DOCSLIB.ORG

Province Needs an Innovative Response to Reopen Borders

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Province Needs an Innovative Response to Reopen Borders Province needs an innovative response to reopen borders New Brunswick Telegraph-Journal (Print Edition)·Herb Emery CA|October 21, 2020·08:00am Section: A·Page: A9 Since March, New Brunswick and the other Atlantic provinces successfully kept COVID- 19 out of the region with tight border controls, social distancing and cautious approaches to re-opening businesses. But has our public health success had an economic dividend in terms of lower business impacts and a quicker return to normal? How has it compared to other provinces and countries still struggling to control COVID-19? It turns out that even before the recent outbreaks in Moncton and Campbellton, our economy didn’t really recover any better than anywhere else. The Atlantic provinces appeared to be in an enviable situation at the end of the summer. The Globe and Mail reported in early October, “With few local infections, the economies of the Atlantic provinces are reopening at a faster rate than any other part of Canada.” The report quoted Université de Moncton political scientist Roger Ouellette: “Compared to the rest of Canada, we’re lucky. We have almost a normal life.” Boosting the belief in New Brunswick’s economic advantages during COVID-19 is the fact that many New Brunswickers may have been better off while not working since March. CBC reporter Robert Jones suggested that the $300 million-per-month of federal relief spending in New Brunswick since March has boosted household incomes to record levels, leaving most households better off than before the pandemic. Earned wages in the province were down nearly $600 million in March through July, when employment recovered, but the Canada Emergency Response Benefit (CERB) paid close to $1.5 billion to more than 165,000 New Brunswick applicants by Sept. 27. Jones argues that record retail sales are evidence of how well New Brunswick residents have fared financially during the pandemic: In June and July, “retail sales in the province hit a two month record $2.55 billion, $193 million more than was spent during the same period last year, long before the pandemic.” Adding to Jones’s case, the province has also been rumoured to have its hottest real estate market in years. But have we rushed to the conclusion that our management of the pandemic has had an economic benefit relative to other provinces and countries? CBC’s Connell Smith recently reported that the state of Maine, with a population nearly twice the size of New Brunswick, has been impacted much more than our province. Maine has had nearly 6,000 cases and 146 deaths as of Oct. 19. At the same time, New Brunswick has had 313 cases and three deaths. The CBC report highlighted how hard the restaurants and bars in Maine had been hit by public health social distancing requirements. Based on the greater health impact of COVID-19 in Maine, one would expect that its economy would show a much greater negative impact from the pandemic, particularly given that Maine does not have the same level of public sector employment as the Atlantic provinces. Public sector employment in Maine is around 20 per cent of total employment, versus over 30 per cent in New Brunswick and Nova Scotia. In Canada, public sector workers did not see their employment fall as much as employment did in the private sector and in New Brunswick and Nova Scotia, public sector employment fully recovered by June. It turns out that New Brunswick and Nova Scotia’s economies have not fared any better than Maine. New Brunswick’s loss of employment after the March lockdown was not as severe as Nova Scotia or Canada overall, but matched Maine’s. New Brunswick’s employment recovered quickly compared to other provinces and Maine, reaching 98 per cent of pre-lockdown employment levels by June. Nova Scotia, Canada and (likely) Maine did not reach that level of employment recovery until September. So New Brunswick had an early lead in jobs recovery that it has since given up. Recovery of employment has been weaker in business sectors, where employment has only recovered to around 95 per cent of pre-lockdown employment levels by September 2019 in New Brunswick, Nova Scotia and Canada overall. But where Nova Scotia and Canada have experienced employment increases each month since March, New Brunswick had employment in the business sector nearly fully recovered by June. Since June, however, New Brunswick has had falling employment in the business sector. Gone are the giddy days when we believed that our low numbers of COVID-19 infections would attract business and remote workers to the province. The Atlantic bubble has been good for flattening the COVID-19 infection curve, but closing the region off from the rest of Canada has not paid an economic dividend. The Atlantic Provinces Economic Council estimated that the revenue loss for the region due to the pandemic was $3 billion in tourism, $3.3 billion for major construction projects, $3 billion for manufacturing, $1.6 billion for retail and $700 million for restaurants. What’s more, we may have killed our airline service in New Brunswick and turned our previously thriving airports into “stranded assets.” WestJet’s announcement that it is suspending nearly all of its flights to the Atlantic region due to low number of travelers, which it attributed to the 14-day isolation requirement, suggests that our public health success has actually come with economic costs. I suppose for those who would like to see a movement to one airport for the region, we now have that: in Halifax. It appears that our earlier recovery was fueled by federal COVID relief and public sector employment stability, but we have