Public Document Pack Committee and Members’ Services Section rd 3 Floor, Adelaide Exchange 24-26 Adelaide Street Belfast BT2 8GD

Friday, 15 February 2008

MEETING OF TOWN PLANNING COMMITTEE

Dear Councillor

The above-named Committee will meet in the Council Chamber, 3rd Floor, Adelaide Exchange on Thursday, 21st February, 2008 at 4.30 pm, for the transaction of the business noted below.

You are requested to attend.

Yours faithfully

PETER McNANEY

Chief Executive

AGENDA:

1. Routine Matters

(a) Apologies

(b) Minutes (Pages 1 - 8)

To adopt the minutes of the meeting of 7 th February.

2. Routine Correspondence (Pages 9 - 10)

3. Request for Deputations

4. Presentations from Statutory Bodies

(a) Northern Ireland Water (Page 11)

(b) Roads Service (Page 12)

5. Northern Ireland Housing Executive (Pages 13 - 14)

6. Housing Needs Conference (Pages 15 - 18)

- 2 - 7. Planning Appeals

(a) Appeal under Article 33 (Pages 19 - 22)

Site East of Ballygomartin Reservoir, Ballygomartin Road Proposal for mixed residential development of 144 dwellings

(b) Appeal under Article 69(5) (Pages 23 - 32)

Appeal against enforcement notice re the unauthorised erection of pigeon lofts at 14 Gransha Way.

8. Delegated Authority (Pages 33 - 72)

9. New Applications (Pages 73 - 98)

10. Schedule of Applications

(a) Deferred Items (Pages 99 - 100)

(b) Belfast Council Schedule -21st February 2008 (Pages 101 - 128)

(c) Applicatios deferred at previous meetings and still under consideration (Pages 129 - 144)

Page 1 Agenda Item 1b

G 116 Town Planning Committee

Thursday, 7th February, 2008

MEETING OF TOWN PLANNING COMMITTEE

Members present: Councillor Lavery (Chairman); the Deputy Lord Mayor (Councillor Kelly); and Councillors Campbell, Cobain, Hendron, Long, Maginness, C. Maskey, McCausland, McCoubrey, McGimpsey, Moore, O’Neill, Patterson, Rodway, Smyth and Wilson.

In attendance: Mr. R. Boyd, Members’ Support Officer; Mr. J. Heaney, Committee Administrator; and Mr. P. Montgomery ) Divisional Mr. J. King ) Planning Office.

Apologies

Apologies for inability to attend were reported from Councillors McCarthy and McClenaghan.

Minutes

The minutes of the meeting of the 24th January were taken as read and signed as correct. It was reported that those minutes together with the minutes of 10th January had been adopted by the Council at its meeting on 4th February, subject to the omission of matters in respect of which the Council had delegated its powers to the Committee.

Routine Correspondence

It was reported that correspondence had been received from various Statutory Bodies in connection with the undernoted items:

Notification from the Northern Ireland Housing Executive of its intention to make an extinguishment of a Public Right-of-Way Order in respect of Swift Place.

Notification from the Northern Ireland Housing Executive of the making of an extinguishment of a Public Right-of-Way Order relating to a portion of Jamaica Street.

Copies of the Orders, letters and maps relating to the above matters were displayed at the meeting for the information of the Members.

The Committee noted the information provided. Page 2

G Town Planning Committee, 117 Thursday, 7th February, 2008

Request for Deputations

The Committee was advised that no requests for deputations had been received.

Future Planning Conferences

The Committee considered the undernoted report in respect of two conferences organised by the Royal Town Planning Institute:

“Relevant Background Information

Notification has been received of two conferences which have been organised by the Royal Town Planning Institute.

Key Issues

The conferences will provide relevant and accessible information for all stakeholders with an interest of involvement in planning and development and, in particular, with the provision of quality sustainability and affordable housing. The conferences will consider issues such as improving the quality of new houses, the importance of planning and raising the quality of design.

Speakers from both local and international fields of expertise in planning issues will participate at each of the conferences and will include Mr. Robin Tetlow, a leading specialist on planning and housing, Mr. Ricky Taylor, Head of Research and Principal Research Advisor for the National Housing and Planning Advice Unit. Mr. Jim Fox, Director of Taylor Young, responsible for urban regeneration and master planning.

The conferences will be structured around a series of lectures from the keynote speakers and each Conference will provide an opportunity for discussion sessions.

Conference Dates and Locations

The two conferences will be held on the following dates and at the undernoted locations:

(i) 9th Annual Housing Design Conference 2008 New Connaught Rooms, London 27th March, 2008/26th September 2008

(ii) 5th Annual Housing Pressures Conference 2008 New Connaught Rooms, London 12th March, 2008 Page 3

Town Planning Committee, G Thursday, 7th February, 2008 118

Resource Implications

The approximate cost per delegate of attending the conferences is set out hereunder:

Conference fees £449 Travel and Accommodation £300

Recommendations

The Committee is recommended to authorise the attendance at the conferences of the Chairman, the Deputy Chairman and the Head of Committee and Members’ Services (or their nominees)”

After discussion, the Committee adopted the recommendation contained within the report and agreed also to authorise the payment of the Conference fees, together with the appropriate travel and subsistence allowances in connection therewith.

Planning Applications

121 Fortwilliam Park

The Committee considered further an application in respect of the alterations to ground levels to form a patio and the construction of retaining wall and timber fence to the rear of the above-mentioned dwelling, for which the Divisional Planning Manager had offered an opinion to approve.

After discussion, the Committee agreed, with one Member voting against, to adopt the recommendation to approve the application.

(As the decision was not unanimous it was subject to ratification by the Council.)

28 Cranmore Gardens

The Committee considered further a planning application in respect of the erection of a two-storey extension to the rear of the above-mentioned dwelling, a two-storey detached garage and a new boundary fence together with alterations to the access, for which the Divisional Planning Manager had offered an opinion to approve.

After discussion, the Committee agreed, with one Member voting against, to adopt the recommendation of the Divisional Planning Manager.

(As the decision was not unanimous it was subject to ratification by the Council.)

THE COMMITTEE DEALT WITH THE FOLLOWING ITEMS IN PURSUANCE OF THE POWERS DELEGATED TO IT BY THE COUNCIL AT ITS MEETING ON 1st NOVEMBER, 1973

Planning Applications

Delegated Authority

The Committee noted a list of planning applications which had been approved under the delegated authority of the Committee at its meeting on 24th January. Page 4

G Town Planning Committee, 119 Thursday, 7th February, 2008

New Applications

The Committee noted a list of planning applications which had been received from the Divisional Planning Manager for the Belfast City Council area for the period from 8th January till 21st January, 2008.

Revised Opinions

The Committee considered the undernoted planning applications in respect of which the Divisional Planning Manager had offered revised opinions:

Site and Applicant Description Divisional Planning Manager’s Opinion

2 Hawthornden Gardens, Two-storey extension with garage Approval Mr. T. Robinson on ground floor and bedroom above (garden store to rear)

52 South Parade, Single-storey extension to rear of Approval Mr. G. McCann dwelling with balcony at first floor level

After discussion, the Committee concurred with the Divisional Planning Manager’s opinion.

Reconsidered Items

The Committee considered further the undernoted planning applications and, after discussion, agreed with the Divisional Planning Manager’s opinion thereon:

Site and Applicant Description Divisional Planning Manager’s Opinion

5 Violet Street, Two-storey extension and creation Approval T and D Properties of dormer window at the rear of the dwelling

23 Norwood Drive, Two-storey extension to side of Approval Mr and Mrs N. Boomer dwelling, single-storey rear extension, construction of rear dormer window and single-storey porch to front of premises

18 Willowbank Gardens, Change of use from dwelling to Refusal Mr. T. Haller two apartments with two-storey rear extension

Page 5

Town Planning Committee, G Thursday, 7th February, 2008 120

Site and Applicant Description Divisional Planning Manager’s Opinion

21 Eglantine Avenue, Conversion of ten-bedroom Refusal Mr. J. Devlin guesthouse to one two-bedroom flat and four one-bedroom flats including alterations and extensions and replacement of store

Applications Withdrawn

The Committee was informed that the undernoted planning application had been withdrawn from the schedule as it had been submitted in error:

Site and Applicant Proposal

215 Upper Meadow Street, Proposed construction of corner Ms. M. Masterson community shop

Schedule of Applications

The Committee considered the Schedule of planning applications which had been submitted by the Divisional Planning Manager in respect of the Belfast City Council area and agreed to adopt the recommendations submitted in relation to the application therein, with the exception of those referred to below:

Location Proposal

35-37 Diamond Gardens Residential development of forty-six apartment units with associated basement car parking and associated landscaping [Deferred at the request of the Deputy Lord Mayor (Councillor Kelly) to enable an office meeting to take place]

Site adjacent to 5 Downview Erection of dwelling with detached Avenue garage [Deferred at the request of Councillor Maginness to enable an office meeting to take place]

Page 6

G Town Planning Committee, 121 Thursday, 7th February, 2008

Location Proposal

Site fronts onto Demolition of all buildings on site and 157-161 North Street and onto construction of mixed use scheme to 40-44 Kent Street include retail on ground floor and ninety-seven apartments with associated car parking [Deferred at the request of Councillor Smyth to enable an office meeting to take place]

406-408 Upper Change of use at ground floor level Newtownards Road from restaurant to public house [Deferred at the request of Councillor Cobain to enable an office meeting to take place]

193a West Circular Road Demolition of existing property and replacement of ground floor retail units and six one-bedroom and two two-bedroom apartments [Deferred at the request of Councillor McCoubrey to enable an office meeting to take place]

6 Ravenhill Park Single-storey extension to rear of dwelling [Deferred at the request of Councillor Hendron to enable an office meeting to take place]

29 Whitehall Parade Replacement of end terrace with four apartments [Deferred at the request of Councillor Wilson to enable an office meeting to take place]

Land to the rear of Carnegie Residential development of thirty-five Hall between Utility Street and apartments to include associated Eureka Drive, works (including social and private Donegall Road units) [Deferred at the request of Councillor Stalford to enable an office meeting to take place]

Page 7

Town Planning Committee, G Thursday, 7th February, 2008 122

Location Proposal

114 Upper Lisburn Road Amendment to previously approved plan (Demolition of dwelling and erection of new building to accommodate six apartments) for the erection of three-storey building containing nine apartments and related siteworks [Deferred at the request of Councillor Patterson to enable an office meeting to take place]

339 Shankill Road Erection of ground floor retail unit and three apartments on the upper two floors including one duplex apartment [Deferred at the request of Councillor Smyth to enable an office meeting to take place]

3 Edinburgh Street Demolition of two apartments and erection of four-storey block containing four apartments [Deferred at the request of Councillor Patterson to enable an office meeting to take place]

44 Wellesley Avenue Change of use from dwelling to two apartments including two-storey rear extension construction of new vehicle access to provide off-street parking [Deferred at the request of Councillor Hanna to enable an office meeting to take place]

43 Osbourne Park Demolition of rear return and erection of two-storey rear and side extensions, construction of garden store along rear boundary [Deferred at the request of Councillor Wilson to enable an office meeting to take place]

Chairman Page 8

Page 9 Agenda Item 2

Town Planning Committee Thursday 21 st February , 2008

Routine Correspondence

The Committee’s comments, if any, have been sought in relation to the undernoted items:

No items have been received at this time

The Committee will be advised at the meeting of any further routine correspondence received.

Page 10

This page has intentionally been left blank

Page 11 Agenda Item 4a

Copy of e-mail from Northern Ireland Water

From: Preston, Simon Sent: 03 October 2007 12:32 To: '[email protected]' Subject: Capital Works Programme Presentations to Local Councils Dear Mr McNaney As elected representatives, Northern Ireland Water recognises that local Councillors are a vital link between our organisation and our customers. I would therefore like to invite you to submit a request for a representation from Northern Ireland Water to attend a Council meeting over the next 6 months to present our Capital Works Programme for the area and answer any general queries you may have in respect of our service. If you would like us to attend a Council meeting, I would request that you please complete the attached form and return it to me at this email address. In order to accommodate all Councils and allow us to prepare the necessary documentation, it would be helpful if you could suggest 4 potential dates. We normally require at least 4 weeks notice. We will then respond in writing confirming the most suitable date and advise you of any further details. If you have any queries, please do not hesitate to contact me on 07890 520 332. Kind regards, Simon Preston Strategic Customer Liaison Officer 07890520332

Page 12 Agenda Item 4b

Copy of e-mail request from Roads Service

Folks,

It's that time of year again when we schedule the bi-annual meetings with Roads Service.

I would envisage the Spring meetings taking place within a six week window commencing from Monday 28th April . Please e-mail me of your first and second preference dates and I will confirm one in due course.

Whilst the Autumn scheduling seems ages away it would be useful to identify relevant dates as early as possible. The associated preparatory work for each of the six City/Borough Councils commences around six weeks in advance of each meeting. Early identification of same enables Roads staff to schedule other commitments accordingly.

I would therefore appreciate inclusion of you nominations for the Autumn meeting. This should be on a similar basis to that above, the earliest date being Monday 13th October.

Thanks.

Terry Ward Roads Service, Eastern Division, Hydebank, 4 Hospital Road, Belfast. BT8 8JL

Tel. 9025 3159

Page 13 Agenda Item 5 Page 14 Page 15 Agenda Item 6

Belfast City Council

Report to: Town Planning Committee

Subject: Northern Ireland’s Housing Needs Conferences

Date: Thursday, 7th February, 2008

Reporting Officer: Mr. R. Boyd, Members’ Support Officer

Contact Officer: Mr. J. Heaney, Committee Administrator (extension 6312)

Relevant Background Information

Notification has been received of the above-mentioned conferences which have been organised by “bmf business services” in partnership with the Department for Social Development and the Northern Ireland Housing Executive and supported by the Strategic Investment Board and the Northern Ireland Federation of Housing Associations

Key Issues

The aim of the conference will be to take a strategic look at Northern Ireland’s housing sector and to identify innovative solutions to the growing lists of challenges faced by the sector. There will be a several expert speakers who will examine a number of perspectives relating to various issues including housing planning and delivery. Local speakers will be joined by a number of visiting presenters who will bring examples of best practice and policy initiatives developed and implemented elsewhere.

Delegates will be provided with an analysis, by acknowledged experts. of the policy priorities for social housing in Northern Ireland and how the challenge of providing additional social housing should be met.

The conference will be structured around a series of lectures from the keynote speakers and a discussion forum, chaired by Ulster Television’s Jamie Delargy, will provide an opportunity to consider a range of differing views, including those of the developer/construction industry, the housing bodies and the Northern Ireland Hosing Executive

The Members may benefit from the discussions on issues relating to the above matters and the conference will provide an opportunity to hear from distinguished national figures, with an in-depth involvement in the provision of housing. Page 16

Conference Dates and Locations

The conference will be held on Wednesday 5 th March in the Stormont Hotel commencing with registration at 8:30a.m. and concluding at 4:30 p.m.

Resource Implications

The approximate cost per delegate of attending the conference is set out hereunder:

Conference fees £195

Recommendations

The Committee is recommended to authorise the attendance at the conference of the Chairman, the Deputy Chairman and the Head of Committee and Members’ Services (or their nominees)

Documents Attached

Information Leaflet Meeting Northern Ireland’s Housing Needs Conference

Page 17 Page 18 Page 19 Agenda Item 7a Page 20 Page 21 Page 22 Page 23 Agenda Item 7b Page 24 Page 25 Page 26 Page 27 Page 28 Page 29 Page 30 Page 31 Page 32 Page 33 Agenda Item 8

BELFAST CITY COUNCIL

Applications for Planning Permission

07 FEBRUARY 2008

Page 34

DEPARTMENT OF THE ENVIRONMENT

PLANNING (NI) ORDER 1991

APPLICATIONS FOR PLANNING PERMISSION

COUNCIL Belfast Date 07-Feb-08

ITEM NO1 DEFERRED APPLIC NO Z/2006/0295/F Full Date Valid 10/02/2006 LOCATION 35-37 Diamond Gardens, Ballyfinaghy, Belfast, BT10 0HE PROPOSAL Residential development of 46 apartment units with associated basement car parking and associated landscaping APPLICANT Mossgiel Developments Ltd REPRESENTATIONS 29 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 2 APPLIC NO Z/2006/0605/F Full Date Valid 16/03/2006 LOCATION 288 Beersbridge Road, Ballyhackamore, Belfast, BT05 5DX PROPOSAL Mixed use commercial and residential (141 no. apartments) in refurbished Mill and 4 no new blocks, plus 191 parking spaces to be provided with all associated access requirements APPLICANT Wilson Developments NI Ltd REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 3 APPLIC NO Z/2006/1362/F Full Date Valid 12/06/2006 LOCATION 61 Dunluce Avenue, Malone Lower, Belfast, BT09 7AW PROPOSAL Conversion from 8 bedroom HMO to 3 no. flats (2 for HMO use) and 3 storey rear extension. APPLICANT Mr G McCaffrey REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL Page 35

ITEM NO 4 DEFERRED APPLIC NO Z/2006/1501/F Full Date Valid 22/06/2006 LOCATION Site adj to 5 Downview Avenue, Belfast, BT15 4EZ PROPOSAL Erection of a dwelling with detached garage APPLICANT Mrs A McAllister REPRESENTATIONS 10 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 5 APPLIC NO Z/2006/2561/F Full Date Valid 07/11/2006 LOCATION Summerhill, Mount Pleasant, Stranmillis Road, Belfast, BT09 5DS PROPOSAL Amendment to previous approval Z/2006/0247/F "Erection of two storey rear extension to form granny flat, single storey side extension, new carport, parking, driveway and alterations to existing dwelling" APPLICANT Mr M O'Sullivan REPRESENTATIONS 1 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 6 APPLIC NO Z/2006/2568/DCA Demolition within Date Valid 07/11/2006 LOCATION 128a Eglantine Ave. Belfast BT9 6EU PROPOSAL Demolition of existing single storey building formerly used as a shop and offices. APPLICANT New Mutual Holding Co Ltd REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION CONSENT Page 36

ITEM NO 7 APPLIC NO Z/2006/2569/F Full Date Valid 07/11/2006 LOCATION 128a Eglantine Ave, Belfast, BT9 6EU PROPOSAL Demolition of building and erection of new office building with roof terrace and car parking APPLICANT New Mutual Holding Company REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 8 APPLIC NO Z/2006/2586/LB Listed Building Date Valid 07/11/2006 LOCATION Summerhill, Mount Pleasant, Stranmillis Road, Belfast, BT9 5DS PROPOSAL Amendment to previous approval Z/2006/0235/LB "Erection of 2 storey rear extension to form granny flat, single-storey side extension, new carport, parking, driveway and alteration to existing dwelling". APPLICANT Mr M O'Sullivan REPRESENTATIONS 1 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION CONSENT

ITEM NO 9 DEFERRED APPLIC NO Z/2006/2766/F Full Date Valid 29/11/2006 LOCATION Site fronts onto 157-161 North Street and onto 40-44 Kent Street, Belfast, BT1 2JA PROPOSAL Demolition of all buildings on site and the construction of a mixed use scheme to include retail on ground floor and 97no. apartments with associated car parking APPLICANT Mr C Ashe REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 1 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL Page 37

ITEM NO 10 APPLIC NO Z/2007/0260/F Full Date Valid 29/01/2007 LOCATION 3 Pretoria Street, Stranmillis Road, Belfast, BT09 5AQ PROPOSAL Change of use from HMO dwelling to 2no. apartments; 1no. HMO and 1no. non HMO (retrospective). APPLICANT Mr D Rice REPRESENTATIONS 1 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 11 APPLIC NO Z/2007/0338/F Full Date Valid 08/02/2007 LOCATION 305 Belmont Road, Belfast PROPOSAL Demolition of existing dwelling and erection of 3no 2-storey dwellings APPLICANT Patton Homes REPRESENTATIONS 5 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 12 APPLIC NO Z/2007/0414/F Full Date Valid 13/02/2007 LOCATION 15 Bawnmore Road, Malone Lower, Belfast, BT09 6LA PROPOSAL Two storey side and rear extension to dwelling APPLICANT Mr & Mrs E Donnelly REPRESENTATIONS 1 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 13 APPLIC NO Z/2007/0649/F Full Date Valid 13/03/2007 LOCATION 7 Botanic Court, Belfast, BT07 1QY PROPOSAL Erection of three storey extension to rear of existing dwelling APPLICANT Mr J Regan REPRESENTATIONS 4 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL Page 38

ITEM NO 14 APPLIC NO Z/2007/0725/F Full Date Valid 22/03/2007 LOCATION 52 Mount Street, Ballymacarret, Belfast, BT06 8DA PROPOSAL Construction of 16no. 1 bedroom apartments with in-curtilage parking & associated site works APPLICANT Abaco Developments LLP REPRESENTATIONS 1 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 15 DEFERRED APPLIC NO Z/2007/0767/F Full Date Valid 27/03/2007 LOCATION 406-408 Upper Newtownards Road Belfast BT4 3EZ PROPOSAL Ground floor change of use from restaurant to public house APPLICANT Classic Wine (NI) Ltd REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION REFUSAL 1 The proposal is contrary to Planning Policy Statement 1 (PPS1) and Development Control Advice Note 7 Public Houses, (DCAN7), in that the development if approved, would be detrimental to the amenities of nearby residential properties by reason of noise, nuisance, inconvenience and general disturbance.

