Biocatalysis in the Chemistry of Lupane Triterpenoids
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
molecules Review Biocatalysis in the Chemistry of Lupane Triterpenoids Jan Bachoˇrík 1 and Milan Urban 2,* 1 Department of Organic Chemistry, Faculty of Science, Palacký University in Olomouc, 17. listopadu 12, 771 46 Olomouc, Czech Republic; [email protected] 2 Medicinal Chemistry, Faculty of Medicine and Dentistry, Institute of Molecular and Translational Medicine, Palacký University in Olomouc, Hnˇevotínská 5, 779 00 Olomouc, Czech Republic * Correspondence: [email protected] Abstract: Pentacyclic triterpenes are important representatives of natural products that exhibit a wide variety of biological activities. These activities suggest that these compounds may represent potential medicines for the treatment of cancer and viral, bacterial, or protozoal infections. Naturally occurring triterpenes usually have several drawbacks, such as limited activity and insufficient solubility and bioavailability; therefore, they need to be modified to obtain compounds suitable for drug development. Modifications can be achieved either by methods of standard organic synthesis or with the use of biocatalysts, such as enzymes or enzyme systems within living organisms. In most cases, these modifications result in the preparation of esters, amides, saponins, or sugar conjugates. Notably, while standard organic synthesis has been heavily used and developed, the use of the latter methodology has been rather limited, but it appears that biocatalysis has recently sparked considerably wider interest within the scientific community. Among triterpenes, derivatives of lupane play important roles. This review therefore summarizes the natural occurrence and sources of lupane triterpenoids, their biosynthesis, and semisynthetic methods that may be used for the production of betulinic acid from abundant and inexpensive betulin. Most importantly, this article compares chemical transformations of lupane triterpenoids with analogous reactions performed by Citation: Bachoˇrík,J.; Urban, M. biocatalysts and highlights a large space for the future development of biocatalysis in this field. The Biocatalysis in the Chemistry of results of this study may serve as a summary of the current state of research and demonstrate the Lupane Triterpenoids. Molecules 2021, potential of the method in future applications. 26, 2271. https://doi.org/ 10.3390/molecules26082271 Keywords: lupane; betulinic acid; betulin; lupeol; biocatalysis; extraction; biotransformation; synthe- sis; prodrugs; enzyme Academic Editor: Irina Ivshina Received: 27 March 2021 Accepted: 11 April 2021 1. Introduction Published: 14 April 2021 Natural products have been used in traditional medicine for a long time, and since the appearance of modern science, they have been recognized as valuable sources of Publisher’s Note: MDPI stays neutral new drugs [1–5]. Considerable money has been invested in their isolation from natural with regard to jurisdictional claims in sources and characterization of their structures and biological activities. High-throughput published maps and institutional affil- screening was introduced for fast and efficient testing of large numbers of new compounds iations. from nature or chemistry labs [6–9]. In 2015, David et al. wrote a very informative review in which the authors summarized some of the most successful drug leads in history that came from natural products [10]. This review also reports that there was a significant decline in investment in natural drug discovery programs during the early 2000s because more Copyright: © 2021 by the authors. attention was paid to combinatorial chemistry and rational drug design, which appeared Licensee MDPI, Basel, Switzerland. to be considerably more promising. Pharmaceutical companies expected new methods to This article is an open access article enable the production of a number of new drugs, aiming at new molecular targets that distributed under the terms and may be game changers for many diseases. The new approach, however, has exhibited conditions of the Creative Commons Attribution (CC BY) license (https:// lower productivity in bringing new drugs to the market than previously expected, and creativecommons.org/licenses/by/ over the years, some of its disadvantages have appeared. One of these drawbacks is that 4.0/). rational design and solid-phase combinatorial chemistry usually use limited structural Molecules 2021, 26, 2271. https://doi.org/10.3390/molecules26082271 https://www.mdpi.com/journal/molecules Molecules 2021, 26, x 2271 FOR PEER REVIEW 2 of 28 26 structuralvariability, variability, which also which limits thealso outcome limits the [11 outcome]. Natural [11]. compounds, Natural co onmpounds, the other on hand, the other have hand,almost have unlimited