A Faunistic Approach to Assess Potential Side-Effects of Genetically Modified Bt-Corn on Non-Target Arthropods Under Field Conditions
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Biocontrol Science and Technology (March 2004), Vol. 14, No. 2, 129Á/170 A Faunistic Approach to Assess Potential Side-Effects of Genetically Modified Bt-Corn on Non-Target Arthropods Under Field Conditions 1 2 1 1 M. P. CANDOLFI ,K.BROWN, C. GRIMM , B. REBER AND H. SCHMIDLI1 1Syngenta Crop Protection AG, CH-4002 Basel, Switzerland; 2Ecotox Limited, Tavistock, Devon, UK (Received 31 October 2001; accepted 13 May 2003) A faunistic study investigating the potential side-effects of corn (Zea mays) genetically modified to express a truncated Cry1Ab protein derived from Bacillus thuringiensis subsp. kurstaki, on non-target arthropods was carried out under field conditions. The communities of non-target arthropods in the soil, on the leaves and flying in the crop area were monitored throughout the growing season. Water-treated, untransformed corn served as a control, and a spray application of a bacterial Bt insecticide (Delfin WG) and a synthetic insecticide (Karate Xpress) used to control the European corn borer (Ostrinia nubilalis; Lepidoptera: Pyralidae) acted as positive reference treatments. Results were analyzed using a principal response curve. Significantly lower infestations by the lepidopteran target species O. nubilalis were observed in the Bt-corn plots compared to the control. No effects of Bt-corn on the communities of soil dwelling and non-target plant dwelling arthropods were observed. A trend towards a community effect on flying arthropods was observed with lower abundance of adult Lepidoptera, flies in the families Lonchopteridae, Mycetophilidae and Syrphidae, and the hymenopteran parasitoids Ceraphronidae. Effects were weak and restricted to two sampling dates corresponding to anthesis. A short but statistically significant effect of Karate Xpress and Delfin was observed on the community of plant dwellers and a prolonged effect of Karate Xpress on the soil dwellers. Keywords: non-target arthropods, fauna, side-effects, Bt-corn, transgenic plants, Bacillus thuringiensis, Cry1Ab, pesticides, Delfin, Karate Xpress, lambda-cyhalothrin, biosafety Correspondence to: Dr. Marco Candolfi, RCC Ltd., Zelgliweg 1, CH-4452 Itingen, Switzerland. Tel.: /41-61- 975-1193; E-mail: [email protected] ISSN 0958-3157 (print)/ISSN 1360-0478 (online)/04/020129-42 # 2004 Taylor & Francis Ltd DOI: 10.1080/09583150310001655701 130 M. P. CANDOLFI ET AL . INTRODUCTION Insecticide formulations containing Bacillus thuringiensis (Bt) have been used in agriculture since the 1950s (Frankenhuyzen, 1993). Toxicity of these products to arthropods is predominantly due to a range of crystal proteins produced by the bacterium. Because most represent protoxins that need to be activated by insect midgut proteases to yield toxic fragments (Lereclus et al., 1993), susceptible insects must have a strongly alkaline mid-gut, proteolytic enzymes, and suitable tissue receptor-sites (Gill et al., 1992). Sprayed Bt-toxins degrade very rapidly under field conditions on foliage (Ignoffo & Garcia, 1978; Krieg, 1986; Glare & O’Callaghan, 2000) and thus plant dwelling arthropods are exposed only during a very limited period of their life span. These factors contribute to the high selectivity of Bt- based insecticides which are used to control lepidopteran and coleopteran pests, mosquitoes and black flies. Side-effects on non-target arthropods have only very rarely been observed under laboratory conditions. Peacock et al. (1998) found 27 of 42 lepidopteran species tested suffered increased mortality. Babrikova et al. (1982) and Babrikova and Kuzmanova (1984) reported higher mortality of the lacewing Chrysoperla carnea (Neuroptera: Chrysopidae) when adults, but not when larvae were fed with food contaminated with three different Bt- spray formulations under laboratory conditions. Petrova and Khrameeva (1989) reported highly deleterious effects of a spray formulation on the predatory mite Phytoseiulus persimilis (Acari: Phytoseiidae), and detrimental effects on Bracon brevicornis (Hymenoptera: Braconidae) were described by Temerak (1980) and Salama et al. (1991). However, the field use of Bt-based insecticides following good agricultural practices is generally considered safe (Flexner et al., 1986; Krieg, 1986; Melin & Cozzi, 1989; Croft, 1990, Meadows, 1993; Glare & O’Callaghan, 2000). One constraint of conventional spray application of Bt-formulations is to reach pests that feed within the plant tissues. The economically most important such pest in corn is the European corn borer, Ostrinia nubilalis (Lepidoptera: Pyralidae). Eggs are laid on leaves, but larvae migrate to the relative protection of the whorls to develop, bore in to the stalk and can lead to plant