DOCSLIB.ORG

It Is Not a Panacea but You Can Try

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
It Is Not a Panacea but You Can Try It is not a Panacea but you can try... Overview of approaches used in different countries for treating stuttering as communication difficulty and speech disorder Olena DEMYDENKO Master’s Thesis Master of Philosophy in Special Needs Education Department of Special Needs Education Faculty of Educational Sciences UNIVERSITY OF OSLO Spring 2013 © Forfatter År Tittel Forfatter http://www.duo.uio.no/ Trykk: Reprosentralen, Universitetet i Oslo II Abstract Communication is a key factor in our life. Communication skills are important for development of the professional and personal relationships. Without them, one’s effectiveness in all roles during the life is limited. The main focus of the present research is stuttering that is a speech disorder where the sounds, syllables, or words are repeated or last longer than normal. The main purpose of the study was to find out the best approaches of treating stuttering through identification and classification of stuttering, and in designation of existing approaches for its treatment with a particular focus on Ukraine and Norway. Focusing on these two countries in an international frame was even more interesting, since understanding of this disorder and the approaches used for its treatment have been very much influenced in the past by the Soviet scientists in Ukraine and by the American, British and Australian researchers in Norway. The study was performed according to the qualitative approach based on a case study design using the document analysis as a research method. Data analyses were performed using a reflective type of analysis and by using the concept of interpretive zone according to Wasser & Bresler (1996). The received results indicated broad spectrum of differences in theories about the cause of stuttering, its definition and classification as well as its assessment between Norway and Ukraine. This led to the differences in approaches used for treatment of stuttering. This study also showed that understanding of stuttering as a disability and its treatment should be analyzed in the context of historical, social, economic and political relations in the two mentioned countries as well as taking into account the national cultural features. In addition, this research highlights other factors that influence the ways of stuttering treatment and that should be considered for adaptation and implementation of new approaches in each country (if such decision would be done). Among them, there are models of designation and treatment of disability, the sectors of healthcare, interactions: speech language therapist– person who stutter, teacher – person who stutter, peers – person who stutter; role of the family and the environment. III Acknowledgements I would like to thank everyone who took part in process of writing this manuscript. First of all, I am very thankful to my supervisors – Ivar Morken and Anne-Lise Rygvold - who have been supportive and encouraging along the whole work process. Their advices and various constructive suggestions were very helpful especially in the part of research devoted to Norway. I am also very thankful to everybody at the Department of Special Needs Education, University of Oslo, both teaching staff and students for an opportunity to conduct this study and make it interesting. My sincere thanks are also given to Professors Steinar Theie, Berit Helene Johnsen, Jorun Buli-Holmberg and Siri Wormnæs for their guidance, inspiring and enthusiastic teaching. I would also give many thanks to Denese A. Brittain and Nicolai Mowinckel-Trysnes for their support and administration during my study at the University of Oslo. Last but not least, I express my deep gratitude to my family and to my husband, whose love are the most inspirational ever! In honor and respect, I dedicate this Master thesis to them. Oslo, May 15 th , 2013 Olena Demydenko IV Table of Contents Abstract ................................................................................................................................ III Acknowledgements ............................................................................................................. IV Table of Contents .................................................................................................................. V List of Tables and Figures .................................................................................................. VII Chapter 1: Introduction ...........................................................................................................1 1.1 Background and purpose of the study .......................................................................2 1.2 Short description of the country – Norway................................................................4 1.2.1 Education ..........................................................................................................4 1.2.2 Towards inclusion in Norway. ...........................................................................4 1.2.3 Development of speech language therapy in Norway .........................................5 1.3 Short description of the country – Ukraine................................................................7 1.3.1 Education in Ukraine .........................................................................................8 1.3.2 Towards inclusion in Ukraine ............................................................................8 1.3.3 Development of speech language therapy in Ukraine ....................................... 10 1.4 Statement of the research problem .......................................................................... 11 1.4.1 Research problem ............................................................................................ 11 1.4.2 Research questions .......................................................................................... 11 1.4.3 Expectations of the study ................................................................................. 12 1.5 Structure of the thesis ............................................................................................. 12 Chapter 2: Theoretical Framework ....................................................................................... 14 2.1 Introduction ............................................................................................................ 14 2.2 The socio-cultural theory of L. S. Vygotsky ........................................................... 15 2.3 Models of designation and treatment of disability ................................................... 