almost variability unlimited of variability molecules, of and molecules, they occupy and a considerablythey occupy largera considerably chemical largerspace chemical than the space more focusedthan the more libraries focused obtained libraries as a obtained result of as the a result previously of the mentionedpreviously mentionedmethods [11 methods]. Although [11]. it Although is often difficult it is often to obtain difficult a unique to obtain active a unique molecule active from molecule natural frommaterial natural and material uncover and its uncover structure its and structure activity, and in activity, many cases, in many this cases, effort this has effort paid has off, paidleading off, toleading a commercial to a commercial drug. Within drug. theWithin past the several past years,several the years, search the for search new for natural new naturalproducts products started started to reemerge to reemerge as a source as a ofsour newce of drugs new [10drugs]. In [10]. our opinion,In our opinion, equilibrium equi- libriumhas been has achieved been achieved between between the two the approaches, two approaches, which which are both are important both important in the in drug the drugdiscovery discovery process. process. OneOne of of the largest and most important gr groupsoups of of natural products, products, which which has has at- at- tractedtracted considerable considerable attention attention from from researchers, researchers, is isterpenes. terpenes. Hundreds Hundreds of terpenes of terpenes are iso- are latedisolated every every year year from from natural natural resources, resources, and and even even more more are are prepared prepared by by semisynthetic methodsmethods [12,13]. [12,13]. Terpenes Terpenes can can have have a a variety of of different roles in living organisms; for example,example, they they can participate in such proce processessses as transferring messages and defending organismsorganisms [14–16]. [14–16]. TerpenesTerpenes can be formally divided into sm smalleraller subclasses based on the number of carbons.carbons. Triterpenes areare thethe subclass subclass that that contains contains 30 30 carbons carbons in itsin structures.its structures. This This subclass sub- classis composed is composed of a large of a large number number of compounds of compounds that may that bemay divided be divided according according to their to basictheir basicskeletons skeletons into into several several structural structural families. families. The The most most important important families families ofof triterpenes areare derivatives derivatives of of protostane, protostane, cycloartane, cycloartane, dammarane, dammarane, and and euphane, euphane, and and pentacyclic pentacyclic de- rivatives,derivatives, such such as asoleanane, oleanane, ursane, ursane, gammacerane, gammacerane, lupane, lupane, and and hopane. hopane. Figure Figure 11 showsshows thethe structures ofof selectedselected main main skeletons skeletons of of pentacyclic pentacyclic triterpenes—lupane triterpenes—lupane (1), ( hopane1), hopane (2), (ursane2), ursane (3), ( and3), and oleanane oleanane (4)[ (174), 18[17,18].]. Figure 1. ExamplesExamples of structural famili familieses of triterpenes—lupane ( 1), hopane ( 2), ursane (3), and oleanane (4). TriterpenesTriterpenes oftenoften have have a varietya variety of biologicalof biological activities, activities, and amongand among them, betulinicthem, betulinic acid (5) acidplays (5 an) plays important an important role, along role, with along ursolic with (6 )ursolic and oleanolic (6) and acidoleanolic (7) (Figure acid 2(7)[) 19(Figure–27]. 2) [19–27].The biological activities of betulinic acid (5) will be discussed later. However, the potential use of 5 as a commercially available drug may be limited by its insufficient solubility in water and low bioavailability [28,29]. This low bioavailability is also the main complication encountered when performing biological experiments; therefore, the optimization of pharmacological parameters, including solubility, is always an important part of the development of derivatives of acid 5. Many studies have focused on structural modifications of betulinic acid (5) that improve its solubility and bioavailability, especially the enhancement of solubility in polar media, and many studies have also focused on the improvement of selectivity [29–31]. In this review, we mostly focus on the biosynthesis of lupane triterpenoids, including betulinic acid (5), biocatalyzed modifications of acid 5, and its derivatives, and we compare those methods to classical approaches of synthetic organic chemistry that are commonly used. Our research group has been focused on the chemical modification of 5 for many years, and currently, we see biocatalysis as an important alternative for the preparation of new molecules