<<

Report to: Planning Committee Agenda Item: 6

Report Title: Report on Planning Enforcement Live Cases and Appeals in the and District Council area. (Paper D)

Date: 9 April 2015

Report by: Head of Planning

For Publication: Yes/No (please delete as appropriate)

If 'not for publication', Insert reference to grounds upon which information is deemed 'confidential' [ref Local Government (Northern ) Act 2014 section 42(2), (3)] or 'exempt' [ref Local Government () Act 2014 section 42(4) Schedule 6]:

(i) Confidential grounds:

(ii) Exempt grounds:

1. Relevant Background and Introduction

1.1 The attached schedule (Appendix A) provides details of all live enforcement cases in the District Council at 1

April 2015. The list provides details of the enforcement status, nature of

the breach and location of the breach.

1.2 Members will be provided with a monthly update on new cases received, cases where formal Notices have been served and cases where court summons has issued.

1.3 Attached at Appendix B is the schedule of enforcement appeals.

2. Key Issues

2.1 The report is presented in accordance with the Council’s protocol and the Committee’s operational procedures.

3. Resource Implications

3.1 Financial There are no particular financial implications associated with the report or this function.

3.2 Human Resources There are no particular HR implications associated with the report or this function.

3.3 Assets and Other Implications N/A

4. Equality and Good Relations Implications There are no adverse equality or good relations implications from the proposals as presented.

5. Sustainable Development Implications N/A

6. Electoral Ward(s) Affected All Wards.

7. Recommendations

RECOMMENDED: that Members note the current list of live enforcement cases.

8. Appendices and Attachments

Appendix A – Schedule of current enforcement cases

Appendix B – Schedule of current enforcement appeals

9. Background Documents

Key to Abbreviations: Case Reference Enforcement Status Nature of Breach Location of Breach K/2007/0115CA Court Action Being Pursued Change of Use 10 Aughadulla Road Omagh Co Tyrone

K/2011/0056/CA ENFORCEMENT ACTION BEING Works to building within a Menarys 44 High Street Omagh Tyrone BT78 1BP PURSUED conservation area

K/2012/0002/CA ENFORCEMENT ACTION BEING Roads Conditions not adhered to Lands Adjacent To 34 Drumnakilly PURSUED Road Cranny Sixmilecross Tyrone BT79 0JP K/2012/0064/CA Warning Letter Issued Unauthorised lean to structure, 12 Kingarrow Road Kingarrow Omagh Tyrone BT79 7TX wooden shed and container adjacent to approved sheep shed

K/2012/0092/CA Seeking Developer Contacts Kitchens, Tiles, Sliding robes sales 180 Donaghanie Road Donaghanie Omagh Tyrone BT79 0XE

K/2012/0108/CA Seeking Developer Contacts Erection of buildings 21 Gortrush Industrial Estate Great Northern Road Omagh BT78 5EJ

K/2013/0014/CA ENFORCEMENT ACTION BEING Substantial infilling of floodplain 10 Derrynaseer Road Shannaragh Dromore Tyrone BT78 3EL PURSUED and culverting of adjacent watercourse

K/2013/0041/CA Assessment of Enforcement Breach of planning condition of Straduff Quarry, Drumlish Road Drumlish Dromore Tyrone BT78 Case K/2008/0749/F 3BL

K/2013/0054/CA NEGOTIATE TO RESOLVE Breach of condition 02 (category 154 Termon Road Tremoge Pomeroy Tyrone BT79 9HW of waste), 04 (building design details) and 05 (door design details) of planning approval K/2006/1491/F K/2013/0091/CA ENFORCEMENT ACTION BEING Change of use from shop (A1) to The Retreat 14 Ashfield Terrace Gortmore Omagh Tyrone BT78 PURSUED shop (A1) and Gymnasium (sui 5ES generis) K/2013/0104/CA ENFORCEMENT ACTION BEING Works to building Approx. 330m SW Of 45 Camcosy PURSUED Road Curraghinalt Omagh Tyrone BT79 7SF

K/2014/0004/CA NEGOTIATE TO RESOLVE Storage of vehicles Land Adjacent To 24 Drum Road Edenderry Omagh Tyrone BT78 1PX

