Attachment Four

ATTACHMENT FOUR

MAP OF SUBMITTER LOCATIONS

Location of Submitters proximate to the application site

403

Notes:

 Numbers correspond with the Submission number from the body of the s42A report.  Submitters 4, 11, 13 and 25 are not located within close proximity of the site and are therefore not included in the above figures.

404 ATTACHMENT FIVE

SUBMISSIONS

From: Auckland Council To: Resource Consent Authority Subject: Resource Consent submission for Pukekohe / Franklin - 11-17 paerata road pukekohe, Pukekohe Date: Tuesday, 25 July 2017 7:39:42 p.m.

Having trouble reading this email? View it in your browser.

Auckland Council

If you have any queries about this request, please hit 'reply' to email us back, or send an email to [email protected]

1. APPLICATION DETAILS

I/we wish to make a submission on the application of (name of applicant): Food stuffs north island

Who proposes to (description of application from public notice): To construct and operate super market

APPLICATION SITE ADDRESS FROM THE PUBLIC NOTICE:

Street number and name: 11-17 paerata road pukekohe

Suburb: Pukekohe

Application number: Luc60302970

2. CONTACT DETAILS:

Full name: Aleisha sullivan and jeremy sullivan

I am a: Property owner

Street number, name and suburb of the property, you are acting on behalf of: 6a kayes road pukekohe

Mobile phone: 021 126 5686

Email address: [email protected]

Address for correspondence: 6a kayes road, Pukekohe, Auckland, 2120

3. SUBMISSION DETAILS:

I/we: Support

specify aspects of the above application you are submitting on: Im really expressing my support for this submission for the supermarket to go ahead

The reasons for my/our submission are: I think pukekohe is such a growing place and opens up jobs and opportunities as pukekohe is only getting bigger

The decision I/we wish the Council to make is (include any part of the application

405 you wish to have amended and any conditions of a general nature): To go ahead and let foodstuffs use the land to produce a new supermarket

I/we wish to be heard at the council planning hearing: No

Uploaded documents:

Head office: 1 Greys Avenue | Private Bag 92300, Auckland 1142 | 09 301 0101

406

Auckland City Council

To whom it may concern,

This document is our submission to the resource consent application for the proposed New World supermarket development at 11-19 Paerata Road and 3 Comrie Place, Pukekohe (development site) by the Foodstaffs North Island Ltd (the developer). Located at 8 Paerata Road which is directly opposite of the 11-19 Paerata Road, we believe that we and our property will be greatly affected by the proposed development. The development (during the construction phase and after) will introduce significant changes to our surroundings, some of which will have significant negative impact on our lives. Those changes are as follows: 1) Increased noise for a long period of time during the construction phase – Although it is reasonable to expect that developments occur in the Business - Light Industry Zone, the proposed development is way out of proportions as it is larger in scale then it would normally be expected in this zone and on this location. Due to the scale of the development, the construction phase will certainly last for a very long time and the proposed work (rock breaking, truck movements, construction of the large building and similar) will introduce high level of noise. This long-lasting high-noise operation will be a major disturbance to our lives as our property is just 20m away from the site and our windows are in the same level where the noise producing operations will be carried on. When assessing the compliance to the Standard E25.6.27, the author of the desk-based Acoustics Assessment supplied with the resource consent application did not assess the effect of the construction phase sounds to the residential area across the Paerata Road. We believe that the level of noise produced during the construction phase will exceed allowed limits and be in breach of the Standard E25.6.2 (please view Standard E25.6.22 as a reference). Although it can be argued that the residential area is already exposed to the noise from the passing traffic on the Pearata Road, the construction work will certainly introduce different, more intense and longer in duration sounds produced by rock-breaking, heavy vehicle movements, heavy machinery operations and similar. This more intense and longer in duration noise will have detrimental effect on our wellbeing and enjoyment of the property 2) Vibrations from rock-breaking and/or blasting during the construction phase – 8 Paerata Road dwelling is 50+ years old and just 20m away from the rock breaking/blasting location. It is very likely that its foundation/walls/roof will sustain some damage if exposed to the planned vibrations. The damage might be structural and shorten the life of the dwelling. The assessor does not assess the effect of vibrations on 8 Paerata Road, despite the location of the proposed storm-water structures where most of the drilling and possibly blasting is planned to occur, is directly opposite to the address. The assessor does conclude that the vibration limits allowed in the Standard E25.6.30 will possibly be exceeded during the construction phase 3) The length and the extent of the disturbance of the traffic during the construction phase and its effect on vehicles getting in and out of 8 Paerata Road driveway - Due

- 1 - 407

to the significant changes in the traffic flow directly in front of the 8 Paerata Road, vehicle movements in and out of the 8 Paerata Road property will be greatly affected. This makes us concerned for our safety when merging with the traffic and we estimate that the length of time that we will be spending waiting to merge with the traffic will increase considerably. This particularly in the mornings when we go to work and during the rush hours. 4) No mitigation for dust in the construction phase – The assessment does not provide a solution for mitigation of dust created during the construction phase. The Ground Contamination Assessment shows presence of lead in the ground and lead is known for its negative effects on health if it enters the body. Also, drilling of basalt is known to produce silica, which is known to negatively impact respiratory health. 5) Increased noise when the complex be fully operational – We disagree with the desk- based assessment provided by the Chiles Ltd as it fails to take in consideration noise generated from all sources when deciding on the level of noise that we will be exposed to. The assessor says that “The residential zones on the opposite side of Paerata Road are in the order of 20 metres from the car park so the sound level without mitigation would be approximately 40 dB LAeq”. This assessment does not take in consideration that the sounds from the car-park are not the only sounds that this development introduces. The assessor does not take in consideration the sounds produced by the “primary” and “diverted” supermarket customers as defined in the Integrated Transport Assessment (ITA). This traffic is new and introduced by the Supermarket and does not normally occur on the Pearata Road. The estimate in the ITA is 354 vehicles per hour during peek times. This will greatly exceed the noise limits defined in the Standard E25.6.2 6) Overspill parking – Shoppers coming from the south and buying one or two items in the supermarket will find it easier to park on the western side of the Paerata Road and walk to the supermarket then to turn right through the line of south-bound cars into the supermarket parking and then wait to merge with traffic (again having to break the busy south-bound traffic for that) on the way out. This will cause two issues for us: a) cars parked to the south of our driveway will block the view to the south to the cars getting out of our driveway and b) there will be less space for parking for our visitors. Although b) is just an inconvenience, a) could pose a serious safety risk for us and our visitors as the cars going out of our driveway will be unable to see incoming northbound cars 7) Carpark illuminance at night time – As the result of the lighting placed on the supermarket carpark, the illumination will overspill to our front lawn area and the windows located on the east of the dwelling. This will make the content of our front yard fully exposed to the passers-by at night increasing the chance that the items left in the front yard overnight be stolen. Also, the light coming through the window of the bedroom located in the east of the dwelling will be a disturbance. We are against the proposed development unless the above issues are fully mitigated to our satisfaction. We are open to further discuss this with the developer.

