Description and Issues of Mineral Extraction on the Great Salt Lake - Tom Tripp, US Magnesium LLC MINERAL EXTRACTION PERSPECTIVES MINERAL EXTRACTION PERSPECTIVES
Disclaimer – This presentation is the work of Tom Tripp and doesn’t imply the official approval or opinion of any of the mineral extractors on the Great Salt Lake (or anyone else)
Cactus on Stansbury Is. THE GREAT SALT LAKE
Remnant of a Pleistocene inland sea – Lake Bonneville
Largest natural lake in USA west of the Great lakes
Terminal lake with no outlet
THE GREAT SALT LAKE
Average inflow (surface water, direct precipitation, ground water) = 6 million acre∙ft
Average outflow = 6 million acre∙ft (by evaporation)
Mineral content derived from dissolved chemical species in the inflows from a large drainage basin
MINERAL EXTRACTION ON THE GREAT SALT LAKE
The salinity of the Lake is obvious to even casual observers
It is presumed that native populations made use of the salt in the Lake prior settlement
The lake has been used for salt production from the earliest historic accounts
MOUNTAIN MAN EXPLORERS
Jedidiah Smith Captain Ashley
Jim Bridger PIONEER SALT PRODUCTION EARLY SALT INDUSTRY
Salt companies formed on the Great Salt Lake as early as 1870 Jeremy and Co -1870 Inland Salt Co - 1890 Inland Crystal Salt – 1891 Intermountain Salt – 1892 Diamond Salt – 1901 Maybe six others MINERAL EXTRACTION ON THE GREAT SALT LAKE
What is the current state mineral extraction on the lake? MINERAL EXTRACTION ON THE GREAT SALT LAKE
There are four major mineral extraction operations on the Great Salt Lake: Great Salt Lake Minerals Morton Salt US Mag Cargill Salt US Magnesium A couple of minor enterprises MINERAL PRODUCTS FROM THE GREAT SALT LAKE
Cargill Salt Located at Timpie, Tooele County Sodium chloride Kiln dried Water softener Agricultural blocks Technical grade
Cargill ships almost all of its product out of the State
MINERAL PRODUCTS FROM THE GREAT SALT LAKE
Morton Salt Located at Southeast end of Stansbury Is. Tooele County Sodium chloride Road salt Kiln dried Water softener Agricultural blocks Technical grade Morton’s presence on the GSL goes back to at least 1915
MINERAL PRODUCTS FROM THE GREAT SALT LAKE
Great Salt Lake Minerals Located in Weber County near Bear River Bay
Products include:
Potassium Sulfate Magnesium chloride Solutions Prills Sodium Chloride Sodium sulfate
Great Salt Lake Minerals Corporation (GSL) is the largest producer of sulfate of potash (SOP) in North America.
