Ad-Uo25 760 Military History of the American Revolution 1976
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
U.S. DEPARTMENT OF COMMERCE National Technical Informa'icn Service AD-UO25 760 MILITARY HISTORY OF THE AMERICAN REVOLUTION PROCEEDINGS OF THE MILITARY HISTORY SYMPOSIUM (6TH) HELD AT THE AIR FORGE ACADEMY, COLORADO, ON 10-11 OCTOBER 1974 OFFICE OF AIR FORCE HISTORY PREPARED FOR AIR FORCE ACADEMY 1976 Il MILITARY HISTORY OF THE * AMERICAN REVOLUTION ~**.* A NATIONAL TECHNICAL INFORMATION SERVICE Proceedings of the I'SAF' Academy - MILITARY' HISTORY ,OF THE AMERICAN REVOLUTPION L) C Lii - <STA-R.F~.TNT A The Mili'ary History Symposium is sponsored jointly by the Department of Hitory and thz Association of Graduates. U nited States \ir Force Academy 19974 ,Military History Sympos.ium Steering Committee: (ioioncl Alfred F. Hurley, Chairman Lieutenant Colonel Ph.lIp D. Caine Lieute).ant Colonel David Maclsaac Major Gary L. R. Anderson, Executive Director Captain Elliott V. Conmerse. Deputy Director Major Gares (larbet, Jr. Libmr• of (ongres (Caaloging in Publicjlion DIatY Military History Symposium, fitt, Unitcl States Air F-orce Academn 1974. Military history of the A,,erican keN omution. Sponsored by the Dep!. of Htistory mi, :he .,\ssociatzi mt (,raduaic,. United .%lates Air Force Academy. Includes index. Supt. of Docs. no.: D 301.78. 174 I United States- History- Rewolutio-. 1i775-1783-(. ,anpaigns .. ld battles- ongresses. I. Underdal. Staric.k I. Ii. United State., Air Fo cc Academy. Dept. of Histor\. III Ir ,ed States. Air oice Acadcnix. Associatioin of (Iradua,'.-I\.V I itle. E230.M48 1974 973.13" 75--6193$9 1-m •c b%b the% urrirnltendt-:,1 ol )ocurenlt I •. (,it et Ilaiig t.'t_ Ualknngion, !)b (. -(Ila)Z sit"~ Slifn ber (WN--(i103-1110 MII.ITARN HISTOR OF1 THIE AMERI( AN REAOL'TIJON The Proceedings of th, 6th Military History Symposium United States Air Force Academy 10-11 October 1974 Edited by Stanley J. Underdal, Major, USAF, Air Force Academy DDC ..................................................... U Li Office .:if Air Force History, Headquarters USAF and United States Air Force Academy Washington: 1976 " •I.-IN ;TATEMENT A App.c".-.' I," putlic release; DL.•kt ution Unlimited THE Null I ARI HIS-1 ()RI SI MPOSIA WF IHEr I 'AA, ACADE)IK 'he proceedings of- all the ;vrnpos*at but the first ai e as ailable post paid f'roni the Superintendent of IDo~unients. Li S (sos ernnent Printing ()f- ticc, \%asrtungion. D( 204W2. I - taN i 9@7.(Curre'nt ( oncepims in MiIitar -1hHworv. fPro'ccedingN not published. 2. NUN~ 1968. ( *otntandarai ( 'onmmnders in Modern If arlare (2n1d* ed., 1971), sto ck iurnhor )874-(XX)3. SI1.60) I . %Iav 1969. S'cience, I echnolog~.v an d Warlare( 1971. %ItOck number 08 74-(XX)2', S1 .25. 4. October 1970. SoIdier.%and .Stu wsinen (I1973) .'tOck number 0870-(X)335, S1lN ( 1915), 5. October 1972. The.4MduIrarv and Socwetv. stock n~umbher 00)8-070-WK367 -8 6. ( )ctoher 1' 1-4. Mtiurv Ihstorv ol OweA metrwaun Re~voliion. (197'6) stock lnumber (WS-070-(00'61-9. Present %olunic. \t'.s or opinions expre-ssed or implied in this publication are those of the au hors and ar, itv to be ,:onstrued as carrying of'ficial sanctioin of the Depar! niewi of t heAir 1-orct. or ot the Linited States Air F-orc, Academy.- C'ON-11ENT-S Page Introduction, M -ijor Stanley J. Underdal .................. First Session: THE 17th HARMON MEMORIAL I.LCTIVRL IN MILITARY HISTORY.. ........................ 13 Opening Remarks ................................ 15 "The American Re',olutioni oday," John Shy ......... Second Session: STRATE(GY REVISITED ................ 33 Chaii-nan: George Billias O pening Rem arks ................................ 35..3 'The Origins of British Strategy in the War tor American lndepende',ce," Ira D. (,ruber ............. 38 "American Strategy Reconsidered," Lieutenant Col.,:iel D)ave R. Palmer. UjSA ............ 52 Comm entary, Ce.'rge Billias ........................ 65 D iscussion ............ ...... ................. '4 B anq uet A dd ress ... .. .... ... .... ....... .. ......... 7.9 O peniatg Rem arks .......................... ..... 81 "A Seaman's Vie%• of the American Revolution,'" Rear Admiral John 1). Haves, USN Ret .............. 82 ThirdSesion: WHAT KIND OF WAR? . 89 Chairman: D;on Higginbotham O pening Rem arks ................................ 91 "Civil, Revolutionary, or Partisan: The Loyalists and the Nature of the War for Independence," Robert M . Calhoon ....... ..... ................ 93 "The Murder of the Militia System in ,he Aftermath of the American Revolution," Richard H. Kohn ...... 110 Corimenr.ry, Don Higginbotham .................... 12- "IDiicu ssio n . 131 Fourth Session: GENERALSHIP AND S01 DI-LRSHI' ... 135 Chairman: Tiheodore Ropp O pening Rem arks ................................ 