DOCSLIB.ORG

Duality of Space and Time.Pdf

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Duality of Space and Time.Pdf THE DUALITY OF SPACE AND TIME AND THE THEORY OF RELATIVITY B. Guy Ecole Nationale Supérieure des Mines de Saint-Etienne, 158, Cours Fauriel, 42023 Saint-Etienne Cedex 2, France e-mail: [email protected] Abstract Space and time concepts cannot be defined independently of each other; thus, there is a mathematical link between the corresponding parameters describing our physical world. An expression of this link is met in that, to-day, assessments of space and time standards are both derived from one single phenomenon, light movement, whose velocity is decided at an arbitrary mathematical value. A way to describe the space-time-associated reality is done by means of a phase-space frame where the position of the entities are represented with respect to each other without the need of a special time parameter. The “ extraction ” of a single time parameter from this frame is done by favoring, among all the physical entities, one that is assumed to be moving by itself (e.g. the photon), the position of which defines the time. Because time is related to position, one may give a pre- temporal significance to a three-dimensional spatial parameter. Three- dimensional pre-time, to which is associated three-dimensional space parameter through a tensorial duality, allows a straightforward expression of the consequences of space-time duality, particularly for frame transformations, with space and time parameters on an equal footing. If one wants to have a suitable connection between the physical descriptions of phenomena both in a mobile frame and in a rest one, the same ratio of space to time standards must be taken in both frames. As a result, effects similar to Lorentz transformation are obtained; they may be understood as picturing a non-Euclidean metrics for the mobile frame as represented in the rest frame. They may also be conceived as uncertainty relations connecting the values of time and space standards to that of light velocity. 1 Introduction In order to build a quantitative representation of the physical world, it is necessary to define a frame where the position and the time of the events are measured. By doing so, space and time co-ordinates are viewed as four independent parameters, setting up a four-dimensional mathematical frame. This frame is considered before any other frame, having a relative motion with respect to it, is examined; so it has been named “ rest frame ” since A. Einstein (1). The well-known associated changes for space and time co- ordinates in Special Theory of Relativity, only occur when a new moving frame with respect to the rest frame is considered. Inside the starting rest frame, space and time co-ordinates are supposed to be measured separately by use of rules and clocks; time measurements have a meaning in the whole frame after all the clocks, located at the different space points, have been synchronized. These operations and the assumptions on which they lie (rigidity of rules, punctuality of clocks etc.) have been abundantly discussed since Einstein. Paradoxically however, it happens today that space and time in the rest frame are not defined (nor measured) independently. Both are determined together by the same non-rest phenomenon: the displacement of an electromagnetic signal (2), (3). The velocity of this signal is inferred, or, rather, decided, to be constant; its value is chosen at an arbitrary mathematical value. In this context, space is no longer measured by rigid rods but by the time of light travel. Practically, space cannot be defined without time because measurement operations of space take time; more fundamentally, in order space has a physical meaning, its different parts must be connected by the time- consuming travel of a signal. For a located observer, true space and the distant objects that constitute it are always discovered through a time mediation. Conversely, time is correlated to displacement of light in space. It may be defined as the position of a photon. This situation takes us back to Aristotle who defined time by movement, time not being intrinsic but defined by the relative position of the objects. In a way, time and space thus appear as two points of view on the same reality. Only the relative positions and relative displacements of physical entities (material and light entities will be treated equivalently in our discussion) matter to build the physical 2 appearance of our world and thus to define space and time. The velocity of material entities can be divided by an arbitrary factor, or any velocity may be subtracted from all the velocities and no apparent change will result. Equivalently, any quantity may be subtracted from all the positions or times, with no change. On the whole, there is an arbitrary both on origin and scale, for positions, times and