Aleksandar Zivaljevic and Snezana Milicevic 8 Paerata Road, Pukekohe 021-161-1671

- 2 - 408 From: Melanie Sopoaga on behalf of Resource Consent Authority To: Quentin Budd Subject: FW: Resource Consent submission for Pukekohe / Franklin - 11-17 Paerata Road and 3 Comrie Place, Pukekohe Date: Tuesday, 15 August 2017 10:18:43 a.m.

From: Auckland Council [mailto:[email protected]] Sent: Monday, 14 August 2017 8:08 p.m. To: Resource Consent Authority Subject: Resource Consent submission for Pukekohe / Franklin - 11-17 Paerata Road and 3 Comrie Place, Pukekohe

If you have any queries about this request, please hit 'reply' to email us back, or send an email to [email protected] 1. APPLICATION DETAILS I/we wish to make a submission on the application of (name of applicant): Foodstuffs North Island Ltd Who proposes to (description of application from public notice): Application be declined unless the issues raised are resolved APPLICATION SITE ADDRESS FROM THE PUBLIC NOTICE: Street number and name: 11- 17 Paerata Road and 3 Comrie Place Suburb: Pukekohe Application number: BUN60302929 Applicant's email address: [email protected] Location of application site: Pukekohe / Franklin Main area to which the application relates: Resource Consents - district issues 2. CONTACT DETAILS: Full name: Aleksandar Zivaljevic I am a: Property owner Street number, name and suburb of the property, you are acting on behalf of: 8 Paerata Road Pukekohe Mobile phone: 021 161 1671 Email address: [email protected] Address for correspondence: 8 Paerata Road, Pukekohe, Auckland, 2120 3. SUBMISSION DETAILS: I/we: Oppose specify aspects of the above application you are submitting on: - Increased noise for a long period of time during the construction phase - Vibrations from rock - breaking and/or blasting during the construction phase - The length and the extent of the disturbance of the traffic during the construction phase and its effect on vehicles getting in and out of 8 Paerata Road driveway - No mitigation for dust in the construction phase - Increased noise when the complex be fully operational - Overspill parking - Carpark illuminance at night time The reasons for my/our submission are: Please refer to the attached document. The decision I/we wish the Council to make is (include any part of the application you wish to have amended and any conditions of a general nature): The applicant to mitigate the issues listed in the submitted document. I/we wish to be heard at the council planning hearing: No Uploaded documents: 8 Paerata Road submission.pdf Having trouble reading this email? View it in your browser.

If you have any queries about this request, please hit 'reply' to email us back, or send an email to [email protected]

1. APPLICATION DETAILS

I/we wish to make a submission on the application of (name of applicant): Foodstuffs North Island Ltd

Who proposes to (description of application from public notice): Application be declined unless the issues raised are resolved

APPLICATION SITE ADDRESS FROM THE PUBLIC NOTICE:

Street number and name: 11-17 Paerata Road and 3 Comrie Place

Suburb: Pukekohe

Application number: BUN60302929

Applicant's email address: [email protected]

Location of application site: Pukekohe / Franklin

Main area to which the application relates: Resource Consents - district issues

2. CONTACT DETAILS:

Full name: Aleksandar Zivaljevic

I am a: Property owner

Street number, name and suburb of the property, you are acting on behalf of: 8 Paerata Road Pukekohe

Mobile phone: 021 161 1671

Email address: [email protected]

Address for correspondence: 8 Paerata Road, Pukekohe, Auckland, 2120

3. SUBMISSION DETAILS:

409 I/we: Oppose specify aspects of the above application you are submitting on: - Increased noise for a long period of time during the construction phase -Vibrations from rock-breaking and/or blasting during the construction phase -The length and the extent of the disturbance of the traffic during the construction phase and its effect on vehicles getting in and out of 8 Paerata Road driveway -No mitigation for dust in the construction phase -Increased noise when the complex be fully operational -Overspill parking -Carpark illuminance at night time

The reasons for my/our submission are: Please refer to the attached document.

The decision I/we wish the Council to make is (include any part of the application you wish to have amended and any conditions of a general nature): The applicant to mitigate the issues listed in the submitted document.

I/we wish to be heard at the council planning hearing: No

Uploaded documents: 8 Paerata Road submission.pdf

Head office: 1 Greys Avenue | Private Bag 92300, Auckland 1142 | 09 301 0101

410 411 412 413 414 415 416 417 418 419 420 From: Melanie Sopoaga on behalf of Resource Consent Authority To: Quentin Budd Subject: FW: Resource Consent submission for Pukekohe / Franklin - 11-17 Paerata Road & 3 Comrie Place, Pukekohe Date: Thursday, 3 August 2017 3:54:52 p.m.

From: Auckland Council [mailto:[email protected]] Sent: Thursday, 3 August 2017 3:22 p.m. To: Resource Consent Authority Subject: Resource Consent submission for Pukekohe / Franklin - 11-17 Paerata Road & 3 Comrie Place, Pukekohe

If you have any queries about this request, please hit 'reply' to email us back, or send an email to [email protected] 1. APPLICATION DETAILS I/we wish to make a submission on the application of (name of applicant): Foodstuffs North Island Ltd Who proposes to (description of application from public notice): Construct and operate a Supermarket APPLICATION SITE ADDRESS FROM THE PUBLIC NOTICE: Street number and name: 11- 17 Paerata Road & 3 Comrie Place Suburb: Pukekohe Application number: LUC60302970 (Land use) & DIS60302971 (Stormwater Discharge) Applicant's email address: [email protected] Location of application site: Pukekohe / Franklin Main area to which the application relates: Resource Consents - district issues 2. CONTACT DETAILS: Full name: Housing New Zealand Corporation Organisation: Housing New Zealand Corporation I am a: Property owner Street number, name and suburb of the property, you are acting on behalf of: 18 & 47 Paerata Road, Pukekohe Business phone: (09) 2615250 Email address: [email protected] Address for correspondence: 205 Great North Road, Greenlane, Auckland Central, 1051 3. SUBMISSION DETAILS: I/we: Neutral regarding the application specify aspects of the above application you are submitting on: Housing New Zealand doesn't really have any objections to the proposal and in principle supports the application. However it wishes to have the right to be able to discuss with the applicant issues that may arise or not currently raised at this stage. The reasons for my/our submission are: Housing New Zealand believes that although sufficient information has been provided at this stage, there are still some issues that could arise during the hearing process that may affect Housing New Zealand nearby properties.adjacent The decision I/we wish the Council to make is (include any part of the application you wish to have amended and any conditions of a general nature): That the Council approve the application subject to conditions that safeguard the environment and interest of the adjoining properties that may have spill on effects from the activity I/we wish to be heard at the council planning hearing: No Uploaded documents: Having trouble reading this email? View it in your browser.