ITEM NO 16 APPLIC NO Z/2007/0792/F Full Date Valid 28/03/2007 LOCATION 1 Orangefield Grove, Ballyhackamore, Belfast, BT05 6DA PROPOSAL Demolition of existing shop and erection of 2-1/2 storey building comprising 1no. shop and 7no. apartments APPLICANT Prodam Developments REPRESENTATIONS 2 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL Page 39

ITEM NO 17 DEFERRED APPLIC NO Z/2007/0939/F Full Date Valid 18/04/2007 LOCATION 193a West Circular Road, Ballymagarry, Belfast, BT13 3QF PROPOSAL Demolition of existing property and replacement with ground floor retail unit & 6no. 1-bedroom & 2no. 2-bedroom apartments APPLICANT Mr S Harrison REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 18 APPLIC NO Z/2007/0987/F Full Date Valid 25/04/2007 LOCATION 56 Ulsterville Avenue, Malone Lower, Belfast, BT09 7AQ PROPOSAL Extension and conversion of existing dwelling to 9 no. apartments and provision of 6 no. new build apartments on land to rear. (amendment to previous approval Z/2003/2986/F). APPLICANT Finner Properties REPRESENTATIONS 2 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 19 APPLIC NO Z/2007/1062/F Full Date Valid 02/05/2007 LOCATION 4 Sunninghill Drive, Old Park, Belfast, BT14 6SB PROPOSAL Erection of single storey extension to rear of dwelling APPLICANT Ms K Campbell REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL Page 40

ITEM NO 20 APPLIC NO Z/2007/1187/F Full Date Valid 14/05/2007 LOCATION 117 University Street, Malone Lower, Belfast, BT07 1HP PROPOSAL Demolition of premises to rear of primary facade, retention of primary facade and construction 9 no. self contained apartments. APPLICANT Strandmills Investments REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 21 DEFERRED APPLIC NO Z/2007/1243/F Full Date Valid 21/05/2007 LOCATION 6 Ravenhill Park, Belfast, BT6 0DE PROPOSAL Single storey extension to rear of dwelling APPLICANT Mr P Blayney REPRESENTATIONS 2 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 22 APPLIC NO Z/2007/1248/F Full Date Valid 22/05/2007 LOCATION 148-150 King's Road, Ballycloghan, Belfast, BT05 7EJ PROPOSAL Construction of a courtyard style development comprising 3no 4 bedroom townhouses and 4no 2 bedroom apartments with associated car parking and landscaping APPLICANT Clear Homes REPRESENTATIONS 2 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL Page 41

ITEM NO 23 APPLIC NO Z/2007/1427/F Full Date Valid 11/06/2007 LOCATION 104 Ardenlee Avenue, Belfast, BT6 0AD PROPOSAL Two storey extension and alterations to rear of dwelling APPLICANT Mr & Mrs W Liddell REPRESENTATIONS 1 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 24 DEFERRED APPLIC NO Z/2007/1461/O Outline Date Valid 13/06/2007 LOCATION 29 Whitehall Parade, Ballynafoy, Belfast, BT07 3GX PROPOSAL Replacement of existing end terrace with 4no. apartments. APPLICANT Mr J Woods REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION REFUSAL 1 The proposal is contrary to Policy QD 1 of Planning Policy Statement 7 "Quality Residential Environments" in that it would, if permitted, result in overdevelopment of the site, which is too restricted to permit the erection of a four apartments of reasonable design and dimensions and with adequate amenity space. The proposal would result in development forward of the building line, which is out of character with the surrounding townscape, in terms of built form and urban grain, which would cause unacceptable damage to local character. Page 42

ITEM NO 25 APPLIC NO Z/2007/1505/F Full Date Valid 19/06/2007 LOCATION 405 Donegall Road, Malone Lower, Belfast, BT12 6FR PROPOSAL Change of use with alterations from existing office premises to 3no. 1 bed apartments with new dormer to the rear. APPLICANT Mr J Donaghy REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 26 DEFERRED APPLIC NO Z/2007/1603/F Full Date Valid 29/06/2007 LOCATION Land to the rear of Carnegie Hall between Utility Street and Eureka Drive, Donegall Road, Belfast. PROPOSAL Residential development of 35 apartments to include associated works (incl social and private units) APPLICANT The Carvill Group REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 27 APPLIC NO Z/2007/1620/O Outline Date Valid 02/07/2007 LOCATION 31 Ravenhill Park, Ballynafoy, Belfast, BT06 0DG PROPOSAL Erection of two storey dwelling in rear garden, existing garage to be retained with the creation of a new vehicular access to No 31 APPLICANT Mr & Mrs T Burns REPRESENTATIONS 7 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION REFUSAL 1 The proposal is contrary to Policy QD 1 of Planning Policy Statement 7 "Quality Residential Environments" and associated guidance in that the development would not create a quality residential environment. The proposal fails to meet the requirements of QD1 in that it would constitute overdevelopment and have an unacceptable impact on existing properties in terms of loss of light, overshadowing, dominance and loss of privacy. Page 43

ITEM NO 28 APPLIC NO Z/2007/1646/F Full Date Valid 03/07/2007 LOCATION Woodford Medical Ltd, 567a Lisburn Road, Belfast. PROPOSAL Retrospective change of use from class a1 shop to class d1 (a) medical clinic on first and second floors only. APPLICANT Dr Mervyn Patterson REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 29 APPLIC NO Z/2007/1650/F Full Date Valid 04/07/2007 LOCATION 24 Deramore Park South, Malone Upper, Belfast, BT09 5JY PROPOSAL Demolition of existing dwelling and erection of 2½ storey replacement dwelling with detached two storey garage and associated external works including a new front boundary. APPLICANT Mr & Mrs Kelly REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 30 APPLIC NO Z/2007/1657/F Full Date Valid 05/07/2007 LOCATION 69 Onslow Parade, Belfast, BT6 0AS PROPOSAL Roof space conversion with dormer to rear and velux windows in front and side roof elevations APPLICANT Mr M Wainwright REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL Page 44

ITEM NO 31 APPLIC NO Z/2007/1712/F Full Date Valid 10/07/2007 LOCATION 56 Locksley Park, Belfast, BT10 0AS PROPOSAL Two storey extension to front of dwelling APPLICANT Mrs Y Elwood REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 32 APPLIC NO Z/2007/1777/F Full Date Valid 20/07/2007 LOCATION 78 Fitzroy Avenue, Malone Lower, Belfast, BT07 1HX PROPOSAL Part demolition of existing building, retention of front facade and construction of 4no flats APPLICANT Mr O' Hare REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 33 APPLIC NO Z/2007/1817/F Full Date Valid 25/07/2007 LOCATION 98 Malone Avenue, Malone Lower, Belfast, BT09 6ES PROPOSAL Change of use from existing HMO to 3no HMO apartments incorporating demolition of existing 2 storey return and construction of 3 storey rear extension

APPLICANT Mrs M Yarr REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION REFUSAL 1 This proposal has been assessed against the relevant Strategies and Policies of the HMO Subject Plan for Belfast 2015. The proposal is contrary to Policy HMO 1 and in particular that part of the policy relating to how the number of HMO dwelling units, as measured on a street by street basis, should not exceed 30%A number of representations have been made in respect of Policy HMO 1. The Draft HMO Subject Plan for Belfast 2015 has reached an advanced stage of preparation and approval for this proposal would cumulatively, along with other similar proposals, be prejudicial to the outcome of the plan process by pre-determining decisions about the nature, scale and location of new development which should properly be taken through the development plan process.

2 The proposal is contrary to Policy HMO 8 of the HMO Subject Plan in that it does not comply with the following criteria: - Extensions/alterations to a house or flat for HMO use, do not exceed 20% of the gross floor space of the original property. Page 45

ITEM NO 34 APPLIC NO Z/2007/1835/F Full Date Valid 26/07/2007 LOCATION 9 Upper Lisburn Road, Belfast, BT10 0GW PROPOSAL Single storey detached garage to rear of dwelling APPLICANT Ms M Dolan REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 35 APPLIC NO Z/2007/1881/F Full Date Valid 01/08/2007 LOCATION 30 Wolseley Street, Malone Lower, Belfast, BT07 1LG PROPOSAL Demolition of building containing 3no flats with retention of front facade & erection of new building containing 4no flats including 3 storey return & rear dormers APPLICANT L&E Properties Ltd REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 36 APPLIC NO Z/2007/1896/F Full Date Valid 03/08/2007 LOCATION Tesco stores, 2 Ballygomartin Road, Belfast, BT13 3LD PROPOSAL Variation of details as consented under Z/2005/1739 to permit alteration of car park layout and reduction to 341 spaces, reconfigured internal service yard arrangement, addition of 2 sprinkler tanks and pump room to SW corner of site and alterations to facades including addition of atrium over access and window, door and stairwell locations. APPLICANT Tesco Stores Ltd REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL Page 46

ITEM NO 37 APPLIC NO Z/2007/1916/F Full Date Valid 06/08/2007 LOCATION Parliament Building, Stormont Estate, Belfast, BT4 3XX PROPOSAL Installation of security search unit, additional security measures and installation of new gates and railings APPLICANT Northern Ireland Assembly REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 38 APPLIC NO Z/2007/1924/F Full Date Valid 07/08/2007 LOCATION 16 Summerhill Avenue, Belfast, BT5 7HD PROPOSAL Two storey and single storey extension to rear of dwelling and single storey porch extension to front of dwelling APPLICANT Mr R Lowry REPRESENTATIONS 1 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 39 APPLIC NO Z/2007/1948/LB Listed Building Date Valid 08/08/2007 LOCATION Parliament Buildings, Stormont, Belfast BT4 3XX PROPOSAL Installation of security search unit, additional security measures and installation of new gates, railings and fencing. APPLICANT Northern Ireland Assembly REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION CONSENT Page 47

ITEM NO 40 APPLIC NO Z/2007/1983/F Full Date Valid 13/08/2007 LOCATION 14 Glenmillan Park, Ballymaghan, Belfast, BT04 2JE PROPOSAL Two storey rear extension and rear dormer APPLICANT Mr P Watson REPRESENTATIONS 3 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 41 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2043/F Full Date Valid 20/08/2007 LOCATION B&Q DIY Supercentre, Boucher Road, Belfast, BT12 6HR PROPOSAL Subdivision of part of existing store to create five new trade units together with associated external alterations APPLICANT B&Q Plc REPRESENTATIONS 1 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 42 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2051/F Full Date Valid 20/08/2007 LOCATION 129 Wandsworth Road, Belfast, BT4 3LW PROPOSAL Two storey extension to side of dwelling, new roof to main dwelling, alteration to roof of existing single storey rear extension and relocation of main entrance in front elevation APPLICANT Mr & Mrs J Davis REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL Page 48

ITEM NO 43 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2098/F Full Date Valid 24/08/2007 LOCATION 14 Carrington Street, Belfast, BT6 8GF PROPOSAL Two storey extension to rear of dwelling APPLICANT Mr D Molloy REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 44 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2109/F Full Date Valid 28/08/2007 LOCATION 34 Wolseley Street, Malone Lower, Belfast, BT07 1LG PROPOSAL Demolition of 3 No. flats with retention of front facade and erection of 5 No. flats including 3 storey return and new front dormers APPLICANT B.A.R Ltd REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 45 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2131/F Full Date Valid 30/08/2007 LOCATION 1 Old Holywood Road, Ballymaghan, Belfast, BT04 2HJ PROPOSAL Demolition of existing property & erection of 3 storey building comprising 8 no apartments (7 two bed apartments and 1 one bed apartment) with on site parking. APPLICANT Ms L Boston REPRESENTATIONS 3 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION REFUSAL 1 The proposal is contrary to policy QD1 of the Department's PPS7: Quality Residential Environments and associated guidance in that it would, if permitted, result in overdevelopment that would harm the character and appearance of the streetscape through inappropriate scale, form and layout and harm the living conditions of existing residents by reason of dominance and overlooking. The proposal would also result in inadequate provision of amenity space for prospective residents and would fail to create a quality and sustainable residential environment. Page 49

ITEM NO 46 DEFERRED APPLIC NO Z/2007/2141/F Full Date Valid 03/09/2007 LOCATION 114 Upper Lisburn Road, Ballyfinaghy, Finaghy, BT10 0BD PROPOSAL Amendment to previous approval Z/2003/1780/F (Demolition of existing dwelling and erection of new building to accommodate 6 apartments) for the erection of 3 storey building containing 9 no. apartments and related site works. APPLICANT Lissue Development Partnership REPRESENTATIONS 1 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION REFUSAL 1 The proposal is contrary to Policy QD1 of the Department's Planning Policy Statement 7: Quality Residential Environments and associated guidance, in that it would, if permitted, result in unacceptable damage to the local character, residential amenity and environmental quality of this area by reason of over development resulting in: - A development that fails to respect the surrounding context and the characteristics of the site in terms of scale and would harm the living conditions of adjacent residents through over dominance and loss of privacy. The proposal would also result in inadequate provision of amenity space for prospective residents.

ITEM NO 47 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2199/F Full Date Valid 10/09/2007 LOCATION 9 Ardenlee Avenue, Belfast, BT6 0AA PROPOSAL Single storey extension to side and rear of dwelling and two storey extension to rear of dwelling with solar panels in both elevations of pitched roof APPLICANT Mr C Rainbird REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 48 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2207/F Full Date Valid 10/09/2007 LOCATION 101 Onslow Parade, Belfast, BT6 0AT PROPOSAL Roofspace conversion with dormer to rear elevation and 3 no. velux windows in front elevation and alterations to existing kitchen APPLICANT Mrs P Hughes REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

Page 50

ITEM NO 49 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2236/F Full Date Valid 13/09/2007 LOCATION 41 Malone Heights, Belfast, BT9 5PG PROPOSAL First floor extension with pitched roof over existing garage and dining room, roofspace conversion within existing pitched roof area with new dormer in north side elevation and single storey extension to south side elevation of dwelling APPLICANT Mr P Henderson REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 50 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2257/F Full Date Valid 13/09/2007 LOCATION 40 Richill Park, Belfast, BT5 6HG PROPOSAL Two storey extension to rear of dwelling and single story extension to side APPLICANT Mrs McGukkin REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 51 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2275/F Full Date Valid 17/09/2007 LOCATION 5A Westland Road, Old Park, Belfast, BT14 6NH PROPOSAL Erection of two storey dwelling APPLICANT Mr B Smith REPRESENTATIONS 1 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 52 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2298/F Full Date Valid 19/09/2007 LOCATION 20 Orpen Road, Belfast, BT10 0BP PROPOSAL Single storey extension to rear of dwelling and roofspace conversion with dormer to rear and 2 no. Velux windows to front elevation APPLICANT Mr J Wilson REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

Page 51

ITEM NO 53 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2312/F Full Date Valid 19/09/2007 LOCATION 12 Chobham Street, Ballyhackamore, Belfast, BT05 5BL PROPOSAL Two storey extension to rear of dwelling and alterations APPLICANT NIHE REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 54 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2313/F Full Date Valid 19/09/2007 LOCATION 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 14, 16, 26, 32 Parkgate Gardens, Belfast, BT4 1ES and 3, 5, 7, 11, 13, 17, 27 Parkgate Parade, Belfast, BT4 1ET and 4, 15 Parkgate Crescent, Belfast, BT4 1EU and 24 Parkgate Avenue, Belfast, BT4 1JA PROPOSAL Two storey extension to rear of dwellings and creation of in curtilage parking to front and alterations. APPLICANT NIHE REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 55 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2326/F Full Date Valid 20/09/2007 LOCATION 47 Knockeden Park, Belfast, BT6 PROPOSAL Single storey extension to rear of dwelling APPLICANT Mr D Smiley REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 56 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2332/F Full Date Valid 20/09/2007 LOCATION 9 Brooke Drive, Ballyfinaghy, Belfast, BT11 9NW PROPOSAL Erection of two storey extension to side and dormer window to the rear of dwelling APPLICANT Mr J Lavell REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL Page 52

ITEM NO 57 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2346/F Full Date Valid 24/09/2007 LOCATION 3 Castlehill Park West, Ballycloghan, Belfast, BT04 3GT PROPOSAL Single storey extensions to rear of dwelling and garage conversion APPLICANT Mr Penton REPRESENTATIONS 1 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 58 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2354/F Full Date Valid 24/09/2007 LOCATION 5 Malone View Road, Belfast, BT9 5PH PROPOSAL Single storey extension at each end to rear of dwelling and new window in front elevation of dwelling APPLICANT Mr P Smith REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 59 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2359/F Full Date Valid 26/09/2007 LOCATION 18 Beechwood Street, Ballyhackamore, Belfast, BT05 5BQ PROPOSAL Erection of 2 storey extension to rear of dwelling APPLICANT Mr T Black REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 60 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2370/F Full Date Valid 27/09/2007 LOCATION 12 Langtry Court, Belfast, BT5 4DN PROPOSAL Single storey extension to rear of existing dwelling APPLICANT Mrs P McPhillips REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL Page 53

ITEM NO 61 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2375/F Full Date Valid 01/10/2007 LOCATION 3 Tillysburn Grove, Ballymaghan, Belfast, BT04 2RA PROPOSAL Two storey side extension onto existing dwelling house APPLICANT Mr Wilson REPRESENTATIONS 1 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 62 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2400/DCA Demolition within Date Valid 02/10/2007 LOCATION 144 Malone Road, Malone Upper, Belfast, BT09 5LH PROPOSAL Demolition of rear outbuildings APPLICANT Mr & Mrs Woods REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION CONSENT

ITEM NO 63 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2420/F Full Date Valid 04/10/2007 LOCATION 5 Kingsberry Park, Ballynafoy, Belfast, BT06 0HT PROPOSAL Demolition of existing single storey rear return and construction of new single storey rear return APPLICANT Ms S Cassidy REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 64 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2436/F Full Date Valid 05/10/2007 LOCATION 49 Richhill Park, Knock, Belfast, BT05 6HG PROPOSAL Two storey front and rear extensions to dwelling APPLICANT Mr & Mrs I Roche REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL Page 54

ITEM NO 65 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2443/F Full Date Valid 08/10/2007 LOCATION 24 Tate's Avenue, Malone Lower, Belfast, BT09 7BY PROPOSAL Change of use from existing dwelling to 3 No. self contained apartments including a 3 storey rear extension. APPLICANT Mr D Patterson REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 66 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2471/F Full Date Valid 10/10/2007 LOCATION 371-373 Ormeau Road, Ballynafoy, Belfast, BT07 3GP PROPOSAL 1 no additional floor to existing 3no floor office building, to include staircase and lift shaft. APPLICANT Hampton Estate - Michael Devlin REPRESENTATIONS 5 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 67 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2488/F Full Date Valid 12/10/2007 LOCATION Fujitsu Trident House, 301 Airport Road West, Belfast, BT3 9ED PROPOSAL Replacement oil tank to the rear of existing buildings on site APPLICANT Fujitsu REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 68 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2499/F Full Date Valid 15/10/2007 LOCATION Unit 6, Tolgate House, 51 Bradbury Place, Belfast, BT7 1RU PROPOSAL New entrance, ATM machine and security door to shop frontage. APPLICANT Hendersons Plc REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL Page 55

ITEM NO 69 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2545/F Full Date Valid 17/10/2007 LOCATION 51 Dublin Road, Malone Lower, Belfast, BT02 7HE PROPOSAL Retrospective change of use from community centre to sandwich bar. APPLICANT Kaizen UKI Ltd REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 70 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2546/F Full Date Valid 17/10/2007 LOCATION 95 Upper Dunmurry Lane, Dunmurry, BT17 0NR PROPOSAL Erection of replacement dwelling and garage APPLICANT S & D Shannon REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 71 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2594/F Full Date Valid 23/10/2007 LOCATION Unit 8, Balmoral Plaza, Boucher Road, Belfast PROPOSAL Retention and use of Unit 8 to include amendment to planning Condition 10 of application Z/2006/1728/F. APPLICANT Marks & Spencer Plc REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 72 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2613/F Full Date Valid 25/10/2007 LOCATION 3 Linenhall Street West & 6 Clarence Street, Belfast, BT2 8AA PROPOSAL Change of use from office to retail and photographer's gallery APPLICANT Gate 49 Limited REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL Page 56

ITEM NO 73 DEFERRED APPLIC NO Z/2007/2643/F Full Date Valid 01/11/2007 LOCATION 339 Shankill Road, Town Parks, Belfast, BT13 3AA PROPOSAL Erection of ground floor retail unit, with 3no apartments on upper two floors including 1no duplex APPLICANT Ms L Herbert REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 74 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2685/F Full Date Valid 01/11/2007 LOCATION 41 Sandhill Gardens, Belfast, BT5 6FF PROPOSAL Single storey extension to side and rear of dwelling including removal of existing shed APPLICANT Mr & Mrs Smyth REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 75 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2689/F Full Date Valid 05/11/2007 LOCATION 2 Sharman Gardens, Malone Lower, Belfast, BT09 5GE PROPOSAL Two storey extensions to side and rear of dwelling including alterations APPLICANT Mrs Loughlin REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 76 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2701/F Full Date Valid 06/11/2007 LOCATION 19 Trigo Parade, Belfast, BT6 9GA PROPOSAL First floor extension to rear of dwelling and new dormer in rear roof elevation APPLICANT Mr & Mrs Patterson REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL Page 57

ITEM NO 77 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2702/F Full Date Valid 06/11/2007 LOCATION 26 Malone View Road, Ballyfinaghy, Belfast, BT09 5PH PROPOSAL Erection of extensions to front of dwelling, roofspace conversion with dormer to rear and roof lights APPLICANT Mr E Elbuzidi REPRESENTATIONS 1 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 78 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2713/F Full Date Valid 06/11/2007 LOCATION 10 Thorndale Avenue, Town Parks, Belfast, BT14 6BL PROPOSAL Alterations to existing house to provide 3 No. flats. APPLICANT Quigg Developments REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION REFUSAL 1 The proposal is contrary to policy QD1 of Planning Policy Statement 7: Quality Residential Environments, policy H8 of the Belfast Urban Area Plan 2001 and the guidance within DGN4: Control of Flat Conversions in that the property is not within a designated Flat Conversion Zone and would, if permitted, result in the loss of a house suitable for single family occupation, fail to provide adequate access to rear bin storage and harm the character, environmental quality and residential amenity of the area.

ITEM NO 79 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2715/A Advertisement Date Valid 07/11/2007 LOCATION Whiterock Children’s Centre, BIFHE Building, 91 Whiterock Road, Belfast PROPOSAL Stainless steel-effect projecting signage and new entrance gate. APPLICANT Whiterock Children's Centre REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION CONSENT Page 58

ITEM NO 80 DEFERRED APPLIC NO Z/2007/2718/F Full Date Valid 07/11/2007 LOCATION 3 Edinburgh Street, Malone Lower, Belfast, BT09 7DS PROPOSAL Demolition of existing 2 No. apartments and erection of 4 storey block containing 4 No. apartments. APPLICANT Dack Estates Ltd REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION REFUSAL 1 The proposal is contrary to Policy QD1 of Planning Policy Statement 7, Quality Residential Environments, in that the scheme fails to take account of local character, environmental quality and amenity, as the form, scale and massing of the proposed development does not respect that of adjacent housing, and will result in a detrimental impact on existing residents. 2 The proposed development would, if permitted, harm the living conditions of residents in adjoining properties by reason of over dominance which would detract from the environmental quality, residential amenity and established character of the surrounding area.

ITEM NO 81 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2720/F Full Date Valid 07/11/2007 LOCATION 37 Glenalina Road, Ballymurphy, Belfast, BT12 7JF PROPOSAL Two storey extension to rear of dwelling and roofspace conversion APPLICANT Mr Fox REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL Page 59

ITEM NO 82 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2740/F Full Date Valid 09/11/2007 LOCATION 44 Wellesley Avenue, Malone Lower, Belfast, BT09 6DG PROPOSAL Change of use from existing dwelling to 2 No. apartments including two-storey rear extension. Construction of new vehicle access to provide off-street parking. APPLICANT Mr P Boyle REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION REFUSAL 1 The proposal is contrary to DGN 4d "Control of Flat Conversions in the Inner Malone Zone of the University Area" in that no further flat conversions are permitted in this property and would result in the loss of a house suitable for single family occupation. 2 The proposal is unacceptable in that it would, if permitted, harm the residential amenity of the adjacent neighbour No. 42 Wellesley Avenue in terms of overlooking.

ITEM NO 83 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2748/F Full Date Valid 13/11/2007 LOCATION 8 Ravensdale Street, Ballymacarret, Belfast, BT05 5GA PROPOSAL Single storey rear extension to dwelling APPLICANT Mrs Hogg REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 84 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2755/F Full Date Valid 13/11/2007 LOCATION 16 Ardenlee Avenue, Ballynafoy, Belfast, BT06 0AA PROPOSAL Two storey extension to rear of dwelling house APPLICANT JT & PY Ltd REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL Page 60

ITEM NO 85 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2756/A Advertisement Date Valid 13/11/2007 LOCATION 68-70 York Road, Skegoneill, Belfast, BT15 3HF PROPOSAL Printed Banner. APPLICANT PSNI ESBU REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION CONSENT

ITEM NO 86 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2759/A Advertisement Date Valid 13/11/2007 LOCATION 134 Tennant Street, Belfast, BT13 3GF PROPOSAL Printed Banner. APPLICANT PSNI ESBU REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION CONSENT

ITEM NO 87 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2771/F Full Date Valid 14/11/2007 LOCATION Moylena House, Benmore Drive, Finaghy PROPOSAL Installation of 1No. 600mm transmission dish upon the existing 4m high telecommunications stub-tower installation at a mean height of 46.65m AGL. APPLICANT Orange PCS Ltd REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL Page 61

ITEM NO 88 DEFERRED APPLIC NO Z/2007/2774/F Full Date Valid 15/11/2007 LOCATION 43 Osbourne Park, Belfast, BT9 PROPOSAL Demolition of existing rear return and erection of two-storey rear and side extensions. Construction of garden store along rear boundary APPLICANT Mr & Mrs McKenna REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION REFUSAL 1 The proposal is contrary to Policy BH 12 of Planning Policy Statement 6 "Planning, Archaeology and the Built Heritage" and Policy EXT 1 of Draft Addendum to Planning Policy Statement 7 "Residential Extensions and Alterations" in that it would, if permitted, harm the character and appearance of the Malone Conservation Area through inappropriate scale, form, materials and design. The proposal, if permitted would harm the living conditions and residential amenity of the neighbouring property No. 41 Osbourne Park due to overshadowing and dominance.

