Matthew S. Meyer Richard E. Hall, AICP County Executive General Manager
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Matthew S. Meyer Richard E. Hall, AICP County Executive General Manager Department of Land Use HISTORIC REVIEW BOARD October 6, 2020 5:00 p.m. Business Meeting Agenda Updated 9/28/2020 ZOOM Video Conference beginning at 5:00 P.M. In accordance with Governor Carney’s Proclamation and the Declaration of a State of Emergency, New Castle County is holding all public meetings as telephone and video conferences, utilizing Zoom Meetings until further notice. The appropriate weblink, call-in number(s) can be found at the Historic Review Board Webpage: newcastlede.gov/313/Historic-Review-Board HRB meetings are held on the 1st (Business Meeting) and 3rd (Hearing) Tuesdays of each month. ROLL CALL RULE OF PROCEDURE MEETING MINUTES September 1, 2020 Meeting Minutes OLD BUSINESS NEW BUSINESS Case No. 2019-08887: 706 New London Road. (Located on the east side of New London Road, south of the intersection with Wedgewood Road.) (TP 09-005.00-074). White Clay Creek Hundred. Code violation case for interior work and demolition without a permit. William Kennedy Post Office and Store ca. 1860. NC21 Zoning. CD 3. App. 2020-05988: 904 Old Baltimore Pike. (Located on the west side of Dayett Mill Road, south of the intersection with Old Baltimore Pike.) (TP 11-014.00-044). Pencader Hundred. Demolition permit to demolish two non- contributing structures located within the Cooch’s Bridge Historic District. I Zoning. CD 11. App. 2020-06221: 10 & 12 Pyles Lane. (Located on the south side of Pyles Lane, east of the intersection with New Castle Avenue.) (TPs 10-005.20-135 & 10-005.20-136). New Castle Hundred. Demolition permit to demolish a ca. 1900 duplex. NC5 zoning. CD 10. App. 2017-0666-S: 5300 Kennett Pike. (Located on the west side of Kennett Pike, north of the intersection with Pyles Ford Road.) (TP 07-012.00-018). Christiana Hundred. Minor subdivision plan to subdivide an existing parcel into two lots and convert an existing barn to a dwelling. Wm. Peters Ag. Complex (Beers) located along the Brandywine National Scenic Byway. NC2a Zoning. CD 2. App. 2019-11735: 2203 W Newport Pike. (Located on the north side of W. Newport Pike, at the northwest corner of the intersection with Stanton Road, W Newport Pike, and Rock Avenue). Mill Creek Hundred. (TP 08-051.10-035). Demolition permit to demolish a ca. 1800 dwelling. NC5 Zoning. CD 9. REPORT OF THE PRESERVATION PLANNER REPORT OF THE CHAIR 87 Reads Way, New Castle, DE 19720 www.nccdelu.org Phone: 302-395-5400 Fax: 302-395-5587 PUBLIC COMMENT …………………………………………………………………………… Individuals needing reasonable accommodations according to the Americans with Disabilities Act call 395-5400 (TT/TTY/TTD: DRS, 1-800-232-5460) MINUTES BUSINESS MEETING NEW CASTLE COUNTY HISTORIC REVIEW BOARD DEPARTMENT OF LAND USE - NEW CASTLE ROOM 87 READS WAY, NEW CASTLE, DELAWARE September 1, 2020 5:00 P.M. The Virtual Business Meeting of the Historic Review Board of New Castle County was held on Tuesday, September 1, 2020 via Zoom meetings. The meeting was called to order by John Davis at [5:02 p.m.] The following Board members were present: Perry Patel Karen Anderson Barbara Silber Rafael Zahralddin John Davis John Brook The following Board members were absent: Steve Johns Historic Review Board, Department of Law Colleen Norris The following Department of Land Use employees were present at the meeting: Betsy Hatch Chris Jackson RULES OF PROCEDURE Ms. Hatch read the rules of procedure into the record. MINUTES & NOTICE OF DECISIONS August 4, 2020 Business Meeting Minutes On a motion made by Mr. Patel and seconded by Mr. Zahralddin, the HRB voted to approve the August 4, 2020 Historic Review Board meeting minutes (In Favor: Silber, Davis, Patel, Zahralddin; In Opposition: None; Abstention: Brook; Absent: Anderson, Johns. Discussion preceding the vote included: Mr. Brook stated that he was not present for the meeting and noted that on the first item under old business should be updated to reflect that he did not accept a motion. Ms. Silber noted that she had an edit to the Section 106 language on page 3. OLD BUSINESS App. 2019-0676-S: 4353 Summit Bridge Road. (East side of Summit Bridge Road, 2,500 feet north of Boyds Corner Road.) (TP 13-007-00-078). St. Georges Hundred. Historic Overlay rezoning and associated parking plan for an adaptive reuse of the A. Eliason House, listed on the National Register of Historic Places, constructed ca. 1856. NC21 Zoning. CD 12. At a meeting held on September 1, 2020, the Historic Review Board considered the application, public testimony provided at its August 18, 2020 public hearing, as well as the recommendation provided by the Department. On a motion made by Mr. Brook and seconded by Mr. Patel, the Historic Review Board voted unanimously to grant APPROVAL of the of the landscape plan and scope of work to be completed by a certified archaeologist. Discussion preceding the vote included the following: Ms. Hatch gave a brief presentation on the application and provided a recap of the public hearing. Ms. Hatch informed the