If you have any queries about this request, please hit 'reply' to email us back, or send an email to [email protected]

1. APPLICATION DETAILS

I/we wish to make a submission on the application of (name of applicant): Foodstuffs North Island Ltd

Who proposes to (description of application from public notice): Construct and operate a Supermarket

APPLICATION SITE ADDRESS FROM THE PUBLIC NOTICE:

Street number and name: 11-17 Paerata Road & 3 Comrie Place

Suburb: Pukekohe

Application number: LUC60302970 (Land use) & DIS60302971 (Stormwater Discharge)

Applicant's email address: [email protected]

Location of application site: Pukekohe / Franklin

Main area to which the application relates: Resource Consents - district issues

2. CONTACT DETAILS:

Full name: Housing New Zealand Corporation

Organisation: Housing New Zealand Corporation

I am a: Property owner

Street number, name and suburb of the property, you are acting on behalf of: 18 & 47 Paerata Road, Pukekohe

Business phone: (09) 2615250

Email address: [email protected]

Address for correspondence: 205 Great North

421 Road, Greenlane, Auckland Central, 1051

3. SUBMISSION DETAILS:

I/we: Neutral regarding the application specify aspects of the above application you are submitting on: Housing New Zealand doesn't really have any objections to the proposal and in principle supports the application. However it wishes to have the right to be able to discuss with the applicant issues that may arise or not currently raised at this stage.

The reasons for my/our submission are: Housing New Zealand believes that although sufficient information has been provided at this stage, there are still some issues that could arise during the hearing process that may affect Housing New Zealand nearby properties.adjacent

The decision I/we wish the Council to make is (include any part of the application you wish to have amended and any conditions of a general nature): That the Council approve the application subject to conditions that safeguard the environment and interest of the adjoining properties that may have spill on effects from the activity

I/we wish to be heard at the council planning hearing: No

Uploaded documents:

Head office: 1 Greys Avenue | Private Bag 92300, Auckland 1142 | 09 301 0101

422 From: Melanie Sopoaga on behalf of Resource Consent Authority To: Quentin Budd Subject: FW: Resource Consent submission for Pukekohe / Franklin - 11-17 Paerata Rd, Pukekohe Date: Thursday, 3 August 2017 10:32:24 a.m.

From: Auckland Council [mailto:[email protected]] Sent: Wednesday, 2 August 2017 3:29 p.m. To: Resource Consent Authority Subject: Resource Consent submission for Pukekohe / Franklin - 11-17 Paerata Rd, Pukekohe

If you have any queries about this request, please hit 'reply' to email us back, or send an email to [email protected] 1. APPLICATION DETAILS I/we wish to make a submission on the application of (name of applicant): Foodstuffs North Island Ltd Who proposes to (description of application from public notice): Build and Operate New World APPLICATION SITE ADDRESS FROM THE PUBLIC NOTICE: Street number and name: 11- 17 Paerata Rd Suburb: Pukekohe Application number: BUN60302929 Applicant's email address: [email protected] Location of application site: Pukekohe / Franklin Main area to which the application relates: Resource Consents - district issues 2. CONTACT DETAILS: Full name: Judith Hind I am a: Property owner Street number, name and suburb of the property, you are acting on behalf of: 16 A Paerata Rd, Pukekohe Home phone: 09 5589098 Email address: [email protected] Address for correspondence: 16A Paerata RD, Pukekohe, Auckland, 2120 3. SUBMISSION DETAILS: I/we: Oppose specify aspects of the above application you are submitting on: Traffic increase on Paerata Rd. Otherwise, in support of development. The reasons for my/our submission are: Already can't turn right onto road from residence or Kayes Rd due to traffic flow. This development will increase traffic, making it even more difficult to turn right. The decision I/we wish the Council to make is (include any part of the application you wish to have amended and any conditions of a general nature): Suggestion of roundabout at Kayes Rd. Traffic flow needs to be studied further. I/we wish to be heard at the council planning hearing: No Uploaded documents: Having trouble reading this email? View it in your browser.

If you have any queries about this request, please hit 'reply' to email us back, or send an email to [email protected]

1. APPLICATION DETAILS

I/we wish to make a submission on the application of (name of applicant): Foodstuffs North Island Ltd

Who proposes to (description of application from public notice): Build and Operate New World

APPLICATION SITE ADDRESS FROM THE PUBLIC NOTICE:

Street number and name: 11-17 Paerata Rd

Suburb: Pukekohe

Application number: BUN60302929

Applicant's email address: [email protected]

Location of application site: Pukekohe / Franklin

Main area to which the application relates: Resource Consents - district issues

2. CONTACT DETAILS:

Full name: Judith Hind

I am a: Property owner

Street number, name and suburb of the property, you are acting on behalf of: 16 A Paerata Rd, Pukekohe

Home phone: 09 5589098

Email address: [email protected]

Address for correspondence: 16A Paerata RD, Pukekohe, Auckland, 2120

3. SUBMISSION DETAILS:

423 I/we: Oppose specify aspects of the above application you are submitting on: Traffic increase on Paerata Rd. Otherwise, in support of development.

The reasons for my/our submission are: Already can't turn right onto road from residence or Kayes Rd due to traffic flow. This development will increase traffic, making it even more difficult to turn right.

The decision I/we wish the Council to make is (include any part of the application you wish to have amended and any conditions of a general nature): Suggestion of roundabout at Kayes Rd. Traffic flow needs to be studied further.

I/we wish to be heard at the council planning hearing: No

Uploaded documents:

Head office: 1 Greys Avenue | Private Bag 92300, Auckland 1142 | 09 301 0101

424 425 426 427 428 429 430 Submission on Resource Consent Application

! 1.0 SUBMITTER DETAILS!

Name of submitter(s) (please write all names in Leigh Shaw full)

Physical Address: 58 Puketutu Road, Bombay Postcode:

Address for service: (if different) PO Box 1167, PUKEKOHE 2340

Telephone (day): 09 238 9991 Mobile: 027 285 1000 Fax:

Email: [email protected]

! 2.0 APPLICATION DETAILS

Application Number: BUN60302929

Name of applicant: (please write all names in Foodstuffs North Island Ltd full)

Address of proposed activity: 11-17 Paerata Road, Pukekohe Postcode:

Description of proposed activity:

The applicant seeks to construct and operate a New World supermarket, being a retail activity in the Light Industry zone. A land use consent and stormwater discharge permit is required and will be assessed together as a non-complying activity.

! 3.0 SUBMISSION DETAILS

My/our submission: (please tick one)

!√ Supports the Application ! Opposes the Application ! Neutral regarding the Application

The specific parts of the application to which my/our submission relates to are: (use additional pages if required.)

The entire application

P0098.3 06/07/10

Page 1 of 2 431 ! 3.0 SUBMISSION DETAILS contd The reasons for my/our submission are: (use additional pages if required.)

The supermarket will meet my social and economic needs by being located conveniently along my daily commute and providing an alternative food supply within my home town, therefore avoiding the need to travel outside the Franklin area. The proposal will provide a modern, attractive building which will improve the visual amenity of the site and surrounding area. The site is readily accessible to the residents of Pukekohe and surrounding areas will provide sufficient parking required for the collection of household groceries. The proposed supermarket will not adversely affect the town centre (which provides for pedestrian-based retail, business and dining) and is considered an efficient use of the site.

The decision I/we would like the Council to make is (including, if relevant, the parts of the application you wish to have amended and the general nature of any conditions sought):

That the proposal should be granted consent

! 4.0 SUBMISSION AT THE HEARING!

! I/we wish to speak in support of my/our submission.

!√ I/we do not wish to speak in support of my/our submission. !√ If others make a similar submission, I/we will consider presenting a joint case with them at the hearing.