16 2.4 Sectors of healthcare .............................................................................................. 17 2.5 Interaction of environment and person with stuttering ............................................ 19 2.6 Theories about stuttering ........................................................................................ 22 Chapter 3: Research Design and Methodology ...................................................................... 32 3.1 Case study .............................................................................................................. 32 3.2 Data sampling ........................................................................................................ 34 3.3 Analysis ................................................................................................................. 35 3.4 Validity .................................................................................................................. 36 V 3.5 Ethical issues .......................................................................................................... 38 3.6 Research limitations ............................................................................................... 38 Chapter 4: Data Analyses and Findings ................................................................................ 40 4.1 Stuttering in Norway .............................................................................................. 40 4.1.1 Definition and classification ............................................................................ 41 4.1.2 Assessment of stuttering .................................................................................. 44 4.1.3 Approaches for treatment of stuttering ............................................................. 45 4.2 Stuttering in Ukraine .............................................................................................. 52 4.2.1 Definition and classification ............................................................................ 53 4.2.2 Assessment of stuttering .................................................................................. 59 4.2.3 Approaches for treatment of stuttering ............................................................. 60 Chapter 5: Discussion and Summary .................................................................................... 72 5.1 Common and differences in understanding phenomenon of stuttering and its treatment in Norway and Ukraine ..................................................................................... 72 5.2 Influence of different factors on treatment of stuttering in Norway and Ukraine ..... 74 5.2.1 Models of designation and treatment of disability ............................................ 75 5.2.2 Assessment of stuttering .................................................................................. 76 5.2.3 The sectors of healthcare ................................................................................
Load more

Recommended publications
  • One Voice 21, June 24, 2006
    One Voice International Issue 21 – June 2006 Downloadable at www.stutterisa.org Stuttering Incorporating The Voice of ELSA, the newsletter of the Association n Stuttering with street banner Edited by Jianliang Zhang, [email protected] A world that understands Stuttering 1, One Voice 21, June 24, 2006 Message from the Board Chair hat would you say if a television crew came to you and said “What do you W want the general public to know about stuttering?” The ISA is the umbrella organization for other international and national stuttering associations throughout the world. It does not seek to form consensus views rather to leave it to national associations to present their own perspective. However in the interests of stimulating discussion in these groups I would like to present how I responded to this question when it was asked of me during television interviews in Cameroon and Kenya last year. I gave the following information: ♦ Stuttering otherwise known as stammering is more than just dysfluent speech. The Dr. M. F. Irwin, ISA Board Chair hesitant speech or overt stuttering the 217-9 Payneham Rd. St. Peters, SA 5069, Australia listener hears is just the tip of the iceberg. Below the surface often lie feelings of International Stuttering Association regards shame and embarrassment which are either path as valid. accompanied by fear of social encounters. In ♦ The general public can support people who addition there maybe varying degrees of stutter by being a partner in the covert stuttering, that are word avoidance, communication process rather than a judge. substitution, and circumlocution, which are It helps if people listen well, smile, and used to hide the overt stuttering behaviour.
    [Show full text]
  • 2018 World Congress Hiroshima, Japan July 13 - 16 the Joint World Congress Schedule Is Subject to Change
    2018 World Congress Hiroshima, Japan July 13 - 16 The Joint World Congress schedule is subject to change. The App will be updated and will accurately reflect the schedule. Details about the App can be found here: https://theifa.org/program/congress-app 2 2018 World Congress Table of Contents Conference Map 04 Welcome Message 05 Our Sponsors 06 Exhibitors 08 Film Screening 09 Keynotes 10 Oral Presentations 14 Friday Poster Sessions 50 Saturday Poster Sessions 68 Sunday Poster Sessions 86 Post Congress Workshops 104 Organizing Committee 105 Donors 106 Please note that the downloadable program brochure does not reflect any changes made to the congress program after 23rd June. Please see the congress app for up-to-date information. One World, Many Voices: Science and Community 3 International Conference Center 4 2018 World Congress Welcome! We want to welcome you to this exciting and unprecedented collaborative event. One World, Many Voices: Science and Community is the Inaugural Joint World Congress of the International Cluttering Association (ICA), International Fluency Association (IFA) and International Stuttering Association (ISA), with local host organizations the Japan Society of Stuttering and Other Fluency Disorders and the Japanese Stuttering Genyukai Organization. The Inaugural Joint World Congress is a ground-breaking initiative, bringing together historically diverse groups to explore experiences of living with, treating, and researching, stuttering and cluttering. We want people who stutter or clutter to feel supported and valued; we want those who work clinically to have opportunities to share and update their skills; and we want researchers to have an opportunity to present high-quality research in a stimulating environment.
