The Sikh Diaspora in Australia: Migration, Multiculturalism and the Imagining of Home
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
THE SIKH DIASPORA IN AUSTRALIA: MIGRATION, MULTICULTURALISM AND THE IMAGINING OF HOME by Rory G. McCarthy BA Anthropology, University of Maine, 1999 MA Anthropology, Western Michigan University, 2004 Submitted to the Graduate Faculty of the Dietrich School of Arts and Sciences in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy University of Pittsburgh 2013 UNIVERSITY OF PITTSBURGH DIETRICH SCHOOL OF ARTS AND SCIENCES This dissertation was presented by Rory G. McCarthy It was defended on March 1st, 2013 and approved by Dr. Clark Chilson, Assistant Professor, Religious Studies Dr. Nicole Constable, Professor, Anthropology Dr. Robert M. Hayden, Professor, Anthropology Dissertation Advisor: Dr. Joseph S. Alter, Professor, Anthropology ii THE SIKH DIASPORA IN AUSTRALIA: MIGRATION, MULTICULTURALISM AND THE IMAGINING OF HOME Rory G. McCarthy, PhD University of Pittsburgh, 2013 Copyright © by Rory G. McCarthy 2013 iii THE SIKH DIASPORA IN AUSTRALIA: MIGRATION, MULTICULTURALISM AND THE IMAGINING OF HOME Rory G. McCarthy, PhD University of Pittsburgh, 2013 When studying a diasporic population, understanding the relationship between dispersed peoples and their cultural homelands can be instructive. Scholars of diaspora have long understood that a relationship exists between a diaspora, and its place of origin. This dissertation approaches the question of connections between population and homeland from a perspective of emotion and nostalgia, asking how differing generations of Sikhs living in Australia think, talk and feel about their cultural homeland of Punjab. These connections to Punjab are filtered through shifting discourse on immigration and ideas of belonging that exist in Australia. Ethnographic research was conducted in Woolgoolga, New South Wales, Australia, over a period of nine months. Family migration narratives were collected from Sikhs living there, who were divided into two age groups- those 35 years of age and under, and those between the ages of 36 and 55. The purpose of this division is to replicate approximate generations of Sikhs, for the comparison of attitudes and experiences with Punjab. Informal and semi-structured interviews were conducted, and participant observation was done at Woolgoolga’s two Sikh gurdwaras, at meetings held during the organizational phase of a major Indian cultural festival, and at various activities and events held in town throughout the course of the field stay. Data collected shows that there is generational variation in the degree of emotional attachment to Punjab as a perceived cultural homeland. At the same time, there is generational difference in the understanding of recent political history in Punjab, and Sikh struggles for an independent state of iv Khalistan. Where older generations of Sikhs hold a much stronger connection to Punjab at the level of emotion and nostalgia, they tend to be more critical of the idea of an independent Sikh state. Conversely, younger generations of Sikhs demonstrate much less emotional connection to Punjab, and have little knowledge about the independence movement for Khalistan. Those who are familiar with the Khalistani movement have romanticized notions about the struggle, and are more likely to support claims that Sikhs are mistreated in India, and require their own state. v TABLE OF CONTENTS PREFACE ......................................................................................................................................X 1.0 CHAPTER ONE: INTRODUCTION ........................................................................ 1 1.1 SIKHISM AND ITS DIASPORA ....................................................................... 7 1.2 WOOLGOOLGA…A SNAP SHOT ................................................................ 11 1.3 THEORETICAL CONSIDERATIONS .......................................................... 14 1.4 CHAPTER ORGANIZATION......................................................................... 21 1.5 CONCLUSIONS ................................................................................................ 27 2.0 CHAPTER TWO: THEORETICAL AND HISTORICAL BACKGROUND ..... 29 2.1 DIASPORA ........................................................................................................ 30 2.2 SOUTH ASIAN OR SIKH DIASPORA .......................................................... 43 2.3 MASCULINTY, VICTIMHOOD OR ORIGINS? ......................................... 47 2.4 NOSTALGIA, MEMORY AND THE DIASPORIC SUBLIME .................. 51 2.5 “KHALISTAN”: TERRITORIAL, HISTORICAL AND POLITICAL ORIGINS ............................................................................................................................. 