Signature of susubmitter(s)bmitter(s) or agent of submitter(s)

Date:

IMPORTANT INFORMATION

The Council must receive this submission before the date and time indicated. A copy of this submission must also be given as soon as reasonably practicable to the applicant at the applicant’s address for service.

All submitters will be advised of hearing details at least 10 working days before the hearing. If you change your mind as to wh ether you wish to attend the hearing, please phone the Council so that the necessary arrangements can be made.

PRIVACY INFORMATION

The information you have provided on this form is required so that your submission can be processed under the RMA, so that statistics can be collected by the Council. The information will be stored on a public register, and held by the Council. The details may also be made available to the public on the Council’s website. These details are collected to inform the general public and community groups about all consents which have been issued through the Council. If you would like to request access to, or correction of your details, please contact the Council.

Page 2 of 2 432 433 434 435 436 From: Lucie Rutherfurd To: miptsubmissions Cc: Hero Potini; Dennis Kirkwood Subject: 11-17 Paerata road & 3 Comrie Place Pukekohe Date: Monday, 21 August 2017 10:31:41 a.m.

Tena koe

Please accept this late submission on behalf of Ngati Tamaoho Trust with regards to application numbers LUC60302970 [land use] & DIS60302971 [Stormwater discharge]

Ngati Tamaoho oppose this application with regards to the Stormwater Discharge portion of the proposal

Ngati Tamaoho is Mana When here and we strive to ensure a healthy environmental outcome for all developments within our rohe.

This proposal does not offer mitigation for most contaminants entering the Whangamaire stream, neither is their any proposal to mitigate with riparian planting the stream "esplanade" There is no proposal to renew or upgrade existing stormwater lines operative since the 60's, which continue to discharge to the Whangamaire stream.

Ngati Tamaoho recommend that this application is declined until a mutually acceptable outcome can be had with regards to treatment of contaminants and enhancing the stream banks of the Whangamaire.

We wish to be heard with regards to this submission

Naku noa na Lucie Rutherfurd

437 1. Traffic survey of flows for Paerata road is out dated and over 14 months old. 2. Traffic accidents are not up to date. There was a serious accident in June 2017 involving a motorcyclist on the intersection of Comrie Place & Paerata Road. This was in rush hour traffic and emergency services were hindered in reaching the scene due to intense traffic flows. This resulted in south bound traffic grid locked back to Lough-bourne drive till after 6pm. A lot of minor accidents on the corner of Kayes road & Paerata road go unreported due to no injuries or Police not required. These are vehicles exiting right from Kayes road on to Paerata during peak traffic times. 3. The location of the traffic count data recorded in 3.2 Table 1 on Paerata road/Crisp Ave does not reflect or take into account traffic flows already detouring off Paerata and travelling up Kayes road due to queued/stopped traffic up to the roundabout Seddon/Edinburgh. Traffic up the suburban street will increase as congestion increases with the vehicles turning into & exiting the proposed new supermarket. 4. Paerata road/ SH22 is a main exit from Pukekohe for emergency services. With increased vehicles turning into & exiting the proposed new supermarket this will reduce response times of these services. 5. The SIDRA Intersection software I believe to be incredibly incorrect & unbelievable.( The right turn exit at both crossings will experience a level of service D or E and delays of around 35 seconds/vehicle, but this is not unusual for a busy site on a busy road during peak periods..) Most delays experienced for vehicles exiting Kayes road, Crisp Ave, Comrie Place, Adams drive on to Paerata road crossing the flow of traffic can be up to 2 minutes in peak traffic. This is increased with larger vehicles such as towing vehicles, light trucks, heavy truck & trailer units and buses. 6. Section 7.4 Impact on neighbouring properties will be increased with turning service vehicles. Peak AM Traffic is already flowing well before 7am; with the addition of, heavy truck & trailer units turning across the flow of traffic will have an effect. These trucks are up to 19 metres in length. This size truck sitting on the centre median strip to turn into Comrie Place takes up over half the measured length from Comrie place to the New World proposed entrance which is approximately 44 metres. The driving approach of these trucks will begin their turning procedure into the centre median from approximately 40 – 50 metres away. This crossing over the intersection of Crisp Ave and the northern proposed exit. 7. Bus Stop opposite northern proposed entrance for BUS 394/392 – Concerns for pedestrians as no pedestrian crossing on Paerata road for people using the bus stop to access the proposed New World. This is a hazard and will increase risk of pedestrians being hit by vehicles. 8. Within 200m of the proposed site there are two locally owned food outlets/dairies, it is a concern as to what would happen to these businesses should a supermarket be built. A supermarket would greatly affect the livelihoods of the owners of these businesses and could force them to close.

438 From: Melanie Sopoaga on behalf of Resource Consent Authority To: Quentin Budd Subject: FW: Resource Consent submission for Pukekohe / Franklin - 11-17 Paerata Road and 3 Comrie Place, Pukekohe Date: Thursday, 17 August 2017 8:22:45 a.m.

From: Auckland Council [mailto:[email protected]] Sent: Wednesday, 16 August 2017 6:15 p.m. To: Resource Consent Authority Subject: Resource Consent submission for Pukekohe / Franklin - 11-17 Paerata Road and 3 Comrie Place, Pukekohe

If you have any queries about this request, please hit 'reply' to email us back, or send an email to [email protected] 1. APPLICATION DETAILS I/we wish to make a submission on the application of (name of applicant): Foodstuffs North Island Limited Who proposes to (description of application from public notice): Construct and operate a supermarket, being a retail activity in the Light Industry zone. Land use consent and a storm - water discharge permit is required and assessed together as a non - complying actvity APPLICATION SITE ADDRESS FROM THE PUBLIC NOTICE: Street number and name: 11- 17 Paerata Road and 3 Comrie Place Suburb: Pukekohe Application number: LUC60302970 & DIS60302971 2. CONTACT DETAILS: Full name: Rachel Blissett & Thomas Carroll I am a: Property owner Street number, name and suburb of the property, you are acting on behalf of: 25 Richardson Avenue, Pukekohe Mobile phone: 027 415 4052 Email address: [email protected] Address for correspondence: 25 Richardson Avenue, Pukekohe, Auckland, 2120 3. SUBMISSION DETAILS: I/we: Oppose specify aspects of the above application you are submitting on: Traffic Issues on Paerata Road Impact on nearby businesses The decision I/we wish the Council to make is (include any part of the application you wish to have amended and any conditions of a general nature): Oppose the planned supermarket, unless Paerata Road congestion is addressed with widening of the road, round - abouts, traffic signals. I/we wish to be heard at the council planning hearing: No Uploaded documents: New World Supermarket.docx Having trouble reading this email? View it in your browser.

