Refashioning Allegorical Imagery: from Langland to Spenser

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Refashioning Allegorical Imagery: from Langland to Spenser Refashioning Allegorical Imagery: From Langland to Spenser DISSERTATION Presented in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree Doctor of Philosophy in the Graduate School of The Ohio State University By John Slefinger Graduate Program in English The Ohio State University 2017 Dissertation Committee: Ethan Knapp, Advisor Hannibal Hamlin, Advisor Sarah-Grace Heller Copyrighted by John Slefinger 2017 Abstract Scholars often frame allegory as if it were tied to stable signifiers (i.e. white as purity) and therefore insulated from material concerns. I argue, however, that allegorical clothing is always-already material. That is, it is necessarily tied to material concerns either with respect to fashion or status, and therefore all allegorical costume should be seen as a comment on contemporary material culture. In order to make this argument, this dissertation tracks allegorical costume in English poetry from Langland to Spenser. Starting in the 14th century, there was a rapid expansion of access to and variety in fashion, and there was an increased awareness that identity could be donned and therefore bought and sold. This troubled contemporary moralists, who struggled to define how clothing worked in the public sphere, and it troubled allegorical poets, who struggled to apply stable literary markers in a shifting discursive field. Because allegory is only able to signify through a shared contemporary discourse, I thus argue that fashion both disrupted the discursive field around dress and destabilized allegorical imagery. Chapter 1 examines William Langland’s Piers Plowman and The Book of Margery Kempe to see how allegorical conventions conflict with the way characters read each other’s clothing, and how the access to power and institutional backing allows certain characters to define how their clothing is read. Chapter 2 explores the rise of the morality play by perusing The Castle of Perseverance, Mankind, and Hyckescorner. ii While, morality plays are often assumed to be heavy handed lectures that impose categorical imperatives on their audience members, this chapter shows that English morality plays are inescapably material. Even though their structure remains consistent, their descriptions and staging of righteousness shifts along with East Anglian politics. Chapter 3 compares Skelton’s Bowge of Court to his one surviving morality play, Magnyfycence. While both are courtly, dramatic allegories, they establish different rules under which clothing can signify and include different individuals into those systems. Chapter 4 analyzes Britomart in Spenser’s Faerie Queene in order to show how the transformative potential of Britomart’s armor shifts with Spenser’s waning enthusiasm for Elizabeth I. This dissertation contends that material valences of allegorical imagery contend with and sometimes overwhelm classical models or literary convention, and that struggle within the mode demonstrates profound continuity between the Middle Ages and the Renaissance. iii Acknowledgments I’d like to start by thanking the dozens of people who have patiently listened to me obsess over historical points of contention, literary quandaries, and details about sumptuary laws for the past few years. Large projects only come together through a dialectic process, and I was lucky enough to have friends, both academic and lay, who were willing to take part in that process even if my research was not in their field. I’m pretty certain I bored a lot of rugby players at a lot of pubs, but they were always polite. Of course, I’d also like to thank the members of my committee, who were so good at pointing me to resources that would refine my argument, and so patient in providing helpful feedback throughout the drafting process. To my fellow medievalists at the Ohio State University, thanks for setting up a Dissertation Reading Group, going through drafts, and pushing me to be clearer. In the scholarly realm, where so many graduate students feel like pretenders, the Ohio State contingent always made me feel like my work was interesting, welcome, and challenging. I’m looking forward to Kalamazoo 2018. Lastly, I want to thank my wife, whose approval I continually sought as I wrote. Thanks for the midnight margaritas, the random road trip songs, and the impromptu clubs we set up in the kitchen. Two are just two. iv Vita June 2003 .......................................................Wheaton-Warrenville High School 2007................................................................B.A. English, Colgate University 2013................................................................M.A. English, The Ohio State University 2011 to present ..............................................Graduate Teaching Associate, Department of English, The Ohio State University Publications “The Two Alisouns: The Miller’s Use of Costume and his Seduction of the Wife of Bath.” Fall 2015, Essays in Medieval Studies. Fields of Study Major Field: English v Table of Contents Abstract ............................................................................................................................... ii Acknowledgments.............................................................................................................. iv Vita ...................................................................................................................................... v Introduction: Allegory and the “Birth” of Fashion ............................................................ 1 Chapter 1: Langland, Kempe, and the Politics of Shame ................................................. 