Casino Advisory Panel Report 30 January 2007
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Final report of the Casino Advisory Panel Recommendations to the Secretary of State for Culture Media and Sport on locations for one regional, eight large and eight small casinos allowed under section 175 of the Gambling Act 2005 30 JANUARY 2007 Final report of the Casino Advisory Panel Recommendations to the Secretary of State for Culture Media and Sport on locations for one regional, eight large and eight small casinos allowed under section 175 of the Gambling Act 2005 30 JANUARY 2007 1 Final report of the Casino Advisory Panel Contents NB: This report and many of the related documents can be found on the Casino Advisory Panel website at http://www.culture.gov.uk/cap/ Preface ................................................................................................................................................7 Summary..........................................................................................................................................8 Map of recommended areas............................................................................10 Part 1: Our work................................................................................................................11 Chapter 1: Panel appointment, our remit and criteria ...........................................................12 Background..............................................................................................................................................12 The appointment of the Panel ...........................................................................................................12 Membership of the Panel ....................................................................................................................13 Members’ interests ................................................................................................................................13 The Panel’s criteria .................................................................................................................................13 Consultation, openness, transparency and the views of the public .......................................15 How many casinos? ..............................................................................................................................15 Relationship of our remit to licensing and the problem of contracts.....................................16 Gaming duty ...........................................................................................................................................17 Chapter 2: Panel procedures..........................................................................................................................17 Our process..............................................................................................................................................17 Process phase 1: scoping and invitation of proposals.................................................................18 Process phase 2: submission of proposals, sifting and shortlisting .........................................19 Process phase 3: finalisation of the shortlists, further examination and testing of proposals......................................................................................21 Process phase 4: decision and reporting.........................................................................................26 2 Contents Part 2: General considerations (lessons learned).................27 Chapter 3: Best possible test of social impact ................................................................................28 What would be a good test? .............................................................................................................28 Particular demographic and social characteristics ........................................................................29 Local demographic and social data ..................................................................................................29 Ease of identification of social changes...........................................................................................29 Lessons from present casinos .............................................................................................................30 Likelihood and timeliness of implementation................................................................................30 The test and individual proposals......................................................................................................30 The test and the whole selection ......................................................................................................31 Chapter 4: Social considerations ................................................................................................................31 What is regeneration? ..........................................................................................................................31 Multiple deprivation ..............................................................................................................................31 Employment.............................................................................................................................................32 Ambient and impulse gambling ........................................................................................................32 Crime .........................................................................................................................................................32 Chapter 5: Some questions of regeneration ....................................................................................33 Government policy ................................................................................................................................33 Demand and economic modelling....................................................................................................33 Job creation .............................................................................................................................................35 Location, profitability and social benefit .........................................................................................35 Chapter 6: Willingness to license...............................................................................................................36 Part 3: Appraisal of proposals.........................................................................37 Chapter 7: Appraisal of the shortlisted proposals for a regional casino..................38 Blackpool ..................................................................................................................................................38 Cardiff........................................................................................................................................................42 Glasgow....................................................................................................................................................45 Greenwich................................................................................................................................................48 Manchester ..............................................................................................................................................51 Newcastle .................................................................................................................................................54 Sheffield ....................................................................................................................................................57 3 Final report of the Casino Advisory Panel Chapter 8: Appraisal of the shortlisted proposals for large and small casinos .......60 Bath and North East Somerset...........................................................................................................60 Bournemouth..........................................................................................................................................61 Brighton and Hove ................................................................................................................................63 Chelmsford ..............................................................................................................................................65 Chesterfield..............................................................................................................................................66 Dudley .......................................................................................................................................................68 Dumfries and Galloway........................................................................................................................69 East Lindsey..............................................................................................................................................71 Great Yarmouth......................................................................................................................................72 Hastings ....................................................................................................................................................74 Kingston-Upon-Hull...............................................................................................................................75 Leeds..........................................................................................................................................................77