If you have any queries about this request, please hit 'reply' to email us back, or send an email to [email protected]

1. APPLICATION DETAILS

I/we wish to make a submission on the application of (name of applicant): Foodstuffs North Island Limited

Who proposes to (description of application from public notice): Construct and operate a supermarket, being a retail activity in the Light Industry zone. Land use consent and a storm-water discharge permit is required and assessed together as a non-complying actvity

APPLICATION SITE ADDRESS FROM THE PUBLIC NOTICE:

Street number and name: 11-17 Paerata Road and 3 Comrie Place

Suburb: Pukekohe

Application number: LUC60302970 & DIS60302971

2. CONTACT DETAILS:

Full name: Rachel Blissett & Thomas Carroll

I am a: Property owner

Street number, name and suburb of the property, you are acting on behalf of: 25 Richardson Avenue, Pukekohe

Mobile phone: 027 415 4052

Email address: [email protected]

Address for correspondence: 25 Richardson Avenue, Pukekohe, Auckland, 2120

3. SUBMISSION DETAILS:

I/we: Oppose

439 specify aspects of the above application you are submitting on: Traffic Issues on Paerata Road Impact on nearby businesses

The decision I/we wish the Council to make is (include any part of the application you wish to have amended and any conditions of a general nature): Oppose the planned supermarket, unless Paerata Road congestion is addressed with widening of the road, round-abouts, traffic signals.

I/we wish to be heard at the council planning hearing: No

Uploaded documents: New World Supermarket.docx

Head office: 1 Greys Avenue | Private Bag 92300, Auckland 1142 | 09 301 0101

440 441 442

FORM 13

SUBMISSION ON A NOTIFIED APPLICATION FOR RESOURCE CONSENT

To: Auckland Council Private Bag 92300 Auckland 1142

Name of Submitter: Fletcher Distribution Limited (trading as PlaceMakers)

This is a submission on a notified application for resource consent from Foodstuffs North Island Limited (“the Applicant”).

The application seeks to construct and operate a supermarket at 11-17 Paerata Road and 3 Comrie Place, Pukekohe. The Submitter operates a building and home improvement store on the adjoining property at 4 Comrie Place. The location of the property occupied by the Submitter, relative to the stated application site, is illustrated in Figure 1 below.

Figure 1 – location of Submitter’s leased premises (red) relative to the application site (white)

Page 1 of 4

443

The proposal is a retail activity in the Light Industry zone and requires a land use consent and stormwater discharge consent, to be assessed together as a non-complying activity. The application numbers assigned by the Council are LUC60302970 (for the land use consent) and DIS60302971 (for the discharge consent).

This submission relates to the following aspects of the application:

 Potential impacts of the proposal on flooding at the Submitter’s site; and  Potential impacts on the Submitter’s access due to supermarket delivery truck movements.

The Submitter opposes the application for resource consent unless these matters can be addressed to its satisfaction. The Submitter is not a trade competitors of the Applicant for the purposes of section 308A of the Resource Management Act 1991 (‘RMA’). The Submitter would be directly affected by the proposed development, the effects of which are adverse environmental effects that do not relate to trade competition or the effects of trade competition.

The reasons for the Submitter’s opposition are that the proposal:

 Is contrary to the sustainable management purpose of the RMA, and does not promote the wise use of natural and physical resources;  Is contrary to the principles expressed in Part 2 of the RMA;  Is inconsistent with objectives, policies and other provisions in relevant statutory planning instruments;  May generate significant adverse effects on the environment and, in particular, on the Submitter.

In particular, but without derogating from the concerns outlined above, the Submitter notes the following:

 The Submitter’s site is affected by flooding and sits within the flood prone area identified by the Council and within the Whangapouri Stream 1% AEP flood plain. While this existing condition is accepted, the Submitter opposes any action within the catchment that will exacerbate flooding risk on its site, through increases in flood depth, the extent of the flood plain, velocity of floodwaters, or the duration over which flood waters remain on its site;

 The Submitter’s site is located downstream of the application site. Both adjoining properties are affected by flood risk, as identified in Figure 2 below. Given the relative location of the two properties, there is significant potential for adverse flooding effects on the Submitter’s premises as a result of works within the existing flood plain on the application site;

Page 2 of 4

444

Figure 2 – location of Submitter’s premises (red) and application site (white) within the flood plain and flood prone area

 An engineering infrastructure report prepared by Stiffe Hooker Limited was submitted with the application. The report indicates that no works will be undertaken within either a flood plain or a flood prone area, because proposed flood mitigation drainage works will be in place prior to the commencement of bulk filling works. While this suggests that flood risk may be alleviated for the development that is proposed, the deposition of more than 6,000m3 of fill material within the flood plain will presumably reduce flood plain capacity and push the displaced water onto other properties. These potential effects are not considered or addressed in the infrastructure report;

 A flood risk assessment was also provided in support of the application, by CKL Stormwater Solutions. Again, the focus in the assessment is on the risk to buildings proposed on the application site with little or no consideration apparent in respect of flooding impacts experienced elsewhere in the catchment. From the limited information available, it appears that there would be an increase in the level of flood waters around the Submitter’s building. This is deduced from a comparison of the levels identified in Figure 4 (pre-development) and Figure 5 (post-development) from the CKL Stormwater Solutions flood risk assessment;

 The Submitter considers that it is not acceptable for development on a site to increase flood risk on other properties within a catchment. It is concerned that the proposal may have such an effect and requires that these matters are carefully addressed in order to demonstrate that no such effects would arise;

 The proposal seeks to provide for entry of delivery trucks from Comrie Place, utilising the land at 3 Comrie Place that forms part of the application site. This access will cross the Submitter’s site at 4 Comrie Place using a shared access formed over reciprocal right of way easements

Page 3 of 4

445

that also involve 3 Comrie Place. Notwithstanding this, part of the proposed access route appears to be contained within land that the Submitter has an exclusive lease over (as identified in Figure 1);

 The Submitter has a concern that its access will be subject to a significant increase in truck traffic, including from large vehicles that may impact on the convenient ingress and egress of its customers. While the Submitter acknowledges that the right of way over its access enables vehicle movements arising from the use of 3 Comrie Place, it questions the legality of using this right of way for vehicles that originate from a property that does not have any conferred right to use the easement over its land.

The Submitter seeks that the application be refused in its entirety, unless the concerns it has raised can be adequately addressed.

The Submitter wishes to be heard in support of its submission. If other parties make a similar submission, the Submitter would consider presenting a joint case with them at any hearing.

A copy of this submission has been sent to the Applicant, at its address for service.

Philip Brown Campbell Brown Planning Limited For and on behalf of Fletcher Distribution Limited, as its duly authorised agent

21 August 2017

Address for service of submitters:

C/- Campbell Brown Planning Limited PO Box 147001 Ponsonby AUCKLAND 1144

Attention: Philip Brown

Telephone: (09) 394 1694 Mobile: 021845327 Email: [email protected]

Page 4 of 4

446 447 448 From: Melanie Sopoaga on behalf of Resource Consent Authority To: Quentin Budd Subject: FW: Resource Consent submission for Pukekohe / Franklin - 11-17 paerata rd and 3 comrie place, pukekohe Date: Thursday, 17 August 2017 8:22:57 a.m.