40 Chapter 2: Morality Plays and the Paradigms of Redemption .......................................... 86 Chapter 3: Skelton’s Conservatism and the Look of Magnificence ............................... 134 Chapter 4: Britomart and the Gravity of Time................................................................ 186 Conclusion: the Continuity of Change ............................................................................ 256 Bibliography ................................................................................................................... 260 vi Introduction: Allegory and the “Birth” of Fashion In Passus XIII of Piers Plowman, we meet Hawkin the Active Man, whose coat is “moled” in “many sondri plottes,” signifying both his sins and distance from salvation. While critical reception has varied widely on the meaning of this episode, it is clear that the fate of Hawkin’s coat will be the fate of his soul: for better or worse his identity is conflated with his dress. In another allegory written over 200 years later, Spenser’s Fairie Queene, Britomart’s armor in Book III reflects her changing identity within the narrative. As a young, unarmed girl she is “froward” and cautious, but once she dons just a few straps and a bit of plate, Britomart transforms herself into a confident and powerful character, emasculating her male rivals with every joust. From the Middle Ages to the Renaissance, we can find dozens of similar examples where characters’ identities are wrapped up in their costume. But in the same period, authors make fundamentally different assumptions about the elasticity of performed identity. In the above pair of examples, Langland’s clothing ties Hawkin down and limits the waferer’s ability to change his identity. Spenser, by contrast, gives us a protagonist who can transcend gender through dress at will: so long as she is wearing mail, she can be male. The Middle Ages introduced fashion to Western Europe, and that in turn spurred radical disagreement as to the transformative potential of clothing. This dissertation will examine several conflicting examples like the ones above. The goal is to answer how 1 shifts in the discourse surrounding clothing along with the material conditions of costume production were reflected in allegory. Doing so illuminates medieval and Early Modern understandings of the embodied self, and how literature both reflected and helped produce the cultural norms of appearance. 1. The Regulation of Identity The story of fashion is a story about defining difference. In the middle of the 14th century, one of clothing’s primary functions in Western Europe was to distinguish between estates and occupations within those estates. Perhaps a definitive example of this function is described by Stella Mary Newton in Fashion in the Age of the Black Prince when she examines the Royal Wardrobe for the 1360 Christmas celebration.1 The records provide a nearly exhaustive picture of the clothing afforded to everyone in the court from the king to the minstrels. Edward III’s outfit is laid out in exact detail, from the tightness of the fit (in accordance with the new fashion) to the gold ribbon trimming that differentiated his outfit from the rest of the attendees’. We learn that Queen Philippa’s outfit was nearly identical to that of Edward’s sister, Joan, except for the extra and expensive ermine that Phillippa’s tailor had to work with. We also learn that 1 Stella Mary Newton, Fashion in the age of the black prince: a study of the years, 1340-1365 (Woodbridge, Suffolk, UK: Boydell Press, 1999). Besides the incredible detail that Newton offers, I focus on Edward III for a couple of reasons: 1) we have more detailed records of his Wardrobe than we do of Richard II’s. In fact, details about Richard’s wardrobe exist (see W. Paley Baildon, "XXII.—A Wardrobe Account of 16–17 Richard II, 1393–4",.Archaeologia 62 (1911): 497-514.), but they are hard to find
Recommended publications
  • Religious Forms and Institutions in Piers Plowman
    This essay appeared in The Cambridge Companion to Piers Plowman, edited by Andrew Cole and Andy Galloway (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2013), 97-116 Religious Forms and Institutions in Piers Plowman James Simpson KEY WORDS: William Langland, Piers Plowman, selfhood and institutions; late medieval religious institutions ABSTRACT Which comes first: institutions or selves? Liberal democracies operate as if selves preceded institutions. By and large, pre-Reformation culture places the institution before the self. The self, and particularly the conscience as the source of deepest ethical and spiritual counsel, is intimately shaped, by the institution of the Church. This shaping is both ethical and spiritual; by no means least, it ensures the soul’s salvation, though administering the sacraments especially of baptism, penance, and the Eucharist. The conscience is not a lonely entity in such an institutional culture. It is, rather, the portable voice of accumulated, communal history and wisdom: it is, as the word itself suggests, a ‘con-scientia’, a ‘knowing with’. These tensions generate the extraordinary and conflicted account of self and institution in Langland’s Piers Plowman. 1 Religious Forms and Institutions in Piers Plowman Which comes first: institutions or selves? Liberal democracies operate as if selves preceded institutions, since electors choose their institutional representatives, who themselves vote to shape institutions. Liberal ideology, indeed, traces its genealogy back to heroic moments of the lonely, fully-formed conscience standing up against the might of institutions; those heroes (Luther is the most obvious example) are lionized precisely because they are said to have established the grounds of choice: every individual will be able to choose, in freedom, his or her institutional affiliation for him or herself.