    [Show full text]
  • Redefining Stuttering by John Harrison, Naming Those Experiences and Elements….Helping Me to See All the Different Strands of My Journey As One Interrelated Whole
    SHEDDING NEW LIGHT ON A CHALLENGING PROBLEM REDEFINING STUTTERING • What the struggle to A Guide to Recovery speak is really all about • 2011 EDITION by JOHN C. HARRISON National Stuttering Association Now is the time A Guide to Recovery REDEFINING STUTTERING What the struggle to speak is really all about by JOHNby JOHN C. H C.ARRISON HARRISON National Stuttering Association 2011 EDITION WORDS THAT WORK San Francisco Copyright © 2011 by John C. Harrison ISBN 1-929773-08-4 2011 Edition. All rights reserved. This book is available as a free download from several web sites. Simply enter“Redefining Stuttering” in the browser search box. Printed copies are available from Amazon or from The National Stuttering Association, 119 W. 40th Street, 14th Floor, New York, N.Y. 10018. [email protected]. For those who are reading a PDF (electronic) version of this book and would like to turn it into a paperback: The book has been formatted for two-sided printing on any electronic copier capable of printing on both sides of the sheet. It is recommended that you use a heavier, colored paper for the front cover. You may also want to protect the book with a clear vinyl sheet at the front and a colored vinyl sheet at the back. Be what you is, cuz if you be what you ain't, you ain't what you is. Grave marker, Boot Hill Cemetery, Tombstone, Arizona Life goes on, and so must he. From the moment he gives himself up, and to the extent that he does so, all unknowingly he sets about to create and maintain a pseudo-self.
    [Show full text]
  • SPEECH IS a RIVER – My Recovery from Stuttering
    SPEECH IS A RIVER MY RECOVERY FROM STUTTERING BY RUTH MEAD Copyright © 201l by: Assn. for the Study & Cure of Stammering ALL RIGHTS RESERVED By Right Brain Press, 2011 ISBN 978-1-4507-0543-1 PRINTED IN THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA SPEECH IS A RIVER – My Recovery From Stuttering TABLE OF CONTENTS INTRODUCTION BY JOHN HARRISON FOREWORD PART I -- SPEECH IS LIKE JAZZ CHAPTER 1 SPEECH IS LIKE JAZZ – (It just happens) CHAPTER 2 LOCKED INTO CONSCIOUS THOUGHT CHAPTER 3 ALWAYS TRYING HAS MADE ME TIRED….MAYBE THAT‟S A START CHAPTER 4 MORE CURES? CHAPTER 5 A MIND-BENDING DISCOVERY – I HAVE A VOICE CHAPTER 6 THE 800 POUND GORILLA IN THE ROOM CHAPTER 7 HITTING ROCK BOTTOM PART II -- THINGS I LEARNED ON THE WAY TO THE ZONE CHAPTER 8 BOTH KINDS OF ME (SOMEONE GREATER THAN MY CONSCIOUS MIND) CHAPTER 9 GETTING ON MY OWN SIDE (OPENING MY EYES, SEEING FOR MYSELF) CHAPTER 10 WRITING DOWN THE STUFF 2 SPEECH IS A RIVER – My Recovery From Stuttering PART III – ARRIVING AT THE ZONE CHAPTER 11 ARRIVING AT THE ZONE PART IV - 7 KEYS TO THE ZONE CHAPTER 12 ONE OF SEVEN. TAKE THE SCARY OUT OF SPEECH (THRU HARRISON‟S HEXAGON) CHAPTER 13 TWO OF SEVEN, SPEECH IS LIKE A RIVER (CREATE A POWERFUL METAPHOR) CHAPTER 14 THREE OF SEVEN. TAKING RESPONSIBILITY FOR CREATING BLOCKS (EXPOSING BLOCKS AS IMAGINARY) CHAPTER 15 FOUR OF SEVEN. OUTWITTING MY BLOCKS: I TALK TO MY MOUNTAIN CHAPTER 16 FIVE OF SEVEN. WRITING THE RIVER; ALLOWING THE FLOW CHAPTER 17 SIX OF SEVEN.
