Frontline-Ph1-Wk8-Themelios-44-1.Pdf
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
An International Journal for Students of Theological and Religious Studies Volume 44 Issue 1 April 2019 EDITORIAL: Themelios Then and Now: The Journal’s 1 Name, History, and Contribution by Brian J. Tabb STRANGE TIMES: Sad Solo by Daniel Strange 6 The Continuation of the Charismata by Andrew Wilson 16 A Response to Andrew Wilson by Thomas R. Schreiner 23 It All Depends Upon Prophecy: A Brief Case for 29 Nuanced Cessationism by Thomas R. Schreiner A Response to Tom Schreiner by Andrew Wilson 36 Towards a Definition of New Testament Prophecy 41 by Richard M. Blaylock The Boundaries of the Gift of Tongues: With 61 Implications for Cessationism and Continuationism by Vern S. Poythress Biblical Words and Theological Meanings: 70 Sanctification as Consecration for Transformation by Ben C. Dunson Finessing Independent Attestation: 89 A Study in Interdisciplinary Biblical Criticism by Lydia McGrew Disputation for Scholastic Theology: Engaging 105 Luther’s 97 Theses by Michael Allen Book Reviews 120 DESCRIPTION Themelios is an international, evangelical, peer-reviewed theological journal that expounds and defends the historic Christian faith. Its primary audience is theological students and pastors, though scholars read it as well. Themelios began in 1975 and was operated by RTSF/UCCF in the UK, and it became a digital journal operated by The Gospel Coalition in 2008. The editorial team draws participants from across the globe as editors, essayists, and reviewers. Themelios is published three times a year online at The Gospel Coalition website in PDF and HTML, and may be purchased in digital format with Logos Bible Software and in print with Wipf and Stock. Themelios is copyrighted by The Gospel Coalition. Readers are free to use it and circulate it in digital form without further permission, but they must acknowledge the source and may not change the content. EDITORS BOOK REVIEW EDITORS Editor: Brian Tabb Old Testament Systematic Theology and Bioethics Bethlehem College & Seminary Peter Lau David Garner 720 13th Avenue South Malaysian Theological Seminary Westminster Theological Seminary Minneapolis, MN 55415, USA Seremban, Malaysia 2960 Church Road [email protected] [email protected] Glenside, PA 19038, USA [email protected] Contributing Editor and President: New Testament Donald A. Carson David Starling Ethics and Pastoralia Trinity Evangelical Divinity School Morling College Rob Smith 2065 Half Day Road 120 Herring Road Sydney Missionary and Bible College Deerfield, IL 60015, USA Macquarie Park, NSW 2113, Australia 43 Badminton Road [email protected] [email protected] Croydon NSW 2132, Australia [email protected] Contributing Editor: Daniel Strange History and Historical Theology Oak Hill Theological College Geoff Chang Mission and Culture Chase Side, Southgate Hinson Baptist Church Jackson Wu London, N14 4PS, UK 1315 Southeast 20th Avenue International Chinese Theological [email protected] Portland, OR 97214, USA Seminary [email protected] East Asia Administrator: Andy Naselli [email protected] Bethlehem College & Seminary 720 13th Avenue South Minneapolis, MN 55415, USA [email protected] EDITORIAL BOARD Gerald Bray, Beeson Divinity School; Hassell Bullock, Wheaton College; Lee Gatiss, Wales Evangelical School of Theology; Paul Helseth, University of Northwestern, St. Paul; Paul House, Beeson Divinity School; Hans Madueme, Covenant College; Ken Magnuson, The Southern Baptist Theological Seminary; Gavin Ortlund, First Baptist Church, Ojai; Jonathan Pennington, The Southern Baptist Theological Seminary; Mark D. Thompson,Moore Theological College; Paul Williamson, Moore Theological College; Mary Willson, Second Presbyterian Church; Stephen Witmer, Pepperell Christian Fellowship; Robert Yarbrough, Covenant Seminary. ARTICLES Themeliostypically publishes articles that are 4,000 to 9,000 words (including footnotes). Prospective contributors should submit articles by email to the managing editor in Microsoft Word (.doc or .docx) or Rich Text Format (.rtf). Submissions should not include the author’s name or institutional affiliation for blind peer-review. Articles should use clear, concise English and should consistently adopt either UK or USA spelling and punctuation conventions. Special characters (such as Greek and Hebrew) require a Unicode font. Abbreviations and bibliographic references should conform to The SBL Handbook of Style (2nd ed.), supplemented by The Chicago Manual of Style (16th ed.). For examples of the the journal's style, consult the most recent Themelios issues and the contributor guidelines. REVIEWS The book review editors generally select individuals for book reviews, but potential