    [Show full text]
  • Irish Gothic Fiction
    THE ‘If the Gothic emerges in the shadows cast by modernity and its pasts, Ireland proved EME an unhappy haunting ground for the new genre. In this incisive study, Jarlath Killeen shows how the struggle of the Anglican establishment between competing myths of civility and barbarism in eighteenth-century Ireland defined itself repeatedly in terms R The Emergence of of the excesses of Gothic form.’ GENCE Luke Gibbons, National University of Ireland (Maynooth), author of Gaelic Gothic ‘A work of passion and precision which explains why and how Ireland has been not only a background site but also a major imaginative source of Gothic writing. IRISH GOTHIC Jarlath Killeen moves well beyond narrowly political readings of Irish Gothic by OF IRISH GOTHIC using the form as a way of narrating the history of the Anglican faith in Ireland. He reintroduces many forgotten old books into the debate, thereby making some of the more familiar texts seem suddenly strange and definitely troubling. With FICTION his characteristic blend of intellectual audacity and scholarly rigour, he reminds us that each text from previous centuries was written at the mercy of its immediate moment as a crucial intervention in a developing debate – and by this brilliant HIST ORY, O RIGI NS,THE ORIES historicising of the material he indicates a way forward for Gothic amidst the ruins of post-Tiger Ireland.’ Declan Kiberd, University of Notre Dame Provides a new account of the emergence of Irish Gothic fiction in the mid-eighteenth century FI This new study provides a robustly theorised and thoroughly historicised account of CTI the beginnings of Irish Gothic fiction, maps the theoretical terrain covered by other critics, and puts forward a new history of the emergence of the genre in Ireland.
    [Show full text]
  • Style: Figuring Subjectivity in 'Piers Plowman C' and 'The Parson's Tale' and 'Retraction': Authorial Insertion and Identity Poetics 04/05/2006 09:03 AM
    Style: Figuring subjectivity in 'Piers Plowman C' and 'The Parson's Tale' and 'Retraction': authorial insertion and identity poetics 04/05/2006 09:03 AM FindArticles > Style > Fall, 1997 > Article > Print friendly Figuring subjectivity in 'Piers Plowman C' and 'The Parson's Tale' and 'Retraction': authorial insertion and identity poetics Daniel F. Pigg For some time, scholars and readers of Chaucer have pondered his knowledge about one of the major poets of his day: William Langland. Readers may typically find statements in scholarly discourse such as "We can now scarcely avoid considering the probability of Chaucer's having actually seen a copy of Piers Plowman in the interval between its first publication (c. 1370) and the beginnings of the Tales at least ten years later" (Bennett 321). Given internal evidence in the fifth passus of the C text - if we are willing to accept any connection between Langland's "autobiographical" confession/apologia and the writer - and documentary evidence of the historical Chaucer, we must assume that each poet was in London for at least a short time. Hypotheses about Chaucer's reading have always been at the forefront of scholarly debate. No one, however, has been about to demonstrate absolutely that Chaucer had knowledge of Piers Plowman. In her closing remarks at the 1994 New Chaucer Society meeting in Dublin, Ireland, Anne Middleton challenged those present to "trouble Chaucer's silences." The present attempt to "trouble the silence" relates to the growth and development of major poetic projects: the C text of Piers Plowman (likely written in the 1380s) and the "final" shape of the Canterbury Tales.
    [Show full text]
  • View of the Great
    This dissertation has been 62—769 microfilmed exactly as received GABEL, John Butler, 1931- THE TUDOR TRANSLATIONS OF CICERO'S DE OFFICIIS. The Ohio State University, Ph.D., 1961 Language and Literature, modern University Microfilms, Inc., Ann Arbor, Michigan THE TUDOR TRANSLATIONS OP CICERO'S DE OFFICIIS DISSERTATION Presented in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree Doctor of Philosophy in the Graduate School of the Ohio State University By John Butler Gabel, B. A., M. A., A. M. ****** The Ohio State University 1961 Approved by Adviser Department of Ehglis7 PREFACE The purpose of this dissertation is to throw light on the sixteenth-century English translations of De Offioiis, one of Cicero’s most popular and most influential works. The dissertation first surveys the history and reputation of the Latin treatise to I600 and sketchs the lives of the English translators. It then establishes the facts of publication of the translations and identifies the Latin texts used in them. Finally it analyzes the translations themselves— their syntax, diction, and English prose style in general— against the background of the theory and prac­ tice of translation in their respective periods. I have examined copies of the numerous editions of the translations in the Folger Shakespeare Library, the Library of Congress, and the libraries of the Ohio State University and the University of Illinois. I have also made use of films of copies in the British Museum and the Huntington Library. I have indicated the location of the particular copies upon which the bibliographical descrip­ tions in Chapter 3 are based.
