www.ukrweekly.com
INSIDE: • Ruslana Lyzhychko speaks in Washington — page 3. • On the road to Chornobyl — page 9. • “Extreme” skiing in Ukraine’s Carpathians — centerfold. HE KRAINIAN EEKLY T PublishedU by the Ukrainian National Association Inc., a fraternal non-profitW association Vol. LXXV No. 15 THE UKRAINIAN WEEKLY SUNDAY, APRIL 15, 2007 $1/$2 in Ukraine National University Political stalemate in Ukraine leads to talk of compromise by Zenon Zawada of Kyiv Mohyla Academy Kyiv Press Bureau KYIV – Caught in a stalemate, strengthens ties with U.S. President Viktor Yushchenko and Prime CHICAGO – The National University Minister Viktor Yanukovych have begun of Kyiv Mohyla Academy recently attempts at reaching compromise in enlarged its contacts and support in the Ukraine’s political crisis, privately United States through an information exchanging lists of proposals and negoti- campaign and fund-raising drive aimed ating points. at expanding the university’s programs In the most significant effort so far, with U.S. institutions and building a Mr. Yushchenko offered on April 10 to more financially secure base for the delay pre-term parliamentary elections future. beyond the scheduled May 27 date, A total of $350,000 was raised during which is widely viewed as unrealistic. a three-week period when the Kyiv He insisted, however, that pre-term elec- Mohyla Foundation of America hosted tions were the only way out of the crisis, the university president, Dr. Viacheslav and he said he expects concessions. Briukhovetsky, at events in the Ukrainian The overture didn’t impress Mr. communities of Washington, northern Yanukovych, who maintained the presi- dent should withdraw his April 2 decree New Jersey, Philadelphia, Detroit and UNIAN/Andrii Mosiyenko Chicago. to dismiss Parliament – which the prime minister described as unconstitutional – Verkhovna Rada Chairman Oleksander Moroz (left), Prime Minister Viktor Dr. Briukhovetsky also conducted Yanukovych (center) and Communist Party of Ukraine Chair Petro Symonenko meetings at Stanford University in or allow the Constitutional Court to review it and make a ruling. appear before tens of thousands of supporters on Independence Square during California, Georgetown University in an April 11 rally. Washington and Bard College in New “If the president repeals this decree, that will be the first step to calm socie- York. While Mr. Yanukovych continues to Stetsiuk, a Constitutional Court judge “We established new relationships of ty,” the prime minister said. “If he does- n’t do that, the consequences, which are stress the need for the Constitutional who was Our Ukraine’s parliamentary cooperation with these distinguished uni- Court to rule on the legality of the presi- appointment. versities. Developing personal contacts unknown, will be on his conscience.” While the president and prime minis- dent’s decree, it appeared increasingly This heavy pressure prompted Court (Continued on page 4) ter exchanged their confidential propos- doubtful the judges would issue a ruling Chair Ivan Dombrovskyi’s attempt to als, they continued rattling their swords anytime soon. resign, they said. in public and had their allies engage in Five Constitutional Court judges said The judges said they would not review further political posturing and maneuver- at an April 10 press conference that they the presidential decree until they were ing throughout government organs. were under persistent external pressure, provided with an environment enabling Yushchenko appeals Addressing more than 50,000 support- without directly identifying the source them to make an independent ruling. ers on Independence Square on April 11, but implying it was the coalition govern- They also asked the government to pro- for world recognition Mr. Yanukovych proposed that one of the ment. vide them with personal security guards. ways to resolve the crisis is to hold presi- “Brazen, public threats against the Judge Viktor Shyshkin, who was of the Holodomor dential elections and parliamentary elec- judges of the Constitutional Court – cer- appointed to the court by the president, tions at the same time. criticized the coalition government for KYIV – President Viktor tain political forces pressuring them with The next day, the president said there the goal of scaring them into directing planting its demonstrators in front of the Yushchenko on April 11 called on Constitutional Court and exacerbating an currently is no constitutional basis for the court’s decisions towards politicized world leaders to recognize the Great already tense political situation. holding pre-term presidential elections, approaches and passing decisions advan- Famine of 1932-1933 – known in Four of the five judges are western which could only take place in the event tageous for them – in our view, don’t Ukrainian as the Holodomor – as of his death, illness, resignation or Ukrainians, three of whom are presiden- genocide against the Ukrainian nation. allow us to make judicial rulings on the tial appointees, which caused suspicion impeachment for crimes. constitutional submission from the He asked world leaders to act before He criticized the coalition for refusing national deputies of Ukraine,” said Petro (Continued on page 8) the 75th anniversary of the Famine, to engage in constructive dialogue and which will be marked in 2008. for further pursuing its campaign to “As president of Ukraine, I am monopolize the Ukrainian government. calling on you to support the adop- tion of a United Nations resolution No money, no rulings to condemn Ukraine’s Holodomor At its April 11 session the Cabinet of and [I am calling on] parliamentari- Ministers issued a resolution refusing the ans from all over the world to president’s order to finance pre-term declare the Great Famine of 1932- elections, stating that the president’s 1933 an act of genocide against the decree violates Ukrainian law and that a people of Ukraine,” he said in his corresponding National Security and statement. He underscored that such Defense Council (NSDC) resolution vio- recognition would play a role in pre- lates the budget code. venting genocides in the future. Minister of Justice Oleksander President Yushchenko said Lavrynovych said the president should Ukraine appreciates the solidarity adhere to the parliamentary ruling that and support of the international com- his decree was unconstitutional. munity. “Our state is thankful to In response, NSDC Chair Vitalii Australia, Georgia, Estonia, Canada, Haiduk said the elections will be Lithuania, Poland, the United States financed by the state budget – an order of America and Hungary, whose par- that will be enforced by legal means. He (Continued on page 4) said the $68 million needed to conduct UNIAN/Oleksander Kosariev elections is in the budget’s reserve fund. Our Ukraine supporters march during April 11 demonstrations in Kyiv. 2 THE UKRAINIAN WEEKLY SUNDAY, APRIL 15, 2007 No. 15 ANALYSIS NEWSBRIEFSNEWSBRIEFS
Yushchenko radicalizes Court postpones its hearings President, law enforcement chiefs meet KYIV – The Constitutional Court of KYIV – President Viktor Yushchenko as political crisis deepens Ukraine has postponed hearings on the told an April 10 meeting of the heads of by Taras Kuzio police planted explosives in the offices of dissolution of the Verkhovna Rada until Ukrainian law enforcement agencies that Eurasia Daily Monitor Pora, a youth-oriented NGO, and accused April 17, Interfax reported on April 10. “all law enforcement and security agen- April 6 them of being “terrorists.” Also on April 10, five Constitutional cies should undertake a peacekeeping • Third, the cancellation of the popular Court judges complained about pressure mission and stay away from political On Monday, April 2, President Viktor “Toloka” television program on State exerted on them and asked for the state to conflicts,” Interfax reported, quoting Yushchenko issued a decree disbanding Channel 1 brought back memories of provide them with bodyguard services. Defense Minister Anatolii Hrytsenko. Parliament and plunging Ukraine into a media censorship. Ukraine’s security services have agreed to Mr. Hrytsenko also said that participants political crisis. Elections are set for May • Fourth, there was the contract killing on provide them with temporary protection. in the meeting did not discuss whether to 27 – before the Constitutional Court will March 28 of Maksym Kurochkin, head of The judges also said that they cannot introduce a state of emergency or rule on the legality of the decree. the pro-Yanukovych “Russian Club” during decide on high-profile cases unless there whether to beef up law enforcement and Mr. Yushchenko is a highly cautious the 2004 elections. His high-profile political are conditions that would allow unbiased security agencies to deal with the situa- and moderate politician who had previous- and business ties to the regime of former rulings. “The president of Ukraine