ITEM NO 89 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2784/O Outline Date Valid 20/11/2007 LOCATION Land 170m NE of 35 Ballymiscaw Road, Holywood PROPOSAL Retirement dwelling for farmer APPLICANT Mr Galway REPRESENTATIONS 2 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION REFUSAL 1 The proposal is contrary to Policies CTY1 and CTY3 of Draft Planning Policy Statement 14, Sustainable Development in the Countryside and the accompanying Ministerial Statement and does not merit being considered as an exceptional case, as other development opportunities on the farm holding have previously been sold off. 2 The proposal is contrary to Policy CTY10 of Draft Planning Policy Statement 14, Sustainable Development in the Countryside, and the accompanying Ministerial Statement in that the proposed dwelling would, if permitted, be unduly prominent in the landscape. 3 The proposal is contrary to Policy CTY11 of Draft Planning Policy Statement 14, Sustainable Development in the Countryside, and the accompanying Ministerial Statement in that: the dwelling would, if permitted result in a build-up of development when viewed with existing building and would therefore result in a detrimental change to the rural character of the countryside.

ITEM NO 90 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2794/F Full Date Valid 19/11/2007 LOCATION 9 St Judes Avenue, Belfast, BT7 PROPOSAL Erection of two storey rear extension APPLICANT Mr W Horwood REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL Page 62

ITEM NO 91 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2799/F Full Date Valid 19/11/2007 LOCATION 174 Cavendish Street, Edenderry, Belfast, BT12 7AX PROPOSAL Two-storey extension to rear of dwelling APPLICANT Mr J Dougherty REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 92 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2802/F Full Date Valid 19/11/2007 LOCATION 22 Timbey Park, Ballynafoy, Belfast, BT07 3BT PROPOSAL Single-storey rear extension to dwelling APPLICANT Ms J Patrick REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 93 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2803/F Full Date Valid 19/11/2007 LOCATION St Aidan’s Christian Brothers Primary School, Whiterock Road, Belfast, BT12 7FW PROPOSAL New one storey porch to front of school and ramp; new pedestrian gate at playground APPLICANT Board of Trustees of St Aidan’s Primary School REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 94 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2808/F Full Date Valid 20/11/2007 LOCATION 59 Fairhill Park, Low-Wood, Belfast, BT15 4FY PROPOSAL Two storey extension to rear of dwelling APPLICANT Mrs A Perry REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL Page 63

ITEM NO 95 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2818/F Full Date Valid 20/11/2007 LOCATION 28 Magdala Street, Malone Lower, Belfast, BT07 1PU PROPOSAL Change of use from House in Multiple Occupancy to two self-contained apartments including single storey extension APPLICANT Mr K Morgan REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 96 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2829/F Full Date Valid 23/11/2007 LOCATION 10 Ballyutoag Road, Ligoniel, Belfast, BT14 8SR PROPOSAL Proposed replacement dwelling and domestic garage. APPLICANT Mr McCallen REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 97 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2836/F Full Date Valid 23/11/2007 LOCATION 35 Knockbreda Park, Galwally, Belfast, BT06 0HB PROPOSAL Demolition of existing dwelling house and erection of 6 apartments with associated parking and amenity space. APPLICANT Mr D Nichol REPRESENTATIONS 15 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION REFUSAL 1 The proposal is contrary to Policy ATC1 of the Department's Addendum to Planning Policy Statement 6: Planning, Archaeology and the Built Heritage in that the site lies within an Area of Townscape Character and does not merit being considered as an exceptional case as; the buildings it proposes to replace make a positive contribution to the character of the Area of Townscape Character. 2 The proposal is contrary to Policy QD1 of the Department's Planning Policy Statement 7: Quality residential environments in that in that it would if permitted result in overdevelopment of the site with excessive amounts of hard surfacing and would cause unacceptable damage to the character and residential amenity of the area through inappropriate scale, form, massing, layout and design and would result in overlooking, overshadowing and loss of privacy to neighbouring residents. Page 64

ITEM NO 98 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2842/F Full Date Valid 26/11/2007 LOCATION 309 Cavehill Road, Ballyaghagan, Belfast, BT15 5EY PROPOSAL Demolish existing building and construct new commercial office (Retrospective) APPLICANT BTW Shiells REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 99 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2855/F Full Date Valid 26/11/2007 LOCATION 242 Whitewell Road, Ballygolan, Newtownabbey, BT36 PROPOSAL Erection of single storey extension APPLICANT Board of Governors Hazelwood Integrated Primary School REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 100 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2863/F Full Date Valid 28/11/2007 LOCATION 30 & 32 Burmah Street, Ballynafoy, Belfast, BT07 3AN PROPOSAL Demolition of 2nr 3 storey existing HMO'S and erection of 6nr 2 bedroom apartments over 3 storeys APPLICANT Messrs J McGinnity & D Gantley REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION REFUSAL 1 The proposal is contrary to PPS7 in that the demolition and redevelopment of the site would harm the character and appearance of the streetscape and result in loss of privacy to adjacent residents through inappropriate scale, form and design. Page 65

ITEM NO101 WITHDRAWN APPLIC NO Z/2007/2877/F Full Date Valid 29/11/2007 LOCATION 215 Upper Meadow Street, Town Parks, Belfast, BT15 2FR PROPOSAL Proposed corner community shop APPLICANT Ms M Masterson REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION REFUSAL 1 The proposed use of this portacabin as a shop would, if permitted, harm the character of this residential street and the living conditions of the residents in Cliftonpark Court and Cliftonpark Avenue by reason of nuisance and general disturbance.

ITEM NO 102 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2879/F Full Date Valid 29/11/2007 LOCATION 27 Osborne Drive, Malone Lower, Belfast, BT09 6LG PROPOSAL Alterations to window openings at rear of dwelling, replacement boiler house enclosure, new front railings and gates APPLICANT Ms Wilson REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 103 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2880/F Full Date Valid 29/11/2007 LOCATION 31, 33 and 35 Egeria Street, Belfast, BT12 5PN PROPOSAL Refurbishment and erection of two storey extensions to each property APPLICANT Mr E Nillons REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL Page 66

ITEM NO 104 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2887/F Full Date Valid 30/11/2007 LOCATION 53 Andersonstown Crescent, Belfast, BT11 PROPOSAL Two-storey extension to rear of dwelling APPLICANT Mr Reid REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 105 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2892/F Full Date Valid 03/12/2007 LOCATION 1 Ebor Drive, Belfast, BT12 6NR PROPOSAL Erection of two storey extension to rear of dwelling APPLICANT Mrs Martin REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 106 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2895/F Full Date Valid 03/12/2007 LOCATION Twin Spire Centre, 155 Northumberland Street, Belfast, BT13 PROPOSAL Creation of first floor office development, sub division of existing retail unit and alterations to shop fronts APPLICANT Mr S Toal REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 107 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2901/F Full Date Valid 03/12/2007 LOCATION 9 Seabank Parade, Belfast, BT15 3NW PROPOSAL Erection of single storey extension to rear of dwelling APPLICANT Mrs D Devonport REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL Page 67

ITEM NO 108 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2902/F Full Date Valid 03/12/2007 LOCATION 172 Skegoneill Avenue, Belfast, BT15 3JU PROPOSAL Erection of two storey extension to rear of dwelling APPLICANT Mrs McClay REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 109 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2907/F Full Date Valid 03/12/2007 LOCATION 8 Lake Glen Drive, Ballymurphy, Belfast, BT11 8TF PROPOSAL Single storey disabled toilet and lobby extension to rear of existing dwelling APPLICANT Mrs S Gorman REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 110 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2908/F Full Date Valid 03/12/2007 LOCATION 4 Garnerville Drive, Ballymaghan, Belfast, BT04 2NZ PROPOSAL Demolish existing rear extension and detached garage and replacement with new double storey extension to side and rear of house APPLICANT Mr Storey REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL Page 68

ITEM NO 111 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2915/F Full Date Valid 04/12/2007 LOCATION 165, 167 & 169 Ormeau Road, Malone Lower, Belfast, BT07 1SQ PROPOSAL Change of use from office/retail - to be used by the Crescent Arts centre on a temporary basis for classroom/workshop/office activities - community arts activities. Minor modifications to entrance of No 165 to incorporate double doors and entrance ramp for disabled access. APPLICANT Mr K Mooney REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 112 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2919/F Full Date Valid 04/12/2007 LOCATION 124 Cluain Mor Drive, Ballymagarry, Belfast, BT12 7UG PROPOSAL Erection of two storey extension to rear of dwelling APPLICANT Mr D Wright REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 113 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2927/F Full Date Valid 05/12/2007 LOCATION 72 Mountcollyer Avenue, Belfast, BT15 3DR PROPOSAL Erection of two storey and single storey extension to rear of dwelling APPLICANT Ms McClay REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL Page 69

ITEM NO 114 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2929/F Full Date Valid 05/12/2007 LOCATION 20 Cyprus Avenue, Ballyhackamore, Belfast, BT05 5NT PROPOSAL Two storey extension to side and rear of dwelling APPLICANT Mr & Mrs Faith REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 115 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2933/F Full Date Valid 05/12/2007 LOCATION 55 New Barnsley Crescent, Belfast, BT12 PROPOSAL Two-storey extension to side of dwelling and roof extension to front and rear APPLICANT Mr Savage REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION REFUSAL 1 The development results in an unacceptable alteration to the existing roof form which is visually obtrusive and will be detrimental to the appearance of the dwelling. The development is out of character with the streetscape and sets an undesirable precedent for similar extensions which would be to the further detriment of the character of the area.

ITEM NO 116 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2938/F Full Date Valid 06/12/2007 LOCATION 23-27, Oxford Street, Town Parks, Belfast, BT01 3LA PROPOSAL Change of ground floor use from class A1 retail to information centre & office use with alterations to building facade and photo voltaic panels on roof. APPLICANT Northern Ireland Court Service REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL Page 70

ITEM NO 117 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2942/F Full Date Valid 07/12/2007 LOCATION 4 Greenan, Shaws Road, Belfast, BT11 8LU PROPOSAL Single-storey extension to rear of dwelling APPLICANT Mrs J Duffy REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 118 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2971/F Full Date Valid 10/12/2007 LOCATION 21 Beechlands, Malone Lower, Belfast, BT09 5HU PROPOSAL Single storey rear extension and alterations to dwelling APPLICANT Mr & Mrs R & J Bailie REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 119 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2977/F Full Date Valid 11/12/2007 LOCATION 186 Finaghy Road North, Ballymoney, Belfast, BT11 9EG PROPOSAL Single-storey extension to rear of dwelling APPLICANT Mrs E Davey REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 120 APPLIC NO Z/2007/3009/F Full Date Valid 13/12/2007 LOCATION 42 Somerton Road, Skegoneill, Belfast, BT15 3LG PROPOSAL Single-storey extension to side and rear of dwelling APPLICANT Mr A Dameny REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL Page 71

ITEM NO 121 APPLIC NO Z/2007/3024/F Full Date Valid 14/12/2007 LOCATION 98 Hesketh Park, Ballysillan Lower, Belfast, BT14 7JS PROPOSAL Single-storey extension to rear of dwelling APPLICANT Mrs P McDermott REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 122 APPLIC NO Z/2007/3034/F Full Date Valid 17/12/2007 LOCATION 13 Navan Green, Ballydownfine, Belfast, BT11 8JR PROPOSAL Two-storey extension to side of dwelling and single-storey extension to rear of dwelling APPLICANT Mr & Mrs L McCready REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 123 APPLIC NO Z/2007/3035/F Full Date Valid 17/12/2007 LOCATION 42 Fortuna Street, Malone Lower, Belfast, BT12 5PL PROPOSAL Two-storey extension to rear of dwelling and alterations APPLICANT Mr E Nimmons REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 124 APPLIC NO Z/2007/3036/F Full Date Valid 14/12/2007 LOCATION Driver Training Facility, Adelaide Depot, Falcon Road, Belfast PROPOSAL Part change of use from existing storage bay into office/training facility APPLICANT Translink REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL Page 72

ITEM NO 125 APPLIC NO Z/2007/3049/F Full Date Valid 17/12/2007 LOCATION 143 Alexandra Park Avenue, Belfast, BT15 3GB PROPOSAL Change of use from dwelling to 3 no. apartments including 3 storey extension to rear. APPLICANT Mr P Coyle REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION REFUSAL 1 The proposal is contrary to policy QD1 of Planning Policy Statement 7: Quality Residential Environments, policy H8 of the Belfast Urban Area Plan 2001 and the guidance within DGN4: Control of Flat Conversions in that the property is not within a designated Flat Conversion Zone and would, if permitted: - result in the loss of a house suitable for single family occupation, - harm the character, environmental quality and residential amenity of the area by reason of noise, nuisance and inadequate parking facilities, - fail to provide an attractive outlook for future residents, and- include a three storey extension that is unacceptable as it is not subordinate to the main dwelling.

ITEM NO 126 APPLIC NO Z/2008/0010/A Advertisement Date Valid 19/12/2007 LOCATION 699 Lisburn Road, Malone Lower, Belfast, BT09 7GU PROPOSAL Retention of shop sign APPLICANT Ms R Little REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION CONSENT

ITEM NO 127 APPLIC NO Z/2008/0124/A Advertisement Date Valid 10/01/2008 LOCATION Unit UG13, Victoria Square, Belfast PROPOSAL Fascia -type shop sign APPLICANT The Perfume Shop REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION CONSENT

Weekly List Of Planning Applications Registered

For the 22/01/08 to: 28/01/08 For: Belfast Applic ID Location Proposal Applic Devt Type Applicant Agent Z/2008/0120/F Fortwilliam Grange, Refurbishment of and alterations to Full Erection of Sarcon 249 Ltd C/o Ms A Kells Coogan & Co Fortwilliam Park, Belfast existing residential blocks (65 units), Building(s) Coogan & Co Architects Architects Ltd, Glengall erection of further 6no. blocks Ltd, Glengall Exchange, Exchange, 3 Glengall comprising 122 no. apartments with 3 Glengall Street, Belfast, Street, Belfast, BT12 5AB basement carpark and landscaping BT12 5AB and erection of 1no detached and 4no semi-detached dwellings. Z/2008/0145/F 10-30 Shankill Road, Town Construction of 11no. apartments Full Erection of Clear Homes Ltd 157-173 Hall Black Douglas Parks, Belfast, Northern and 1no. ground floor commercial Building(s) Roden Street, Belfast, Architects, 152 Ireland, BT13 unit with ancillary space and BT12 5QA Albertbridge Road, associated parking. Belfast, BT5 4GS Page 73 Z/2008/0147/F 167 Upper Newtownards Demolition of exisitng building & Full Redevelopment Nesbitt 167 Upper Robinson Frizzell Road, Belfast, BT4 erection of new 4 storey office Newtownards Road, Architects., 14 High building & car parking. Belfast, BT4 3HZ Street,, Holywood., BT18 9AZ Z/2008/0169/O 173-187 Ravenhill Construction of 250no apartments Outline Erection of Ravenhill Limited Quinn RPP, Clarence Avenue, Ballynafoy, with basement car parking and Building(s) Partnership PO Box 665, Gallery, Linenhall Street, Belfast, Northern Ireland, associated landscaping Roseneath, The Grange, Belfast, BT2 8BG St Peter Port, Guernsey, GY1 3SJ Z/2008/0172/A 2/4, Donegall Place, Town Shop sign - external, projecting sign Advertisement Display of Mcdonald'S Restaurant Smith AEW Architects, Agenda Item9 Parks, Belfast, Northern - internally Advertisement Ltd 11-59 High Road, Century Buildings, St Ireland, BT01 5BA East Finchley, London, Mary's, Parsonage, N2 8AW Manchester, M3 2DF Z/2008/0173/F 1 Larkfield Gardens, Demolition of vacant garage Full Erection of A&M Motors C/o Agent Mr A Wood VWP Strandtown, Belfast, building and erection of a small Building(s) VWP Architects Ltd, 90 Architects Ltd, 90 Northern Ireland, BT04 detached one and a half storey Castlereagh Road, Castlereagh Road, Belfast, BT5 5FR Belfast, BT5 5FR

05 February 2008 Page 1 of 7 Applic ID Location Proposal Applic Devt Type Applicant Agent Z/2008/0174/F 2 Elaine Street, Malone Demolition of rear return and Full Building Mr Finegan C/O Thomas Thomas O'Hare Lower, Belfast, Northern construction of two storey side and Extension/Alterat O'Hare Architects, 54 Architects, 54 Dunmurry Ireland, BT09 5AR rear extension to existing dwelling. ion Dunmurry Lane, Belfast, Lane, Belfast, BT17 9JR BT17 9JR Z/2008/0185/F 731 Upper Newtownards Extension to existing building (office Full Building Kirkwoods Ltd 731 Upper Murrow , 4 Woodland Road, BT4 & workshop) & new garage. Extension/Alterat Newtownards Road, Manor, Belfast, BT8 7RG ion Belfast, BT4 3NU Z/2008/0178/F 89 Wellesley Avenue, Change of use from 2 to 3 No. Full Change of Use Mr & Mrs J Haugh 127 Mr D Mccrickard Manor Malone Lower, Belfast, Apartments including demolition of Longstone Road, House, 79 Main Street, Northern Ireland, BT09 rear return; erection of 3 storey rear Annalong, BT34 4XA Castlewellan, Co.Down, extension; and alterations. BT31 9DQ Z/2008/0182/F 5 Sans Souci Lane, Single storey extension to dwelling Full Building Mr L Mccrudden 5 Sans Mr D Burgess , 24 Belfast, BT9 Extension/Alterat Souci Lane, Malone Templeburn Road, ion Road, Belfast Raffrey, Crossgar, BT30

9NG Page 74 Z/2008/0184/F Eithne House, Maeve Cladding of the existing buildings, Full Building Nihe 32-36 Great Victoria VB Evans & Company, 3 House, Duncairn Parade, provision of pitched roofs, Extension/Alterat Street, Belfast Pilots View, Heron Road, Belfast, BT15, Finn House, replacement of windows and ion Belfast, BT3 9LE Fianna House, Queens provision of communal aerials and Parade, Belfast, BT15, satelite dishes including temporary Oisin House and provision of same to allow for Cuchulainn House, Victoria cladding works Parade, Belfast, BT15. Z/2008/0135/F 33,35+37 Stranmillis Demolition of 3 no properties Full Redevelopment Gibson C/o Agent Rush & Rush Rush & Co Ltd, 7 Road, Malone Lower, retaining front and side facades and Co Ltd, 7 Upper Malone Upper Malone Road, Belfast, Northern Ireland, rebuilding 3no offices behind Road, Belfast, BT9 6TD Belfast, BT9 6TD retained facades with rear and side extensions Z/2008/0140/F Ravenhill Guest House, Demolition of laundry and boiler Full Building Mr & Mrs Nicholson C/o McGarry-Moon Architects, 690 Ravenhill Road, house and erection of 3 storey Extension/Alterat McGarry-Moon Architects, 9 Fallahogey Road, Ballynafoy, Belfast, managers accommodation ion 9 Fallahogey Road, Kilrea, BT51 5ST Northern Ireland, BT06 Kilrea, BT51 5ST

05 February 2008 Page 2 of 7 Applic ID Location Proposal Applic Devt Type Applicant Agent Z/2008/0155/F 68 Brittons Parade, Belfast, Erection of single-storey extension Full Building Mrs Mm Quigley 68 Mr N Quigley N. Quigley, BT12 7PJ to rear of dwelling for disabled use. Extension/Alterat Brittons Parade, Belfast, 296 Limestone Road, ion BT12 7PJ Belfast, BT15 3AR Z/2008/0171/F 53 Martinez Avenue, Single storey extension to rear of Full Building Mr & Mrs Johnston 53 Andy McDowell Design, Ballyhackamore, Belfast, dwelling Extension/Alterat Martinez Avenue, Belfast, 26 Bellevue, Bangor, Co Northern Ireland, BT05 ion BT5 5LY Down, BT20 5QW Z/2008/0175/F 21-25 Boucher Road, Demolition of existing building and Full Erection of Donegal Place Mr Booth Coogan & Co Ballymurphy, Belfast, construction of 3 no. retail units and Building(s) Investments Limited Architects Ltd, Glengall Northern Ireland, BT12 associated carparking. Glengall Exchange, 3 Exchange, 3 Glengall Glengall Street, Belfast, Street, Belfast, BT12 5AB BT12 5AB Z/2008/0181/O DVLA 148-158, Installation of solar panels on roof of Outline Building Dfpni Rathgael House, Mr D Allan White Young Corporation Street, Town building. Extension/Alterat Balloo Road, Bangor, Green, Northwest Parks, Belfast, Northern ion BT19 7NA Business Complex, Derry, Ireland, BT01 3DH BT48 85E Page 75 Z/2008/0191/F 1012 Upper Crumlin Road, Demolition of existing dwelling and Full Erection of Mr G Bates 1012 Upper Mackel & Doherty BT14 erection of new dwelling Building(s) Crumlin Road, Belfast, Architects, 6 Kinnaird BT14 8FH Street, Belfast, BT14 6BE Z/2008/0193/F 97 Joanmount Park, Old Bay window to front of dwelling. Full Building Ms W Taylor 97 Park, Belfast, Northern Extension/Alterat Joanmount Park, Belfast, Ireland, BT14 6PG ion BT14 6PG Z/2008/0040/F 37 Glandore Avenue, Demolition of existing house and Full Erection of Fraser Homes Ltd C/O Mr D Sutherland Skegoneill, Belfast BT15 erection of 2no townhouses. Building(s) Sutherland Architects Ltd, Sutherland Architects Ltd, 3FD 10 Cleaver Park, Malone 10 Cleaver Park, Malone Road, Belfast Road, Belfast, BT9 5HX Z/2008/0128/F 44 Ulsterville Avenue, Demolition of existing offices and Full Erection of Pjp Properties Ltd Iveagh Joe Walsh Architects, 8A Malone Lower, Belfast, erection of 9no apartments Building(s) Court, 2A Railway Street, Catherine Street, Northern Ireland, BT09 Newcastle Killyleagh, Co Down, BT30 9QQ Z/2008/0136/DC 33,35+37 Stranmillis Demolition of 3 No. Properties Demolition Redevelopment Mc Gibson C/O Agent, 7 Rush & Company LTD, 7 Road, Malone Lower, retaining front and side facades within Cons Area Upper Malone Road, Upper Malone Road, Belfast, Northern Ireland, Belfast, BT9 6TD Belfast, BT9 6TD

05 February 2008 Page 3 of 7 Applic ID Location Proposal Applic Devt Type Applicant Agent Z/2008/0166/F 37 Eglantine Avenue, Demolition of existing 3 storey Full Building Gemin Properties 16 Derek J White, New Inn, Malone Lower, Belfast, return. Alterations within existing Extension/Alterat Malone Beeches, Belfast, Cashel, Co Tipperary Northern Ireland, BT09 building & new 3 storey rear return ion BT9 6EW 6DW to form 9no apartments. Z/2008/0180/O DFP Solicitors Office, Installation of photovoltaic arrays Outline Minor Works/Env. Dfpni Rathgael House, Mr D Allan White Young Victoria Hall, 12 May and solar thermal panels on roof of Improve. Balloo Road, Bangor, Green, Northwest Street, Town Parks, Belfast, building. BT19 7NA Business Complex, Derry, Northern Ireland, BT01 4NL BT48 85E

Z/2008/0188/F Lands located Land located approx 5 metres north Full Other Domestic Multi Development Uk Ltd Moore Building Design approximately 1 metre east of Maysfield Leisure Centre.4no. Alteration 8th Floor, 11-13 Partnership, 2 Bruce of No.69-71 Great Victoria vehicle management signs Gloucester Street, Belfast, Street,, Belfast, BT2 7JD Street. Land located associated with the Victoria Square BT1 4LS approx 1 metre north of development No.31 Chichester Street. Land located south-east of Page 76 Laganside Courts, approximately 10 metres of Oxford Street. Z/2008/0189/F 14 Duncoole Park, Old Two-storey extension to rear of Full Building Mr & Mrs Sydney 14 Christopher Fox , 25 Park, Belfast, Northern dwelling for disabled use. Extension/Alterat Duncoole Park, Belfast, Kilcoole Gardens, Ireland, BT14 8JT ion BT14 8JT Cavehill, Belfast, BT14 8LF Z/2008/0197/F 13 Hallidays Road, Belfast, Conversion from existing HMO to Full Change of Use T&D Properties C/o Total Total Architecture & BT15 2no dwellings including alterations. Architecture & Design Ltd, Design Ltd, 23 University Amendment to previous approval 23 University Street, Street, Belfast, BT7 1FY Z/2007/1882/F to include a 3 storey Belfast, BT7 1FY return. Z/2008/0202/F 111-129 Springfield Road, Proposed mixed use development Full Erection of Mr B Mckee C/o PJ Pj Morgan , 17 Edenderry, Belfast BT12 to include 60no residential and 2no Building(s) Morgan, 17 Glengoland Glengoland Crescent, 7DQ retail units and associated car Crescent, Belfast, BT17 Belfast, BT17 parking.

