Big Sur Multi-Agency Advisory Council Friday, June 19, 2020 10:00 A.M

Home , Big Sur land use, California condor, Pfeiffer Beach, Pine Ridge Trail

Big Sur Multi-Agency Advisory Council Friday, June 19, 2020 10:00 a.m. – 1:00 p.m.

Virtual Meeting Join Online: https://montereycty.zoom.us/j/98722307255 Join Via Telephone: 1-669-900-6833 or 1-346-248-7799 Webinar ID: 987 2230 7255

Congressman Jimmy Panetta and Supervisor Mary Adams, Co-Chairs*

I) CALL TO ORDER - 10:00 a.m.

II) ROLL CALL AND INTRODUCTIONS

III) APPROVE MINUTES OF November 1, 2019

IV) PUBLIC COMMENT ON NON-AGENDA ITEMS

V) NEW BUSINESS - 10:30 a.m. a) Offshore Wind Presentation by representatives from CA Department of Energy, Navy, BOEM, and NOAA

VI) OLD BUSINESS - 11:30 a.m. a) Brief Status Updates on ongoing issues (1-2 minutes) i) CHP Housing – CHP and California State Parks ii) Log Jam(s) on Big Sur River – California State Parks iii) Wayland Bridge Replacement – California State Parks iv) Restrooms, including Garrapata and other locations – California State Parks, USFS, others v) Big Sur Byway Committee Formation - Board of Supervisors vi) Cell phone coverage issues – Congressman Panetta’s Office

VII) REPORTS FROM MEMBER AGENCIES (please bring written report) a) Big Sur Resident Member, North Coast b) Big Sur Resident Member, South Coast c) Big Sur Chamber of Commerce d) Community Association of Big Sur e) Monterey County Planning Department f) Monterey County Board of Supervisors g) Monterey Peninsula Regional Park District

h) California Coastal Commission i) Caltrans j) State Parks and Recreation k) Monterey Bay National Marine Sanctuary l) United States Forest Service m) 30th District, State Assembly n) 17th District, State Senate o) United States Congress

VIII) REPORT FROM OTHER AGENCIES ON ISSUES PERTINENT TO BIG SUR

IX) NEXT MEETING: September 18, 2020

X) ADJOURNMENT - 1:00pm

For minutes and agendas from 2017 forward, please visit: http://www.co.monterey.ca.us/planning/cca/BSMAAC/bsmaac_main.htm

BIG SUR MULTI-AGENCY ADVISORY COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES FOR NOVEMBER 1, 2019 PFEIFFER BIG SUR LODGE CONFERENCE CENTER PFEIFFER BIG SUR STATE PARK, BIG SUR

I. CALL TO ORDER Supervisor Adams called the meeting to order at 10:03 am. She made several changes to the meeting agenda: • Under New Business, moved the Big Sur Health Center presentation to go first as item a.; and • Under Old Business, moving the Caltrans TDM presentation to item a., and moving cell phone coverage issues to item c.

II. ROLL CALL AND INTRODUCTIONS Roll call and introductions were made. BSMAAC members in attendance included Martha Karstens (Resident of Big Sur – North Coast), Anneliese Agren (Resident of Big Sur – South Coast), Kirk Gafill (Big Sur Chamber of Commerce), Pam Peck (Big Sur Community Association), John Dugan (Monterey County Resource Management Agency), Mike Watson (California Coastal Commission), Supervisor Mary Adams (Monterey County, District 5), John Palaniuk (Monterey Peninsula Regional Park District), Karen Grimmer (MBNMS), Sara von Schwind (Caltrans), Brent Marshall (California State Parks), Fin Eiffert (USFS), Robert Rivas (California Assembly, District 30), Colleen Courtney (California Senate, District 17), Kathleen Lee (US Congress, District 20).

III. APPROVAL OF MINUTES: The August 23, 2019 minutes were approved. IV. PUBLIC COMMENT ON NON-AGENDA ITEMS: • Rick Aldinger asked if Caltrans could explain what was accomplished at Bixby Bridge and Hurricane Point. Sara von Schwind responded that the project included shoulder widening and explained that the culverts were in disrepair and degraded and had to be replaced. They expected to be complete at the end of November. • Mike Caplin shared progress on the California Coastal Trail, including that the maps were recently updated to show the first draft of the proposed alignments, that they are available ton the website for the project, and that you can also sign up for e-mails about it on the website. • Carrie Frangioso mentioned updated research on sudden oak death. • Dana Carnazzo made a request for Caltrans to discuss the entrance to Old Coast Road. • Aengus Jeffers thanked those who provided community letters of support for Blaze. He shared that they have resolved all issues with everyone willing to site down, but that there are outstanding issues with Sierra Club and Donaldson including the Rural Community Center designation and Visitor Serving Commercial zoning. He asked if people who were concerned to please share comments with Coastal Commission staff. The next steps are for the Coastal Commission to make a substantial issue determination on the appeal. Mike Watson stated he is accepting interested parties and comments. Dana Carnazzo added this is very important.

- 1 -

DRAFT BSMAAC November 1, 2019 Minutes

V. NEW BUSINESS: a) Big Sur Health Center Presentation • Carrisa Chapalett, chair of the Big Sur Health Center board, shared that they have been serving the community for 40 years. They are a non-profit organization that provides health care and support to the fire brigades. They have been doing strategic planning because they have outgrown their facility. They have a new building designed and some possible funding but need a site for it. They requested to have an agenda item about this at a future BSMAAC meeting.

b) State and Local Regulations on Defensible Space and fire fuel management – Monterey County Resource Management Agency and California Coastal Commission • Supervisor Adams opened the presentation acknowledging that fire preparedness is a critical issue to everyone in the state and the trauma with the current fires in Sonoma. She introduced County Resource Management Agency staff Carl Holm and John Dugan, as well as CalFIRE Chief David Fulcher and Big Sur Fire Brigade Chief Matt Harris. • John Dugan began the discussion about defensible space and how to protect residences and other structures while not violating the rules. The primary regulation for defensible space is defined by Public Resources Code 4291, which sets standards for fuel management within 30 feet and 100 feet of habitable structures in rural areas. He then described the Coastal Act and the delegation of authority to local agencies through certified plans and policies that address related issues such as environmentally sensitive habitat areas (ESHA), visual resources, forest resources. Plans and policies are implemented through individual coastal development or administrative permits. • Mike Watson continued with a description of the relationship between the County and the Coastal Commission. He described that the Coastal Act contains a range of topics and resource policies that are covered by four Local Coastal Plans (LCP) in the County, including the Big Sur LCP, as well as by Title 20 of the Monterey County code and implementation programs. These describe how to protect resources, but also how to protect life and property. He acknowledged that the policies can be at cross purposes at times, for example hazards and ESHA, but that it is not insurmountable to resolve possible inconsistencies. He gave examples of permits that have been issued along these lines. • John Dugan then noted other plans and regulations that apply to fire preparedness and defensible space, including the Monterey County Community Wildfire Protection Plan (CWPP), inclusion of Wildfire Urban Interface areas in the California Building Code that went into effect in 2008, as well as other federal regulations about erosion control, flood control, etc. He shared a handout that is intended to explain how the County balances CalFire guidelines on how to manage fire fuel which includes some things that can be done without a permit. The County does not charge any fees for an over the counter review of a landscape plan to verify this. He noted that they confer with Coastal Commission staff on areas where questions and potential conflicts come up. They seek to aid property owners, but sometimes the issues transcend the County to state and federal regulations. He stated that there would be opportunities for continued dialogue.

- 2 -

DRAFT BSMAAC November 1, 2019 Minutes

Public comment: • Martha Karstens asked if within the 100 feet if she can weed eat and limb up the trees. • Anneliese Agren asked whether Big Sur Fire Brigade is doing inspections. • Matt Harris responded that they have a CalFire grant to do community mapping with fire fighting infrastructure and that they can help identify issues at the same time. They will be pursuing additional grants for a chipping programs and supporting property owner responsibilities. They will be communicating on these opportunities via CABS, road associations, as well as with individual property owners, and that information is also available on their website. • Pam Silkwood thanked County staff. She noted that they have come a long way since 2010 in recognizing that it is not an intent to clear out Big Sur, but to create defensible space. • Mike Caplin disagreed with the County’s presentation, stating that they still do not understand defensible space. He believes the Public Resources code only provides minimum regulations and that they should not be limited to 100 feet. Even though it is not required, people should be able to go beyond. He stated that there are vast area of California that are overgrown with vegetation that would burn. • Mike Emmett, President of the Fire Safe Council, stated that he had helped author the CWPP and that it is available on their website. He noted that the issue of conflicted regulations is discussed in the plan. He thanked the presenters for bringing the issue forward and stated that it is time to start talking about solutions. He gave examples like the National Strategic Fire Protection Plan, the Tahoe Basin approach as described in the Emergency Tahoe Basin report. It concludes that protection of life and property and protection of the environmental must be prioritized in that order, with fuel reduction as a priority for public safety. • Marty (?) spoke of the personal experience of a neighbor whose insurance was requiring a 200 foot clearance. She stated this is an ongoing process, as vegetation will grow back. • Dana Carnazzo was concerned about Pampas grass as another big issue. She stated it is something you have to stay on top of and asked how we can work to keep invasive plants from coming back and spreading. • A member of the public stated that they agree about vegetation clearance, but that it is also as important to fire proof homes. Vegetation maintenance is ongoing and there is a lot of fuel, so structural fire proofing also needs to be balanced, for example with new roofs. • Another member of the public asked a question about foaming and other preventative mitigations. They requested additional information from the fire agencies about these options. • Matt Harris responded that there are some things you can have on hand, and that fire trucks have fire foam and gel, but there are complexities with them. • David Fulcher, CalFIRE Chief, observed that everything being talked about has an effect, and that there are interactions between all of the measures that can be taken. He mentioned the 45-day projects that CalFIRE has been implementing. He noted that there are new laws and building codes that are all part of a greater process and that you cannot focus on just one aspect. He also noted that there are current grant programs that are open to do some of the things we should do. - 3 -

DRAFT BSMAAC November 1, 2019 Minutes

• Dan Kieg asked if there is a difference between the County staff’s position and the Land Use Advisory Committee. • John Dugan stated that it is in the details of differing definitions of ESHA and that the County didn’t believe they have the authority to override the policies of the LCP. Ultimately any proposed changes to the policies would have to be approved by the Board of Supervisors. • Steve Beck gave thanks to Mike and Pam for all of their hard work. He said he was glad to see the RMA handouts and that there was a lack of knowledge about clearing that they help explain. He appreciated the comments about structural fire protection, and figuring out how to live with fire. In some cases it may be best to shelter in place. • A person who is a renter noted that their landlord had provided hydrogel but that it had expired. • Dana Carnazzo shared that her home is constructed with fire safety in mind, and that she recommends metal and cement. • Mike Caplin asked how many people were clear on what to do, and that he thought it was still not crystal clear. He stated that we have an overgrown County and asked if we will have to go through more fires in order to get the regulations changes. He requested that the Board of Supervisors ask the governor to declare an emergency and suspend regulations. He asked Supervisor Adams to ask County Counsel to investigate if this is feasible. • Martha Diehl stated that she doesn’t believe people will get in trouble for doing necessary work. • Assembly member Robert Rivas mentioned that a number of bills had been introduced but they won’t necessarily be enacted, stating that he was surprised they hadn’t been called into special session. He said he would share more in his comments, and that he would be happy to work with the County. • Colleen Courtney spoke on behalf of Senator Bill Monning, stating that their office would like to hear from people who are having trouble getting insurance renewals. • Dan Kieg state that he was cited by the County for taking down trees during the Soberanes fire. • Michael Emmett encouraged review of the CWPP recommendations. He noted that the Fire Safe Council has brought in $2-3M in grants but there is concern about the costs associated with environmental review and that projects are constrained by regulations. • Mike Caplin gave examples of where fire regulations have been in conflict, e.g. the County fining someone for removing a dead tree, and Fire Safe Council grants where they had to leave a grant incomplete because of dead tan oaks being in a creek/riparian area. He asked the County and State to ask the Governor to suspend these kinds of regulations. • Supervisor Adams closed the discussion stating that her office would follow up and have discussions with other agencies to explore the request.

VI. OLD BUSINESS: a. Caltrans Big Sur Transportation Demand Management Plan • John Olenik from Caltrans gave an overview presentation on the draft plan (see power point attached). - 4 -

DRAFT BSMAAC November 1, 2019 Minutes

• Mike Caplin asked if the TDM Plan acknowledges the CABS Destination Stewardship Plan that is being underway and whether they dovetail. • John responded that they wouldn’t be inconsistent but would be reinforcing. He noted that the best thing about plans like the TDM is that they can lead to funding. • Steve Beck stated that he had read the plan, and that he was happy about several things in it, for example the goal for real time data. He hopes for bike lanes and he was glad the plan looked at other ways the highway is used but noted that bike lanes are not being included in Caltrans maintenance projects. • Mary Ann Georgine commented that the shuttle to Pfeiffer Beach idea is good, but that if the same amount of cars are still being allowed in it would not address the problem. She suggested a reservation system. • A member of the public commented that bikes actually cause traffic jams. They asked if they would be able to inform people of time delays and noted that it hinges on the communication network. • Anneliese Agren commented that the south coast meetings are 2 hours away and suggested use of technology. • A member of the public commented about off highway parking capacity may be a limitation and asked whether there was consideration of where people can park. They asked if this is all contingent upon new infrastructure. • John responded that implementation will need to include expanded services.

b. Big Sur Byway Committee Formation • Supervisor Mary Adams said she is still following up on formation of the byway committee and that she is reopening nominations to the committee in order to recruit additional names. Her office has since met with Caltrans, State Parks and the Forest Service to further discuss how to make the most of the new committee. • John Olenik commented that the Byway Committee is called for in the Coast Highway Management Plan, and that the new TDM plan will be an element of the CHMP. He said that the Byway Committee can be an implementing entity but now there seems to be renewed energy to do it. • A member of the public asked whether the Byway Committee could look at undergrounding of utilities and John responded yes, because that is a recommendation in the CHMP.

c. Cell Phone Coverage Issues • Kathleen Lee gave an update on communications infrastructure issues. She first noted that AT&T had been invited to the BSMAAC but had been unable to attend this meeting. They had met the prior week and focused on copper infrastructure and land line work, but it hadn’t started yet. Business leaders in the community were helping to impress upon AT&T that this is a problem for the community and encouraged people to contact the CPUC to help put pressure on them, and to call AT&T directly to make requests for land line work. • She then gave an update that the Post Ranch Inn cell project had also been delayed due to engineering issues and missing the construction window. More broadly, expansion of cell service is going to require AT&T to make a better business case for services to be added. They are now pursing a legislative effort with Safenet. The PG&E public safety power shutoffs has highlighted how this is an issue throughout rural California.

- 5 -

DRAFT BSMAAC November 1, 2019 Minutes

• Kirk Gafill commented that the Point Sur cell tower had been offline and was subject to going offline with the power shutoffs, showing the need for a back up power source. He said they are looking at January 2020 and there were challenges with the approach to the back up system. He said they hadn’t been able to identify a willing property owner for citing a new tower. AT&T doesn’t have an incentive to improve the infrastructure, and there is a need to engage through the CPUC, FPCC and state elected officials to get them to make the changes the community is looking for. He stated this is going to be a team effort. • Anneliese asked about Viasat. • Michael Wisner asked about the CPUC and whether it was in their charter that the utilities need to serve less populated areas. He said he thought the CPUC must have a policy about that. • Martha Diehl commented that there is more than one way to get a job done, and that in addition to pressuring the CPUC, there is a need to help all carriers to understand the market in Big Sur with visitors and the number of trips down the coast being much larger than the number of residents. • Steve Beck shared that over the last few months he had spent over 400 hours dealing with AT&T and asked why there wasn’t further effort on a Verizon cell tower. He suggested Mount Manual and considering state and federal lands. • Brent Marshall responded that AT&T needed to coordinate with State Parks because of the bridge work at Point Sur. He said it was a nominal lease cost for that site on state lands and that Verizon didn’t bid. AT&T is interested in locations at Buzzards Peak and Captain Cooper School. • A member of the public mention that they have satellite, and that maybe it could help service the area. • A member of the public shared that there is a category on the complaint for rural services, and they had gotten a quick response. • Mike Caplin shared his experience of how he ended up switching to satellite and suggested it should be considered a national security issue. • Diana Valentine commented that they are responsible for lots of people at their resort and asked without communications how can they get emergency services. Matt Harris responded that AT&T has provided Big Sur Fire Brigade with satellite phones, but they are very costly. Someone else noted that AT&T had brought an emergency generator to their tower at Palo Corona.

d. Brief Status Updates i) CHP Housing – Brent Marshall share that the CHP permits had been approved and that they were now expecting to be done by the end of next year ii) Garrapata State Park Restrooms – Brent Marshall shared they had met with Joe Sidor at the County and were preparing to submit an application. They’ve had evaluations for archaeology and natural resources protection and done tribal consultations. iii) Log Jam on the Big Sur River – Brent Marshall had no updates. His staff Mathew Allen is assisting with this issue. iv) Wayland Bridge – Brent Marshall commented that this was on going and that there is some complexity and a funding issue. v) Restrooms, including Garrapata and other locations – California State Parks, USFS, others – no updates.