has tion. According to Mr. Hrytsenko, two ly ruled out disbanding Parliament. Until President Leonid Kuchma complemented issued a decree to dissolve the Verkhovna groups are monitoring the activity of mid-March only the Yulia Tymoshenko Mr. Kurochkin’s links to organized crime. Rada within his constitutional authority. Ukrainian law-enforcement agencies: Bloc supported a call for early elections, Finally, there is also a personal factor. Regretfully, some well-known statesmen one operates on behalf of the president which were officially not due until March Mr. Yushchenko’s decision to disband and political figures are making prema- and is led by Vitalii Haiduk, the secretary 2011. In the two weeks prior to the decree, Parliament came after repeated provoca- ture statements that the decree is uncon- of the National Defense and Security Mr. Yushchenko, the Presidential tions against him from the Anti-Crisis stitutional, whereas the Constitution says Council, and the second acts on behalf of Secretariat, Our Ukraine and former Coalition and government. that only the Constitutional Court is the government and is led by Vice Prime Internal Affairs Minister Yurii Lutsenko, On numerous occasions the coalition and authorized to decide on the constitutional- Minister Volodymyr Radchenko. who heads the National Self-Defense, government have repeatedly and unneces- ity of the decree,” the judges said in a (RFE/RL Newsline) shifted to the Tymoshenko Bloc’s position. sarily embarrassed the president. These statement. The Constitutional Court con- Symonenko seeks president’s ouster There are at least five reasons for the included the unconstitutional dismissal of sists of 18 judges, appointed by the presi- shift. Foreign Affairs Minister Borys Tarasyuk, dent, the Parliament and the Council of KYIV – Petro Symonenko, leader of • First, a sense of déja vu surrounding refusal to accept the president’s choice for Judges, a nonpartisan judicial body, the Communist Party of Ukraine, is call- Anatolii Kinakh’s appointment as minister his replacement, the law on the Cabinet of which each name six. An effective ruling ing on supporters of the ruling coalition of the economy which echoes events in Ministers, the refusal to join the president’s requires the support of at least 10 judges. to demand the ouster of President Viktor 2002, when the pro-presidential majority constitutional commission to improve the (RFE/RL Newsline) Yushchenko. Speaking at a rally on bribed liberals and trade unionists to defect hastily adopted reforms, attempts at remov- Independence Square in Kyiv on April 4, from Our Ukraine. This gave President Yushchenko: court must be obeyed ing governors (oblast administration chair- he said the main slogan should be “Out Yushchenko his strongest legal argument men) and failure to implement the August KYIV – Viktor Yushchenko said on with Yushchenko and his Orange team.” that the ongoing “buying” of deputies was 2006 Universal of National Unity. April 10 that all political forces involved (Ukrayinski Novyny) altering the outcome of the 2006 elections. Threats to change the Constitution to in the Ukrainian governmental crisis Since April 2004 it has been illegal for make Russian a second state language should accept and honor, rather than dis- Rada wants presidential election… deputies to change factions. and the refusal to vote in favor of the law cuss, any future Constitutional Court rul- • Second, last month police raided Mr. KYIV – The Verkhovna Rada unani- on the 1933 Famine-Genocide damaged ing on the legality of the presidential Lutsenko’s apartment and arrested members mously adopted with the 258 votes of the relations with Mr. Yushchenko further. decree dissolving the Verkhovna Rada, of the National Self-Defense. Again, this ruling coalition an address to the These are emotional and non-negotiable Interfax reported. “I would like felt familiar, as weapons and explosives Ukrainian people on April 9 in which it issues for national democrats. Constitutional Court rulings to be obeyed were reportedly planted to incriminate them said it will agree to early parliamentary rather than discussed,” Mr. Yushchenko as alleged “terrorists.” In October 2004 the (Continued on page 14) elections if they are held concurrently said. “I am sure that this rule is applicable with a presidential election and a referen- to all sides,” he replied when asked dum on Ukraine’s accession to NATO, whether he himself will obey a ruling if Interfax reported the same day. “If elec- Compromise between President Yushchenko the Constitutional Court finds his decree tions are the only way to settle the con- unconstitutional. “Both the Constitution flict, we will insist on simultaneous pres- and its interpretation by the Constitutional idential elections and a referendum on and Yanukovych’s coalition: is it possible? Court should be respected by all parties to Ukraine’s NATO entry,” the address read. the process. This is one of the fundamental by Pavel Korduban sial decision to restore Serhii Kivalov, The parliamentarians who participated in preconditions for resolving any conflict, the vote reiterated their stance that the Eurasia Daily Monitor who had been blamed for trying to rig the including the conflict that is under way in April 10 2004 presidential elections in Mr. Ukraine today.” (RFE/RL Newsline) (Continued on page 15) Yanukovych’s favor, as chairman of the Ukrainian President Viktor Yushchenko Central Electoral Commission. has rejected calls for a truce from Prime Mr. Yushchenko, however, did not bend Minister Viktor Yanukovych and ignored the to pressure, so the coalition changed its tac- FOUNDED 1933 pacifying overtures made by Mr. tics and started to send pacifying signals. THE UKRAINIAN WEEKLY Yanukovych’s allies in Parliament last week. On April 4 Parliament changed the wording An English-language newspaper published by the Ukrainian National Association Inc., Mr. Yushchenko insists that his April 2 of its April 2 statement against the dissolu- decree to dissolve Parliament was in line a non-profit association, at 2200 Route 10, P.O. Box 280, Parsippany, NJ 07054. tion, removing from it the accusation Yearly subscription rate: $55; for UNA members — $45. with the Constitution and that an early against Mr. Yushchenko of “masterminding election to Parliament will take place on Periodicals postage paid at Parsippany, NJ 07054 and additional mailing offices. a coup.” Speaking on the same day, Mr. (ISSN — 0273-9348) May 27 despite the parliamentary majori- Yanukovych offered Mr. Yushchenko a ty’s disapproval. “zero option.” He said that his allies would It is not clear, however, how and with The Weekly: UNA: accept most of the president’s earlier Tel: (973) 292-9800; Fax: (973) 644-9510 Tel: (973) 292-9800; Fax: (973) 292-0900 what money the election will be conduct- demands, such as amendments to the law ed. The ruling coalition is boycotting it, on the Cabinet and making some of the Postmaster, send address changes to: Editor-in-chief: Roma Hadzewycz and the Finance Ministry says there is no provisions of the Yushchenko-drafted The Ukrainian Weekly Editors: money for it in the state coffers. Universal of National Unity of August 2200 Route 10 Zenon Zawada (Kyiv) The parliamentary majority’s initial 2006, in exchange for the withdrawal of the P.O. Box 280 Matthew Dubas reaction to President Yushchenko’s decree April 2 decree. Parsippany, NJ 07054 was highly emotional. The Coalition of Mr. Yanukovych made more compro- Prime Minister Yanukovych’s Party of the mise offers at his press conference on The Ukrainian Weekly Archive: www.ukrweekly.com; e-mail: [email protected] Regions (PRU), the Socialists and the April 5. He ruled out impeachment for Communists, protesting Mr. The Ukrainian Weekly, April 15, 2007 No. 15, Vol. LXXV Mr. Yushchenko and said that he had Copyright © 2007 The Ukrainian Weekly Yushchenko’s legally doubtful decree, asked Austrian Federal Chancellor Alfred made a series of controversial statements Gusenbauer to mediate efforts to settle ranging from accusations of power the Ukrainian crisis. The prime minister usurpation and calls for Mr. Yushchenko’s remained firm, however, on the point of ADMINISTRATION OF THE UKRAINIAN WEEKLY AND SVOBODA impeachment to instructions to the early elections. He said that his allies Procurator General’s Office to open a would recognize them only if the Walter Honcharyk, administrator (973) 292-9800, ext. 3041 criminal case into the “abuse of office” by Constitutional Court finds that the presi- e-mail: [email protected] President Yushchenko, to threats of crimi- dential decree was legitimate. Maria Oscislawski, advertising manager (973) 292-9800, ext. 3040 nal responsibility against those state offi- On April 6 the pro-Yanukovych coali- e-mail: [email protected] cials who complied with Mr. tion showed yet more readiness to sur- Mariyka Pendzola, subscriptions (973) 292-9800, ext. 3042 Yushchenko’s “criminal orders.” e-mail: [email protected] Parliament also took a highly controver- (Continued on page 16) No. 15 THE UKRAINIAN WEEKLY SUNDAY, APRIL 15, 2007 3 Ruslana Lyzhychko speaks at Woodrow Wilson Center in D.C. by Violetta Tutunik and expressed her commitment to preserving and pro- U.S.