05 February 2008 Page 4 of 7 Applic ID Location Proposal Applic Devt Type Applicant Agent Z/2008/0211/DC 615 Antrim Road, Proposed demolition of existing Demolition Demolition Bh Property Limited Harry Rolston Architect Skegoneill, Belfast BT15 detached dwelling. within Cons Area Russell Court, Claremount Ltd, 616 Upper 4DY Street, Belfast, BT9 6JX Newtownards Road, Belfast, BT4 3HG Z/2008/0183/F Factory site North West of Construction of 158 apartments with Full Erection of Brackhill C/o CMG Mr C Mcguigan CMG Maldon Street and underground car parking and Building(s) Planning, 158 Upper Planning, 158 Upper Monarch Parade Junction associated landscaping Newtownards Road, Newtownards Road, off Donegall Road, Belfast, Belfast, BT4 3EQ Belfast, BT4 3EQ BT12 Z/2008/0201/F To the rear of 712 Crumlin Erection of 2 No. apartments. Full Erection of Wainwright Properties Mr S Salley HBK Road, Ballysillan Lower, Building(s) 169 Bangor Road, Architects, 2 Garvey Belfast, Northern Ireland, Holywood, Co.Down, Studios, 2-14 Longstone BT14 8AD BT18 OET Street, Lisburn, BT28 Z/2008/0203/F 22 Lakeglen Crescent, Two-storey extension to side of Full Building Mr M Brown 22 Lakeglen Belfast, BT11 8T6 dwelling. Extension/Alterat Crescent, Belfast, BT11 ion 8TG Page 77 Z/2008/0209/F 22 Downview Avenue, Proposed dwelling and garage to Full Erection of Mr & Mrs F Doherty 22 Sketch Architecture, 11 Low-Wood, Belfast BT15 rear of 22 Downview Avenue. Building(s) Downview Avenue, Glenvale, Glenariffe, Antrim Road, Belfast Ballymena, Co. Antrim, BT44 0RW Z/2008/0210/F 98 Skegoneill Avenue and Ground floor Coffee Shop with Full Erection of Mr W Haire 6 Glandore Mr M Hackett Hackett & 2a+2b Victoria Gardens, garages to rear and four apartments Building(s) Parade, Belfast, BT15 3FX Hall, Unit B1.12, Skegoneill, Belfast, above. Portview, 310 Northern Ireland, BT15 Newtownards Road, Z/2008/0217/F 11 Broomhill Park, Malone New domestic access for dwelling Full Other Domestic Mr G Mc Kernan C/o Coogan & Co, Glengall Lower, Belfast, Northern Alteration Coogan & Co, Glengall Exchange, 3 Glengall Ireland, BT09 5JB Exchange, 3 Glengall Street, Belfast, BT12 5AB Street, Belfast, BT12 5AB Z/2008/0231/F CIYMS, 91 Circular Road, Proposed extension to existing Full Erection of Trustees Of Ciyms 91 Scott Wilson, Beechill Belfast, BT4 sports pavillion to include new Building(s) Circular Road, East House, Beechill Road, squash/badminton courts, free Belfast, BT4 2GD Belfast, BT8 7RP weights area, changing rooms and associated works

05 February 2008 Page 5 of 7 Applic ID Location Proposal Applic Devt Type Applicant Agent Z/2008/0059/F 3 Riverview Street, Malone Front dormer to existing HMO Full Building Mr D Boyle C/o Total Total Architecture & Lower, Belfast, Northern (retrospective) Extension/Alterat Architecture, 23 University Design Ltd, 23 University Ireland, BT09 5FD ion Street, Belfast, BT7 1FY Street, Belfast, BT7 1FY

Z/2008/0157/F 6 Green Crescent, Belfast, Two storey extension to side and Full Building Mr & Mrs Mullaly 6 Green Mr D Chambers , 126 BT5 6JE rear of dwelling Extension/Alterat Crescent, Belfast, BT5 6JE Rashee Road, Ballyclare, ion BT39 9HT Z/2008/0190/F 284 Stranmillis Road, 2 storey rear extension and Full Building Mrs K Greeves 284 Mr D Daly Daly and Malone Lower, Belfast, alteration of front porch Extension/Alterat Stranmillis Road, Belfast, O'Neill, 23 William Northern Ireland, BT09 ion BT9 5DZ Street, Portadown Z/2008/0195/F 29A, Windsor Avenue, Erection of replacement dwelling Full Erection of Mr & Mrs D Lamph 21 John D Kelly, 18 High Malone Lower, Belfast, and garage Building(s) Deramore Drive, Belfast, Street, Lurgan, Co Northern Ireland, BT09 BT9 5JR Armagh, BT66 8AW

Z/2008/0213/A 551-553 Lisburn Road, Proposed internally illuminated Advertisement Display of Mr A Jeffrey Pizza Miss Williams Technioal Page 78 Malone Lower, Belfast, fascia sign and projecting sign, a Advertisement Express, Hunton House, Signs Limited, Hillie Northern Ireland, BT09 7GQ menu/poster display installed Highbridge Estate, Oxford Business Centre, 132 St internally behind glazing and Road, Uxbridge, UB8 Albans Road, Watford, alterations to shop front. WD24 4AE Z/2008/0220/F 13 Connsbrook Avenue, Demolish existing building and Full Erection of Darado Properties Ltd C/o Adair JWA Design, 1 Ballyhackamore, Belfast, erect a block of 14 apartments with Building(s) JWA Design, 1 Bramble Bramble Grove, Old Northern Ireland, BT04 associated parking Grove, Old Carrick Road, Carrick Road, Newtownabbey, BT37 0GE Newtownabbey, BT37 0GE

Z/2008/0221/F 69 Greystown Road, Upper Two storey rear extension, roofspace Full Building Mr M Mc Goldrick C/o Mr S Macartney Ivory Malone, Belfast conversion, demolition of existing Extension/Alterat Ivory Architects, 66 Architects, 66 Rawbrae garage and erection of new garage ion Rawbrae Road, Road, Whitehead, BT38 Whitehead, BT38 9SZ 9SZ Z/2008/0223/F 48 Cricklewood Park, 2 storey extension to side and rear Full Building Mr M Chillingworth 48 Mr J Morrison Jim Malone Lower, Belfast, of dwelling with part single storey Extension/Alterat Cricklewood Park, Belfast, Morrison Architects, 31 Northern Ireland, BT09 5GW extension at rear ion BT9 5GW Cricklewood Park, Belfast, BT9 5GW

05 February 2008 Page 6 of 7 Applic ID Location Proposal Applic Devt Type Applicant Agent Z/2008/0225/F 10 Myrtlefield Park, Single storey rear extension to Full Building Mr B Keating 10 Kevin Fennell Design, 2A Malone Lower, Belfast, dwelling Extension/Alterat Myrtlefield Park, Belfast, Dorchester Park, Belfast, Northern Ireland, BT09 ion BT9 6NE BT9 6RH Z/2008/0226/F 6 Ambleside Street, Town Erection of detached single storey Full Erection of Mr D Stanley 6 Kevin Fennell Design, 2A Parks, Belfast, Northern utility/washroom Building(s) Ambleside Street, Belfast, Dorchester Park, Belfast, Ireland, BT13 1QP BT9 6RH Z/2008/0227/F 57 Marlborough Park Single storey extension to side of Full Building Miss C Morgan 26 Mr F Harsh , 6 Glennor North, Belfast, BT9 rear return including new porch. Extension/Alterat Lancefield Road, Lisburn Crescent West, Carryduff, ion Road, Belfast, BT9 BT8 8JF Z/2008/0232/F 8 Springfield Crescent, 2 storey extension to rear and single Full Building Miss J Tolan C/o Robert Robert Bryson, 18 Edenderry, Belfast, storey extension to front of dwelling. Extension/Alterat Bryson, 18 Gransha Park, Gransha Park, Belfast, Northern Ireland, BT12 ion Belfast, BT11 8AU BT11 8AU Z/2008/0233/F 464, Castlereagh Road, Amendment to previous approval Full Building Orangefiled Presbyterian Brian Payne Architects, 7 Carnamuck, Belfast, (Z/2005/2016/F); installation of air Extension/Alterat Church 464 Castlereagh College Avenue, Bangor,

Northern Ireland, BT05 6QQ handling ventilation grilles and ion Road, Belfast, BT5 6BH Co Down, BT20 5HJ Page 79 condensor units. Z/2008/0234/F 9 Winston Gardens, Proposed new garage. Full Building Mr & Mrs R Orr 9 Winston Knox & Clayton Architects Ballycloghan, Belfast, Extension/Alterat Gardens, Belfast, BT5 , 2A Wallace Avenue, Northern Ireland, BT05 ion 6HZ Lisburn, BT27 4AA Z/2008/0237/F 3 London Street, Two storey extension to rear of Full Building Mr F Macken C/o Barry O' Mr B O'Donnell , 51 Ballynafoy, Belfast, dwelling and internal alterations Extension/Alterat Donnell, 51 Carnbrae Carnbrae Avenue, Northern Ireland, BT06 ion Avenue, Newtown Park, Newtown Park, Four Four Winds, Belfast, BT8 Winds, Belfast, BT8 6NH Z/2008/0240/F 30 Torrens Gardens, Old Two storey extension to rear of Full Building Mr M Burns 59 Cardigan Park, Belfast, Northern dwelling with two new windows to Extension/Alterat Drive, Belfast, BT14 6LY Ireland, BT14 6JB gable. ion Z/2008/0241/F 2 Veryon Gardens, Green Proposed pitched roof to replace flat Full Building Mr Gibson 2 Veryan Mr P Jenkins , 40 Mount Castle, Newtownabbey, roof over existing single storey Extension/Alterat Gardens, Belfast, BT36 Merrion Park, Rosetta, Northern Ireland, BT36 extension ion 6LZ Belfast, BT6 0GB TOTAL:- 53

05 February 2008 Page 7 of 7 Weekly List Of Planning Applications Registered

For the 29/01/08 to: 04/02/08 For: Belfast Applic ID Location Proposal Applic Devt Type Applicant Agent Z/2008/0034/DC 29A, Windsor Avenue, Demolition of one-and-a-half storey App within Demolition Mr & Mrs D Lamph 21 John D Kelly, 18 High Malone Lower, Belfast, dwelling, garage and swimming Conservation Deramore Drive, Belfast, Street, Lurgan, Co Northern Ireland, BT09 pool annex. Area BT9 5JR Armagh, BT66 8AW Z/2008/0186/F 34 Knockhill Park, Single-storey rear extension and Full Building Mr & Mrs G Darragh 34 McCready & Co Ballycloghan, Belfast, alterations to dwelling. Extension/Alterat Knockhill Park, Belfast, Architects, 8 Market Northern Ireland, BT05 ion BT5 6HY Place, Lisburn, BT28 1AN Z/2008/0199/F 76 Marlborough Park Erection of two storey side and rear Full Building Dr & Mrs Doran 22 Mr G O'Connor , 20 Central, Belfast, BT9 6HN extension with single storey element Extension/Alterat Osborne Park, Belfast, Osborne Park, Belfast, solely to rear of premises ion BT9 6JN BT9 6JN Page 80 Z/2008/0216/F 18+20 Stranmillis Park, Demolition of 2 existing HMO's and Full Erection of Mr B Mc Givern & Mr N McGinnity Gantley Ltd, Malone Lower, Belfast, erection of 6 self contained Building(s) Smyth C/o McGinnity Third Floor, Cathedral Northern Ireland, BT09 apartments to include retention of Gantley Ltd, Third Floor, Chambers, 143 Royal front facade and erection of Cathedral Chambers, 143 Avenue, Belfast, BT1 1FH extension to rear. Royal Avenue, Belfast, BT1 1FH Z/2008/0224/F 278 Beersbridge Road, Demolition of existing property and Full Erection of Mr R Davidson C/oA- U Weir A-Three Ballymacarret, Belfast, erection of 2 storey 2x2 bedroom Building(s) Three Architecture Design Architecture Design Northern Ireland, BT05 apartments Plan, 43-45 Church Planning, 43-45 Church Street, Portadown, Street, Portadown, County Armagh, BT62 3EU County Armagh, BT62 3EU

Z/2008/0235/F 253-257 Ligoniel Road, Residential development of 6 no. Full Erection of Mr D Trolan Draperstown, Mr A Begley Building Legoniel, Belfast, Northern apartments with associated siteworks Building(s) BT34 7JN Design Solutions, 76 Ireland, BT14 8DQ and car parking. Main Street, Pomeroy, Co Tyrone, BT70 2QP

15 February 2008 Page 1 of 12 Applic ID Location Proposal Applic Devt Type Applicant Agent Z/2008/0247/F 711-713 Lisburn Road, Partial rear extension at ground and Full Building Galgorm Properties C/o Monaghan Tennyson Malone Lower, Belfast, first floor to existing retail unit Extension/Alterat Monaghan Tennyson Architects, 2 Rathgar Northern Ireland, BT09 ion Architects, 2 Rathgar Street, Belfast, BT9 7GD Street, Belfast, BT9 7GD Z/2008/0249/F 26 Ravensdene Crescent, Proposed extension to existing Full Building Mr B Mc Givern 26 KJG Design, 14 Glebe Ballynafoy, Belfast, dwelling Extension/Alterat Ravensdene Crescent, Road, Ballywally, Northern Ireland, BT06 ion Belfast Stangford, Co Down, BT30 7AW Z/2008/0251/LB Belfast City Hall, Donegall Retention of "Big Wheel" in the Listed Building Engineering Belfast City Council City Mr Curran Consarc Design Square, Belfast, BT1 grounds of the City Hall from 01 Consent Operation Hall, Dongall Square, Group, The Gas Office, March - 31 December 2008. Belfast, BT1 5GS Belfast, BT07 2JD Z/2008/0252/F Belfast City Hall, Donegall Retention of "Big Wheel" in the Full Engineering Belfast City Council Consarc Design Group Square, Belfast, BT1 grounds of the City Hall from 01 Operation Belfast City Council, Ltd, The Gas Office, 4 March - 31 December 2008. Belfast City Hall, Cromac Quay, Ormeau Donegall Square, Belfast, Road, Belfast, BT7 2JD Page 81 Z/2008/0256/F 10 Dhu Varren Parade, Replace existing flat roof on rear Full Building Mr & Mrs Swann 10 Dhu Mr Henderson , 1 Belfast, BT13 return with a new pitched roof. Extension/Alterat Varren Parade, Belfast, Lyndhurst Court, Belfast, ion BT13 3FJ BT13 3XE Z/2008/0257/F 34 Glenside Park, Proposed single storey rear Full Building Mr & Mrs A Mc Nally C/o Mr M Bradley , 52 Ballysillan Lower, Belfast, extension Extension/Alterat Mark Bradley, 52 Lansdowne Park, Belfast, Northern Ireland, BT14 ion Lansdowne Park, Belfast, BT15 4AG BT15 4AG Z/2008/0205/LD 221 Spamount Street, Flat roof replacement with new LD Certificate Building Mr Mc Caffrey 221 Mr P Jenkins , 40 Mount Town Parks, Belfast, pitched roof too, two existing single- Proposed Extension/Alterat Spamount Street, Belfast Merrion Park, Belfast, Northern Ireland, BT15 storey rear returns. ion BT6 0GB Z/2008/0214/F 249 259, Ormeau Road, Demolition of existing commercial Full Replacement Mc Alister Holdings Ltd White Ink Architects, 4th Ballynafoy, Belfast, units and associated stores and 5th Floor, Lesley Floor, 21 Talbot Street, Northern Ireland, BT07 3GG construction of ground floor retail Buildings, 61 Fountain Belfast, BT1 2LD unit with storage, 58no apartments Street, Belfast, BT1 5EX with basement and ground floor carpark (3 to 6 storeys)

15 February 2008 Page 2 of 12 Applic ID Location Proposal Applic Devt Type Applicant Agent Z/2008/0245/A Co-Op food store, 361, 1x fascia sign continuous on five Advertisement Display of Cws Financial Services Mr K Watson Futurama Beersbridge Road, plains 1x double sided projecting Advertisement Hanover Buildings, New LTD, Olympia House, Ballyhackamore, Belfast, Century House, Middleton Grove, Leeds, Northern Ireland, BT05 Manchester LS11 5TJ Z/2008/0255/LD 2 Northwick Drive, Single-storey extension to rear of LD Certificate Building Mr F Murphy 2 Northwick Mr P Jenkins , 40 Mount Edenderry, Belfast, dwelling. Proposed Extension/Alterat Drive, Belfast Merrion Park, Belfast, Northern Ireland, BT14 ion BT6 0GB Z/2008/0258/F 39 Norwood Drive, Two storey extension and integral Full Building Mr N Major 39 Norwood A.S. Whiteman Architects, Ballymisert, Belfast, garage to semi-detached two storey Extension/Alterat Drive, Belmont, Belfast, 2F Old Brewery Court, 31 Northern Ireland, BT04 dwelling (amendment to previous ion BT4 2EB Regent Street, planning approval Z/2007/0135) Newtownards, BT23 4AD Z/2008/0262/F Lands at 1+1b Ardenlee Amendments to the existing Full Revised House Tascan Properties Ms A Gibson Kevin Cartin Avenue, Ballynafoy, approval for seven dwellings, Type(s) Limited Unit 5 Belmont Architects Ltd, Unit 5 Belfast, Northern Ireland, consisting of changes to external Office Park, 232-240 Belmont Road, 232-240 BT06 0AA finishes and fenestration and Belmont Road, Belfast, Belmont Road, Belfast, Page 82 provision of rear extensions. BT4 2AW Z/2008/0263/F 43 Cliftondene Gardens, Single-storey extension to side of Full Building Ms M Murtagh 43 Mr H Morgan , 583 Old Park, Belfast, Northern dwelling and replacement of flat Extension/Alterat Cliftondene Gardens, Donegall Road, Belfast, Ireland, BT14 7PF roof to a pitched roof to existing ion Belfast, BT14 7PF BT12 6DX single-storey rear return. Z/2008/0266/A Unit 1c, Castlecourt, Royal 1 flex face, 1 fascia and 1 banner Advertisement Display of Zavvi The School House, Image Technique Ltd, Avenue, Belfast, BT1 sign Advertisement 50 Brook Green, London, Saxon Business Park, W6 7RR Stoke Prior, Bromsgrove, Worcestershire, BT60 4AD Z/2008/0267/F 36 Kingsdale Park, Proposed detached garage Full Building Mr R Graham 36 Mr A Gregg , 32 Carolhill Ballycloghan, Belfast, Extension/Alterat Kingsdale Park, Belfast, Drive, Belfast, BT4 2FT Northern Ireland, BT05 ion BT5 7BY Z/2008/0268/F 48 Willesden Park, Malone Proposed two storey side and rear Full Building Mr R Harwood 48 Mr P Cunningham VWP Lower, Belfast, Northern extension. Dormer windows, attic Extension/Alterat Willesden Park, Belfast, Architects, 90 Castlereagh Ireland, BT09 5GY conversion and roof alterations ion BT9 5GY Road, Belfast, BT5 5FR

15 February 2008 Page 3 of 12 Applic ID Location Proposal Applic Devt Type Applicant Agent Z/2008/0269/F 27 Haddington Gardens, Two storey extension to rear of Full Building Ms A Simpson 27 Mr W Storey Wayne Ballymaconaghy, Belfast, dwelling Extension/Alterat Haddington Gardens, Storey Associates, 46 Northern Ireland, BT06 ion Belfast, BT6 0AN Strand Avenue, Holywood, BT18 9AW Z/2008/0270/F 96 North Road, 2 storey rear extension to dwelling Full Building Mr M Doherty C/o Dempsey Architects, 677 Ballyhackamore, Belfast, and new vehicular access Extension/Alterat Dempsey Architects, 677 Lisburn Road, Belfast, Northern Ireland, BT04 ion Lisburn Road, Belfast, BT9 7GT BT9 7GT Z/2008/0275/F 43 Strathmore Park South, Two storey side and single storey Full Erection of Mr B Rooney C/o TSA Stokes TSA Planning, 18 Low-Wood, Belfast, extension to rear of dwelling Building(s) Planning, 18 Clarence Clarence Chambers, Northern Ireland, BT15 Chambers, Donegal Donegal Square East, Square East, Belfast, BT1 Belfast, BT1 5HE 5HE Z/2008/0276/F 17 Herbert Street, Rear extension to provide wc for Full Building Mrs M O'Neill C/O NIHE, Mr K Moore V B Evans & Edenderry, Belfast, disabled tennant. Extension/Alterat 32-36 Great Victoria Co, 3 Pilots View, Heron

Northern Ireland, BT14 ion Street, Belfast, BT2 7BA Road, Belfast, BT3 9LE Page 83 Z/2008/0076/F 535 Falls Road, Conversion of dwelling back to Full Change of Use Sanco Systems Ltd 531 Robert Ogle, 107 Ballymurphy, Belfast, commercial use. Use Class A1 Falls Road, Belfast, BT11 Colinglen Road,, Belfast, Northern Ireland, BT11 9AA BT17 0NP Z/2008/0148/F 75/77 May Street, Town Refurbishment of existing building Full Building O' Reilly Stewart Robinson & McIlwaine Parks, Belfast, Northern into new offices, including a new Extension/Alterat Solicitors O' Reilly Architects, 84-94 Great Ireland, BT01 3JL roof and projecting feature balcony ion Stewart House, 114-116 Patrick Street, Belfast, on top floor. Royal Avenue, Belfast, BT1 2LU BT1 1DL Z/2008/0165/F 24 Dunmore Drive, Proposed new dwelling with access Full Erection of Mrs B Angus 2 Abbey Mr T Mc Glinchey , 5B Skegoneill, Belfast BT15 off Glanworth Gardens. Building(s) Close, Shore Road, Hawthorn Office Park, 45 3GN Newtownabbey, BT37 9XA Stockmans Way, Belfast, BT9 7ET

15 February 2008 Page 4 of 12 Applic ID Location Proposal Applic Devt Type Applicant Agent Z/2008/0192/A Donegall Square West 1 free standing advertising panel, Advertisement Display of Bt Ni Payphones Ltd BT Mr M Mussen Clear outside No.2 The 1.8M X 1.2M Advertisement NI Payphones, Lisburn Channel NI Ltd, Unit 2, Apartment, Belfast Telephone Exchange, Ashbank, Channel Railway Street, Lisburn, Commercial Park, Queens BT28 1XP Road, Belfast, BT3 9DT

Z/2008/0194/F 17 Viewfort Park, Old Replacement 2.5 storey dwelling Full Replacement Mr P Slane C/o Agent Gifford & Cairns Forge, Dunmurry, Northern and garage Gifford & Cairns, 21 Architects, 21 Listooder Ireland, BT17 9JY Listooder Road, Crossgar, Road, Crossgar, Downpatrick, Co Down, Downpatrick, Co Down, BT30 9JE BT30 9JE Z/2008/0200/A Royal Avenue outside 1 free standing advertising panel, Advertisement Display of Bt Ni Payphones Ltd BT Mr M Mussen Clear Castlecourt, Approx. 15m 1.8M X 1.2M Advertisement NI Payphones Ltd, Channel NI Ltd, Unit 2, North of Berry Street Lisburn Telephone Ashbank, Channel Exchange, Railway Commercial Park, Queens Page 84 Street, Lisburn, BT28 Road, Belfast, BT3 9DT

