Study Guide Jewish Women in the Partisans
www.jewishpartisans.org Edited in Consultation with Shana Penn Jewish Women Partisans: held up police stations and stole their arsenals. “I was a fighter” They operated from hideouts made within wild, dense forests or mountainous terrain. This “I was a fighter, I was always a fighter. Jews did harsh, perilous, combat existence was ruled and not go like sheep to their slaughter,” emphasizes populated by men. partisan Eta Wrobel, who began her resistance activities immediately after Germany invaded Of the approximately 30,000 Jewish partisans who her native Poland in September 1939. “Fear was fought in both non-Jewish and Jewish resistance not in my dictionary!” declares Greek partisan units in German-occupied Europe, fewer than Sarah Fortis, who organized one of the only all- ten percent were women. Some performed roles female brigades to fight the Fascists in World traditionally assigned to women: they tended to the sick and the wounded, cooked for and fed the troops, and acted as decoys, smugglers and couriers. Arms-bearing women like Eta in Poland and Sarah in Greece were exceptions to the rule. Although their numbers were small and their duties often limited, women combined courage and savvy with sheer will and luck to become part of the vital infrastructure that sustained partisan movements across the war-torn continent. Despite the twin evils of antisemitic and sexist violence that threatened their survival, Jewish women partisans overcame the specific and compounded dangers they faced both as women and as Jews.
From Protected to Protector
The road to the partisans usually began in the ghettos and camps, where women were forced to develop strategies that could help them and their families survive. Some of these tactics departed Female Jewish resistance fighters War II. Women partisans like Eta Wrobel and from socially acceptable conventions, such as the in the forests near Pinsk, c. 1943 Source: USHMM Sarah Fortis recall their roles in the anti-Nazi smuggling of arms; others were extensions of the resistance with fierce pride. Their boldness is all traditional female caretaking role. Women of all the more remarkable given that women were not ages—mothers, sisters and daughters—used their readily welcomed into male-dominated partisan wits and their resources to find food, clothing, units. Guns were the law of the forest, and guns shelter, information, and valuable contacts for belonged to men. their families. Sonia Orbuch’s mother, for example, bribed a policeman with her wedding ring to The primary role of a partisan was to take up arms allow the family to escape the Luboml ghetto in and fight the enemy in guerilla-type warfare, Poland—today in Western Ukraine—in October focusing on military and strategic targets. 1942. Brenda Senders of Sarni, Poland, found Partisans killed Nazis and their local collaborators; refuge for a younger sister with a Christian farmer they disrupted transportation and communication and ensured her safety by warning the caretaker: lines to the war front. They dynamited railroad “My sister is the only one left from my family, Conforms to Common Core Standards tracks, enemy power plants and factories; they jewishpartisans.org/standards and you better take care of her. If you betray
1 FINLAND
NORWAY
ESTONIA
SWEDEN USSR
LATVIA DENMARK LITHUANIA Gertrude Boyarski Mira Shelub
PRUSSIA GREAT BRITAIN BELARUS NETHERLANDS (USSR)
BELGIUM GERMANY POLAND
(USSR) Eta Wrobel CZECHOSLOVAKIA Sonia Orbuch
FRANCE AUSTRIA SWITZERLAND HUNGARY
ROMANIA
YUGOSLAVIA
MarisaSPAIN Diena ITALY BULGARIA Brenda Senders
ALBANIA TURKEY GREECE
Sara Fortis
her, remember—I’ll come for revenge.” The sister This map depicts approximate partisan Some families made a point of teaching girls how activity of the women featured in this survived. Such strength of mind would well serve to conspire against the Nazis. In the Polish town study guide from 1942 to 1944. The borders of this map are from Europe in other women who subsequently made their way of Lokow, Eta Wrobel’s father, active in the Polish 1939, before the German/Soviet non- into partisan units. underground, taught his 18-year-old daughter aggression pact. survival tactics after her mother and six siblings On the whole, traditional gender roles made were killed in one of the first Nazi roundups of Additional Resources on it harder and thus less common for women to This Subject Jews in Poland. Eta recalls: “He instructed me to separate from their families and try to join the t help the underground resistance, and constantly partisans on their own. Women usually chose Find out more about these and other encouraged me. ‘Don’t be afraid. Only you can do Jewish partisan women—including to remain in the ghetto with their loved ones, profiles with video testimonials, it. I order you to survive.’ And that’s what I did.” photographs and short biographies: whether out of loyalty, fear, or lack of confidence www.jewishpartisans.org/women and skills. It was a hot August day in 1942, when t the Germans began rounding up the Jews of “Only boys can go!” Show the accompanying short film, the Sarni ghetto. In the midst of the gunshots, Every Day the Impossible: Women in the Partisans: killings, and mayhem, Brenda Senders’s mother Not all women were encouraged by their www.jewishpartisans.org/films pulled her daughter close: “Brenda, you must go families to risk escape and engage in clandestine t into hiding.” Brenda resisted, “Where am I going resistance. In October 1942, Meyer Orbuch was Take the Jewish Women in the to hide? No. Whatever will be with the family, will in the Luboml Ghetto in Poland. He had collected Partisans video course: guns and made plans to escape into the woods www.jewishpartisans.org/elearning be with me.” But her mother insisted, “No, maybe one of us will survive.” So at her mother’s urging, with several other young men. His mother begged Brenda was emboldened to escape and take her Meyer to take his older sister, Sonia, along. Meyer younger sister with her. refused, explaining that, “No girls can go with us. Only boys can go!” Meyer went to the forest, and Sonia remained with her family in the ghetto. In
2 such instances, women who might have wanted take you in.” In lieu of arms, Brenda brought a to run could not, and often were murdered keen familiarity with the local forests; she also together with their families. However, in Sonia’s knew some of the Christian inhabitants, who had case, she and the rest of her family managed a done business with her family and could supply treacherous flight during the final destruction the partisans with food and shelter. Her father, a of the ghetto and went into forester, had shared his knowledge and love of the hiding. woods with her when she was growing up, and Brenda used this knowledge to beg her way into a Other families attempted Soviet unit: “Take me in. I want to fight.” to escape the ghettos and stay together. Mira Shelub Sonia Orbuch and her family were admitted into a and her family fled the Soviet partisan unit on the Ukrainian border, but Zdziedociol Ghetto in Poland Sonia says they would have been turned away if 1942, just as the Germans her Uncle Tzvi had not been with them. Tzvi had began killing off the ghetto been a scout in the Polish underground and could population. Fifteen year-old offer the Soviets his reconnaissance skills. That Sarah Fortis and her mother knowledge saved Sonia, Tzvi, and her parents. traveled a 12-hour journey by donkey to a remote village But skilled or not, the partisans mainly regarded in Greece, as the German Jews as liabilities, not as resources, because occupied their beautiful the presence of Jews threatened the security hometown of Chalkis. Marisa of the secret combat units. The Nazis and their Diena followed her partisan collaborators hunted runaway Jews tenaciously. brother to a hideout in the Local populations, though they might be loyal Italian mountains, where to the partisans, would often betray Jews in she eventually trained exchange for food or other bribes. Some partisan other young women in units preferred to kill Jews rather than harbor Sarah Fortis poses for a photo in them, due to their own antisemitic beliefs. her Greek partisan uniform Date reconnaissance activities. In unknown. Source: JPEF. each instance, women fled with family when no options other than death stood before them. “The Highest Priority Was To Save Jewish Lives”
With the Partisans: Jews and Mira Shelub recounts that antisemitism in Women “Unfit for Battle” partisan units was a threat to Jewish survival Jewish men and women faced a whole new set of and led to the creation of all-Jewish camps. Her challenges once they made contact with partisan husband Nochim, whom she met in a Soviet unit, groups. Many Eastern European units, composed established one such camp in eastern Poland. of ex-Soviet soldiers who were escaped prisoners All-Jewish units, while fewer in number, accepted of war and male anti-Fascists from native Jewish women readily. These units often shared a populations, did not accept Jewish fugitives. They dual purpose: to rescue fellow Jews unconditionally were even less likely to accept women. For Jews and to sabotage the enemy. “The highest priority to join these units, they had to find their own was to survive and save Jewish lives,” emphasizes weapons and ammunition or bring special skills Eta Wrobel, who helped form a Jewish unit in such as communications, medicine, or knowledge central Poland in October 1942. “Sure, we wanted of local geography. But the Jews who ran to the to disturb the Germans so they