-Ukraine Foundation moting Ukraine’s ethnic heritage as a prerequisite to Ukraine finding its own ideology, stability and recogni- WASHINGTON – Ukrainian National Deputy tion by the international community. In addition, Ms. Ruslana Lyzhychko gave a presentation on “Leading Lyzhychko emphasized the need to mobilize the youth Ukraine into a New Era of Global and European as the future generation of progressive, pro-Western Citizenship” at the Woodrow Wilson International leaders who will be the key to a truly democratic Center for Scholars on March 30. The event was co- Ukraine. sponsored by the U.S.-Ukraine Foundation, the Kennan During the question and answer session, Ms. Institute of the Woodrow Wilson International Center Lyzhychko was asked about her involvement in for Scholars and the Children of Chornobyl Relief and Ukraine’s anti-human trafficking campaign, her activity Development Fund. with the Children of Chornobyl Relief and Development A UNICEF goodwill ambassador and winner of Fund, and her work with UNICEF. Eurovision 2004, Ms. Lyzhychko, a member of the Our Nadia McConnell, president of the U.S.-Ukraine Ukraine faction, emphasized the need to integrate Foundation, asked Ms. Lyzhychko to explain how she Ukraine into the Euro-Atlantic community through envisions a shift in the Ukrainian government from the membership in the North Atlantic Treaty Organization current struggle for power to a situation where the gov- (NATO), the World Trade Organization (WTO) and the ernment will be more focused on resolving the numer- European Union (EU). She discussed issues such as ous issues that were identified by Ms. Lyzhychko. human trafficking problems in Ukraine, her involvement Ms. Lyzhychko acknowledged that strong forces of with UNICEF, her campaign against drugs, her promo- instability exist in Ukraine. Nevertheless, she reassured tion of Ukrainian language and culture, her new “Wild the audience that President Yushchenko has played and Energy” initiative and the current political situation in is continuing to play a vital role in the efforts to stabilize Ukraine. the situation at hand. She said she believes that Mr. After introductory welcoming remarks by Renata Yushchenko will find a way to compromise with the Heidi Fancher/Woodrow Wilson Center Kosc-Harmatiy, program associate at the Kennan destabilizing forces and work on ways to resolve prob- Institute, and Dr. Oleh Shamshur, Ukraine’s ambassador lematic issues such as conflicts over NATO, energy and Ruslana Lyzhychko at the Woodrow Wilson Center. to the United States, Ms. Lyzhychko shared her vision language. Deputy Lyzhychko said that she does not of the future of Ukraine and described her efforts to pro- believe those issues are of primary concern, but that Ukraine. mote a positive image of Ukraine in the international maintaining unity in Ukraine is most urgent. She urged In regard to Russia, Ms. Lyzhychko stated that she community as well as within Ukraine. all politicians of Ukraine to unite and find common has a positive view of Russia and that problematic It is essential for Ukraine to develop its own ideology ground to resolve the current impediments to stability. issues between the two countries should be worked out as an independent state, said Ms. Lyzhychko. In order to When asked about her view of Ukrainians’ position diplomatically and not via provocative statements of accomplish this, it is important to promote the richness on NATO and the European Union, Ms. Lyzhychko said any kind. of Ukrainian culture in Ukraine as well as abroad. Ms. there is an overwhelming need to inform the Ukrainian The entire webcast of Ms. Lyzhychko’s “Leading Lyzhychko has made many efforts in pursuit of this by people about the actual responsibilities of NATO and the Ukraine into a New Era of Global and European taking advantage of opportunities during her travels as a European Union and the benefits associated with Euro- Citizenship” is available to view online at: singer and winner of Eurovision, and has used her popu- Atlantic integration. http://www.wilsoncenter.org/index.cfm?topic_id=1424 larity to promote a political message about Ukraine as To facilitate this task, Ms. Lyzhychko has established &fuseaction=topics.event_summary&event_id=230383 well as the humanitarian efforts in which she is a committee on European integration and currently Deputy Lyzhychko’s presentation at the Woodrow involved. Through efforts such as integrating Ukrainian chairs a subcommittee on information, which deals with Wilson International Center for Scholars was part of a culture into her music and organizing yearly expeditions informational outreach. However, funds are limited and four-day visit to the United States, which included to the Carpathian Mountains, Ms. Lyzhychko explained she doubts the proper allocation of these funds. She pro- meetings with the U.S. Department of State, the that she hopes to keep Ukrainian culture flourishing. posed that a professional approach to information out- Coalition for a Secure and Democratic Ukraine and the She reiterated her support for President Viktor reach is necessary in order to ensure that quality infor- International Organization for Migration, as well as a Yushchenko and Ukraine’s pro-Euro-Atlantic stance, mation about the EU and NATO reaches the people of performance at the Slavic Festival in Washington.
Ruslana meets with Coalition Quotable notes for Secure and Democratic Ukraine “ …We will never accept any ultimatums that are outside the bounds of the law and the Constitution. … If the president subscribes to the principles of democracy, and if he adheres to by Marta Matselioukh new stars in politics” by fostering them, then he should know the principles of how they work. The choice of the Ukrainian peo- U.S.-Ukraine Foundation democratic values among the ple does not depend on the point of view of the president. He should honor it. Thus he should youth of Ukraine. Quality educa- also honor the representatives of the Ukrainian people – those who were elected by the people. tion would enable new progres- WASHINGTON – Members of And the decisions made today by the government are aimed strictly at the betterment of the sive leaders to become vibrant lives of our people. the Coalition for a Secure and members of the future political Democratic Ukraine met with “Today we call upon both the president and the opposition to build our country with us, to order, she noted. Ruslana Lyzhychko, member of work for the improvement in the lives of our people, and to build a strong country. Therefore I Ms. Lyzhychko underscored the Ukraine’s Verkhovna Rada, to dis- call upon all of you to act in peace and unity. Only this can be our future. The unity of the importance of cultivating cuss the political, economic, and Ukrainian people, of this hard-working people, opens the way to the future. Anything else is Ukrainian culture and promoting a social issues currently facing impossible. …” positive image of Ukraine domes- Ukraine. The meeting was held on March 30 at the U.S.-Ukraine tically and abroad. She also noted – Prime Minister Viktor Yanukovych, speaking at an April 2 rally on Kyiv’s European Foundation’s office in how impressed she was with Square, as translated by The Ukraine List. Washington. American patriotism and said that Ms. Lyzhychko, a member of she would like to “see as many the Our Ukraine faction in flags in Ukraine as in the United “Our country has again been brought onto the brink of serious turmoil. A group of radical- Parliament, addressed a variety of States,” commensurate with the ly minded politicians, who have called themselves the united opposition, is seeking to trans- issues at the meeting, including a Orange Revolution times. form their own internal problems and unfulfilled power ambitions into a full scale political NATO information campaign in The Coalition for a Secure and battle. Ukraine, the confrontation Democratic Ukraine is the succes- “Not thinking about the possible repercussions of their actions, they are prepared to deprive between the Yushchenko adminis- sor to the Jackson-Vanik society of stability and civil peace but also to put in question the very existence of Ukrainian tration, on the one hand, and the Graduation Coalition, and has statehood. … government and Rada majority assigned priority to promoting the “We witness how political adventurers are trying to turn President [Viktor] Yushchenko into coalition, on the other, the possi- U.S. Congress-Verkhovna Rada a hostage in this irresponsible affair. Through blackmail and undisguised threats of a new bility of new Verkhovna Rada partnership, supporting Ukraine’s maidan, he is being pushed to sign an unconstitutional decree on the dissolution of the elections, and the Ukrainian lan- integration into the Euro-Atlantic Verkhovna Rada. guage issue. community, and promoting “The Verkhovna Rada unequivocally states that there are no legal grounds to call snap elec- Emphasis was placed on the Ukraine’s market reform, demo- tions and dissolve the current Parliament that was elected in free and fair elections in accor- need to develop a strong democra- cratic development and energy dance with democratic norms. … cy in Ukraine and overcome all efficiency. The U.S.