? It’s one of the most perplexing questions in philosophy and brain science. Fellows in CIFAR’s new Azrieli Program in Brain, Mind & Consciousness are using new scientific methods to get to the bottom of it. 23 Healthy oceans 23 New understanding of microbial life could help us heal coral reefs and even give insight into how oceans regulate the world’s climate. 33 The secret of our success Humans aren’t as intelligent as we think we are. Luckily, our knack for social learning lets us create a culture that’s smarter than any of us. 41 Circles in the sky An Escher drawing that mirrors the shape 33 of the universe. 43 IdeasExchange CIFAR’s new IdeasExchange platform connects researchers, change makers and innovators to drive change in society. 45 CIFAR’s donors 47 History note What an experiment filmed by the BBC taught us about identity, social 41 roles and the danger of tyranny. 2 Reach Magazine Spring 2016 —V olume 15, Issue 1 Managing Editor Creative Direction Kurt Kleiner Concrete [email protected] www.concrete.ca Reach Magazine, CIFAR BN / Registration N° 180 Dundas Street West, Suite 1400 11921 9251 RR0001 Toronto, ON M5G 1Z8 Produced by CIFAR Marketing & Communications About CIFAR CIFAR creates knowledge that is transforming our world. The Institute brings together out- standing researchers to work in global networks that address some of the most important ques- tions our world faces today. Our research is focused on improving human health, transforming technology, building strong societies and sustaining the Earth. Our networks help support the growth of research leaders and are catalysts for change in business, government and society. Established in 1982, CIFAR is a Canadian-based, global organization, comprised of nearly 350 fellows, scholars and advisors from more than 100 institutions in 16 countries. CIFAR is gener- ously supported by the governments of Canada, British Columbia, Alberta, Ontario and Quebec, Canadian and international partners, as well as individuals, foundations and corporations. His Excellency The Right Honourable David Johnston (Honorary Patron) Governor General of Canada Ottawa ON Board of Directors Barbara Stymiest Lindsay Gordon (Chair, CIFAR) Chancellor Corporate Director University of British Columbia Toronto ON Vancouver BC Bruce H. Mitchell Anthony R.M. Graham (Vice-Chair, CIFAR) Vice Chairman President & CEO Wittington Investments Limited Permian Industries Limited Toronto ON Toronto ON Jacqueline Koerner Stephen J. Toope Founder and Past Chair (Vice-Chair, CIFAR) Ecotrust Canada Director, Munk School of Global Affairs Vancouver BC University of Toronto Toronto ON Stephen D. Lister Managing Partner Peter J. G. Bentley Imperial Capital Limited Director & Chair Emeritus Toronto ON Canfor Corporation Vancouver BC Patricia Meredith Clarkson Centre for Board Effectiveness Jean-Guy Desjardins University of Toronto Chairman, CEO Toronto ON Fiera Capital Corporation Montreal QC Gilles G. Ouellette Group Head, BMO Wealth Management Jim Dinning BMO Financial Group Chairman Toronto ON Western Financial Group High River AB Lawrence Pentland Corporate Director David A. Dodge Toronto ON Senior Advisor Bennett Jones LLP Hugo F. Sonnenschein Ottawa ON President Emeritus & Distinguished Service Professor Department of Economics University of Chicago Pierre Y. Ducros Chicago IL President P. Ducros & Associates Bill Young Montreal QC Founder and Managing Partner Monitor Clipper Partners Brenda Eaton Boston MA Corporate Director Victoria BC Alan Bernstein President & CEO Morten N. Friis CIFAR Non-Executive Director Toronto ON Cover illustration by Royal Bank of Scotland Adam Simpson. Toronto ON 3 Advances News highlights from our research networks ARTHUR McDONALD RECEIVES THE NOBEL PRIZE Arthur B. McDonald (Queen’s University), associate fellow in CIFAR’s Cosmology & Gravity program, received the 2015 Nobel Prize in Physics for his discovery that neutri- nos change identities, a finding which shows that these sub- atomic particles have mass. He Deep Genomics combines deep learning with genome science. Photo: Image courtesy of Science shares the prize with Takaaki Kajita of Japan. McDonald led a research seemed to be disappearing. group, including Senior Fellow McDonald’s group discovered CIFAR FELLOW LAUNCHES Mark Chen (Queen’s Univer- that SNO was in fact captur- DEEP GENOMICS sity), at the Sudbury Neutrino ing the neutrinos, but that Observatory (SNO), studying the missing ones had actual- Senior Fellow Brendan Frey neutrinos formed through nu- ly changed ‘identities’ during (University of Toronto) launch- clear reactions in the sun. As their trip from the sun – chang- ed a startup company, Deep these tiny particles travelled ing from one to another of Genomics, which will develop to Earth, two-thirds of them three different types of neutri- technology to predict how no. Not only did the discovery changes in our genome affect explain the missing neutrinos, human biology and health. it also implied that neutri- The company is using tech- nos actually have mass. This nology based on an artificial finding challenged the Stan- intelligence approach called dard Model of particle physics, deep learning, which CIFAR changing our understanding of fellows in the Learning in one of the most abundant par- Machines & Brains program ticles in the universe. have pioneered. Frey, who is McDonald has been in- appointed to this program and volved with CIFAR for 18 years, also to CIFAR’s program in previously as the Cosmology Genetic Networks, has com- & Gravity program’s advisory bined deep learning with new committee chair and as a mem- technologies for reading and Arthur B.