This petition has collected 460 signatures using the online tools at iPetitions.com

Printed on 09-30-2011

Page 1 of 37 Save Clyne Valley

Sponsored by: This petition has been devised by the Killay Residents Action Group. The Group was organised in response to the local authority's submission Clyne Valley Country Park as an LDP candidate sites for residential use.

About the petition

Re Local Development Plan (LDP) KS 001, ward, . As part of the LDP process, the City and County of Swansea has proposed TWO candidate sites in Clyne Valley Country Park for residential development. Both areas are currently designated as Green Wedge, and are next to other areas of Clyne Valley Country Park which are designated as Areas of Outstanding Natural Beauty.

This particular petition concerns ONLY the Killay site, KS001. DO NOT USE THIS PETITION IF YOU HAVE ALREADY SIGNED THE PAPER PETITION as it is worded the same as this one.

See links also for: Further details are available at http://www.saveclynevalley.co.uk/ and via the emailing group at http://groups.google.com/group/save-clyne-valley

WE WISH THE CITY AND COUNTY OF SWANSEA TO WITHDRAW IMMEDIATELY THIS SITE FROM THE ABOVE LDP AND RETAIN ITS STATUS AS GREEN WEDGE/COUNTRY PARK

Page 2 of 37 Signatures

1. Name: David Thomas on Aug 10, 2011 Address: 4 Clyne Valley Cottages, Killay, Swansea, SA2 7DU Comments: Save our countryside.

2. Name: Joe Watkins on Aug 10, 2011 Address: Swansea Comments:

3. Name: J. Watkins on Aug 10, 2011 Address: Swansea Comments:

4. Name: Lily Green on Aug 10, 2011 Address: 1 Hillside Lane, Frampton Cotterell, , Bs36 2hz Comments:

5. Name: Mr William Jason Bevan on Aug 10, 2011 Address: 54 Erw Non Llannon Comments: Save a beautiful woodland enjoyed by many and with such diverse wildlife...

6. Name: Ash Price on Aug 10, 2011 Address: 42 Malvern Terrace, Brynmill, Safety Comments:

7. Name: Michaela Spurling on Aug 10, 2011 Address: Milton Keynes Comments:

8. Name: Anonymous on Aug 10, 2011 Address: 57 Pant-y-Dwr Three Crosses Comments:

9. Name: Barbara Parry on Aug 10, 2011 Address: 127 Broadmead, , SA2 7RJ Comments:

10. Name: Mike Moores on Aug 10, 2011 Address: 1 stepney road, , swansea Comments:

11. Name: Alwyn Jones on Aug 10, 2011 Address: 1, ffordd dryden, killay, swansea, Comments: swansea council appear to be overly keen to push ahead with plans to use designated green wedge areas as designated developement sites. The Killay area has not got the resources to cope with the consequences of such high numbers of new dwellings and the resulting massive hike in population.

12. Name: Bettina Dooley on Aug 10, 2011 Address: 16 conifer close, kirkby , , l33 1us Comments:

13. Name: Nesta Thomas on Aug 10, 2011 Address: 14 Warwick Rd, , Swansea, SA2 8DY Comments:

Page 3 of 37 14. Name: Anonymous on Aug 10, 2011 Address: 6 Warwick Rd Swansea Comments:

15. Name: Jessica Lloyd on Aug 10, 2011 Address: 19 Heol -y - Nant, Caewern, Neath Comments:

16. Name: Paul Reynolds on Aug 10, 2011 Address: 87 Gabalfa Rd, SA2 8ND Comments:

17. Name: Anonymous on Aug 10, 2011 Address: 51 Morris Lane, St Thomas, Swansea, SA1 8AU Comments:

18. Name: Victoria Jones on Aug 10, 2011 Address: 497 Road, Killay, Swansea. SA2 7DY Comments:

19. Name: Nicola Thomas on Aug 10, 2011 Address: 12 Mulberry Ave, West Cross, Swansea, SA3 5HD Comments:

20. Name: Alan Jones on Aug 10, 2011 Address: 7 ddol rd dunvant swansea sa2 7ub Comments:

21. Name: Luke Hanson on Aug 10, 2011 Address: 29 Seaview Tce, sa16ff Comments: I deeply disagree with this development!!!!

22. Name: Keith M Ross on Aug 10, 2011 Address: 2 Francis Street, Brynmill, Swansea, SA1 4NH Comments:

23. Name: J. Sherlock on Aug 11, 2011 Address: Sketty, Swansea Comments: Came across this tranquil space about twenty years ago - travesty to develop it. It's an oasis.

24. Name: Paul Brain on Aug 11, 2011 Address: 8, Landor Drive, Loughor, SA4 6GL Comments: Too much of an encroachment into a wildlife 'hotspot'

25. Name: Christine Gallon on Aug 11, 2011 Address: 6 Cae Bryn Avenue Comments: Swansea has enough redundant buildings and we need the green spaces

26. Name: Caroline Copner on Aug 11, 2011 Address: Ennistymon co Clare ireland Comments:

27. Name: Wendy Harris on Aug 11, 2011 Address: 16 Maes y Parc, Swansea Comments:

28. Name: Gary Gregor on Aug 11, 2011

Page 4 of 37 Address: 36 Eastmoor Park Crescent, West Cross, Swansea Comments: A superb area for walkers, runners and dog walkers. If part of it is gobbled up for housing development that cannot be reversed.

29. Name: Lea Cohen Sanchez on Aug 11, 2011 Address: Ty Beck BHD 2.3, Sketty Road, 16-26 SA2 0NG Comments:

30. Name: Caleala Clifford on Aug 11, 2011 Address: 19 Cromwell St, Mount Pleasant, Swansea Comments:

31. Name: Professor Rory Wilson on Aug 11, 2011 Address: Biosciences, Swansea University Comments:

32. Name: Olivia Dunn on Aug 11, 2011 Address: 21 stanley terrace swansea Comments:

33. Name: Michael Victor Thomas on Aug 11, 2011 Address: 29 ger-y-castell Kidwelly Dyfed SA17 4TT Comments:

34. Name: Paul Seacombe on Aug 11, 2011 Address: 52 Clarence Court, Swansea, SA1 3QY Comments:

35. Name: Glynis Williamson on Aug 11, 2011 Address: 10 Brynau Drive, Swansea Comments: Clyne Valley Country Park is a tremendously valuable site for all the people of Swansea for their recreational use and for visitors to Swansea, It is a link from the forshore into the countryside which forms a natural corridor for wildlife. It is a heritage which if it is used for building purposes is lost to future generations. We need to preserve it.

36. Name: Anonymous on Aug 11, 2011 Address: 29 Nicholl Street, Swansea, SA1 4HF Comments:

37. Name: M.Burrows. on Aug 11, 2011 Address: 15.Northeron.West Cross.SA35PJ. Comments:

38. Name: Maggie Jones on Aug 11, 2011 Address: 115 Heol Hafdy Swansea Comments:

39. Name: Kathryn Jenkinson on Aug 11, 2011 Address: kidwelly Comments:

40. Name: David Finan on Aug 11, 2011 Address: 15 Nash close, Houghton Regis, Bedfordshire, LU5 5SS Comments: Save Clyne Valley, an area of such beauty.

41. Name: Megan Woodhouse on Aug 12, 2011 Address: 48 Eversley Road Comments:

42. Name: Maryrose Jones on Aug 13, 2011

Page 5 of 37 Address: 10 Byng Street, Comments:

43. Name: Cynthia Mumford on Aug 13, 2011 Address: 66 Bryn Road, Waunarlwydd, Swansea, SA5 4RB Comments:

44. Name: Sue Butler on Aug 14, 2011 Address: 12 Murton Lane, Newton, SA3 4TR Comments:

45. Name: Michael Isaac on Aug 15, 2011 Address: 45A, Hendrefoilan Road, Tycoch, Swansea, SA2 9LT Comments:

46. Name: Dr Dan Forman on Aug 16, 2011 Address: 37 Rotherslade Road, Langland, Swansea, SA3 4QW Comments: As an experienced ecologists from Swansea University I have been involved in many projects in the Clyne Valley. This site is home to breeding otters, breeding polecats ( a section 42 species in ), several species of bats, kingfishers, bullfinches, and many, many other protected species. It is vital that this green corridor be maintained to ensure that the WA and LA can hit its biodiversity targets set by Europe.

47. Name: Daniel Taylor on Aug 16, 2011 Address: 206, Avenue, Townhill Comments:

48. Name: Amy Moores on Aug 17, 2011 Address: 1 Stepney Road, Waunarlwydd, Swansea, Sa5 4ta Comments:

49. Name: Michael Moores on Aug 17, 2011 Address: 1, stepney road, waunarlwydd, Swansea, SA5 4TA Comments:

50. Name: Neven Korashi on Aug 17, 2011 Address: 2 Carnglas Road, Sketty, Swansea, SA2 9BJ Comments:

51. Name: Paul De Vall on Aug 18, 2011 Address: 48 Manselfield Road Comments:

52. Name: Howard Bills on Aug 18, 2011 Address: 10 warwick road, derwen fawr, swansea, sa2 8dz Comments:

53. Name: Christos on Aug 19, 2011 Address: 26, Exley av. Comments:

54. Name: Jem Wade on Aug 19, 2011 Address: 13 goodeve park hazel wood rd bristol Comments:

55. Name: Patricia Hixson on Aug 19, 2011 Address: 33 Glen Road, west cross Comments:

56. Name: Rosie Loveridge on Aug 19, 2011

Page 6 of 37 Address: 26 Exley Avenue, Sheffield S6 2WH Comments:

57. Name: Carol Thomas on Aug 19, 2011 Address: 491 gower road, killay, swansea Comments:

58. Name: ROGER L. DAVIES on Aug 19, 2011 Address: 33 TWYNI TEG. KILLAY, SWANSEA Comments:

59. Name: Jamie Hogg on Aug 19, 2011 Address: The House, Llys Nini Animal Centre, , Swansea, SA49WB Comments: Please save this place as I use it with my children.

60. Name: Kelvin Childs on Aug 20, 2011 Address: 61 Woodcote, Killay Comments:

61. Name: Kerry Matthews on Aug 20, 2011 Address: 2 clos yr allt. Comments:

62. Name: Teresa De Vall on Aug 20, 2011 Address: 48, Manselfield Road, Murton, Swansea. Comments:

63. Name: Dr Sharon Gibbs on Aug 20, 2011 Address: 81 Addison Road, Guildford, Surrey GU1 3QE Comments:

64. Name: Mary Hayman on Aug 20, 2011 Address: 11 field street lLandore Comments: It is really important to keep this area of woodland, with its remnants of old industry as a green artery in Swansea

65. Name: Ms M Poole on Aug 20, 2011 Address: Beaconsfield, Sketty, Swansea Comments: There are plenty of other spaces for houses in Swansea and indeed plenty of houses lying empty for years. Please keep this area of outstanding natural beauty as it is and not even think of turning it into a concrete jungle!