Z/2008/0204/F 2 Upper Malone Road, Two storey rear and side extension, Full Building Mr & Mrs Irvine 2 Upper Kennedy Tweedie&Neill Malone Upper, Belfast, proposed front porch and alterations Extension/Alterat Malone Road, Belfast, Architects, 21 Marine Northern Ireland, BT09 to dwelling. ion BT18 9HY Parade, Holywood, BT18 9HY Z/2008/0206/A Outside 10 11, Shaftesbury 1 free standing advertising panel, Advertisement Display of Bt Payphones Ni Ltd Mr M Mussen Clear Square, Malone Lower, 1.8m x 1.2m Advertisement Lisburn Telephone Channel NI Ltd, Unit 2, Belfast, Northern Ireland, Exchange, Lisburn, BT28 Ashbank, Channel BT02 7DA 1XP Commercial Park, Queens Road, Belfast, BT3 9DT

Z/2008/0207/A Opposite 41 Arthur Street 1 free standing advertising panel, Advertisement Display of Bt Ni Payphones Ltd Mr M Mussen Clear (Avoca), Town Parks, 1.8m x 1.2m Advertisement Lisburn Telephone Channel NI Ltd, Unit 2, Belfast, Northern Ireland, Exchange, Railway Ashbank, Channel BT01 4GG Street, Belfast, BT28 1XP Commercial Park, Queens Road, Belfast, BT3 9DT

15 February 2008 Page 5 of 12 Applic ID Location Proposal Applic Devt Type Applicant Agent Z/2008/0208/A Royal Avenue, Belfast, 1 free standing advertising panel, Advertisement Display of Bt Ni Payphones Ltd Mr M Mussen Clear Outside Primark, BT1 1.8m x 1.2m Advertisement Lisburn Telephone Channel NI Ltd, Unit 2, Exchange, Railway, Ashbank, Channel Lisburn, BT18 1XP Commercial Park, Queens Road, Belfast, BT3 9DT

Z/2008/0212/F 1 Hill Street, Belfast, BT1 Proposed structure to enclose Full Building Ultimate Leisure Group O'Donnell O'Neill Design external smoking area Extension/Alterat Plc 26 Mosley Street, Associates, 5 Stranmillis ion Newcastle Upon Tyne Road, Belfast, BT9 5AF Z/2008/0215/F 69-71 Great Victoria Proposed 13 storey mixed use Full Erection of Mrs R Copeland & Mrs S Knox & Clayton Architects Street, Belfast development with apartments Building(s) Mc Kelvey 120 W.Sterne , 2A Wallace Avenue, (48no) and ground floor retail Parkway, Littleton, CO Lisburn, BT27 4AA 80120, USA Z/2008/0219/LD 5 Kenmare Park, Malone Single-storey extension to rear of LD Certificate Building Mr B Millar 5 Kenmare Mr I Mccallum , 5 The Lower, Belfast, Northern dwelling. Proposed Extension/Alterat Park, Belfast, BT12 5BU Willows, Newtownards,

Ireland, BT12 5BU ion BT23 8FJ Page 85 Z/2008/0222/A Strip of land at junction of 2 free standing 48 sheet display Advertisement Display of Clear Channel Ni Ltd Hillview Road and Crumlin panels Advertisement Channel Commercial Road Belfast Park, Queens Road, Belfast, BT3 9DT Z/2008/0229/F 143 Knock Road, Knock, Retention of two storey rear Full Building Mr & Mrs W Ferguson 143 Belfast, Northern Ireland, extension to dwelling. Extension/Alterat Knock Road, Belfast, BT05 6LH ion BT5 6LG Z/2008/0236/A Unit 1 Westwood Centre, 1x 1900mm internally illuminated Advertisement Display of Asda Stores Ltd Great Mr C Place Omega Signs BT11 disc sign, 2x 1900mm externally Advertisement Wilson Street, Leeds, Ltd, Newmarket illuminated disc sign, 2x 740mm LS11 5AD Approach, Leeds, LS9 externally illuminated disc sign, 1x 1390x 1100mm opening hours

15 February 2008 Page 6 of 12 Applic ID Location Proposal Applic Devt Type Applicant Agent Z/2008/0238/F 64-72 Castlereagh Road, Erection of 1 no. commercial unit at Full Erection of Ddd Ltd C/O A-three Ms S Mcparland A-Three Ballymacarret, Belfast, ground floor level with 8 no Building(s) Architecture Design, Architecture Design Northern Ireland, BT05 apartments at first and second floor Planning, 43-45 Church Planning, 43-45 Church and 2 no. of duplex apartments at Street, Portadown, Street, Portadown, third floor amendments to approval County Armagh, BT62 3EU County Armagh, BT62 3EU Z/2005/1627/F Z/2008/0239/F 9 Benbradagh Gardens, Proposed single storey extension to Full Building Mrs M Rooney 9 Mr Eddie Weir, Ballydownfine, Belfast, rear of dwelling. Extension/Alterat Benbradagh Gardens, Architectural Design Northern Ireland, BT11 ion Belfast, BT11 8JS Partnership, 12a Hibernia Street, Holywood, BT18 9JE Z/2008/0243/F 7 Garranard Park, Proposed demolition of existing Full Redevelopment Mr & Mrs R Forster 7 Mr I Gault Wandsworth Ballymisert, Belfast, dwelling and erection of new Garranard Park, Belfast, Architecture Ltd., 5 The Northern Ireland, BT04 dwellings BT4 2GL Close, Millars Forge, Dundonald, Belfast, BT16 Page 86 1QS Z/2008/0244/F 6 Castleorr Manor, Killeen Two storey rear extension to Full Building Mr G Truesdale 6 Mr G Mccone , 9 (Holywood), Belfast, Extension/Alterat Castleorr Manor, Belfast, Cairnburn Drive, Belfast, Northern Ireland, BT04 ion BT4 BT4 2HW Z/2008/0246/F 1 Balmoral Avenue, Two storey side and rear extension Full Building Mr J Mcmahon 1 Mcmahon , 1 Balmoral Malone Upper, Belfast, to existing dwelling. Extension/Alterat Balmoral Avenue, Avenue, Belfast, BT9 Northern Ireland, BT09 ion Z/2008/0253/F 35 Donegall Street, Town Change of Use from Office space to Full Change of Use Dance Resource Base 35 Parks, Belfast, Northern Dance Studio at first floor level. Donegall Street, Belfast, Ireland, BT01 2FG BT1 2FG Z/2008/0254/F 59 Onslow Gardens, Replacement two storey dwelling Full Building Mr B Halliday 8 Winana Mr A Newett , 8 Winona Ballymaconaghy, Belfast, and garage. Extension/Alterat Lodge, Donaghcloney, Lodge, Donaghcloney, Northern Ireland, BT06 ion BT66 7GE Co Armagh, BT66 7GE Z/2008/0259/F 19 Mervue Street, Town Ground floor extension to rear of Full Building Mr M Mc Donald C/o VB Evans & Company, 3 Parks, Belfast, Northern dwelling for WC (disabled tenant) Extension/Alterat NIHE, 32-36 Great Pilots View, Heron Road, Ireland, BT15 2JL ion Victoria Street, Belfast, Belfast, BT3 9LE BT2 7BA

15 February 2008 Page 7 of 12 Applic ID Location Proposal Applic Devt Type Applicant Agent Z/2008/0264/F Vacant land between Social Housing consisting of 49 No. Full Erection of Fold Housing Association Mr P Minnis Todd Iverna Street & recently dwellings (35 No. townhouses and Building(s) Fold House, 3 Redburn Architects, 41-43 Hill completed fold housing at 14 No. apartments.) Square, Holywood Street, Belfast, BT1 2PB Beit Street and land at Symons Street - Connaught Street, BT12. Z/2008/0265/LD 14 Rushfield Avenue, Single storey rear extension to LD Certificate Building Mr S Waterworth 14 Kerr Wayne Storey Ballynafoy, Belfast, existing dwelling. Proposed Extension/Alterat Rushfield Avenue, Associates Ltd, 46 Strand Northern Ireland, BT07 ion Belfast, BT7 3FP Avenue, Holywood, Co Down, BT18 9AW Z/2008/0271/F 241 Whitewell Road, Two-storey side extension to existing Full Erection of Keenwood Construction Kevin Cartin Architect, Drumnadrough, dwelling and erection of 9no Building(s) Ltd C/o Kevin Cartin Unit 5 Belmont Office Newtownabbey BT36 7NW apartments with associated car Architect, Unit 5 Belmont Park, 232 - 240 Belmont parking and landscaping in rear Office Park, 232 - 240 Road, Belfast, BT4 2AW garden. Belmont Road, Belfast, BT4 7NW Page 87 Z/2008/0272/F 1,9 Blacks Road, 1,2 Multi-element improvements to 45 Full Building Nihe Design & Property McCutcheon & Wilkinson, Carnanmore Gardens, no. NIHE owned dwellings and 6 no. Extension/Alterat Services, Belfast Area 18 Linenhall Street, 1,3,9A,13A,11A,13B,15A,1 NIHE garages. External cyclic ion Office, 32-36 Great Ballymena, BT43 5AL 5B,17A,17B,19A,19B,20,2 maintenance to 4 No. owner Victoria Street, Belfast 1A,21B,22A,22B,23A,23B, occupied flats. 24A,24B,28,30 Carnanmore Park, 5,11,13,14,15,16,19,21,25 ,27 Donegore Gardens, 80,82,90A,90B,92A,92B,9 6,98 Tildarg Avenue Z/2008/0273/F 140 Kilcoole Gardens, Old Conversion of single dwelling to 2 Full Building Ms D Menaul 140 Mackel & Doherty Park, Belfast, Northern no. dwellings with alterations to Extension/Alterat Kilcoole Gardens, Belfast, Architects, 6 Kinnaird Ireland, BT14 8LJ elevations. ion BT14 8LJ Street, Belfast, BT14 6BE

15 February 2008 Page 8 of 12 Applic ID Location Proposal Applic Devt Type Applicant Agent Z/2008/0279/F 163-165 Ligoniel Road, Demolition of existing 2-storey Full Erection of Edeneast Ltd 88 Claggan JADA Architects, Ballysillan Lower, Belfast, public house and off-licence. Building(s) Lane, Cookstown, BT80 Wellington Park Business Northern Ireland, BT14 Erection of mixed-use development 9UR Centre, 3 Wellington comprising 2 no ground floor retail Park, Belfast, BT9 6DJ units and 6 no residential apartments over with associated Z/2008/0281/F 188 Belmont Road, Provision of 5 No. temporary Full Temporary The Board Of Governors Ms S Mccoy Samuel Strandtown, Belfast, classroom units, temporary toilet Building Strathearn School Stevenson & Sons, 4 Northern Ireland, BT04 and locker accommodation and the Strathearn School, Greenwood Avenue, relocation of 5 No. existing mobiles Belfast, BT4 2AU Belfast, BT4 3HR with alterations. Z/2008/0282/A Unit 4, St Georges Market, Painted timber fascia with foan Advertisement Display of Subway Development Kerr Wayne Storey Belfast, BT1 3NQ Advertisement Ireland 3 Market Place, Associates Ltd, 46 Strand Carrickfergus, BT38 7AW Avenue, Holywood, Co Down, BT18 9AW Page 88 Z/2008/0283/A Isaac Agnew, 1 Boucher 1x fascia sign, 1x double sided Advertisement Display of Isaac Agnew 1 Boucher Mr K Watson Futurama Way, Belfast, BT12 totem sign, 1x singel sided entrance Advertisement Way, Belfast, BT12 6RE LTD, Olympia House, Middleton Grove, Leeds, LS11 5TJ Z/2008/0287/LB Unit 4, St Georges Market, Proposed erection of signage in the Listed Building Display of Subway Development Wayne Storey Associates, Belfast, BT1 form of painting existing timber Consent Advertisement Ireland 3 Market Place, 46 Strand Avenue, fascia and erecting sets of foamx Carrickfergus, BT38 7AY Holywood, BT18 9AW letters to the fascia. Z/2008/0288/F 23 Eccles Street, Town 2 storey extension to rear of existing Full Building Mr J Doherty C/o Arcus Arcus Architects, Arena Parks, Belfast, Northern dwelling Extension/Alterat Architects, Arena Building, 85 Ormeau Ireland, BT13 3GS ion Building, 85 Ormeau Road, Belfast, BT7 1SH Road, Belfast, BT7 1SH Z/2008/0289/F 8 Clare Hill, Old Park, Two-storey extension to side of Full Building Mr R Croft 8 Clare Hill, Drawing And Planning Belfast, Northern Ireland, dwelling and single-storey extension Extension/Alterat Belfast, BT14 8LY Services , 22 Dhu Varren BT14 8LY to rear of dwelling. ion Crescent, Belfast, BT13 3FL

15 February 2008 Page 9 of 12 Applic ID Location Proposal Applic Devt Type Applicant Agent Z/2008/0290/F 49 Waterloo Gardens, Low- Two storey extension to rear of Full Building Mr M Devine 49 Waterloo Mr P Morgan , 17 Wood, Belfast, Northern dwelling Extension/Alterat Gardens, Belfast, BT15 Glengoland Crescent, Ireland, BT15 4EY ion Belfast, BT17 0JG Z/2008/0291/F Lands at 107-115 Ligoniel Erection of 43 no. residential units Full Erection of Iconic Developments Ltd Mackel and Doherty Road, Ballysillan Lower, including 26 no. 2-bedroom Building(s) C/o Mackel And Doherty Architects, 6 Kinnaird Belfast, Northern Ireland, apartments in two blocks, 5 no Architects, 6 Kinnaird Street, Antrim Road, BT14 8BW townhouses and 12 no .semi- Street, Antrim Road, Belfast, BT14 6BE detached dwellings. Associated Belfast, BT14 6BE carparking and amenity spaces and new access road. Z/2007/2983/F 14a Deramore Park South, Erection of domestic garage Full Erection of Irvine 14A Deramore Park Mr S Hagan John P Malone Upper, Belfast, Building(s) South, Belfast, BT9 5JY Hagan, Montrose House, BT09 5JY. 17-21 Church Street, Portadown, BT62 3LN Z/2008/0274/F Ligoniel Primary School Ramped access to nursery school Full Building Belfast Education & VB Evans & Company, 3

and Glenbank Nursery entrance and vertical lift extension Extension/Alterat Library Board 40 Pilots View, Heron Road, Page 89 School, Ligoniel Road, to main school building. ion Academy Street, Belfast, Belfast, BT3 9LE Belfast BT1 2NQ Z/2008/0292/F Royal Group of Hospitals, Erection of single-storey extension Full Building Royal Group Of Hopsitals Isherwood & Ellis Maternity, Belfast to the maternity building to provide Extension/Alterat Grosvenor Road, Belfast, Architects, 15 Malone additional storage. ion BT12 6BA Road, Belfast, BT9 6RT Z/2008/0293/F 73 Monagh Road, Single-storey extension and dormer Full Building Mr Brennan 73 Monagh Mr P Jenkins , 40 Mount Ballymurphy, Belfast, window to rear of dwelling. Extension/Alterat Road, Belfast Merrion Park, Rosetta, Northern Ireland, BT11 ion Belfast, BT6 0GB Z/2008/0294/F 30 Rosapenna Drive, Town Single storey extension to rear of Full Building Mr C P Mc Manus & Miss Mr P Jenkins , 40 Mount Parks, Belfast, Northern dwelling Extension/Alterat A M Morrison 30 Merrion Park, Belfast, Ireland, BT14 6GT ion Rosapenna Drive, Belfast BT6 0GB Z/2008/0296/F 21 Combermere Mews, Proposed change of use from vacant Full Change of Use Mr R Dean 80 Fane Kenneth Wilson Belfast, BT12 5FP ground floor store to produce new Street, Belfast, BT9 7BW A.B.I.A.T, 12 Downshire entrance, licensed bar facilities and Road, Belfast, BT6 9JL disabled toilet facilities.

15 February 2008 Page 10 of 12 Applic ID Location Proposal Applic Devt Type Applicant Agent Z/2008/0300/F 61 Strathroy Park, 2 storey extension to rear and single Full Building Ms K O'Hanlon 61 Drawing & Planning Edenderry, Belfast, storey porch to front of existing Extension/Alterat Strathroy Park, Belfast, Services, 22 Dhu Varren Northern Ireland, BT14 dwelling ion BT14 7LN Crescent, Belfast, BT13 3FL Z/2008/0302/LD 17 Rosapenna Parade, Flat roof replacement with new LD Certificate Building Mr J Teer 17 Rosapenna Mr P Jenkins , 40 Mount Town Parks, Belfast, pitched roof to existing single-storey Proposed Extension/Alterat Parade, Belfast Merrion Park, Belfast, Northern Ireland, BT14 rear return. ion BT6 0GB Z/2008/0152/F 263 Orby Drive, Belfast, First floor extension to rear of Full Building Mr B Simons 263 Orby BT5 6BG dwelling and roof space conversion Extension/Alterat Drive, Belfast, BT5 6BG with rear dormer and new window in ion side elevation Z/2008/0187/O HSE, 83 Ladas Drive, Installation of photo voltaic arrays Outline Engineering Dfpni Rathgael House, Mr D Allan White Young Lisnasharragh, Belfast, and solar thermal panels on roof of Operation Balloo Road, Bangor, Green, Northwest BT06 9FR building to provide hot water and BT19 7NA Business Complex, Derry,

generate electricity from renewable BT48 85E Page 90 energy resource Z/2008/0228/F North Foreshore Site, Management System for landfill Full Engineering Belfast City Council Mr R Haldane WDR & RT Dargan Road, Belfast gas, comprising capping, Operation Development Taggart, Laganwood installation of gas abstraction, wells Department, Cecil Ward House, Newforge Lane, and pipework (gas to be drawn off to Building, 4-10 Linenhall Malone Road, Belfast, be flared at a nearby existing Street, Belfast, BT2 8BP BT9 5NX facility), and site access. Z/2008/0260/F Power Generation Installation of an electricity Full Engineering Mr J Mellor Unit 11, Compound, Dargan Road generating station fuelled by landfill Operation Bedford Business Centre, Landfill site, Dargan Road, gas collected from the Mile Road, Bedford, Belfast BT3 9JP. neighbouring landfill site. MK42 9TW Z/2008/0261/F 15 Lichfield Avenue, First floor rear extension to dwelling Full Building Mr A Jones 15 Lichfield Mr A Quinn , 52 Ballyhackamore, Belfast, Extension/Alterat Avenue, Belfast, BT5 5JQ Edenderry Village, BT05 5JQ ion Belfast, BT8 8LG Z/2008/0278/LD 14 Whiterock Drive, Erection of single-storey garage to LD Certificate Building Ms K Heffernan 14 White Kevin Fennell Design, 2A Ballymurphy, Belfast, side of dwelling. Existing Extension/Alterat Rock Drive, Belfast, BT12 Dorchester Park, Belfast, Northern Ireland, BT12 ion BT9 6RH

15 February 2008 Page 11 of 12 Applic ID Location Proposal Applic Devt Type Applicant Agent Z/2008/0295/F 14 Cluan More Drive, Erection of a two storey side Full Building Mr D O'Neill 14 Cluan Kevin Fennell Design, 2A Belfast, BT12 extension, a single storey front Extension/Alterat More Drive, Belfast, BT12 Dorchester Park, Belfast, extension and garden shed / store. ion BT9 6RH Z/2008/0299/F 43 Wallasey Park, Old Erection of a single storey extension Full Building Mrs A Hughes 43 Jenkins Techniplan Park, Belfast, BT14 6PN to rear of dwelling. Extension/Alterat Wallasey Park, Belfast Enterprises, 40 Mount ion Merrion Park, Belfast, BT6 OGB Z/2008/0301/F 156 Shankill Road, Town Renovation of ground floor retail Full Building Mr A Sherwani 401 Mr K Galashan Drawing & Parks, Belfast, BT13 2BE unit with a 2 bedroom self Extension/Alterat Lisburn Road, Belfast, Planning Services, 22 contained apartment over. ion BT9 7EW Dhu Varren Crescent, Belfast, BT13 3FL Z/2008/0303/A Musgrave Cash & Carry, 1- Framed white aluminium sheet with Advertisement Display of Musgrave Wholesale Mr Pw Wilson Nestor Kelly 15 Dargan Crescent, Low- blue text, fixed to existing cladding Advertisement Services 1-15 Dargan Consulting Eng, Wood Intake, Belfast, Crescent, Belfast, BT3 9HJ Sheraton House, Northern Ireland, BT03 Hartsland Avenue, Cork,

Republic Of Ireland Page 91 Z/2008/0304/LD 25 Colinview Street, Flat roof replacement with new LD Certificate Building Mr M F Quinn 25 Mr P Jenkins , 40 Mount Edenderry, Belfast, pitched roof too existing two-storey Proposed Extension/Alterat Colinview Street, Belfast Merrion Park, Belfast, Northern Ireland, BT12 rear return. ion BT6 0GB TOTAL:- 83

15 February 2008 Page 12 of 12

Weekly List Of Planning Applications Registered

For the 05/02/08 to: 11/02/08 For: Belfast Applic ID Location Proposal Applic Devt Type Applicant Agent Z/2008/0168/F 471-481 Lisburn Road, Demolition of existing retail unit Full Redevelopment Stranmillis Investments Mr Furey RPP Architects Malone Lower, Belfast, and erection of a commercial Ltd C/o RPP, Clarence LTD, Clarence Gallery, BT09 7EZ building (4.5 storeys), comprising Gallery, Linenhall Street, Linenhall Street, Belfast, office and retail with basement Belfast, BT2 8BG BT2 8BG Z/2008/0314/F 54 Fruithill Park, Erection of a single-storey extension Full Building Mrs M Maguire No 54 Mr P A Anderson Paul Ballydownfine, Belfast, to rear of dwelling. Extension/Alterat Fruithill Park, Belfast, Anderson Chartered BT11 8GF ion BT11 OG Architect, 34 Woodfield, Newtownabbey, BT37 Page 92 Z/2008/0318/F 12 Northwood Parade, Erection of a two storey extension to Full Building Mr F Kernaghan 12 Skegoneill, Belfast, BT15 rear of dwelling Extension/Alterat Northwood Parade, 3QH ion Belfast, BT15 3QH Z/2008/0335/DC 75-81 Victoria Street, Demolition of existing building. Demolition Demolition Mr N O'Hanrahan C/o Coogan & Co, Glengall Town Parks, Belfast BT1 within Cons Area Coogan & Co, Glengall Exchange, 3 Glengall Exchange, 3 Glengall Street, Belfast, BT12 5AB Street, Belfast, BT12 5AB Z/2008/0277/F 8 Lanyon Place, Belfast, Erection of mixed use development Full Erection of William Ewart Properties Lavery Broadway Malyan, BT1 : office use, retail/restaurant use, Building(s) Ltd The Linenhall, 32-38 42-48 Howard Street, residential use (104 no. apartments) Linenhall Street, Belfast, Belfast, BT1 6PA with associated ancillary space & BT2 8BG parking to basement & lower ground levels. Z/2008/0285/F 43 Ardenlee Gardens, Erection of a single storey rear Full Building Mr R Bennett 43 Mr A Gregg , 32 Carolhill Ballynafoy, Belfast, BT06 extension to dwelling for disabled Extension/Alterat Ardenlee Gardens, Drive, Belfast, BT4 2FT 8QH use. ion Belfast, BT6 8QH Z/2008/0297/F 32 Kimberley Drive, Erection of a two-storey rear Full Building Mr M Linden 32 Mr P Jenkins , 40 Mount Ballynafoy, Belfast, BT07 extension and a front porch to Extension/Alterat Kimberley Drive, Belfast Merrion Park, Belfast, 3EE dwelling. ion BT6 0GB