- 6 -

DRAFT BSMAAC November 1, 2019 Minutes

VII. REPORTS FROM MEMBER AGENCIES: a. Martha Karstens, North Coast Big Sur Resident, provided a written report and asked folks to see her notes.

b. Annalisa Agren, South Coast Big Sur Resident, handed out a map. She thanked State Parks that things were better at JP Burns, and mentioned Caltrans, USFS, elected officials, CABS and the Red Cross for a south coast emergency site.

c. Kirk Gafill, Big Sur Chamber of Commerce, shared that visitor levels were still below the peak levels.

d. Pam Peck, Community Association of Big Sur, said that Butch was at another meeting. She gave an update on destination stewardship, that they had secured County funding, contracted with Costas Christ, and were doing outreach and conducting traffic counts. She said there will be more stakeholder meetings to come. There will be more of an update at the December CABS meeting. They hope to have a first draft by March with proposed plans and projects, and a final draft by June. They are continuing to work on a Sycamore Canyon shuttle plan for next summer. More than 1,000 people from around the world have taken the Big Sur Pledge. The Caltrans TDM is an important plan.

e. John Dugan, Monterey County Resource Management Agency announced that there with be a LUAC meeting in January and that the annotated draft LUP update was out.

f. Supervisor Mary Adams, Monterey County, mentioned that she had made a referral about improving enforcement on roadside camping, that the timeline for the short term rental ordinance had been pushed back, and that she had nominated Big Sur Kate (Novoa) as one of the Veterans of the Year.

g. John Palaniuk, Monterey Peninsula Regional Park District, shared that the Palo Colorado fuel break had been done, that Mill Creek was still closed, that they are leading hikes at San Jose Creek, and that they are working on setting up an incident comment location at Palo Corona Regional Park.

h. Mike Watson, Coastal Commission, announced that the Coastal Commission had approved the ordinance for a one year outdoor cannabis cultivation program at the November meeting, that he was working with Caltrans on Mud Creek and Paul’s Slide, and that they are commenting on the proposed Limekiln bridge replacement project. He noted that there was 3rd party appeal of the Blaze project and to give him contact information if you want to be noticed about that project. He had just received the LUP update from the County but hadn’t had a chance to look at it yet. He suggested that he would plan to pull out the fire policies to possibly move forward with those separate from a larger effort.

i. Sara von Schwind, Caltrans, shared that they were completing Paul’s Slide and would end the one-way signal by January. They will be doing pre-emptive closures with an emailed press release with details. Mud Creek would be looked at independently from Paul’s Slide, but possible that both could be closed at the same time. They are starting their project at Big Creek - 7 -

DRAFT BSMAAC November 1, 2019 Minutes

and it may have some one-way traffic controls. She referred to their project list, noting #4, culvert replacements, #7 widening shoulders and guardrail replacement.

j. Brent Marshall, State Parks, shared that they were doing the Naval Facility tours while the light station was done. State Parks has revitalized a number of ideas for how it can be used within the existing plan. The Central Coast Lightkeepers are working on a fencing project and improving the highway side. They are closely following the Limekiln bridge replacement project.

k. Karen Grimmer, MBNMS, shared that the water quality program was planning the first fliush monitoring with a half dozen sites in Big Sur. She mentioned research activity related to a nautilus & octopus garden that Ruben Lasgard is looking at in Point Sur Canyon. She mentioned that their Law Enforcement TAC would be meeting in December in Cambria to address poaching and wildlife interference. They are holding a drone use workshop in December to look at use in general and best practices. There has been a lot of activity around whale entanglement and there is a training coming up for volunteers.

l. Fin Eiffert, U.S. Forest Service, mentioned the strategic community fuel break proposed with support from Jamie Tuitele-Lewis at the RCD. It is a joint grant between the USFC and NRCS with the intent of doing vegetation management on 1400 acres. They have signed good neighbor agreements for the Mescal and Hennesey ridge for the State’s fuel break projects. The Pine Ridge Trail decision memo was signed in September, and crews were starting to do the trail work. He expressed gratitude for his first year of working in his position, for working together with the community, shared efforts and intelligent and rational solutions.

m. Assemblyman Robert Rivas, commented that he has learned so much about how to be an effective advocate for this region, noting that he represents parts of four counties and multiple cities. He said these meetings help him learn, and that he is working with other state elected on regional issues. Solutions are complex and may work in some areas but not others. He noted bills he has worked on related to farm worker housing as an example. He also mention a bill that had passed providing new oil spill protections for non-floating oil. He said he is anticipating issues with PG&E and the considerations if there is a move to break PG&E up. He said housing and homelessness are going to continue to be major issues.

n. Colleen Courtney, on behalf of Senator Bill Monning, thanked CalFIRE Chief Fulcher for his attendance. She appreciated the Caltrans TDM plan meetings and incorporation of community comments. She noted that the PG&E power shut offs had affected areas throughout the district and that the priority right now was responding to roughly 400 fires. She asked for people to contact them if they are having problems with their fire insurance. She noted that they are following the Monterey Peninsula’s water situation but were not seeking to influence the Coastal Commission. She said Senator Monning does support the Pure Water Monterey Project and the Measure J feasibility study.

o. Kathleen Lee, on behalf of Congressman Jimmy Panetta, commented that obviously DC has been an interesting place, and that congress was voting on starting the impeachment process that week. Regardless, legislation still occurs. She said they had been hearing comments about staffing shortages and deferred maintenance needs at Los Padres National Forest, with - 8 -

DRAFT BSMAAC November 1, 2019 Minutes

information needed for the next budget. They are working on a farmworker/workforce mobilization bill, noting labor shortages in agriculture. Their office has secured an additional $1.6M from FEMA for Palo Colorado. They had approximately 400,000 contacts to their office this year.

VIII. REPORTS FROM OTHER AGENCIES ON ISSUES PERTINENT TO BIG SUR None.

IX. NEXT MEETING March 20, 2020 at 10am.

X. ADJOURNMENT Supervisor Adams adjourned the meeting at 1:17 p.m.

- 9 -

BIG SUR HIGHWAY 1 SUSTAINABLE TRANSPORTATION DEMAND MANAGEMENT PLAN BSMAAC

DESIGN WORKSHOP | LSC November 1, 2019 TIMELINE

• Last meeting we discussed potential strategies • We refined them over the summer to determine opportunities for Highway 1 PURPOSE • Transportation Demand Management: • Develop viable alternatives to driving • Identify support strategies needed to shift use patterns

• Identify potential electric vehicle charging stations

• Knowledge transfer toolkit

• Build upon the 1986 Big Sur Land Use Plan 2004 CHMP • Corridor Aesthetics • Landslide Management & Storm Damage Response • Vegetation Management BUILDING FROM THE BIG SUR COAST HIGHWAY MANAGEMENT PLAN & BIG SUR LAND USE PLAN

2004 CHMP: “essential Big Sur Coast experience that is simply to be in a rugged natural environment and enjoy the spectacular views.” • Traveler Experience Core Value: …The need to provide access must uphold the value of preserving the informal visitor experience and be balanced with adequate resource protection to ensure appreciation and enjoyment of these resources for generations to come. 1986 LUP: “Visual access should be emphasized… as an appropriate response to the needs of visitors.” VALUES

• Organized yet Independent Travel

• Iconic Visual Access of Primary Importance

• Respect for Environment and Community

• Responsive and Action- Oriented with Adaptive and Innovative Strategies

• Balanced

• Inclusive TDM OPPORTUNITIES • Primary: • Transit and Shuttles • Shared Use Shoulders & Paths • Travel Info • Support Facilities: • Build confidence that facilities are available • Address issues affecting overall travel experience for residents and visitors • Support corridor exploration • Data collection for adaptive management TRANSIT OPPORTUNITIES • What We Heard • Support exploration • Provide access to high demand destinations to manage congestion • Coordinate with Park IT! • Consider EV opportunities • Focus on visitor use of transit • Consider private shuttle opportunities • Opportunities • Through Corridor Transit • Point Lobos Shuttle • Big Sur Shuttle • Pfeiffer Beach Shuttle • Private Shuttles TRAVEL INFORMATION OPPORTUNITIES • What We Heard • Coordination with how the area is marketed • Big Sur Pledge – visitor ethic • Visitors don’t know where facilities are • Signage in the viewshed to be limited and of the right character • Ability for all visitors to understand • Opportunities • Multi-Agency Visitor Hubs

• Coordinated signage • Reinforcing desired user behavior • Marketing campaigns INFRASTRUCTURE OPPORTUNITIES • What We Heard • Need to provide access to visitor facilities • Slow vehicles impact experience • Lack of technology infrastructure limits communication opportunities and constrains emergency response • Roadway geometries could constrain transit opportunities • Support for public EV charging • Opportunities • Restrooms • Slow vehicle turnouts • Paved viewpoints • Technology • Geometric improvements • Electric vehicle charging stations ACTIVE TRANSPORTATION OPPORTUNITIES • What We Heard • Opportunities • Provide space for road • Shared Use Shoulders cyclists where possible • Shared Use Paths • Leverage other projects • Pedestrian Facilities to create shared use • California Coastal Trail shoulders • Encourage biking to destinations • Address pedestrians along highway • Consider opportunity for the Cal. Coastal Trail DATA COLLECTION OPPORTUNITIES • What We Heard • Need for up-to-date, accurate information for decision-making

• Opportunities • Permanent traffic count locations • Annual visitor information • Additional visitor data and travel information PARKING MANAGEMENT OPPORTUNITIES • What We Heard • Strategies are complex and interconnected • Hwy 1 is only access to Big Sur for employees, residents, and visitors – need to meet all needs • Need to address and provide access to parklands • Address parking

• Opportunities • Focus on high demand visitor locations • Utilize management systems ADAPTIVE MANAGEMENT PARTNERSHIPS & BYWAY ORGANIZATION • Partnerships • Byway Organization • Collaboration needed to • Recommend priorities implement TDM • Clarify issues • Confirm priorities & lead • Provide forum for projects stakeholder to be heard • Establish roles and • Help interpret plan responsibilities, funding, & recommendations operational agreements HOW TO COMMENT • Website • www.sustainablehighway1.com/ • Contains Public Draft Document, Appendices, and Display Boards • Provide written comments in the “Comments” link • Send comment letters to [email protected] • By December 9, 2019 www.sustainablehighway1.com .Big Sur Multi Agency Advisory Council report June 19, 2020 10:00

Big Sur Resident member, (north coast) -- Martha Karstens.

The Round up cost has gone up to $11 due to the rising costs of ink and paper.

Big Sur Historical Society Museum is waiting for the County guidelines to determine if and when we will reopen.

The Grange has taken the opportunity with not being used to take care of some dry rot projects and has been painted.

CERT report:

We started a zoom CERT training in early May and will do our final hands on practical training on June 20th. This will bring 17 new CERT members on board to assist with any community needs going forward!!

The trees that were near the edge of the highway just south of Fernwood have been removed, thank you to whoever did the work. There is still the log jam just downstream from the church that needs attention.

Martha Karstens

BSMAAC South Coast Report – June 2020 Any questions? Please message me at: [email protected]

USFS - Visitor Use Management program needed! Forest Closure of 3 roads April 16. Closure lowers traffic counts on https://www.fs.fed.us/recreation/programs/nvum/ Los Burros and South Coast Ridge, but Plaskett continues to receive • Tom Collins introduced us to USFS’ Visitor Use Management high volume and orange cones and Road Closed signs are moved framework and asks for it to manage visitors within Ventana, LPNF, by public who continue to camp. and Silver Peak Wilderness. • Sally Christ of Big Sur Destination Stewardship Plan reports that “A number of comments received describe issues around backcountry access, camping, etc.” Please let's pursue a Visitor Management Plan. "... to collaboratively develop long-term strategies to manage the amounts and types of visitor use to achieve desired conditions and improve access, connect visitors to key experiences, and protect resources." https://visitorusemanagement.nps.gov

South Coast 3 dirt roads Traffic Counts Graph:

Purpose for the Closure: "These roads, trails, and trail-heads are drawing increasingly heavy vehicle traffic and large groups of people, creating Compare traffic counts to Residents, not all residents drive the road circumstances where social distancing is not possible. Additionally, every day. some roads, trails, and trail-heads are located adjacent to South Coast Ridge: + 15 residents residential properties and could potentially contribute to exposure Plaskett: about 7 residents risks to local residents. Roads and trails may create unmanageable Los Burros: about 30 residents vectors for further community spread of COVID-19." BSMAAC South Coast Report – June 2020 Any questions? Please message me at: [email protected]

Highway Events still planned in 2020 Gratitude List • • September 12: Best Buddies Bikes for IDD Isolation Carmel to Get Well Soon CHP John! Your South Coast community is keeping San Simeon. www.bestbuddieschallenge.org/hc you in our thoughts and sends you good vibes for your recovery. • October 5-7: Arthritis Foundation California Coast Classic Bike for arthritis - 250 riders. Carmel to Thank Caltrans for the information posted on the message boards at Cambria. https://events.arthritis.org/index.cfm?fuseaction=donord north and south of Highway 1 into Big Sur. rive.event&eventid=944 • October 10-11 dates to be confirmed: Tour de Fresh. Thank you USFS for immediate response to fire on Plaskett and offer www.tourdefresh.com to residents for clearance of risky areas, and for the closure of roads. • October 16-18: Challenged Athletes Foundation. www.challengedathletes.org/events/million-dollar-challenge Thank you Big Sur Fire for immediate response to fire on Plaskett and for coverage of so much South Coast activity.

Thank you CABS for weekly COVID-19 Community meeting and its minutes.

Thank you to CHP, CA F&W, MoCo Sheriff for patrolling South Coast.

Daily/Weekly/Monthly totals Avg 2019-12-01 to 2020-06-30 (213 days) Daily Totals 500

400

300

200

100

0 2019-12 2020-01 2020-02 2020-03 2020-04 2020-05 2020-06 2020-07

Avg Weekly Totals* 1500

1000

500

2019-12-012019-12-092019-12-232020-01-062020-01-202020-02-032020-02-172020-03-022020-03-162020-03-302020-04-132020-04-272020-05-112020-05-252020-06-082020-06-22 Avg Monthly Totals* 6k

0 2019-12-01 2020-01-01 2020-02-01 2020-03-01 2020-04-01 2020-05-01 2020-06-01

Los Burros NF- SCRRoad Plaskett Los NF- Date Plaskett Notes Burros SCRRoad 2019-12-31 Color Key: Counts should be halved for 2020-01-01 inbound/outbound of one vehicle. 2020-01-02 83 88 95 2020-01-03 112 130 142 Red Numbers = Car counts over 100 - Peak Counts. 2020-01-04 98 204 123 -January had 8 peak counts. 1 holiday weekend. 2020-01-05 64 88 80 2020-01-06 73 42 70 -February had 12 peak counts. 1 holiday weekend. 2020-01-07 102 61 72 2020-01-08 85 37 51 -March had 13 peak counts. No holiday weekend. 2020-01-09 96 45 41 Schools closed. Stay at home order 2020-01-10 111 61 82 statewide/countywide. 2020-01-11 124 106 115 2020-01-12 146 59 117 -April had 5 peak counts in its first 8 days. 2020-01-13 56 28 39 2020-01-14 121 28 43 2020-01-15 78 29 35 2020-01-16 42 21 22 2020-01-17 85 88 51 MLK Weekend 2020-01-18 159 170 154 MLK Weekend 2020-01-19 127 141 159 MLK Weekend 2020-01-20 65 70 126 MLK Weekend 2020-01-21 69 33 59 2020-01-22 62 44 78 2020-01-23 67 61 44 2020-01-24 80 73 74 2020-01-25 74 131 89 2020-01-26 63 100 89 2020-01-27 44 39 70 2020-01-28 89 36 41 2020-01-29 67 36 44 2020-01-30 61 18 45 2020-01-31 81 117 48 2020-02-01 123 207 120 2020-02-02 51 93 73 2020-02-03 48 29 62 2020-02-04 85 41 44 2020-02-05 63 53 54 2020-02-06 70 43 56 2020-02-07 80 92 119 2020-02-08 94 162 187 2020-02-09 88 175 98 2020-02-10 80 56 46 2020-02-11 76 56 51 2020-02-12 57 40 38 Los NF- Date Plaskett Notes Burros SCRRoad 2020-02-13 63 34 66 Color Key: Counts should be halved for 2020-02-14 173 178 184 Presidents Day Weekend 2020-02-15 365 425 416 Presidents Day Weekend 2020-02-16 257 465 444 Presidents Day Weekend 2020-02-17 135 188 208 Presidents Day Weekend 2020-02-18 74 45 90 2020-02-19 76 78 60 2020-02-20 80 49 80 2020-02-21 93 53 96 2020-02-22 111 165 178 2020-02-23 75 112 117 2020-02-24 67 32 55 2020-02-25 107 38 43 2020-02-26 58 50 62 2020-02-27 87 33 77 2020-02-28 96 73 144 2020-02-29 100 164 151 2020-03-01 94 132 122 2020-03-02 77 44 72 2020-03-03 67 63 52 2020-03-04 68 46 57 2020-03-05 104 39 40 2020-03-06 93 98 85 2020-03-07 107 62 95 2020-03-08 84 65 86 2020-03-09 61 39 83 2020-03-10 66 36 40 2020-03-11 46 32 52 2020-03-12 76 51 76 2020-03-13 110 63 84 2020-03-14 71 69 71 2020-03-15 38 38 44 On this day Gavin Newsom announced bars and winery closures, restaurants need to reduce and/or offer delivery/curb service, and 65+ must isolate. 2020-03-16 45 26 64 SF announces city quarantine with all bizniz closing except grocery, RX, and banks.

