Community, to Its in Frogs, a Brief Reference Is Made to Cleon and Hyperbolus, Who of the Ancient Coimentators on Aristonh
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
otherwise) ot poets in . is the freedom (or Athens to wished. What constraints, legal or:social, explicit or ite what they ot tantasy and icit, existed to limit the dramatists play their critiques the Atheniawillingr mess to again. There is no record of arny legal or other interactions with ag- particular or general of offer grieved individuals outside the theater, as there had been for Cleon. its policies? It is hard to ow how leaders, and muchcommunity, to its In Frogs, a brief reference is made to Cleon and Hyperbolus, who of the ancient coimentators on Aristonh. trust the evidence are now apparently the ace lawsuit-bringers in the Underworld other sources that reter to "decrees." a plays (the scholia) and its, and fines (569-70), and plenty of living individuals are named in passing with Aristophanes and other involving Athenian playwrights and brief mockery and abuse: Cleisthenes (48. 57. 422). Callias contents of their plays. But on the whole it appears thas (428), the Cleigenes (709), Clitophon (967). etc. All ot this appears to be stan- restrictions existed. formal dard comic procedure. But not even against the slippery Theramenes were indeed to or the Comic poets expected reter to topical e (540, 967-70) populist anti-Spartan leader Cleophon (678, and issues, and also to mock prOminent individuals events I504, I532) 1s any serious or sustained criticism mounted. Outside the text of the been a tradition within iambos and comic drama. And wheraalways plays themselves, we are told (again, by the that at some a in our Suda) point charge was Aristo- erence is occasionally made sources to actual brought against censOrei. someone , in phanes by (implicithy Cleon) that he was a the form of laws being introduced "foreigner," special forbidding certain t a topics that is, noncitizen, apparently because ot his tamily's connection or types of performance-particularly the by "ridiculing name" with Aegina. This prosecution seems not to have been successful, of individual (onomasti kómôidein) citizens-and whereas the and other too text o "accusations apparently tailed. Altogether, close ex- Aristophanes' plays also contains references to citizens (mainly Cle- amination of all of this evidence, together with a number of other on) reacting vigorously and publicly to being lampooned by him mostly quite unbelievable-remarks in scholia and elsewhere about laws and on stage and thus making a great deal of trouble for the playwright. particular decrees being passed at various points during the fifth the evidence overall is spotty and inconclusive. Indeed, the rules century banning mockery by name completely, leads to the conclusion that Cleon's attacks on may well have changed at different times. Aristophanes were probably not based on any law about or Here is what we can reconstruct with a fair particular comedy festival invective, but (briefy) degreeof were simply an infuriated to In his earliest Aristo- attempts by victim find some recourse certainty. plays, especially Babylonians (426), on the basis of general social norms of had attacked Cleon. He mentions this in Achar- decency. Aristophanes gen phanes virulently had a erally very free hand to criticize whom he wished. nians (425), stating that Cleon had retaliated: "Because of last year's comedy, he dragged me before the Council and slandered me (die the and made a . In balle) up bunch of lies. "(Ach. 378-80). follow Athenian Politics, the War and Frogs ing year his Knights (424) was a full-blast attack on Cleon from start to finish. he Athenian But two years later, in Wasps (422), he states (1284-91) that political system was a direct democracy-the first Cleon had in history, the whole "bitten" him quite severely and "caused him| alotu involving citizen body of 30,00o to 40,000 nmen. Then as trouble" so that he (Aristophanes) had recently made some kmd ot now, not all members of the dêmos ("people") he saw to concession or compromise with him (1290o)-mainly becausc always eye eye with one another about policy, about their 9).No leaders, about the had not found interpretation of what itself should anyone else to stand up on his behalf (1286-89). "democracy" foes not really entail, even about whether or not it after made sense at all as a long this, Cleon was killed in battle, and Aristophanes olitician political system. Athenian were volatile and appear to have politics often violent. engaged so fiercely with any particular po Aristophanes and His Athenian Audience 37 36 ARISTOPHANES' FroGS the Cleisthenic democracy had first been Between 508 (when of over a around the Helles- and the performance rogs just hundred Aegean and especially introduced) years presence throughout the several extremes of sIC since this was the means of had experienced to