66. Name: Gary Stanley on Aug 20, 2011 Address: 34 Broadacre, Killay, Swansea. SA2 7RU Comments:

67. Name: Thea Nash on Aug 21, 2011 Address: heather cottage fainwood lane sa27hp Comments: plz plz don't do it coz its a lovely place to be

68. Name: Steve Roe on Aug 21, 2011 Address: 569, Gower Road, Upper Killay Comments:

69. Name: Alison Griffiths on Aug 21, 2011 Address: 569, Gower Road, Upper Killay Comments: I think the road infrastructure would be unable to cope with the additional traffic, The access road would not be suitable as it is already a dangerous junction. Also, I think that Killay would lose it's character.

70. Name: Henry Fleming on Aug 21, 2011 Address: 40 Marlborough Road, Swansea, SA2 0EA

Page 7 of 37 Comments:

71. Name: Jayne Loft on Aug 22, 2011 Address: 642 Gower Rd. Upper Killay Comments:

72. Name: Victoria Thomas on Aug 22, 2011 Address: 14 Woodcote, Killay, Swansea Comments:

73. Name: Patrick Thomas on Aug 22, 2011 Address: 14 Woodcote, Killay, Swansea, SA2 7AZ Comments:

74. Name: Hilary Bignell on Aug 22, 2011 Address: 46 Glanmor Park Road Sketty Comments:

75. Name: Jim Loft on Aug 22, 2011 Address: 642, Gower Road, Upper Killay, Swansea SA2 7EX Comments: Using existing public green space to build houses is not what the the people of Swansea expect in 2011 and beyond. There is ample 'brown field' space within the Swansea area for housing development. Also, housing priority should be given to starter homes, witness the executive homes built on Gower Road near the Post Office that have remained empty and unsold for more than 5 years, a disgrace.

76. Name: Paul Gibbs on Aug 22, 2011 Address: 696 Gower Road Comments:

77. Name: Amparo Barrera on Aug 22, 2011 Address: 696 Gower Road Comments:

78. Name: Carlos Barrera on Aug 22, 2011 Address: 696 Gower road Comments:

79. Name: Joe Loft on Aug 23, 2011 Address: 642, Gower Road, Upper Killay, Swansea. SA2 7EX Comments:

80. Name: David Stephens on Aug 23, 2011 Address: 495 Gower Road, Killay, Swansea Comments: The City Council has quite correctly designated the Clyne Valley Country Park as a Green Wedge in its current Unitary Development Plan (UDP). Nothing has changed that would warrant a re-designation to residential land in the new Local Development Plan (LDP). Councillors! -Don't let us down!

81. Name: Dr J C Arnold on Aug 23, 2011 Address: Rose Cottage, Llanmadoc, Swansea Comments: Clyne Valley is a unique green space in the midst of an urban environment. I and my family have used it for many years for walking, running and exploring nature. The proposed developments would severely erode this wonderful part of the City.

82. Name: Sarah Reilly on Aug 23, 2011 Address: 5, The Mount, , SA4 3HA Comments:

83. Name: Simon Medicke on Aug 23, 2011 Address: 98 Gwelfor, Dunvant, Swansea. Comments: Maintaining green wedges and country parks such as Clyne is critical for our children and for our future, once they are gone they are gone forever, and surely be regretted by future councils. Also Killay, Sketty and Dunvant simply do not have roadway

Page 8 of 37 infrastructure to support this level of new homes. Gower Road is a nightmare for the commuter most days as it is.

84. Name: Anonymous on Aug 23, 2011 Address: 441 GOWER ROAD,KILLAY,SWANSEA Comments:

85. Name: Liz Johnsen on Aug 23, 2011 Address: 158 Hanover St, Swansea SA1 6BP Comments: Don't destroy Clyne

86. Name: Jacqueline Sohal on Aug 23, 2011 Address: 5 Penyrheol Drive, Sketty, SA2 9JT Comments:

87. Name: Barbara Sohal on Aug 23, 2011 Address: 5 Penyrheol Drive, Sketty, Swansea Comments:

88. Name: Jacqueline Sohal on Aug 23, 2011 Address: 5 Penyrheol Drive, Sketty, SA2 9JT Comments:

89. Name: Barbara Sohal on Aug 23, 2011 Address: 5 Penyrheol Drive, Sketty, Swansea Comments:

90. Name: Anonymous on Aug 23, 2011 Address: 5 cynoced close dunvant swansea Comments:

91. Name: Jeffrey Gleave on Aug 23, 2011 Address: 27 hen parc avenue, upper killay, swansea, sa2 7ha Comments:

92. Name: Harry Griffiths on Aug 23, 2011 Address: 569 gower road upper killay Comments:

93. Name: Katherine Forwood on Aug 23, 2011 Address: 39 oakridge, sketty Park Swansea Comments: keep the woods the way it is now, a place of beauty where everyone can enjoy.

94. Name: Anonymous on Aug 23, 2011 Address: 44 Woodcote, Killay, Swansea Comments:

95. Name: Andrew Pelosi on Aug 23, 2011 Address: Pelosi Comments: Swansea council are bowing to pressure that will ruin a beautiful area, Clyne, Bishopston etc. etc. What happened to the Green Belt!!!

96. Name: Roger Knight on Aug 24, 2011 Address: 20 Hen Parc Avenue, Upper Killay,Swansea Comments: Absolute sacrilege to even think of destroying this beautiful countryside. Access roads ,utilities and scholls will not be able to cope with this additional influx.

97. Name: Rhian Macnamara on Aug 24, 2011 Address: 80 Pantycelyn Road, Townhill, Swansea Comments:

Page 9 of 37 98. Name: Fran Hoksbergen on Aug 24, 2011 Address: 636 Gower Road Comments:

99. Name: Linda Foulis on Aug 24, 2011 Address: Red Deer, Alberta, Canada Comments: Our green areas need to be protected!

100. Name: Jane Coles on Aug 24, 2011 Address: 5 Willow Glade, Llanigon, HR3 5PQ Comments: Too much green belt has disappeared as it is. Please don't make it even worse!

101. Name: Elizabeth Hall on Aug 25, 2011 Address: Vicarage House , Kirkby Wharfe. LS24 9DE Comments: why spoil greenbelt when there are brownfield sites available?

102. Name: Sherril Olive on Aug 25, 2011 Address: 7 The Withey, EX5 2QD Comments: Country Parks are what they are called and should not be included in any planning - if we do not save our green spaces, what will happen to us?

103. Name: TONY & VAL FRAYNE on Aug 25, 2011 Address: 20,SPRINGFIELD AVE,UPPER KILLAY,SWANSEA Comments: this is a wonderful place that my wife and our children and grandchildren played when small lets keep it that way for future generations.

104. Name: Hayley Rees on Aug 25, 2011 Address: 564A Gower Road, Upper Killay, Swansea Comments:

105. Name: Mike Hughes on Aug 25, 2011 Address: 10 Chapel Road Crofty Gower Swansea. Comments: Clyne Valley is an oasis for peopkle and animals alike and should be kept in its current state for the future people of this city.

106. Name: Eddy Hoksbergen on Aug 25, 2011 Address: 636 Gower Road, Upper Killay, Swansea, SA2 7EX Comments:

107. Name: Jason Cogger on Aug 25, 2011 Address: 9 frogmore avenue sketty swansea Comments: wrong in so many ways

108. Name: Sophia Thompson on Aug 25, 2011 Address: 8 Millwood Gardens, Killay, Swansea, SA2 7BE Comments: I can't believe that such a proposal even exists! Is there nothing safe for people to enjoy? Leave the valley alone! There will be another way for providing housing but don;t destroy such a beautiful area.

109. Name: Nathan Thompson on Aug 26, 2011 Address: 8 Milwood Gardens, swansea SA2 7BE Comments:

110. Name: Zoe Thompson on Aug 26, 2011 Address: 4 Wrecclesham Road, Farnham Comments:

111. Name: Joel Thompson on Aug 26, 2011 Address: Millwood Gardens, Killay

Page 10 of 37 Comments:

112. Name: Clare Anstead on Aug 26, 2011 Address: Saffron Walden Comments: I was born in Killay and I want the Clyne Valley to remain our heritage for future generations.

113. Name: Mike Thompson on Aug 26, 2011 Address: 8 Millwood Gardens, Killay, SA2 7BE Comments: I cannot believe that this can have been proposed!

114. Name: Carmen Economou on Aug 26, 2011 Address: 7 Pages Hill N10 1PX Comments: People need open spaces for their sanity. Homes are also needed but not at the expense of areas of natural beauty. Alternative areas should be used

115. Name: Darren Thomas on Aug 26, 2011 Address: 16 cefn celyn, dunvant, Swansea Comments:

116. Name: Lloyd Davies on Aug 26, 2011 Address: 20 Derwen fawr Road, Sketty, Swansea Comments: This is a particularly valuable area both for wildlife and people of the region. It has established native woodland which must be preserved. No houses !!!

117. Name: Micah Thompson on Aug 26, 2011 Address: 8 Millwood Gardens, Killay Comments:

118. Name: Helen Knowles on Aug 27, 2011 Address: 8 Edgemoor Drive Upper Killay Swansea SA2 7HH Comments:

119. Name: Chris Knowles on Aug 27, 2011 Address: 8 Edgemoor Drive Upper Killay Swansea SA2 7HH Comments:

120. Name: Kevin Lawson on Aug 27, 2011 Address: 6 Lon Coed Parc, Cockett Comments: I have spent several years studying the myxomycetes of Cyne Woods, which incude some rare species, and I am concerened that any development in the vicinity may constitute a threat.

121. Name: Ian Harries on Aug 27, 2011 Address: 44 Hen Parc Lane, Upper Killay, Swansea Comments:

122. Name: M.Kirby on Aug 28, 2011 Address: 10 Ridgeway, Killay Comments: This space is too important for recreation to be spoilt by ANY development !