velocities of physical entities, and, again, there is something too much in counting space and time independently. At last, according to the above modus operandi, light is a physical phenomenon to be described within our representation of the world, and at the same time the tool to measure space and time: therefore it is no longer possible to define separately the velocity of light and the value of space and time units; we are in a circle. In short, time and space are computed as independent parameters within a four- (and not three-) dimensional frame, and, in the same time, are linked at the basic definition level. In the present paper, we propose a first quantitative assessment of this paradox and examine the question whether something may be discussed about space-time dimension and about time and space parameter independence. The paper will remain at a cinematic level; dynamical and electrodynamical questions will only be alluded to. Our theory does not bear on observational data. We think it will help discuss, and possibly solve, several internal inconsistencies in Relativity Theory that have been raised by many authors, and also give a new content to the formulae of Relativity Theory, that will be partly modified. Outline of the paper In first step (Sect. 1), we start with a 3-dimensional spatial frame, called E3, wherein the position of each entity of the universe is merely defined by the distance from the origin of co-ordinates. Each spatial coordinate may be duplicated by the light travel time from the origin. This is a first way to express the fundamental link between space and time co-ordinates and space E3 thus already has a temporal meaning. On this basis, a phase-space may be constructed, called Q3N, with the 3N co-ordinates of the N entities composing the universe. Velocities need not be represented in this phase- space for reasons that will appear clear in the sequel. 3 The second step (Sect. 2) will consist in favouring, among all the entities of the preceding universe, and thanks to postulates that will be indicated, one specific entity that is moving by itself (e.g. a photon), in order to define a time for the whole frame. This is another way to say that time was already embodied in spaces E3 and Q3N; so, a phase-space with an additional time parameter of the type Q3N+1 might actually be replaced by a timeless phase- space Q3N, and, by way of consequence, one dimension of standard space- time E3+1 may be seen as superfluous with respect to the three dimensions of timeless space E3. In other words, if a space such as E3+1 is compulsorily needed to draw the trajectories of physical entities from a practical point of view, one must know that this space is in part redundant, because the spatial axes already have a temporal meaning and the time axis already a spatial meaning. In phase space Q3N the trajectories of the entities are simply defined with respect to the other entities. Provisionally, the three spatial coordinates of the above photon allow to define a three-dimensional pre-time (that might equivalently be defined by three photons moving along the three co-ordinate axes). Pre-time coordinates are merely position coordinates that are computed separately from other spatial parameters and that serve as a basis to choose the ordinary time parameter. Together with the three spatial coordinates of the entities, the three temporal co-ordinates of the photon define an intermediate 6-dimensional frame, E6, that proves to be useful, in particular, to discuss frame changes. In third step (Sect. 3), we will examine more fully the case when starting three-dimensional space E3 is non-Euclidean; in that case, one is naturally led to give two associated tensorial characters (covariant and contravariant respectively) for the three pre-time and the three space co-ordinates of the photon considered at previous step. In fourth step (Sect. 4), we will be ready to consider the case of one moving frame with respect to another, either in the E3 (or E6) spatio-temporal representation, or in the Q3N phase-space representation; because of the fundamental link between time and space parameters, such frame movement may equivalently be viewed as an intrinsic unprecision on the space and time measurements within one single frame. The following sections (5, 6 and 7) will give a physical, Lorentz- transformation type, interpretation to the preceding results and discuss 4 corresponding equations for the three-dimensional time case. One important contribution of the three dimensional pre-time is to help connect moving frames when the relative velocity vector is arbitrary in three dimensional space (and not parallel to one axis), a situation that causes some difficulties in the classical Relativity Theory. In next section (8), we will sum up how to get back to a four-dimensional space (transition from E6 to E4), with a time with one dimension instead of three.
