Gender, Lineage, and Localization in Sri Lanka's
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
GLOBAL NETWORKS, LOCAL ASPIRATIONS: GENDER, LINEAGE, AND LOCALIZATION IN SRI LANKA’S BHIKKHUNĪ ORDINATION DISPUTE by TYLER A. LEHRER B.A., California State University, Sacramento, 2013 A thesis submitted to the Faculty of the Graduate School of the University of Colorado in partial fulfillment of the requirement for the degree of Master of Arts Department of Religious Studies 2016 This thesis entitled: Global Networks, Local Aspirations: Gender, Lineage, and Localization in Sri Lanka’s Bhikkhunī Ordination Dispute written by Tyler A. Lehrer has been approved for the Department of Religious Studies ________________________________________________________ Dr. Holly Gayley, Committee Chair Assistant Professor, Religious Studies ________________________________________________________ Dr. Deborah Whitehead Associate Professor, Religious Studies ________________________________________________________ Dr. Carla Jones Associate Professor, Anthropology Date _____________________ The final copy of this thesis has been examined by the signatories, and we find that both the content and the form meet acceptable presentation standards of scholarly work in religious studies. IRB protocol #: 15-0563 iii Lehrer, Tyler A. (M.A., Religious Studies) Global Networks, Local Aspirations: Gender, Lineage, and Localization in Sri Lanka’s Bhikkhunī Ordination Dispute Thesis directed by Assistant Professor Dr. Holly Gayley This thesis investigates many of the figures and events that have made full ordinations of Buddhist nuns (bhikkhunīs) both possible and contested in contemporary Sri Lanka. I draw on interviews and materials collected during the winter of 2015–16 to show how local actors cooperate across distinctions of nationality and Buddhist practice tradition to revive a defunct lineage. I argue that some of the previous scholarship on women’s renunciation in contemporary Sri Lanka conflates ‘international’ with ‘western,’ and privileges the local while forestalling a more nuanced analysis of the local-translocal exchange of speech and activism which constitutes one of the defining characteristics of the revival. I argue that these studies, while championing the voices of ten precept nuns and their everyday practices of renunciation, problematically assert that the current bhikkhunī ordination initiative represents the foreign incursion of western feminist speech which is at odds with the self-conception of Lankan renunciant women. In addition, I cast light on an emerging dimension of the bhikkhunī ordination mobilization not yet articulated in previous studies: the interrelationship between an already- gendered Islamophobic Buddhist nationalist discourse and support for nuns’ ordination as an integral step toward rescuing a Buddhist sāsana in decline. Although my findings here are still preliminary, I reveal a complex entanglement between geopolitical ethnic antagonism and the visibility of gender and gender roles in contemporary Sri Lanka through which the bhikkhunī ordination dispute is brought into visibility in a new way. Rather than as subjects to be rescued by western feminism, in this new discourse, Sri Lanka’s bhikkhunīs become agents of social service and moral restoration in local villages. Taken together, the central characteristics of these overlapping projects which enable and support bhikkhunī ordination suggest new ways of conceptualizing the enterprise with global implications and local sites of engagement, activism, and contestation. Through this, the themes of transnational cooperation, strategies of localization, and ethno-religious antagonism update our view of the contemporary revival and open up new questions for further analysis. Dedicated to my parents, Sharon and Rich. v ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS First and foremost, I would like to acknowledge and thank the many figures, named and unnamed, whose voices and stories appear in these pages. Their generosity of time and patience with my incessant curiosity have made the present study possible. Second, I would like to thank my thesis advisor Dr. Holly Gayley, and my committee members Dr. Deborah Whitehead and Dr. Carla Jones for the stimulating coursework, conversations, and mentoring that have helped shape my research trajectory and budding academic career in productive and fruitful ways. I hope the conversation does not end here. I would also like to thank the Department of Religious Studies and the Graduate School at the University of Colorado Boulder for providing me with a research grant to conduct the short period of fieldwork in Sri Lanka from which much of this thesis draws. I want to thank Professor Bandara Herath and Ramya for being such excellent Sinhala teachers and for their friendship over the past two years. From both classroom and home, they have given me the tremendous gift of a strong foundation in the Sinhala language which has opened up innumerable opportunities and horizons for study and cultural immersion. Finally, I wish to thank Dr. Anne M. Blackburn, Dr. Anne Hansen, Dr. Susanne Mrozik, and Dr. Emma Tomalin, with whom I have shared my ideas and research over the past months, and whose insights, feedback, and mentorship have helped to shape the present investigation. Any errors and omissions are my own. vi CONTENTS Chapter I: The Race to be First: An Introduction to Nuns’ Ordination in Contemporary Sri Lanka .......................................1 Introduction ..............................................................................................................................1 Theoretical Approach ...............................................................................................................6 Source Materials ......................................................................................................................9 Structure and Guiding Questions ............................................................................................14 Note on Language ...................................................................................................................16 Chapter II: A Lineage Interrupted: Following the Global History of Gendered Buddhist Renunciation ......................................18 Introduction .............................................................................................................................18 From Vesali to Dambulla: A Global History of Buddhist Women’s Renunciation in Sri Lanka ..........................................................................................................................20 Prior Scholarship on Buddhist Women’s Renunciation in Theravāda Practice .....................35 Conclusion ..............................................................................................................................50 Chapter III: “I Am the First Bhikkhunī:” Kolonnawe Kusuma and the Sakyadhītā International Association of Buddhist Women ......................................52 Introduction .............................................................................................................................52 Kolonnawe Kusuma, the First Bhikkhunī ...............................................................................57 The 1996 Sarnath Ordination ..................................................................................................61 Sakyadhītā and Global Feminist Discourse ............................................................................67 Inamaluwe Sumangala and the Dambulla-Bodh Gaya Bhikkhunīs ........................................76 Conclusion ..............................................................................................................................80 Chapter IV: Purity, Politics, and the Sāsana: Kirama Wimalajōthi and the Dekanduwela Bhikkhunī Training Center .............................82 Introduction .............................................................................................................................82 Kirama Wimalajōthi and the Bodu Bala Sena ........................................................................87 The BCC and the Dekanduwela Bhikkhunī Training Center ..................................................90 Wimalajōthi, Sumangala, and Islamophobia ..........................................................................97 International Training for Bhikkhunīs ....................................................................................101 Conclusion .............................................................................................................................106 Chapter V: Concluding Remarks .............................................................................................109 Overview ................................................................................................................................109 Limitations .............................................................................................................................111 Future Directions ...................................................................................................................113 Bibliography of Primary Sources .............................................................................................114 Bibliography of Secondary Sources .........................................................................................117 vii FIGURES, PHOTOS, AND MAPS 1. Bhikkhunīs paying respect to their teacher (author photo: Horana, December 2015) ..............9 2. Cave temple painting of Saṇghamittā giving