123. Name: Lesley Dindorp on Aug 28, 2011 Address: The Rock, Lon Killan, Dunvant Swansea Comments: We must stop this development at all costs. The council need to realise that we will not sit back and let them sell away the best parts and most needed parts of Our Local Areas. They are quick enough to put a halt to planning permission for individuals, but area more than happy to rip up the local woodland and build god knows how many red brick homes, which will not be inkeeping with their surrounding areas. Say No to This Development.

124. Name: Mary Hannigan on Aug 28, 2011 Address: 54New N Comments:

Page 11 of 37 125. Name: Anonymous on Aug 28, 2011 Address: 21 hen parc lane Comments: animals homes are being detroyed. STOP THE HOUSING

126. Name: Gill Swain on Aug 28, 2011 Address: 72 Brynymor Road, Gowerton, Swansea SA4 3EZ Comments:

127. Name: David Roberts on Aug 28, 2011 Address: 1 Wimmerfield Avenue, Killay, Swansea. Comments: I thought clyne was designated country park

128. Name: Chris Pallett on Aug 29, 2011 Address: 124 garrod ave. dunvant sa2 7xq Comments:

129. Name: Linda Welch on Aug 29, 2011 Address: 539 Gower Road Comments:

130. Name: Anna Colclough on Aug 29, 2011 Address: 99 woodcote, killay Comments:

131. Name: Anonymous on Aug 29, 2011 Address: 1 Brierfield Ave, , NG11 7DA Comments: Q

132. Name: Geraint Thomas on Aug 30, 2011 Address: 3 Church Green, Pakenham, Suffolk Comments: Having grown up in the Clyne Valley area I am dismayed at the prospect of this development. I can completely understand the necessity for housing in the UK, although thought must be given to where developments take place. Clyne Valley is NOT one of these places!

Outstanding beauty, wild life, wonderful walks. Open spaces, tranquillity & fun. From experience I can say that this is an area that encourages people to get out and explore. Children, teenagers and adults can use this area for recreation. Do NOT destroy this!

It’s said that Wales is God’s country, you can see why when walking through Clyne Valley.

133. Name: Alysha Morgan on Aug 30, 2011 Address: 1 Heol Glasnant, Killay, Swansea, SA2 7BX Comments:

134. Name: Michael John Fenton, BA(Hons), MA Ed, DipMus, AHEA on Aug 30, 2011 Address: 7 Wimmerfield Close, Killay, Swansea SA2 7DE Comments: Virgin green land in the City should be carefully preserved, particularly when in an area of outstanding natural beauty. The proposal would destroy a precious local amenity, enjoyed by walkers, cyclists (I am one), not to mention the abundant wildlife. I feel so strongly about this that if the land were to be thus desecrated, I would resolve never again to vote for the party(ies) approving it.

135. Name: Julia Killa on Aug 30, 2011 Address: 11 Grange Crescent Comments: This immensely important resource of peace and recreation for wildlife, Swansea residents and tourists must not be plundered for personal or commercial gain. The protection of its current boundaries should be strengthened not eroded.

Page 12 of 37 136. Name: Richard Hood on Aug 30, 2011 Address: 11 Grange Crescent, West Cross, Swansea, SA3 5ET Comments:

137. Name: Mrs Christine Williams on Aug 30, 2011 Address: 4 Road Comments:

138. Name: Mrs Christine Williams on Aug 30, 2011 Address: 4 Pennard Road, Bishopston, Swansea. Comments: Any building development would be disastrous for Clyne Valley. It would seriously disturb the flora and fauna, insects, butterflies, and other wildlife which make the area so special.

139. Name: Mr Ian Rayer on Aug 30, 2011 Address: 22 Fairy grove Killay Comments: I object to this development becuase it will meen the loss of a substantial emenity and put even more traffic on Gower rd which is already overloaded and is the only way into swansea

140. Name: Kathryn Hughes on Aug 30, 2011 Address: 122 Bryn Road, Brynmill, Swansea Comments:

141. Name: Helen Silverberg on Aug 30, 2011 Address: 332 Gower Road, Killay. Swansea SA2 7AE Comments: Further development in this area would significantly increase the traffic congestion along Gower Rd.

142. Name: Robert Killa on Aug 30, 2011 Address: 11 Grange Crescent, West Cross, Swansea Comments: Building companies care nothing for the environment that many people enjoy. It's just money money money. Is it also that Swansea City council just want to collect more council tax? Again money money money.

143. Name: Kerin Dindorp on Aug 30, 2011 Address: 84 Summerland Park Upper Killay Comments: Why shouldhouses be built in beautiful area depriving people of countryside.

144. Name: Darren Grounds on Aug 30, 2011 Address: 135 Dunvant Road Killay Swansea SA2 6SX Comments: I object to this development and have emailed the council through the relevnt channels.

145. Name: Jessica Esa on Aug 30, 2011 Address: 4 Edgemoor Drive Upperkillay Swansea Comments: A beautiful site that holds many memories for a lot of people that I know, it would be a huge loss to Killay and the surrounding areas if this land was destroyed.

146. Name: Anne Rayer on Aug 31, 2011 Address: 4st peters road newton swansea Comments:

147. Name: Elizabeth Cantrell on Aug 31, 2011 Address: 52 Guildofrd Road Comments:

148. Name: Julie Dunn on Aug 31, 2011 Address: 62, Derlwyn, Dunvant, Swansea, SA2 7QE Comments: I am horrified at the thought of losing the fields in clyne. Is this the start of covering the valley in tarmac ?

149. Name: Olivia Dunn on Aug 31, 2011 Address: 21 stanley terrace Swansea Comments:

Page 13 of 37 150. Name: Elsie Wyeth on Aug 31, 2011 Address: 21 stanley terrace Swansea Comments:

151. Name: Ben Wyeth on Aug 31, 2011 Address: 21 stanley terrace Swansea Comments:

152. Name: Chris James on Aug 31, 2011 Address: 16 vaughan place swansea Comments: there are enough houses. end of.

153. Name: Stephen Wasiniak on Aug 31, 2011 Address: 52 woodcote killay swansea Comments: The loss of flora and fauna in this area, which is enjoyed by people all over Swansea, as a result of such a project, would be detrimental to the whole ecosystem of this area. Hundreds of animals will be dislocated. Yet, as well as the woods and their inhaibtants, it is we as people who will lose out the most. Clyne valley is one of Swansea's most attractive feautures. Such an act, as the one proposed, is totally unacceptable.

154. Name: Jenny Brisley on Sep 01, 2011 Address: 19 Clos Cynan, killay, swansea, SA2 7DL Comments:

155. Name: Katie Donath on Sep 02, 2011 Address: 15 Clive road, Comments:

156. Name: Rachel Thomas on Sep 03, 2011 Address: 1 bron-y-bryn, killay Comments:

157. Name: Jill Dickinson on Sep 03, 2011 Address: 1,Royal Oak Raod, Derwen Fawr, Swansesa SA2 8ES Comments: I strongly object to any develpment in Clyne Valley Country Park

158. Name: M.R.Harris on Sep 03, 2011 Address: 17 hen parc avenue Comments: Development should follow the brownfield sites guidlines in and around Swansea and bring life back to the town centre.

159. Name: Nicola Broadbridge on Sep 03, 2011 Address: [email protected] Comments: Can't believe that yet another green space is under threat :o(

160. Name: Sue Neate on Sep 03, 2011 Address: Stroud, Glos. Comments:

161. Name: Nicola Thomas on Sep 03, 2011 Address: 12 Mulberry Ave, West Cross, Swansea, SA3 5HD Comments:

162. Name: Sharon Rees on Sep 04, 2011 Address: 3 moor park cottages, llanbedr, crickhowell, powys Comments:

163. Name: Cynthia Mumford on Sep 04, 2011 Address: 66 Bryn Road, Swansea SA5 4RB Comments:

Page 14 of 37 164. Name: Joanne Morgan on Sep 04, 2011 Address: 16 talbot street gowerton swansea sa43db Comments: It is to my great dissapointment to have seen the many a signs leading to the proposals for the KS 001, Killay site! As a user of the valley for many years i cannot beleive that it is actually being thought of to be used for houses not only is it green belt land but also home to many animals and also my stables in which is situated at the further end of the valley! As i am out in the valley everyday with either the dog or hacking my horse i know that it is of great use to all people whether they are walking themselves, their dogs or just enjoying the country side that we actually have left and untouched! Another concern of mine is that traffic is killay is never quiet and to assume that there would be 400+ more cars on the main road through killay is rediculous and as there is only one entrance that would lead to the proposed houses traffic would be dreadful! I think that if everyone in the surrounding area knew that this was happening, they would all certainly object to this! i hope that people are passing on this information and that as many people can object as possible and i really hope that we can save the valley!

165. Name: Elizabeth Thomas on Sep 05, 2011 Address: 6, Bude Haven Tce Norton Swansea Comments:

166. Name: Carol Klaes on Sep 05, 2011 Address: am talblick 2 72202 Nagold Germany Comments: Is nothing sacred anymore!

167. Name: Maybellene Breeze on Sep 05, 2011 Address: 11 Lon Teify Cockett Swansea SA2 0YB Comments: Once again Swansea Councillors have shown they will do ANYTHING for money and believe we can do nothing to stop them. Please sign this petition and stop this desecration of our beautiful countryside. NOW!

168. Name: James Boyle on Sep 05, 2011 Address: 86 gwelfor, Dunvant, Swansea, SA2 7QJ Comments: Simply unacceptable! The natural beauty in the area is the reason that it is still such a great place to live. Don't ruin that for our children.

169. Name: Helen Rogers on Sep 05, 2011 Address: 86 gwelfor, Dunvant, Swansea, SA2 7QJ Comments: Where does it all stop? If we don't act now there will be no green space left for future generations.

170. Name: Edmund Taylor on Sep 05, 2011 Address: 102 Castle Road, , Swansea. Comments:

171. Name: Neil Watson on Sep 05, 2011 Address: sa2 8ar Comments:

172. Name: Ursula Morgan on Sep 05, 2011 Address: 102 Castle Road, Mumbles, SA3 5TA Comments:

173. Name: BRIAN BREEZE on Sep 05, 2011 Address: 11 Lon Teifi, Cockett, Swansea SA2 0YB Comments: How can our council even consider the sale of Clyne Valley? We owe it to our children and grandchildren to stop them!