-Ukraine “The Verkhovna Rada is categorically opposed to any attempts to discredit and defame the obstacles that are currently inter- Foundation serves as the secretari- highest representative body of the people. It is opposed to the attempts to pressure the presi- fering with that goal. Specifically, at of the coalition. dent, trying to use his authority to carry out anti-constitutional acts in the interests of certain Ms. Lyzhychko highlighted the For more information, or to join opportunistic politicians in order to destabilize the socio-political situation in the country, urgent need to address the stability the Coalition for a Secure and which can cause irreparable damage. …” factor in Ukraine today and to Democratic Ukraine, readers may unify the country as a whole. contact Marta Matselioukh at mar- – The Verkhovna Rada’s April 2 address to the people of Ukraine, as translated by The In addition, Ms. Lyzhychko [email protected] or at 202-223- Ukraine List. called for the “need to cultivate 2228. 4 THE UKRAINIAN WEEKLY SUNDAY, APRIL 15, 2007 No. 15
This achievement represents a major National University... recognition for Ukraine in the legal aca- Hryhorii Nestor turns 116, (Continued from page 1) demic field. Many of Kyiv Mohyla Law and establishing academic legitimacy School’s graduates are working in top enters Ukraine’s record books through the success of our students, fac- international and Ukrainian law firms, ulty and graduates is of utmost impor- and in the government and ministries. tance. It opens the doors to acceptance One of Ukraine’s former vice ministers and acknowledgment of the international of justice is a graduate of the Kyiv academic community and ensures aca- Mohyla Law School. demic freedom and autonomy in Foundation expresses gratitude Ukraine. Thanks to the support of the Ukrainian communities in the U.S., we Marta Farion, elected president at the are able to continue in this direction,” Dr. Kyiv Mohyla Foundation’s recent annual Briukhovetsky commented. meeting, said, “The fund-raising drive Accompanying Dr. Briukhovetsky to brought out hundreds of supporters in the several of the events was the founda- various communities during cold and tion’s co-chairman, Ambassador snowy winter weekends and raised William Green Miller, who said, “the $350,000 – and we are very grateful. generous response to the appeal for sup- The support of individuals, organizations port of Kyiv Mohyla Academy is proof and financial institutions in the that the key to a prosperous future for an Ukrainian community has been generous independent democratic Ukraine depends and is highly valued, and acknowledge- upon the quality of its leadership. The ment and appreciation of donations and a old leadership is passing and the future list of donors will be presented in the will be in the hands of a new leadership near future.” from the generation now in university.” She added that the funds will be trans- He continued: “Kyiv Mohyla Academy ferred for designated uses at the universi- is dedicated to the best possible education ty and a report will be issued. for the highest quality of qualified youth “The cooperation and assistance of the and its new curriculum is designed to Ukrainian National Association and the enable them to lead a new nation. Kyiv directors of Ukrainian cultural centers in each community, as well as friends made UNIAN/Oleksander Baran Mohyla Academy is already regarded as one of the best – if not the best – universi- the fund-raising tour possible,” Ms. Hryhorii Nestor, unofficially the world’s oldest man, celebrated his 116th Farion underscored. birthday on March 15 in the village of Staryi Yarychiv in the Lviv Oblast. ty in Ukraine. This position is in large measure due to the enlightened direction Ms. Farion noted that “much more of its president, Viacheslav Briukhovetsky, remains to be done, and some very excit- by Larysa Marchuk Mother of God will be your advocate. and the excellent faculty he has put togeth- ing university projects are ahead of us.” When I pass away, hold on to the icon.” Special to The Ukrainian Weekly er. Support of Kyiv Mohyla Academy is One of these is the interest of Newsweek District council members also greet- an investment in Ukraine’s future as a International, whose senior editor came STARYI YARYCHIV, Ukraine – It ed Mr. Nestor with his birthday, bring- leading democratic nation in Europe.” to Bard College to meet with Dr. was a sunny day, and Ukraine’s oldest ing flowers and money. Briukhovetsky and also with the universi- person sat on a bench outside his house “He is indifferent to money,” Ms. NUKMA achievements noted ty’s dean of social sciences, Dr. Serhiy and basked in the first spring rays. Savchuk said. “When he receives his Kvit, who established the university’s The main purpose of the U.S. tour was “Today is a nice day,” Hryhorii Nestor pension, he simply looks at the portrait department of journalism. Newsweek to report on some of NUKMA’s remark- said. “I feel good and warm. God shines of Shevchenko and says, ‘Oh, look will be establishing an office in Kyiv and able achievements since 1991 and to light and I am alive, thank God.” how sad he is … but this one’s happi- is looking for young journalists in train- March 15 was Mr. Nestor’s 116th er!,’ he says holding the image of assure the Ukrainian diaspora that its ing at Kyiv Mohyla,” Ms. Farion related. birthday. But the elderly man warned his Franko on the 20-hrv bill.” moral and financial support are justified. The Kyiv Mohyla Foundation, a non- grandniece Oksana Savchuk not to set the The doors remained open as guests The university essentially remains a pri- profit organization, has been engaged in table or celebrate because he is fasting. shuffled in and out. Then suddenly the vate institution and, therefore, depends work to help Kyiv Mohyla Academy in “Our old man (didus) loves God and old man became noticeably worried. on the continuing moral and financial raising financial assistance in the U.S. observes all the holidays,” said Ms. “What’s wrong, didu (grandfather)?” support of the North American Ukrainian and also to develop relationships with Savchuk, who works as a teacher in the Ms. Savchuk said. “Maybe something diaspora and other private individual and American universities, foundations, village school. “From his youth, he was isn’t right. Say so.” corporate donors. grants, assists Kyiv Mohyla students, raised with a love for God. He is fast- “Where is my family? Strange peo- The university has had many achieve- faculty and administrators during their ing now. Every morning, he prays a ple are walking all around,” he replied. ments during its brief renaissance. Since stays in the U.S. The foundation set a long while and sings psalms.” “Where are Ilko’s grandchildren? Is it Ukraine’s re-established independence in goal of raising $1 million in 2007 from a Dozens of reporters had arrived in possible they won’t come?” 1991 the university reaffirmed its role as combination of sources - individuals, Mr. Nestor’s village of Staryi Yarychiv, “They will come later, when all the the country’s leading academic institu- foundations, organizations. The Lviv Oblast, just 16 miles (25 kilome- guests leave,” Ms. Savchuk said calm- tion and reformer in education, being the Ukrainian community contributed a sig- ters) from Lviv, for his 116th birthday. ing him. first university in Ukraine to introduce nificant portion toward the fund-raising Mr. Nestor was undaunted, having There were seven children in the anonymous admissions testing, stringent goal and provided the moral support nec- already learned how to pose for cam- Nestor family; three of his siblings died admissions criteria and instruction in essary to build the university’s national eramen and photographers and confi- early and four survived. both Ukrainian and English. Its mission and international significance. dently speak into microphones and Older brother Mykhailo served as a in educating the leaders of the future is audio recorders. church cantor; the youngest, Ilko, went to attested by nearly 4,500 graduates, most Press-office, Kyiv Mohyla Foundation He joyfully greeted everyone with- France to earn money; and sister of whom have attained leading positions out declining, asking only that they Kateryna as a young woman traveled to in the private