K/2014/0009/CA RECEIPT OF PLANNING Unauthorised decking / raised 14 Sperrin View Culmore Omagh Tyrone BT78 5BJ APPLICATION platform partly outside the curtilage of dwelling K/2014/0024/CA RECEIPT OF PLANNING Unauthorised Signage Poundstretcher 8-10 Scarffe's Entry Omagh Tyrone BT78 1JH APPLICATION

K/2014/0030/CA NEGOTIATE TO RESOLVE Unauthorised mobile home To The Rear Of 18 Carnalea Road Castletown Tyrone BT78 2HP

K/2014/0033/CA Assessment of Enforcement New large building to rear of 238 Drumnakilly Road Carrickmore Sixmilecross Tyrone BT79 Case dwelling 9PU

K/2014/0038/CA ENFORCEMENT ACTION BEING Vehicle sales 7 Main Street Beragh Tyrone BT79 0SY PURSUED K/2014/0042/CA ENFORCEMENT ACTION BEING Quarry Land At Aghnamoe Road Dromore Co Tyrone BT78 3HR PURSUED

K/2014/0043/CA RECEIPT OF PLANNING Unauthorised fence and vehicular 20 Loughrey Terrace Drumnaforbe Drumquin Tyrone BT78 APPLICATION driveway and access 4SG

K/2014/0046/CA RECEIPT OF PLANNING Erection of replacement garage 5 Willowmount Park Mullaghmore Omagh Tyrone BT79 7EA APPLICATION

K/2014/0047/CA RECEIPT OF PLANNING Sightlines not in place 110m SW Of 84 Corbo Road Cattor Seskinore Tyrone BT78 APPLICATION 1UU

K/2014/0049/CA ENFORCEMENT ACTION BEING Lagoon Land Adjacent To And 200m North Of 14 Mullawinny PURSUED Road Mullawinny Fintona Tyrone BT78 2LX

K/2014/0051/CA NEGOTIATE TO RESOLVE Breach of condition no. 01 (use of 81 Tattysallagh Road Clanabogan Lower Drumquin Tyrone BT78 building) of planning approval 3BS K/2011/0496/F

K/2014/0064/CA NEGOTIATE TO RESOLVE Breach of Condition no. 01 of Approx. 170m North East Of 11 Blackhill K/2008/0515/RM Road Cornamucklagh Dromore Tyrone BT78 3HL

K/2014/0073/CA NEGOTIATE TO RESOLVE Wind turbine erected without Approx 240m North Of 16 Castleroddy planning permission Road Dunbreen Omagh Tyrone BT79 7UA

K/2014/0084/CA Assessment of Enforcement Alleged unauthorised Gym/Boxing Sheds To The Rear Of 16A Case Club, Mechanics and Hydro Road Gortmore Omagh Tyrone BT78 5DR Coating Business K/2014/0085/CA Assessment of Enforcement Fuel sales 180 Donaghanie Road Donaghanie Omagh Tyrone BT79 0XE Case

K/2014/0086/CA NEGOTIATE TO RESOLVE Depositing of waste Omagh Acad Rugby Football Club Mellon Park Drive Conywarren Omagh Tyrone BT78 5NE

K/2014/0088/CA New Enforcement Case Breach of condition nos 06 (earth Land To The South Of 134 Termon bund), 07 (earth bund/wall), 08 Road Aghnanereagh Pomeroy Tyrone BT79 9HW (landscaping) and 09 (earth K/2014/0092/CA Assessment of Enforcement Breach of condition No. 02 (depth Halifax UK 22 High Street Omagh Tyrone BT78 1BQ Case of fascia) of K/2013/0084/A

K/2015/0001/CA NEGOTIATE TO RESOLVE Unauthorised excavation 1 Brookmount Crescent Gortmore Omagh Tyrone BT78 5HG removing front garden and boundary wall K/2015/0003/CA NEGOTIATE TO RESOLVE Unauthorised Floodlighting Radergan Road Altcloghfin Garvaghy Tyrone BT70 2EH

K/2015/0006/CA New Enforcement Case Oil tank erected on roof of Embankment Buildings Old Market Place Omagh Tyrone BT78 building 1BT

K/2015/0011/CA New Enforcement Case Anemometer 89 Barony Road, Mountifeld

K/2015/0012/CA New Enforcement Case Large Signage above frontage 54-56 High Street, Omagh although unit is still derelict