174. Name: Gemma Read on Sep 05, 2011 Address: Oak Hill House, Etchilhampton, Devizes, SN10 3JY Comments:

175. Name: Alexandra Jaquest on Sep 05, 2011 Address: Lohhof 7, 20535 Hamburg, Germany Comments: I am from Germany but having lived in Swansea for a while, it is like a second home for me. Being a teacher in adult education, I always spread the word among my students, encouraging them to visit beautiful Swansea and Wales. I love the fact that you are in the city, but also so close to nature, with its green valleys and of course the Gower so close. But especially the natural

Page 15 of 37 refugees almost in the inner city, like Clyne Valley, are so very precious. It's so very important to think in the long term, support sustainability and save these natural habitats.

176. Name: Peter Rees on Sep 05, 2011 Address: 19 Laurel place, Sketty Comments:

177. Name: Pauline McDonald on Sep 05, 2011 Address: 66 Vivian Road, Sketty, Swansea, SA20UL Comments:

178. Name: Jennie Plenty on Sep 05, 2011 Address: 46 Queens Road Mumbles Swansea Comments:

179. Name: Dominique Boho on Sep 05, 2011 Address: 141 Saunders Way, Sketty, Swansea, sa2 8bj Comments: We don't need more brick and mortar... save the trees!!!!

180. Name: Mary Dicker And Spotty Dog on Sep 05, 2011 Address: 77 Lewis Road Neath SA11 1DJ Comments:

181. Name: Anonymous on Sep 05, 2011 Address: 8 brynsifi terrace swnasea Comments: absolutely disgusting, Swansea council sort your act out.

182. Name: Alex Blackmore on Sep 05, 2011 Address: 7 Henderfoilan road Comments:

183. Name: Anonymous on Sep 05, 2011 Address: 30 Brynmill Terrace, SA2 0BA Comments:

184. Name: Nicola on Sep 05, 2011 Address: Bowden Comments:

185. Name: Anonymous on Sep 05, 2011 Address: gwynfor road swansea Comments:

186. Name: David West on Sep 05, 2011 Address: 55 Wimmerfield Crescent Killay Comments: Dont build there!!

187. Name: Julie Taylor on Sep 05, 2011 Address: 2 Rosemary Close, Tycoch, Swansea, SA2 9HZ Comments:

188. Name: Mr W Williams on Sep 05, 2011 Address: 4 hillside cres uplands swansea Comments: you can not keep building without loosing inportant habitat for animals and birds on a permanent basis

189. Name: Sheila Doogan on Sep 05, 2011 Address: 56 huntingdon way, sketty, swansea Comments:

Page 16 of 37 190. Name: Geraint Griffiths on Sep 05, 2011 Address: Flat 3, 8 Sketty Road, Uplands, Swansea Comments:

191. Name: Jackie Baker on Sep 05, 2011 Address: 38 chestnut avenue westcross swansea Comments: Leave the park alone it has history and its beauty should not be destroyed..

192. Name: Emma Jane Breeze-Nelmes on Sep 05, 2011 Address: 51 Rhondda Street, Mount Pleasant Comments:

193. Name: Anonymous on Sep 05, 2011 Address: 8 Prince Edward Mansions Road, London W2 4WB Comments:

194. Name: Helen Nruce on Sep 05, 2011 Address: 31 cwrt sart,neath Comments:

195. Name: Jane Ambrose on Sep 05, 2011 Address: 62 akeman street Comments: once it's spoilt, it's spoilt for ever. Surely the environmental history of the Swansea valley.

196. Name: Jayne Saer on Sep 05, 2011 Address: Carmarthen Comments:

197. Name: Anonymous on Sep 05, 2011 Address: 48 Newfoundland Road, Cardiff Comments:

198. Name: Donna Breeze on Sep 06, 2011 Address: 11 Lon Teify, Cockett, Swansea, sa2 0yb. Comments: This is a travesty, you should be ashamed of yourselves, destroying your countrys' natural beauty in the name of profit. Please think again and make this city proud of it's council..

Yours Faithfully, Donna Breeze.

199. Name: Susie Jewell on Sep 06, 2011 Address: 20 Trafalgar Place, Brynmill, Swansea. SA2 0BU Comments: This place is super special. It is also utterly irreplaceable. Houses are not the issue as there are plenty of places in and around Swansea that could be used instead. Why destroy the habitat of so many endangered species? Is it even legal?

200. Name: Gabby Rowley-Conwy on Sep 06, 2011 Address: 46 Hazel Road, Uplands, Swansea Comments:

201. Name: Ray Boothby on Sep 06, 2011 Address: 24 west bury street, swansea Comments: disgraceful. i hope the developers get cancer.

202. Name: Jennifer Jones on Sep 06, 2011 Address: 5 kemble street, swansea, SA2 0BX Comments: Its disgusting. You have already built ugly and pointless buildings in SA1, the more houses you build, and the uglier you make this progressively ugly town, the less people will want to live here you fools. The parks and countryside is the one thing Swansea has going for it. don't spoil it!

Page 17 of 37 203. Name: Gail Evans on Sep 06, 2011 Address: 30 heol treharne, abergwynfi sa13 3aj Comments:

204. Name: Jack on Sep 06, 2011 Address: Malone Comments: The green spaces in Swansea make this city great, please leave them alone.

205. Name: Nicolas on Sep 06, 2011 Address: Hughes Comments: A haven in the center of Swansea, the lovely part of the ugly/lovely town.

206. Name: Simon Phillips on Sep 06, 2011 Address: 62 Hafod Street, Hafod, Swansea, SA1 2HB Comments: Don't you dare touch Clyne, it's beautiful. There must be another site you could build on??

207. Name: Sophie Maund on Sep 06, 2011 Address: 25 Oldway, Bishopston, Swansea Comments:

208. Name: Tom-Daniel Laugerud on Sep 06, 2011 Address: 15 Prince of Wales road, SA1 2EX Comments: Leave Clyne Valley woods alone! Number one, it's the best place in Swansea to go walking or a quite run. Number two, as filmstudent it's a great location! Also for photo!

209. Name: Mat Thomas on Sep 06, 2011 Address: 42 Withy Park Comments: Absolutely shocking, what are they thinking!?

210. Name: Matthew Jones on Sep 06, 2011 Address: 19 nicholl st, swansea sa14hf Comments: is nothing sacred in this city anymore?

211. Name: Ian Barrett on Sep 06, 2011 Address: [email protected] Comments:

212. Name: Ruth Davies on Sep 06, 2011 Address: 2 Cwrt Y Fedw Birchgrove Swansea Comments:

213. Name: Alyce Von Rothkirch on Sep 06, 2011 Address: 21 Windsor Street, Uplands, Swansea Comments:

214. Name: Ian Davies on Sep 06, 2011 Address: 15,Coedcelyn road, Sketty sa2 8ds Comments: There are a lot of unsightly areas around Swansea that are just crying out to be developed.These can be seen as you enter swansea by road and rail. Make these areas look respectable rather than rape and ruin a spot of beauty. Your developement plans are comparable to the damage caused by the rioting and looting that has erupted around Britain.

215. Name: Alexandra Velten on Sep 06, 2011 Address: Floersheimer Str 25, 65239 Hochheim, Germany Comments:

216. Name: Alex Jenkins on Sep 06, 2011 Address: william street, mumbles swansea Comments:

Page 18 of 37 217. Name: Carys Griffiths on Sep 06, 2011 Address: 5, Mary Twill Lane, Caswell Comments: Idiots.

218. Name: James on Sep 06, 2011 Address: 5, Lon Ger - Y - Coed, Sketty, Swansea, SA2 0YH Comments:

219. Name: Claudia Phillips on Sep 06, 2011 Address: 37 Lon Enfys Swansea SA7 9XQ Comments:

220. Name: Joshua on Sep 06, 2011 Address: Beynon Comments: Your ruining our wooded areas. Please stopp!

221. Name: Jill Allen on Sep 06, 2011 Address: 71 Belgrave Road SA4 6RF Comments:

222. Name: Alex Martin on Sep 06, 2011 Address: 740 Gower Road, Upper Killay, Swansea SA2 7HQ Comments: We need green belt, cycle tracks etc to live and breathe and keep sane. Use brownfield sites to build more houses on, not beautiful tranquil sites of sanctuary.

223. Name: Tammy Davies on Sep 06, 2011 Address: Flat 2, 53 Bryn Rd, Brynmill, Swansdea SA2 0AP Comments:

224. Name: Anonymous on Sep 06, 2011 Address: 5 cecil st swansea Comments: No need to ruin Clyne!!

225. Name: Deborah Alame-Jones on Sep 06, 2011 Address: 16 Bromley Road, Lytham St Annes, Lancs Comments: Having been a resident of Killay for many years, I really appreciated being able to walk in Clyne Valley. Such a beautiful area for local residents and everyone else to enjoy. The wildlife habitat would be compromised should any housing development go ahead . I stand against any such proposed housing development.

226. Name: Matthew Beynon on Sep 06, 2011 Address: 102 new mill road sketty swansea Comments: Save clyne

227. Name: Alan Beynon on Sep 06, 2011 Address: 102 new mill road sketty swansea sa28pb Comments: Save clynnnee!!

228. Name: Anonymous on Sep 06, 2011 Address: 29 nicholl street, swansea Comments:

229. Name: Tomas L Martin on Sep 06, 2011 Address: 740 Gower Road Comments:

230. Name: Roger Gadd on Sep 06, 2011 Address: 226 Derwen Fawr Road Swansea SA2 8EA Comments: Housing is choking the area.

Page 19 of 37 231. Name: Safira on Sep 06, 2011 Address: Westerkade 3 Amsterdam 1015XA Comments:

232. Name: Graham Griffiths on Sep 06, 2011 Address: Narberth, Pembs Comments:

233. Name: Lauran Belcher on Sep 06, 2011 Address: 105 High Street, Cymmer, Porth Rhondda Cynon Taff Comments: This should not happen. Wales is known for its greenery, it's what brings people here from all around the world and to demolish this natural beauty would be un-benificial to the area.

234. Name: Johan Söderberg on Sep 06, 2011 Address: Alkv 103, 61336 Oxelosund Sweden Comments:

235. Name: James Tanner on Sep 06, 2011 Address: 2 Heathfield Court, 63 Heathfield, Swansea, SA1 6EJ Comments:

236. Name: Carl Llewellyn on Sep 06, 2011 Address: 12 aneurin way Comments: Clyne is a beautiful place and there are so many people that enjoy it as it is already. If these woodlands are taken it will take one of the things people love about swansea which is the natural beauty.