shouldn’t have forests were civilians, not soldiers, and arrived at it easy, but I think saving Jews was the most a partisan camp with little more than the scant important work. It was my work. In a year and a possessions they could carry when they had fled. half, we saved about a hundred people.” Considered too weak, unskilled, and inferior to be Saving Jewish lives was a priority for Jewish fighters, Jews were seen as burdens to the unit— partisan groups, which is why one in four of their and Jewish women were seen as double burdens. inhabitants were women, compared to the one Brenda Senders understood that, “The partisans in fifty in non-Jewish units. In Ukraine’s Naliboki expect you to bring ammunitions, or they won’t Forest, The Bielski Brigade set up family camps for
3 women, children, and the elderly. From 1942 until you into the unit,” a friend of Gertrude’s father Discussion Questions the end of the war, the Bielski camp provided propositioned her. She refused his offer and refuge to more than 1,200 Jews, who assisted instead stood guard duty as an admissions test, 1. Which of the women in in military operations or repaired weapons, succeeding in joining the partisan group on her the study guide or film did made clothing and cooked for the fighters. own. you relate to most? Why? Did Women made up 30 to 40 percent of the Bielski she remind you of someone “It was difficult for a woman in a predominantly population. you know? What was your male organization to avoid propositions and connection? Sadly, the very advantage of family camps proved advances by male partisans,” Mira Shelub to be their weakest point. By being stationary acknowledges. “The female population was 2. What were the additional and admitting everyone regardless of gender, small. Men wanted sweethearts. I was lucky obstacles that Jewish women age, or physical ability, family camps became enough to be protected by my parents. That had to overcome in order to vulnerable to exposure and attack from both the made all the difference.” Mira explains that some join a partisan group? Which German troops and local people, who shared the women willingly “chose an officer” because the of these obstacles do you think Nazis hatred of Jews. Gertrude Boyarski’s mother relationship offered protection and privileges, would be most difficult to and younger siblings lived in a family camp such as relief from combat assignments, larger overcome? Why? while Gertrude, her father, and an older brother food rations, and more comfortable living lived nearby among the partisan units. Gertrude quarters. A man could buy a woman food, 3. What were some of the recalls the last time she visited her mother in clothing, and shelter for her and her family. In a factors that helped Jewish women become partisans? the family camp. A surprise attack by local Nazi raid, a man with a gun could protect a woman collaborators killed many unarmed members of and her family. the camp, including Gertrude’s mother. Lucky to 4. Which, in your opinion, is survive the raid, Gertrude ran through the forest Those women who didn’t pair off with men feared more accurate: Jewish women were bound by and played to her father’s unit, where she remained until the the consequences of their decision to remain unattached. They had no one to help them carry traditional female roles as end of the war. partisans, or: Jewish women the heavy loads of wood and water, or prepare broke with conventions and the huge campfires for cooking the partisans’ stereotypes as partisans. Cite Women and Men: “Select meals. Serious problems could result if the examples from the text to an officer, life will go better food was not ready on time, and it became an support your argument. for you” enormous source of stress for single women, as Sonia Orbuch recounts. Every morning, she and 5. What is the poem “Tanya” The double threats of antisemitism and sexism the other women were given two short hours to (page 8) an account of? seemed a never-ending consequence of the war. “carry water, chop the wood, build a fire, prepare How did Tanya’s path to the Jewish women faced the constant danger of the food, cut, cook, and clean up. If I had no one partisans differ from the other accounts you have read? Why sexual abuse, rape, and forced abortion in the to help me, it was impossible to do the work in wasn’t Tanya’s name honored ghettos and camps, where they were targeted two hours… We always worried that if we were after the war? by the Nazis as breeders of an inferior race that not able to perform, we will be thrown out of had to be exterminated. The trail of physical the partisans. So you had to deal with it.” Sonia 6. Do you think that Jewish and sexual violence followed women into weathered frostbite, hunger, and the loss of her women partisans were ordinary