From: Auckland Council [mailto:[email protected]] Sent: Wednesday, 16 August 2017 8:22 p.m. To: Resource Consent Authority Subject: Resource Consent submission for Pukekohe / Franklin - 11-17 paerata rd and 3 comrie place, pukekohe

If you have any queries about this request, please hit 'reply' to email us back, or send an email to [email protected] 1. APPLICATION DETAILS I/we wish to make a submission on the application of (name of applicant): Thomas Thumath Who proposes to (description of application from public notice): Construct and operate a supermarket APPLICATION SITE ADDRESS FROM THE PUBLIC NOTICE: Street number and name: 11- 17 paerata rd and 3 comrie place Suburb: pukekohe Application number: luc60302970 2. CONTACT DETAILS: Full name: Thomas colin clarkson - thumath I am a: Property owner Street number, name and suburb of the property, you are acting on behalf of: 38 Paerata Road Business phone: 0212575016 Home phone: 095520132 Mobile phone: 021 257 5016 Email address: [email protected] Address for correspondence: 38 Paerata Road, pukekohe, Auckland, 2120 3. SUBMISSION DETAILS: I/we: Oppose specify aspects of the above application you are submitting on: The proposed supermarket is located on a main road that cannot handle the peak hour traffic between 4 to 6pm. With the extra population of Wesley Town that the supermarket is supposed to serve, there is insufficient access to the site. There is an existing supermarket one kilometer further down the road, and another a further kilometer from that. The addition of a fourth supermarket although needed to serve the extra population is poorly situated at the proposed site. The reasons for my/our submission are: The increase in traffic overwhelming the current road infrastructure especially at peak times, well before the extra population has begun to utilize the proposed supermarket. The decision I/we wish the Council to make is (include any part of the application you wish to have amended and any conditions of a general nature): Decline the application at the proposed site as it is in a poorly situated area. I/we wish to be heard at the council planning hearing: No Uploaded documents: Having trouble reading this email? View it in your browser.

If you have any queries about this request, please hit 'reply' to email us back, or send an email to [email protected]

1. APPLICATION DETAILS

I/we wish to make a submission on the application of (name of applicant): Thomas Thumath

Who proposes to (description of application from public notice): Construct and operate a supermarket

APPLICATION SITE ADDRESS FROM THE PUBLIC NOTICE:

Street number and name: 11-17 paerata rd and 3 comrie place

Suburb: pukekohe

Application number: luc60302970

2. CONTACT DETAILS:

Full name: Thomas colin clarkson-thumath

I am a: Property owner

Street number, name and suburb of the property, you are acting on behalf of: 38 Paerata Road

Business phone: 0212575016

Home phone: 095520132

Mobile phone: 021 257 5016

Email address: [email protected]

Address for correspondence: 38 Paerata Road, pukekohe, Auckland, 2120

3. SUBMISSION DETAILS:

I/we: Oppose

449 specify aspects of the above application you are submitting on: The proposed supermarket is located on a main road that cannot handle the peak hour traffic between 4 to 6pm. With the extra population of Wesley Town that the supermarket is supposed to serve, there is insufficient access to the site. There is an existing supermarket one kilometer further down the road, and another a further kilometer from that. The addition of a fourth supermarket although needed to serve the extra population is poorly situated at the proposed site.

The reasons for my/our submission are: The increase in traffic overwhelming the current road infrastructure especially at peak times, well before the extra population has begun to utilize the proposed supermarket.

The decision I/we wish the Council to make is (include any part of the application you wish to have amended and any conditions of a general nature): Decline the application at the proposed site as it is in a poorly situated area.

I/we wish to be heard at the council planning hearing: No

Uploaded documents:

Head office: 1 Greys Avenue | Private Bag 92300, Auckland 1142 | 09 301 0101

450 451 452 RMA Submission Prepared for 9 Paerata Road

We, the owners of 9 Paerata Road oppose the proposal for the construction and operation of a Supermarket at 11-17 Paerata Rd & 3 Comrie Place as proposed in the information disclosed as part of the RMA application LUC60302970 and DIS60302971. The applicant’s site is immediately to the north of our property

The concept of the supermarket is one we are generally happy with, it's the effects of construction and permanent disadvantage to our property that places us in opposition.

In particular, we have concerns over flooding, construction effects and traffic / proximity of the vehicle access relative to our existing access way.

Flooding concerns.

The flooding investigation and proposed mitigation for the overland flow is all focused on the applicants site.

The AEE pg 18 states "Furthermore, the proposed development and flood mitigation system will ensure that the flood hazard existing in the area is not exacerbated for upstream or downstream properties."

We have not identified any assessment of effects the changes which will result on adjoining sites.

We are concerned that the acoustic wall and or building up of the site along the southern boundary of the site at 11 Paerata Road (northern boundary with 9 Paerata Road) is going to obstruct the overland flow water which currently enters 9 Paerata Road and flows north east into 11 Paerata Road (see Fig. 1).

453

Figure 1 Marked up Plan showing Acoustic wall and existing overland flows

An acoustic wall is a solid wall to ground level, we see no opportunity for water to flow away as it currently would when flow waters run over Paerata Road.

Additionally, any change to the ground level along this boundary is also going to have the same effect of preventing flow (ie. any increase in ground level will create a “dam” and cause ponding on our property).

From the plans provided it is not clear what the finished ground level will be on the applicants site either the new parking/access areas or the 2m planting that is proposed to be placed between the acoustic wall and boundary with 9 Paerata Road.

We ask that the impacts of overland flow and flooding are accessed and mitigated relative to 9 Paerata Road.

454 Traffic

The southern entry is proposed to be 2m (see Fig.2) from the existing entry to 9 Paerata Road. We are concerned with the large amount of traffic arriving from the south queuing and impeding right turning out of 9 Paerata Road. Left turning traffic from the supermarket is also going to impede access in and out of 9 Paerata Road.

We question John Burgesse’s statement (Fig.3), particularly the description "well clear", 2m is very close.

We also see the acoustic wall as a visual impairment to sight lines (to both driveways) as it will prevent approaching pedestrians or vehicles seeing vehicles waiting to leave either driveway.

Figure 2 Proximity of driveways, plan from engineering drawings provided.

Impact on immediate neighbours is not adequately addressed in the transport assessment. We notice that the transport assessment does not mention the existence of the businesses located at 9 Paerata Road.

455 We would like to see a more detailed investigation performed that considers our driveway and effects on vehicle turning movements (including visibility).

Figure 3 Exert from 7.4 Integrated Transport Assessment - John Burgess

Construction effects

The acoustic report provided details how the premise of the Dentist practice (9 Paerata Road) should be treated as a residential site for the purposes of noise and vibration assessment. We would like to see this as a condition of consent should consent be granted.

Our Tenant (9A Paerata Road) has expressed concern for their dental X-ray equipment located at the dental practice when subjected to blasting or rock breaking effects.

We have concerns regarding the proposed mitigation which includes only proposing rock breaking/blasting when the premises are not occupied (page 5 acoustic assessment). While this will mitigate effects on people, this does not protect any equipment installed in the building or the buildings themselves.

We request that an active approach to mitigate potential adverse affects is provided including pre and post construction building inspections, vibration monitoring, consultation with adjoining owners/occupiers and further consideration of any specific measures to protect sensitive equipment within the buildings.

456 From: Melanie Sopoaga on behalf of Resource Consent Authority To: Maxine Strydom Cc: [email protected] Subject: FW: Thank you for your submission Date: Monday, 21 August 2017 6:23:08 p.m.