stalled. We are now more dependent on government employment and spending to maintain our employment and incomes, and with a weakening business sector. A frequent criticism of my commentaries that I receive from readers is that I don’t offer solutions, or at least solutions that they like. And certainly the observation that our public health success at flattening COVID-19 has come with economic costs and has not generated the perceived economic advantages begs the question: what we need to do going forward? Do we remain in our regional bubble to prioritize public health objectives or try to move back toward “normal”? My interpretation of the region’s approach is that we will continue mandating 14-day quarantines until such time as there is an effective and available vaccine. The provincial and federal governments need to be aware that this public health prioritization requires ongoing government support for households and businesses, as we have seen with CERB and other relief efforts. But with a weakening business sector, the pressure on publicly funded supports is going to increase. It will be critical that governments provide transparent signals of how much support they can provide and for how long, especially if an available and effective vaccine is years away. There is an alternative course of action, and it is not abandoning our strong public health focus. If our goal is to remain COVID-19 free, then can we find innovative strategies that would allow us to open up our borders to the rest of Canada, if not beyond? Can we find smart approaches for controlling COVID-19 so that businesses at risk of shutdown because of our current blunt approach are able to invest in safe operations? For this course of action, we need effort and resources put toward solving these challenges. It needs to be similar to what we saw from the provincial governments in the spring, rather than the policy adopted since then of simply waiting COVID-19 out. We are only six months from the start of the 2021 tourist season. With a continuation of the Atlantic bubble, next season’s tourism revenues are at risk if we can’t use information, innovation and entrepreneurial effort to control COVID-19. Herb Emeryis a Brunswick News columnist and the Vaughan Chair of Regional Economics at the University of New Brunswick. .
Load more

Recommended publications
  • The Epidemiology of COVID-19 in Canada in 2020: the Pre-Vaccine Era February 2021
    The Epidemiology of COVID-19 in Canada in 2020: The Pre-Vaccine Era February 2021 An RSC Policy Briefing The Epidemiology of COVID-19 in Canada in 2020: The Pre-Vaccine Era An RSC Policy Briefing Authors Wendy Sligl (Chair) University of Alberta David Waldner University of Alberta Jennie Johnstone University of Toronto Robyn Harrison University of Alberta Duncan Webster Dalhousie University Lynora Saxinger University of Alberta Peer Review Monitor Tom Marrie, FRSC Dalhousie University Peer Reviewers Nick Daneman University of Toronto Rob Fowler University of Toronto Srinivas Murthy The University of British Columbia David Patrick The University of British Columbia Dan Reid Dalhousie University Robert Strang Chief Medical Officer of Health, Nova Scotia Suggested citation for Policy Briefing Report: Waldner D, Harrison R, Johnstone J, Saxinger L, Webster D, Sligl W. The Epidemiology of COVID-19 in Canada in 2020: The Pre-Vaccine Era. Royal Society of Canada. 2021 Cover Art Christine De Vuono, For Your Own Good, (2020) Over the course of the pandemic, those in long term care facilities have been hit hardest with the impact of COVID-19 outbreaks. The response has been to lock down care homes and ban visitors, volunteers and even care packages, as attempts to stop the virus from entering the facility. This had the unintended, but very real consequence of isolating our most vulnerable from those who care for and love them. “For Your Own Good”, made of 100 carved figures from identical bars of soap, then placed in mason jars, which in turn are placed on shelves, allow us to look in on the miniature elderly figures, who look out at us.
    [Show full text]
  • Atlantic Agriculture
    FOR ALUMNI AND FRIENDS OF DALHOUSIE’S FACULTY OF AGRICULTURE SPRING 2021 Atlantic agriculture In memory Passing of Jim Goit In June 2020, campus was saddened with the sudden passing The Agricultural Campus and the Alumni Association of Jim Goit, former executive director, Development & External acknowledge the passing of the following alumni. We extend Relations. Jim had a long and lustrous 35-year career with the our deepest sympathy to family, friends and classmates. Province of NS, 11 of which were spent at NSAC (and the Leonard D’Eon 1940 Faculty of Agriculture). Jim’s impact on campus was Arnold Blenkhorn 1941 monumental – he developed NSAC’s first website, created Clara Galway 1944 an alumni and fundraising program and built and maintained Thomas MacNaughton 1946 many critical relationships. For his significant contributions, George Leonard 1947 Jim was awarded an honourary Barley Ring in 2012. Gerald Friars 1948 James Borden 1950 Jim retired in February 2012 and was truly living his best life. Harry Stewart 1951 On top of enjoying the extra time with his wife, Barb, their sons Stephen Cook 1954 and four grandchildren, he became highly involved in the Truro Gerald Foote 1956 Rotary Club and taught ski lessons in the winter. In retirement, Albert Smith 1957 Jim also enjoyed cooking, travelling, yard work and cycling. George Mauger 1960 Phillip Harrison 1960 In honour of Jim’s contributions to campus and the Alumni Barbara Martin 1962 Association, a bench was installed in front of Cumming Peter Dekker 1964 Hall in late November. Wayne Bhola Neil Murphy 1964 (Class of ’74) kindly constructed the Weldon Smith 1973 beautiful bench in Jim’s memory.