Load more

Recommended publications
  • The Sundial, Beyond the Form and Time
    ISAMA BRIDGES The International Society of the Mathematical Connections Arts, Mathematics, and Architecture in Art, Music, and Science The Sundial, Beyond the Form and Time ... Andrzej Zarzycki 227 Brighton Street Belmont, MA 02478 E-mail: [email protected] Abstract Architecture (iir" k 1-t].lk" ch ... r) n. 1. The art and science of designing and erecting buildings. Can a building inspire scientific thinking? Can an architectural structure reflect the complexity of the universe? Is there a relationship between the artistic and scientific? This paper discusses an approach to design, which uses an architectural structure as a research apparatus to pursue scientifically driven beauty. Architecture could be defined as the man-made universe - the universe whose primary function was to shelter us from elements, animals and other people. Broadly speaking, to protect us from the "outer Uni­ verse". It is not surprising that the evolution of architecture follows the same trajectories as the evolution of our thinking and perception ofthe surrounding world. However, somewhere along the lines of history, archi­ tecture acquired another purpose and began to playa new role in our self-awareness. In ancient, medieval and even modem times, we have viewed architecture as a medium to express, symbolize, and address the meaning of our existence. Ancient temples reveal an intimate knowledge of geometry and human perception by purposefully distorting their forms to balance visual illusions. Medieval cathedrals manifested greatness of God through art and structural achievements, while contemporary monu­ ments address the social and philosophical aspirations of a present-day society. As a result of this centuries long evolution~ we now associate architecture with its less utilitarian and more symbolic values.
    [Show full text]
  • History of Sundials
    History of Sundials The earliest record of the sundial dates back as early as 3500 BCE. At this time the ancient Egyptians were building tall, slender monuments from stone, called obelisks, which cast shadows that functioned like a sundial. Obelisks enabled people to divide the day into morning and afternoon, and they also showed the longest and shortest days of the year when the shadow they cast was longest or shortest at noon. Later on, additional markers were added around the base of the obelisk to indicate further subdivisions of time. Possibly the first portable timepiece came into use around 1500 BCE. Still a sundial, this was another Egyptian invention and it divided the day into ten parts plus two “twilight hours” in the morning and evening; was this the origin of the “twelve hour day” that we know today? Around 600 BCE the Egyptians came up with another invention, the merkhet (the oldest known astronomical tool), which allowed them to tell the time at night when there was no sun to cast a shadow. The merkhet worked in a similar way to a sundial: you would line up a pair of them in a north-south direction using the Pole Star, and then as certain stars crossed that line you would be able to tell what time it was. In the pursuit of year-round accuracy sundials gradually developed from their original shape, of a flat or vertical plate or surface, to much more elaborate forms. One version was a bowl-shape, cut into a block of stone, with a central vertical pointer (gnomon) whose shadow fell on lines marking sets of hour lines for different seasons.
    [Show full text]
  • A Modern Approach to Sundial Design
    SARENA ANISSA DR. JASON ROBERTSON ZACHARIAS AUFDENBERG A Modern Approach to Sundials DEPARTMENT OF PHYSICAL SCIENCES INTRODUCTION TO VERTICAL SUNDIALS TYPES OF VERTICAL SUNDIALS RESULTS Gnomon: casts the shadow onto the sundial face Reclining Dials A small scale sundial model printed out and proved to be correct as far as the hour lines go, and only a Reclining dials are generally oriented along a north-south line, for example they face due south for a minor adjustment to the gnomon length was necessary in order for the declination lines to be Nodus: the location along the gnomon that marks the time and date on the dial plate sundial in the Northern hemisphere. In such a case the dial surface would have no declination. Reclining validated. This was possible since initial calibration fell on a date near the vernal equinox, therefore the sundials are at an angle from the vertical, and have gnomons directly parallel with Earth’s rotational axis tip of the shadow should have fell just below the equinox declination line. angular distance of the gnomon from the dial face Style Height: which is visually represented in Figure 1a). Shown in Figure 3 is the final sundial corrected for the longitude of Daytona Beach, FL. If the dial were Substyle Line: line lying in the dial plane perpendicularly behind the style 1b) 1a) not corrected for longitude, the noon line would fall directly vertical from the gnomon base. For verti- cal dials, the shortest shadow will be will the sun has its lowest altitude in the sky. For the Northern Substyle Angle: angle that the substyle makes with the noon-line hemisphere, this is the Winter Solstice declination line.