K/2015/0013/CA New Enforcement Case Removal of waste from alleged 17 Shinnagh Road Mullaslin Sixmilecross unauthorised quarry

K/2015/0014/CA New Enforcement Case pment has commenced controry 8 St Julians Cottages Omagh to condition 10 on decision notice K/2007/0439/F also condition 2 K/2015/0015/CA New Enforcement Case Unauthorised vehicular access To The Rear Of 3 Starrs opened to rear of property onto Crescent Meetinghousehill Omagh Tyrone BT78 1LY DRD maintained road/lane blocking car parking bays and K/2015/0016/CA New Enforcement Case Sign advertising 'HOT FOOD' Beltany Road Omagh obscuring vision at junction of main Road/ Castletown Road

K/2015/0018/CA New Enforcement Case 15 High Street Omagh Tyrone BT78 1BA

L/2005/0139CA Court Action Being Pursued Operational Devt Mullanshellistragh

L/2008/0062CA Draft Enforcement Notice Unpermitted Building Derryclavan,

L/2009/0064CA Court Action Being Pursued Unauthorised agricultural Trustan Glebe, Mackan, , Co. Fermanagh buildings and yard

L/2009/0160CA Assessment of Enforcement Operational Devt Galloon Gardens, Gortgommon, , BT92 8GT Case

L/2011/0028/CA NEGOTIATE TO RESOLVE Unauthorised change of use of 1 Enniskillen Road Lisbellaw Co Fermanagh garage to 2no. apartments and breach of condition No 2 of approval L/2006/2382 ( provision of sight lines) L/2011/0037/CA Court Action Being Pursued Breach of condition 2 of approval 47 Golf Village Belleek Road Enniskillen Co Fermanagh L/2004/2370/F (use of holiday chalet as permanent residence) L/2011/0055/CA RECEIPT OF PLANNING Alleged unauthorised recycling of Killyvilly, Tempo Road, Enniskillen APPLICATION end of life vehicles and scrap metals

L/2011/0065/CA Enforcement Notice Issued Unauthorised building Roscor Bridge Road, Belleek, Co Fermanagh

L/2012/0007/CA Seeking Developer Contacts Breach of condition 4 and 5 of Tullyullagh Tempo Co Fermanagh approval L/2006/0949/F

L/2012/0008/CA Warning Letter Issued Unauthorised storage of skips Lands At 27 Largy Road, Largy, Enniskillen and external processing of waste materials and erection of shed.

L/2012/0036/CA ENFORCEMENT ACTION BEING Change of use of domestic garage 81 Lough Shore Road Silverhill Enniskillen Fermanagh BT74 PURSUED and yard to vehicle valeting 5NH business

L/2012/0140/CA NEGOTIATE TO RESOLVE Change of use of agricultural land Corraquill Country to paint ball course Cottages Drumettagh Enniskillen Fermanagh BT92 9FT

L/2013/0017/CA RECEIPT OF PLANNING Unauthorised Builders Yard Site Approximately 100m South Of No. 62 Sheehinny Road, Derrylin, APPLICATION Fermanagh

L/2013/0024/CA Warning Letter Issued Removal of trees that were Site North Of Erneview House Derrylin Co Fermanagh conditioned to be retained and laneways on the land L/2013/0037/CA RECEIPT OF PLANNING Unauthorised Shed 82 Main Street Lisoneill Fermanagh BT92 0JD APPLICATION L/2013/0046/CA Seeking Developer Contacts Advertisement and flag pole Site Approx. 15m SE Of 2 Moorlough Road, Aghagay, Newtownbutler, County Fermanagh (on Roadside Bank)

L/2013/0053/CA ENFORCEMENT ACTION BEING Unauthorised change of use of Site North And East Of 72 Forthill Street (The Enniskillen Hotel), PURSUED land to storage and distribution Tonystick, Enniskillen, County Fermanagh, BT74 6AJ (Storage of Steel containers and vehicles on site)

L/2013/0062/CA NEGOTIATE TO RESOLVE Shed The Rigg Enniskillen Co Fermanagh BT74 5ED