    [Show full text]
  • One Voice 17 May 2004
    One Voice nternational I Issue 17 - May 2004 Stuttering Incorporating The Voice of ELSA, the newsletter of Association the European League of Stuttering Associations Special edition from the seventh world congress for people who stutter Perth, Australia,February 15-20, 2004 pleasure to organise the group of overseas attendees who with Reach out and get together scholarships from the world congress organisers and ISA were participating at the meeting. For most of them it was their first Stefan Hoffmann such event and I believe it strengthened their commitment to ISA Outreach Working Group Chair work with and for the ISA family. Here above, you can see the photo taken at the congres venue. 15 countries are represented The long awaited 7th world congress for people who stutter is from all continents. now already history. But I believe that for quite a few people, I invite you to read on the next pages about how the meeting the memory will be meaningful for long time to come. I had the was seen by them. continued on page 3 ‘A world that understands stuttering’ 2 – One Voice 17 May 2004 ISA is making a real difference to people who stutter Report of board chair to ISA meeting, The ISA has continued to produce its newsletter One February 14th 2004 Voice. I thank Andrew Harding of the British Stammering Association who has edited and produced the last four issues and before him Warren Brown of the New Zealand Mark Irwin Speak Easy Association. Both men are journalists and have Australia been extremely diligent and creative in their efforts.
    [Show full text]
  • Stuttering and Cluttering
    Stuttering and Cluttering Stuttering and Cluttering provides a comprehensive overview of both theor- etical and treatment aspects of disorders of fluency: stuttering (also known as stammering) and the lesser known cluttering. The book demonstrates how treatment strategies relate to the various theories as to why stuttering and cluttering arise, and how they develop. Uniquely, it outlines the major approaches to treatment alongside alternative methods, including drug treatment and recent auditory feedback procedures. Part 1 looks at different perspectives on causation and development, emphasizing that in many cases these apparently different approaches are inextricably intertwined. Part 2 covers the assessment, diagnosis, treatment, and evaluation of stuttering and cluttering. In addition to chapters on estab- lished approaches, there are sections on alternative therapies, including drug therapy, and auditory feedback, together with a chapter on counselling. Ref- erence is made to a number of established treatment programs, but the focus is on the more detailed description of specific landmark approaches. These provide a framework from which the reader may not only understand others’ treatment procedures, but also a perspective from which they can develop their own. Offering a clear, accessible and comprehensive account of both the theo- retical underpinning of stammering therapy and its practical implications, the book will be of interest to speech language therapy students, as well as quali- fied therapists, psychologists, and to those who stutter and clutter. David Ward is Director of the Speech Research Laboratory at the University of Reading, and a specialist fluency clinician within the NHS. He qualified as a speech language therapist in 1987, and later received an MA in linguistics and phonetics and a PhD in motor control and stuttering.
    [Show full text]
  • One Voice 16
    One VoiceOne Voice 16 July 2003 – International Issue 16 - July 2003 Stuttering Incorporating The Voice of ELSA, the newsletter of the Association European League of Stuttering Associations World Congress 20042004 The PPererthth-ect place Turn to page 3 for previews ‘A world that understands stuttering’ 2 – One Voice 16 July 2003 ISA Board chair’s report International Year of the Child Who Stutters 2004 has been assigned by the ISA as the International Year of the Child Who Stutters (IYCWS). Michael Sugarman from San Francisco is leading this initiative, having been appointed to this ISA role in 2001. Michael is a very experienced and highly respected advocate for people who stutter. The ISA Board is extremely appreciative of his willingness to take on this volunteer role. Heartening news is that ELSA (European League of Stuttering Associations) is keen to promote the IYCWS as well. entitled to participate). Board members are elected for a CD ROM project three-year term and a member can serve a maximum of One of the key elements of the IYCWS will be the release three consecutive terms. There will be at least two of a CD Rom for distribution in schools, with stuttering vacancies in Perth. ISA member associations are information for children who stutter, their fluent encouraged to nominate representatives to the ISA classmates, their parents and their teachers. At this stage conference who might also consider standing for election a draft copy has been produced. A launch date for version to the ISA Board. The meeting will be held on Saturday 1 has been set for August at the International Fluency 2 - 5pm, and Sunday from 10 to 5pm.