55 2.5.1 Origins of Territorial Linkage...................................................................... 57 2.5.2 Political Influences: From Azad Punjab to Punjabi Suba ......................... 59 2.5.3 Political Influences: From Azad Punjab to Punjabi Suba ......................... 63 2.6 CONCLUSIONS ................................................................................................ 67 vi 3.0 CHAPTER THREE: MIGRATION TO TELIA- SIKHS IN “WHITE AUSTRALIA” ............................................................................................................................. 69 3.1 IMMIGRATION PRIOR TO FEDERATION ............................................... 71 3.1.1 Australian Labor Needs ................................................................................ 71 3.1.2 Australian Labor Needs ................................................................................ 73 3.1.3 Indian and Anti-Asian Sentiment ................................................................ 75 3.1.4 “Grandfather” Tales ..................................................................................... 77 3.2 FEDERATION AND ‘WHITE AUSTRALIA’ ............................................... 79 3.3 THE ‘THIRD PHASE’ OF INDIAN IMMIGRATION ................................. 83 3.3.1 Woolgoolga during the Third Phase ............................................................ 85 3.3.2 Woolgoolga experiences its own “Second Phase” ....................................... 87 3.3.3 Sikh Firsts in Woolgoolga ............................................................................. 89 3.4 CONCLUSIONS ................................................................................................ 93 4.0 CHAPTER FOUR: MUTLICULTURALISM IN AUSTRALIA .......................... 95 4.1 MULTICULTURALISM CONCEPTUALIZED ........................................... 97 4.1.1 Multiculturalism and its Iterations .............................................................. 97 4.1.2 Conservative Multiculturalism ..................................................................... 98 4.1.3 Liberal Multiculturalism .............................................................................. 99 4.1.4 Plural Multiculturalism .............................................................................. 100 4.2 MULTICULTURALISM IN AUSTRALIA: A HISTORY ......................... 103 4.2.1 Early Factors ................................................................................................ 104 4.2.2 Multiculturalism Emerges .......................................................................... 107 4.2.3 Immigration Nation ..................................................................................... 111 vii 4.2.4 Community Language Programs ............................................................... 113 4.2.5 Resistance to Multiculturalism ................................................................... 115 4.3 WOOLGOOLGA IN AN AGE OF MULTICULTURALISM ................... 118 4.3.1 The Tale of Two Temples ............................................................................ 119 4.3.2 Factionalism ................................................................................................. 121 4.3.3 Changing Agricultural Landscape ............................................................. 125 4.4 CONCLUSIONS .............................................................................................. 129 5.0 CHAPTER FIVE: UNDERSTANDING HOMELANDS-CROSS- GENERATIONAL MEANING IN A DIASPORA ................................................................ 132 5.1 THEORETICAL ORIENTATION ................................................................ 134 5.1.1 Cosmopolitan Australian Sikhs .................................................................. 134 5.1.2 (bi)local Australian Sikhs ............................................................................ 136 5.1.3 Transnational Labor Migrant .................................................................... 137 5.2 ONE MAN’S STORY OF NOSTALGIA ...................................................... 138 5.2.1 Jorahvar’s Story .......................................................................................... 138 5.3 OTHER REFLECTIONS ON PUNJAB ....................................................... 150 5.4 PUNJAB IS A FILTHY, STINKY PLACE ................................................... 153 5.4.1 Population and pollution ............................................................................. 154 5.5 INDIAN POLITICS AND THE GENERATION GAP ................................ 158 5.5.1 Living Through A Crisis ............................................................................. 159 5.5.2 Sons of the Village React: “It was us bearded people…” .......................