L/2013/0067/CA ENFORCEMENT ACTION BEING Unauthorised shed and vehicle 50 Road Sessiagh West Enniskillen Fermanagh BT92 PURSUED repairs. 2DH L/2013/0095/CA Warning Letter Issued Visibility splays not in place 28 Letterboy Road Ederny Kesh Fermanagh BT93 0EF L/2013/0098/CA RECEIPT OF PLANNING Signage Clarke's Drive Thru' Fuel Depot, 207 APPLICATION Road Kinoughtragh Derrylin Enniskillen County Fermanagh BT92 9QF L/2013/0100/CA NEGOTIATE TO RESOLVE Breach of condition 3, Condition 4 Corry Belleek Co Fermanagh and Condition 6 of L/2011/0524/F

L/2013/0114/CA NEGOTIATE TO RESOLVE Breach of condition 2 of Lands 300m NE Of 'The Cranny'152 Derrylin L/2012/0767/F Road Enniskillen Fermanagh BT92 2BA L/2014/0008/CA NEGOTIATE TO RESOLVE Disposal of waste material Site Approximately 130m South West Of 4 Castle I rvine Road, Castle I rvine Demesne, , County Fermanagh, BT94 1EB

L/2014/0011/CA NEGOTIATE TO RESOLVE Unauthorised Marina Marina I mmediately North Of 'Moorings Marina' 152 Derrylin Road Bellanaleck Enniskillen Fermanagh BT92 2BA L/2014/0014/CA RECEIPT OF PLANNING Building 2 Killyvilly Grove Killyvilly Enniskillen Fermanagh BT74 4DR APPLICATION L/2014/0016/CA NEGOTIATE TO RESOLVE Erection of 3 agricultural sheds Land Immediately NW To NE Of 25 Scardans Road Larkhill Belleek Fermanagh BT93 2BP L/2014/0017/CA NEGOTIATE TO RESOLVE Car breakers Kilgarrow Newtownbutler Co Fermanagh L/2014/0018/CA NEGOTIATE TO RESOLVE Alleged unauthroised dwelling Kilgarrow Newtownbutler Co Fermanagh L/2014/0021/CA NEGOTIATE TO RESOLVE Change of use of land / buildings 100m East Of 214 Gardiners Cross to builders yard / storage Road Drumderg Fermanagh BT94 3JL compound L/2014/0024/CA Assessment of Enforcement Commencement of Development Adjacent To 70 Drumshimuck Case Road Drumlught Derrylin Enniskillen Fermanagh BT92 9BD

L/2014/0025/CA NEGOTIATE TO RESOLVE Alleged unauthorised extension to Site Adjacenet To 74 Church Hill dwelling Road Bunnahone Enniskillen Fermanagh BT93 6BP L/2014/0026/CA NEGOTIATE TO RESOLVE Alleged unauthorised agricultural Craghan Road Craghan Fermanagh BT94 2BT Shed L/2014/0029/CA NEGOTIATE TO RESOLVE Alleged unauthorised agricultural Site To The East Of 108 Greenhill shed under construction Road Currin Maguiresbridge Fermanagh BT94 4QD

L/2014/0030/CA NEGOTIATE TO RESOLVE Access arrangements not West Of Coolyermer Lough Co Fermanagh complied with L/2014/0032/CA NEGOTIATE TO RESOLVE Infilling of the lough Dixon's Marina Slee Inishmore Lisbellaw Co Fermanagh L/2014/0035/CA NEGOTIATE TO RESOLVE Alleged unauthorised car breaking Road (Mc Govern's Old Garage) Derrylin Co Fermanagh facility L/2014/0037/CA NEGOTIATE TO RESOLVE Unauthorised access Adjacent To 168 Tullyreagh Road Tempo Co Fermanagh BT94 3PJ

L/2014/0040/CA RECEIPT OF PLANNING Change of use of land to vehicle Site To The Rear Of 1-10 Kinarla APPLICATION recovery yard Court Silverhill Enniskillen Fermanagh BT74 5JA L/2014/0041/CA NEGOTIATE TO RESOLVE Breach of conditions 1 and 2 of Lands At 33 Main Street Drumhaw Lisnaskea Fermanagh BT92 L/2011/0777/F 0JB L/2014/0042/CA NEGOTIATE TO RESOLVE Unauthorised Agricultural Shed 94 Farnamullan Road Farnamullan Lisbellaw Lisbellaw Fermanagh BT94 5EA