    [Show full text]
  • Bodies of Knowledge: the Presentation of Personified Figures in Engraved Allegorical Series Produced in the Netherlands, 1548-1600
    University of Pennsylvania ScholarlyCommons Publicly Accessible Penn Dissertations 2015 Bodies of Knowledge: The Presentation of Personified Figures in Engraved Allegorical Series Produced in the Netherlands, 1548-1600 Geoffrey Shamos University of Pennsylvania, [email protected] Follow this and additional works at: https://repository.upenn.edu/edissertations Part of the History of Art, Architecture, and Archaeology Commons Recommended Citation Shamos, Geoffrey, "Bodies of Knowledge: The Presentation of Personified Figures in Engraved Allegorical Series Produced in the Netherlands, 1548-1600" (2015). Publicly Accessible Penn Dissertations. 1128. https://repository.upenn.edu/edissertations/1128 This paper is posted at ScholarlyCommons. https://repository.upenn.edu/edissertations/1128 For more information, please contact [email protected]. Bodies of Knowledge: The Presentation of Personified Figures in Engraved Allegorical Series Produced in the Netherlands, 1548-1600 Abstract During the second half of the sixteenth century, engraved series of allegorical subjects featuring personified figures flourished for several decades in the Low Countries before falling into disfavor. Designed by the Netherlandsâ?? leading artists and cut by professional engravers, such series were collected primarily by the urban intelligentsia, who appreciated the use of personification for the representation of immaterial concepts and for the transmission of knowledge, both in prints and in public spectacles. The pairing of embodied forms and serial format was particularly well suited to the portrayal of abstract themes with multiple components, such as the Four Elements, Four Seasons, Seven Planets, Five Senses, or Seven Virtues and Seven Vices. While many of the themes had existed prior to their adoption in Netherlandish graphics, their pictorial rendering had rarely been so pervasive or systematic.
    [Show full text]
  • Dawn of the Reformation Vol 1
    THE DAWN OF THE REFORMATION BY HERBERT B. WORKMAN, MA. VOL. I THE AGE OF WYCLIF London: CHARLES H. KELLY 2, CASTLE ST., CITY RD.; AND 26, PATERNOSTER ROW, E.C. 1901 OCR and formatting by William H. Gross www.onthewing.org Nov 2016 Page breaks have been adjusted for readability (widow/orphan) PREFACE I HAVE entitled this little work The Dawn of the Reformation. My purpose is to trace the various influences and forces both within and without the Church, which produced the great revolution of the sixteenth century. At what hour" dawn" begins is always a matter of dispute, and depends largely on local circumstances. But one thing is certain. A new day has begun long before the average worker has commenced his toil. So with the Reformation. The study of its causes cannot commence with Erasmus or Savonarola; its methods and results were to some extent settled for it in the century before Luther or Cranmer. My narrow limits have compelled me to omit many things of interest, and to compress into a few lines others which demanded as many pages. viii PREFACE I have constantly realised that to write a small history is more difficult than to write one of larger margins. In what I have included, as well as in what I have omitted, the understanding of the Reformation and its causes has alone had weight. If it be objected that I have given a disproportionate space to Wyclif, or made him bulk larger than he did in his own day, I must plead that his life has scarcely received the attention it deserves.