Historic Review Board that the applicant had contracted with a professional archaeologist and provided the scope of work to be completed on the site. Ms. Silber commended the applicant on the project, noting that the pool demolition is an unusual situation and noted that the surface observation by the archaeologist will satisfy the condition. Ms. Anderson noted that the information provided by the applicant was well documented regarding the landscaping and lighting on the site. Ms. Hatch noted that the archaeological report would be shared with the Historic Review Board. App. 2018-05785: 2314 Glasgow Avenue. (West side of Glasgow Ave., north of the intersection of Glasgow Ave. and Pulaski Hwy.) Pencader Hundred, (TP 11-026.00-043). Building Permit to renovate historic barn (Brooks House, c.1795). NC10, CR, and Historic Overlay Zoning. CD 11. At a meeting held on September 1, 2020, the Historic Review Board considered the application, public testimony provided at its August 18, 2020 public hearing, as well as the recommendation provided by the Department of Land Use. On a motion made by Mr. Brook and seconded by Mr. Patel, the Historic Review Board voted unanimously to DENY the proposed permit as the proposed materials are inconsistent with the New Castle County Historic and Cultural Resource Design Guidelines for exterior modifications, as well as the surrounding National Register Historic District. The Historic Review Board recommended the applicant bring forward different materials that maintain historic character and nature of the building. Discussion preceding the vote included the following: Ms. Hatch gave a brief presentation on the application and read into the record the Staff Recommendation. Mr. Davis confirmed with Staff that the Historic Review Board has the ability to deny the proposed materials for the exterior of the structure, as the property was located with the bounds of an Historic overlay zoning district. Mr. Brook noted that the staff is following the required design guidelines and asked Staff if they had talked with the applicants about alternative materials. Ms. Hatch noted that the Department had talked with the applicants regarding what materials are appropriate based on the proposed design guidelines; however, the applicants wished to proceed with the T1-11 siding. Mr. Brook stated that the Historic Review Board is charged with ensuring that Historic overlay properties follow the appropriate design guidelines. Mr. Zahralddin concurred, noting the applicants had not demonstrated why they would not consider higher quality materials that align with the NCC Historic and Cultural Resource Design Guidelines. NEW BUSINESS None. REPORT OF THE PRESERVATION PLANNER Ms. Hatch noted that the demolition permit for 565 Walker School Road was not on the agenda this evening, as the Staff has been trying to work with both the DE Division of Fish and Wildlife and the DE Division of Historic and Cultural Affairs for an update on the application prior to bringing it back before the Historic Review Board for consideration. Ms. Hatch noted that the Department is continuing to work on the Historic Marker Program proposed by Councilwoman Durham and noted that the Department is close to ironing out final details. Finally, Ms. Hatch stated that the next meeting would be on September 15, 2020 at 5:00 pm. Mr. Patel asked if there was an update on the demolition application for 2203 W Newport Pike. Ms. Hatch stated that the Department is meeting with the engineer and the legal counsel in the upcoming week regarding the application. Ms. Hatch stated the County is also considering utilizing Certified Local Government Grant funds to have the structure documented. Ms. Hatch stated the application should be appearing before the HRB at its October business meeting. REPORT OF THE CHAIRPERSON None. COMMENTS FROM THE PUBLIC None. ADJOURNMENT The Board voted to adjourn the meeting at 6:31 p.m. ATTEST: Richard E. Hall, AICP John R. Davis General Manager Chairperson Department of Land Use Historic Review Board MID-ATLANTIC HISTORIC BUILDINGS AND LANDSCAPES SURVEY Assessment of the Impact to Significance for the William Kennedy House and Store White Clay Creek Hundred New Castle County, Delaware 1 MID-ATLANTIC HISTORIC BUILDINGS AND LANDSCAPES SURVEY Assessment of the Impact to Significance for the William Kennedy House and Store (CRS # N04009) White Clay Creek Hundred New Castle County, Delaware By Catherine Morrissey, M.A. Prepared For New Castle County Department of Land Use Center for Historic Architecture and Design University of Delaware September 2020 2 The University of Delaware is committed to assuring equal opportunity to all persons and does not discriminate on the basis of race, color, gender, religion, ancestry, national origin, sexual orientation, veteran status, age, or disability in its educational programs, activities, admissions, or employment practices as required by Title IX of the Education Amendments of 1972, Title VI of the Civil Rights Act of 1964, the Rehabilitation Act of 1973, with the Americans with Disabilities Act, other applicable statutes, and University policy.