the resistance units. Many found themselves loved ones in order to prove her worth and be or extraordinary women – or cornered and coerced by partisan men, who accepted by the Soviet partisans. both? In other words, was there were demanding sexual favors in exchange for something unique about these protection. An estimated 60 percent of the adults in the individuals that enabled them Bielski partisan group lived as couples, and to become partisans or were Sonia Orbuch remembers being horror-struck some of the relationships, like Mira’s marriage they simply ordinary people when the commander’s wife took her aside for a to partisan leader Nochim Shelub, would last a in an extraordinary time. Support your argument with a private conversation soon after her family arrived lifetime. Other women coupled with men from statement from the text. in the Soviet camp: “You’re a young girl, there very different religious and class backgrounds— are very few women in the partisans, and I would men whom they would never have met or chosen advise you to select an officer. Life will go better in a peacetime situation. for you,” the woman said. Many women, however, had relationships forced The women who were the most vulnerable were on them, especially in non-Jewish units. Though those who operated alone and were usually it was rarely discussed openly, women had to face young and unmarried. “Be my wife and I will get the bitter irony that some of them had escaped
4 the Nazis only to be threatened with rape or especially a Jewish man, whose identity could be Discussion Questions murder at the hands of partisans in non-Jewish readily exposed. Because circumcision in Europe for the Film Every groups. occurred almost exclusively among Jewish men, Day the Impossible: their true identities could be easily revealed. The Jewish Women in the Partisans Not all partisan environs were dangerous for partisan units recognized and benefited from this women, and some camps punished rape severely. fact. In the Soviet camp where Gertrude Boyarski 1. In her interview, Eta Wrobel worked, the commander protected women from When young Marisa Diena became the Vice- said: “I was born a fighter. I sexual assault as part of his overall effort to Commander of Information Services in an Italian was free.” What do you think impose greater discipline in the combat units. “He partisan group, she enlisted and trained peasant this means? How does being a told us to count on him for support,” she recalls. fighter connect with the idea After a Polish girl was raped, the commander of freedom? issued a swift punishment. The instigator of the assault was held before all the partisans, and 2. For what reasons do you after his crime was announced, he was shot on think women were more easily the spot. The commander’s warning to the other accepted into Jewish partisan men could not have been more clear. groups as opposed to non- Jewish ones? Once Jewish camps were formed, women became better protected against sexual coercion. Frank 3. Do you consider the actions Blaichman, leader of an all-Jewish unit, says he of the women partisans in this felt duty bound to protect the women. “There film to be extraordinary, or were many bullies in our group... But I would say simply what anyone in their circumstances would have to the women: ‘Don’t be afraid to say ‘No.’ And done if given the chance? I told the men, ‘If you want to have a girlfriend, Do you think the women in okay. But to abuse women and then go back on this film think of themselves the partnership—no, you can’t do this.’” as heroes, as survivors, or as something else? Why do you think so? Women’s Work: Caretakers and Couriers For a bibliography of sources related to this study guide Women played a variety of roles in both Jewish please go to: and non-Jewish groups, but primarily their jewishpartisans.org/sources partisan activities were extensions of their Sara Ginaite stands guard at the liberation of the Vilna ghetto, traditional caretaker roles. They were responsible 1944. Source: USHMM For more information please for feeding their entire unit, nursing the wounded contact: and the sick, setting up and breaking down camp, women to become courier messengers. “No one Jewish Partisan doing the laundry, and cleaning and carrying suspected their involvement…” Marisa explains. Educational Foundation weapons—vital duties that ensured a camp’s “We didn’t have all the things that a real army 2 0OST 3TREET survival, safety, and ability to function. has, like communications services. Instead, we had Suite the peasant girls, who could maintain connections San Francisco, CA 941 415-563-2244 (tel) Working in a makeshift hospital under the and pass information back and forth.” guidance of their only doctor, 17 year-old Sonia 415-563-2442 (fax) [email protected]