1337 "Washington and His Lieutenants: Some Pr iblems in Command,"-George F. Scheer ................... 139 "The Common Soldier in the American Revolution,. John R. Sellers .................................. 151 (ommentarý. Theodore Ropp ....................... 162 D iscu ssio n . .. 164 Wral-UpScssion: THE SIXTH MILITARY HISIO()RV SYMPOSIUM IN PERSPECTiVE .................. 167 Chairman: John Shy Opeziing Remarks .............................. 169 Commentary, Linda Grant DcPauA .................. 1-2 Commentary, Squadron Leader John D. Biett. RAF ...... i'79 Commentary, LOUiS M orton ........................ 183 Discussior' ................................ ... 18" The Pa.-icipants ................................... 191 In d ex . .. 19 5 ~~ . ~ - - ~ ~ ~ ~ -~.I INTRODUCTION As we enter the Bicentennial anriiversary year commemorating out nation's independence, a flood of scholarly writings on he Revolut'onary War is being turned out by book publishers and scholarly periodicals. One special conference after anothei, together with a larger-than-usual riumber of sessions at the annual convention meetings of the major professional history organizations, is devoted to an examination of our Revolutionary heritage. In recent years historians have begun to ask new questions about the circumstances that surrounded the achievement of American in- dependence, have begun to examine the everyday aspects of life and death in that era, have emphasizeJ the study of society "from .he bottom up" instead of" from the top dow-'-," and have sharpeiaed their analytical skills through the use of new kinds of evidence and r.ew kinds of tools such as computer-assisted statistical runs. With the plethora of conference proceedings, articles and books now becoming readily available to the interested reader-enough to satisfy even the most gluttonous reading appetite--why shouid this publication be so presumptuous as to claim a degree of uniqueness that warrants aiten- •ion by scholars, students and interested laymen? Somehow in the midst of our celebratory scholarship, the military history of the American Revolu- tion, while certainly not being neglected by historians, has not been ac- corded a great deal of interest by the reading public. Perhaps that is because in the minds of many people so much of past military history has been "blood.-and-guts" battle history or self-serving accounts of how various high-ranking gene Als, by dint of fortune or ability, managed almost singlehandedly to "win" this or that war. Perhaps also our reac- tion to recent Ari-rican military involvements has caused an involuntary shrinking away from the study of military history exczpt by dedicated professional historians or by polemicists seeking evidence to support their belief that all military activities are evil and antithetical to basic societal morality. De.spite popular conceptions, not all military history is traditional iattle history or memoirs. Mary military historians are asking the sa4me questions -f their subect material and using the sdme new analytical tools as are their compatriot scholars in other areas of historical research. They also are looking at history from the bottom up to discover the roles of such neglected groups as women, children, Blacks and common soldiers in the various wartime generations. They also are examining more closely the decision-making process to discover why civilian leaders, commanders and soldiers act as they do. = , . ... .I 2 The Sixth Military History Symposium sought to bring together military historians of the American Revolution who were asking the new questios and using the new research lools. The result, we believe, was a blend of careful scholarship and provocative comment that commend.s it- self to anyone interested in the history of our nation's birth. Overarching the entire program was the subject ot .he annual Harmon Memorial Lec- ture, "The American Revolution Todty." Despite a sudden illness that prevented the participation of Professor Joho R. Alden of Duke University and the inconvenient calling of a British general election that demanded the presence (f Professor Esmond Wright of the University of London, the symposium began on schedule the morning of 10 October 1974. In ihe audience were more than 200 historians from the United States and Canada together with members of the Academy Cadet Wing, Academy staff and faculty. Colonel Alfred F. Hurley, Professor and Head of the Department of History, introduced the Academy Superintendent, Major General lames R. Allen, who welcomed the visitors and commented on the threefold purpose of the continuing symposia: to support orig.nal research in military history, to provide writ- ten contributions to military history through the publication of the sym- posia proceQdings, and to encourage Academy cadets to pursue further study ot their chosen