and government sectors. speak louder. the U.S., worked in a tobacco factory, The university’s new library, named The Guinness World Records repre- returned to her native village and married. after its principal donors Omelian and Yushchenko appeals... sentative in Ukraine, Ihor Pidchibii, In 1939 the family was resettled Tetiana Antonovych of the U.S., will be (Continued from page 1) traveled from Kyiv to present Mr. from Monastyrets, a village in what is officially opened in May and will house liaments have recognized that Famine as Nestor – who was born in 1891 – with now Polish territory, to the small vil- a collection of more than 400,000 vol- genocide,” he noted. a certificate officially recognizing him lage of Partseliatsiya in the Kamianka- umes and 1,000 periodicals. In a separate statement addressed to as Ukraine’s oldest man. Buzka district of the Lviv Oblast. The academic legacy of Prof. Omeljan Ukrainians living around the world, Mr. “Hryhorii Nestor is two years older Mr. Nestor’s relatives gathered later Pritsak, founder of the Harvard Yushchenko expressed support for the Ukrainian Research Institute and a lead- than the official world record holder,” on his birthday in a tight family circle. efforts of the Ukrainian World Congress ing specialist in Oriental studies, will be Mr. Pidchibii said. “He has the right to Ilko’s grandchildren, Vira, Nadiya, and its committee for observances of the housed in a separate historical building earn the title of the planet’s oldest liv- Liubov and Oleh came, along with Ms. 75th anniversary of the 1932-1933 Great currently under reconstruction. This ing resident and write his name in the Savchuk – the granddaughter of Mr. Famine. He said its work, which is aimed building will become a museum and cen- Guinness Book of Records.” Nestor’s sister Kateryna – her husband at promoting Holodomor awareness, ter of archives that will be available to “We’ve already submitted an appli- and three children. should make each Ukrainian citizen and all scholars. cation to register our Ukrainian record. “Here is the icon that Ilko gave his sis- each citizen of the world forever remem- The latest achievement of NUKMA It’s a two-or three-month wait. May ter Kateryna when he returned from work- ber “those millions of innocent people faculty and students is related to the uni- God allow our elderly man (starozhyl) ing in France,” Ms. Savchuk said, show- tortured to death.” to live long enough to see his recogni- ing the small picture with some writing in versity’s law school, whose dean is Andrij tion,” he added. French. “The date on it is 1898. She gave A. Meleshevych. The Kyiv Mohyla Law Among Mr. Nestor’s other visitors this to Hryhorii, who gave it to me.” School won the National Championship Share The Weekly was Staryi Yarychiv Village Council The Savchuk family, with whom Mr. in the Philip C. Jessup International Law Chair Andrii Andrushko, who presented Nestor lives, is convinced he is a Moot Court Competition in Ukraine, with a colleague. him with a Mother of God of Perpetual source of happiness and wealth, and competing with the top established law Order a gift subscription by writing to: Help icon, which delighting the old man. that God sent him, because he con- schools of Ukraine. The team of Kyiv Subscription Department, The Ukrainian Weekly, “A new history begins today with stantly teaches them to find joy in Mohyla students will be coming to 2200 Route 10, P.O. Box 280, Parsippany, NJ 07054. this icon,” Mr. Nestor said. “The every living moment. Washington to participate in the interna- Cost: $55 (or $45 if your colleague is a UNA member). tional competition. No. 15 THE UKRAINIAN WEEKLY SUNDAY, APRIL 15, 2007 5
THE UKRAINIAN NATIONAL ASSOCIATION FORUM
UNA’s newly redesigned website The General Assembly lets visitors calculate insurance needs of the Ukrainian National Association by Matthew Dubas home repairs, auto repairs and medical emergencies; and F.) annual PARSIPPANY, N.J. – Everyone has a dependent/home care expenses, which EXECUTIVE COMMITTEE NICHOLAS FIL little voice that occasionally pops into his include care for dependent, home mainte- 105 LATHAM RIDGE RD or her head asking questions such as: nance, food and clothing and an estimate PRESIDENT LATHAM, NY 12110 How much insurance coverage would I of the number of years to continue sup- STEFAN KACZARAJ need for my final expenses? Will the port. UKRAINIAN NATIONAL ASSOCIATION EUGENE OSCISLAWSKI children have money for education? Who Next, you determine your life insur- 2200 ROUTE 10 5 STABLE LN will pay off the mortgage? Who will ance coverage based on liquid assets that PARSIPPANY, NJ 07054 FLEMINGTON, NJ 08822 repay my debts? In case of an emergency, need protection such as cash, saving how well am I prepared? Who will care for the family elders? accounts and other liquid assets. FIRST VICE-PRESIDENT MYRON PYLYPIAK To protect your family’s financial Finally, you determine how much ZENON HOLUBEC 11204 SE 234TH ST security, the Ukrainian National additional coverage would be needed for 5566 PEARL RD KENT, WA 98031 Association’s website (www.ukrainianna- your individual situation. Estimate the PARMA, OH 44129 total cash needs from step one (sections tionalassociation.org) offers solutions for OLYA CZERKAS A-F), minus the total available liquid current and prospective members. SECOND VICE-PRESIDENT 565 RIVIERA BAY DR NE Visitors to the website – UNA members assets and existing life insurance from step two. This estimates the additional MICHAEL KOZIUPA ST PETERSBURG, FL 33702 and non-members alike – can use the 26 SUMMIT AVE online calculator (Microsoft Windows is life insurance needed. CEDAR KNOLLS, NJ 07927 AL KACHKOWSKI required to run the calculator program) to Some points to consider when evaluat- estimate what coverage would be appro- ing your life insurance include: making 126 SIMON FRASER CRES priate for their unique situation, provid- adjustments due to variances in cost of DIRECTOR FOR CANADA SASKATOON, SK S7H 3T1 ing financial solutions for everyday con- living and inflation; conducting annual MYRON GROCH cerns. policy reviews to meet your family’s 16 KEVIN DR PAUL PRINKO The first step in the calculation is changing needs; and supplementing your FONTHILL, ON L0S 1E4 CANADA 450 JEANES ST based on: A.) final expenses, including retirement income with UNA annuities PHILADELPHIA, PA 19116 medical bills, funeral costs, attorney fees and life insurance policies. NATIONAL SECRETARY and other associated costs; B.) children’s After you estimate your life insurance CHRISTINE E. KOZAK BOHDAN KUKURUZA education fund, which considers the total needs, your UNA representative can help UKRAINIAN NATIONAL ASSOCIATION 5441 N NEVA AVE cost of earning a degree and the number you determine the right insurance poli- 2200 ROUTE 10 CHICAGO, IL 60638 cies for you and your family. For more of children; C.) mortgage balance, D.) PARSIPPANY, NJ 07054 debt repayment, including auto loans, specific details about policy coverage, EUGENE SERBA home equity loans, credit cards and other readers may contact a UNA representa- debts; E.) an emergency fund for major tive or call 800-253-9862. TREASURER 233 BELAIRE DR ROMA LISOVICH MT. LAUREL, NJ 08054 UKRAINIAN NATIONAL ASSOCIATION 2200 ROUTE 10 SERGUEI DJOULA PARSIPPANY, NJ 07054 4740 LACOMBE Young UNA’ers MONTREAL, QC H3W 1R3 CANADA AUDITING COMMITTEE HONORARY MEMBERS GERALD TYSIAK 38 PROVIDENCE DR ANNA CHOPEK W SAND LAKE, NY 12196 1001 OPPENHEIMER DR, #101 LOS ALAMOS, NM 87544 WASYL SZEREMETA 1510 HILLTOP TERR MYRON KUROPAS HUNTINGDON VALLEY, PA 19006 107 ILEHAMWOOD DR DEKALB, IL 60115 VASYL LUCHKIW 49 WINDMILL LN TARAS SZMAGALA SR. NEW CITY, NY 10956 10976 TANAGER TR BRECKSVILLE, OH 44141 ADVISORS ANATOLE DOROSHENKO MAYA LEW 16955 SYCAMORE CT 245 E 25TH ST, APT 8-G NORTHVILLE, MI 48168 NEW YORK, NY 10010 STEFAN HAWRYSZ GLORIA HORBATY BLDG A, APT 306 3 PEQUOT RD 600 E. CATHEDRAL RD WALLINGFORD, CT 06492 PHILADELPHIA, PA 19128-1933
UNA Branch 15 in Washington has four new members: (from left) Lianne Chapin, Paul Salvi, Stephen Salvi and Katia Chapin. Two-year-olds Lianne and Mission Statement Katia are twin daughters of Dora Chomiak and Daren Chapin of New York. Paul, 3, and Stephen, 6 months, are the sons of Tania Chomiak-Salvi and Lucantonio The Ukrainian National Association exists: Salvi of Washington. The four cousins were enrolled by their grandparents Martha Bohachevsky-Chomiak and R. L. Chomiak. • to promote the principles of fraternalism; • to preserve the Ukrainian, Ukrainian American and Ukrainian Canadian heritage and culture; and Do you have a young UNA’er, • to provide quality financial services and products to its members. or potential young UNA’er in your family? As a fraternal insurance society, the Ukrainian National Association reinvests its Call the UNA Home Office, 973-292-9800, to find out how to enroll. earnings for the benefit of its members and the Ukrainian community.