    [Show full text]
  • Physics: Sundial Science
    Physics: Sundial Science MAIN IDEA Discover how the sun and its shadow is used to tell time by creating a sundial – an instrument that tracks the position of the sun to indicate time of day. SCIENCE BACKGROUND For centuries humans, have utilized the power of the sun as a light source, to grow food, and to tell time. Ancient civilizations used the sun to understand basic astronomy. By tracking the height of the sun in the sky, these civilizations developed calendars for the year and were able to identify harvesting and planting seasons (fall and spring equinoxes) all by tracking the movement of the sun. This also helped certain civilizations find the Equator, an imaginary circle around the Earth that divides it into two halves, the northern and southern hemisphere. By tracking the sun’s apparent position through the creation of sundials, these ancient civilizations were able to divide the day into morning and afternoon. A sundial is a device used to track time by marking a shadow on its surface as the sun moves. Light travels as a wave, similar to waves in the ocean. Shadows occur when this light wave is blocked by an object, creating a dark silhouette of that object on nearby surfaces as light continues to travel all around the object. Based on where the light source is, and the object that is blocking it, the shadow will look different. This is why for a sundial, the shadow will change throughout the day and even more noticeably throughout the year for the same time of day.
    [Show full text]
  • Reflection of Space-Time in Ancient Cultural Heritage of Urals*
    Open Access Library Journal Reflection of Space-Time in Ancient * Cultural Heritage of Urals Alina Paranina Herzen State Pedagogical University, St. Petersburg, Russia Received 9 July 2016; accepted 1 August 2016; published 4 August 2016 Copyright © 2016 by author and OALib. This work is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution International License (CC BY). http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ Abstract Based on the example of Shigir idols, the article reviews the possibility of using the ancient sacred objects as tools for orientation in space-time (according to dating of C-14, the age of the Grand Shi- gir Idol is 11,000 years). Author’s reconstructions of solar navigation technology are justified by: paleo-astronomic and metrological calculations; reflection of curve of shadow of the gnomon dur- ing the year in the proportions of the body and face of anthropomorphic figures; comparison of geometric basics of “faces” of Shigir idols, masks of Okunev stelae in Khakassia and vertical sundi- al on the milestones of the eighteenth century in St. Petersburg. The results show a rational as- signment of objects of ancient culture. Keywords Ancient Cultural Heritage, Shigir Idols, Okunev Stelae, Sundial and Calendars, Orientation in Space-Time Subject Areas: Archaeology 1. Introduction Big Shigir Idol is the most ancient wooden sculpture in the world, made of larch in the Mesolithic (radiocarbon age of 11,000 years). It is stored in the Sverdlovsk regional museum in Yekaterinburg (Russia). Unique arc- haeological object was discovered in 1890 by workmen of Kurinskiy gold mine, at depth of 4 meters of peat deposits of drained part of the lake, on the eastern slope of the Middle Urals.
    [Show full text]
  • Sundials – the Original Way to Tell Time
    Sundials – The Original Way to Tell Time Sundials were used by many cultures to help the people know what time it was. When the Sun was directly overhead and the shadows of people and objects were at their shortest, it was said to be noon. As technology advanced, clocks and watches took the place of sundials. However, these clocks and watches were still set and checked by using a sundial. Pocket/Portable Sundial Sundials are the oldest known instruments for telling time. The surface of a sundial has markings for each hour of daylight. As the Sun moves across the sky, another part of the sundial casts a shadow on these markings. The position of the shadow shows what time it is. The flat surface of a sundial is called a dial plate. It may be made of metal, wood, stone, or other materials. Numbered lines on the dial plate, called hour lines, show the hours of the day. A part called a gnomon sticks up at an angle from the dial plate. The sloping edge of the gnomon is called the style. As the day passes, the gnomon's shadow moves around the dial. Every hour it falls on a new hour line. Ancient Sundial The ancient Egyptians made the earliest known sundial in about 3500 BC. This sundial was simply a stick or a pillar that cast a shadow on the ground. The ancient Greeks made a sundial with a bowl-shaped opening cut into a block of stone or wood. A pointer in the center cast shadows inside the bowl.