237. Name: Phil Jones on Sep 06, 2011 Address: 15 st pauls terrace garden village Comments:

238. Name: Martyn Hancock on Sep 07, 2011 Address: 21 danycoed rd, Sa79pb Comments:

239. Name: Kim Belvedere on Sep 07, 2011 Address: 3/184 westgarth street northcote, aus 3070 Comments:

240. Name: John Roach on Sep 07, 2011 Address: Fairwood view, Howells Road, Dunvant, Swansea SA2 7RR Comments:

241. Name: Bev Khan on Sep 07, 2011 Address: 22 Penlan Crescent, Uplands, Swansea Comments: They want to turn everything into one big building site

242. Name: M A Williams on Sep 07, 2011 Address: 5 maes-yr-haf,LLANSAMLET,Swansea Comments:

243. Name: Donna Brown on Sep 07, 2011 Address: 31 broadmead, killay, swansea Comments: How can they possibly think about building on such a beautiful place

244. Name: Charlie Brook-Fairfax on Sep 07, 2011 Address: Mill Cottage, Perrott's Brook, Cirencester. GL7 7BS Comments:

Page 20 of 37 245. Name: Paul Houlton on Sep 07, 2011 Address: 16 pennard drive pennard gower swansea Comments: i worked in this wonderfull country park back in the 80s to restore it for wildlife and residents of swansea and gower i was employed by swansea council.now they want to cover it in concrete. disgusting.there are plenty of brown field sites.use these instead.leos site penlan.velindre steelworks site do not destroy the green lungs of swansea

246. Name: Vince Parry on Sep 07, 2011 Address: 3 Holly Bush Cottages, The Langrove, Gower, SA3 2EB Comments:

247. Name: Lynda Bannister on Sep 07, 2011 Address: 274 St Davids Rd North, Lytham St Annes, Lancashire, FY8 2JX Comments:

248. Name: Phillip Bennington on Sep 08, 2011 Address: 60 Hanover Street, Mount Pleasant, Swansea, SA1 6BE Comments:

249. Name: Jess Khan on Sep 08, 2011 Address: 22 Penlan Crescent, Uplands, Swansea SA2 0RL Comments:

250. Name: Jack on Sep 08, 2011 Address: Malone Comments:

251. Name: Luke Charters on Sep 08, 2011 Address: 48 Terrace Road, Mount Pleasant, Swansea Comments: There are so many brownfield sites in and around Swansea, that considering construction in Clyne Valley is completely ridiculous. It is wasteful and unnecessary.

252. Name: Tamsin Page on Sep 08, 2011 Address: SA1 6HW Comments:

253. Name: Anonymous on Sep 08, 2011 Address: 15 Royal Oak Road,Derwen Fawr,Swansea. Comments: It would be a tragedy to build on this lovely woodland valley and destroy the woodland and foliage, not to mention the habitat of animals & birdlife.

254. Name: Michael Relph on Sep 08, 2011 Address: 11 Dulais Grove Swansea SA2 8BL Comments:

255. Name: Fay Relph on Sep 08, 2011 Address: 11 Dulais Grove Swansea SA2 8BL Comments:

256. Name: Phil Martin on Sep 09, 2011 Address: 740 Gower Road, Upper Killay, Swansea, SA2 7HQ Comments:

257. Name: Victoria Baker on Sep 09, 2011 Address: 3 Rhyddings Park Road. Comments:

258. Name: Maria Morgan on Sep 09, 2011 Address: 2 Cwmbath Road, , Swansea SA6 7AH Comments:

Page 21 of 37 259. Name: Tim Blakemore on Sep 09, 2011 Address: 1 St Aiden drive Killay, Swansea SA2 7AX Comments:

260. Name: Sharon Blakemore on Sep 09, 2011 Address: 1 St Aiden drive Killay, Swansea SA2 7AX Comments:

261. Name: KATHRYN GRAY on Sep 10, 2011 Address: London Comments:

262. Name: Ann Wardle on Sep 10, 2011 Address: Bristol Comments:

263. Name: J. Inglis on Sep 11, 2011 Address: Sketty, SA2 8JJ. Comments:

264. Name: Linda Martin on Sep 11, 2011 Address: SN12 7AX Wiltshire Comments: This cannot go ahead. We cannot lose this area which is so beautiful.

265. Name: Anonymous on Sep 11, 2011 Address: Newport Comments:

266. Name: Samuel Edwards on Sep 11, 2011 Address: Six bells, Abertillery Comments:

267. Name: Jane Heynes on Sep 11, 2011 Address: 7 redwell road wellingborough Comments: Swansea council,stop this idea immediately, you should protect the countryside and build on brown sites and on old industrial land.

268. Name: C Currie on Sep 11, 2011 Address: Invernesshie Comments: Please re consider and let sight retain its status as green wedge/country park

269. Name: P Lambert on Sep 11, 2011 Address: 99 evelyn dr HA5 4RN Comments: Scandalous proposal! There must be a less valuable area for housing development in the region

270. Name: M P Taylor on Sep 11, 2011 Address: DT6 4AG Comments:

271. Name: Oliver Burston on Sep 11, 2011 Address: 8, Grange Crescent, Coychurch, Bridgend, CF355HP Comments: Such green spaces are vital.

272. Name: Jane Coles on Sep 11, 2011 Address: 5 Willow Glade, Llanigon, Hay on Wye, Powys Comments: Why can't you redevelop derelict urban sites with new housing?

Page 22 of 37 273. Name: Ruth Jowett on Sep 11, 2011 Address: Jowett Comments:

274. Name: Lisa Wesley on Sep 11, 2011 Address: Comments:

275. Name: Jane Harries on Sep 11, 2011 Address: 1 Highbridge Rd Wappenham NN12 8SL Comments:

276. Name: Susan Hughes on Sep 11, 2011 Address: 76 Boleyns Avenue, Braintree, Essex CM7 5TX Comments: Please do not develop the land around Touchwood, stop building on the country park.

277. Name: Nick Andrews on Sep 11, 2011 Address: 10 Caswell Bay Road, Bishopston, Swansea SA3 3DD Comments: I love walking in Clyne Woods - they are an irreplaceable asset to Swansea. There are plenty of other places to build houses!

278. Name: IAN HODGSON on Sep 11, 2011 Address: 16 VICTORIA AVE. Comments:

279. Name: Ann Lane on Sep 11, 2011 Address: lane Comments: we are loosing too muchj of britains woods and tracks through developement why cant brown sites be used instead

280. Name: Irene Spencer-Woods on Sep 11, 2011 Address: 10 Greenacres, , EX45BS Comments: Not on our cherished land!

281. Name: Stuart Fyfe on Sep 11, 2011 Address: 77A Saint Francis Rd., , South Wiltshire. SP1 3QR Comments:

282. Name: Anonymous on Sep 11, 2011 Address: 8 Humberdale Way, Warboys, Cambs PE28 2RX Comments:

283. Name: Maggie Stilson on Sep 11, 2011 Address: 44 Sanford St. Barrie, ON, Canada Comments:

284. Name: Laura Sykes on Sep 11, 2011 Address: 537, Mierscourt Road, Rainham, Kent Comments: I grew up near the Clyne Valley and I think it would be a dreadful shame if any of it were lost. It is a huge asset to Swansea.

285. Name: Rakshanda Anderson on Sep 11, 2011 Address: 38 Campbell Road, London W7 3EB Comments: Please stop building on green land - soon there will be none left.

286. Name: Liz Machin on Sep 12, 2011 Address: 2 barlings road Comments:

287. Name: Suzanne Renton on Sep 12, 2011

Page 23 of 37 Address: 4 Burnside of Lethen Nairn IV12 5QH Comments: There are bound to be less pretty sites where the houses could go - so everyone can continue to enjoy the ancient footpaths.

288. Name: Brenda Timms on Sep 12, 2011 Address: Bwlchauduon, Ffarmers, SA19 8JJ Comments:

289. Name: Brenda Timms on Sep 12, 2011 Address: Bwlchauduon, Ffarmers, SA19 8JJ Comments:

290. Name: Margaret M Laslett on Sep 12, 2011 Address: 12 Tulk House, Ottershaw Park, Ottershaw, Surrey KT16 0QG Comments:

291. Name: Bev Halstead on Sep 12, 2011 Address: Ffoslas Farm, Culla Rd, Trimsaran Comments:

292. Name: ERIC WILLIAMS on Sep 12, 2011 Address: 18, paddock st, Llanelli, Carms sa15 2ru Comments:

293. Name: Jim Young on Sep 12, 2011 Address: 16 Hendrefoilan Road Comments: The proposal is totally unacceptable and outrageous

294. Name: Roger Stein on Sep 12, 2011 Address: 8 Lunnon Close, Parkmill, Swansea SA3 2EL Comments:

295. Name: Paul Reynolds on Sep 12, 2011 Address: 87 Gabalfa Rd, Swansea SA2 8ND Comments:

296. Name: STUART WINKS on Sep 12, 2011 Address: 53 WESTLAND AVENUE WEST CROSS SA3 5NR Comments: This move must be resisted at all costs to save a valuable natural resource of children & future generations as a learning base

297. Name: Merfyn Williams on Sep 12, 2011 Address: 94 Rhyd-y-Defaid Dr SA2 8AN Comments: This area is an essential part of the Clyne Valley Country Park.

298. Name: Jon Reynolds on Sep 12, 2011 Address: 87 Gabalfa Road, SA2 8ND Comments:

299. Name: Linda Doyle on Sep 12, 2011 Address: 2 Chapel Ascote Cottages, Ladbroke, Southam, CV47 2DB Comments:

300. Name: John Powell on Sep 12, 2011 Address: 15, Mulgrave Way, Blackpill Comments: Act now to keep our green woodland and open space

301. Name: Abigail Reynolds on Sep 12, 2011 Address: 50 Beech Road, , WV10 6TP

Page 24 of 37 Comments: As an ex-Swansea resident and still a frequent visitor, I am horrified at the thought of houses being built on any part of the Clyne Valley.

302. Name: Lavinia Gay Mitchell on Sep 12, 2011 Address: 86 Derwen Fawr Road Sketty SA2 8AQ Comments: I wish to save Clyne Valley Retain its Status as Green Wedge/Country Park

303. Name: Robert Cuthill on Sep 12, 2011 Address: 35 Gwerneinon Road, Sketty Comments: The Country Park should be treated as an entity and not have pieces eroded from it for residential development. Consideration should be given to recreational development and amenities on the reclaimed refuse tip.

304. Name: Robin Hancock on Sep 12, 2011 Address: 7 Cunningham Close, Sketty, SA2 8LG Comments: Nibbling away at an established Country Park is not the way forward when there are so many derelict brown-field sites available throughout Swansea.