Newsom asks restaurants to do take-out only Los NF- Date Plaskett Notes Burros SCRRoad 2020-03-17 46 41 76 TheColor Counties Key: Counts of Marin, should Contra be halved Costa, for Alameda, Santa Clara, San Mateo, Santa Cruz and San Francisco order a Shelter In Place beginning March 17, 2020.

County of Monterey Health Officer has issued a Shelter- in-Place Order effective at 12:01 a.m. on March 18, 2020 and will continue to be in effect until April 7, 2020.

Mendocino, Monterey, San Benito and Sonoma counties adopt shelter-in-place orders, while Ventura County tells at-risk residents (i.e. those over 70-years old with health conditions and over 75 in general) to shelter- in-place. Even more counties declare local emergencies, and many adopt bans on gatherings larger than 10 to 50 people (depending on the county) and discourage meetings in general.

2020-03-18 72 76 118 7 more counties adopt shelter-in-place orders. 2020-03-19 126 83 154 Statewide shelter-in-place order issued. Governor Newsom issues a stay at home order to protect the health and well-being of all Californians and to establish consistency across the state in order to slow the spread of COVID-19. 2020-03-20 115 131 190 2020-03-21 142 143 249 2020-03-22 93 87 104 2020-03-23 93 37 54 Newsom closes parking lots to state beaches and parks to reduce gathering.

Fifteen states have now followed California’s lead in ordering residents to stay at home, covering 158 million Americans. 2020-03-24 69 30 56 2020-03-25 63 58 100 2020-03-26 80 69 96 2020-03-27 76 109 204 2020-03-28 177 149 181 USFS Forest Order 20-02 closes Developed Recreation Site and developed campgrounds, except trailheads. Effective March 28, 2020 through April 30, 2020

2020-03-29 113 98 98 2020-03-30 87 87 103 2020-03-31 168 68 137 Los NF- Date Plaskett Notes Burros SCRRoad 2020-04-01 141 108 144 Color Key: Counts should be halved for 2020-04-02 143 95 173 2020-04-03 192 142 202 2020-04-04 167 138 141 2020-04-05 59 70 52 2020-04-06 48 29 64 2020-04-07 131 23 65 2020-04-08 62 22 77 2020-04-09 49 26 64 2020-04-10 122 126 177 Easter Weekend 2020-04-11 205 227 326 Easter Weekend 2020-04-12 102 145 152 Easter Weekend 2020-04-13 92 39 67 2020-04-14 75 65 88 2020-04-15 94 66 156 USFS closes South Coast trails and dirt roads to all except residents and authorized persons until June 1. (Plaskett is mistakenly not included.) 2020-04-16 89 83 106 2020-04-17 43 55 213 2020-04-18 48 55 101 2020-04-19 42 8 84 2020-04-20 25 4 91 2020-04-21 37 6 54 2020-04-22 44 6 96 2020-04-23 27 16 205 2020-04-24 73 21 137 2020-04-25 76 22 173 2020-04-26 35 15 113 2020-04-27 38 20 115 2020-04-28 44 9 94 2020-04-29 38 15 73 2020-04-30 31 22 69 USFS extends road/trail closure to May 15. 2020-05-01 68 18 118 2020-05-02 48 30 131 2020-05-03 48 14 74 2020-05-04 33 19 72 2020-05-05 39 18 58 2020-05-06 49 12 67 2020-05-07 22 16 106 2020-05-08 47 20 159 2020-05-09 48 16 139 2020-05-10 46 13 70 Mother's Day 2020-05-11 46 18 84 2020-05-12 40 15 64 2020-05-13 32 10 78 2020-05-14 45 20 73 Los NF- Date Plaskett Notes Burros SCRRoad 2020-05-15 53 25 94 ORDERColor Key: NO. Counts 05-07-00-20-09 should be halvedextended for to June 1 for developed recreation sites/campgrounds 2020-05-16 32 43 141 ORDER NO. 05-07-00-20-09 extended to June 19 for developed recreation sites/campgrounds 2020-05-17 30 37 52 2020-05-18 40 4 59 2020-05-19 36 16 64 2020-05-20 46 14 144 2020-05-21 73 13 79 2020-05-22 68 23 222 Memorial Day Weekend Friday 2020-05-23 60 38 376 Memorial Day Weekend Saturday 2020-05-24 80 43 396 Memorial Day Weekend Sunday 2020-05-25 75 22 200 Memorial Day Weekend Monday 2020-05-26 69 22 109 2020-05-27 59 32 106 2020-05-28 48 38 101 2020-05-29 57 43 149 2020-05-30 39 48 133 2020-05-31 32 45 123 2020-06-01 49 20 134 Coastal USFS trailheads reopened. 2020-06-02 51 23 160 USFS Forest Order No. 05-07-51-20-12 extended to June 14 for road closures USFS extends target shooting ban to December 31. 2020-06-03 69 35 289 Fire on Plaskett reported at 11:03 a.m. NUMBERS WILL BE HIGH DUE TO FIRE PERSONNEL TRAFFIC 2020-06-04 56 40 250 Fire on Paskett Day 2. 2020-06-05 57 21 262 2020-06-06 91 32 167 2020-06-07 42 39 87 2020-06-08 46 18 130 2020-06-09 47 21 67 2020-06-10 86 27 109 Week starting Los BurrosNF- SCRRoadPlaskett 2019-12-01 2019-12-02 2019-12-09 2019-12-16 2019-12-23 2019-12-30 625 893 770 2020-01-06 737 411 548 2020-01-13 668 505 503 2020-01-20 480 512 559 2020-01-27 516 546 441 2020-02-03 528 595 620 2020-02-10 1,071 1,254 1,245 2020-02-17 644 690 829 2020-02-24 609 522 654 2020-03-02 600 417 487 2020-03-09 468 328 450 2020-03-16 639 587 955 2020-03-23 671 550 789 2020-03-30 957 708 952 2020-04-06 719 598 925 2020-04-13 483 371 815 2020-04-20 317 90 869 2020-04-27 315 128 674 2020-05-04 284 114 671 2020-05-11 278 168 586 2020-05-18 403 151 1,340 2020-05-25 379 250 921 2020-06-01 415 210 1,349 2020-06-08 418 154 714 2020-06-15 2020-06-22 2020-06-29 Month starting Los BurrosNF- SCRRoadPlaskett 2019-12-01 2020-01-01 2,670 2,257 2,375 2020-02-01 2,932 3,229 3,419 2020-03-01 2,727 2,169 3,043 2020-04-01 2,372 1,678 3,672 2020-05-01 1,508 745 3,841 2020-06-01 1,782 828 4,965 BIG SUR CHAMBER OF COMMERCE

Big Sur Multi-Agency Council Member Report

Date: June 19, 2020 Zoom Meeting

As of June 12, 2020, virtually all visitor serving businesses in Big Sur were permitted to re-open subject to modification per CAL/OSHA industry re-opening guidelines.

For those businesses that were able to open in late May for Dining In and In Store Shopping, business levels have running from 25-50% with gradual increases each day. With re-opening of lodging for leisure and campgrounds as we go into summer, visitation levels are expected to increase significantly.

Primary challenges for visitor serving businesses in this period are recruiting additional employees to meet COVID-19 related health and safety standards to ensure employee and guest safety and increased seasonal demand for staffing to align with business levels. Thus far, a significant number of employees who have been recalled to duty have needed additional time off to attend to childcare and at-risk care giving due to schools, day care facilities, and other services being unavailable.

Additionally, while the enhanced Federal unemployment benefit of $600 per week has been of great importance in providing for workforce economic health and stability and the attendant benefits to employers to have their work force be available when they re-open, it now appears to be a potential disincentive for unemployed workers to return to the work force in many positions as employers begin to recall employees.

Further, most visitor serving businesses are constrained from achieving normal or peak capacity revenue opportunities due to social distancing requirements to reduce occupancy in their businesses. Thus, businesses are faced with higher costs to ensure employee and guest health and safety and lower revenue opportunity in many cases.

Visitor interest and desire to come to Big Sur remains quite high and we anticipate being able to accelerate our economic rebound as the scenic and rural attributes of our area and location between the Bay Area and Southern California are well situated to benefit from the primary drive market travelers who are expected to be in the vanguard of the travel industry recovery.

Respectfully submitted,

Kirk Gafill President

PROJECT APPLICATIONS IN BIG SUR County of Monterey Resource Management Agency – Planning ACTIVITY BETWEEN OCTOBER 9, 2019 AND JUNE 2, 2020

The following projects are currently active within the Big Sur Coast Land Use Plan area or have been decided since October 9, 2019. Changes are highlighted:

FILE # APPLICANT AREA PROPOSED USE PLN200048 FOSTER STEVEN L NO ADDRESS AMENDMENT TO APPLY A SCENIC EASEMENT OVER THE REMAINING BUILDING ENVELOPE (PLANNER: JOE & GILLIAN R TRS ASSIGNED TO PARCEL, AREA(S) ON TWO PARCELS. THE PROPERTIES ARE LOCATED ON ROCKY CREEK ROAD, LOTS 1 SIDOR) ET AL BIG SUR AREA AND 8 OF THE ROCKY CREEK RANCH SUBDIVISION, BIG SUR [NO ADDRESSES ASSIGNED TO PARCELS] (ASSESSOR'S PARCEL NUMBERS 418‐132‐001‐000 AND 418‐132‐008‐000), BIG SUR LAND USE PLAN, COASTAL ZONE. PROJECT SUBMITTED ON APRIL 13, 2020; 30‐DAY REVIEW PERIOD ENDED MAY 13, 2020. PROJECT DEEMED “COMPLETE” ON MAY 6, 2020. PROJECT HAS NOT BEEN SET FOR HEARING AS OF THIS DATE.

PLN200040 FERNWOOD 47200 HIGHWAY 1, DESIGN APPROVAL TO ALLOW THE REPLACEMENT OF SIX (6) EXISTING PARK MODEL UNITS (PERMIT RESORT LLC BIG SUR WITH NEW AIRSTREAM CLASSIC MODELS. ALL UTILITIES ARE ALREADY IN PLACE. THE TECHNICIAN II: (KING VENTURES) PROPERTY IS LOCATED AT 47200 HIGHWAY 1, BIG SUR (ASSESSOR'S PARCEL NUMBER 419‐ JOANNE LEON) 211‐022‐000), BIG SUR LAND USE PLAN, COASTAL ZONE. PROJECT SUBMITTED ON FEBRUARY 10, 2020; PROJECT DEEMED “INCOMPLETE” ON APRIL 15, 2020.

PLN190385 ROBERTS BRYAN 37600 HIGHWAY 1, COMBINED DEVELOPMENT PERMIT CONSISTING OF A COASTAL DEVELOPMENT PERMIT (PLANNER: & ADRIENNE D MONTEREY AND DESIGN APPROVAL FOR TWO (2) TIEDBACK SOLDER PILE WALLS TO STABILIZE THE RICHARD “CRAIG” TRS SLOPE BELOW A RESIDENCE AND SEPTIC SYSTEM. THE WALLS ARE ROUGHLY PARALLEL AND SMITH) LOCATED ABOVE A COASTAL BLUFF. ONE WALL IS APPROXIMATELY 124.4 LINEAR FEET AND ONE WALL IS APPROXIMATELY 157.6 LINEAR FEET. THE WALL FACES WOULD BE COVERED WITH A NATURAL STONE. THIS PROJECT PROPOSAL IS THE REQUIRED FOLLOW‐UP PERMIT TO EMERGENCY PERMIT PLN190043 THAT ALLOWED FOR A HILFIKER WALL OF APPROXIMATELY 128 LINEAL FEET, LOCATED APPROXIMATELY AT THE EDGE OF THE BACKYARD AREA, ABOVE THE COASTAL BLUFF. THE PROPERTY IS CURRENTLY DEVELOPED WITH AN SINGLE FAMILY DWELLING AND SEPTIC SYSTEM. THE PROPERTY IS LOCATED AT 37600 HIGHWAY 1, MONTEREY (ASSESSOR'S PARCEL NUMBER 418‐111‐012‐000), BIG SUR COAST LAND USE PLAN, COASTAL ZONE. PROJECT SUBMITTED ON FEBRUARY 25, 2020; 30‐ DAY REVIEW PERIOD ENDED MARCH 26, 2020. PROJECT DEEMED “COMPLETE” ON MARCH 25, 2020. PROJECT HAS NOT BEEN SET FOR HEARING AS OF THIS DATE.

Updated on 6/11/2020 1

FILE # APPLICANT AREA PROPOSED USE PLN190368 FENTON PETER TR 48681 & 48715 LOT LINE ADJUSTMENT BETWEEN TWO LEGAL LOTS OF RECORD OF APPROXIMATELY 10.13 (PLANNER: HIGHWAY 1, ACRES (ASSESSOR'S PARCEL NUMBER 420‐191‐006‐000 ‐ PARCEL A) AND 10 ACRES YASMEEN BIG SUR (ASSESSOR'S PARCEL NUMBER 420‐191‐005‐000 ‐ PARCEL B) RESULTING IN TWO LOTS WITH HUSSAIN) NO CHANGE IN PARCEL ACREAGE. THE PROPERTIES ARE LOCATED AT 48715 AND 48681 HIGHWAY 1, BIG SUR (ASSESSOR'S PARCEL NUMBER 420‐191‐005‐000 & 420‐191‐006‐000), BIG SUR COAST LAND USE PLAN, COASTAL ZONE. PROJECT SUBMITTED ON MARCH 25, 2020; 30‐DAY REVIEW PERIOD ENDED MARCH 24, 2020. PROJECT DEEMED “INCOMPLETE” ON JUNE 4, 2020. PROJECT RE‐SUBMITTED ON JUNE 4, 2020; SECOND 30‐ DAY REVIEW PERIOD WILL END JULY 2, 2020.

PLN190351 RICHARD D 30560 AURORA DEL AFTER‐THE‐FACT COMBINED DEVELOPMENT PERMIT CONSISTING OF A COASTAL (PLANNER: ANNA MACDONALD MAR, DEVELOPMENT PERMIT FOR THE DEMOLITION OF A SINGLE FAMILY DWELLING AND A QUENGA) FAMILY CARMEL COASTAL DEVELOPMENT PERMIT TO ALLOW DEVELOPMENT WITHIN 100 FEET OF PARTNERSHIP ENVIRONMENTALLY SENSITIVE HABITAT AREAS. THIS PERMIT ABATES CODE ENFORCEMENT VIOLATION (14CE00051). THE PROPERTY IS LOCATED AT 30560 AURORA DEL MAR, CARMEL (ASSESSOR'S PARCEL NUMBER 243‐331‐003‐000), BIG SUR COAST LAND USE PLAN, COASTAL ZONE. PROJECT RE‐SUBMITTED ON MARCH 11, 2020; PROJECT DEEMED “COMPLETE” ON MAY 7, 2020. PROJECT APPROVED BY ZONING ADMNISTRATOR ON JUNE 11, 2020. FINAL LOCAL ACTION NOTICE WILL BE SENT TO COASTAL COMMISSION. STATUS IS “PENDING APPROVED”.

PLN190160 UBBEN JEFFREY W 37791 PALO COASTAL DEVELOPMENT PERMIT TO ALLOW THE CONSTRUCTION OF A TWO‐STORY 699 (PLANNER: & LAURA H TRS COLORADO ROAD, SQUARE FOOT ACCESSORY DWELLING UNIT WITH DECK AND A 45 SQUARE FOOT RICHARD “CRAIG” CARMEL RETAINING WALL. GRADING OF 55.8 CUBIC YARDS CUT AND 53.3 CUBIC YARDS FILL. THE SMITH”) PROPERTY IS LOCATED AT 37791 PALO COLORADO ROAD, CARMEL (ASSESSOR'S PARCEL NUMBER 418‐091‐019‐000), BIG SUR COAST LAND USE PLAN, COASTAL ZONE. PROJECT SUBMITTED ON FEBRUARY 28, 2020; 30‐DAY REVIEW PERIOD ENDED MARCH 27, 2020. PROJECT DEEMED “INCOMPLETE” ON APRIL 1, 2020.