breakage or lodging (Ely, 1993). In southern Europe the Mediterranean corn borer, Sesamia nonagrioides (Lepidoptera: Noctuidae), is one of the most damaging pests of corn and is also characterized by its endophytic larval behavior (Gonza´lez-Nu´n˜ez et al., 2000). Corn has been genetically modified to express the CryIAb protein derived from B. thuringiensis, thus providing a high level of resistance to larval feeding of corn borers (Koziel et al., 1993; Gonza´lez-Nu´n˜ez et al., 2000). Bt-corn was first commercially released in the US in 1996 (Roush, 1997) and was grown commercially on 9.9 million ha in 2002 (including stacked varieties expressing insect resistance and herbicide tolerance) in the USA, Canada, Argentina, South Africa, Spain, Honduras and Germany (James, 2002). In the Bt-corn used in this trial, the CryIAb protein is expressed in a truncated and thus partly inactivated form, under the control of the promoter phosphoenolpyrovate carboxylase in green tissues and a pollen-specific promoter in pollen, and is therefore present in significant levels in the leaves and the pollen. Highest levels related to plant fresh weight were found in the seedling stage, but on a per acre rate at anthesis (Fearing et al., 1997). Much of the selectivity data generated in the past 30 years on Bt-insecticide formulations can be applied to Bt-corn. However, potential side-effects on non-target arthropods need verification to account for the different concentration, mode and duration of exposure and the fact that CryIAb protein expressed in Bt-corn is already partially activated. A number of studies have addressed this issue in recent years. Laboratory studies conducted with Coleomegilla maculata (Coleoptera: Coccinellidae), Orius insidiosus (Heteroptera: Antho- coridae) and Chrysoperla carnea (Neuroptera: Chrysopidae) showed no detrimental effects on pre-imaginal development and survival when insect larvae were fed transgenic Bt-corn pollen (Pilcher et al., 1997). Hilbeck et al. (1998a) reported that C. carnea larvae raised with Bt-corn-fed prey Á/ O. nubilalis or Spodoptera litoralis (Lepidoptera, Noctuidae) Á/ showed POTENTIAL EFFECTS OF Bt -CORN 131 higher pre-imaginal mortality (62%) than larvae raised on CryIAb-free prey (37%). Subsequent studies showed that C. carnea larvae fed with a liquid artificial diet mixed with the purified CryIAb toxin (concentration of 100 mg CryIAb/ml diet) exhibited a higher pre-imaginal mortality (57%) when compared to CryIAb-free diet (30%) (Hilbeck et al., 1998b). However, Lozzia et al. (1998a) found no differences in postembryonic developmental time, fecundity or survival of the aphid Rhopalosiphum padi (Homoptera: Aphididae) reared on Bt- versus untransformed corn and also reported no detrimental effects on pre-imaginal development and mortality of C. carnea fed on R. padi that had been reared on Bt-corn when compared to untransformed corn plants. A further tritrophic experiment in the laboratory also showed no effects when Orius majusculus (Heteroptera: Anthocoridae) was fed with the thrips Anaphothrips obscurus (Thysanoptera: Thripidae) reared on Bt-corn expressing CryIAb (Zwahlen et al., 2000), a result that was confirmed in the field when comparing abundances of nymphs and adults of O. insidiosus on Bt-corn with untrans- formed corn (Al-Deeb et al., 2001). Corn plants genetically modified to contain the event 176, encoding for a truncated CryIAb toxin, have been shown to release toxin into the soil environment by root exudates. These toxins can be persistent when bound to clay or humic acids, since they are protected against microbial degradation, and they have been shown to remain biologically active in bioasssays with tobacco hornworm, Manduca sexta (Lepidoptera: Sphingidae), and the Colorado potato beetle, Leptinotarsa decemlineata (Coleoptera: Chrysomelidae) (Saxena et al., 1999, 2002; Saxena & Stotzky, 2000). Under field conditions, Orr and Landis (1997) reported no significant negative effect of Bt-corn on the densities of O. insidiosus, coccinellids and chrysopids with a tendency towards higher densities of predators in Bt-corn fields compared to isogenic corn. Pilcher et al. (1997) reported no significant effects of Bt-corn on the abundance of species in the families Anthocoridae, Coccinellidae and Chrysopidae. Field data on additional non-target taxa were published by Lozzia and Rigamonti (1998) and Lozzia et al. (1998b). These authors reported no significant effects of Bt-corn on the abundance of carabid beetles, cicadellids, alticini beetles, parasitic hymenopterans, and syrphids. All of these studies above have compared non-target effects of Bt-corn on selected bio-indicator species with an untreated isoline. There has been little work done to compare the community-level effects of Bt-corn with the alternative of using conventional insecticides. Due to the