L/2014/0043/CA Assessment of Enforcement Alleged unauthorised vehicular Lough Shore Road Corry Belleek Fermanagh BT93 3FU Case access L/2014/0045/CA Assessment of Enforcement Alleged unauthorised cattle yard, Cules Road Irvinestown Co Fermanagh BT94 1AX Case concrete base and walls L/2014/0046/CA Assessment of Enforcement Works not in accordance with 1 Cornagrade Terrace Cornagrade Enniskillen Fermanagh BT74 Case approved plans (L/2012/0331/F) 6DS

L/2014/0049/CA NEGOTIATE TO RESOLVE Vehicular access and landscaping Drumbadreevagh Belleek Co Fermanagh

L/2014/0050/CA NEGOTIATE TO RESOLVE Alleged unauthorised scrapyard 130 Coa Road Woaghternerry Enniskillen Co Fermanagh BT74 4AD L/2014/0053/CA Assessment of Enforcement Alleged unauthorised access to a Gortnalee Derrygonnelly Road Co Fermanagh Case dwelling L/2014/0056/CA NEGOTIATE TO RESOLVE Alleged unauthorised dumping of Rossory Church Road Enniskillen Co Fermanagh materials and new access L/2014/0058/CA NEGOTIATE TO RESOLVE Alleged unauthorised access Killykeeran Brookborough Co Fermanagh L/2014/0060/CA Assessment of Enforcement Alleged unauthorised shed 9A Tully Road Tully Fermanagh BT94 1RE Case L/2014/0064/CA Assessment of Enforcement Alleged unauthorised replacement Drumadravy Road Coolaness Irvinestown Co Fermanagh Case piggery and extension to premises

L/2014/0065/CA NEGOTIATE TO RESOLVE Non compliance with pre Land 40m North Of 50 Cornagrade commencement conditions 8, 9, Road Kilmacormick Enniskillen Fermanagh BT74 6DX 12, 13 and 16 of L/2008/0394/F

L/2014/0066/CA Assessment of Enforcement Alleged unauthorised livery Kinmore Road Kinmore Lisnaskea Co Fermanagh Case business L/2014/0067/CA Assessment of Enforcement Alleged unauthorised agricultural Adjacent To 26 Derryhoney Road Lisbellaw Co Fermanagh Case shed L/2014/0068/CA Assessment of Enforcement Alleged unauthorised removal of Land At Irvinestown Road Cherrymount Enniskillen Co Fermanagh Case trees L/2014/0070/CA NEGOTIATE TO RESOLVE Unauthorised Development - Belcoo Quarry, Bohoo Road, Belcoo Co Fermanagh (1) Drilling of Boreholes (2) Erection of a fence

L/2014/0072/CA NEGOTIATE TO RESOLVE Parking and servicing conditions Toddle In Day Nursery 1-3 Corporation not adhered to Street Tonystick Enniskillen Fermanagh BT74 6AF L/2014/0074/CA Assessment of Enforcement Dumping of waste materials Quarry At Gardrum Road Belcoo Co Fermanagh Case L/2014/0076/CA NEGOTIATE TO RESOLVE Unauthorised works at the site Acres And Droles Road Mullaghkippen Lisbellaw Co Fermanagh