THE UNA: 113 YEARS OF SERVICE TO OUR COMMUNITY 6 THE UKRAINIAN WEEKLY SUNDAY, APRIL 15, 2007 No. 15
NEWS AND VIEWS THE UKRAINIAN WEEKLY Stalemate in Ukraine A tale of two men in Canada’s military by Lubomyr Luciuk into a “foul-gorged” landscape. Digging “The president has dissolved a Verkhovna Rada that was based on treachery.” deep trenches there was impossible so – Our Ukraine National Deputy Ksenia Liapina There were two of them. Both were “grouse butts,” stacked islands of sand- liars. The younger man was Stephen, age bags, provided the only shelter our troops “The Orange forces want to force us to live not in compliance with the law, or 25. His older brother, George, was 33. had, poor protection against artillery even with our beliefs, but to follow instructions from abroad.” Until August 17, 1914, they lived near bombardments of the intensity that the – Communist Party Chairman Petro Symonenko Edmonton. Within two weeks of the war 1st Battalion’s War Diary recorded on being declared, they had volunteered to May 23-24. Of George’s body no identi- The two quotations above sum up the feelings of the two warring sides in Ukraine join the Canadian Over-Seas as the political crisis that came to the fore with President Viktor Yushchenko’s dis- fiable trace was ever found and no Expeditionary Force. Then they were sent memorial cross erected. missal of the Verkhovna Rada concluded its second week. Both claim they are east, to the Valcartier Militia Camp, just defending the rights of voters and the Constitution of Ukraine, each claims the other And therein lies a tale. Neither George outside Quebec City. That’s where they nor Stephen should have been anywhere is guilty of usurping power, and both claim to speak for the people of Ukraine. completed their Attestation Papers, on Thankfully, all is calm in Ukraine, even as the verbal volleys continue to fly near the Western Front. They were not September 4 and 19. Both swore they had born in Russia. They came from a west- between the ruling coalition and the opposition and, we might add, despite the been born in Russia, an allied power. Mr. hysterical statements by some coalition supporters about troop movements, ern Ukrainian village, Beremiany. It still E. Pascoe witnessed their statements, pre- exists. And, on the date the Great War planned kidnappings of politicial leaders and imminent civil war. sumably believing they were honest lads. The latest news indicates that there is some movement toward compromise, with the was declared, their hamlet was within the They weren’t. It took just over 90 years for borders of the Austro-Hungarian Empire. two Viktors exchanging proposals, but thus far rejecting them. The president is stand- the truth, and me, to catch up with them. ing firm on his decision to dismiss the Rada, though he is willing to have the pre-term Technically, by Ottawa’s definition, the Stephen became Private No. 19388 brothers were both “enemy aliens.” parliamentary elections take place at a later date, while Prime Minister Yanukovych is with the 9th Infantry Battalion. George spouting the line that if pre-term elections to the Rada are held, pre-term presidential If that had been discovered they would was also a Private, No. 19361, in the 1st have been interned, along with thousands elections must be held concurrently. Mr. Yushchenko said he believes a political settle- Infantry Battalion. We know a bit more – ment may be reached to resolve the conflict, while Mr. Yanukovych said he wants the of their fellow Ukrainian Canadians in one but not much – about each of them. Constitutional Court to rule on the constitutionality of the presidential decree. of the 24 concentration camps set aside for Stephen was short, standing around 5 Meanwhile, according to our Kyiv correspondent, the demonstrations in Kyiv are that purpose. There they would have been feet 3 inches perhaps a bit taller as some not really being taken seriously – save for those out to earn a buck. There is good forced to labor for the profit of their jailers of his documents record a height of 5 feet news and bad on the national democratic front, as some forces are seriously looking and subjected to other state-sanctioned 5 inches. He had a dark complexion, ahead to the elections and talking about running as a bloc, while significant divi- indignities. The Dividenko brothers avoid- brown eyes and black hair but no other sions remain among others. (Don’t these folks learn the lessons of past elections?) ed all that by lying about who they were distinguishing marks. The war soon “Big brother” Russia continues to carefully watch events unfolding in Ukraine, and where they had come from. The price changed that. He picked up a venereal looking for any opportunity to “help.” The Russian Federation’s Duma passed a res- they paid for fibbing you already know. disease behind the lines, “not severe” olution calling President Yushchenko’s decree “unconstitutional” and expressing Yet George was not entirely lost to according to the March 2, 1915, note in concern over his act “dissolving a legally elected Parliament” and thus destabilizing history. His name, along with that of the his medical record. Worse would come. Ukraine. Clearly an example of foreign interference in Ukraine’s internal affairs, 11,284 other Canadian soldiers who went In May an exploding shell rendered this harkened back to Russian President Vladimir Putin’s involvement in supporting “missing, presumed dead” in France, and him completely and permanently deaf in the candidacy of Mr. Yanukovych for president (and then twice congratulating him whose bodies were never recovered, is his left ear, partly so in the right. on his victory even as the vote was disputed). And, pro-Russian elements were in inscribed on the Vimy Memorial’s ram- full view as a flag of the “Donetsk Republic,” bearing the Russian national emblem Returned to duty, he was again hurt badly, parts. Canada’s prime minister, Stephen that depicts a two-headed eagle, was unfurled on the maidan. on June 13, 1916, with gunshot wounds Harper, was there in recent days to honor Our view from the faraway U.S.: we support the position that will most to the face and neck. But his frontline the memory of all those men. Having empower the people of Ukraine. The people deserve to have true leaders who military service continued until October spoken in Parliament of the need for care not about themselves, not about their business interests and not about their 8, 1917, when he suffered contusions to righting the historical injustices done to parties, but about the people who voted them into office and, yes, even about his hip, head and hand. Repatriated to Ukrainians and other Europeans during those who did not vote for them. In short, their loyalty must be to the nation of England, he was eventually shipped Canada’s first national internment opera- Ukraine. And, in order to overcome the current stalemate in Ukraine, the people home, arriving in Halifax aboard the tions, I trust Mr. Harper paused, if only must be allowed to pass judgement. Empress Britain on January 21, 1919. for a few seconds, to look upon the name Discharged as “medically unfit” on of “G. Dividenko.” February 19, Stephen was officially Where George lies may forever be declared to have a 15 percent disability known only unto God but who he was – as a direct result of military service. So, an “enemy alien” who died for Canada – April at 30, he was a disabled and unskilled is now known to all. Turning the pages back... laborer, with no home other than the YMCA’s Red Triangle Club in Toronto. EDITOR’S NOTE: April 9 marked the 12 He died there in 1934. 90th anniversary of the Canadian mili- Stephen endured another loss. George, It was 20 years ago that The Ukrainian Weekly reported on the tary attack on Vimy Ridge in France. 1987 also 5 feet 3 inches, but with blue eyes, According to the Canadian Broadcasting Chrysler-sponsored CBS-TV docu-drama “Escape from Sobibor.” brown hair and a fair complexion, was Based on a book by Richard Rashke, the film depicts an escape of Corp. (CBC), the battle was hailed as the killed in action, on May 24, 1915, during first allied success of World War I, and as 300 inmates during 1943 from the death camp at Sobibor. the Battle of Festubert. He fell some- The made-for-TV movie, which was released on April 12, 1987, sparked protests by “the cornerstone of the nation’s where in the vicinity of Le Quinque [Canada’s] image of its place in the the Ukrainian community in Washington, Chicago, Philadelphia and New York, due to Road, described in Lt. Edmund the repeated references to “Ukrainian guards.” According to the Ukrainian community, world.” The Vimy memorial, which was Blunden’s haunting war poem of the erected near Arras, France, lists the this made it appear as if all the guards at the death camp were Ukrainian. Some sus- same name as a “cemeterial fen,” sunk pected that the network was attempting to associate Ukrainians with Nazism. As a names of 11,285 Canadian soldiers who result of the work of the protesting organizations, the film aired with a disclaimer that died in France and whose remains were noted the film contained some “prejudicial ethnic references.” Lubomyr Luciuk is a professor of polit- never found. The rededication of the The script of the docu-drama was sent to schools nationwide that participated in the ical geography at The Royal Military restored monument took place on CBS Television Reading Program. The word “Ukrainian” appears 90 times in the College of Canada in Kingston, Ontario. Monday, April 9. script, while “German” only appears three times. Dennis Doty, the film’s producer told The Weekly that, based on independent research, which included survivors’ accounts and their testimony at trials, the guard force during IN THE PRESS mid-1942 to 1943 was in fact composed of Ukrainians. “Every survivor alive today and every piece of literature tells us they (the guards) were Ukrainians,” Mr. Doty added. Dr. Taras Hunczak of the Ukrainian Research and Documentation Center refuted these assertions and said that no more than 25 percent of the guards could have been Pre-term elections in Ukraine Ukrainians. Dr. Yitzhak