Updated on 6/11/2020 2

FILE # APPLICANT AREA PROPOSED USE PLN190088 BARBUR PETER 48200 COAST RIDGE COMBINED DEVELOPMENT PERMIT CONSISTING OF A: 1) COASTAL ADMINISTRATIVE AND (PLANNER: MARY ROAD, DESIGN APPROVAL TO CONSTRUCT AN APPROXIMATELY 3,000 SQUARE FOOT ONE‐STORY ISRAEL) BIG SUR SINGLE FAMILY DWELLING; 2) COASTAL ADMINISTRATIVE PERMIT AND DESIGN APPROVAL TO CONSTRUCT A 1,200 SQUARE FOOT ACCESSORY DWELLING UNIT; 3) COASTAL ADMINISTRATIVE PERMIT AND DESIGN APPROVAL TO CONSTRUCT A 425 SQUARE FOOT GUESTHOUSE; 4) COASTAL ADMINISTRATIVE PERMIT FOR THE CONVERSION OF ONE TEST WELL TO A PERMANENT WELL; 5) COASTAL DEVELOPMENT PERMIT TO ALLOW DEVELOPMENT WITHIN 100 FEET OF ENVIRONMENTALLY SENSITIVE HABITAT; AND 6) COASTAL DEVELOPMENT PERMIT TO ALLOW DEVELOPMENT ON SLOPES IN EXCESS OF 30%. THE PROPERTY IS LOCATED AT 48200 COAST RIDGE ROAD, BIG SUR (ASSESSOR'S PARCEL NUMBER 419‐031‐034‐000), BIG SUR COAST LAND USE PLAN, COASTAL ZONE. PROJECT SUBMITTED ON MAY 22, 2020; 30‐DAY REVIEW PERIOD ENDS JUNE 19, 2020. STATUS IS “APPLIED”.

PLN190049 VITA ROBERT A 36918 PALO FOLLOW‐UP COASTAL DEVELOPMENT PERMIT OF AN PREVIOUSLY APPROVED EMERGENCY (PLANNER: LIZ AND JENNIE G CO‐ COLORADO ROAD, PERMIT (PLN170270) TO ALLOW AN 11‐MILE BIG SUR MARATHON RACE TIED TO THE GONZALES) TRS (GRIMES CARMEL ANNUAL BIG SUR INTERNATIONAL MARATHON. THIS RACE CONSISTS OF APPROXIMATELY RANCH RACE) 1,600 PARTICIPANTS ON THE GRIMES RANCH WHICH IS LOCATED ON THE EAST SIDE OF HIGHWAY 1, CARMEL (ASSESSOR'S PARCEL NUMBER 243‐262‐006‐000), SOUTH OF PALO COLORADO ROAD, BIG SUR COAST LAND USE PLAN, COASTAL ZONE. PROJECT DEEMED “COMPLETE” ON APRIL 2, 2019. PROJECT APPROVED BY ZONING ADMNISTRATOR ON MARCH 12, 2020. FINAL LOCAL ACTION NOTICE SENT APRIL 8, 2020; NO APPEAL RECEIVED BY COASTAL COMMISSION. STATUS IS “CONDITION COMPLIANCE”.

PLN180339 KONIG CHADD 46199 CLEAR RIDGE COMBINED DEVELOPMENT PERMIT CONSISTING OF A: 1) COASTAL ADMINISTRATIVE (PLANNER: EDWARD ROAD, PERMIT AND DESIGN APPROVAL FOR THE DEMOLITION OF AN EXISTING 1,060 SQUARE YASMEEN BIG SUR FOOT SINGLE FAMILY DWELLING AND CONSTRUCTION OF A 3,730 SQUARE FOOT TWO‐ HUSSAIN) STORY SINGLE FAMILY DWELLING WITH A 641 SQUARE FOOT GARAGE, A BREEZEWAY, A 351 SQUARE FOOT LOWER DECK, AN IN‐GROUND POOL, AND GRADING INVOLVING 1,157 CUBIC YARDS OF CUT AND 22.48 CUBIC YARDS OF FILL; 2) COASTAL ADMINISTRATIVE PERMIT FOR A MOBILE HOME AND DECK; 3) COASTAL DEVELOPMENT PERMIT FOR DEVELOPMENT ON SLOPES EXCEEDING 30 PERCENT; AND 4) COASTAL DEVELOPMENT PERMIT FOR THE REMOVAL OF AN OAK TREE. THE PROPERTY IS LOCATED AT 46199 CLEAR RIDGE ROAD, BIG SUR (ASSESSOR'S PARCEL NUMBER 419‐221‐004‐000), BIG SUR COAST LAND USE PLAN, COASTAL ZONE. PROJECT RE‐SUBMITTED ON MARCH 6, 2020; 30‐DAY REVIEW PERIOD ENDED APRIL 3, 2020. STATUS IS “COMPLETE” BY OPERATIONAL LAW. PROJECT HAS NOT BEEN SET FOR HEARING AS OF THIS DATE.

Updated on 6/11/2020 3

FILE # APPLICANT AREA PROPOSED USE PLN150337 ESALEN INSTITUTE 54105 HIGHWAY 1, COASTAL ADMINISTRATIVE PERMIT AND DESIGN APPROVAL TO ALLOW THE REPLACEMENT (PLANNER: (ESALEN SOUTH BIG SUR OF TWO PREVIOUSLY BURNED DOWN EMPLOYEE HOUSING UNITS WITH THREE WORKER RICHARD “CRAIG” COAST EMPLOYEE HOUSING BUILDINGS CONSISTING OF: BUILDING #1 ‐ 3,896 SQUARE FEET, BUILDING #2: SMITH) HOUSING) 5,870 SQUARE FEET AND BUILDING #3: 5,500 SQUARE FEET, AND ONE COMMON BUILDING OF 1,010 SQUARE FEET (PRIMARILY BELOW GRADE); AND GRADING (4,941 CUBIC YARDS CUT AND OVER EXCAVATE 3,728 CUBIC YARDS ONSITE AND IMPORTED FILL AND RE‐GRADE. THE PROPERTY IS LOCATED AT 54105 HIGHWAY 1, BIG SUR (ASSESSOR'S PARCEL NUMBER 421‐011‐018‐000), ON THE EAST SIDE OF HIGHWAY 1, BIG SUR COAST LAND USE PLAN, COASTAL ZONE. PROJECT APPROVED BY PLANNING COMMISSION ON MARCH 11, 2020. STATUS IS “PENDING APPROVED”. FINAL LOCAL ACTION NOTICE WILL BE SENT TO COASTAL COMMISSION.

Updated on 6/11/2020 4

The following projects within the Big Sur Coast Land Use Plan area are active, but have had NO CHANGE IN STATUS since October 9, 2019:

FILE # APPLICANT AREA PROPOSED USE PLN190325 BARBUR PETER 48200 COAST RIDGE COASTAL ADMINISTRATIVE PERMIT TO ALLOW THE CONSTRUCTION OF ONE (1) TEST (PLANNER: MARY ROAD, WELL. THE PROPERTY IS LOCATED AT 48200 COAST RIDGE ROAD, BIG SUR (ASSESSOR'S ISRAEL) BIG SUR PARCEL NUMBER 419‐031‐034‐000), BIG SUR COAST LAND USE PLAN, COASTAL ZONE. PROJECT SUBMITTED OCTOBER 15, 2019; DEEMED “INCOMPLETE” ON NOVEMBER 14, 2019. PROJECT RE‐SUBMITTED DECEMBER 19, 2019; PROJECT DEEMED “COMPLETE” ON JANUARY 17, 2020. PROJECT HAS NOT BEEN SET FOR HEARING ACCORDING TO ACCELA. [NO CHANGE IN STATUS]

PLN190107 PACIFIC GAS & 38521 HIGHWAY 1, COASTAL DEVELOPMENT PERMIT TO ALLOW THE REMOVAL OF 20 TREES (18 MONTEREY (PLANNER: ELECTRIC CO MONTEREY CYPRESS & 2 MONTEREY PINE) WITHIN THE CRITICAL VIEWSHED. THE PROPERTY IS RICHARD “CRAIG” LOCATED AT 38521 HIGHWAY 1, MONTEREY (ASSESSOR'S PARCEL NUMBER 418‐111‐002‐ SMITH) 000), BIG SUR COAST LAND USE PLAN, COASTAL ZONE. PROJECT SUBMITTED DECEMBER 11, 2019; DEEMED “INCOMPLETE” ON JANUARY 10, 2020. STATUS IS “INCOMPLETE”. [NO CHANGE IN STATUS]

PLN190100 WATERSUN DAVID 46720 PFEIFFER RIDGE COMBINED DEVELOPMENT PERMIT CONSIST OF: 1) COASTAL ADMINISTRATIVE PERMIT (PLANNER: JOE ROAD, AND DESIGN APPROVAL TO ALLOW CONSTRUCTION OF A 2,293 SQUARE FOOT DETACHED SIDOR) BIG SUR NON‐HABITABLE ACCESSORY STRUCTURE; AND 2) COASTAL DEVELOPMENT PERMIT TO ALLOW DEVELOPMENT WITHIN 100 FEET OF ENVIRONMENTALLY SENSITIVE HABITAT AREA. THE PROPERTY IS LOCATED AT 46720 PFEIFFER RIDGE ROAD, BIG SUR (ASSESSOR'S PARCEL NUMBER 419‐241‐030‐000), BIG SUR COASTAL LAND USE PLAN, COASTAL ZONE. PROJECT SUBMITTED APRIL 4, 2019; 30‐DAY REVIEW PERIOD ENDED SEPTEMBER 5, 2019. STATUS IS “COMPLETE”. PROJECT HAS NOT BEEN SET FOR HEARING ACCORDING TO ACCELA. [NO CHANGE IN STATUS]

Updated on 6/11/2020 5

FILE # APPLICANT AREA PROPOSED USE PLN180491 DEETJENS INC 48865 HIGHWAY 1, COASTAL ADMINISTRATIVE PERMIT AND DESIGN APPROVAL TO ALLOW REPLACEMENT OF (PLANNER: JOE BIG SUR THE ON‐SITE WASTEWATER TREATMENT SYSTEM; AND COASTAL ADMINISTRATIVE PERMIT SIDOR) TO ALLOW DEVELOPMENT ON SLOPES EXCEEDING 30 PERCENT. THE PROPERTY IS LOCATED AT 48865 HIGHWAY 1, BIG SUR (ASSESSOR'S PARCEL NUMBER 420‐181‐002‐000), BIG SUR COAST LAND USE PLAN, COASTAL ZONE. PROJECT SUBMITTED APRIL 23, 2019; PROJECT DEEMED “INCOMPLETE” ON MAY 22, 2019. STATUS IS “INCOMPLETE”. [NO CHANGE IN STATUS]

PLN180296 CALIFORNIA DEPT OF 44350 HIGHWAY 1, COASTAL ADMINISTRATIVE PERMIT TO ALLOW THE PERMANENT ON‐SITE PLACEMENT OF (PLANNER: JOE PARKS & RECREATION MONTEREY 10,500 CUBIC YARDS OF PREVIOUSLY STOCKPILED SOIL. THE PROPERTY IS LOCATED AT SIDOR) 44350 HIGHWAY 1, BIG SUR (ASSESSOR'S PARCEL NUMBER 159‐011‐015‐000), POINT SUR STATE HISTORIC PARK [FORMER POINT SUR NAVAL FACILITY], BIG SUR COAST LAND USE PLAN, COASTAL ZONE. APPLIED ON JUNE 6, 2018; 30‐DAY REVIEW PERIOD ENDED ON JULY 6, 2018. STATUS IS STILL “APPLIED”. STATE PARKS STAFF NEEDS TO CHANGE THE SCOPE OF THE PROJECT. JOE SIDOR WILL SPEAK WITH STATE PARKS STAFF TO “VOID” THE PROJECT. [NO CHANGE IN STATUS]

PLN180166 GORES SAM TR 47062 CLEAR RIDGE AMENDMENT TO A PREVIOUSLY APPROVED COMBINED DEVELOPMENT PERMIT (PC93112) (PLANNER: ROAD, TO ALLOW AN INCREASE OF SQUARE FOOTAGE CONSISTING OF: A 5,756 SQUARE FOOT YASMEEN BIG SUR ONE‐STORY SINGLE FAMILY DWELLING, A 920 SQUARE FOOT ATTACHED GARAGE AND A HUSSAIN) 1,200 SQUARE FOOT ACCESSORY DWELLING UNIT. THE PROPERTY IS LOCATED AT 47062 CLEAR RIDGE ROAD, BIG SUR (ASSESSOR'S PARCEL NUMBER 419‐271‐005‐000), BIG SUR COAST LAND USE PLAN, COASTAL ZONE. APPLIED ON AUGUST 29, 2018; DEEMED “COMPLETE” ON SEPTEMBER 28, 2018. PROJECT RE‐SUBMITTED ON AUGUST 23, 2019; PROJECT DEEMED “INCOMPLETE” ON SEPTEMBER 27, 2019. PROJECT RE‐SUBMITTED ON OCTOBER 28, 2019; PROJECT DEEMED COMPLETED ON NOVEMBER 12, 2019. PROJECT HAS NOT BEEN SET FOR HEARING ACCORDING TO ACCELA. [NO CHANGE IN STATUS]

Updated on 6/11/2020 6

FILE # APPLICANT AREA PROPOSED USE PLN170932 EVANS PETER H TR 38793 PALO COMBINED DEVELOPMENT PERMIT CONSISTING OF: 1) A COASTAL ADMINISTRATIVE (PLANNER: JOE COLORADO ROAD, PERMIT AND DESIGN APPROVAL TO ALLOW CONSTRUCTION OF A 980 SQUARE FOOT SIDOR) MONTEREY SINGLE FAMILY DWELLING, 128 SQUARE FOOT COVERED PORCH, 20 SQUARE FOOT COVERED ENTRY, 184 SQUARE FOOT DECK AND INSTALLATION OF NEW WATER TANKS; 2) A COASTAL DEVELOPMENT PERMIT TO ALLOW DEVELOPMENT ON SLOPE EXCEEDING 30 PERCENT; AND REMOVAL OF TREES DAMAGED BY THE SOBERANES WILDFIRE. THE PROPERTY IS LOCATED AT 38793 PALO COLORADO ROAD, CARMEL (ASSESSOR'S PARCEL NUMBER 418‐161‐006‐000), BIG SUR COAST LAND USE PLAN, COASTAL ZONE. APPLICATION RE‐SUBMITTED OCTOBER 12, 2018 AND DEEMED “COMPLETE” ON NOVEMBER 8, 2018. PROJECT HAS NOT BEEN SCHEDULED FOR HEARING AS OF THIS DATE, AT THE REQUEST OF THE APPLICANT. STATUS IS “COMPLETE”. [NO CHANGE IN STATUS]

PLN170728 LIPMAN HILLARY TR 47540 HIGHWAY 1, COMBINED DEVELOPMENT PERMIT CONSISTING OF: A COASTAL DEVELOPMENT PERMIT (PLANNER: (LOMA VISTA INN) BIG SUR AND DESIGN APPROVAL FOR A GENERAL DEVELOPMENT PLAN FOR ASSEMBLAGES OF RICHARD “CRAIG” PEOPLE; A COASTAL DEVELOPMENT PERMIT AND DESIGN APPROVAL TO ALLOW A SMITH) COMMERCIAL CANNABIS RETAILER OPERATION IN AN EXISTING RETAIL SPACE; A COASTAL DEVELOPMENT PERMIT FOR DEVELOPMENT WITHIN THE CRITICAL VIEWSHED; AND A COASTAL DEVELOPMENT PERMIT TO ALLOW DEVELOPMENT WITHIN 750‐FEET OF A KNOWN ARCHAEOLOGICAL RESOURCE. THIS PERMIT WOULD ALSO CLEAR EXISTING CODE ENFORCEMENT VIOLATIONS: 15CE00197 AND CE980108. THE PROPERTY IS LOCATED AT 47540 HIGHWAY 1, BIG SUR (ASSESSOR’S PARCEL NUMBER 419‐311‐020‐000), BIG SUR COAST LAND USE PLAN, COASTAL ZONE. APPLIED ON OCTOBER 15, 2018. DEEMED “INCOMPLETE” ON NOVEMBER 14, 2018. STATUS IS “INCOMPLETE”. [NO CHANGE IN STATUS]