From: Greg Smith [mailto:[email protected]] Sent: Monday, 21 August 2017 4:39 p.m. To: Resource Consent Authority Subject: Re: Thank you for your submission

Hello,

Can I please add another document to support this submission awe made.

Regards,

457 page1image256

Greg

On 21/08/2017, at 3:06 PM, Auckland Council wrote:

If you have any queries about this request, please hit 'reply' to email us back, or send an email to [email protected] 1. APPLICATION DETAILS I/we wish to make a submission on the application of (name of applicant): Foodstuffs North Island Ltd Who proposes to (description of application from public notice): Construction and operation of a new supermarket and ancillary retail/café tenancies along with associated parking and loading areas, vehicle accesses and signage APPLICATION SITE ADDRESS FROM THE PUBLIC NOTICE: Street number and name: 11- 17 Paerata Road and 3 Comrie Place Suburb: Pukekohe Application number: LUC60302970, DIS60302971 Applicant's email address: [email protected] Location of application site: Pukekohe / Franklin Main area to which the application relates: Resource Consents - district issues 2. CONTACT DETAILS: Full name: Greg & Cynthia Smith I am a: Property owner Street number, name and suburb of the property, you are acting on behalf of: 9 Paerata Road, Pukekohe Mobile phone: 021 775 010 Email address: [email protected] Address for correspondence: 54 Runciman Road, RD2 Pukekohe, Pukekohe, Pukekohe, 2677 3. SUBMISSION DETAILS: I/we: Oppose specify aspects of the above application you are submitting on: Please see attached document (9 Paerata.pdf) The reasons for my/our submission are: Please see attached document (9 Paerata.pdf) The decision I/we wish the Council to make is (include any part of the application you wish to have amended and any conditions of a general nature): Please see attached document (9 Paerata.pdf) I/we wish to be heard at the council planning hearing: Yes Uploaded documents: 9 Paerata.pdf Having trouble reading this email? View it in your browser.

458 If you have any queries about this request, please hit 'reply' to email us back, or send an email to [email protected]

1. APPLICATION DETAILS

I/we wish to make a submission on the application of (name of applicant): Foodstuffs North Island Ltd

Who proposes to (description of application from public notice): Construction and operation of a new supermarket and ancillary retail/café tenancies along with associated parking and loading areas, vehicle accesses and signage

APPLICATION SITE ADDRESS FROM THE PUBLIC NOTICE:

Street number and name: 11-17 Paerata Road and 3 Comrie Place

Suburb: Pukekohe

Application number: LUC60302970, DIS60302971

Applicant's email address: [email protected]

Location of application site: Pukekohe / Franklin

Main area to which the application relates: Resource Consents - district issues

2. CONTACT DETAILS:

Full name: Greg & Cynthia Smith

I am a: Property owner

Street number, name and suburb of the property, you are acting on behalf of: 9 Paerata Road, Pukekohe

Mobile phone: 021 775 010

Email address: [email protected]

Address for correspondence: 54 Runciman Road, RD2 Pukekohe, Pukekohe, Pukekohe, 2677

3. SUBMISSION DETAILS:

I/we: Oppose specify aspects of the above application you are submitting on: Please see attached document (9 Paerata.pdf)

The reasons for my/our submission are: Please see attached

459 document (9 Paerata.pdf)

The decision I/we wish the Council to make is (include any part of the application you wish to have amended and any conditions of a general nature): Please see attached document (9 Paerata.pdf)

I/we wish to be heard at the council planning hearing: Yes

Uploaded documents: 9 Paerata.pdf

Head office: 1 Greys Avenue | Private Bag 92300, Auckland 1142 | 09 301 0101

460 461 From: Melanie Sopoaga on behalf of Resource Consent Authority To: Maxine Strydom Subject: FW: Resource Consent submission for Pukekohe / Franklin - 11-17 Paerata Road & 3 Cromrie Place, Pukekohe., Pukekohe Date: Monday, 21 August 2017 6:20:14 p.m.

From: Auckland Council [mailto:[email protected]] Sent: Sunday, 20 August 2017 5:06 p.m. To: Resource Consent Authority Subject: Resource Consent submission for Pukekohe / Franklin - 11-17 Paerata Road & 3 Cromrie Place, Pukekohe., Pukekohe

If you have any queries about this request, please hit 'reply' to email us back, or send an email to [email protected] 1. APPLICATION DETAILS I/we wish to make a submission on the application of (name of applicant): Foodstuffs North Island Limited Who proposes to (description of application from public notice): Consent and operate a supermarket, being a retail activity in the Light Industry Zone. Land use consent and a storm - water discharge permit is required and assessed together as a non - complying activity. APPLICATION SITE ADDRESS FROM THE PUBLIC NOTICE: Street number and name: 11- 17 Paerata Road & 3 Cromrie Place, Pukekohe. Suburb: Pukekohe Application number: LUC60302970 & DIS60392971 2. CONTACT DETAILS: Full name: Jonathan Cameron & Michelle Knowles I am a: Property owner Street number, name and suburb of the property, you are acting on behalf of: 3/159 Edinburgh Street Mobile phone: 027 225 2914 Email address: [email protected] Address for correspondence: 3/159 Edinburgh Street, Pukekohe, Auckland, 2120 3. SUBMISSION DETAILS: I/we: Support specify aspects of the above application you are submitting on: We have no opposition to the proposed plans and feel it would be a good location and of great benefit to the community. The decision I/we wish the Council to make is (include any part of the application you wish to have amended and any conditions of a general nature): To approve the proposed activity. I/we wish to be heard at the council planning hearing: No Uploaded documents: Having trouble reading this email? View it in your browser.

If you have any queries about this request, please hit 'reply' to email us back, or send an email to [email protected]

1. APPLICATION DETAILS

I/we wish to make a submission on the application of (name of applicant): Foodstuffs North Island Limited

Who proposes to (description of application from public notice): Consent and operate a supermarket, being a retail activity in the Light Industry Zone. Land use consent and a storm-water discharge permit is required and assessed together as a non-complying activity.

APPLICATION SITE ADDRESS FROM THE PUBLIC NOTICE:

Street number and name: 11-17 Paerata Road & 3 Cromrie Place, Pukekohe.

Suburb: Pukekohe

Application number: LUC60302970 & DIS60392971

2. CONTACT DETAILS:

Full name: Jonathan Cameron & Michelle Knowles

I am a: Property owner

Street number, name and suburb of the property, you are acting on behalf of: 3/159 Edinburgh Street

Mobile phone: 027 225 2914

Email address: [email protected]

Address for correspondence: 3/159 Edinburgh Street, Pukekohe, Auckland, 2120

3. SUBMISSION DETAILS:

I/we: Support

462 specify aspects of the above application you are submitting on: We have no opposition to the proposed plans and feel it would be a good location and of great benefit to the community.

The decision I/we wish the Council to make is (include any part of the application you wish to have amended and any conditions of a general nature): To approve the proposed activity.