305. Name: Amy Want on Sep 12, 2011 Address: Huntingdon Way, Tycoch, Swansea SA2 9HN Comments:

306. Name: David Crabb on Sep 12, 2011 Address: Pembroke Street, Manselton, Swansea, SA5 8PU Comments:

307. Name: Josie Salter on Sep 12, 2011 Address: Sutton Coldfield Comments: we need to save these wonderful lands as they are vanishing too quick, it takes years for nature to make these views and only a short time for builders to wreck it, please, leave some countryside for people to enjoy as it is meant to be.

308. Name: Caroline Crimp on Sep 12, 2011 Address: 31 Penyrheol Drive Comments:

309. Name: Karen Davies on Sep 12, 2011 Address: 33 Lundy Drive, West Cross, Swansea, SA3 5QL Comments:

310. Name: Ian Plain on Sep 12, 2011 Address: 33 Bathford Hill Ba17sw Comments: Our Children play here every time they come to visit their Grandparents, This is over development and destruction of the envioroment for no apparent reason.

311. Name: J M Neilson on Sep 12, 2011 Address: 19 Gabalfa Road Sketty Swansea SA2 8NF Comments: It is unthinkable that the City and County of Swansea Council should even be considering ANY development of any description on this ancient heritage site.

312. Name: Helen Miller on Sep 12, 2011 Address: 27 Highmead Ave Comments:

313. Name: Hilary Werker on Sep 12, 2011 Address: 33 Overland Rd., Mumbles, Swansea SA3 4LL Comments:

314. Name: Margaret Crompton on Sep 12, 2011 Address: 13 Clos Alyn, Cardiff, CF13 8LB Comments: I sign this with enormous concern for the preservation of what is an old and glorious woodland.I do so not only as a

Page 25 of 37 former resident of Swansea who has been so grateful for the preservation to date of such a wonderful area, but also now as one of those who visits Swansea and wishes to ensure that future generations are able to enjoy its beauty and tranquility. Beyond these concerns is the wider issue that such special places need to be protected as part of our national heritage.

315. Name: Pam Thirwell on Sep 12, 2011 Address: 6 Parklands Court Sketty Swansea Comments: We need this green space, leave it alone.

316. Name: Kim Fabricius on Sep 12, 2011 Address: 17 Carnglas Road, Swamsea SA2 9BJ Comments:

317. Name: MRS J HOLT on Sep 12, 2011 Address: 191 Whitton Road.Twickenham. Middx.TW2 7QZ Comments: Know this area as my daughter was at University of Wales, Swansea for 7 years. Please keep this land as a country park for future generations.

318. Name: Mrs.Ann Henderson on Sep 12, 2011 Address: 20, Glasfryn Close, Cockett,Swansea,SA2 0FP Comments:

319. Name: Gill Lawton on Sep 12, 2011 Address: 8, Raglan Road, Sa2 9LR Comments:

320. Name: Jane Rees on Sep 12, 2011 Address: 12 Garth View, Ynysforgan, Swansea. Comments:

321. Name: Leslie Bright on Sep 12, 2011 Address: 91 Ardness Place, Comments: PLEASE LEAVE THIS SITE AND AREA AS IT IS

322. Name: Keith Fuller on Sep 12, 2011 Address: 8 High View Gardens, Sketty, Swansea, SA2 8ER Comments: There are plenty of derelict sites around Swansea to build on without stealing the publics green Space.

323. Name: Keith Fuller on Sep 12, 2011 Address: 8 High View Gardens, Sketty, Swansea, SA2 8ER Comments:

324. Name: Grant Leavy on Sep 12, 2011 Address: 18 Ocean View Close Sketty Swanswa SA2 8EP Comments: I am opposed to any developments within the Clyne Country Park. I have used the park for the last 25 years and would object any changes.

325. Name: Chris Scullion on Sep 12, 2011 Address: 26 Wimblewood Close, West Cross, Swansea, SA3 5LQ Comments: There's enough houses in this area as it is and loads being built in the centre of Swansea. Please keep our woods and this beautiful park area safe.

326. Name: Rosemary Crahart on Sep 13, 2011 Address: 167 West St., Gorseinon SA4 4AG Comments: Don't let an unthinking Council destroy a beautiful and well-loved area which is also one of historical significance as a site of early industry. Better a heritage trail through woodland than more bricks and concrete.

327. Name: Marjorie Wilson on Sep 13, 2011 Address: 18 Alden Drive Comments: This area must be preserved. It is used by all ages from all parts of Swansea. At a time when people are encouraged to keep fit in the natural environment it is madness to destroy this facility.

Page 26 of 37 328. Name: Dulcie Engel on Sep 13, 2011 Address: 40 Chery Grove SA2 8AT Comments:

329. Name: Angela Latimer on Sep 13, 2011 Address: 121 Goetre Fawr Rd, Dunvant Swansea Comments: The effect on wildlife and the natural environment will be huge if this development goes ahead. The reduction of green spaces and opportunities for physical leisure pursuits for the local will have an effect on their physical and mental health. At a time when obesity and stress and anxiety disorders are on the increase, any development which has an adverse affect on these does not support the priorities of the local authority, national priorities on reducing obesity and increasing physical activity.

330. Name: Sue Dobney on Sep 13, 2011 Address: 63 Northcliffe Ave Nottingham NG3 6DA Comments: I have always considered that Local Authorities have too much power during their short stay in office. They can change the environment and lives and it is only their opinion. Their total constituency should have a referendum on issues as vital as building on sites such as the Clyne Valley. TOO LATE TO CHANGE BACK ONCE THESE BUREAUCRATS HAVE SPOKEN!

331. Name: Anonymous on Sep 13, 2011 Address: 121 goetre fawr road, dunvant,swansea Comments:

332. Name: Chris Grigson on Sep 13, 2011 Address: 16 Rhyd Yr Helyg, Sketty, Swansea, SA2 8DH Comments: This area is rich in historic artefacts, flora and fauna and provides a valuable breathing space for the west of Swansea.

333. Name: Sue Moorman on Sep 13, 2011 Address: 24 cliff path, lake, isle of wight. po36 8pl Comments: Please, do not nbuild on this gorgeous landscape that is home to many wonderful animials insects and wildlife, we must reasure and look after this land for future generations to enjoy as we all have.

334. Name: Saira Baldwin on Sep 13, 2011 Address: swansea Comments:

335. Name: Grace Birt on Sep 13, 2011 Address: 5, Birkdale Close, Mayals, Swansea. Comments: This area is an extremely important habitat for wildlife. Its ancient trees and varied vegetation and topography should be protected and maintained to ensure its continued status as a valued green wedge (EV23). If its edges are allowed to be nibbled away over the coming years and decades then future generations will end up with the same situation as has happened in Hendrefoilan - the total ruination of a very beautiful and rare habitat for wildlife that has been swallowed up by housing. To maintain a healthy society we cannot afford to lose any more of our precious ancient woodlands. It should be Swansea Council's goal to ensure the safety of green areas not only for it's residents but for the wildlife that has no voice of its own.

336. Name: RR Bullock on Sep 13, 2011 Address: 51 Cherry Grove SA2 8AU Comments: I strongly agree with the sentiments of this petition.

337. Name: Rachel Hall on Sep 13, 2011 Address: 55 Westport Avenue, Mayals Comments:

338. Name: Teresa De Vall on Sep 13, 2011 Address: 48, Manselfield Road, Murton Comments: GOOD LUCK!

339. Name: Liz Morris on Sep 13, 2011 Address: 2 Chesshyre Street, Brynmill, SA2 0DB Comments: Plenty of BROWNSITES in Swansea. Leave green area alone.

Page 27 of 37 340. Name: Brenda J Spence on Sep 13, 2011 Address: 85 West Cross Lane SA3 5LU Comments:

341. Name: Kay Rowlands on Sep 13, 2011 Address: 137, Saunders Way Comments: Far too much of our beautiful countryside is being developed . I don`t like the houses that are currently being built so close to the road on the site of the old Bible College in Derwen Fawr

342. Name: Nicky Stonelake on Sep 13, 2011 Address: 32 Gwerneinon Road, Derwen Fawr, Swansea SA2 8EW Comments:

343. Name: Marilyn Jones on Sep 13, 2011 Address: 14 Langland Terrace Brynmill Swansea SA2 0BB Comments: WE NEED GREEN SPACES AND AREAS OF NATURAL OUTSTANDING BEAUTY FOR ALL TO ENJOY IN THIS WORLD....

344. Name: Pamela Evans on Sep 13, 2011 Address: 10 Eastlands Park, Bishopston, Swansea, SA3 3DQ Comments: I grew up in Wimmerfield and recall going for walks through Clyne Valley. It is a relaxing walk and a place where children can be one with nature.

345. Name: Jackie Lyndon on Sep 13, 2011 Address: SA2 Comments: Keep Clyne green!

346. Name: Sue Bartle on Sep 14, 2011 Address: 32 heol y nant rhos Comments:

347. Name: Wenda Hall on Sep 14, 2011 Address: 5 Cwmfferws Road, Tycroes, Ammanford Comments: This area should be kept for people to enjoy the outdoors and as 'green lungs' for Swansea. It should not be built on - there are brown field sites that can be used for that!

348. Name: Robert Hasell on Sep 14, 2011 Address: 17 Falconwood Court, 24 Montpelier Row, LONDON SE3 0RS Comments: As a regular visitor to Swansea I have often walked with the dog in this area. It is a beautiful asset and the city should be proud of it. I cannot believe hat the council is proposing this act of vandalism.

349. Name: Dorothy Wilson on Sep 14, 2011 Address: 22 Bryn y Mor Crescent, Uplands, Swansea SA1 4QH Comments:

350. Name: Jackie Sawyers on Sep 14, 2011 Address: 39 Southlands Drive, West Cross, Swansea Comments: please save this space

351. Name: Roger Gadd on Sep 14, 2011 Address: 226 Derwen Fawr Road Swansea SA2 8EA Comments: With declining populations in general, the council should work much harder to redevelop some of the brownfield sites that are going to ruin.