PLN170583 SANFORD T COLB & 36995 PALO COMBINED DEVELOPMENT PERMIT CONSISTING OF: 1) A COASTAL ADMINISTRATIVE (PLANNER: COMPANY COLORADO ROAD PERMIT AND DESIGN APPROVAL TO ALLOW THE DEMOLITION AND CONSTRUCTION OF A RICHARD “CRAIG” CARMEL SINGLE FAMILY DWELLING AND RETAINING WALLS; 2) A COASTAL DEVELOPMENT PERMIT SMITH) TO ALLOW DEVELOPMENT WITHIN 100‐FEET OF AN ENVIRONMENTALLY SENSITIVE HABITAT AREA; 3) A COASTAL DEVELOPMENT PERMIT TO ALLOW DEVELOPMENT ON SLOPES IN EXCESS OF 30% AND 4) A VARIANCE TO REDUCE THE REAR YARD SETBACK FROM 20 FEET TO 7 FEET. THE PROPERTY IS LOCATED AT 36995 PALO COLORADO ROAD, CARMEL (ASSESSOR'S PARCEL NUMBER 418‐031‐027‐000), BIG SUR COAST LAND USE PLAN, COASTAL ZONE. PROJECT RE‐SUBMITTED ON NOVEMBER 19, 2018; PROJECT DEEMED “COMPLETE” ON DECEMBER 12, 2018. INITIAL STUDY REQUIRED & CIRCULATED ON JANUARY 3, 2020; CEQA COMMENT PERIOD ENDED FEBRUARY 6, 2020. STATUS IS “COMPLETE”. [NO CHANGE IN STATUS]

Updated on 6/11/2020 7

FILE # APPLICANT AREA PROPOSED USE PLN160856 MAEHR TED H AND 38829 & 1122 PALO AFTER‐THE‐FACT COMBINED DEVELOPMENT PERMIT TO CLEAR CODE ENFORCEMENT CASE (PLANNER: JOE RAINER RICHARD COLORADO ROAD, (CE080464) CONSISTING OF: 1) A COASTAL ADMINISTRATIVE PERMIT AND DESIGN SIDOR) SCOTT CARMEL APPROVAL FOR THE CONSTRUCTION OF A 1,466 SQUARE FOOT SINGLE FAMILY DWELLING, A DETACHED 270 SQUARE FOOT STUDY ROOM, A 450 SQUARE FOOT TWO‐STORY BARN, A 75 SQUARE FOOT SHED, A 90 SQUARE FOOT SHED, A 250 SQUARE FOOT CARPORT/WORKSHOP, 12 WATER STORAGE TANKS (10,000 GALLONS; 5 AT 4,900 GALLONS; 3,000 GALLONS; 2,500 GALLONS; 1,000 GALLONS; AND 3 AT 500 GALLONS), A WATER CATCHMENT SYSTEM, ON‐SITE WASTEWATER SYSTEM, APPROXIMATELY 600 LINEAR FEET OF UNPAVED DRIVEWAY, AND ASSOCIATED GRADING; 2) A COASTAL DEVELOPMENT PERMIT TO ALLOW REMOVAL OF 3 MADRONE TREES; AND 3) A COASTAL DEVELOPMENT PERMIT TO ALLOW A LOT LINE ADJUSTMENT BETWEEN TWO LEGAL LOTS OF RECORD CONSISTING OF PARCEL 1, 43.65 ACRES (ASSESSOR’S PARCEL NUMBER 418‐ 151‐005‐000), AND PARCEL 2, 7.25 ACRES (ASSESSOR’S PARCEL NUMBER 418‐151‐006‐ 000). THE ADJUSTMENT WOULD RESULT IN TWO PARCELS OF 40.43 ACRES (PARCEL A) AND 10.47 ACRES (PARCEL B). THE PROPERTIES ARE LOCATED AT 38829 AND 1122 PALO COLORADO ROAD, CARMEL (ASSESSOR’S PARCEL NUMBERS 418‐151‐005‐000 AND 418‐ 151‐006‐000), BIG SUR COAST LAND USE PLAN, COASTAL ZONE. APPLIED ON MARCH 23, 2017; 30‐DAY REVIEW ENDED ON APRIL 21, 2017. APPLICATION RE‐SUBMITTED ON DECEMBER 20, 2018. PROJECT DEEMED “COMPLETE” ON FEBRUARY 11, 2019. PROJECT HAS NOT BEEN SCHEDULED FOR HEARING AS OF THIS DATE ACCORDING TO ACCELA. [NO CHANGE IN STATUS]

PLN160851 MORGENRATH 46821 HIGHWAY 1, COMBINED DEVELOPMENT PERMIT CONSISTING OF 1) COASTAL DEVELOPMENT PERMIT, (PLANNER: ANNA MARTHA J TR ET AL BIG SUR DESIGN APPROVAL, AND GENERAL DEVELOPMENT PLAN TO ALLOW THE ESTABLISHMENT QUENGA) (BLAZE ENGINEERING) OF A COMMERCIAL BUSINESS OPERATION INCLUDING A 760 SQUARE FOOT OFFICE, A 600 SQUARE FOOT WORKSHOP, AN 800 SQUARE FOOT STORAGE UNIT, STORAGE OF EQUIPMENT SUCH AS GENERATORS, CEMENT SILO, DIESEL STORAGE TANKS, AND SEPTIC SYSTEM; 2) COASTAL DEVELOPMENT PERMIT TO ALLOW DEVELOPMENT ON SLOPES IN EXCESS OF 30%; 3) A COASTAL DEVELOPMENT PERMIT TO ALLOW REMOVAL OF 16 PROTECTED TREES; AND 4) COASTAL ADMINISTRATIVE PERMIT TO CONVERT A TEST WELL INTO A PERMANENT WELL. THE PROPERTY IS LOCATED AT 46821 HIGHWAY 1, BIG SUR (ASSESSOR'S PARCEL NUMBER 419‐201‐007‐000), BIG SUR COAST LAND USE PLAN, COASTAL ZONE. PROJECT WAS APPROVED BY BOARD OF SUPERVISORS ON AUGUST 27, 2019 BOARD OF SUPERVISORS HEARING. FINAL LOCAL ACTION NOTICE SENT OCTOBER 9, 2019. TWO APPEALS RECEIVED BY THE COASTAL COMMISSION. STATUS WILL REMAIN “PENDING APPROVED” UNTIL COASTAL COMMISSION MAKES A DECISION ON THE APPEALS. [NO CHANGE IN STATUS]

Updated on 6/11/2020 8

FILE # APPLICANT AREA PROPOSED USE PLN160766 DOOLITTLE WILLIAM 48228 HIGHWAY 1, EMERGENCY COASTAL DEVELOPMENT PERMIT TO REMOVE AND REPLACE A 40 FOOT (PLANNER: NADIA G & NANCY C TRS BIG SUR LINEAR RETAINING WALL THAT HAS FAILED AND THE EXISTING RETAINING WALL MAY FALL GARCIA) OFF FROM THE SLOPE TO A SECTION OF COASTLANDS ROAD AND COULD POTENTIALLY COMPROMISE THE PROPERTY'S DRIVEWAY, BLOCKING INGRESS AND EGRESS. THE PROPERTY IS LOCATED AT 48228 HIGHWAY 1, BIG SUR (ASSESSOR'S PARCEL NUMBER 420‐ 171‐039‐000), BIG SUR COAST LAND USE PLAN, COASTAL ZONE. APPROVED BY THE DIRECTOR OF RMA PLANNING ON OCTOBER 18, 2016. STATUS IS “PENDING APPROVED”. PLANNER & HEARING SECRETARY NEED TO UPDATE WORKFLOW TASKS IN ACCELA; HEARING SECRETARY WILL PROCESS PERMIT RESOLUTION AND UPLOAD INTO ACCELA. [NO CHANGE IN STATUS]

PLN160573 DOOLITTLE WILLIAM 48228 HIGHWAY 1, EMERGENCY COASTAL DEVELOPMENT PERMIT TO REMOVE AND REPLACE A 40 FOOT (PLANNER: JOE G & NANCY C TRS BIG SUR LINEAR RETAINING WALL THAT HAS FAILED AND THE EXISTING RETAINING WALL MAY FALL SIDOR) OFF FROM THE SLOPE TO A SECTION OF COASTLANDS ROAD AND COULD POTENTIALLY COMPROMISE THE PROPERTY'S DRIVEWAY, BLOCKING INGRESS AND EGRESS. THE PROPERTY IS LOCATED AT 48228 HIGHWAY 1, BIG SUR (ASSESSOR'S PARCEL NUMBER 420‐ 171‐039‐000), BIG SUR COAST LAND USE PLAN, COASTAL ZONE. APPLIED ON OCTOBER 18, 2016; STATUS IS STILL “APPLIED”. [NO CHANGE IN STATUS]

PLN160571 WOLFF ANTHONY 38089 PALO COMBINED DEVELOPMENT PERMIT CONSISTING OF 1) COASTAL ADMINISTRATIVE PERMIT (PLANNER: JAIME COLORADO ROAD, TO ALLOW AN AS‐BUILT 585 SQUARE FOOT ACCESSORY DWELLING UNIT, AND 2) COASTAL GUTHRIE) CARMEL DEVELOPMENT PERMIT FOR DEVELOPMENT ON SLOPES OVER 30%; AND 3) DESIGN APPROVAL. THE PROPERTY IS LOCATED AT 38089 A PALO COLORADO ROAD, CARMEL (ASSESSOR'S PARCEL NUMBER 418‐131‐017‐000), BIG SUR COAST LAND USE PLAN, COASTAL ZONE. PROJECT DEEMED INCOMPLETE ON FEBRUARY 24, 2017. [NO CHANGE IN STATUS]

Updated on 6/11/2020 9

FILE # APPLICANT AREA PROPOSED USE PLN160558 LIPMAN HILLARY TR 47540 HIGHWAY 1, COASTAL ADMINISTRATIVE PERMIT TO ALLOW FIVE (5) 4,999 GALLON WATER TANKS. THE (PLANNER: LIZ BIG SUR PROPERTY IS LOCATED AT 47540 HIGHWAY 1, BIG SUR (ASSESSOR'S PARCEL NUMBER 419‐ GONZALES) 311‐020‐000), BIG SUR COAST LAND USE PLAN, COASTAL ZONE. APPLIED ON AUGUST 26, 2016; DEEMED INCOMPLETE ON SEPTEMBER 6, 2016. PROJECT RE‐SUBMITTED ON FEBRUARY 22, 2017; DEEMED INCOMPLETE ON MARCH 22, 2017 [NO CHANGE IN STATUS]

PLN160512 RICHARD D 30560 AURORA DEL COMBINED DEVELOPMENT PERMIT CONSISTING OF: 1) A COASTAL ADMINISTRATIVE (PLANNER: ANNA MACDONALD FAMILY MAR, PERMIT AND DESIGN APPROVAL TO ALLOW THE DEMOLITION AND REBUILD OF A SINGLE QUENGA) PARTNERSHIP CARMEL FAMILY DWELLING; 2) A COASTAL DEVELOPMENT PERMIT TO ALLOW DEVELOPMENT WITHIN A POSITIVE ARCHAEOLOGICAL BUFFER; 3) A COASTAL DEVELOPMENT PERMIT TO ALLOW DEVELOPMENT WITHIN 100 FEET OF ENVIRONMENTALLY SENSITIVE HABITATS; 4) A COASTAL DEVELOPMENT PERMIT TO ALLOW DEVELOPMENT WITHIN 50 FEET OF A COASTAL BLUFF; AND 5) A VARIANCE TO REDUCE THE SIDE YARD SETBACK ON THE NORTHERN PROPERTY LINE TO SIX FEET. THE PROPERTY IS LOCATED AT 30560 AURORA DEL MAR, CARMEL (ASSESSOR'S PARCEL NUMBER 243‐331‐003‐000), BIG SUR COAST LAND USE PLAN, COASTAL ZONE. APPLIED ON MARCH 17, 2017; DEEMED INCOMPLETE ON APRIL 18, 2017. SUPPLEMENTAL INFORMATION SUBMITTED ON MAY 5, 2017; DEEMED “INCOMPLETE” ON MAY 5, 2017. [NO CHANGE IN STATUS]

PLN160470 RANCHOL DEL MONTE 37821 PALO COASTAL ADMINISTRATIVE PERMIT AND DESIGN APPROVAL TO ALLOW CONSTRUCTION (PLANNER: LLC & DAGMAR ELISE COLORADO ROAD, OF A 1,496 SQUARE FOOT SINGLE FAMILY DWELLING WITH AN EXISTING DETACHED 1,140 RAMON FRANKLIN CARMEL SQUARE FOOT BARN AND PHOTOVOLTAIC SYSTEM WHICH WILL REMAIN. THE PROPERTY MONTANO – IS LOCATED AT 37821 PALO COLORADO ROAD, CARMEL (ASSESSOR'S PARCEL NUMBER NEEDS TO BE RE‐ 418‐101‐003‐000), BIG SUR COAST LAND USE PLAN, COASTAL ZONE. APPLIED ON JULY 20, ASSIGNED) 2016; 30‐DAY REVIEW PERIOD ENDED ON AUGUST 19, 2016. [NO CHANGE IN STATUS]

Updated on 6/11/2020 10

FILE # APPLICANT AREA PROPOSED USE PLN160108 OROSCO PATRICK 47070 HIGHWAY 1, COMBINED DEVELOPMENT PERMIT TO CORRECT CODE ENFORCEMENT VIOLATION (PLANNER: CRAIG WEBBER & AMANDA BIG SUR (14CE00255) CONSISTING OF: 1) COASTAL ADMINISTRATIVE PERMIT TO ALLOW AFTER‐ SPENCER) BROOKS THE‐FACT ADDITIONS TO AN EXISTING SINGLE FAMILY DWELLING; 2) COASTAL DEVELOPMENT PERMIT TO ALLOW AFTER‐THE‐FACT CONSTRUCTION OF A RETAINING WALL ENCROACHING INTO SLOPES IN EXCESS OF 30%; AND 3) DESIGN APPROVAL TO ALLOW AFTER‐THE‐FACT CONCRETE PAD DECKS ON AN EXISTING GRADED PADS. THE PROPERTY IS LOCATED AT 47070 HIGHWAY 1, BIG SUR (ASSESSOR'S PARCEL NUMBER 419‐ 211‐006‐000), BIG SUR COAST LAND USE PLAN, COASTAL ZONE. DEEEMED COMPLETE ON JANUARY 20, 2017; SET FOR APRIL 12, 2017 PLANNING COMMISSION HEARING. RE‐ SCHEDULED FOR A PC HEARING DATE TO BE DETERMINED; STATUS IS STILL “SET FOR HEARING”. PER CRAIG SPENCER, PROVIDED DIRECTION TO APPLICANT. WAITING ON SUBMITTAL OF ADDITIONAL INFORMATION. [NO CHANGE IN STATUS]

PLN160191 RIDEOUT BIG SUR 47020 HIGHWAY 1, COASTAL DEVELOPMENT PERMIT TO ALLOW DEVELOPMENT WITHIN 100 FEET OF (PLANNER: PROPERTIES LLC BIG SUR ENVIRONMENTALLY SENSITIVE HABITAT AND A DESIGN APPROVAL TO ALLOW ASHLEY (RIVERSIDE REPLACEMENT OF A CONCRETE CROSSING STRUCTURE OVER THE BIG SUR RIVER NAKAMURA – CAMPGROUND & (RIVERSIDE CAMPGROUND) WITH A CLEAR SPAN BRIDGE TO IMPROVE FISH PASSAGE NEEDS TO BE RE‐ CABINS) CONDITIONS FOR FEDERALLY PROTECTED STEEL HEAD TROUT. THE PROPERTY IS LOCATED ASSIGNED) AT 47020 HIGHWAY 1, BIG SUR (ASSESSOR'S PARCEL NUMBER 419‐211‐003‐000), BIG SUR LAND USE PLAN, COASTAL ZONE. DEEMED INCOMPLETE ON APRIL 14, 2016. [NO CHANGE IN STATUS]