    [Show full text]
  • Sundials in Medieval Islamic Science and Civilization J
    Sundials in Medieval Islamic Science and Civilization J. L. Berggren (Simon Fraser University, Burnaby, B.C. Canada) Sundials were ubiquitous in medieval Islam, open your mouth wide/ You will show all since their shadows showed when it was time to passersby the time of day.”5 The Arab perform the midday and afternoon prayers, two of conquerors would have encountered sundials the five prayers the Prophet Muhammad had everywhere they went and could hardly fail to prescribed for faithful Muslims.1 How these two have been impressed by a device that could, by daytime prayer times were defined in early Islam means of a shadow, tell how many hours of the is still an open question, but by the eighth century day had passed or how many remained until of our era they had come to be defined by the sunset, the beginning of the Muslim day. Around increase of the shadow over its minimum at the year 700, as early as 70 years after the midday. Thus, the midday prayer began just after beginning of the Muslim era, the Umayyad Caliph the noon shadow crossed the meridian, or when Abd al-Aziz, ruling in Damascus, used what the shadow had been observed to increase, or would undoubtedly have been a Graeco-Roman (in medieval Andalusia and North Africa) when it sundial for regulating the times of his prayers by had increased by ¼ the length of the gnomon. the seasonal hours.6 The afternoon prayer began when the shadow of a vertical gnomon exceeded the length of its Coupled with this visual impression was the noon shadow by the length of the gnomon, and it Muslim scientists’ high regard for their Greek ended either at sunset or when the excess of the predecessors.
    [Show full text]
  • Stemgems SIMPLE SUNDIALS
    SHORT DISCOVERY-BASED STEM EXPERIENCES gemsgems SIMPLE STEMBrought to you by SUNDIALS the NATIONAL AFTERSCHOOL ASSOCIATION Summer is a great opportunity to engage young people with the outdoors. This inexpensive experience uses a simple sundial to demonstrate how the Sun moves across the sky and connects young people to the spinning of the Earth. It is a great activity kick off exploration of time, history, astronomy and the weather. bigIDEAS WHAT DOES THE SUN HAVE TO DO WITH TELLING TIME? For thousands of years, humans have used the sun’s light and heat to regulate their activities. Early humans rose and retired with the sun. The sun’s path across the sky from east to west measured the progression of each day. Watching the Sun move across the sky you can see how easy it was for people living in ancient times to believe that the Sun actually moved around Earth. Ancient Egyptians believed that the Sun, which they called Ra, rose in the east, flew across the sky each day, set in the west, and then traveled beneath the Earth to start all over again the next morning. About 3,500 years ago, the Egyptians divided each day and night into twelve parts, for a total of twenty-four parts, or hours, in each day. They observed that each day, the sun appeared to move through an entire 360-degree arc in 24 hours. They also discovered that as the sun appeared to move, so did the shadows it cast. When the ancient Egyptians placed a stick straight into the sand, its shadow would rotate at a fairly steady rate of 15 degrees per hour.
    [Show full text]
  • Designing an Accurate Sundial for Clock Time
    Designing an Accurate Sundial for Clock Time Sundials are based on a simple fact: the Earth rotates once every 24 hours, exactly. The earth being 360 degrees around, like any circle, it rotates at 15 degrees per hour, exactly, or 1 degree every four minutes. So the Sun appears to move across the sky at 15 degrees per hour, and a shadow cast by the sun moves at the same rate. An axis aligned parallel with the Earth©s pole of rotation will cast a moving shadow on a band around it. Marks on the band can show the time according to the Sun. The most common sundial has a pointer, also called the gnomon or style, parallel to the Earth©s rotation axis, and a horizontal base marked with time lines. This article tells how to determine the angle of the time lines from the base of the pointer so that they show a time which, with a small correction, is the same as your local clock time. The angle of the pointer above the base is the same angle as the latitude where the sundial will be used. The angle of the time lines depend depend on both the latitude and longitude of the location. The correction comes in since the Sun©s path across the sky is not perfectly regular because the Earth©s orbit around the Sun is not circular but slightly elliptical. Also, the Earth©s equatorial plane is tilted from its orbital plane around the Sun. The combined effect causes the speed of the sun across the sky to vary a little during a year, so time shown by a sundial will differ from clock time.