352. Name: Jan Bradshaw on Sep 14, 2011 Address: bath Comments:

Page 28 of 37 353. Name: Tony Young on Sep 14, 2011 Address: 80 Eiddwen Rd. Penlan Swansea SA5 7EW Comments:

354. Name: Christianne Forrest on Sep 14, 2011 Address: 15 Tavisrock road Sketty Swansea SA2 0SL Comments:

355. Name: Kath Marks on Sep 14, 2011 Address: Leigh on Sea , Essex Comments:

356. Name: Margaret R Nicholls on Sep 14, 2011 Address: 11, Thistleboon Drive, Mumbles, Swansea Comments: This space must be retained for leisure use, it will be a criminal offence of residential housing is allowed. Swansea Council stated that it would keep all open spaces and Clyne Valley was one mentioned in this, so how can they change their minds so quickly. If the Council keep eating into all the areas of beauty in Swansea we will have nothing left but a concrete jungle with no where for the public to unwind and enjoy.

357. Name: Andrew Hayman on Sep 14, 2011 Address: 44 rue dumont d'urville, 78960 Voisins-le-Bretonneux, France Comments:

358. Name: Wendy Gadd on Sep 15, 2011 Address: 226, Derwen Fawr Road, Sketty, Swansea Comments:

359. Name: Caroline Bunce on Sep 15, 2011 Address: 27 Roath Court Road, Cardiff, CF24 3SD Comments:

360. Name: Andrea Gould on Sep 15, 2011 Address: Yellowstone House, Blavkhills Lane, Fairwood,SA2 7JN Comments:

361. Name: David Ashman on Sep 15, 2011 Address: 14 huntingdon way swansea Comments: Swansea is not short of brown field sites to build on. Taking this land is the lazy way out.

362. Name: Sian Mead on Sep 16, 2011 Address: 18a New Chapel Street, Treorchy, CF42 6RS Comments:

363. Name: Ann Cooke on Sep 16, 2011 Address: 74 Walter Road, Swansea SA1 4QA Comments: To lose this unique and precious nature trail, so popular and therapeutic for walkers and cyclists near the heart of our city, to residential development would be a great tragedy. Please re-think the LDP and preserve this site for future generations and for all our sakes.

364. Name: Robert Denley on Sep 16, 2011 Address: Brookvale, , Swansea SA2 7LD Comments: It is vital that Swansea keps its open recreational areas. Swansea's desire for building development without ensuring other facilites are adequate, as demostrated in the latest Marina free-for-all, must be checked.

365. Name: HILARY ASHWIN on Sep 16, 2011 Address: 2, LON ENFYS. TRALLWN. SWANSEA SA79XQ Comments: TOO MUCH OF OUR GREEN SPACE IS BEING TAKEN OVER TO BUILD ON, WE MUST PRESERVE ALL WE CAN

366. Name: Linda Barrett on Sep 16, 2011 Address: 3 Linkside Langland Swansea

Page 29 of 37 Comments:

367. Name: Zoe on Sep 16, 2011 Address: London NW6 Comments: Unbelievable what that council gets away with - I'm enraged!

368. Name: Avril Rolph on Sep 16, 2011 Address: Southgate, Gower Comments: Why aren't empty houses, upper floors above shops etc. being treated as priority housing spaces? This site, and many other proposed ones too, should remain as they are.

369. Name: J A Powell on Sep 16, 2011 Address: 1 GELLI GWYN ROAD, MORRISTON SWANSEA Comments: Please do not destroy this beautiful valley, it is a joy to look at, at any time of the year.

370. Name: Valerie Jones on Sep 16, 2011 Address: 12 Glynderwen Close Comments:

371. Name: Jack Cooke on Sep 16, 2011 Address: 74 Walter Road, Swansea SA1 4QA Comments: This is an absolute disgrace and all those responsible should be deeply ashamed of what they are even considering.

372. Name: Irene Ward on Sep 16, 2011 Address: 3 Mills Road Mel;ksham..SN12 7DT Comments: During the ten years I lived in Swansea, my family and I came to know and love the Clyne Valley. Swansea would be the poorer if this ancient and beautiful area were to be ruined by development.

373. Name: John Mallaburn on Sep 16, 2011 Address: 30 Gower Rd. Sketty. Swansea. SA2 9BY Comments: WITHDRAW IMMEDIATELY THIS SITE FROM THE ABOVE LDP AND RETAIN ITS STATUS AS GREEN WEDGE/COUNTRY PARK

374. Name: Alan Perry on Sep 16, 2011 Address: 76 Terrace Rd. Comments: Leave Clyne alone - stop profiteering on land that belongs to all of us!

375. Name: Michael Burns on Sep 17, 2011 Address: 19 millfield close derwen fawr swansea sa2 8bd Comments: Roads, infrastructure and environment alreadt overloaded. Future development should be guided to areas of swansea which have the capacity to absorb new buildings, people and activity. fro example NE, N and East swansea.

376. Name: Allyson Leavy on Sep 17, 2011 Address: 18 Ocean View Close Sketty Swansea Comments: Protect the valley and the animals that live there.

377. Name: G J Davies on Sep 17, 2011 Address: 62 Priors Way, Dunvant, Swansea, SA2 7UJ Comments: This is a glorious asset for visitors and residents alike. If Swansea is at all serious about enhancing its status as a tourism area, it must protect all these glorious parks. If new houses are needed, then every effort should be made to bring tired/derelict houses in the city centre to life or to develop on brown field sites on the edge, where industry has moved out. The bay and the green lungs, such as Clyne and Singleton, are the best assets the City has. Do not destroy them!

378. Name: Jeremy Cartwright on Sep 17, 2011 Address: 18 Ocean View Close, Sketty, Swansea Comments: The benefits of established "green areas" will be there for all citizens to enjoy - housing developments do not benefit those already living in the area - work it out for yourselves, council members

379. Name: Mavis Williams on Sep 17, 2011 Address: 12 Briarwood Close, SA10 7UH

Page 30 of 37 Comments: Please retain Clyne Valley as a country park

380. Name: Angela.Ball on Sep 17, 2011 Address: 12 Golwg Hafren, Sketty Comments:

381. Name: Aida Birch on Sep 17, 2011 Address: 59 Danygraig Road;Melincryddan Comments: An area of outstanding beauty, ancient trees, wildflowers and wild-life. Unsuitable for a housing development, houses could be prone to flooding.

382. Name: Maggie Jones on Sep 17, 2011 Address: 115 Heol Hafdy SA7 9RZ Comments:

383. Name: A D Halls on Sep 18, 2011 Address: Woking, Surrey Comments: These green lungs are vital in builkt up areas and must be saved for our health and future generations

384. Name: Jeffrey Giansiracusa on Sep 18, 2011 Address: 12 Druids Close, SA3 5TY Comments: The Clyne valley is a magical place for me and hundreds of others who use it regularly. It would be a tragedy to lose it to development.

385. Name: Abi Cherry on Sep 18, 2011 Address: 289 Dunvant Road, Dunvant, Swansea Comments:

386. Name: Stuart Cairns on Sep 18, 2011 Address: 42 Rhyd-y-Defaid drive, Swansea Comments:

387. Name: Olwen Fyfe-Williams on Sep 18, 2011 Address: 77a St Francis Rd, Salisbury, Wilts SP1 3QR Comments: Swansea's centre needs attention. Convert/modify and improve existing sites then the new homes necessary will be close to facilities and people still have access to something green.

388. Name: Sian Raichoudhury on Sep 18, 2011 Address: 33 Hen Parc Lane, Upper Killay, Swansea, SA2 7EY Comments: This is another incursion into a valuable green space.

389. Name: Rebecca Clifford on Sep 18, 2011 Address: 12 Druids Close, Mumbles, Swansea Comments:

390. Name: Katy Beard on Sep 19, 2011 Address: 42 Rhyd-y-Defaid drive, Swansea Comments: Such a beautiful area used by many should not be destroyed!

391. Name: Liz Slack on Sep 19, 2011 Address: 1 Blackhills Lane Comments:

392. Name: Carol Slack on Sep 19, 2011 Address: 1 Blackhills Lane Comments:

393. Name: Claire Whomes on Sep 19, 2011

Page 31 of 37 Address: 98 pennard drive, southgate, Gower, Swansea SA3 2DP Comments:

394. Name: Natalie Thomas on Sep 19, 2011 Address: 154 Overland Road SA3 4EU Comments:

395. Name: Anonymous on Sep 19, 2011 Address: 28 Lon Pen Y Coed, SA2 0YE Comments:

396. Name: Eleanor Lewis on Sep 19, 2011 Address: 37,heneage drive,west cross Comments:

397. Name: Nicola Davies on Sep 19, 2011 Address: 1 Howard's Way, Gorseinon, Swansea Comments: Is nowhere sacred anymore? Leave us to enjoy what little there is of green countryside PLEASE!

398. Name: Jamie Taylor on Sep 19, 2011 Address: 5 haulwen road cockett swansea sa2 0gg Comments:

399. Name: Simon Orchard on Sep 19, 2011 Address: 39 maes-y-felin Comments:

400. Name: I. Seaton on Sep 19, 2011 Address: 28 Slade Rd, Newton, Mumbles. Comments: I object to the destruction of this beautiful area which gives so much pleasure to so many people and which has a very rich history attached to it. The remaining green areas of Swansea seem to be under increasing threat from the shortsghted policies of the Council. To allow building in this area would be an unforgiveable act of municipal vandalism. The houses built on such developments are in any case rarely affordable by local people so this proposal makes no sense from any perspective. Clyne Valley should be left as it is.

401. Name: Les Taylor on Sep 19, 2011 Address: 23 Halleys Court Woking Comments:

402. Name: Dr Farhan Husain on Sep 20, 2011 Address: 4 Rhyd Yr Helyg Comments: The natural beauty of the area will be devastated if building is not stopped.

403. Name: Naomi Trodden (nee Jones) on Sep 20, 2011 Address: 12 Queens Road, Mumbles, Swansea SA3 4AN Comments:

404. Name: Freya Fenton on Sep 20, 2011 Address: 39 Maes-Y-Felin, Swansea Comments: There is nowhere in the local area with the same natural beauty - please don't destroy it with more over-priced housing none of the local people can afford and that truly isn't needed!

405. Name: Ian Hodgson on Sep 20, 2011 Address: 6 Kingston Road SA2 0SS Comments:

406. Name: Robert Jones on Sep 20, 2011 Address: 617, Gower Road, Upper Killay, SWANSEA Comments: Environmentally disastrous - more traffic, dense development - wrecking a wildlife corridor from the City to Gower

Page 32 of 37 407. Name: David Rees on Sep 20, 2011 Address: 664 Gower Road, Upper Killay, Swansea SA2 7HE Comments: Clyne Valley is a beautiful Nature Reserve on the edge of Gower. How could ANYONE wish to systematically destroy this for no apparent reason. I am a long term member of the Gower Ornithological Society, & have been birding here for over 20 years.There are many varied species here that NEED this environment. Think again!