Updated on 6/11/2020 11

FILE # APPLICANT AREA PROPOSED USE PLN160047 POST RANCH INN LLC 47998 & 47900 COMBINED DEVELOPMENT PERMIT CONSISTING OF: 1) AN AMENDMENT TO A (PLANNER: & HIGHWAY 1, PREVIOUSLY APPROVED PROJECT AND GENERAL DEVELOPMENT PLAN (PLN970492) TO ANNA QUENGA) ONESIMO PARCEL C BIG SUR RELOCATE 4 GUEST UNITS (CONSTRUCT TWO PREVIOUSLY APPROVED 945 SQUARE FOOT LLC GUEST UNITS IN A DIFFERENT LOCATION, CONVERT THE POST HOUSE INTO ONE GUEST UNIT, AND CONVERT THE POST CARETAKER UNIT INTO ONE GUEST UNIT), RELOCATE 12 EMPLOYEE HOUSING UNITS (THREE 609 SQUARE FOOT TWO‐BEDROOM HOUSING UNITS, THREE 532 SQUARE FOOT STUDIO HOUSING UNITS, A 341 SQUARE FOOT THREE UNIT STAFF BUNKHOUSE, AND THREE 1,104 SQUARE FOOT MANAGEMENT HOUSING UNITS), RELOCATE SPA FACILITIES (CONVERT THE BUTTERFLY BUILDING FROM ONE GUEST UNIT TO A SPA AND CONSTRUCT A DETACHED 108‐SQUARE FOOT SPA TREATMENT ROOM), REPURPOSE A 341 SQUARE FOOT MAINTENANCE BUILDING INTO AN EMPLOYEE COMMONS HALL, AND CONSOLIDATE CENTRAL SERVICE FACILITIES (CONSTRUCT A 1,358 SQUARE FOOT WORKSHOP AND TWO 341 SQUARE FEET STAFF RESTROOMS); 2) COASTAL DEVELOPMENT PERMIT AND DESIGN APPROVAL TO IMPROVE AN EXISTING PUBLIC TRAIL AND RESTROOM ADA ACCESSIBILITY, ENCLOSE A 1,502 SQUARE FOOT DECK AT THE REAR PORTION OF THE SIERRA MAR RESTAURANT; AND ADD 138 SQUARE FEET TO THE RECEPTION BUILDING; 3) COASTAL DEVELOPMENT PERMIT TO IMPROVE WATER AND FIRE WATER SUPPLY SYSTEMS, WASTEWATER TREATMENT SYSTEM, AND STORMWATER TREATMENT FACILITIES; 4) COASTAL DEVELOPMENT PERMIT TO ALLOW THE REMOVAL OF PROTECTED TREES; 5) A COASTAL DEVELOPMENT PERMIT TO ALLOW DEVELOPMENT WITHIN 100 FEET OF ESHA; AND 6) A COASTAL DEVELOPMENT PERMIT TO ALLOW DEVELOPMENT WITHIN 750 FEET OF A POSITIVE ARCHAEOLOGICAL SITE. THE PROPERTIES ARE LOCATED AT 47900 AND 47998 HIGHWAY 1, BIG SUR (ASSESSOR'S PARCEL NUMBERS 419‐311‐042‐000 & 419‐311‐038‐000), BIG SUR COAST LAND USE PLAN, COASTAL ZONE. APPLICANT RE‐SUBMITTED MAY 25, 2018; 30‐DAY REVIEW PERIOD ENDED ON JUNE 22, 2018. PROJECT DEEMED “COMPLETE” ON JULY 26, 2018. INITIAL STUDY REQUIRED. [NO CHANGE IN STATUS]

PLN150349 CARMEL UNIFIED HIGHWAY 1, BIG SUR DESIGN APPROVAL FOR THE REPLACEMENT OF TWO WATER TANKS FOR THE CAPTAIN (PLANNER: JOE SCHOOL DISTRICT COOPER SCHOOL WATER SYSTEM. THE PROPERTY IS LOCATED ON HIGHWAY 1 (NO SIDOR) (CAPTAIN COOPER ADDRESS ASSIGNED TO PARCEL), BIG SUR (ASSESSOR'S PARCEL NUMBER 159‐021‐005‐ SCHOOL) 000), BIG SUR COAST LAND USE PLAN, COASTAL ZONE. DEEMED INCOMPLETE ON MAY 1, 2015. APPLICANT/AGENT RE‐SUBMITTED ON MARCH 17, 2016; STATUS IS “RE‐ SUBMITTED”. THE SCHOOL DISTRICT STAFF NEEDS TO PROVIDE INFORMATION. [NO CHANGE IN STATUS]

Updated on 6/11/2020 12

FILE # APPLICANT AREA PROPOSED USE PLN150151 STATE OF CALIFORNIA 47225 HIGHWAY 1, COASTAL DEVELOPMENT PERMIT AND DESIGN APPROVAL TO ALLOW THE REPLACEMENT (PLANNER: BIG SUR OF A CULVERT BRIDGE WITH A FREE‐SPAN BRIDGE AND RESTORATION OF THE ASHLEY STREAMBED. THE PROPERTY IS LOCATED AT 47225 HIGHWAY 1, BIG SUR [PFEIFFER BIG NAKAMURA – SUR STATE PARK] (ASSESSOR'S PARCEL NUMBER 419‐031‐002‐000), BIG SUR COAST LAND NEEDS TO BE RE‐ USE PLAN, COASTAL ZONE. DEEMED COMPLETE ON MARCH 11, 2015. STATUS CHANGED ASSIGNED) TO “SET FOR HEARING” BUT PROJECT HAS NOT BEEN SCHEDULED FOR A HEARING DATE AS OF THIS DATE. [NO CHANGE IN STATUS]

PLN140729 WTCC VENTANA 48123 HIGHWAY 1, DESIGN APPROVAL FOR SIGNAGE AND TRAIL IMPROVEMENTS, ASSOCIATED WITH THE (PLANNER: JOE INVESTORS V LLC BIG SUR INSTALLATION OF TRAIL AND DIRECTIONAL/INTERPRETIVE SIGNAGE, AND CONSTRUCTION SIDOR) (VENTANA INN) OF APPROXIMATELY 2,700 LINEAR FEET OF ON‐SITE TRAILS, INCLUDING STEPS AND APPROXIMATELY 500 LINEAR FEET OF RETAINING WALLS, CONSTRUCTION OF 17 PARKING SPACES (INCLUDING 2 ADA‐COMPLIANT SPACES). THE TRAIL IMPROVEMENTS AND SIGN POSTS WILL USE NATURAL COLORS AND MATERIALS (DOUGLAS FIR AND CEDAR). THE SIGNS WILL USE EARTH TONE COLORS, EXCEPT FOR THE DISABLED PARKING, TRAIL MAP, AND INTERPRETIVE SIGNS. THE PROPERTY IS LOCATED AT 48123 HIGHWAY 1, BIG SUR (ASSESSOR'S PARCEL NUMBERS 419‐321‐010‐000 AND 419‐321‐015‐000), BIG SUR LAND USE PLAN, COASTAL ZONE. APPEAL TO BE HEARD BEFORE THE BOARD OF SUPERVISORS AT LATER DATE TO BE DETERMINED; INDEFINITELY DELAYED. [NO CHANGE IN STATUS]

PLN130342 MONTEREY BAY AREA PALO COLORADO, BIG DESIGN APPROVAL TO ALLOW THE DEMOLITION OF AN EXISTING STORAGE BUILDING AND (PERMIT COUNCIL INC SUR RECONSTRUCTION OF A 630 SQUARE FOOT STORAGE BUILDING. THE PROPERTY IS TECHNICIAN: LOCATED AT PALO COLORADO, BIG SUR, CA (ASSESSOR'S PARCEL NUMBER 418‐181‐021‐ JOANNE LEON) 000), BIG SUR COAST LUP. DEEMED INCOMPLETE ON JUNE 7, 2013. [NO CHANGE IN STATUS]

PLN110473 SKINNER PETER G 54220 HIGHWAY 1, COMBINED DEVELOPMENT PERMIT CONSISTING OF 1) COASTAL ADMINISTRATIVE PERMIT (PLANNER: DAN BIG SUR TO REMOVE EXISTING OVERHEAD UTILITIES AND PLACE UTILITIES UNDERGROUND, LISTER – NEEDS TO RELOCATE EXISTING GENERATOR TO NEW CONCRETE UTILITY PAD, TWO (2) NEW 5,000 BE RE‐ASSIGNED) GALLON WATER TANKS, RELOCATE PROPANE TANK, AND NEW FIRE HYDRANT; AND 2) COASTAL DEVELOPMENT PERMIT FOR THE REMOVAL OF 8 EUCALYPTUS TREES AND 6 MONTEREY PINE TREES. THE PROPERTY IS LOCATED AT 54220 HIGHWAY 1, BIG SUR (ASSESSOR'S PARCEL NUMBER 421‐231‐003‐000), BIG SUR LAND USE PLAN, COASTAL ZONE. DEEMED INCOMPLETE ON APRIL 2, 2012. [NO CHANGE IN STATUS]

Updated on 6/11/2020 13

FILE # APPLICANT AREA PROPOSED USE PLN110214 NOVOA KATHLEEN 31200 PLASKETT COASTAL DEVELOPMENT PERMIT TO ALLOW A MINOR SUBDIVISION TENTATIVE PARCEL (PLANNER: LIZ WOODS ET AL RIDGE ROAD, BIG SUR MAP OF AN EXISTING 120 ACRE PARCEL INTO TWO PARCELS CONSISTING OF ONE FORTY GONZALES) ACRE PARCEL (PARCEL 1) AND ONE 80 ACRE REMAINDER PARCEL (PARCEL 2). THE PROPERTY IS LOCATED AT 31200 PLASKETT RIDGE ROAD, BIG SUR (ASSESSOR'S PARCEL NUMBER 423‐011‐010‐000). BIG SUR LAND USE PLAN AREA, COASTAL ZONE. TABLED; DEPARTMENT CANNOT SUPPORT MINOR SUBDIVISION BECAUSE OF SLOPE‐DENSITY; APPLICANT IS APPLYING FOR A TRANSFER OF DEVELOPMENT CREDIT (TDC) TO GET CREDIT TO APPLY FOR SUBDIVISION. [NO CHANGE IN STATUS]

PLN100396 RAISER HELEN M TR 30650 AURORA DEL COMBINED DEVELOPMENT PERMIT REQUIRED BY CONDITION NUMBER 4 OF EMERGENCY (PLANNER: MAR, CARMEL PERMIT (PLANNING FILE PLN100094) CONSISTING OF: 1) A COASTAL ADMINISTRATIVE RICHARD “CRAIG” PERMIT FOR THE CONSTRUCTION OF AN APPROXIMATELY 15 FOOT TALL, 130 FOOT LONG SMITH) HILFIKER WALL (TERRACED WALL) TO STABILIZE AND REPAIR A FAILING SLOPE AROUND AN EXISTING SINGLE FAMILY DWELLING, INSTALLATION OF DRAINAGE IMPROVEMENTS INCLUDING A CULVERT AND CONCRETE CHECK DAMS PLACED BELOW THE SLOPE; 2) COASTAL DEVELOPMENT PERMIT FOR DEVELOPMENT WITHIN 100 FEET OF ENVIRONMENTALLY SENSITIVE HABITAT; 3) COASTAL DEVELOPMENT PERMIT FOR DEVELOPMENT WITHIN 50 FEET OF A COASTAL BLUFF; 4) COASTAL DEVELOPMENT PERMIT FOR DEVELOPMENT ON SLOPES EXCEEDING 30 PERCENT; 5) COASTAL DEVELOPMENT PERMIT FOR DEVELOPMENT WITHIN 750 FEET OF KNOWN ARCHAEOLOGICAL RESOURCES; AND 6) DESIGN APPROVAL. THE PROPERTY IS LOCATED AT 30650 AURORA DEL MAR, CARMEL (ASSESSOR'S PARCEL NUMBER 243‐341‐001‐000), BIG SUR COAST LAND USE PLAN, COASTAL ZONE. DEEMED COMPLETE ON FEBRUARY 1, 2013. INITIAL STUDY SENT OUT DECEMBER 23, 2019; CEQA COMMENT REVIEW PERIOD ENDED FEBRUARY 3, 2020. [NO CHANGE IN STATUS]

PLN080166 JARDINE ALAN C AND SYCAMORE CANYON COASTAL DEVELOPMENT PERMIT TO ALLOW A LOT LINE ADJUSTMENT BETWEEN TWO (PLANNER: MARY ANN TRS ROAD WEST OF LEGAL LOTS OF RECORD OF APPROXIMATELY 7.51 ACRES (ASSESSOR'S PARCEL NUMBER RAMON HIGHWAY 1, BIG SUR 419‐261‐012‐000) AND 2.52 ACRES (ASSESSOR'S PARCEL NUMBER 419‐262‐013‐000), MONTANO ‐ RESULTING IN TWO LOTS OF. 2.52 (PARCEL A) AND 7.51 (PARCEL B) RESPECTIVELY. THE NEEDS TO BE RE‐ PROJECT IS LOCATED ON SYCAMORE CANYON ROAD WEST OF HIGHWAY 1, BIG SUR, AND ASSIGNED) COASTAL ZONE. REVISIONS NEED TO BE MADE. DEEMED INCOMPLETE ON MAY 26, 2009. [NO CHANGE IN STATUS]

Updated on 6/11/2020 14

FILE # APPLICANT AREA PROPOSED USE PLN070520 PACIFIC GAS & BETWEEN JULIA COASTAL DEVELOPMENT PERMIT TO ALLOW THE INSTALLATION OF FIREFLY BIRD FLIGHT (PLANNER: CRAIG ELECTRIC PFEIFFER BURNS DIVERTERS ON PG&E POWER LINES NOT VISIBLE FROM HIGHWAY ONE AND SWAN FLIGHT SPENCER) STATE PARK, BIG SUR DIVERTERS ON POWER LINES WITHIN THE CRITICAL VIEWSHED FROM JULIA PFEIFFER BURNS STATE PARK TO GRIMES POINT. THE BIRD FLIGHT DIVERTERS WILL BE INSTALLED TO HELP REDUCE CALIFORNIA CONDOR FATALITIES FROM COLLISIONS WITH POWER LINES. CONDORS ARE A FEDERALLY ENDANGERED SPECIES. THE PROJECT IS LOCATED FROM JULIA PFEIFFER BURNS STATE PARK TO GRIMES POINT BECAUSE A COASTAL DEVELOPMENT PERMIT FOR DEVELOPMENT IN THE CRITICAL VIEWSHED IS NEEDED. TABLED [NO CHANGE IN STATUS]

PLN070362 CAL TRANS – WILLOW POST MILE 10.4, COASTAL DEVELOPMENT PERMIT TO ALLOW A GENERAL DEVELOPMENT PLAN TO (PLANNER: LIZ SPRINGS SOUTH OF GORDA, ADDRESS THE LONG RANGE DEVELOPMENT AND OPERATIONS OF THE WILLOW SPRINGS GONZALES) PM 10 BIG SUR STATION IN THREE PHASES: PHASE I INCLUDES A NEW OFFICE BUILDING; PHASE II CONSISTS OF CONSTRUCTING A NEW SLAB TO ACCOMMODATE EQUIPMENT FOR WASHING VEHICLES AND RECYCLING OF WASTEWATER; AND PHASE III CONSISTS OF REMODELING EXISTING EQUIPMENT BUILDING TO INCLUDE NEW WINDOWS/DOORS AND PAVING; AN LCP AMENDMENT TO REZONE THE MAINTENANCE STATION FROM THE WATERSHED AND SCENIC CONSERVATION ZONING DISTRICT AND INCORPORATE IT INTO THE GORDA RURAL COMMUNITY CENTER DISTRICT; AND DESIGN APPROVAL. THE PROJECT IS LOCATED AT HIGHWAY ONE, POST MILE 10.4, SOUTH OF GORDA RURAL CENTER IN THE BIG SUR AREA. APPLIED ON JUNE 8, 2009; DEEMED INCOMPLETE ON JULY 7, 2009. [NO CHANGE IN STATUS]

PLN060189 BURKE TIMOTHY M & PALO COLORADO COASTAL DEVELOPMENT PERMIT TO ALLOW A LOT LINE ADJUSTMENT THAT WOULD (PERMIT DANA L (J T) ROAD, SOUTH OF RECONFIGURE THREE EXISTING VACANT LOTS RESULTING IN TWO OF THE SMALLER LOTS TECHNICIAN: TWIN PEAKS, BIG SUR BEING MOVED FROM THE EASTERLY LOCATION TO THE WESTERLY LOCATION FOR THE MARIA LOPEZ) PURPOSES OF BETTER ACCESS. THE RESULTING LOT SIZES WOULD REMAIN AT EXISTING SIZES TO INCLUDE 39.92, 6.60 AND 7.56 ACRES (ASSESSOR'S PARCEL NUMBERS 418‐011‐ 041‐000, 418‐011‐043‐000, 418‐011‐042‐000). THE PROJECT IS LOCATED ON PALO COLORADO ROAD, SOUTH OF TWIN PEAKS, BIG SUR AREA, AND COASTAL ZONE. APPROVED BY THE SUBDIVISION COMMITTEE DECEMBER 14, 2006; APPEALED BY THE COASTAL COMMISSION (A‐3‐MCO‐07‐004). APPEAL POSTPONED BY APPLICANT ON SEPTEMBER 9, 2009 AT CALIFORNIA COASTAL COMMISSION HEARING. [NO CHANGE IN STATUS]