    [Show full text]
  • The Halifax Region Tourism Opening
    The Halifax Region Tourism Opening 2020 Plan Prepared for Discover Halifax Halifax Regional Municipality Prepared by FINAL REPORT June 11, 2020 Prepared for Discover Halifax Halifax Regional Municipality Prepared by Fathom Studio 1 Starr Lane Dartmouth, NS 902 461 2525 fathomstudio.ca Release R1—11 June 2020 Contents 01 Protecting People; Our Two Imperatives ......................................... 1 1.1 The Tourism Imperative & Objectives of this Plan ..................................................2 02 Introduction ......................................... 5 2.1 A Pre-Covid Snapshot of Tourism in NS ...................................................................5 2.2 The Provincial Reopening Strategy .7 2.3 A Proposal for the Easing of Tourism Restrictions ...............................................8 03 Strategy for keeping our Destination Safe ......................................................13 3.1 Travel Between Safe Markets .........14 3.2 Safe Spaces ...........................................22 3.3 Communication to promote safe travel & public health goals ..............32 3.4 Responsive Design to Adapt to Changing Epidemiology......................36 04 Site Specific Actions .......................39 4.1 Halifax & Lunenburg Waterfronts .43 4.2 Citadel Hill National Historic Site ...51 4.3 Nova Scotia Provincial Parks ...........55 4.4 Halifax Regional Municipality Parks, Trails, & Gardens ....................................57 4.5 Downtown Halifax / Dartmouth ......61 4.6 Halifax Shopping Centre ....................64
    [Show full text]
  • The Relative Performance of Federal and Non-Federal Countries During the Pandemic
    The Forum of Federations, the global network on federalism and multilevel governance, supports better governance through learning among practitioners and experts. Active on six continents, it runs programs in over 20 countries including established federations, as well as countries transitioning to devolved and decentralized governance options. The Forum publishes a range of information and educational materials. It is supported by the following partner countries: Australia, Brazil, Canada, Ethiopia, Germany, India, Mexico, Nigeria, Pakistan and Switzerland. The Relative Performance of Federal and Non-federal Countries During the Pandemic David Cameron © Forum of Federations, 2021 ISSN: 1922-558X (online ISSN 1922-5598) Occasional Paper Series Number 50 The Relative Performance of Federal and Non-federal Countries During the Pandemic By David Cameron For more information about the Forum of Federations and its publications, please visit our website: www.forumfed.org. Forum of Federations 75 Albert Street, Suite 411 Ottawa, Ontario (Canada) K1P 5E7 Tel: (613) 244-3360 Fax: (613) 244-3372 [email protected] Suggested citation for Forum of Federations' publications: Rupak Chattopadhyay, Handbook of Federal Countries 2009 (Forum of Federations, Oxford Press, 2009) The Relative Performance of Federal and Non-federal Countries During the Pandemic 3 Introduction The story of COVID-19 can be divided into two broad, overlapping phases. The first phase covers the period from the initial outbreak of the pandemic at the beginning of 2020 until about January 2021. That is the time when – without a preventive vaccine – the world struggled to contain its spread and to provide health care to those who fell ill. The second phase of the story starts in early 2021, when effective vaccines began to be manufactured and administered to national populations.