    [Show full text]
  • Aristocratic Identities in the Roman Senate from the Social War to the Flavian Dynasty
    Aristocratic Identities in the Roman Senate From the Social War to the Flavian Dynasty By Jessica J. Stephens A dissertation submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy (Greek and Roman History) in the University of Michigan 2016 Doctoral Committee: Professor David Potter, chair Professor Bruce W. Frier Professor Richard Janko Professor Nicola Terrenato [Type text] [Type text] © Jessica J. Stephens 2016 Dedication To those of us who do not hesitate to take the long and winding road, who are stars in someone else’s sky, and who walk the hillside in the sweet summer sun. ii [Type text] [Type text] Acknowledgements I owe my deep gratitude to many people whose intellectual, emotional, and financial support made my journey possible. Without Dr. T., Eric, Jay, and Maryanne, my academic career would have never begun and I will forever be grateful for the opportunities they gave me. At Michigan, guidance in negotiating the administrative side of the PhD given by Kathleen and Michelle has been invaluable, and I have treasured the conversations I have had with them and Terre, Diana, and Molly about gardening and travelling. The network of gardeners at Project Grow has provided me with hundreds of hours of joy and a respite from the stress of the academy. I owe many thanks to my fellow graduate students, not only for attending the brown bags and Three Field Talks I gave that helped shape this project, but also for their astute feedback, wonderful camaraderie, and constant support over our many years together. Due particular recognition for reading chapters, lengthy discussions, office friendships, and hours of good company are the following: Michael McOsker, Karen Acton, Beth Platte, Trevor Kilgore, Patrick Parker, Anna Whittington, Gene Cassedy, Ryan Hughes, Ananda Burra, Tim Hart, Matt Naglak, Garrett Ryan, and Ellen Cole Lee.
    [Show full text]
  • Hacettepe University Faculty of Letters Department of English Language and Literature Course Syllabus
    Hacettepe University Faculty of Letters Department of English Language and Literature Course Syllabus Title of the Course IED 151 (03) Introduction to Britain I Year and Term 2017-2018 Autumn Class Hours Mondays – 9.00-12.00 Classroom B8-B03 Office Hours Mondays – 13.30-15.30 & Tuesdays – 9.30-11.30 E-Mail [email protected] / [email protected] I. Course Objective: The aim of the course is to make a survey of Britain and British literature in its historical context. In line with this, the historical evolution of British society and literature from the early ages to the 17th century will be explored through the study of major social, political, and historical developments together with their reflections in the works of literature dating from the mentioned period. II. Course Outline (based on three classes per week): Week I (25 Sep.) General Introduction: Geography, Nationalities (England, Scotland, Wales, Northern Ireland), Ethnic Minorities Week II (02 Oct.) Early Britain - The Social and Cultural History of British Society in the Early Middle Ages: The Celts, the Romans, Asterix in Britain (1986) Week III (9 Oct.) The Saxons, Christianity, Paganism, the Vikings, Vicky the Viking (2009) Week IV (16 Oct.) The Outline of Medieval Literature - Major Literary Works: Beowulf, The Dream of the Rood, The Battle of Maldon Week V (23 Oct.) Midterm I Week VI (30 Oct.) England in the Middle Ages: The Norman Conquest, Feudalism, The Mists of Avalon (2001) Week VII (06 Nov.) The Government, Political Developments (Magna Carta), the Church,
    [Show full text]
  • The Life of the Poet
    The Life of the Poet No one knows who wrote Piers Plowman, and if someone named William Langland did so, no one knows anything certain about him.1 The only evi- dence for that name’s association with the poem comes from three notes that readers penned into the pastedowns (the inside covers) of two me- dieval manuscripts. These short, spontaneous glosses, read together with the few references in the poem to the narrator as “Will,” provide the only grounds for attributing the poem to a named author. The first note, dated ca. 1400, in a manuscript ofPiers Plowman from Gloucestershire but discovered in Ireland (Dublin, Trinity College, MS D.4.1), reads: Memorandum, quod Stacy de Rokayle, pater Willielmi de Langlond, qui Stacius fuit generosus et morabatur in Schiptone under Whic- wode, Tenens domini le Spenser in comitatu Oxon., qui praedic- tus Willielmus fecit librum qui vocatur Perys Ploughman. (Adams, Rokele Family 19) It was Stacy de Rokayle who was William de Langlond’s father; this Stacy was of gentle birth and lived in Shipton-under-Wychwood in Oxfordshire, holding land from Lord le Spenser; the aforesaid Wil- liam wrote the book called Piers Plowman. (Kane, ODNB 488)2 The other notes are found in a manuscript now in the Huntington Library, Hm 128. One, penned by Tudor historian John Bale, offers information similar to that of the Dublin manuscript but gives a different first name for the poet: 2 • An Introduction to Piers Plowman Robertus Langlande natus in comitatu Salopie in villa Mortymers Clybery in the claylande, within .viij.