be as strong as ever, later, the Athenians and pont continued aboutout their city and its constitut and other crucial supplhes and despair, access to nmuch of Athens grain failure, optimism securing and disastrous expedition to Sic1ly eight back with pride to the and men lost in the Athenians looked nostalgia . of The ships and month month. their briet a vivid by and Salamis (480), to period ofco-le ad- previously were still memory; Marathon (490) years that a the Athenian lived with the reality Spartan- world with >parta (1n early 460s), and to every Greek to day by day, Attica. of the on the northern of ership fortress sat in Decelea edge ot increasing domination over the la decades occupied orchards, and their subsequent large to the fields and the "Delian League'"y out raiding parties ravage of (originally , i.e., sending the confederation their "alhes" both agriculture and travel throughout which came severely curtailing islands and cities ot the Aegean under their fields, work- the many Thousands Athenians whose homes -house, which mas region. of the to 440-decades during the demes Attica had been control during 460s mag- in one of the rural of were built shops, shrines lay on the being and visitors in the cen- new Acropolis last years cooped up city nificent temples living most ofthe twenty-tive the and admire the monuments else in the to Athens to watch plays in the Piraeus, or temporary focked ter of Athens itself or port of and self-contidence were thus based both corridor land between the Athenian self-image housing constructed in the narrow of with the ran between Athenians' military successes-along freedom defensive walls (the Walls") that on the past two parallel "Long on their and fear had been endemic and independence that these guaranteed-and continuing them. Overcrowding, deprivation, long Persian Athens had become cultural preeminence. Since the Wars, to Athenian life. torce over 100 artistic hub of the Greek world summer an Athenian of unquestionably the intellectual and Just the previous (406), a built for all of Greece" Thuc. won a critical sea-battle over Spartan navy (largely (as Pericles claimed, the "school (paideusis) ships had islands near Lesbos (Xen. the time however, much had changed-mostly for from Persian funding) off the of Arginusae 2.41).By of Frogs, several collective this victory was in the worse, in terms of material comforts, self-confidence, Hell. 1.6.24-38). Inspirational though the immediate current a defeat would have spelt and military outlook-and opinions differed radically about respects, since probably means which it was achieved, and its political and leadership. Much of the empire (or the end of the war, the by policies, prospects, tor controversial and in some demoral1zing "allies") had been lost, forever. Athens was hated by a high propor- aftermath, were ways clear the text of tion of the other Greek city-states. The Persiansalways likely to be the Athenian population at large, as is made very by a decree a major player in Greek politics given their much greater financial Frogs. Before the battle, the Athenians had passed offering but even freedom and resources and centralized and better organized foreign poicies- not only citizenship to metics and foreigners service. Slaves to slaves who would volunteer for were now paying close attention to the task of helping the Pelopon- citizenship any of the official Athenian war ettort (in con- nesians build an effective navy, a task which, if successful, inevitably were not normally part where the were rou- spelled defeat for Athens. Several of the most talented, or most rea- trast, for instance, to Roman practice, galleys decree was an sonable and of the manned slaves and convicts); so this sensible, Athenian politicians had died, or were in tinely by exile. trom usual and not every Athe- Consensus on anything was hard to achieve. extraordinary departure practice, In of a extension of their jealously guarded early spring 405, the Athenians were in the twenty-sixth nian felt that such sweeping of an had the battle of Arginusae year agonizing and seemingy never-ending war.Their rights of citizenship was justified. Nor was in empire Athenian had tatters, with only the island of itself been an success. Twenty-five ships large Samos still a loyal and unmitigated significant ally in the war effort. Yet the had lost seventy-five), and thousands of need for a powerful naval been lost (the Spartans 38 ARISTOPHANES FROGS Aristophanes and His Athenian Audience 39 the biggoei in seasprobably had drowned stormy loss of crewmen of the Pelo Athenian campaign Peloponnesian ar, in any single a similar to what we tind in F'rogs: the Athe life In the attermath,aftermath, somsome said play) conveys message Sicilian expedition. from the that nian democracy ("the people") needs to be selective, yet inclusive apart the fieet were to blame for commanding failin to generals and well-integrated.