15 February 2008 Page 1 of 7 Applic ID Location Proposal Applic Devt Type Applicant Agent Z/2008/0298/F Musgrave Cash & Carry, 1- Proposal to provide loading bay Full Building Musgrave Wholesale Westor Kelly Consulting 15 Dargan Crescent, Low- extension (397m2). Concrete base Extension/Alterat Services 1-15 Dargan Engineers, Sheraton Wood Intake, Belfast, BT03 4.5m x 4.5m internal alterations ion Crescent, Duncrue Road, House, Hartlands Avenue, 9JP provide chill and frozen rooms. Belfast, BT3 9HJ Cork Operations office and driver's toilet. Battery changing room. 1st floor canteen, toilets and locker rooms. Z/2008/0305/F Knocknagoney Road, Erection of bus shelter on public Full Erection of Clear Channel Ni Ltd Unit opposite 1 Knocknagoney footpath Building(s) 2 Ashbank, Channel Gardens, Knocknagoney, Commercial Park, Queens Belfast, BT04 2QA Road, Belfast, BT3 9DT

Z/2008/0306/A 23 Cregagh Road, Consent to display fascia sign and a Advertisement Display of Cws Retail Financial Mr K Watson Futurama Ballynafoy, Belfast, double sided projecting sign Advertisement Services Hanover LTD, Olympia House, Northern Ireland, BT06 Buildings, New Century Middleton Grove, Leeds, House, Manchester LS11 5TJ Page 93 Z/2008/0309/F 8 Sandhurst Gardens, Erection of a two storey rear Full Building Mr P Mongan C/o Agent O'Connor Gregory Malone Lower, Belfast, extension to dwelling. Extension/Alterat Gregory Architects, 4 Architects, 4 Crescent BT09 5AW ion Crescent Gardens, Gardens, Belfast, BT7 Belfast, BT7 1NS 1NS Z/2008/0310/F 28 Malone Heights, Roofspace remodelling with dormer Full Building Ms L James 28 Malone Mr Mmck Mckernan Malone Upper, Belfast, to rear Extension/Alterat Heights, Belfast, BT9 Martin McKernan ion Chartered Architects, 88 Clifton Street, Belfast, BT13 1AB Z/2008/0311/F 48 Greystone Park, Belfast, Conversion of existing garage to Full Building Mr R Snape 48 Greystown Kevin Fennell Design, 2A BT9 6UP family room, two storey rear Extension/Alterat Park, Belfast, BT9 6UP Dorchester Park, Belfast, extension and single storey rear ion BT9 6RH extension to dwelling. Z/2008/0312/F 13 Norglen Drive, Erection of a single storey rear Full Building Mrs J Mccourt 13 Norglen Mr R Bryson , 18 Gransha Ballymurphy, Belfast, extension. Extension/Alterat Drive, Belfast, BT11 8DG Park, Belfast, BT11 8AU BT11 8DG ion

15 February 2008 Page 2 of 7 Applic ID Location Proposal Applic Devt Type Applicant Agent Z/2008/0315/F 101 Deerpark Road, Old Erection of a three storey rear Full Building Mr M Connor 101 Park, Belfast, BT14 7PX extension. Extension/Alterat Deerpark Road, Belfast, ion BT14 7PX Z/2008/0319/F 8 Ardmore Drive, Erection of a two storey rear Full Building Mr S Mc Ilwaine 8 Ballyfinaghy, Belfast, extension, a single storey rear and Extension/Alterat Ardmore Drive, Belfast, BT10 0JN side extension, and roof space ion BT10 0JN conversion with rear dormer window. Z/2008/0320/F 100 Downview Park West, Demolition of existing dwelling and Full Erection of Mr M Lee C/O Agent, Mr B Johnston Ferguson Low-Wood, Belfast, BT15 construction of 5 no. apartments Building(s) Ferguson Wheeler, Wheeler, Citylink Business 5HZ over 3 storeys with in-curtilage College House, Citylink, Park, Durham Street, parking. Business Park, BT12 5HZ Belfast, BT12 4HQ Z/2008/0321/F 166-194 Woodvale Road, Construction on cleared site of Full Erection of Erne Developments Mr C Craig Whittaker & Edenderry, Belfast, BT13 mixed use development consisting Building(s) Tudor Renewal Area, Watt Architects, 379 3BX of 12 townhouses, 3 apartments and Residents Association, Antrim Road,

a 3-storey office building 133 Tennent Street, Newtownabbey, BT36 Page 94 Z/2008/0324/F 28 & 34-52 Gardiner Residential development of 3 no. Full Erection of Mr S Toan 12 Thornburn Mackel and Doherty Street, Town Parks, Belfast, three bedroom apartments, 6no two Building(s) Road, Newtownabbey, Architects, 6 Kinnaird BT13 2GT bedroom apartments and 6no BT36 7HZ Street, Antrim Road, townhouses with associated car Belfast, BT14 6BE parking and amenity space. Z/2008/0336/F 453-459 Antrim Road, Demolition of existing buildings and Full Erection of Davidson & Hardy (Ls) Ltd Coogan & Co, Glengall Skegoneill, Belfast, BT15 erection of 29No. residential units Building(s) C/o Coogan & Co, Exchange, 3 Glengall 3BJ with associated car parking and Glengall Exchange, 3 Street, Belfast, BT12 5AB landscaping. Glengall Street, Belfast, BT12 5AB Z/2008/0337/F 7 Sunninghill Gardens, Erection of a single storey extension Full Building Mr W Simpson 7 Mr Eddie Weir, Old Park, Belfast, BT14 6SP to rear of dwelling Extension/Alterat Sunninghill Gardens, Architectural Design ion Belfast, BT14 6SP Partnership, 12a Hibernia Street, Holywood, BT18 9JE

15 February 2008 Page 3 of 7 Applic ID Location Proposal Applic Devt Type Applicant Agent Z/2008/0198/F 29 Jerusalem Street, New roof dormer to rear and Full Building L&E Properties C/o Total Mr Sm Millen Total Malone Lower, Belfast, alterations to existing HMO Extension/Alterat Architecture & Design Ltd, Architecture & Design Ltd, BT07 1QN ion 23 University Street, 23 University Street, Belfast, BT7 1FY Belfast, BT7 1FY Z/2008/0218/F 17 Kimberley Drive, Erection of a single storey extension Full Building Ms G Flood 17 Kimberley Mr W A J Dawson , 21 Belfast, BT7 3EE to rear of dwelling and new Extension/Alterat Drive, Belfast, BT7 3EE Jameson Street, Belfast, vehicular access to front of dwelling ion BT7 2GV Z/2008/0280/LB 14, 15 & 16 Upper Demolition of existing rear returns Listed Building Redevelopment Mr & Mrs J Miskelly C/o Mr C Mcguigan CMG Crescent, Malone Lower, and retention and refurbishment of Consent CMG Planning, 158 Planning, 158 Upper Belfast, BT07 1NT facade and main houses with new 3 Upper Newtownards Newtownards Road, storey returns to rear and associated Road, Belfast, BT4 3EQ Belfast, BT4 3EQ works to provide 3no dwellings Z/2008/0284/F 313 Beersbridge Road, Demolition of existing end-terrace Full Building Six Mile Developments Mr A Mcdowell AMD Ballyhackamore, Belfast, property and construction of Extension/Alterat Ltd C/o AMD Architectural Architectural Design, 8 BT05 5DS apartment block comprising 3no 1 ion Design, 8 Canvy Manor, Canvy Manor, Portadown,

bedroom apartments with associated Portadown, BT 63 5LP BT 63 5LP Page 95 site works Z/2008/0286/LD 8 Norton Drive, Malone Proposed single storey extensions to LD Certificate Building Mr G Craig 8 Norton Upper, Belfast, BT09 6ST side and rear of dwellinghouse Existing Extension/Alterat Drive, Belfast, BT9 6ST ion Z/2008/0307/LD 27 Veryan Gardens, Green Single-storey extension to rear of LD Certificate Building Mr J Patton 27 Veryan Mr P Jenkins , 40 Mount Castle, Newtownabbey, dwelling. Proposed Extension/Alterat Gardens, Belfast Merrion Park, Belfast, Northern Ireland, BT36 ion BT6 0GB Z/2008/0313/F 31 University Road, Change of use of third floor attic Full Change of Use Ms H O' Malley C/o The Mr A Acheson The Boyd Malone Lower, Belfast, storage for the restaurant to staff Bo Tree, 31 University Partnership, 1 River's accommodation Road, Belfast, BT7 1NA Edge, 13 Ravenhill Road, Belfast, BT6 8DN Z/2008/0323/F 17 Sandhurst Drive, Change of use from dwelling to 3no. Full Change of Use Mr S Napier 19 Colenso Mr C Dynan , 147 Malone Lower, Belfast, apartments and erection of a 2 1/2 Parade, Belfast, BT9 5AN Sandown Road, Belfast, BT09 5AY storey rear extension BT56GX

15 February 2008 Page 4 of 7 Applic ID Location Proposal Applic Devt Type Applicant Agent Z/2008/0327/F 165, 167, 169 Ormeau Demolition of existing building and Full Redevelopment Mr M Mcmahon C/O Coogan & Co, Glengall Road, Malone Lower, erection of 2No. small retail units Coogan & Co, Glengall Exchange, 3 Glengall Belfast, BT07 1SQ and 32No. residential units with Exchange, 3 Glengall Street, Belfast, BT12 5AB associated groundfloor parking. Street Z/2008/0350/F 88 Owenvarragh Park, Erection of a two storey extension to Full Building Ms M Lavery C/o Robert Robert Bryson, 18 Ballydownfine, Belfast, side and rear of dwelling Extension/Alterat Bryson, 18 Gransha Park, Gransha Park, Belfast, BT11 9BE ion Belfast BT11 8AU Z/2008/0351/F 40 Greenan, Shaws Road, Erection of single-storey outbuilding Full Building Mr E Murray C/o Robert Robert Bryson, 18 BT11 in rear garden. Extension/Alterat Bryson, 18 Gransha Park, Gransha Park, Belfast, ion Belfast, BT11 8AU BT11 8AU Z/2008/0352/F 75-81 Victoria Street, Demolition of existing building and Full Erection of Mr N O'Hanrahan C/o Coogan & Co, Glengall Belfast erection of 10-storey mixed use Building(s) Coogan & Co, Glengall Exchange, 3 Glengall scheme comprising retail at ground Exchange, 3 Glengall Street, Belfast, BT12 5AB floor and apartment development of Street, Belfast, BT12 5AB 53 units above. Page 96 Z/2008/0353/F Glenbank Business Park, New storage/workshop unit with Full Erection of Industrial Floorcare Pyper Brian Pyper & Crumlin Road, Ballysillan ancillary offices Building(s) Machines Unit 28, North Associates, Birchtree Lower, Belfast, BT14 8AD City Business Park, 2 House, 21 Enterprise Duncairn Gardens, Road, Bangor, BT19 7TA Belfast, BT15 2GG Z/2008/0354/F Victoria Square Construction of layby and bus Full Minor Works/Env. Multi Development (Uk) Bdp Planning , 2 Bruce Development, Chichester Improve. Ltd Multi Development Street, Belfast, BT2 7JD Street, Belfast (UK) Ltd, 8th Floor, 11-13 Gloucester Street, Belfast, BT1 4LS Z/2008/0355/F Northern Bank Building, Infill development of central light Full Erection of Northern Bank Ltd Braniff Associates, 5 Donegall Square West, well (to roof level) to provide Building(s) Northern Bank, Donegall Windsor Avenue North, Belfast, BT1 additional 217square metres of Square West, Belfast, Malone Road, Belfast, BT1 6JS BT9 6EL

15 February 2008 Page 5 of 7 Applic ID Location Proposal Applic Devt Type Applicant Agent Z/2008/0359/F Existing car park 60m North Removal of Condition 02 of Full Removal of Plg Whitewell Metropolitan Adair JWA Design, 1 of 837-869 Shore Road, planning permission Z/1999/2537. Condition(s) Tabernacle C/O JWA Bramble Grove, Old Belfast BT15 4HN Design, 1 Bramble Grove, Carrick Road, Old Carrick Road, Newtownabbey, BT37 0GE Newtownabbey, BT37 OGE

Z/2008/0360/F 7 Stockmans Court, Belfast, Erection of a single storey extension Full Building Mrs O'Prey 7 Stockmans Construction Services, 26 BT11 9RT to rear of dwelling Extension/Alterat Court, Belfast, BT11 9RT Ashcroft Way, Lower ion Ballinderry, Lisburn, BT28 2AY Z/2008/0170/F 30 Loopland Drive, Belfast, Erection of a single storey extension Full Building Ms S Brown 30 Loopland Mr A Acheson The Boyd BT6 9DX to rear of dwelling Extension/Alterat Drive, Belfast, BT6 9DX Partnership, 1 River's ion Edge, 13 Ravenhill Road, Belfast, BT6 8DN Z/2008/0250/F 9 Kensington Road, Single storey extension to rear of Full Building Ms O'Kane C/O Thomas Thomas O'Hare Belfast, BT5 6NG dwelling Extension/Alterat O'Hare Architects, 54 Architects, 54 Dunmurray Page 97 ion Dunmurry Lane, BT17 Lane, Belfast, BT17 9JR Z/2008/0317/LB 22 Adelaide Park, Belfast, Repair and upgrading works Listed Building Other Domestic Government Of Malaysia Mr As Shahabuddin BT9 6FX Consent Alteration Level 1, Block E9, Parcel ASBA Architect, 42-2, C, Putrajaya, Malaysia, Jalan Wangsa Setia 3, 62505 Wangsa Melawati, Kuala Lumpur, 53300 Z/2008/0331/F 2 Mount Prospect Park, Erection of a two storey side and Full Building Mr E Cush 92 J Aidan Kelly MCIAT, 50 Malone Lower, Belfast, rear extension to dwelling. Extension/Alterat Lurganeden Road, Tullycullin Road, BT09 7BG ion Pomeroy, Co Tyrone, Dungannon, BT70 3LY BT70 2TL Z/2008/0334/F 94 Old Holywood Road, Erection of a two storey extension to Full Building Mr J Watson 94 Old Consarc Design Group, Ballymaghan, Belfast, side and rear of dwelling Extension/Alterat Holywood Road, Belfast, The Gas Office, 4 Cromac BT04 2HP ion BT4 2HP Quay, Ormeau Road, Belfast, BT7 2JD

15 February 2008 Page 6 of 7 Applic ID Location Proposal Applic Devt Type Applicant Agent Z/2008/0338/F 4 Green Road, Erection of a two storey rear Full Building Mr J Mcelroy C/O Agent, Des Ewing Chartered Ballycloghan, Belfast, extension to dwelling Extension/Alterat Des Ewing Residential Architect, The Studio, 13 BT05 6JA ion Architects, 13 Bangor Bangor Road, Holywood, Road, Holywood, BT18 BT18 0NU 0NU Z/2008/0340/F 6 Houston Gardens, Roofspace conversion to include Full Building Mr D Stronge 6 Houston Mr A Mc Auley Belfast, BT5 6AU 2no. rear dormer windows Extension/Alterat Gardens, Belfast, BT5 6AU McGuinness Architect, ion 319 Cavehill Road, Belfast, BT15 5EY Z/2008/0346/LD 13 Mornington Place, Conversion of existing integral LD Certificate Building Mr S Sloan C/o Robert Robert Bryson, 18 Belfast, BT7 3LD garage to habitable room including Proposed Extension/Alterat Bryson, 18 Gransha Park, Gransha Park, Belfast, new window and replacement of ion Belfast, BT11 8AU BT11 8AU patio doors with new window to rear elevation.

Z/2008/0348/F 26 Enid Parade, Belfast, Single storey extension to rear and Full Building Mr & Mrs Martin 26 Enid Stephen Adams Page 98 BT5 6EL side of dwelling and outside store to Extension/Alterat Parade, Belfast, BT5 6EL Architecture, 3 Bertha front side of dwelling ion Row, Ballygrainey Road, Craigavad, Holywood, BT18 0NU TOTAL:- 47

15 February 2008 Page 7 of 7 Page 99 Agenda Item 10a

APPLICATIONS DEFERRED FROM PREVIOUS MEETING

ITEM NO D 1 APPLIC NO Z/2006/2878/F Full Date Valid 14/12/2006 LOCATION 40, 42, 44, 46, 48, 50 Park Avenue, Belfast PROPOSAL Demolition of existing dwellings and erection of 40 apartments and associated car parking. APPLICANT Huxely Properties Ltd REPRESENTATIONS 3 Objections 0 Support 1 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL 1 Deferred by Cllr Long for office meeting - 06/12/2007. 2 Opinion remains to approve.

ITEM NO D 2 APPLIC NO Z/2007/0268/F Full Date Valid 08/02/2007 LOCATION 7 Camberwell Terrace, Belfast, BT15 3AS PROPOSAL Change of use from dwelling to three apartments including three-storey rear extension APPLICANT Mr P Coyle REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 1 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL 1 Deferred by Cllr C Maskey for office meeting - 24/01/2008. 2 Opinion remains to approve.

ITEM NO D 3 APPLIC NO Z/2007/1140/F Full Date Valid 01/05/2007 LOCATION 37 Deramore Drive, Malone Lower, Belfast, BT09 5JS PROPOSAL Demolition of attached garage, erection of two storey side extension and alterations to dwelling. APPLICANT Dr. D McAuley REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL 1 Deferred by Cllr Kelly for office meeting - 22/11/2007. 2 Change of opinion to approval. Page 100

ITEM NO D 4 APPLIC NO Z/2007/1952/F Full Date Valid 08/08/2007 LOCATION 42 Downview Avenue, Low-Wood, Belfast, BT15 4FB PROPOSAL Erection of 2no. semi-detached houses APPLICANT Mannix McAlister REPRESENTATIONS 6 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL 1 Deferred by Cllr Lavery for office meeting - 22/11/2007. 2 Change of opinion to approval.

ITEM NO D 5 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2197/F Full Date Valid 07/09/2007 LOCATION 265 Falls Road, Ballymurphy, Belfast, BT12 6FD PROPOSAL Change of use from terrace dwelling to a coffee shop at ground floor level with a single-storey extension to the rear and 1no apartment on the upper floors APPLICANT Ms D Trew REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL 1 Deferred by Cllr Hartley for office meeting - 06/12/2007. 2 Change of opinion to approval.

Page 101 Agenda Item 10b

DEPARTMENT OF THE ENVIRONMENT

PLANNING (NI) ORDER 1991

APPLICATIONS FOR PLANNING PERMISSION

COUNCIL Belfast Date 21-Feb-08

ITEM NO 1 APPLIC NO Z/2006/0604/LB Listed Building Date Valid 16/03/2006 LOCATION 288 Beersbridge Road, Ballyhackamore, Belfast, BT05 5DX PROPOSAL Mixed use commercial and residential (159 no. apartments) plus 190 parking spaces to be provided with all associated access requirements APPLICANT Wilson Developments NI Ltd REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION CONSENT

ITEM NO 2 APPLIC NO Z/2006/2126/DCA Demolition within Date Valid 15/09/2006 LOCATION 82 Malone Road/1a Beechlands, Malone Lower, Belfast, BT09 5HP PROPOSAL Demolition of existing 2no. dwellings APPLICANT Donard Properties Ltd REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION CONSENT

ITEM NO 3 APPLIC NO Z/2006/2134/F Full Date Valid 15/09/2006 LOCATION 82 Malone Road/1a Beechlands, Malone Lower, Belfast, BT09 5HP PROPOSAL Erection of 2 no. replacement semi-detached dwellings with detached garages. APPLICANT Donard Properties Ltd REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL Page 102

ITEM NO 4 APPLIC NO Z/2006/2264/F Full Date Valid 02/10/2006 LOCATION Plots 33, 34 & 35 Thornberry, Wolfhill Avenue South, Legoniel, Belfast, BT14 8EU PROPOSAL Repositioning of dwelling at plot No. 35, change of house type at plot Nos 33 & 34 from 2No. of semi-detached to 2No. of detached dwellings, construction of retaining wall (1.2m) & adjustment of floor levels of plot Nos.33-35 APPLICANT Mr G Mulvenna REPRESENTATIONS 2 Objections 0 Support 1 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 5 APPLIC NO Z/2006/2407/F Full Date Valid 16/10/2006 LOCATION 327 - 329, Upper Newtownards Road, Ballycloghan, Belfast, BT04 3JH & 1 Knockhill Park, Belfast, BT5 6HX PROPOSAL Demolition of existing buildings and erection of mixed-use development comprising 4 No. retail units and 14 No. residential units APPLICANT Herbel Restaurants Ltd REPRESENTATIONS 17 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 6 APPLIC NO Z/2007/0164/F Full Date Valid 17/01/2007 LOCATION Thornberry, Wolfhill Avenue South, Ligoneil, Belfast PROPOSAL Repositioning of previously approved dwellings (Ref. No. Z/1997/2222/F) at plots 18, 19, 20 and 21, new retaining wall and screen fencing, replacement tree planting APPLICANT Mr G Mulvenna REPRESENTATIONS 2 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL Page 103

ITEM NO 7 APPLIC NO Z/2007/0466/F Full Date Valid 20/02/2007 LOCATION 14 Belmont Avenue West, Strandtown, Belfast, BT04 3DD PROPOSAL Construction of 6no. 1 bedroom studio apartments and associated site works. APPLICANT Abaco Developments REPRESENTATIONS 3 Objections 0 Support 1 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 8 APPLIC NO Z/2007/0708/F Full Date Valid 21/03/2007 LOCATION 15-17 Upper Lisburn Road, Ballyfinaghy, Finaghy, BT10 0GW PROPOSAL Erection of 2 No. detached houses and 3 town houses. APPLICANT Castro Homes LLP REPRESENTATIONS 1 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 9 APPLIC NO Z/2007/0827/F Full Date Valid 03/04/2007 LOCATION 2 Edgecumbe Gardens, Belfast, BT4 2EG PROPOSAL Demolition of existing 2 storey dwelling and construction of 4 no 2 storey apartments APPLICANT Mr Hull REPRESENTATIONS 2 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL Page 104

ITEM NO 10 APPLIC NO Z/2007/0857/F Full Date Valid 11/04/2007 LOCATION Lands 40m South East of 18-24 Mayfield Square, Blacks Road, Belfast. PROPOSAL Erection of 21No. apartments (incorporating 3 additional apartments and amendments to fenestration of previously approved scheme for 18 new build apartments Ref: Z/2006/0355/F). APPLICANT Grafton Homes REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 11 APPLIC NO Z/2007/1176/F Full Date Valid 14/05/2007 LOCATION 17-19 Wellington Park Avenue, Belfast, BT9 6DT PROPOSAL Change of use from existing dwellings to 8 no. apartments including three storey extension to rear APPLICANT Mr & Mrs G Meegan REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION REFUSAL 1 The proposal is contrary to Policy BH12 of the Department's Planning Policy Statement 6: 'Planning, Archaeology and the Built Heritage' in that the site lies within the Malone Conservation Area and the development would, if permitted, detract from its character by way of scale, form and massing and would significantly affect the residential amenity of adjoining properties by way of dominance and overlooking.

ITEM NO 12 APPLIC NO Z/2007/1296/F Full Date Valid 25/05/2007 LOCATION 24 Osborne Gardens, Malone Lower, Belfast, BT09 6LF PROPOSAL Demolition of existing dwelling and construction of new 2.5 storey dwelling APPLICANT Mr & Mrs J Sloan REPRESENTATIONS 8 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL Page 105

ITEM NO 13 APPLIC NO Z/2007/1456/F Full Date Valid 13/06/2007 LOCATION Rear of 76 Eglantine Avenue, Malone Lower, Belfast, BT09 6EU PROPOSAL Proposed development consisting of 2no. 2-bedroom apartments with parking and access to rear alleyway. APPLICANT Mr & Mrs H Campbell REPRESENTATIONS 12 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION REFUSAL 1 The proposal is contrary to Policy QD1 of the Department's Planning Policy Statement 7: Quality residential environments in that in that it would if permitted result in overdevelopment of the site and would cause unacceptable damage to the residential amenity of the area through inappropriate layout and scale and would result in inadequate amenity space for existing and prospective residents as well as dominance and loss of privacy to neighbouring residents.