Updated on 6/11/2020 15

FILE # APPLICANT AREA PROPOSED USE PLN050722 DOUD JOHN EDWARD EAST OF HIGHWAY 1 COASTAL DEVELOPMENT PERMIT FOR A LOT LINE ADJUSTMENT BETWEEN FOUR LOTS OF (PLANNER: NEEDS & JANE DEVINE DOUD BETWEEN SOBERANES 555 ACRES (LOT A, ASSESSOR'S PARCEL NUMBER 243‐211‐023‐000), 530 ACRES (LOT 10, TO BE RE‐ TRS POINT AND KASLER ASSESSOR'S PARCEL NUMBER 243‐211‐022‐000), 144 ACRES (LOT 2, ASSESSOR'S PARCEL ASSIGNED) POINT APPROX. TWO NUMBER 417‐011‐016‐000) AND 146 ACRES (LOT 3, ASSESSOR'S PARCEL NUMBER 417‐ MILES NORTH OF 021‐002) TO RESULT IN FOUR PARCELS WITH 116 ACRES (PARCEL JD1), 72 ACRES (PARCEL PALO COLORADO JD2), 931 ACRES (PARCEL JD3), 256 ACRES (PARCEL JD4). PARCEL A WAS PART OF A 2‐LOT ROAD, BIG SUR ADJUSTMENT APPROVED IN 2003 (PLN030027). THE PROJECT IS LOCATED EAST OF HIGHWAY 1 BETWEEN SOBERANES POINT AND KASLER POINT APPROXIMATELY TWO MILES NORTH OF PALO COLORADO ROAD, BIG SUR AREA, COASTAL ZONE. APPROVED BY THE MINOR SUBDIVISION COMMITTEE FEBRUARY 22, 2007 AND APPEALED; WILL BE SUBMITTING APPLICATION FOR MINOR AND TRIVIAL AMENDMENT. [NO CHANGE IN STATUS]

PLN040759 DU BOIS JOHN H & 50580 PARTINGTON COMBINED DEVELOPMENT PERMIT CONSISTING OF: 1) A COASTAL DEVELOPMENT PERMIT (PLANNER: MARCIA A RIDGE, BIG SUR TO CLEAR A VIOLATION FOR THE INSTALLATION OF TWO 5,000 GALLON WATER TANKS ON RAMON SLOPES OF 30% OR GREATER; 2) COASTAL ADMINISTRATIVE PERMIT FOR A LOT LINE MONTANO ‐ ADJUSTMENT, BETWEEN TWO EXISTING LEGAL PARCELS OF 10.8 ACRES (PARCEL 1) AND 46 NEEDS TO BE RE‐ ACRES (PARCEL 2) RESULTING IN TWO LOTS OF 10.8 ACRES (PARCEL A) AND 46 ACRES ASSIGNED) (PARCEL B). THE PROPERTIES ARE LOCATED AT PARTINGTON RIDGE, BIG SUR (ASSESSOR’S PARCEL NUMBER 420‐211‐015‐000 AND 420‐211‐018‐000) EAST OF HIGHWAY 1, COASTAL ZONE. DEEMED COMPLETE DECEMBER 12, 2005; PROJECT HAS BEEN SUSPENDED FOR COMPLIANCE WITH CODE ENFORCEMENT. [NO CHANGE IN STATUS]

PLN040180 WESTON JANE ET AL LOCATED WEST OF COASTAL DEVELOPMENT PERMIT FOR A LOT LINE ADJUSTMENT TO RECONFIGURE FOUR (PLANNER: NEEDS HIGHWAY ONE, EXISTING LOTS OF RECORD (ASSESSOR'S PARCEL NUMBERS 420‐011‐002‐000 AND 420‐ TO BE RE‐ SOUTHERLY OF POST 171‐032‐000) OF APPROXIMATELY 0.15, 23, 34, AND 75 ACRES EACH IN THE COASTLANDS ASSIGNED) RANCH INN, BIG SUR SUBDIVISION INTO FOUR LOTS OF APPROXIMATELY 18, 27, 45, AND 45 ACRES EACH. THE LOTS ARE LOCATED WEST OF HIGHWAY ONE, SOUTHERLY OF POST RANCH INN, BIG SUR AREA, COASTAL ZONE. APPROVED BY MINOR SUBDIVISION COMMITTEE MAY 26, 2005; APPEALED BY THE COASTAL COMMISSION (#A‐3‐MCO‐05‐052) [NO CHANGE IN STATUS]

Updated on 6/11/2020 16

FILE # APPLICANT AREA PROPOSED USE PLN030127 EIZNER EDUARDO & 46205 CLEAR RIDGE AMENDMENT TO A PREVIOUSLY APPROVED COASTAL ADMINISTRATIVE PERMIT AND (PLANNER: NEEDS CAROLYN SHEARER RD, BIG SUR DESIGN APPROVAL (RESOLUTION NO 970383) CONSISTING OF THE FOLLOWING: 1) DELETE TO BE RE‐ THE PREVIOUSLY APPROVED TWO‐STORY SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENCE FROM THE PLANS; 2) ASSIGNED) CONVERT THE EXISTING 810 SQ. FT. ARTIST STUDIO (YURT) INTO A SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENCE; 3) CONSTRUCT A 1,725 SQ. FT. ONE‐STORY ADDITION AND A 525 SQ. FT. DECK TO THE ARTIST STUDIO; AND 4) RELOCATE AND ATTACH THE PREVIOUSLY APPROVED 240 SQ. FT. CARPORT TO THE ARTIST STUDIO. THE PROPERTY IS LOCATED AT 46205 CLEAR RIDGE ROAD, BIG SUR (ASSESSOR’S PARCEL NUMBER 419‐221‐006‐000), BIG SUR COAST AREA, COASTAL ZONE. TABLED AT ZONING ADMINISTRATOR MEETING OCTOBER 30, 2003. [NO CHANGE IN STATUS]

PLN020400 GURRIES (CALTRANS) 35781 HWY 1 (PM COASTAL DEVELOPMENT PERMIT TO ALLOW THE ESTABLISHMENT AND OPERATION OF (PLANNER: NEEDS 63.0), BIG SUR TWO PERMANENT EARTH MATERIAL DISPOSAL SITES FOR MATERIAL REMOVED FROM TO BE RE‐ HIGHWAY 1 IN THE BIG SUR AREA. THE AREAS WITHIN THE PROPERTY USED FOR ASSIGNED) MATERIAL DISPOSAL ARE IDENTIFIED AS SITES A AND C, AND COMBINED WILL HOLD APPROXIMATELY 70,000 CUBIC YARDS OF EARTH MATERIAL. THE PROJECT INCLUDES RESTORATION AND REVEGETATION OF DISTURBED AREAS; PERMANENT REMOVAL AND RESTORATION OF THE EXISTING ACCESS DRIVEWAY TO THE PROPERTY; AND CONSTRUCTION OF A NEW DRIVEWAY WHICH WILL SERVE AS SINGLE ACCESS TO THE PROPERTY AND DISPOSAL SITES. THE PROPERTY IS LOCATED AT 35781 HIGHWAY 1 (POST MILE 63.0), BIG SUR AREA (ASSESSOR’S PARCEL NUMBER 243‐301‐030‐000), COASTAL ZONE. TABLED AT MARCH 26, 2003 PLANNING COMMISSION HEARING‐ NO MEETING DATE HAS BEEN SET [NO CHANGE IN STATUS]

PLN020374 HAUSWIRTH ROBERT 39290 COAST RD, COMBINED DEVELOPMENT PERMIT CONSISTING OF A COASTAL ADMINISTRATIVE PERMIT (PLANNER: & SHARON MONTEREY FOR THE DEMOLITION OF AN EXISTING 897 SQ. FT. SINGLE FAMILY DWELLING AND RICHARD “CRAIG” CONSTRUCTION OF A 3,945 SQ. FT. TWO‐STORY SINGLE FAMILY DWELLING WITH SMITH) BASEMENT AND A 480 SQ. FT. DETACHED GARAGE (TOTAL STRUCTURAL COVERAGE IS 3,439 SQ. FT.); A COASTAL DEVELOPMENT PERMIT FOR DEVELOPMENT WITHIN 100 FEET OF MAPPED OR FIELD IDENTIFIED ENVIRONMENTALLY SENSITIVE HABITAT; GRADING (540 CUBIC YARDS OF CUT/FILL); AND DESIGN APPROVAL. THE PROPERTY IS LOCATED AT 39290 COAST ROAD, MONTEREY (ASSESSOR’S PARCEL NUMBER 418‐121‐023‐000), BIG SUR AREA, COASTAL ZONE. TABLED FROM JUNE 12, 2003 ZONING ADMINISTRATOR MEETING; PREPARATION OF AN INITIAL STUDY TO ADDRESS POTENTIAL IMPACTS TO BIXBY CREEK AND ENVIRONS – INFORMATION REQUESTED NOT SUBMITTED BY APPLICANT. APPLICANT INQUIRED ABOUT RESTARTING THE PROJECT; PLANNER CONTACTED APPLICANT ON FEBRUARY 13, 2014. [NO CHANGE IN STATUS]

Updated on 6/11/2020 17

FILE # APPLICANT AREA PROPOSED USE PLN010530 HILL JAMES III EAST OF OLD COAST COASTAL DEVELOPMENT PERMIT FOR A MAJOR LOT LINE ADJUSTMENT OF (PLANNER: NEEDS ROAD, BIG SUR APPROXIMATELY 960 ACRES OF THE 7000+/‐ ACRE EL SUR RANCH. THE PROPOSAL IS TO TO BE RE‐ RECONFIGURE TEN PARCELS RANGING FROM 47 ACRES TO 196 ACRES. THE PROPERTY IS ASSIGNED) LOCATED EAST OF THE CONFLUENCE OF THE NORTH AND SOUTH FORKS OF THE LITTLE SUR RIVER, (ASSESSOR’S PARCEL NUMBERS PORTIONS OF 418‐021‐021‐000, 418‐021‐025‐ 000 AND 418‐021‐034‐000), EAST OF OLD COAST ROAD, BIG SUR AREA, COASTAL ZONE. [ADMINISTRATIVE DETERMINATION THAT THE PROJECT WAS SUBJECT TO STATE LAW LIMITING LOT LINE ADJUSTMENTS TO 4 PARCELS APPEALED BY APPLICANT TO PLANNING COMMISSION – APPEAL DENIED ON DECEMBER 11, 2002 – PC DECISION APPEALED TO THE BOARD OF SUPERVISORS SOON THEREAFTER AND SUBSEQUENTLY TABLED AT MAY 27, 2003 BOARD OF SUPERVISORS MEETING TO ADDRESS LOT LEGALITY ISSUES] NO HEARING DATE HAS BEEN SET. STATUS CHANGE ON 09/10/2007, TABLED BY BOARD OF SUPERVISORS IN 2003. SUSPENDED [NO CHANGE IN STATUS]

PLN010311 TRAPKUS STEPHEN TR 3.2 MILES EAST OF COASTAL DEVELOPMENT PERMIT FOR A LOT LINE ADJUSTMENT BETWEEN TWO LEGAL (PLANNER: NEEDS HWY 1 ON PALO LOTS OF RECORD (ASSESSOR’S PARCEL NUMBERS 418‐131‐028‐000 AND 418‐132‐005‐ TO BE RE‐ COLORADO, BIG SUR 000). THE LOT LINE ADJUSTMENT WILL ADD 7.8 ACRES TO ASSESSOR’S PARCEL NUMBER ASSIGNED) 418‐131‐028‐000. THE PROPERTIES ARE LOCATED AT THE 3.2 MILE MARKER AT PALO COLORADO ROAD, BIG SUR, AND COASTAL ZONE. TABLED AT JULY 25, 2002 SUBDIVISION COMMITTEE MEETING FOR REDESIGN – NO HEARING DATE HAS BEEN SET. [NO CHANGE IN STATUS]

PLN000142 CALTRANS 2000‐ HWY 1 VARIOUS SITES EMERGENCY COASTAL DEVELOPMENT PERMIT TO REMOVE LANDSLIDE THAT IS BLOCKING (PLANNER: NEEDS DISPOSAL SITE PM27.8 & 22.4, BIG BOTH LANES OF HWY 1. INCLUDES REVIEW OF DISPOSAL SITES FOR EXCESS MATERIAL TO BE RE‐ SUR FROM PITKINS CURVE AND BIG CREEK SLIDES. (SEE PLN000425 AND PLN000426 FOR ASSIGNED) FOLLOW‐UP DISPOSAL.) SUSPENDED [NO CHANGE IN STATUS]

PLN980487 GRIES BEVERLY STERN GORDA MOUNTAIN COASTAL DEVELOPMENT PERMIT AND DESIGN APPROVAL FOR A 540 SQUARE FOOT (PLANNER: CRAIG NO 4, BIG SUR CARETAKER UNIT AND CARPORT ON A PARCEL WITH AN EXISTING SINGLE FAMILY SPENCER) RESIDENCE. THIS PROJECT WILL BRING THE EXISTING ILLEGAL MANUFACTURED UNIT INTO COMPLIANCE WITH THE ZONING ORDINANCE AND RESOLVE COUNTY CODE VIOLATION FILE #85‐315:D. THE PROPERTY IS FRONTING AND SOUTHERLY OF GORDA MOUNTAIN RD, LOCATED AT NO. 4 GORDA MOUNTAIN (ASSESSOR'S PARCEL NUMBER 424‐011‐016‐000) IN THE BIG SUR AREA OF THE COASTAL ZONE. DEEMED INCOMPLETE ON APRIL 14, 1999. (PROJECT HAS BEEN SUSPENDED DUE TO NO ACTIVITY) [NO CHANGE IN STATUS]

Updated on 6/11/2020 18

FILE # APPLICANT AREA PROPOSED USE PLN970596 PACIFIC BELL LOPEZ POINT, BIG SUR COASTAL DEVELOPMENT PERMIT AND DESIGN APPROVAL FOR A MICROWAVE DISH (PLANNER: NEEDS ENCLOSED IN A SHED (22' 6" IN HEIGHT) LOCATED WITHIN THE CRITICAL VIEWSHED OF TO BE RE‐ STATE HIGHWAY 1. THE PROJECT INCLUDES A PROPANE TANK, 7' HIGH CEDAR FENCE AND ASSIGNED) SOLAR PANELS ON THE SHED ROOF. THIS WILL PROVIDE PACIFIC BELL TELEPHONE SERVICE ALONG THE SOUTH COAST AREA OF BIG SUR. THE PROPERTY IS FRONTING ON THE WESTERLY SIDE OF STATE HIGHWAY 1, LOCATED AT LOPEZ POINT (ASSESSOR'S PARCEL NUMBER 422‐011‐010‐000) IN THE BIG SUR AREA OF THE COASTAL ZONE. PROJECT HAS BEEN SUSPENDED DUE TO INACTIVITY. [NO CHANGE IN STATUS]

PLN970595 PACIFIC BELL POST RANCH (WEST COASTAL DEVELOPMENT PERMIT AND DESIGN APPROVAL FOR A MICROWAVE DISH ON A (PLANNER: NEEDS SIDE OF HWY 1), BIG 34' HIGH SUPPORT ANTENNA FOR PACIFIC BELL TELEPHONE SERVICE; AND A VARIANCE TO TO BE RE‐ SUR EXCEED THE 15' MAXIMUM ALLOWABLE HEIGHT FOR AN ACCESSORY STRUCTURE. THE ASSIGNED) PROPERTY IS FRONTING ON AND WESTERLY OF STATE HIGHWAY 1, LOCATED AS PARCEL "C" ON THE POST RANCH PROPERTY (ASSESSOR'S PARCEL NUMBER 419‐311‐036‐000) IN THE BIG SUR AREA OF THE COASTAL ZONE. TABLED – PROJECT HAS NEVER BEEN DEEMED COMPLETE OR INCOMPLETE. [NO CHANGE IN STATUS] PD040368 DOUD JOHN EDWARD W OF HWY 1 N OF CONSIDER LAND USE PLAN AMENDMENT AND ZONE CHANGE FROM OUTDOOR (PLANNER: GARRAPATA BRIDGE RECREATION (OR) TO WATERSHED & SCENIC CONSERVATION (WSC/40) FOR A 2.5‐ACRE NEEDS TO BE RE‐ (BIG SUR COAST LUP) LOT LOCATED NORTH OF GARRAPATA CREEK, SOUTH OF GARRAPATA PARK, AND WEST OF ASSIGNED) HIGHWAY ONE, BIG SUR (ASSESSOR'S PARCEL NUMBER 243‐212‐016‐000), COASTAL ZONE. APPROVED BY BOARD OF SUPERVISORS ON NOVEMBER 14, 2006; LOCAL COASTAL PROGRAM AMENDMENT SENT TO CALIFORNIA COASTAL COMMISSION IN JUNE 2007. CALIFORNIA COASTAL COMMISSION RECOMMENDED DENIAL‐APPEAL WITHDRAWN TO ADDRESS LEGAL LOT ISSUE. [NO CHANGE IN STATUS]

Updated on 6/11/2020 19 BSMAAC Report June 2020

Actions Taken by MPRPD to Keep Some Sites Open for Public Use During the Coronavirus Pandemic

COVID-19 Response: MPRPD Executive Staff proactively met on March 10 in preparation for then forth-coming county, state, and national response to COVID-19. Staff formulated and implemented critical strategies in advance of the initial Shelter- in-Place Order’s issuance. The primary goal was, and continues to be, protection of the public’s, Board’s, and Staff’s health in alignment with federal, state, and local recommendations and Orders. MPRPD’s actions include:

a. Adaptation: Like many organizations, MPRPD does not have an adopted plan for a viral pandemic of this magnitude. Staff continues to research what other organizations are doing and has prudently improvised its office and field work to ensure the Public’s and Staffs’ safety and health. Rangers continue to adapt to circumstances as the situation changes daily. Staff will continue to work cooperatively with our partners. The Public has adhered to the social distancing requirements set forth by County and State officials thereby allowing our parks to remain open.

b. Board Meetings: Staff has researched options, legal requirements, and technology to hold the May & June 2020 MPRPD Board meeting entirely remotely.

c. California Wildlife Day (CWD) Cancelled: One of the region’s most popular single-day outdoor events was cancelled. With only two weeks before CWD, the Carmel River Watershed Conservancy and MPRPD Staff scrambled to postpone the event. Discussions underway re: possibly hosting a “smaller” event once the County’s Shelter-in-Place Order is lifted. If this event cannot be held this fall, it may be held next spring.

d. Contact with Other Organizations: Staff meets and communicates regularly with the County OES and other organizations to be briefed on the latest CDC, State and County recommendations and Orders. This information is then issued to Staff.