reviewers may contact them about reviewing specific books. As part of arranging book reviews, the book review editors will supply book review guidelines to reviewers. Themelios 44.1 (2019): 1–5 EDITORIAL ThemeliosThen and Now: The Journal’s Name, History, and Contribution — Brian J. Tabb — Brian Tabb is academic dean and associate professor of biblical studies at Bethlehem College & Seminary in Minneapolis and general editor of Themelios. requently my computer or “smart” phone autocorrects Themelios to Themeless. The latter would make a rather unfortunate name for an international journal of theology! In this editorial, I will reflect on the journal’s name, its history, and my hopes for its future contribution. We certainly Fwouldn’t want Themelios to become “theme-less.” 1. The Journal’s Name The journal’s name transliterates the Greek term θεμέλιος, which is typically rendered “foundation” in its fifteen NT occurrences. θεμέλιος refers to the foundation on which a building rests. Jesus highlights the utter folly of constructing a house with no foundation (Luke 6:49)—a warning to those who would hear his words and not heed them. Likewise, he urges would-be disciples to count the cost lest their lives resemble an abandoned construction project with a foundation but no tower on it (Luke 14:27–30). Paul stresses that the church is “God’s building” established on the secure foundation of Jesus Christ (1 Cor 3:9–11). The apostle identifies Jewish and Gentile believers together as “members of the household of God, built on the foundation [ἐπὶ τῷ θεμελίῳ] of the apostles and prophets, Christ Jesus himself being the cornerstone, in whom the whole structure, being joined together, grows into a holy temple in the Lord” (Eph 2:19–21). 2. The Journal’s History The International Fellowship of Evangelical Students first published the journal Themelios in October 1962.1 The initial volume featured articles by Howard Marshall, Donald Guthrie, Leon Morris, Francis Schaeffer, and others, as well as a fine exposition of Ephesians 2:20 by the Irish missionary theologian 1 This section reflects insights gleaned from personal correspondence in February 2019 with the following current and former editors and editorial board members of Themelios: Gerald Bray, D. A. Carson, Andy Naselli, Dan Strange, Carl Trueman, Stephen Williams, and Stephen Witmer. 1 Themelios R. J. McKelvey.2 McKelvey reasons that Isaiah 28:16 lies behind the NT authors’ figurative references to Christ as the “cornerstone” and “foundation” laid in Zion. As the cornerstone (ἀκρογωνιαῖος), Christ not only supports the superstructure of God’s house but also serves to unify it as it is built (συναρμολογέω in Eph 2:21). McKelvey argues that the difficult phrase “the foundation of the apostles and prophets” refers to the twelve apostles and the OT prophets as the foundation on whom membership in the church rests for Gentile and Jewish believers alike. The journal’s first editor, Andrew F. Walls, describes Themelios as an international and interdenominational journal “addressed to theological students, and all who are preparing for the Christian ministry, throughout the world.”3 Appealing to Ephesians 2:20, Walls stresses that the journal is concerned with “the bed-rock foundation of the historic faith” and Christ, who holds the apostolic building together. He concludes: The scope of THEMELIOS is the whole of Christian theology: the entire field of the Christian pastor and theologian. In this field, all the powers of the mind are called into service, and the journal will seek to provide information and to provoke thought – sometimes about issues which today are often too lightly dismissed. A humble and a loving heart is also a requirement, and THEMELIOS will have failed if it does nothing to stir its readers to adoration and to devotion.4 In 1975, the Religious & Theological Students Fellowship, part of the Universities and Colleges Christian Fellowship in the UK, took over publishing Themelios. At this time the journal merged with Theological Students Fellowship Bulletin, a periodical that began circulating in Autumn 1951 and published a total of seventy-two volumes featuring short articles by noted theologians like J. I. Packer, F. F. Bruce, and Howard Marshall. The first issue in the relaunched version of Themelios featured articles by J. I. Packer (“Hermeneutics and Biblical Authority”), the new journal’s first editor R. T. France (“Inerrancy and New Testament Exegesis”), and Robert P. Gordon (“Preaching from the Patriarchs”). In January 1978, Robert Norris succeeded R. T. France as general editor and held the position until David Wenham took over in January 1982. Following Wenham, Themelios was edited by Christopher J. H. Wright (1990–1994),