    [Show full text]
  • Transcript of a Presentation, by Alan Badmington, to the British Stammering Association National Conference at Hope University, Liverpool, England on 9 September 2001
    TRANSCRIPT OF A PRESENTATION, BY ALAN BADMINGTON, TO THE BRITISH STAMMERING ASSOCIATION NATIONAL CONFERENCE AT HOPE UNIVERSITY, LIVERPOOL, ENGLAND ON 9 SEPTEMBER 2001 STUTTERING IS NOT JUST A SPEECH PROBLEM My name is Alan Badmington………Alan Badmington. You cannot imagine just how much pleasure it gives me to say that in front of an audience. You see, for over 50 years, I experienced extreme difficulty in telling people who I was. Yes, that simple task, which the majority of the population takes so much for granted, caused me so much frustration, anxiety and heartache. I understand that I commenced stuttering at the age of about 3 years, and although I received early therapy, I do not recall encountering any major difficulties until I entered the grammar school at the age of 11. On the first day, as the registers were being prepared, I have vivid memories of struggling to give my name and address in front of some 30 other pupils, most of whom were complete strangers. Reading aloud in class was another disaster. As it progressed around the room, I would be calculating (10 desks ahead) exactly what I would be saying. Struck by the stark realisation that my passage contained many words with which I knew I would encounter difficulty, I would opt out, remain silent, and the reading would pass to the next pupil. That was one of the first examples, I can recall, of approach avoidance. Further speech therapy followed without much success. I could read aloud in the therapy room, but could not ask, or respond to, questions in class.
    [Show full text]
  • People Who Stutter Can Overcome Social Fear Vrbal
    [email protected] https://www.yukafukuoka.com/ PEOPLE WHO STUTTER CAN OVERCOME SOCIAL FEAR VRBAL Yuka Fukuoka DSI, 2018 Thesis INTRO TO PROBLEM SUMMARY OF PROJECT INITIAL RESEARCH FIRST RESEARCH SECOND RESEARCH THIRD RESEARCH CONTENT FOURTH RESEARCH IDEATION YUKA FUKUOKA Yuka Fukuoka is from Japan, and studied Information and Service Design PROTOTYPE at Tama Art University, Japan. After graduating she worked at Yahoo! Japan as a designer and then attended the University of Tokyo’s ITERATION Interfaculty Initiative in Information Studies as a research student. She is interested in changing the general publics perspective on people with disabilities. IMPLEMENTATION FIRST INTERVENTION FINAL INTERVENTION LEARNING NEXT STEP CONCLUSION INTRO TO PROBLEM PROBLEM CONTEXT Stuttering is a communication disorder in which the flow of speech is broken by repetitions (li-li-like this), prolongations (lllllike this), or abnormal stoppages (no sound) of sounds. There may also be unusual facial and bodily movements associated with the effort to speak. So what problems does stuttering actually cause, outside of making it hard to talk? First, you are not able to talk like the people around you. Your parents and teachers notice and friends tease you, so your repeated experiences instill you with a sense of failure. You blame yourself for being unable to do what everyone else can do. You conclude that you’re inferior, and your self-confidence falls. Finally, you lose confidence in com- munication, stop approaching people, and miss out on opportunities in life. Through this process, people who stutter easily become people with social anxiety disorder. I definied that this is the core problem.
    [Show full text]
  • One Voice 36 February 2015 One Voice
    INTERNATIONAL STUTTERING ASSOCIATION ONE VOICE 36 FEBRUARY 2015! ONE VOICE Incorporating The Voice of ELSA, the newsletter of the European League of Stuttering Associations Pg. 2-4 Message from the Chair - K. Boss Pg. 5 Message from ELSA - E. Farr, A. Blom Pg. 6-7 Message from Outreach - K. Boss Pg. 8-9 Talking Without Fear - P. Mertz Pg. 10-11 Australian Speak Easy Association- M.Irwin Pg. 12 Public Perceptions of Stuttering - R. Kaketa Pg. 13 Info about e-book: Teachers and Stuttering - Dr. Pedro R. Rodriguez C Pg. 14-19 Dimension Neurofonoaudiologica (English) A. Barrales Diaz Pg. 20-25 Dimension Neurofonoaudiologica (Spanish) A. Barrales Diaz Pg. 26 Update from the Netherlands - B. Bast ! PAGE 1 INTERNATIONAL STUTTERING ASSOCIATION ONE VOICE 36 FEBRUARY 2015! MESSAGE FROM THE CHAIR Message from the Chair. Hello to all International Stuttering Association (ISA) friends around the world. This is a message I prepared six months ago. A year has passed since this ISA Board was elected by our membership in Lunteren (Netherlands). One of the clear messages you gave us was to work more closely with the professional community.. Links with the International Fluency Association (IFA) are being maintained. There is a continued e$ort by all concerned to improve treatment for PWS. Examination and publication of holistic treatments o$ered by many SLPs / SLTs will give PWS a better understanding of what treatments are available. I have a series of articles being published in the e-newsflash (http://www.isastutter.org/news/e-newsflash) about various treatments which go beyond the stuttering syllable count.
    [Show full text]