Staff has also been in regular contact with the BLM, State Parks and County to align how the four organizations respond to the COVID-19 pandemic and align open space management practices. This should minimize the public’s potential confusion as they visit the region’s parks and open spaces administered under various jurisdictional authorities. e. Daily Staff Meetings: MPRPD’s Executive Staff institutionalized and continues to participate in multi-division meetings daily via Microsoft Teams. Division Leads meet with their respective Staff and Volunteers. f. Discovery and Visitor Centers: These facilities were closed to the public as there was not an effective means of maintaining social distancing within these buildings. Many of the exhibits could potentially transmit disease because of their propensity of being touched by visitors. We also want to protect our Volunteers because many are members of a vulnerable population. g. Drinking Fountains: Turned-off, cordoned and signed prohibiting public use due to potential of disease transmission through the touching of handles and buttons. Visitors are encouraged to bring their own water. h. Dumpsters: Placed at trailheads for public use to minimize Staff’s handling of garbage and recyclables typically deposited in smaller garbage cribs. i. Easter/Memorial Holiday Weekend(s): Rangers installed signage and cordoned picnic amenities to discourage gatherings and eliminate exposure to “high-contact” items like picnic tables. These holiday weekends went smoothly without incident. j. FACEBOOK and Email: Public support has been favorable in how MPRPD has handled and is handling the novel coronavirus. k. Gates: Rangers coordinated with our grazing partners so that some gates in the Front Ranch and other locations could be left open. This greatly reduces people touching gates, latches, hardware, and locks. l. Policies and Procedures: Like many organizations throughout the United States, MPRPD did not have Policies and Procedures specifically addressing the pandemic or other potential major natural or human-caused disasters. Staff has researched and has drafted policies and procedures for the Board’s review and consideration. m. Remote or Isolated Work: Staff worked diligently to establish workstations and network connections, and obtain laptops, hardware and tools needed for Staff’s continued productivity despite Shelter-in-Place Orders.

n. Re-opening of Discovery/Visitor Centers, Parks, Facilities and Programs: Staff is researching nationally to determine if other organizations are drafting or have drafted Re-opening Plans and Strategies. Our Volunteers/Staff are also exploring MPRPD-specific re-opening scenarios and will develop corresponding plans. These will be shared with the Board. Whether “Re-opening” is phased or wholesale in three weeks, three months, or three years – MPRPD wants to be ready and prepared to responsibly execute our angle of attack.

MPRPD is communicating regularly with the County of Monterey, State Parks and BLM to align our messaging as properties and facilities in the region reopen.

o. San Jose Creek Trail: In conference with our partners, the trail’s opening was postponed and will not be available for public use until County’s Order is lifted. The opening of this trail will be coordinated with the Big Sur Land Trust, State Parks, and others.

p. Signage: MPRPD’s Divisions worked together to design, fabricate, and install signage related to COVID-19 requirements, CDC recommendations, and park regulations.

Signage was posted in English and Spanish at parking lots, trailheads, along trails, and at the RCU lawn and other former gathering areas advising the public to adhere to social distancing requirements and not congregate. q. Special Use Permits: Issuance of Special Use Permits temporarily on hold during the Shelter-in-Place Oder. r. Sports Fields Closed: In compliance with the latest County Order, the Cachagua playground and multi-sport field and de Dampierre Park in its entirety have been closed until the Order is lifted. s. Visitor Center Restrooms (GRRP): Closed and secured. Portable toilets and hand-washing stations are being provided to the public. These are being pumped twice a week and cleaned by a separate contractor daily. This eliminates MPRPD Staff cleaning, supplying, and maintaining restrooms, and reduces possible exposure to pathogens.

SITES PRESENTLY OPEN: 1. Frog Pond Wetland Preserve (Del Rey Oaks): Park and trails remain open;

2. Garland Ranch Regional Park (Carmel Valley Village): Park and trails remain open but picnic tables, restroom building, drinking fountain, and Visitor Center are closed;

3. Kahn Ranch Unit (Carmel Valley Village): Park and trails remain open;

4. Palo Corona Regional Park (Carmel): Park and trails remain open;

5. Rancho Canada Unit (Carmel): Park and trails remain open but picnic tables, drinking fountain, and Discovery Center are closed.

SITES TEMPORARILY CLOSED: 1. De Dampierre Park (Carmel Valley Village): Entire park is closed because it primarily consists of a baseball/softball sports field complex. Closure is necessary to ensure compliance with the County’s latest Order;

2. Marina Dunes Preserve (Marina): Entire Preserve is closed. Closure is necessary to ensure compliance with the County’s latest Order;

3. Mill Creek Preserve (Big Sur): Entire Preserve is closed.

4. Cachagua Community Park (Community of Cachagua): Park open intermittently as food bank distribution site only. Picnic tables, community center, playground, and multi-use baseball/softball sports field are closed;

The closure of de Dampierre Park, Marina Dunes Preserve and Cachagua Community Park until further notice, helps ensure our patrons adhere to social distancing guidelines. Mill Creek Redwood Preserve remains closed for public use due extensive damage caused by the Soberanes Fire. County-owned and maintained Palo Colorado Road has not been repaired and danger of limb and treefall from charred and fire-stressed trees remains.

PROJECT UPDATE – STATE ROUTE 1 IN SAN LUIS OBISPO & MONTEREY COUNTIES (HIGHWAY 46 TO CARMEL RIVER)

PREPARED FOR JUNE 19 , 2020 BIG SUR MULTI -AGENCY ADVISORY COUNCIL MEETING

PROJECTS UNDER CONSTRUCTION Project Construction Construction Funding Coastal Manager Project Location Description Contractor Comments Timeline Cost Source Development (Resident Permit Engineer) Highway 1 Construction began Piedras In San Luis Obispo in mid-August. Blancas On- County south of the Empire Project has a 3-yr. Landscape Fall 2018 - Paul Martinez 1. Site Arroyo De La Cruz $7.8 million SHOPP Yes Landscaping plant establishment. mitigation Spring 2022 (RS) Landscape & Bridge Inc. Estimate completion Mitigation (PM 64.0-R66.9) of construction in (49282) spring 2022. In San Luis Obispo County about 19 Bridge rail was miles north of completed in early Cambria from 0.1 Highway 1 May. Drainage and mile Construct August 2019 Souza Polar Star Emergency Berkeley Lindt paving in progress. 2. north of San Retaining – Summer $4.1 million Yes Construction, Creek Funds (RS) Removal of signal Carpoforo Creek Wall/Viaduct 2020 San Luis Obispo (1M170) tentatively Bridge to scheduled for mid- 0.6 miles north of June. San Carpoforo Creek (PM 71.8) 445 working days Highway 1 In Monterey County Electrochemical Summer Truesdale (including 250 Big Creek near Lucia at Big Chloride Kelly McClain 3. 2019-Fall $11.4 million Maintenance Waiver Corporation of working days for Bridge ECE Creek Bridge Extraction of (RJ) 2021 California ECE treatment and (1K1604) (PM 28.1) Bridge Structure curing period)

In Monterey County Construction end Highway 1 near Big Sur from January Carla Yu extended due to Big Sur Pavement Granite Rock 4. Torre Canyon Bridge 2020—Spring $24 million SHOPP Yes (PF) contractor starting CAPM rehabilitation Company to Carpenter Street 2022 work later due to (1F680) (PM 39.8-74.6) winter suspension.

SZC—5.28.2020

1 | P a g e

PROJECT UPDATE – STATE ROUTE 1 IN SAN LUIS OBISPO & MONTEREY COUNTIES (HIGHWAY 46 TO CARMEL RIVER)

PREPARED FOR JUNE 19 , 2020 BIG SUR MULTI -AGENCY ADVISORY COUNCIL MEETING

PROJECTS UNDER CONSTRUCTION (Cont’d.) Project Construction Construction Funding Coastal Manager Project Location Description Contractor Comments Timeline Cost Source Development (Resident Permit Engineer) Construct Maintenance In Mon. and SCr Highway 1 Vehicle Pull Counties, from just Mon/SCr Outs, A. Teichert & south of Salinas Rd. Spring 2020— Carla Yu Construction began 5. Roadside Repairing $4.3 million SHOPP Exclusion Sons Inc. of OC in Mon. Co. to just Spring 2021 (IN) March 2020. Safety Guardrail, and Sacramento, CA north of Larking (1C980) Relocating Valley Rd. in SCr Co. Irrigation Equipment Bids opened on 3/19/20. Project Electrical/ awarded on 4/3/20. North District Various locations Signs/ Alfaro Project has possible Crosswalk throughout Monterey Flashing Spring/Summer Mike Lew Communications 150-day lead time for 6. Enhancements and Santa Cruz $1,000,000 Minor No Beacons/ 2020 (RJ) Construction Inc., fabrication of Modified (SRs 1, 9, 68, 129, Markings/ Compton, CA Type 15 FBS (1G760) 152, 183) Pavements Standards, for mounting flashing beacons.

PROJECTS IN DEVELOPMENT (Cont’d.)

Coastal Construction Construction Funding Project Project Location Description Development Comments Timeline Cost Source Manager Permit

Highway 1 In Monterey County from Limekiln Creek south of Limekiln Creek Value Analysis preformed in mid- Bridge Summer 2025 7. Bridge to just north of Replace bridge $64.6 million SHOPP Yes Carla Yu September 2019, no significant Replacement – Winter 2028 Limekiln Creek Bridge changes to scope. (1F510) (PM 20.1-21.9)

SZC—5.28.2020

2 | P a g e

PROJECT UPDATE – STATE ROUTE 1 IN SAN LUIS OBISPO & MONTEREY COUNTIES (HIGHWAY 46 TO CARMEL RIVER)

PREPARED FOR JUNE 19 , 2020 BIG SUR MULTI -AGENCY ADVISORY COUNCIL MEETING

PROJECTS IN DEVELOPMENT (Cont’d.)

Constructi Coastal Construction Funding Project Project Location Description on Development Comments Timeline Source Manager Cost Permit

Highway 1 Replace Culvert Near Lucia south of Project was RTL on 3/10/20. Near Limekiln Limekiln Bridge Replace culvert and Summer/Fall 8. $850,000 SHOPP Yes Carla Yu Project expected to be voted at Creek repair erosion 2020 6/25/20 CTC meeting. (PM 20.4) (0Q500) Construct tieback Highway 1 Near Lucia south of Big wall, restore roadway PA&ED: 9/1/20 Orient Express Creek Bridge and facilities, place Spring/Summer $6.2 PS&E: 1/2/22 9. Tieback Wall SHOPP Yes Mike Lew Water Pollution 2023 million RTL: 5/1/22

(27.5/27.7) Control BMPs, and Begin Construction: 4/1/23 (1K010) erosion control Highway 1 Castro Canyon At Castro Canyon Bridge PA&ED should be complete by Bridge Rail Aaron 10. Replace bridge rail Winter 2022 $3 million SHOPP Yes mid-July and move into the Upgrade Henkel (PM 43.1) Design phase.

(1H490) Highway 1 Near Big Sur at 1.0 Mile Coastlands Wall south of Pfeiffer Canyon Permanent Approve PID Approved: 5/4/20 $2.1 11. Permanent Bridge Restoration/Tieback Summer 2023 SHOPP Yes Mike Lew RTL: 8/20/21 million Restoration retaining wall Begin Construction: 2/17/22 (1M460) (PM 44.5/44.45) Project report completed March Highway 1 Little Between Little Sur River 2020, accelerated from Fall 2020. Sur Retaining Wall and North of Big Sur Construct earth $5.4 12. Fall 2022 SHOPP Undetermined Carla Yu Design and Structures advancing retaining system million the design to continue (1K050) (PM 55.9/55.9) acceleration.

SZC—5.28.2020

3 | P a g e

PROJECT UPDATE – STATE ROUTE 1 IN SAN LUIS OBISPO & MONTEREY COUNTIES (HIGHWAY 46 TO CARMEL RIVER)

PREPARED FOR JUNE 19 , 2020 BIG SUR MULTI -AGENCY ADVISORY COUNCIL MEETING

PROJECTS IN DEVELOPMENT (Cont’d.)

Coastal Construction Construction Funding Project Project Location Description Development Comments Timeline Cost Source Manager Permit

Environmental studies are Highway 1 underway. Project is a “long lead” Garrapata Creek At Garrapata Creek with a longer than normal 13. Bridge Rail Bridge Bridge rail Fall 2023/Fall environmental study period $3 million SHOPP Yes Carla Yu Replacement rehabilitation 2024 needed to develop a context (PM 62.97) sensitive solution for the bridge (1H800) rail with historic structures.

Highway 1 Electrochemical At Garrapata Creek Garrapata Creek Chloride Summer Project is in Design Phase. Bridge 14. Bridge Rehab Extraction (ECE) 2021/Summer $10 million SHOPP Exemption Carla Yu Construction timeline includes

of bridge 2023 one year of plant establishment. (PM 63.0) (1H460) structure The project will provide off-site landscaping and mitigation on Highway 1 State Parks lands for impacts to Piedras Blancas San Luis Obispo County wetlands and coastal prairie from Off-site north of the Arroyo De La Landscape Spring 2021- Paul 15. $7.5 million SHOPP Yes the Piedras Blancas Realignment Landscape Cruz Bridge mitigation Summer 2027 Martinez project. A 5-year plant Mitigation (PM R67.2) establishment period is planned. (49285) Project is delayed 1 year to complete R/W negotiations. In Monterey County, on Highway 1 Route 1, 0.2 miles Carmel River Drainage Winter Local, David County is updating the Final 16. south of Carmel River $11 million Yes Overflow Bridge Improvements 2021/2022 Oversight Rasmussen Project Report. Bridge (1F650) (PM 71.9 - 72.3)

SZC—5.28.2020

4 | P a g e

PROJECT UPDATE – STATE ROUTE 1 IN SAN LUIS OBISPO & MONTEREY COUNTIES (HIGHWAY 46 TO CARMEL RIVER)

PREPARED FOR JUNE 19 , 2020 BIG SUR MULTI -AGENCY ADVISORY COUNCIL MEETING

CANDIDATE PROJECTS Coastal Construction Construction Funding Project Project Location Description Development Comments Timeline Cost Source Manager Permit In Monterey County from 0.1 Highway 1 Culvert mile north of the Drainage Unassigned Project to be programmed in 2020 SHOPP. 17. Rehab 1 SLO county line to System Summer 2026 $9 million SHOPP Yes (Joe Erwin) Environmental studies to begin July 2020. (1J990) 2.8 miles south of Restoration Big Sur (PM 0.1 -43.8) On Route 1 in Replace Bridge Monterey County Railing and Highway 1 Big from 1 mile north extract Project to be programmed in 2020 SHOPP. Creek Bridge Rail of Vicente Creek chlorides, Unassigned 18. Summer 2024 $23 million SHOPP Yes Environmental (PA&ED) phase expected to Replacement Bridge to 1 mile drainage (Joe Erwin) begin July 2020. (1J870) south of Sycamore improvements Draw Bridge and (PM 26.9/38.3) count station

ACRONYMS USED IN THIS REPORT:

CDP Coastal Development Permit ED Environmental Document PA&ED Project Approval and Environmen tal Document PS&E Plans, Specifications, and Estimate RTL Ready to List SHOPP State Highway Operation and Protection Program STIP Statewide Transportation Improvement Program

SZC—5.28.2020

5 | P a g e