The Judaizers
Judaize – “To live like a Jew” (Galatians 2:14), or “To make someone live like a Jew” Judaizer – “One who Judaizes others”
On The One Hand… Jesus was a Jew. “The Twelve Apostles” & “The Seventy Disciples” were all Jews. Jesus commissioned the Twelve (and the Seventy) to evangelize Jews only. (Matthew 10:5; cf. Luke 10). The earliest believers in the Gospel were all Jews. The early Church consisted of Jewish believers. The early Church used the Jewish Scriptures as the inspired & authoritative Word of God. The early Church only evangelized Jews. (Acts 11:19)
On The Other Hand… The Abrahamic Covenant anticipated the evangelization of Gentiles. (Genesis 12:3; 22:18; 26:4; 28:14) The Great Commission of Jesus mandated the evangelization of Gentiles. (Matthew 28:18-20) God called Peter to evangelize the Gentiles specifically. (Acts 10:1-11:18) After Peter opened the door, other Jewish believers specifically evangelized Gentiles. (Acts 11:20-26)
The Origin of the Heresy In AD 47 (a Jewish Sabbatical Year), Pharisees within the Church at Jerusalem, travelled to the Church at Antioch, Syria, and falsely represented that the Apostle James (Jesus’ half-brother & leader of the Church at Jerusalem) expected these Gentiles to proselytize to Judaism (by being circumcised & keeping the Law of Moses). Peter, who was in Antioch at the time, caved in to their pressure, and withdrew his fellowship from those Gentile believers who had not proselytized. Because of Peter’s poor example, Barnabas also withdrew his fellowship. The Apostles Paul immediately & publicly denounced their misrepresentation of the Gospel message. (Acts 15:1-2; Galatians 2:11-16)
The Inspired Response The Church at Antioch sent Barnabas & Paul (who took along with them his student, the uncircumcised Gentile believer, Titus) to the Church at Jerusalem to resolve the issue. The Pharisee believers presented their case. A repentant Peter gave his input. Barnabas & Paul gave testimony about their work among the uncircumcised Gentiles. James summed everything up with some Scripture and then offered the inspired response which was then formulated into a circular letter that should have ended the matter. (Acts 15:2-35; Galatians 2:1-11)
The Persistence of the Heresy was Addressed by Paul Paul’s Letter to the Galatians (AD 48) was specifically written about the issue. Paul’s Letter to the Romans (AD 57 or 58) touches upon the issue, especially Chapters 14-15. Paul’s Letter to the Philippians (AD 61 or 62) warns against the Judaizers in Chapter 3. Paul’s First Letter to Timothy (c. AD 63) alludes to this heresy in Chapter 4. Paul’s Letter to Titus (c. AD 63) also alludes to this heresy in Chapters 1 & 3.
Early Versions of this Heresy
The Ebionites (Hebrew for “Poor Ones”)1 Taught that the Law was binding on those believing in Jesus Considered Paul an apostate from the Law and therefore rejected his writings Used only the Gospel of Matthew (as they understood it) o While one group of Ebionites accepted the “Virgin Birth,” another rejected this doctrine o The Ebionites distinguished between the man “Jesus” & the “Spirit of Christ” who only dwelt within Jesus from immersion to death Oddly enough, it was an Ebionite priest who encouraged Muhammed’s early teaching during the early 600s
The Nazarenes of the 4th Century (Jordan, Iraq & Iran) were basically Ebionites who accepted the Virgin Birth
The Pasagians of 12th & 13th Centuries (Lombardy, northern Italy), were basically Ebionites who thought that Jesus was the highest created being through whom everything else was created
Modern Versions of this Heresy
Seventh Day Baptists Originated in England, during the early 1600s Came to Rhode Island during the middle 1600s & spread from there
Seventh Day Adventists Adventism arose out of Baptist “Second Coming” Cult in the 1840s They accepted the teaching of Ellen G. White during the 1860s A core group of these Adventists adopted a strict form of Sabbatarianism
Church of God (Seventh Day) is a version of Seventh-Day Adventism which rejected the teachings of Ellen G. White
World-wide Church of God is a version of the Church of God (Seventh Day) which accepted the teaching of Herbert W. Armstrong during the 1930s-1990s. Armstrong taught a form of British- Israelism (that the British people are ethnic Israelis & therefore the object of Biblical prophecy).
1 Irenaeus, Against Heresies, Book 1, Chapter 26, Paragraphs 1-2