Arad, director of the Yad Vashem, Israel’s Holocaust memori- “Ask Ukraine’s voters,” editorial, tion in Parliament] have made a legiti- al, said that most of the guards were Ukrainians and Latvians. The Globe and Mail, Toronto, April 6: mate case for switching sides. The results In response to the film, groups such as the Ukrainian Heritage Council, the World could very well go against the president. Jewish Congress, the Ukrainian American Professionals and Businesspersons “Ukraine has been plunged into anoth- “Meanwhile, an inquiry should be Association of New York/New Jersey, the Ukrainian American Justice Committee, the er major political and constitutional crisis held to determine whether bribes or Ukrainian Congress Committee of America and the Ukrainian National Center: History because some politicians have not yet other illegal inducements were used, and and Information Network (UNCHAIN) began a letter-writing campaign targeted at grasped their obligations in a parliamen- the prime minister should stop rousing Chrysler and CBS officials. tary democracy… the divisive forces in Ukrainian society Apparently in reaction to the film’s publicity, four swastikas were scratched into “President [Viktor] Yushchenko is and start practicing the art of compro- the surface of St. Volodymyr Ukrainian Orthodox Cathedral in New York between right to leave it up to Ukraine’s voters to mise that underpins all healthy democra- Friday and Saturday morning, April 10-11, 1987. resolve this crisis – to decide if the prime cies. As the president wrote this week in minister [Viktor Yanukovych] and his the Financial Times: ‘Genuine democ- Source: “‘Escape from Sobibor’ Producer stands by his research,” by Roma coalition have overstepped their mandate rats should never fear the verdict of the Hadzewycz, The Ukrainian Weekly, April 5, 1987. and if the defectors [to the ruling coali- people.’ ” No. 15 THE UKRAINIAN WEEKLY SUNDAY, APRIL 15, 2007 7
NEWS ANALYSIS Faces and Places Weak institutions at the root by Myron B. Kuropas of Ukraine’s political crisis by Brian Whitmore ances and competing institutions that RFE/RL characterize Western democracies. Thinking the unthinkable April 3 In Kyrgyzstan, months of stalemate led to the prime minister’s resignation on With the clash between west and east cultural center of the Ukrainian people. Here we go again. The streets of Kyiv March 29. in Ukraine accelerating, one Ukrainian is In time, Galicia-Volhynia came under the are filling up with opposing demonstra- So far, Kyrgyz President Kurmanbek thinking the unthinkable. rule of the Polish-Lithuanian tors clad in orange and blue. Just another Bakiev – elected after an uprising in “After 15 years of independence, there Commonwealth. With the rise of the crisis in the new democratic Ukraine. 2005 ousted President Askar Akaev – has is not a single clear reason for Ukraine to Kozaks, Ukraine’s fortunes improved some- Ukrainian President Viktor tried to placate the opposition and work remain one country,” writes Dmitry what, especially during the time of Hetman Yushchenko has disbanded Parliament in with Parliament. Some opposition groups Koublitsky in a March 10 Kyiv Post com- Bohdan Khmelnytsky (1648-1657). the name of the Constitution. Prime are nevertheless demanding that Bakiev mentary. A native of Lviv, he has been Independence died with the hetman’s signa- Minister Viktor Yanukovych – citing the step down. advocating full independence for western ture on the 1654 Treaty of Pereyaslav, how- very same Constitution – has declared Georgia – which in 2003 ushered in a Ukraine since 1996. ever. Other hetmans tried but failed to the move illegal and vowed to resist. new wave of democratic revolutions in Mr. Koublitsky believes that: restore Ukraine’s independence. Weary of But why exactly do political disputes the former Soviet Union – has so far “Secession of western Ukraine – and not Ukraine’s recalcitrance, Russia and Poland in the former Soviet Union tend to spill escaped such unrest. just Galicia [Halychyna] will allow us, formally divided Ukraine into “Left Bank out on to the streets? But analysts say Georgia’s institutions western Ukrainians, to achieve what can Ukraine” and “Right Bank Ukraine” with Alexander Rahr of the German have not yet been truly tested. no longer be achieved by ‘Greater the Treaty of Andrusovo in 1667. Council on Foreign Relations says the President Mikheil Saakashvilli, who Ukraine.’ It will make possible a smaller Independence hopes were reborn briefly problem – in Ukraine and elsewhere in was elected after the 2003 Rose Ukraine as an integral part of Europe. Our under Hetman Mazepa but perished at the the region – lies in the lack of democratic Revolution, enjoys an overwhelming small compact country will not be called Battle of Poltava in 1709. The Zaporozhian traditions. majority in Parliament – and Georgia just ‘Ukraine’ anymore, but we will still be Sich was destroyed by Russia’s Catherine II “The problem, even 15 years after the remains largely a presidential republic Ukrainians. European Ukrainians, that is.” in 1775 and Ukraine remained divided until demise of the Soviet Union, is to bring with a strong executive. Another state called Ukraine will co- the onset of the first world war. Poets like the leading politicians into a situation Mr. Saakashvilli repeatedly says that exist next door, Mr. Koublitsky argues. Its Taras Shevchenko in eastern Ukraine and where they obey the rules of the game, he intends to give up some of his presi- national capital will be Kyiv and those peo- Ivan Franko in western Ukraine kept free- which they obviously don’t do,” Mr. dential power in favor of a stronger ple will revere Taras Shevchenko just like dom hopes alive, however. Rahr says. “And second, the problem is Parliament – but has made no moves western Ukrainians. “Let that Ukraine be With the collapse of the Russian Empire the mentality of the elites and the broader toward actually doing so. proud of its huge industrial potential; have in 1917, Ukrainian political and organiza- population, which also favor leaders and “I don’t think we have a parliamentary Russian as a second – or first or the only – tional leaders formed a Central Rada in not law.” republic in Georgia,” Mr. Rahr says. “We state language; retain an over-regulated Kyiv and, on January 22, 1918, declared economy permanently feeding corruption; Ukraine’s independence. When Austro- Personality and politics have seen a presidential [system] replaced by a new strong leader, have laws that only deepen lawlessness; Hungary began to collapse, western Following the 2004 Orange Saakashvili, which he still is. Georgia is shout a strong ‘no’ to NATO and ‘yes’ to Ukrainian leaders met in Lviv on November Revolution, Ukraine tried to move away not moving toward a genuine democratic Moscow’s chokingly tight embrace.” 1, 1918, and established the Western from the powerful executives who have system like Ukraine was after the Orange Like many of us in North America, Mr. Ukrainian National Republic (ZUNR). The been prevalent in the former Soviet Revolution. Kyrgyzstan is also difficult Koublitsky is weary of the “everlasting two Ukrainian republics formally united on Union and build a true parliamentary because there you have local clans and a struggle for power in Kyiv between differ- January 22, 1919. Unity was short-lived. As system. The presidency’s powers were kind of split in the country [between] the ent political actors,” a struggle that “always Ukraine was besieged by Gen. Anton trimmed and Parliament’s were strength- north and the south.” consumes the involved parties entirely, Denikin’s white Russians from the south, ened. leaving no space or time to come up with Bolshevik Russians from the east and the At the time, many observers hailed the Russia’s influence coherent reform strategies and policies that Poles under Gen. Josef Pilsudski from the west, western and eastern Ukrainians were changes as the revolution’s most impor- Part of the problem lies in the neigh- the country so crucially needs.” unable to permanently unite their forces to tant legacy. borhood these countries are forced to live But what about the Orange fight common foes. “In the final analysis,” But President Yushchenko’s decision in – one dominated by an increasingly Revolution? Didn’t that unite Ukraine? writes Prof. Orest Subtelny in his “Ukraine: to dissolve Parliament represents the end authoritarian Russia with strong interests No, claims Mr. Koublitsky. It “was noth- A History,” “the vast cultural, psychological of this experiment. in its neighbors’ affairs. ing but a general protest against the exist- and political differences that accumulated “Ukraine is shifting away from the “There is a challenge in their region ing state of affairs in the country. It cer- between east and west Ukrainians during the idea of a parliamentary republic,” Mr. from countries like Russia, which are tainly was not a united, well thought-out centuries of living in dissimilar environ- Rahr explains. “Ukraine has failed to backsliding in terms of democracy,” says push for a new structural model.” build – the first country in the post- Nadia Diuk, senior director for Europe Dr. Ivan Katchanovski disagreed with ments were now coming to the fore.” Soviet space – a democratic system and Eurasia at the National Endowment Mr. Koublitsky in a March 21 Kyiv Post Disagreements between the two based on parliamentary leadership and for Democracy, a non-profit organization commentary, arguing that integration of the Ukraines carried over into the peace not on the leadership of one single per- that receives support from the U.S. two Ukraines is essential. At the same time, process at Versailles. Neither side could son, namely the president.” Congress. “It’s not easy for a country however, he cited a 2003 Institute of agree on a common front. When it was Mr. Rahr says that when faced with like Kyrgyzstan that is surrounded by Politics Survey that underscored deep divi- clear that a united Ukraine was impossible, difficulties, politicians in the former authoritarian dictatorships.” sions between the two Ukraines. According Ukrainian Americans still hoped for an