Jeuda 124 Oak Eng.Qxd
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
World Bank: 2,809 working children and youth give their opinions on the projects African Movement of Working Children and Youth (AMWCY) JEUDA 124 - 2 - Consulting children on projects funded by the World Bank Opinions expressed in this document are those of their authors and do not necessarily reflect those of the organizations concerned in this publication. Reproduction is free for educational or scientific purposes, with clear indi- cation of the source and address, as well as sending copies to Enda. n Written by Dominique Gomis : Socio-Anthropologue Fabrizio Terenzio : Regional Coordinator, enda- ja n Consultants from 5 countries - Benin : Cather Nansounon - Burkina Faso : Issouf Hema - Burundi : Icoyitungiye Prosper - Cameroun : Tchatat Yakwa Godain Powel - Côte d’Ivoire : N’dri Yao Claude n Facilitation - 2.809 enfants et jeunes travailleurs des 5 pays - Moussa Harouna, coordinator program AMWCY - Aimé Bada, responsible for training, enda- ja - Mamadou Niambélé, assistant training, enda- ja n Photo Credit and illustrations Anoh Cyrille, Isaak Traore, Paulin, Maïga Moussa, Simboro Seydou, Zodissi Louis, WCY from Cameroun, WCY from Burundi n Production El Hadj Sarr © enda- jeunesse action. December 2013 ISSN 0850 - 1629 This document is produced with the support of Oak Foundation Enda- Jeunesse Action BP 3370 Dakar - Sénégal Tél. : (221) 33 889 34 20 -Fax : (221) 33 823 51 57 Courrier électronique : [email protected] Internet : www.maejt.org Consulting children on projects funded by the World Bank - 3 - S o m m a i r e I- CHILDREN AND YOUTHS ...............................................P.4 II- PRESENTING THE ACHIEVED OUTCOMES ..................P.6 1- Children and youths' level of knowledge and proximity in regards to projects on which they expressed themselves........p.6 2- Project's advantages and threats .........................................p.11 3- Child labor ..........................................................................p.15 4- Education ...............................................................................p.22 5- Health .....................................................................................p.27 6- Blossoming out and greater well-being ................................p.32 7- Vulnerability ..........................................................................p.35 III- RECOMMENDATIONS ................................................P.43 12 Recommendations on the design and management of projects .............................................................p.43 5 Recommendations to the World Bank .....................................p.43 9 Recommendations to States and project actors .....................p.43 IV- PROSPECTS ...............................................................P.45 APPENDIX ........................................................................P.47 1- Process diagram and actors' role .........................................p.47 2- Table of countries, localities, and participants in the local and national consultations .....................................p.48 3- Projects financially supported by the World Bank on which the children expressed themselves ............................p.49 4- The 5 African countries concerned: Benin, Burkina Faso, Burundi, Cameroon, Côte d'Ivoire ....................p.50 5- AMWCY statistics in 2013 ....................................................p.51 - 4 - Consulting children on projects funded by the World Bank I - CHILDREN AND YOUTHS Children, youths and consultants who took part at the Cameroon consultation 2,809 working children and youths attended a consultation that was held from May to July 2013. Among the attendees were housemaids, apprentices learning different trades, vendors, workers from various economic sectors; snail, pig, chicken and fish breeders; hairdres- sers, market gardeners and children involved in other numerous jobs and who, for the most part, are either working or studying in formal schools or taking literacy courses by AMWCY. 2,084 were children who were less than 18 years old; while the youths included 725; girls, 1,358 and boys, 1,451. They were represented by 163 children and youths (each one of them representing more than 17 WCYs) in the national consultations organized in 5 countries (see below); Local consultations were held in 105 localities broken down as follows: Benin : Abomey, Ab-Calavi, Agbangnizoun, Aguégué, Allada, Avrankou, Bassila, Bembèrèkè, Bohicon, Comè, Cotonou, Covè, Dassa, Grand-popo, Kandi, Kétou, Kpomassè, Lac, Lokossa, Malanville, Mboua, Missérété, Natitingou, Ndali, Ouidah, Parakou, Porto-Novo, Sèmèkpodji, Ségbanlan, Zakpota, Zè, Zinvié. Consulting children on projects funded by the World Bank - 5 - Burkina Faso : Accart ville, Arfalao 1, Banfora, Bodoville, Bounouna, Bobo Dioulasso, Cissin, Delwendé, Espoir, Flantama, Kongolokande, Koudougou Kua Nayalgué, Ouagadougou Ouezzin ville, Patte d'oie, Rayitaaba, Samadin, Sarfalao 2, Songtaaba, Wafu Burundi : Bujumbura, Bujumbura Mairie, Bubanza, Gitega, Cibitoke, Muramvya, Ruyigi, Bururi, Cankuzo Cameroon : Baolio, Chasad., Congore, Domayo, Ebanga, Elig-doum, Emende, Etol, et quartier Kanabeng, Mbeka, Mboua, Mile 4, Mile 8, Ndamekon, Nkolbisson, Nkolfoulou, Nkol-bikok, Nyemeyon, Okola (Lendom), Ngoya, Obala 3, Pajok, Pitoare, Camp haous- sa Cote d'Ivoire : Abidjan, Daloa, Duekoué, Grand-Lahou, Katiola, Korhogo, Ferkéssedougou, San-Pedro Touba, Toumodi This report focuses mainly on what they said; their positions in relation to different issues; their recommendations and prospects (sometimes internal to AMWCY). The figures provided show the average stances among the 5 national consultations held. These debates occurred thanks to Oak's request to AMWCY and Enda TM. Thus, WCYs were able to become more involved in this World Bank projects issue they have been closely watching. Some of the children consulted had a direct working experience from World Bank-finan- ced worksites; others worked on the periphery of those same worksites; for example, in shoddy restaurants that provided food for workers. So, this is more than an opinion children express through the experiences they describe, when they report facts, like night shifts, or various abuses they were subjected to, for example regarding wages, they must be listened to, for they know what they are talking about. When they propose some improvements, such proposals should be taken very seriously. By the way, one is struck by the fact that most of their recommendations deal with project management issues … In fact, the number of children who expressed themselves is very minimal; yet it repre- sents hundreds of thousands of members and supporters of this important African Movement of Working Children and Youth (see AMWCY statistics, Appendix 5). Let us learn to listen to them! - 6 - Consulting children on projects funded by the World Bank II. PRESENTING THE ACHIEVED OUTCOMES 1- Children and youths' level of knowledge and proximity in regards to projects on which they expressed themselves Burundi's WCY at the workshop During the five national consultations, the two following introductory questions were asked of the participants to test their knowledge, involvement and proximity in regards to the projects they expressed themselves on. 1. Have you ever heard about these projects? How? 2. Did the children have any contact with these projects? 1.1 "Have you ever heard about these projects on which you are expressing yourself? " a) Those who said no (have not heard about it) (25%) Burkina Faso: 224 participants (including those consulted at grassroots level) have declared that they had never heard about the projects the World Bank have financed in their areas. They claimed that this is mainly due to a lack of information, which is often caused by the fact that they live far from decision-making spheres. Consulting children on projects funded by the World Bank - 7 - Burundi: Those who hold such a point of view argue that: Combining communication strategies enabled extensive communication. Different chan- nels were used to inform people in general; children and youths in particular. Administrative meetings, the media (radios, televisions, etc), press releases through churches; posters and banners were used as well. But more than 77% say that they have heard about these works while they were being implemented, and that 30% heard about them through informal ways. Children declare that they have not had any opportunity to express themselves before. Cameroon: They back their choice with the fact that some children were aware of the activities of the Project for the Improvement of Agricultural Competitiveness (PACA), of the National Program of Participative Development (PNDP) and of the Lom Pangar project (construction of the hydroelectric dam) for example, but without knowing that these activities were part of those projects. According to consulted children, the on- going projects are government projects, designed and financed by the government of Cameroon. Cote d'Ivoire: To prove that they were not informed about projects financed in their towns, regarding the following lines: - There is no radio report and "I haven't heard griots saying the World Bank has financed a project in Touba" - They have not seen any advertisement regarding a project that has been financed by the World Bank : "we do not have access to information on projects that are implemented in Abidjan" - They often get information from NGOs, governmental organizations, but they are not further informed on funding.