408. Name: Laura Maisie Hayman on Sep 20, 2011 Address: 18 westbourne Grove Sketty Comments: This valley is still being explored for evidence of our industrial heritage. the planned building would barr the area from further investigation.

409. Name: Laura Maisie Hayman on Sep 20, 2011 Address: 18 westbourne Grove Sketty Comments: My husband pioneered the exploration of the valley and documented evidence he found of its industrial history. A great deal of interest was generated by slide shows and talks which he gave in Swansea and further afield.The Clyne project continues to explore the valley and valuable sites would be lost if building is allowed.

410. Name: Julia Martin on Sep 20, 2011 Address: Parkmill, Gower Comments:

411. Name: Tyrone Jenkins on Sep 20, 2011 Address: 65 westbury Street, Swansea SA1 4JN Comments:

412. Name: Rosemary Davies on Sep 21, 2011 Address: Crown Meadow, Coalway, Coleford, Glos Comments:

413. Name: Julie Gallagher on Sep 21, 2011 Address: 48 Eastdean Drive Leeds LS14 1HG Comments:

414. Name: Duncan James Smith on Sep 22, 2011 Address: 57 oakridge sketty park,swansea Comments: Until there is a pious Government that rules according to the Vedic spiritual laws it will always be problematic .Chant the Holy names of Lord sri Krishna.

415. Name: Philippa Morgan on Sep 22, 2011 Address: 13 Victoria Road, Devizes, Wiltshire, SN10 1ET Comments: I believe that devlopment of Clyne Valley for housing would be the wrong thing to do and that this ancient woodland should be designated as an area which should NEVER be built on. It should be preserved as one of the good things which is still left in Swansea, and there are precious few of those.

416. Name: Angharad Evans on Sep 23, 2011 Address: 53 Pentrebane St, Cardiff CF11 7LN Comments:

417. Name: Kathryn Wilkins on Sep 24, 2011 Address: 22 gwerneinon road sketty swansea sa28en Comments:

418. Name: Derek Smith on Sep 24, 2011 Address: 1 Plas Newydd, Cwm Ifor Road, Burry Port Comments: I first came to live in Swansea in 1956. This is the saddest thing that I have heard about the area. Surely the people of Swansea will not let this happen.

419. Name: Arthur Hendey. on Sep 24, 2011

Page 33 of 37 Address: 245 heol gwyrosydd,penlan,swansea. SA5 7BT Comments:

420. Name: Roy Morgan on Sep 25, 2011 Address: 266 Derwen Fawr Road, Sketty, Swansea, SA2 8EJ Comments: Not another threat to the Clyne area! We have the Bible College new carbuncle estate, are threatened with obliterating the large garden opposite with yet more houses and goodness knows what else. Now an area that has enormous leisure and recreational potential could be eroded away.

421. Name: TIM ATKINSON on Sep 25, 2011 Address: 79 COMBE ST.,CHARD, SOMERSET Comments: WHEN I LIVED IN SWANSEA I ENJOYED THE OPEN SPACES WHICH THE CITY HAS TO OFFER. ONCE THEY ARE GONE, YOU CANNOT GET THEM BACK.

422. Name: Richard Hope on Sep 25, 2011 Address: 75 Priors Way, Dunvant, Swansea, SA2 7UH Comments:

423. Name: Dr Russ Harris on Sep 25, 2011 Address: 11 Coed Mor, Sketty, Swansea Comments: I have walked through these woods for many years, from my previous home in Gowerton and my current home in Sketty. It is a thoroughfare for people without using cars, very topical, don't you think?

424. Name: David & Jill Dickinson on Sep 25, 2011 Address: 1, Royal Oak Road, Derwen Fawr, Swansea Comments: We suppport the above submission

425. Name: Yvonne Mccoubrey on Sep 25, 2011 Address: 10 Northbrook Road Comments:

426. Name: Tom Morris on Sep 25, 2011 Address: 26 Romilly Road, Canton Cardiff Comments: Please preserve Wales' beautiful landscape

427. Name: Rhys Pillai on Sep 25, 2011 Address: 57 rotherslade road, swansea Comments:

428. Name: Adell Bridges on Sep 26, 2011 Address: 9 springfield ave, swansea Comments:

429. Name: Mark Holverson on Sep 26, 2011 Address: 62 Glanmor Road, Uplands, Swansea Comments:

430. Name: Rob Ronconi on Sep 26, 2011 Address: 555 gower rd upper killay, swansea Comments:

431. Name: Mrs Deborah Avington on Sep 26, 2011 Address: 23 Warwick Road SA2 8DY Comments:

432. Name: Jennifer Power on Sep 26, 2011 Address: 27rhyd-y-defaid drive derwen fawr Swansea Comments: the Marina has been ruined by over building,housing on the lower derwen fawr road is packed together-don't let the

Page 34 of 37 valley and the environment be destroyed in this area

433. Name: Ann Iles on Sep 26, 2011 Address: 37 Gwerneinon Road Sketty Comments: How can they even think of doing this

434. Name: Clare Hazell on Sep 26, 2011 Address: 18 glynderwen close, derwen fawr, swansea Comments:

435. Name: John Gregson on Sep 26, 2011 Address: 71 quixote Cresent Frindsbury kent ME2 3XB Comments:

436. Name: P Collier on Sep 26, 2011 Address: 15 warwick rd Derwen Fawr Comments:

437. Name: Valerie Bullock on Sep 26, 2011 Address: 51 Cherry Grove Swansea SA2 8AU Comments:

438. Name: Glenys Lee on Sep 26, 2011 Address: 13 Vincent Close, Bromley Comments:

439. Name: Roger Rees on Sep 26, 2011 Address: Gwerneinon Road, Derwen Fawr, Sketty, Swansea Comments: Leave the green sites alone, if you have to build, do it on the many brown sites in Swansea.

440. Name: Sally on Sep 26, 2011 Address: 25 rhyd yr helyg, sketty, swansea sa2 8dh Comments: leave Clyne valley alone. Build houses on brown field sites and perserve the beautful green lungs of the city

441. Name: Diane Legg on Sep 27, 2011 Address: 17dombeyhousehenrydickenscourtlondonw114dw Comments: Preserve and keep the green spaces which are our heritage for the next generation.

442. Name: Anthea Symonds on Sep 27, 2011 Address: 9 Hendy Close, Derwen Fawr Comments: NO No NO Not more lego land buildings which will not sell at outrageous prices and become a blot. Use brownfield sites - Swansea has many of them.

443. Name: Georgina Hayman on Sep 28, 2011 Address: 42, Lon Cadog, Sketty, Swansea SA2 0TN Comments:

444. Name: J Ryan on Sep 28, 2011 Address: 17 Aneruin Way, Sketty, Swansea Comments:

445. Name: Angharad Griffiths on Sep 28, 2011 Address: 17 Aneruin Way, Sketty, Swansea Comments:

446. Name: Jane Davies on Sep 28, 2011 Address: 29 Warwick Road, Sketty Swansea SA2 8DY Comments: This area of beautiful countryside does not need houses built on it. I walk quite often in the country park and surroundings, as do alot of people, and so not wish to see houses in the near vicinity. Surely it is better for the City and County of

Page 35 of 37 Swansea to have open spaces for people to exercise in than extra un-necessary houses. There are ample brown field sites to use first.

447. Name: David Pilot on Sep 28, 2011 Address: 25 Royal Oak Road Comments:

448. Name: Andi Hatwood on Sep 28, 2011 Address: 47 webster ave, cv82ej Comments: i visit the country park once a year after visiting the site where my grandmother's ashes were scattered (we make the trip yearly and tour around wales before heading into / bristol bridge). it would be devistating to visit next year and find hundreds of houses in such a beautiful setting. there are plenty of disused areas to regenerate rather than treading into parklands.

i work for the local council over here as a youth worker. i work mostly on intervention work but work on other projects as a forest schools leader and teach the children to go into natural environments and appreciate what it offers to us / them, and how we should respect where we live. I cannot highlight how much they learn and enjoy their natural settings and how much it supports their learning.

it would be a total shame to destroy such environments (for the sake of profit for some), i can appreciate that the government have figures to meet in providing housing but regeneration will firstly keep sacred places (parks) safe and teach the new generation on how to recycle areas/ land respecting where they live rather than moving on to new beautiful locations to devastate there.

by all means contact me on this subject as i have more to say!

449. Name: Lynne Davies on Sep 29, 2011 Address: 44 Grove Road,Pontardawe, Swansea Comments: There is so much land within the city of Swansea that has derelict warehouses on that will never be used again for industry and we have a city centre that has so many empty shop units that could be used in other way and the solution to lack of housing is to build on the beautiful green spaces we have??? That's just crazy . Keep the green space and solve the problems of housing in a more creative way.

450. Name: Duncan Croft on Sep 29, 2011 Address: 80 howells rd. dunvant swansea Comments: stop destroying swansea there will soon be nothing left to enjoy.

451. Name: Dawn Smith on Sep 29, 2011 Address: 1 Bryntirion, Pontyberem, Llanelli SA15 5BX Comments:

452. Name: C. M. Pearce on Sep 29, 2011 Address: 51 Gelli Aur, Treboeth, Swansea Comments:

453. Name: Martin Lloyd on Sep 29, 2011 Address: 12 Ystrad Einon, Gorseinon, Swansea Comments: It defies comprehension that this proposal is even being considered. Clyne Valley is such a precious asset. Surely our council can't be that stupid.

454. Name: J.E.Thomas on Sep 29, 2011 Address: 12 Windmill Terrace, St. Thomas, Swansea, SA1 8DDN Comments:

455. Name: G.Bailey on Sep 29, 2011 Address: 15 St. James Court, Uplands, Swansea Comments:

456. Name: M.Thomas on Sep 29, 2011 Address: 14 Warwick Rd, Sketty, Swansea, SA2 8DY Comments:

Page 36 of 37 457. Name: Cath Davies on Sep 29, 2011 Address: pontardawe, swansea Comments:

458. Name: Tamsin Josty on Sep 29, 2011 Address: 62 owls lodge lane, swansea Comments: I strongly object to plans to develop the clyne valley site

459. Name: Anwen Cale on Sep 29, 2011 Address: 33 Maytree Avenue, West Cross, Swansea Comments:

460. Name: Rob Anderson on Sep 29, 2011 Address: 1 Canterbury Road, Brynmill, SWansea SA2 0DD Comments:

Page 37 of 37

Powered by TCPDF (www.tcpdf.org)