Soviet Union tend to fall back on what Russia, of course, had its own show- to the survey, some 68 percent of eastern independent eastern Galicia, raising some they know best – attempting to rule with down between the president and parlia- Ukrainians express favorable views of $138,000 for the Galician cause. Hope died a strong hand. mentary opposition back in 1993. At that Ukraine’s 1654 incorporation by Moscow. in 1923 when the Council of Ambassadors “If politicians recognize that it is easi- time, Russia’s pro-Western President While most western Ukrainians have posi- awarded Ukrainian Galicia to Poland. er for them to try to come to power and Boris Yeltsin solved the crisis by shelling tive attitudes towards Ivan Mazepa, Following the war, Ukraine was parti- rule the country through authoritarian what many saw as a reactionary opposi- Mykhailo Hrushevsky and Symon Petliura, tioned among Czechoslovakia, Romania, means and not through compromises and tion into submission. only a minority of eastern Ukrainians share Russia and Poland. Ukraine remained democratic choices, then they choose the At the time, many in the West cheered such views. “About half of the respondents partitioned until Stalin’s forced unifica- easiest way, the authoritarian way,” Mr. Mr. Yeltsin on and called the move a vic- in eastern Ukraine, compared to a small tion during and after World War II. Rahr explains. tory for democratic forces. minority of western Ukrainians, express a Ukraine has been partitioned for most favorable attitude towards Vladimir Lenin,” of its history. This fact plus Samuel Looking around the region Today, many view those events as the end of Russia’s democratic experiment writes Dr. Katchanovski. Amazingly, some Huntington’s 1996 contention in “Clash Ukraine is not the only country in the and the beginning of the overbearing 30 percent of eastern Ukrainians have a of Civilizations” that Ukraine is a “cleft region struggling with the checks, bal- executive that now rules the Kremlin. favorable view of Stalin! country” that “could split along its fault There are certain historical precedents line into separate entities, the eastern of for an independent western Ukraine. As which would merge with Russia,” it’s a the political power of Kyivan Rus’ began miracle of sorts that “one Ukraine” has Want to reach us by e-mail? to wane in the 11th century, the empire survived for nearly 16 years. was gradually partitioned among royal Will the present Ukraine follow in the Editorial staff: [email protected] heirs. The first and most complete seces- footsteps of 1918 Ukraine? I think not. sion was that of the Principality of Galicia. Ukraine’s leadership is wobbly, but it’s Subscription Department: [email protected] Galicia eventually united with Volhynia not stupid. Could a separate western [Volyn] in the 12th century and, under the Ukraine survive economically? Probably Advertising Department: [email protected] rule of able rulers (Roman, Danylo, Lev), not. But the idea is tempting. People are the Galician-Volhynian Kingdom survived thinking the unthinkable. Only God Production Department: [email protected] for almost 200 years. Following attacks on knows what the future will bring. Kyiv, first by the Muscovites in 1169, and Publications Administration: [email protected] then by the Mongol/Tatars in 1240, Myron Kuropas’s e-mail address is Galicia-Volhynia emerged as the ethno- [email protected]. 8 THE UKRAINIAN WEEKLY SUNDAY, APRIL 15, 2007 No. 15
enough judges to review the presidential of having prepared and mobilized elite day, he said. Political stalemate... decree, as 12 judges constitute a quorum. army units to kidnap coalition leaders, Some coalition protesters are even (Continued from page 1) However, the possibility loomed that a including Prime Minister Yanukovych. undermining the cause of the coalition among coalition supporters that the quorum may soon be lost. “Three fighting units of 100, 150 and government, which is trying to cast itself judges made their statements to either On the evening of the judges’ state- 180 soldiers are mobilized and ready to as the political force fighting for Ukrainian threaten or denigrate the coalition gov- ment, Our Ukraine Faction Chair executing the task of seizing the Cabinet national unity and independence. of Ministers, the Verkhovna Rada, and On Independence Square itself, coali- ernment. Viacheslav Kyrylenko called on law arrest deputies, coalition members, gov- tion supporters carry Russian Federation The western Ukrainians are Yaroslava enforcement authorities to investigate the ernment officials,” Mr. Kalashnikov said. flags. Donetsk separatists led by Machuzhak, Dmytro Lylak, Volodymyr judges’ claims of pressure. “The scariest is they’re ready to kidnap Oleksander Tsurkan arrived for the Kampo and Mr. Stetsiuk; the presidential The Court has scheduled April 17 as the prime minister of Ukraine and his protests waving a Donetsk Republic flag. appointments are Mr. Shyshkin (a Moldova the day it will begin to review the presi- dential decree, its press service reported. entourage that escorts him.” Donetsk Oblast Council Chair Anatolii native), Mr. Kampo and Mr. Lylak. Just two days earlier, leaders of Blyzniuk said the Donetsk separatists Indeed, the judges revealed support for Parliament at work Ukraine’s armed forces and law enforce- were a planted provocation by the Mr. Yushchenko’s dismissal decree, ment authorities said during an April 10 Yushchenko government. However, Mr. Ukraine’s Parliament kept meeting in which they said was issued within the meeting at the Presidential Secretariat Tsurkan has been a consistent, well- daily special sessions, directly violating capacity of his presidential authority and that they had no plans to call a national known Donetsk separatist for several the president’s decree and disregarding therefore, required adherence. They criti- state of emergency. years. cized coalition leaders for declaring his the authority of the Presidential To prevent any potential for concerns The scene on the maidan stage wasn’t decree unconstitutional, stressing that Secretariat. or suspicion regarding the Ministry of much better. only the court can determine its constitu- National deputies continued making Defense, Mr. Hrystenko said he ordered Reminiscent of the hysterical reaction tionality. accusations against the president from his commanders not to raise the army’s of eastern Ukrainians during the Orange In response, coalition leaders accused the podium, accusing him of dividing the level of military preparedness during the Revolution, speakers began attacking Mr. the judges of making an illegal statement. country and comparing his conduct to political crisis. He also noted he was fol- Yushchenko for having “an American Mr. Shyshkin said President that of fascists and Nazis. lowing President Yushchenko’s direct wife, and American children.” (The pres- Yushchenko didn’t pressure them or The inflammatory and destabilizing order not to involve Ukraine’s armed ident’s five children were all born in request them to appear in the Presidential conduct of coalition deputies escalated forces in a political conflict. Ukraine.) Secretariat, as had been rumored. when Party of the Regions National Mr. Hrytsenko said Mr. Kalashnikov’s A group of supporters from Belarus Even without the participation of the Deputy Oleh Kalashnikov accused statements were provocative, for which he appeared on stage calling for a revival of five judges, the Constitutional Court has Minister of Defense Anatolii Hrytsenko deserved to be stripped of his national the Soviet Union. deputy’s status. He asked the Party of the Coalition supporters also staged daily Regions to dismiss him from its ranks, and rallies in front of key government build- voiced regret that he wasn’t able to strip ings, namely the Presidential Secretariat, Church leaders support president him of his officer status in the military. the Central Election Commission, the The coalition government of three par- Security Service of Ukraine, the Ukrinform Ukrainian Catholic Church, representa- ties continued their refusal to acknowledge Constitutional Court and the Verkhovna tives of the Ukrainian Christian KYIV – Representatives of five that pre-term elections were imminent, Rada. Evangelical Church and the Evangelical even as many of Ukraine’s political parties While the pro-coalition rally is largely Churches of Ukraine, in an April 5 Christian Church of Ukraine, as well as address to the people of Ukraine, began holding congresses to determine a commercial enterprise, with observers the Conference of Roman Catholic whether they would approach the elections estimating only about 10 to 20 percent expressed their support of President Bishops of Ukraine. Viktor Yushchenko’s dismissal of the independently or as part of a bloc. idealistic supporters, the support for the Patriarch Filaret stated: “We support Verkhovna Rada Chairman Oleksander opposition forces isn’t overwhelming Verkhovna Rada. the position of the president of Ukraine – Moroz stressed the need for a decision by either. The signatories to the statement were: the guarantor of the Constitution – and the Constitutional Court, while adding An April 11 rally on European Square, Patriarch Filaret of the Ukrainian we believe that what he has outlined in that only compromise would provide a just a stone’s throw from Independence Orthodox Church – Kyiv Patriarchate, his decree is the best way out of the cur- resolution to the crisis. Square, drew several thousand activists, Patriarch Lubomyr Husar of the rent situation.” In further attacks on Mr. Hrytsenko, mostly party functionaries and teenagers, Mr. Moroz asked the Cabinet of who also were cutting class. Ministers on April 10 to review his Activists from Pora, the grassroots appointment, hinting at the Parliament’s movement of energetic youth that served interest in the defense minister’s dis- as the Orange Revolution’s backbone, are missal. noticeably absent from any activities. They have set up only a handful of tents Protesters for hire in front of the Presidential Secretariat ' , The coalition government has man- and the Central Election Commission. * &