MINERAL PRODUCTS FROM THE GREAT SALT LAKE
US Magnesium LLC Located in Stansbury Basin, Tooele County Products include:
Magnesium metal Chlorine (liquid) Magnesium chloride Calcium chloride Sulfate salts (raw) Sodium chloride (raw) Iron chlorides (byproduct)
Only primary magnesium production facility in North American Supports ATI titanium operation with Mg
MINERAL EXTRACTION ON THE GREAT SALT LAKE
What makes the Great Salt Lake naturally attractive for mineral extraction? Abundance and composition of mineral content Weather patterns favorable to evaporative concentration Shallow lake bed geography facilitates evaporation impoundments Access to infrastructure, transportation and populations centers GREAT SALT LAKE - MINERAL CONTENT
Nominal Composition (south arm) of the water in: GSL Ocean Water Chloride (Cl-) 8.2% 1.9% Sodium (Na+) 5.1% 1.08% +2 Sulfate (SO4 ) 1.1% 0.091% Magnesium (Mg+2) 0.5% 0.13% Potassium (K+) 0.3% 0.04% Calcium 0.006% 0.04%
Nominally about 4-5 times the salinity than sea water FAVORABLE WEATHER PATTERNS
A long net evaporation period is mid-March to early October
Low humidity and in frequent summer precipitation aid evaporation
Net evaporation is about 50 inches of water
At US Mag during the hottest part of the evaporative season, daily average evaporation reaches 750,000 gallons/minute
Magnesium derives +95% of it energy input from solar energy LAKE BED GEOGRAPHY
In general the Great Salt Lake is shallow with gently sloping floors
Appropriate evaporations ponds can be constructed with simple engineering
In many areas there are impermeable clay layers that limit vertical seepage rates
Areas surrounding the lake provide granular fill for solar pond dike construction ECONOMIC IMPACT OF GSL MINERAL EXTRACTION IN UTAH
Jobs provided* Direct – 1,967 Indirect – 3,400 Total – 5,638
Wages paid* Direct – $168 million Indirect – $141 million Total – $309 million
*Derived from “Economic Significance of the Great Salt Lake to the State of Utah” prepared for the Great Salt Lake Advisory Council by Bioeconomics Inc., January 2012
ECONOMIC IMPACT OF GSL MINERAL EXTRACTION IN UTAH
Total Economic Output* Direct – $685 million Indirect – $446 million Total – $1,131 million
85% of the economic impact from the lake is derived from the mineral extraction industries
*Derived from “Economic Significance of the Great Salt Lake to the State of Utah” prepared for the Great Salt Lake Advisory Council by Bioeconomics Inc., January 2012
MINERAL EXTRACTION - GSL ISSUES
What Every Business Wants: Certainty
MINERAL EXTRACTION - CERTAINTY
Long term arrangements that allow confidence for investment Access to land/ponds Access to raw materials Water Mineral content Constancy in regulatory requirements
MINERAL EXTRACTION - CERTAINTY
There are plenty of uncertainty for the mineral extraction industries: Can’t guarantee weather Can’t guarantee markets or competition Can’t guarantee energy costs Or a host of other things MINERAL EXTRACTION - GSL ISSUES
What Else Does Every Business Wants:
Equity/Understanding MINERAL EXTRACTION - FAIRNESS
Industry understands that: The Lake ownership was granted to the State for the benefit of the citizens
The Lake is managed for multiple uses
There are many classes of Lake shareholders with various priorities
Mineral extraction is a legitimate shareholder that has existed for a long time on the Lake with demonstrated benefits and impacts MINERAL EXTRACTION - FAIRNESS
Many of the issues to be solved at the Great Salt Lake can only be addressed as watershed issues Because the mineral extraction facilities are visible, they are a shareholder unfairly expected to solve problems alone while other “upstream” shareholders are not asked to share a burden. Substantial royalties and lease fees from mineral extraction benefit FFSL restoration in upland areas. MINERAL EXTRACTION – LAKE LEVEL
Elevation of the Lake is important to mineral extraction industry There is no certainty on this issue. It is dependent on climate trends and upstream water users Extreme (natural) swings in lake level are hard to affect Late 1200’s the lake went dry Around 1700 the lake naturally flowed to the west desert
MINERAL EXTRACTION – LAKE LEVEL
Industry generally supports a State strategy on Lake elevation control
Infrastructure, both public and private, are jeopardized at high levels
Access to Lake water/minerals is affected at low lake levels MINERAL EXTRACTION – SALINITY
The railroad causeway dividing the lake has resulted in a migration of minerals to the North arm of the Lake Part of the mineral industry looks at this as an injustice Another part of mineral industries considers the concentrated North arm a mineral treasure to be preserved MINERAL EXTRACTION ON THE LAKE
The extraction industries on the Lake are diverse long standing enterprises They are unique in the country and world They materially contribute to the State’s economic well being and coffers They are cooperative and respected in local and State government They desire to be good partners with other Lake share holders
MINERAL EXTRACTION PERSPECTIVES
Thank You for your attention!