I/we wish to be heard at the council planning hearing: No

Uploaded documents:

Head office: 1 Greys Avenue | Private Bag 92300, Auckland 1142 | 09 301 0101

463 464 465 466 467 468 469 470 471 472 473 474 Auckland Council

Submission for Resource Consent LUC60302970 & DIS60302971

Foodstuffs North Island Limited – proposed building and operating a New World Supermarket on Paerata Road Pukekohe.

(1) Traffic: The proposal does not address the access to and from Crisp Avenue. It is directly opposite the proposed site. The traffic plan mentions a turning entry to the supermarket car park from Paerata Road for north bound traffic. Usually done by a stripped turning lane painted on the road. This will mean traffic turning right out of Crisp Avenue trying to head South – towards the main town centre and amenities – will be extremely difficult. North bound traffic will flow on the western side of the turning lane. As there is a secondary access road to a dairy and Motel about 5m into Crisp Avenue combined with the projected housing growth and therefore traffic volume increases this intersection will become congested. Turing either left or right will be extremely difficult at peak times.

(2) Pedestrian Access: The vast majority of residential properties are on the western side of Paerata Road: Shown in your 400m-1km radius diagrams. If they wanted to walk to the supermarket- where do they cross the main road? No provision for pedestrian crossings on Paerata Road. The local bus stop is also directly opposite the site and adjacent to the Crisp Avenue exit.

(3) Blasting: The statements about blasting and noise levels indicate that blasting will generally be within set limits. Change that to must be below the set levels. Ground shakes will occur with blasting. If any damage to residential properties occurs, who is responsible for repairs and or damages? Most of the dwellings closest to the site are brick- which does not tolerate ground movement without creating some problems (cracks etc)

(4) Traffic-trucks etc during construction. The reports indicate that while in construction heavy vehicles will exit the site through a southern access way on to Paerata Road. All site access and exiting traffic could and should use Comrie place access so to ease traffic congestion close to the roundabout at Seddon Street/Paerata Road.

(5) Food and other Food Waste. There are already 3 supermarkets in Pukekohe, they produce waste from food (fruit and vegetable) plus packaging of unsold items or old stock. How will these items be managed? Food scrapes – eg lettuce leaves, rotten fruit – can be a source of food for rodents which will thrive near the water way on the eastern side of the site.

(6) After hours: Car parks are great venues for skate boarders, hoons in cars etc. What provisions are in place for site management after hours?

The above factors, if not addressed, will have a significant impact on the real estate values of residents in Crisp Avenue. Particularly if vehicle traffic access is difficult.

Paul and Dianne Meads

475

476 From: Auckland Council To: Resource Consent Authority Subject: Resource Consent submission for Pukekohe / Franklin - 5 Crisp Avenue, Pukekohe 2120 Date: Sunday, 20 August 2017 8:32:46 p.m.

Having trouble reading this email? View it in your browser.

Auckland Council

If you have any queries about this request, please hit 'reply' to email us back, or send an email to [email protected]

1. APPLICATION DETAILS

I/we wish to make a submission on the application of (name of applicant): Paul and Dianne Meads

Who proposes to (description of application from public notice): Lodge a Submission

APPLICATION SITE ADDRESS FROM THE PUBLIC NOTICE:

Street number and name: 5 Crisp Avenue

Suburb: Pukekohe 2120

Applicant's email address: [email protected]

Location of application site: Pukekohe / Franklin

Main area to which the application relates: Resource Consents - district issues

2. CONTACT DETAILS:

Full name: Paul Henry Meads + Dianne Marion Meads

Organisation: Local Resident

I am a: Property owner

Street number, name and suburb of the property, you are acting on behalf of: 5 Crisp Avenue

Home phone: 09 2387605

Mobile phone: 021 238 6945

Email address: [email protected]

Address for correspondence: 5 Crisp Avenue, Pukekohe, Auckland, 2120

3. SUBMISSION DETAILS:

I/we: Neutral regarding the application

specify aspects of the above application you are submitting on: Transport access and

477 exit from Crisp Avenue-especially if turning south onto Paerata Road. A right hand turn towards the main township of Pukekohe and its amenities will become extremely difficult. See seperate uploaded file.

The reasons for my/our submission are: (1) Street Access-To and from Crisp Avenue. (2) Pedestrian Access. (3) Blasting baslt rock and its removal. The This is close to residential housing. Blasting and ground shakes if any damage structural or other who is liable? Who pays for such damage should it occur. (4) Site access during construction...should all be through Comrie Place (5) Food waste.Supermarkets create a significant amount of waste by unsold product. How will ii be managed?

The decision I/we wish the Council to make is (include any part of the application you wish to have amended and any conditions of a general nature): The above are the main factors that we are concerned about. The other really important factor is the impact on property values if access to Crisp Avenue is difficult.

I/we wish to be heard at the council planning hearing: No

Uploaded documents:

Head office: 1 Greys Avenue | Private Bag 92300, Auckland 1142 | 09 301 0101

478 From: Auckland Council To: Resource Consent Authority Subject: Resource Consent submission for Pukekohe / Franklin - 11-17 Paerata road & 3 Comrie Place, Pukekohe Date: Wednesday, 2 August 2017 9:05:14 a.m.

Having trouble reading this email? View it in your browser.

Auckland Council

If you have any queries about this request, please hit 'reply' to email us back, or send an email to [email protected]

1. APPLICATION DETAILS

I/we wish to make a submission on the application of (name of applicant): Foodstuffs North Island Limited

Who proposes to (description of application from public notice): to construct and operate a supermarket, being a retail activity in the light industry zone. Land use consent and a storm water discharge permit is required and assessed together as a non complying activity

APPLICATION SITE ADDRESS FROM THE PUBLIC NOTICE:

Street number and name: 11-17 Paerata road & 3 Comrie Place

Suburb: Pukekohe

Application number: LUC60302970 & DIS60302971

Applicant's email address: [email protected]

Location of application site: Pukekohe / Franklin

Main area to which the application relates: Resource Consents - district issues

2. CONTACT DETAILS:

Full name: Jacqueline Elliott

I am a: Property owner

Street number, name and suburb of the property, you are acting on behalf of: 10b Richardson avenue, Pukekohe

Home phone: 092380518

Mobile phone: 027 472 9102

Email address: [email protected]

Address for correspondence: 10b Richardson avenue, PUKEKOHE, PUKEKOHE, 2120

479 3. SUBMISSION DETAILS:

I/we: Neutral regarding the application specify aspects of the above application you are submitting on: mainly where the building is going to be.

The reasons for my/our submission are: our families main issue with this is it already takes ages turning right out of kayes road. and with more traffic coming from this proposed supermarket it is going to make it even harder. most of the people on our street end up turning right and going the long way around so we aren't sitting waiting for so long.

The decision I/we wish the Council to make is (include any part of the application you wish to have amended and any conditions of a general nature): Our family has no issue with the supermarket going in as long as they sort out lights or something that will help residents living on kayes road and off kayes road. you can't put something like that in and put lights for coming in and out of the supermarket and not help kayes road when there are so many issues now. and it's only going to get worse as the wesley subdivision finishes.

I/we wish to be heard at the council planning hearing: No

Uploaded documents:

Head office: 1 Greys Avenue | Private Bag 92300, Auckland 1142 | 09 301 0101

480 481 482