ITEM NO 14 APPLIC NO Z/2007/1507/F Full Date Valid 19/06/2007 LOCATION 1 & 3 St Agnes Drive, Ballydownfine, Belfast, BT11 8GZ PROPOSAL Proposed demolition of existing dwellings and the construction of 2no retail units with office on the first floor with associated car parking. APPLICANT Mr D Kennedy REPRESENTATIONS 9 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 15 APPLIC NO Z/2007/1575/LB Listed Building Date Valid 26/06/2007 LOCATION 9 metres west from Junction of Victoria Street and Upper Church Lane, Belfast, BT1. PROPOSAL Removal, restoration and relocation of the Jaffe Fountain from Botanic Gardens Park to Victoria Square regeneration project, Victoria Street. APPLICANT Multi Development UK Ltd REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION CONSENT Page 106

ITEM NO 16 APPLIC NO Z/2007/1610/F Full Date Valid 29/06/2007 LOCATION 3 Lemberg Street & 27-29 Rydalmere Street, Belfast, BT12 6GF PROPOSAL Construction of 6no. 2.5-storey terraced houses and 20no. 2-bed apartments APPLICANT Mr R Suitor REPRESENTATIONS 23 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 17 APPLIC NO Z/2007/1692/F Full Date Valid 09/07/2007 LOCATION 65-71, Dublin Road, Malone Lower, Belfast, BT02 7HE PROPOSAL Erection of an 8 storey building with retail on ground floor and 27 apartments on the upper floors, 2 basement level car parking areas, access to car park from Ventry Lane APPLICANT Mr D Patton, Patton Group REPRESENTATIONS 2 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 18 APPLIC NO Z/2007/1731/A Advertisement Date Valid 16/07/2007 LOCATION Land adjacent to Harbour Exchange Retail Park, Airport Road West, Belfast PROPOSAL Free Standing Navigation Tower Sign APPLICANT Ikea Properties Inv Ltd REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION CONSENT

ITEM NO 19 APPLIC NO Z/2007/1820/F Full Date Valid 25/07/2007 LOCATION Tesco Metro, 2 Royal Avenue, Town Parks, Belfast, BT01 1DA PROPOSAL Restoration works to building including internal repairs to dome APPLICANT Tesco Stores Limited REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL Page 107

ITEM NO 20 APPLIC NO Z/2007/1824/LB Listed Building Date Valid 25/07/2007 LOCATION 2 Royal Avenue, Town Parks, Belfast, BT01 1DA PROPOSAL Restoration works to building, including internal repairs to dome. APPLICANT Tesco Stores Limited REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION CONSENT

ITEM NO 21 APPLIC NO Z/2007/1878/F Full Date Valid 31/07/2007 LOCATION 101 Fortwilliam Parade, Skegoneill, Belfast, BT15 3LU PROPOSAL 3 Storey rear extension and alterations to 2 storey dwelling APPLICANT Mr & Mrs T Agnew REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION REFUSAL 1 The proposal is contrary to Policy EXT1 of the Addendum to Planning Policy Statement 7 in that the extension would, if permitted, adversely affect the amenities of the area by reason of its unsympathetic scale, form and its impact on the character and appearance of the surrounding area.

ITEM NO 22 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2046/F Full Date Valid 20/08/2007 LOCATION Lands to the east of 66 Balfour Avenue, Malone Lower, Belfast, BT07 2EX PROPOSAL Erection of 3 General Needs Apartments APPLICANT Clanmil Hal REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL Page 108

ITEM NO 23 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2152/F Full Date Valid 04/09/2007 LOCATION 26 Lansdowne Road, Low-Wood, Belfast, BT15 4AA PROPOSAL Extension to side and rear of dwelling, widened access and works to boundaries. APPLICANT Mr O Stockman REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 24 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2188/F Full Date Valid 07/09/2007 LOCATION 57 Donegall Avenue, Malone Lower, Belfast, BT12 6LS PROPOSAL Change of use from shop unit on ground floor to a two bedroom apartment, together with the refurbishment of remaining floors to 2No. 2 bedroom apartments with the construction of a 2.5 storey rear extension. APPLICANT Mr D Patterson REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 25 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2202/F Full Date Valid 10/09/2007 LOCATION 232 Donegall Road, Malone Lower, Belfast, BT12 5NE PROPOSAL Change of use from dwelling into two apartments with single-storey extension, dormer window and fire escape to rear APPLICANT Mr D Patterson REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION REFUSAL 1 The proposal is contrary to DGN4: Control of Flat Conversions in that the site is not considered appropriate for subdivision into multiple dwelling units for the following reasons: -to protect existing housing stock still considered suitable for single family accommodation, -additional traffic generation,-adequacy of parking facilities,- increased levels of noise, nuisance and disturbance. Page 109

ITEM NO 26 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2222/F Full Date Valid 12/09/2007 LOCATION 54 North Road, Ballyhackamore, Belfast, BT05 5NH PROPOSAL Single storey ground floor and first floor rear extensions to dwelling. APPLICANT Mr & Mrs P & J Murphy REPRESENTATIONS 1 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 27 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2224/F Full Date Valid 12/09/2007 LOCATION 14 Sharman Road, Malone Lower, Belfast, BT09 5FW PROPOSAL Demolition of existing shed and single storey return and construction of two storey extension to side and rear of dwelling APPLICANT Ms O Farran REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 28 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2240/F Full Date Valid 13/09/2007 LOCATION Site adjacent to no.13 Strandburn Parade, Strandtown, Belfast, BT04 1LZ PROPOSAL Erection of 2 storey dwelling APPLICANT Mr G Duff REPRESENTATIONS 4 Objections 0 Support 1 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION REFUSAL 1 The proposal is contrary to PPS2 and PPS8 in that it fails to protect and integrate existing landscape features into the overall design and layout of the development and would result in the loss of visually significant trees and open space of public value.

Page 110

ITEM NO 29 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2269/F Full Date Valid 14/09/2007 LOCATION 297 Shankill Road, Town Parks, Belfast, BT13 1FT PROPOSAL Replacement of front facade. Change of use to estate agents at ground floor and two bedroom apartment at the first and second floor APPLICANT Morris Estate Agents REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 30 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2277/F Full Date Valid 17/09/2007 LOCATION Footpath in front of the David Keir Building, Malone Road, Belfast, BT9 5BQ PROPOSAL 15m high Hutchison Flexicell slim line street furniture column containing GSM/UMTS antennae, 1x2G cabinet, 1x 3G cabinet APPLICANT O2 (UK) Ltd REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 31 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2315/F Full Date Valid 19/09/2007 LOCATION 26 Cromwell Road, Malone Lower, Belfast, BT07 1JW PROPOSAL Demolition of existing HMO with retention of front facade and erection of 6no. flats with 4 storey rear return and rear dormers. APPLICANT Dm Properties REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL Page 111

ITEM NO 32 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2363/F Full Date Valid 26/09/2007 LOCATION 71 Galwally Avenue, Breda, Belfast, BT08 7AJ PROPOSAL Reduction in height of existing roof, erection of first floor extension over garage, single storey side extension and associated works. APPLICANT S Sharma REPRESENTATIONS 2 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 33 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2365/F Full Date Valid 26/09/2007 LOCATION 426 Ravenhill Road, Ballynafoy, Belfast, BT06 0BU PROPOSAL Demolition of existing house & garage and erection of a two-storey building incorporating an endodontic surgery at ground floor level with an apartment at first floor level. APPLICANT Mr J Hurson REPRESENTATIONS 5 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 34 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2368/F Full Date Valid 27/09/2007 LOCATION 43 45, Queen's Square, Town Parks, Belfast, BT01 3FG PROPOSAL Extension to previously approved mixed-use development (REF: Z/2005/1291/F) involving demolition of existing building and development to comprise bar-restaurant, offices, 4 no. apartments and associated basement car park. APPLICANT Mrs D Dougherty REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL Page 112

ITEM NO 35 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2401/F Full Date Valid 02/10/2007 LOCATION Suite 6, 4th floor, Sturgen Buildings, 9-15, Queen Street, Town Parks, Belfast, BT01 6EA PROPOSAL Change of use from office to yoga studio. APPLICANT Bikram Yoga REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 36 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2427/F Full Date Valid 04/10/2007 LOCATION 24 Cromwell Road, Malone Lower, Belfast, BT07 1JW PROPOSAL Demolition of 2 existing flats with retention of front facade and erection of building to accommodate 6 flats with a four storey rear return and rear dormer window APPLICANT M Meenan & J Doherty REPRESENTATIONS 2 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 37 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2438/F Full Date Valid 05/10/2007 LOCATION Lands to the rear of 57 & 59 Ravenhill Parade, Ballynafoy, Belfast, BT06 8NU PROPOSAL Erection of 2 storey building comprising 4no 2 bed apartments with in- curtilage parking accessed from Lismain Street. APPLICANT Kane Developments Ltd. REPRESENTATIONS 2 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL Page 113

ITEM NO 38 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2446/F Full Date Valid 05/10/2007 LOCATION 2 Old Suffolk Road, Englishtown, Belfast, BT11 9PL PROPOSAL Construction of 7no. apartments and associated car parking. APPLICANT Mr B Morgan REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 39 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2449/F Full Date Valid 09/10/2007 LOCATION 49 Knightsbridge Park, Malone Lower, Belfast, BT09 5EH PROPOSAL Amendment to previously approved dwelling (Ref Z/2007/0581) including amended layout and relocation of utility room into garage

APPLICANT Mr C Cooley REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 40 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2453/F Full Date Valid 09/10/2007 LOCATION Maynard Sinclair Pavilion, Stormont Estate, Upper Newtownards Road, Belfast, BT4 3TA PROPOSAL External first floor canopy over existing viewing terrace and 3No. new windows into office accommodation. APPLICANT NICSSA REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL Page 114

ITEM NO 41 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2536/F Full Date Valid 16/10/2007 LOCATION 96 Erinvale Avenue, Belfast, BT10 0FP PROPOSAL Single storey extension to rear of dwelling APPLICANT Mr Stewart REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 42 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2549/F Full Date Valid 17/10/2007 LOCATION 21 Clonaver Crescent South, Belfast, BT4 2EY PROPOSAL Proposed single storey extension to rear of dwelling. APPLICANT Mr & Mrs Woods REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 43 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2559/F Full Date Valid 10/10/2007 LOCATION Dwellings at Northwich Drive, Strathroy Park and Holmdene Gardens, Belfast, BT14 PROPOSAL Multi element improvement works to 66No. dwellings to include 2- storey rear extensions and associated site works APPLICANT NIHE REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL Page 115

ITEM NO 44 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2574/RM Reserved Matters Date Valid 22/10/2007 LOCATION 167 Andersonstown Road, Ballydownfine, Belfast, BT11 9EA

PROPOSAL Demolition of existing house and construction of a residential development comprising 12no. 1 & 2 bedroom apartments APPLICANT J.M.C Contracts REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 45 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2577/F Full Date Valid 22/10/2007 LOCATION 330-332 Donegall Road, Malone Lower, Belfast, BT12 6FX PROPOSAL Demolition of existing building and erection of a 3-storey building comprising 9no apartments APPLICANT Clear Homes REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 46 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2583/F Full Date Valid 23/10/2007 LOCATION 22 Madras Street, Town Parks, Belfast, BT13 3GP PROPOSAL Extension to existing church building to provide church hall APPLICANT Church of The First Born REPRESENTATIONS 3 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL Page 116

ITEM NO 47 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2584/F Full Date Valid 22/10/2007 LOCATION Ground beside northbound carriageway at off-slip of Westlink at Grosvenor Road. PROPOSAL Installation of 15m high CCTV pole APPLICANT PSNI REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 48 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2614/F Full Date Valid 25/10/2007 LOCATION CIYMS, 91 Circular Road, Ballymisert, Belfast, BT04 2GD PROPOSAL Extension to existing tennis facility incorporating additional court, associated fencing and floodlighting. APPLICANT Trustees of CIYMS REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 49 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2635/F Full Date Valid 29/10/2007 LOCATION 3 Carolhill Gardens, Ballymisert, Belfast, BT04 2FS PROPOSAL Demolition of existing dwelling and construction of 2 residential apartments APPLICANT Mr G Marshall REPRESENTATIONS 1 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 50 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2651/F Full Date Valid 31/10/2007 LOCATION 330 Donegall Road, Malone Lower, Belfast, BT12 6FQ PROPOSAL Erection of a 3-storey building comprising 6no apartments APPLICANT Clear Homes REPRESENTATIONS 121 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL Page 117

ITEM NO 51 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2657/F Full Date Valid 31/10/2007 LOCATION 83 & 85 Victoria Road, Strandtown, Belfast, BT04 1QW PROPOSAL Demolition of No. 83 and No.85 including detached garages and front wall. Erection of 1 apartment block consisting of four 2 bed apartments and 4 studio apartments. New front wall to be erected APPLICANT Mr B Khan REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 52 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2678/F Full Date Valid 02/11/2007 LOCATION Alexandra Park Depot, Alexandra Park, Antrim Road, Belfast, BT15 7PN PROPOSAL Erection of 3no flood lights columns at 6 meters high and CCTV provision to yard. APPLICANT Ms R McFlynn REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 53 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2687/A Advertisement Date Valid 02/11/2007 LOCATION Adjacent to 78 Shaws Road, Ballymoney, Belfast, BT11 9QJ PROPOSAL 2 no. 48 sheet advertising hoarding. APPLICANT Arena Advertising REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION REFUSAL 1 The proposal is contrary to Planning Policy Statement 17 Control of Outdoor Advertisements in that the advertisement would, if permitted, harm the residential and visual amenity of the area by reason of its size, location and scale. Page 118

ITEM NO 54 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2700/F Full Date Valid 06/11/2007 LOCATION 14 Easton Crescent, Town Parks, Belfast, BT14 6LJ PROPOSAL Conversion of existing detached house to 5 no. 2 bedroom apartments, including two storey extension to rear. APPLICANT O'Neill Developments REPRESENTATIONS 1 Objections 0 Support 1 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION REFUSAL 1 The proposal is contrary to policy QD1 of Planning Policy Statement 7: Quality Residential Environments, policy H8 of the Belfast Urban Area Plan 2001 and the guidance within DGN4: Control of Flat Conversions in that the property is not within a designated Flat Conversion Zone and would, if permitted:- result in the loss of a house suitable for single family occupation, - harm the character, environmental quality and residential amenity of the area by reason of noise, nuisance and inadequate parking facilities,- fail to provide an attractive outlook for all future residents, and- include an extension at the rear that is unacceptable as it is not subordinate to the main dwelling.

ITEM NO 55 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2711/F Full Date Valid 07/11/2007 LOCATION 17 Lansdowne Road, Low-Wood, Belfast, BT15 4DB PROPOSAL Retrospective application for alteration and extension of roof to include side dormer to 2nd floor apartment. APPLICANT Mr R Kirwin REPRESENTATIONS 3 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION REFUSAL 1 The proposal is contrary to the Addendum to Planning Policy Statement 7: Residential extensions and alterations in that the development results in an unacceptable alteration to the existing roof form which is visually obtrusive and will be detrimental to the appearance of the dwelling. The development is out of character with the streetscape and sets an undesirable precedent for similar extensions which would be to the further detriment of the character of the area.

ITEM NO 56 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2722/F Full Date Valid 08/11/2007 LOCATION 2 Riverdale Park West, Ballymoney, Belfast, BT11 9DE PROPOSAL Erection of 2.5 storey extension to side of dwelling and a dormer window to rear. APPLICANT Mr & Mrs Campbell REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL Page 119

ITEM NO 57 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2779/F Full Date Valid 15/11/2007 LOCATION 91-93 Rugby Avenue, Malone Lower, Belfast, BT07 1RE PROPOSAL Demolition of existing retail unit and flat with retention of front facade and erection of new retail unit and 4 No. flats. APPLICANT Mr N McKee REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 58 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2800/F Full Date Valid 19/11/2007 LOCATION Writers Square, Donegall Street, Belfast. PROPOSAL Erection of a bronze figurative sculpture on a stone plinth. Temporary approval for 3 years APPLICANT International Brigade Commemoration Committee REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 59 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2858/F Full Date Valid 27/11/2007 LOCATION 4 Donegall Park Avenue, Belfast, BT15 4ET PROPOSAL Erection of single storey extension to rear of dwelling and erection of two storey garage in rear garden APPLICANT Mr Shiraz REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 60 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2894/F Full Date Valid 03/12/2007 LOCATION 13 Cloverhill Park, Belfast, BT04 2JW PROPOSAL Single storey extension to rear of dwelling APPLICANT Mr P Timpany REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL Page 120

ITEM NO 61 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2897/F Full Date Valid 03/12/2007 LOCATION 88-104, Andersonstown Road, Ballydownfine, Belfast, BT11 9AN PROPOSAL Erection of new control room, new gates and alterations to existing boundary walls at existing exits and resurfacing of existing hard-standing APPLICANT Antrim County Committee of GAA REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 62 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2898/F Full Date Valid 03/12/2007 LOCATION 43 Tweskard Park, Ballymaghan, Belfast, BT04 2JZ PROPOSAL Two-storey side extension, single-storey rear extension, new front porch and alterations to dwelling. APPLICANT Mr S Whalley REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 63 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2940/F Full Date Valid 06/12/2007 LOCATION 4 College Avenue, Belfast, BT1 PROPOSAL A 10 storey extension incorporating 9 no. apartments, ground level car parking (5 no. additional spaces) with minor amendments to approved development

APPLICANT Leehill Properties Ltd REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL ITEM NO 64 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2957/F Full Date Valid 07/12/2007 LOCATION 122-124 Great Victoria Street, Belfast, BT2 7BG PROPOSAL Proposed change of use to youth hostel/backpacking facility incorporating provision of new ramped access. APPLICANT Mr P McElroy REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL Page 121

ITEM NO 65 APPLIC NO Z/2007/3000/F Full Date Valid 13/12/2007 LOCATION 4 St Jude’s Crescent, Belfast, BT6 PROPOSAL Two and a half storey and single storey rear extensions including conversion of existing garage, roof space conversion and alterations. APPLICANT Kearney REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 66 APPLIC NO Z/2007/3003/F Full Date Valid 13/12/2007 LOCATION 2 Brackenwood Lane, Upper Malone Road, Belfast, BT9 PROPOSAL Proposed swimming pool, sauna and steam room extension at existing dwelling house APPLICANT Mr & Mrs P Walsh REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL Page 122

ITEM NO 67 APPLIC NO Z/2007/3063/F Full Date Valid 19/12/2007 LOCATION 1-4 Herdman Channel Road, Low-Wood Intake, Belfast, BT03 9BL PROPOSAL Proposed extension to workshop including undercover wash bay APPLICANT Hireco (NI) Ltd REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 68 APPLIC NO Z/2008/0002/F Full Date Valid 20/12/2007 LOCATION 18 Kirkliston Gardens, Ballyhackamore, Belfast, BT05 6EE PROPOSAL Amendment to previous approval Z/2006/2772/F "Single storey extension to side and rear of dwelling and conversion of existing garage to bedroom/living accommodation" to include increase in floorspace and alterations. APPLICANT Mrs A Moore REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 69 APPLIC NO Z/2008/0003/F Full Date Valid 20/12/2007 LOCATION 22 Penrose Street, Malone Lower, Belfast, BT07 1QX PROPOSAL Extension to existing two storey rear return and alterations to existing House in Multiple Occupancy APPLICANT L&E Properties REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL Page 123

ITEM NO 70 APPLIC NO Z/2008/0005/A Advertisement Date Valid 20/12/2007 LOCATION 9 Kings Road, Belfast, BT5 6JF PROPOSAL Display of free standing sign APPLICANT Abbeyfield Belfast Society REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION REFUSAL 1 The proposal is contrary to Policy BH 13 of PPS 6 'Planning Archaeology and the Built Heritage' and would if permitted be an unduly prominent and intrusive feature in this street scene and harm the visual character of this predominantly residential area within the King's Road Conservation Area due to inappropriate design.

ITEM NO 71 APPLIC NO Z/2008/0007/F Full Date Valid 19/12/2007 LOCATION 80 Annadale Crescent, Ballynafoy, Belfast, BT07 3DN PROPOSAL Single storey rear extension to dwelling for disabled access APPLICANT NIHE REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 72 APPLIC NO Z/2008/0036/F Full Date Valid 28/12/2007 LOCATION 65 Cliftonpark Avenue, Town Parks, Belfast, BT14 6DR PROPOSAL Erection of three-storey and single-storey extension to rear of dwelling with dormer window and detached garage to the rear of the property. APPLICANT Mr F Hamilton REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL Page 124

ITEM NO 73 APPLIC NO Z/2008/0044/DCA Demolition within Date Valid 02/01/2008 LOCATION 25 & 27 Maryville Park, Malone Lower, Belfast, BT09 6LN PROPOSAL Demolition of one pair of semi detached dwellings to be replaced with two detached dwellings APPLICANT Mr & Mrs Quinn REPRESENTATIONS 1 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION REFUSAL 1 The proposal is contrary to Policy BH14 of the Department's Planning Policy Statement 6: Planning, Archaeology and the Built Heritage in that the existing building makes a significant contribution to the character and appearance of the Malone Conservation Area.

ITEM NO 74 APPLIC NO Z/2008/0045/F Full Date Valid 02/01/2008 LOCATION 25 & 27 Maryville Park, Malone Lower, Belfast, BT09 6LN PROPOSAL Demolition of existing pair of semi detached dwellings and construction of two detached dwelling houses. APPLICANT Mr & Mrs Quinn REPRESENTATIONS 3 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION REFUSAL 1 The proposal is contrary to policy BH12 of the Department's Planning Policy Statement 6, Planning, Archaeology and the Built Heritage in that it would, if permitted harm the character and appearance of the Malone Conservation Area through its inappropriate scale, massing, design, building materials and detailing.