    [Show full text]
  • Solar Matters II Teacher Page
    Solar Matters II Teacher Page Making A Sundial Student Objectives: The student will: Key Words • design, construct and demonstrate gnomon the use of a gnomon by constructing sundial a sundial • track the movement of a shadow cast by the gnomon over the course Time: of a day Sundial construction (20 minutes) • predict the length of shadow at a Recording shadows on dial (four 10 specified time. minute sessions) Reading, Science Journal and Materials: discussion (45 minutes) • paper plates, 9 in. white (1 per student) • plastic drinking straws (1 per student) • pencils (regular, red and blue) • rulers • scissors •tape • sidewalk chalk (white or yellow) • compass . Background Information A sundial is an instrument that indicates the time of the day by the shadow, cast on a surface of an object, marked to show hours or fraction of hours. Although any object whose shadow is used to determine time is called a gnomon, the term is usually applied to a style, pin, metal plate or other shadow-casting object that is an integral part of a sundial. It is not known when the sundial was invented, or who invented it. Sundials can be found in many ancient civilizations, including the Babylonian, Greek, Egyptian and Roman Ages. Sundials exist in most countries, in various forms, differing in construction according to the knowledge of astronomy and mathematics. Sundials are also abundant in the Far East and China and Japan, but not much is known in terms of their history. The earliest extant sundial, an Egyptian instrument of 1500 BC, is a flat stone on which is fixed an L-shape bar whose short vertical limb casts a shadow measured by markings on the longer horizontal limb.
    [Show full text]
  • The Astronomical League |
    ASTRONOMICAL LEAGUE A FEDERATION OF ASTRONOMICAL SOCIETIES A NON-PROFIT ORGANIZATION To promote the science of astronomy: By fostering astronomical education; By providing incentives for astronomical observation and research; By assisting communication among amateur astronomical societies. ASTRO NOTES Produced by the Astronomical League Note 10: What Time Is It? There are many methods used to keep time, each having its own special use and advantage. Until recently, when atomic clocks became available, time was reckoned by the Earth's motions: one rotation on its axis was a "day" and one revolution about the Sun was a "year." An hour was one twenty-fourth of a day, and so on. It was convenient to use the position of the Sun in the sky to measure the various intervals. Apparent Time This is the time kept by a sundial. It is a direct measure of the Sun's position in the sky relative to the position of the observer. Since it is dependent on the observer's location, it is also a local time. Being measured according to the true solar position, it is subject to all the irregularities of the Earth's motion. The reference time is 12:00 noon when the true Sun is on the observer's meridian. Mean Time Many of the irregularities in the Earth's motion are due to its eccentric orbit and tidal effects. In order to add some consistency to the measure of time, we use the concept of mean time. Mean time uses the position of a fictitious "mean Sun" which moves smoothly and uniformly across the sky and is insensitive to the Earth's irregularities.
    [Show full text]
  • The Equatorial Sundial Telling Time with the Sun
    Directions: Create a document to answer the Questions. That will be your report. Optional: Include a picture of yourself using the sundial that we can put on the Physics 90 public web page. The Equatorial Sundial Telling Time with the Sun Overview There are various kinds of sundials. The easiest kind to understand is the equatorial sundial. All sundials have to be adjusted for your latitude, longitude, and daylight savings time, but the adjustments for the equatorial sundial are the simplest, so that is what we’ll build. 1. Acknowledgements Usually acknowledgements go at the end of a document, but this document relies so much on the Sky & Telescope article, “How to Make a Sundial the Simple Way,” https://skyandtelescope.org/observing/how-to- make-a-sundial/, by Tony Flanders that the acknowledgement deserves to be at the beginning. In the United States, Sky & Telescope has long been the leading magazine for amateur astronomers, including some pretty serious ones. Consider subscribing for a year if you want to keep up with new discoveries in astronomy. It is not expensive. 2. Types of Sundials The most common kind of sundial is often found in gardens. In the most common kind, the face of the “clock” is level or horizontal, and so this kind is called a “horizontal” sundial. The reason we are not making the most common kind is that a level surface receives the shadow of the Sun in a distorted way, and the amount of the distortion depends on latitude. QUESTION 1. There is also a kind called a “vertical” sundial, that can be mounted on a wall.
    [Show full text]