L/2014/0079/CA Assessment of Enforcement Unauthorised wall 40 Main Street Aghagay Newtownbutler Fermanagh BT92 8JW Case L/2014/0081/CA Assessment of Enforcement Breach of Condiions 10 and 11 of Land To The Rear Of 148-164 Aghintain Road Camgart Case L/2007/1161/F (visibility splays not in place) L/2014/0083/CA NEGOTIATE TO RESOLVE Unauthorised decking To The Rear Of No.16 Hollybank Kilmacrannell Castle Balfour Demesne Lisnaskea Fermanagh BT92 0HH L/2014/0085/CA Assessment of Enforcement Building Silverhill Enniskillen Co Fermanagh Case L/2014/0088/CA NEGOTIATE TO RESOLVE Slurry pits Lands Approx. 30m South East Of 103 Crevenish Road Crevenish Kesh Co Fermanagh BT93 1DD L/2014/0089/CA Assessment of Enforcement Unauthorised Dwelling 22 Tiraroe Road Tiraroe Derrylin Fermanagh BT92 9QU Case L/2014/0093/CA Assessment of Enforcement Access Belcoo East Belcoo Co Fermanagh BT93 5FN Case L/2014/0094/CA Assessment of Enforcement Dwelling not built as approved Approx 40m North Of 422 Lough Shore Case Road Legg Belleek Fermanagh BT93 3BP L/2014/0096/CA NEGOTIATE TO RESOLVE Unauthorised car park Land Opposite 8 Woodhill Cottages Derrynanny Enniskillen Fermanagh BT94 1QA L/2014/0097/CA Assessment of Enforcement Unauthorised building Rear Of 44 Rossmacaffry Case Road Rossbeg Lisnaskea Fermanagh BT92 0RA L/2014/0099/CA Assessment of Enforcement Motor vehicle repair business 192 Gardiners Cross Case Road Drumderg Maguiresbridge Fermanagh BT94 3JL L/2014/0100/CA Assessment of Enforcement Shed Dernish I sland Co Fermanagh Case L/2014/0101/CA Assessment of Enforcement Sale of animal food stuffs and 274 Lough Shore Road Cosbystown Belleek Fermanagh BT93 Case bouncy castle hire business 7ER L/2014/0107/CA Assessment of Enforcement Unauthorised hardcoring of land Adjacent To Tracey Conrete Old Rossorry Case (Extension to Tracey Concrete) Road Rossorry Enniskillen Fermanagh BT74 7LF

L/2014/0108/CA NEGOTIATE TO RESOLVE Unauthorised storage of vehicles Lands West Of 46 Crevenish Road Rosscolban Kesh Fermanagh BT93 1TF L/2014/0109/CA New Enforcement Case Hairdressing Salon Lands Approx. 170m SE Of 14 Killard Road Derrygennedy Newtownbutler Fermanagh BT92 8BF

L/2015/0002/CA Assessment of Enforcement Unauthorised Fences Chanterhill Park Moneynoe Glebe Or Case Chanterhill Enniskillen Fermanagh BT74 4BG L/2015/0004/CA NEGOTIATE TO RESOLVE Breach of Condition 3 relating to 100 M South East Of 109 Edenmore Road, Tempo noise emissions from turbine of L/2013/0575/F L/2015/0005/CA NEGOTIATE TO RESOLVE Alleged Breach of condition Approximately 40 Metres East Of 270 Tempo Road, Largy, Garvary, (Landscaping) Enniskillen BT94 3BH L/2015/0006/CA NEGOTIATE TO RESOLVE Development not built in Land Between 31C And 31D Main accordance with the Approval Street Townhill Irvinestown Fermanagh BT94 1GJ L/2015/0008/CA NEGOTIATE TO RESOLVE Operational development Mountdrum Cross Roads Tattygare Road Lisbellaw L/2015/0009/CA NEGOTIATE TO RESOLVE Unauthorised access to Land Adjacent To 119 Tempo Road, Enniskillen, Fermanagh BT74 gym/fitness business 4RH L/2015/0011/CA NEGOTIATE TO RESOLVE Change of Use to a Gymnasium Unit 8, Scaffog Business Park, 134 Road, Enniskillen trading as Dutchy Fitness

L/2015/0016/CA New Enforcement Case Change of use - Selling goods at Derrylin Primary School Main Street Derrylin Fermanagh BT92 old site of primary school 9LA L/2015/0017/CA Assessment of Enforcement Trees (TPO) Cut Down Glen Tempo Enniskillen Fermanagh BT94 3JW Case L/2015/0018/CA New Enforcement Case Erection of Conservatory 7 Tattygare Road Mountdrum Lisbellaw Fermanagh BT94 5GJ L/2015/0019/CA New Enforcement Case Non Compliance with condition 02 Adjacent To 35 Droles Road, Mullaghakippin, Lisbellaw Agri Storage only - Extension now used for Livestowck (Sheep) L/2014/0133/F

L/2015/0020/CA New Enforcement Case Stone Retaining Wall Corramore Garrison Enniskillen Fermanagh BT93 4AY Enforcement Reference Number PAC reference Appeal Type Proposal Location

The unauthorised use of land for the storage and sale of fuel making a material change of use of the said lands being development carried out without the Enforcement grant of planning 180 Donaghanie road, K/2014/0085/CA 2014/E0039 Notice permission required Omagh Tyrone Applicant Appeal Status

Awaiting case submission C/o Mr Douglas Kerr date