ITEM NO 75 APPLIC NO Z/2008/0052/F Full Date Valid 03/01/2008 LOCATION 39 Downview Gardens, Low-Wood, Belfast, BT15 4GH PROPOSAL Erection of new pitched roof to dwelling APPLICANT Mr Moore REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL Page 125

ITEM NO 76 APPLIC NO Z/2008/0054/F Full Date Valid 03/01/2008 LOCATION 9 Woodvale Parade, Edenderry, Belfast, BT13 3LH PROPOSAL Single-storey conservatory extension to side of dwelling APPLICANT Ms G Gilfillan REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 77 APPLIC NO Z/2008/0056/F Full Date Valid 04/01/2008 LOCATION 1091 Crumlin Road, Upper Ballysillan, Belfast, BT14 8RX PROPOSAL Demolition of existing dwelling and construction of new dwelling with associated alterations to existing outhouse. APPLICANT Magee REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 78 APPLIC NO Z/2008/0066/F Full Date Valid 07/01/2008 LOCATION 21-29 Royal Avenue, Town Parks, Belfast BT1 1FB PROPOSAL Change of use of ground floor from Class A1 retail to Class A2 financial services. APPLICANT HSBC Plc REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 79 APPLIC NO Z/2008/0078/F Full Date Valid 07/01/2008 LOCATION 4 Kinedar Crescent, Belfast, BT4 3LY PROPOSAL Proposed two storey extension to rear of premises APPLICANT Mr M Heaton REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL Page 126

ITEM NO 80 APPLIC NO Z/2008/0083/F Full Date Valid 31/12/2007 LOCATION 7 Andersonstown Grove, Ballymurphy, Belfast, BT11 8FQ PROPOSAL Single storey extension to rear of dwelling APPLICANT Miss F Hartley REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 81 APPLIC NO Z/2008/0090/F Full Date Valid 08/01/2008 LOCATION 66 Sheridan Street, Town Parks, Belfast, BT15 2BT PROPOSAL Single-storey extension to side of dwelling APPLICANT Mr J Kelly REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 82 APPLIC NO Z/2008/0098/F Full Date Valid 08/01/2008 LOCATION 229 Mountpottinger Road, Ballymacarret, Belfast, BT05 4LF PROPOSAL Single storey extension to rear APPLICANT Mrs Macklin REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 83 APPLIC NO Z/2008/0103/F Full Date Valid 08/01/2008 LOCATION 9 Broughton Gardens, Ballynafoy, Belfast, BT06 0BB PROPOSAL Replacement single storey garage. APPLICANT Mr D Brown REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL Page 127

ITEM NO 84 APPLIC NO Z/2008/0104/F Full Date Valid 08/01/2008 LOCATION 5 Beechfield Court, Ballymacarret, Belfast, BT05 4DY PROPOSAL Proposed single storey extension to rear of dwelling APPLICANT Mrs Morrow REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 85 APPLIC NO Z/2008/0105/F Full Date Valid 08/01/2008 LOCATION 36 Clara Street, Ballymacarret, Belfast, BT05 5GB PROPOSAL Ground floor extension to rear of dwelling house APPLICANT Mrs Greer REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 86 APPLIC NO Z/2008/0117/F Full Date Valid 10/01/2008 LOCATION 286 Albertbridge Road, Ballymacarret, Belfast, BT05 4GX PROPOSAL Ground floor extension to provide WC for disabled tenant APPLICANT Mr & Mrs A Patterson REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

ITEM NO 87 APPLIC NO Z/2008/0118/F Full Date Valid 10/01/2008 LOCATION 15 Herbert Street, Edenderry, Belfast, BT14 7FE PROPOSAL Single-storey extension to rear of dwelling APPLICANT Mrs Crawford & Mrs Duffy C/O NIHE REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL Page 128

ITEM NO 88 APPLIC NO Z/2008/0130/F Full Date Valid 11/01/2008 LOCATION 7 Runnymede Drive, Malone Lower, Belfast, BT12 6LZ PROPOSAL Two storey extension to rear of dwelling APPLICANT Mr R & Mrs P Linton REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support Petitions OPINION APPROVAL

Page 129 Agenda Item 10c

APPLICATIONS DEFERRED FROM PREVIOUS MEETING AND STILL UNDER CONSIDERATION

1 APPLIC NO Z/2002/2135/F APPLICANT Mr M McBride

LOCATION Land adjacent to Ford Visteon Plant, Finaghy Road North, Belfast, BT11 PROPOSAL Proposed housing development comprising of 44no. townhouses and 12no. semi-detached dwellings

1 Deferred by Cllr. Maskey under reason 5 - 03/11/05.

2 APPLIC NO Z/2005/1104/F APPLICANT Hunterswood Properties Ltd

LOCATION Site to rear of 68-74A Ligoniel Road, Ballysillan Lower, Belfast, BT14 8BY PROPOSAL Demolition of existing warehouses and erection of 48 No. residential units

1 Deferred by Cllr McCausland for office meeting - 10/01/2008.

3 APPLIC NO Z/2005/1837/F APPLICANT Belfast City Council

LOCATION Site of existing football changing pavilion at Strangford Avenue playing fields, Belfast, BT9 PROPOSAL Erection of single storey building N.E. of existing football changing pavilion to provide additional changing and showering facilities.

1 Deferred by TPC for Parks Department to speak to residents - 08/12/05.

4 APPLIC NO Z/2005/2433/F APPLICANT Mr & Mrs Graham

LOCATION Land adjacent to 110 Malone Road, Malone Lower, Belfast, BT09 5HQ PROPOSAL Erection of dwelling

1 Deferred by Cllr Maginness - 07/12/06

Page 130

5 APPLIC NO Z/2006/0295/F APPLICANT Mossgiel Developments Ltd

LOCATION 35-37 Diamond Gardens, Ballyfinaghy, Belfast, BT10 0HE PROPOSAL Residential development of 46 apartment units with associated basement car parking and associated landscaping

1 Deferred by Cllr Kelly for office meeting - 07/02/2008.

6 APPLIC NO Z/2006/0599/O APPLICANT Knock Golf Club

LOCATION Land at Knock Golf Club, Upper Newtownards Road, Belfast PROPOSAL Development at Knock Golf course incorporating a residential development (revised scheme) with access to Stoney Road, car parking, formal and informal open space, the retention of a 9-hole golf course and conversion of existing clubhouse to community use

1 Deferred for deputations/office meeting - 21/06/07.

7 APPLIC NO Z/2006/1260/F APPLICANT Mr & Mrs D Acton

LOCATION 43 Kings Road, Belfast, BT05 6JH PROPOSAL Erection of dwelling within existing garden

1 Deferred by Cllr Long for office meeting - 24/01/2008.

8 APPLIC NO Z/2006/1501/F APPLICANT Mrs A McAllister

LOCATION Site adj to 5 Downview Avenue, Belfast, BT15 4EZ PROPOSAL Erection of a dwelling with detached garage

1 Deferred by Cllr Maginness for office meeting - 07/02/2008. Page 131

9 APPLIC NO Z/2006/1845/F APPLICANT Mr C Tilson

LOCATION 68 Upper Malone Road, Malone Upper, Belfast, BT09 5PD PROPOSAL Replacement of existing bungalow with new two & half storey dwelling

1 Deferred by Cllr Hanna for office meeting - 04/10/2007.

10 APPLIC NO Z/2006/2231/DCA

APPLICANT Belfast South Methodist Church

LOCATION Lisburn Road Methodist Church, 238-266 Lisburn Road, Malone Lower, Belfast, BT09 6GF PROPOSAL Demolition of church, hall, ancillary accommodation, front gates and railings

1 Deferred by Cllr Hanna - 17/05/2007.

11 APPLIC NO Z/2006/2332/F APPLICANT Belfast South Methodist Circuit

LOCATION Lisburn Road Methodist Church, 238-266 Lisburn Road, Malone Lower, Belfast, BT09 6GD PROPOSAL Replacement of existing church and halls with new church and halls

1 Deferred by Cllr. Hanna - 17/05/2007.

12 APPLIC NO Z/2006/2501/F APPLICANT Mr O' Kane

LOCATION 322 Stranmillis Road, Malone Lower, Belfast. BT9 5EB PROPOSAL Demolition of existing dwelling and erection of dwelling with vehicular access

1 Deferred by Cllr McCarthy for office meeting - 22/11/2007.

13 APPLIC NO Z/2006/2715/O APPLICANT Mr R Wilson

LOCATION Side garden of 194 Upper Malone Road, Belfast, BT17 9JZ PROPOSAL Erection of dwelling and detached garage

1 Deferred by Cllr. Hanna - 17-05-2007 Page 132

14 APPLIC NO Z/2006/2766/F APPLICANT Mr C Ashe

LOCATION Site fronts onto 157-161 North Street and onto 40-44 Kent Street, Belfast, BT1 2JA PROPOSAL Demolition of all buildings on site and the construction of a mixed use scheme to include retail on ground floor and 97no. apartments with associated car parking

1 Deferred by Cllr Smyth for office meeting - 07/02/2008.

15 APPLIC NO Z/2006/2771/F APPLICANT Charioteer Ltd

LOCATION 739-745 Antrim Road, Belfast, BT15 4EL PROPOSAL Demolition of existing buildings and erection of a residential development of 57 No. apartments with associated landscaping and underground car park

1 Deferred for deputations - 04/10/2007.

16 APPLIC NO Z/2007/0117/F APPLICANT Ms D McCartney

LOCATION 32 Cardigan Drive, Belfast, BT14 PROPOSAL Change of use of ground floor dwelling to day nursery (first floor to be retained as living accommodation) with associated alterations and erection of two storey extension to rear

1 Deferred by Cllr Long for office meeting. Cllr Maginness to be informed of any amendments - 20/09/2007.

17 APPLIC NO Z/2007/0136/F APPLICANT Power and Devine

LOCATION 41 Eglantine Avenue, Belfast, BT09 PROPOSAL Demolition of building in 3no. HMO flats with retention of front facade and erection of 4no. 1 bedroom flats and 1no. 2 bed flat with 2 storey store to rear.

1 Deferred by Cllr Kelly for office meeting - 24/01/2008. Page 133

18 APPLIC NO Z/2007/0139/DCA

APPLICANT Power and Devine

LOCATION 41 Eglantine, Avenue, Belfast, BT09 PROPOSAL Demolition of existing building in 3no. HMO flats with retention of front facade.

1 Deferred by Cllr Kelly for office meeting - 24/01/2008.

19 APPLIC NO Z/2007/0154/F APPLICANT Messrs GML Developments

LOCATION Lands at 1-3 Glenhoy Mews, Belfast, BT05 5LH PROPOSAL Construction of sixteen studio apartments with associated soft and hard landscaping.

1 Deferred by Cllr. Wilson for office meeting - 18/10/2007.

20 APPLIC NO Z/2007/0225/F APPLICANT M&M Property

LOCATION 57 Ashley Avenue, Malone Lower, Belfast, BT09 7BU PROPOSAL Erection of two-and-a-half storey development containing 3no apartments including demolition of an existing dwelling

1 Deferred by Cllr Hanna for office meeting - 08/11/2007.

21 APPLIC NO Z/2007/0279/F APPLICANT North & West Housing Ltd

LOCATION 13-29 Glenluce Walk, Belfast, BT04 2QR PROPOSAL Erection of 17 dwellings for social housing

1 Deferred by Cllrs Rodgers and Rodway - 21/06/07.

22 APPLIC NO Z/2007/0283/F APPLICANT Iconic Developments Ltd

LOCATION 8 Castle Park, Ballyaghagan, Belfast, BT15 5FF PROPOSAL Demolition of existing dwelling house and erection of 9no two bedroom apartments in two blocks with associated parking and amenity spaces

1 Deferred by Cllr McCausland for office meeting - 20/09/2007. Page 134

23 APPLIC NO Z/2007/0753/F APPLICANT ABM (NI) Limited

LOCATION 1 Henderson Avenue, Skegoneill, Belfast, BT15 5FL PROPOSAL Erection of 2No. commercial units and 4No. apartments

1 Deferred by Cllr McCausland for office meeting - 10/01/2008.

24 APPLIC NO Z/2007/0767/F APPLICANT Classic Wine (NI) Ltd

LOCATION 406-408 Upper Newtownards Road Belfast BT4 3EZ PROPOSAL Ground floor change of use from restaurant to public house

1 Deferred by Cllr Cobain for office meeting - 07/02/2008.

25 APPLIC NO Z/2007/0858/F APPLICANT NMC Developments

LOCATION 22 & 22a Fruithill Park, Ballydownfine, Belfast, BT11 8GE PROPOSAL Demolition of existing dwellings and erection of 8no apartments with associated car parking and access

1 Deferred by Cllr McCarthy for office meeting - 16/08/2007

26 APPLIC NO Z/2007/0907/F APPLICANT Mr G Gareth

LOCATION Lands to the rear of 120 Eglantine Avenue, Malone Lower, Belfast, BT09 6EU PROPOSAL Erection of detached 2-storey dwelling to rear

1 Deferred by Cllr. McCausland for office meeting - 18/10/2007 Page 135

27 APPLIC NO Z/2007/0932/F APPLICANT Mr A Williams

LOCATION 27 Brookhill Avenue, Town Parks, Belfast, BT14 6BS PROPOSAL Change of use from dwelling to three apartments and erection of two storey rear extension

1 Deferred by Cllr Cobain for office meeting - 20/09/2007.

28 APPLIC NO Z/2007/0939/F APPLICANT Mr S Harrison

LOCATION 193a West Circular Road, Ballymagarry, Belfast, BT13 3QF PROPOSAL Demolition of existing property and replacement with ground floor retail unit & 6no. 1-bedroom & 2no. 2-bedroom apartments

1 Deferred by Cllr McCoubrey for office meeting - 07/02/2008.

29 APPLIC NO Z/2007/1027/F APPLICANT Mr J Bittles

LOCATION 135 Cavehill Road, Skegoneill, Belfast, BT15 5BL PROPOSAL Demolition of garage and erection of 2-storey dwelling attached to existing dwelling

1 Deferred by Cllr Lavery for office meeting - 06/12/2007.

30 APPLIC NO Z/2007/1072/F APPLICANT Hagan Homes LTD

LOCATION 58-80 (even numbers) Peter's Hill, 77 Brown's Square and 19, 21, 23 and 25 Gardiner Place, Belfast, BT13 PROPOSAL Erection of 49 apartments and 1 retail unit with associated site works and parking

1 Deferred by Cllr D Dodds for office meeting - 10/01/2008. Page 136

31 APPLIC NO Z/2007/1075/F APPLICANT Mr T Connolly

LOCATION 42 Florenceville Avenue, Ballynafoy, Belfast, BT07 3GZ PROPOSAL Change of use from 2no apartments to 4no apartments including two storey rear extension, roofspace conversion and alterations to existing dwelling

1 Deferred by Cllr Patterson for office meeting - 08/11/2007.

32 APPLIC NO Z/2007/1084/F APPLICANT Mr J Gilleece

LOCATION 'Treetops', 50 Antrim Road, Ballygolan, Newtownabbey, BT36 7PL PROPOSAL Erection of 12no. apartments

1 Deferred by Cllr Lavery for office meeting - 18/10/2007

33 APPLIC NO Z/2007/1144/F APPLICANT Mr J Smyth T/A Keens

LOCATION 163 Templemore Avenue, Ballymacarret, Belfast, BT05 4FQ PROPOSAL Demolition of existing dwelling & proposed 3 storey extension to retail premises for retail use & provision of covered passageway to form new shop front to side elevation.

1 Deferred by Cllrs Empey & Stoker for office meeting - 04/10/2007.

34 APPLIC NO Z/2007/1236/F APPLICANT Ms E McCullough

LOCATION 50 Manna Grove, Ballyrushboy, Belfast, BT05 6AJ PROPOSAL Erection of first floor conservatory to rear of dwelling

1 Deferred by Cllr Wilson for office meeting - 04/10/2007.

Page 137

35 APPLIC NO Z/2007/1243/F APPLICANT Mr P Blayney

LOCATION 6 Ravenhill Park, Belfast, BT6 0DE PROPOSAL Single storey extension to rear of dwelling

1 Deferred by Cllr Hendron for office meeting - 07/02/2008.

36 APPLIC NO Z/2007/1318/F APPLICANT Connswater Homes LTD

LOCATION 36A-38A Park Avenue, Strandtown, Belfast, BT04 1JJ PROPOSAL Demolition of 3 No. existing detached houses and new build development of 20 No. 'lifetime' 3 person 2 bedroom apartments including associated site works

1 Deferred by Cllr Rodway for office meeting - 06/12/2007.

37 APPLIC NO Z/2007/1423/F APPLICANT Emo Developments

LOCATION 34 Knightsbridge Park, Malone Lower, Belfast, BT09 5EA PROPOSAL Erection of two semi-detached dwellings

1 Deferred by Cllr Patterson for office meeting - 04/10/2007.

38 APPLIC NO Z/2007/1461/O APPLICANT Mr J Woods

LOCATION 29 Whitehall Parade, Ballynafoy, Belfast, BT07 3GX PROPOSAL Replacement of existing end terrace with 4no. apartments.

1 Deferred by Cllr Wilson for office meeting - 07/02/2008. Page 138

39 APPLIC NO Z/2007/1518/F APPLICANT Mr B Morrison

LOCATION 1 Northbrook Gardens, Malone Lower, Belfast, BT09 7EA PROPOSAL Two storey extension to side and rear of dwelling

1 Deferred by Cllr Wilson for office meeting - 18/10/2007

40 APPLIC NO Z/2007/1598/F APPLICANT Carrmor Developments

LOCATION 77 Galwally Avenue, Breda, Belfast, BT08 7AJ PROPOSAL Demolition of existing dwelling and construction of one two-storey apartment block to include 4 apartments and one three-storey apartment block to include 6 apartments.

1 Deferred by Cllrs McCarthy and Patterson - 06/12/2007.

41 APPLIC NO Z/2007/1603/F APPLICANT The Carvill Group

LOCATION Land to the rear of Carnegie Hall between Utility Street and Eureka Drive, Donegall Road, Belfast. PROPOSAL Residential development of 35 apartments to include associated works (incl social and private units)

1 Deferred by Cllr Stalford for office meeting - 07/02/2008.

42 APPLIC NO Z/2007/1719/F APPLICANT Belfast Islamic Centre

LOCATION 38 Wellington Park, Malone Lower, Belfast, BT09 6DN PROPOSAL Extension to form new entrance hall and disabled ramp

1 Deferred by Cllr Rodgers for office meeting - 10/01/2008. Page 139

43 APPLIC NO Z/2007/1761/O APPLICANT Mr E McKay

LOCATION 12a Knocklofty Park, Strandtown, Belfast, BT04 3NA PROPOSAL The proposal is for the erection of a detached 2 storey dwelling in the side garden of no. 12 Knocklofty Park

1 Deferred by Cllr Rodway for office meeting - 10/01/2008.

44 APPLIC NO Z/2007/1792/F APPLICANT Lynbourne Developments

LOCATION 29-31 Brookhill Avenue, Town Parks, Belfast, BT14 6BS PROPOSAL Alteration and extension of 2 no. dwellings to form 6 no. self contained apartments.

1 Deferred by Cllr Maginness for office meeting - 22/11/2007.

45 APPLIC NO Z/2007/1891/F APPLICANT Pineridge Developments

LOCATION 32-34 Rosetta Park, Ballynafoy, Belfast, BT06 0DL PROPOSAL Erection of 2 storey extension to rear of no34 Rosetta Park to provide 2no new apartments, demolition of existing garages, and provision of car parking/landscaped area.

1 Deferred by Cllr Wilson for office meeting - 24/01/2008.

46 APPLIC NO Z/2007/1915/F APPLICANT McCullagh & McGrath Developments

LOCATION Site for 699 and 707 Antrim Road, Low-Wood, Belfast, BT15 4EH PROPOSAL Additional 2 No. one bedroom apartments to development previously approved under Z/2007/0692/F for 6 No. apartments

1 Deferred by Cllr Cobain for office meeting - 04/10/2007.

Page 140

47 APPLIC NO Z/2007/1945/F APPLICANT Broomesdale Investment

LOCATION 733, 733a, 733b and 735 Antrim Road, Green Castle, Belfast, BT15 4EL PROPOSAL Erection of 3 Apartment buildings comprising 55 units with communal gardens, basement car parking for 61 spaces and 16 surface car parking spaces.

1 Deferred by Cllr Smyth for office meeting - 10/01/2008.

48 APPLIC NO Z/2007/1971/F APPLICANT Mr I Barr

LOCATION 77 Orby Road, Ballyrushboy, Belfast, BT05 5HN PROPOSAL Proposed development to include 4 no apartments with associated car parking and landscaping.

1 Deferred by Cllr Kyle for office meeting - 24/01/2008.

49 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2014/F APPLICANT Clear Healthcare

LOCATION Lands between Shankill Parade and North Boundary Street, Shankill Ward, Shankill Road, Belfast, BT13 PROPOSAL Relocation of existing Shankill Healthcare GPs and Pharmacy to create 2 medical surgeries, pharmacy associated accommodation and car parking and 14 no. apartments with 1 no. car parking space per unit and associated private/shared amenity space.

1 Deferred by Cllr D Dodds for office meeting - 24/01/2008.

50 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2138/F APPLICANT Mr C McSwiggan

LOCATION 18 Rugby Avenue, Malone Lower, Belfast, BT07 1RG PROPOSAL Change of use from dwelling to 3 no. flats and three storey rear extension

1 Deferred by Cllr McKenzie for office meeting - 24/01/2008. Page 141

51 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2139/F APPLICANT Mr M Taylor

LOCATION 9 Trossachs Park, Ballyfinaghy, Belfast, BT10 0AX PROPOSAL Two-storey front extension, single-storey side & rear extension, new roofspace accommodation with increased ridge height to dwelling.

1 Deferred by Cllr Rodgers for office meeting - 08/11/2007.

52 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2141/F APPLICANT Lissue Development Partnership

LOCATION 114 Upper Lisburn Road, Ballyfinaghy, Finaghy, BT10 0BD PROPOSAL Amendment to previous approval Z/2003/1780/F (Demolition of existing dwelling and erection of new building to accommodate 6 apartments) for the erection of 3 storey building containing 9 no. apartments and related site works.

1 Deferred by Cllr Patterson for office meeting - 07/02/2008.

53 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2267/F APPLICANT J Kabir

LOCATION 28 Dunkeld Gardens, Old Park, Belfast, BT14 6NT PROPOSAL Erection of 2-storey extension to rear of dwelling

1 Deferred by Cllr Cobain for office meeting - 22/11/2007.

54 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2364/F APPLICANT Mr C McMaster

LOCATION 8 Knockmount Park, Knock, Belfast, BT05 6GR PROPOSAL Erection of two bedroom dwelling house and garden area

1 Deferred by Cllr Campbell for office meeting - 24/01/2008. Page 142

55 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2460/F APPLICANT Jerlag Properties

LOCATION 1-5 Belmont Road, Strandtown, Belfast, BT04 2AA PROPOSAL Mixed use redevelopment consisting of ground floor retail and residential above with undercroft car parking and associated works and access.

1 Deferred by Cllr Rodway for office meeting - 10/01/2008.

56 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2478/F APPLICANT M&M Properties

LOCATION 1 & 1a Penrose Street, Malone Lower, Belfast, BT07 1QX PROPOSAL Demolition of existing dwelling (with retention of front facade) and rear store and erection of 3 No. flats.

1 Deferred by Cllr Reilly - to be back on next schedule - 06/12/2007.

57 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2479/F APPLICANT Mrs B Hanif

LOCATION 697 Lisburn Road, Malone Lower, Belfast, BT09 7GU PROPOSAL Change of use from shop to a cafe / sandwich bar with sit in facilities

1 Deferred by Cllr Patterson for office meeting - 10/01/2008.

58 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2560/F APPLICANT Mr G & H Wall

LOCATION 38 Brookvale Avenue, Town Parks, Belfast, BT14 6BW PROPOSAL The refurbishment and conversion of an existing three storey building to provide three self contained apartments.

1 Deferred by Cllr Lavery for office meeting - 24/01/2008. Page 143

59 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2643/F APPLICANT Ms L Herbert

LOCATION 339 Shankill Road, Town Parks, Belfast, BT13 3AA PROPOSAL Erection of ground floor retail unit, with 3no apartments on upper two floors including 1no duplex

1 Deferred by Cllr Smyth for office meeting - 07/02/2008.

60 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2647/F APPLICANT Mr S Mc Cann

LOCATION 113 Bloomfield Avenue, Ballyhackamore, Belfast, BT05 5AB PROPOSAL Demolition of existing dwelling and erection of 3 no 1 bed apartments with car parking on street

1 Deferred by Cllr Stoker for office meeting - 10/01/2008.

61 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2718/F APPLICANT Dack Estates LTD

LOCATION 3 Edinburgh Street, Malone Lower, Belfast, BT09 7DS PROPOSAL Demolition of existing 2 No. apartments and erection of 4 storey block containing 4 No. apartments.

1 Deferred by Cllr Patterson for office meeting - 07/02/2008.

62 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2740/F APPLICANT Mr P Boyle

LOCATION 44 Wellesley Avenue, Malone Lower, Belfast, BT09 6DG PROPOSAL Change of use from existing dwelling to 2 No. apartments including two-storey rear extension. Construction of new vehicle access to provide off-street parking.

1 Deferred by Cllr Hanna for office meeting - 07/02/2008. Page 144

63 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2774/F APPLICANT Mr & Mrs McKenna

LOCATION 43 Osbourne Park, Belfast, BT9 PROPOSAL Demolition of existing rear return and erection of two-storey rear and side extensions. Construction of garden store along rear boundary

1 Deferred by Cllr Wilson for office meeting - 07/02/2008.

64 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2810/F APPLICANT Mr E McCann

LOCATION Land adjacent to (West of) 118 North Street, Belfast, BT1 PROPOSAL Reinstatement of entrance to existing car park (entrance only)

1 Deferred by Cllr Cobain for office meeting - 24/01/2008.

65 APPLIC NO Z/2007/2874/F APPLICANT Mr M O'Neil

LOCATION 8 Clifton Crescent, Town Parks, Belfast, BT14 6LF PROPOSAL Change of use from single dwelling to 2no apartments.

1 Deferred by Cllr Lavery for office meeting - 24/01/2008.