    [Show full text]
  • Robert Graves the White Goddess
    ROBERT GRAVES THE WHITE GODDESS IN DEDICATION All saints revile her, and all sober men Ruled by the God Apollo's golden mean— In scorn of which I sailed to find her In distant regions likeliest to hold her Whom I desired above all things to know, Sister of the mirage and echo. It was a virtue not to stay, To go my headstrong and heroic way Seeking her out at the volcano's head, Among pack ice, or where the track had faded Beyond the cavern of the seven sleepers: Whose broad high brow was white as any leper's, Whose eyes were blue, with rowan-berry lips, With hair curled honey-coloured to white hips. Green sap of Spring in the young wood a-stir Will celebrate the Mountain Mother, And every song-bird shout awhile for her; But I am gifted, even in November Rawest of seasons, with so huge a sense Of her nakedly worn magnificence I forget cruelty and past betrayal, Careless of where the next bright bolt may fall. FOREWORD am grateful to Philip and Sally Graves, Christopher Hawkes, John Knittel, Valentin Iremonger, Max Mallowan, E. M. Parr, Joshua IPodro, Lynette Roberts, Martin Seymour-Smith, John Heath-Stubbs and numerous correspondents, who have supplied me with source- material for this book: and to Kenneth Gay who has helped me to arrange it. Yet since the first edition appeared in 1946, no expert in ancient Irish or Welsh has offered me the least help in refining my argument, or pointed out any of the errors which are bound to have crept into the text, or even acknowledged my letters.
    [Show full text]
  • Langland, William (C. 1325–C. 1390), Poet | Oxford Dictionary of National Biography
    Oxford Dictionary of National Biography Langland, William (c. 1325–c. 1390) George Kane https://doi.org/10.1093/ref:odnb/16021 Published in print: 23 September 2004 Published online: 23 September 2004 Langland, William (c. 1325–c. 1390), poet, is known from only three sources. These are a Latin memorandum of about 1400 on the last leaf of an unfinished copy of his poem The Vision of Piers Plowman made about the same time (TCD, MS D.4.1 (212)), a cluster of sixteenth-century ascriptions by the antiquary John Bale (d. 1563), and the poem itself. Origins Even the memorandum seems primarily about Langland's parentage, as if this were the object of interest: It was Stacy de Rokayle who was William de Langlond's father; this Stacy was of gentle birth and lived in Shipton- under-Wychwood in Oxfordshire, holding land from Lord le Spenser; the aforesaid William wrote the book called Piers Plowman. Dublin, Trinity College, MS D.4.1 (212) The memorandum is authenticated by knowledgeable local annals dated from 1294 to 1348 in the same hand above it on the page, with clear interest in the Despensers. Extension of that interest to include the poet's family is indicated by a recent discovery (Matheson) that his grandfather Peter de Rokele had been in the service of Hugh le Despenser the younger, indeed had several times been violently and unlawfully active in his interest, and that, having in April 1327 been pardoned for 'adhering' to Despenser, he was within months implicated in a conspiracy to release the captive Edward II.
    [Show full text]
  • Indian Princess and Roman Goddess: the First Fetuale Symbols of America
    Indian Princess and Roman Goddess: The First FeTuale Symbols of America JOHNHIGHAM KCAUSE America was bom in the mind of Europe, the marks ofthat origin have always been strong on the symbols B of its identity. The earliest allegorical images ofthe New World were almost wholly conventional reworkings of European memories: their patent lack of authenticity brings us today a shock of nonrecognition. Eventually, Americans themselves took charge of their symbols, which then acquired a more native inflection. In the long run, however, distinctiveness and separateness have been less pronounced in the visual language of American nationalism than we ordinarily suppose. None of the major embodiments of an American identity is understandable apart from its transatlantic origins, and none in its essential character has belonged to this country alone. The European invention of America occurred, of course, through symbols, and among the earliest were lines on a map. America had to be conceived as a place before it could acquire a ftirther meaning. Maps alone, however, are only empty diagrams. Along with the abstract proportionalities of maps, early modem people craved concrete depictions of what they could not see di- This paper, in a slightly different form, was presented at the semiannual meedng of the American Antiquarian Society held at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology on April iS, !(//>. JOHN HIGH AM is professor emeritus of history at The Johns Hopkins University. Copyright © i (;<;o hy American Antiquarian Society 45 ¿ßi'' American Antiquarian Society rectly. And between the two, connecting immediate representa- tions of sensory experience with some underlying scheme of mean- ing, they wanted imaginative symbols to infuse visible objects with ideal truths.
    [Show full text]