    [Show full text]
  • Coronavirus (COVID-19): Restrictions and Guidance
    State of emergency declared. See Novel Coronavirus (COVID-19) updates (https://novascotia.ca/coronavirus/) and check for location, program and service closures, cancellations and changes (https://novascotia.ca/closures/). Coronavirus (COVID-19) (../) » Restrictions and guidance Coronavirus (COVID-19): restrictions and guidance Public health directives that everyone in Nova Scotia needs to follow to help prevent the spread of COVID-19. On this page 1. Self-isolation requirements 2. Self-isolation requirements with modifications 3. Exemptions from self-isolation 4. Compassionate exceptions from self-isolation 5. Specialized worker exceptions from self-isolation 6. Gathering limits 7. Exemptions to gathering limits 8. Business and service restrictions 9. Employers exempt from gathering limits and social distancing 10. Travel 11. Enforcement Self-isolation requirements You’re legally required to self-isolate (../symptoms-and-testing/#self-isolate) for 14 days or as directed by Public Health if you: have COVID-19 symptoms and are waiting to be tested and get your test results were at a potential exposure site (http://www.nshealth.ca/covid-exposures) and Public Health advises that you need to self-isolate while you’re waiting to be tested and for your test results have been tested for COVID-19 and have been told by Public Health that you need to self-isolate while you’re waiting to get your test results have tested positive for COVID-19 have been told by Public Health that you’re a close contact of a confirmed COVID-19 case or may have been exposed
    [Show full text]
  • Evidence of the Standing Committee on Health
    43rd PARLIAMENT, 2nd SESSION Standing Committee on Health EVIDENCE NUMBER 038 Friday, May 21, 2021 Chair: Mr. Ron McKinnon 1 Standing Committee on Health Friday, May 21, 2021 ● (1100) ed in 96% less air traffic and a 90% drop in non-commercial traffic [English] entering Canada by land, compared with pre-pandemic volumes. The Chair (Mr. Ron McKinnon (Coquitlam—Port Coquit‐ lam, Lib.)): I call this meeting to order. It's important to point out that Canadian citizens, permanent resi‐ Welcome, everyone, to meeting number 38 of the House of Com‐ dents and people registered as an Indian under the Indian Act have mons Standing Committee on Health. The committee is meeting to‐ a right to enter Canada. However, all travellers seeking to enter day to study a number of matters relating to the emergency situa‐ Canada go through enhanced screening measures by CBSA border tion facing Canadians in light of the COVID-19 pandemic. service officers, and must meet testing and quarantine requirements to keep Canadians safe, unless they qualify as exempt. I would like to welcome the witnesses. From Canada Border Ser‐ vices Agency, we have John Ossowski, president, and Denis Vinette, vice-president, travellers branch; from the Department of Of course, some cross-border travel is necessary to maintain the Health, Dr. Stephen Lucas, deputy minister; from the Department flow of goods and services critical to our economy and our people. of Public Works and Government Services, Mr. Bill Matthews, The majority of individuals crossing in vehicles at the land ports of deputy minister; from the National Advisory Committee on Immu‐ entry are essential service providers, such as truck drivers and nurs‐ nization, Dr.
    [Show full text]
  • Newfoundland and Labrador Response Monitor
    North American COVID-19 Policy Response Monitor: Newfoundland and Labrador February 21, 2021 What is the North American COVID-19 Policy Response Monitor? The North American COVID-19 policy monitor has been designed to collect and organize up-to-date information on how jurisdictions are responding to the crisis. It summarizes responses of health systems as well as wider public health initiatives. The North American policy monitor is an offshoot of the international COVID-19 Health System Response Monitor (HSRM), a joint undertaking of the WHO Regional Office for Europe, the European Commission and the European Observatory on Health Systems and Policies. Canadian content to HSRM is contributed by the North American Observatory on Health Systems and Policies (NAO). Contents List of Acronyms and Abbreviations ............................................................................................................. 2 1. Preventing transmission ........................................................................................................................... 3 2. Ensuring sufficient physical infrastructure and workforce capacity ....................................................... 16 3. Providing health services effectively....................................................................................................... 21 4. Paying for services .................................................................................................................................. 27 5. Governance ............................................................................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Zero Covid Roadmap 2
    Roadmap to Eliminating COVID-19 in 5-6 Weeks Through the Zero Covid Strategy Introduction Towns, cities, provinces, and countries can eliminate coronavirus in 5-6 weeks through the Zero Covid strategy, even without the completion of mass vaccination campaigns. The goal is to return to normal social and economic activities safely: gatherings with family and friends and opening of schools, restaurants, bars, theater, sports events and business activities without special precautions. The key to the actions required to achieve this is that the time over which they are needed is short, the shorter the better, so that extraordinary actions can and should be done with this goal in mind. Travel restrictions, isolation facilities, financial and other support for vulnerable individuals, and short and strict lockdowns are indispensable elements of this approach. The Zero Covid strategy is being piloted in Europe and has already virtually eliminated the virus in Australia, New Zealand, Vietnam, Thailand, Singapore, China, Taiwan, Mongolia, and the Atlantic provinces of Canada. See this Lancet article for an overview of why the Zero Covid strategy is the optimal approach to containing coronavirus, as well as maintaining social/economic activities. This roadmap lays out six steps that countries or sub-national regions can take to eliminate COVID-19 in 5-6 weeks through the Zero Covid strategy: 1. Define protected zones 2. Implement Zero Covid messaging campaign 3. Implement five week lockdown, along with strong protective and supportive measures 4. Convert hotels and other facilities into managed isolation and quarantine facilities 5. Quarantine incoming travelers in designated hotels 6.
    [Show full text]
  • Special Measures Order (Atlantic Canadian Travelers)
    Special Measures Order (Atlantic Canadian Travelers) Made pursuant to Section 28 of the Public Health Protection and Promotion Act June 23, 2021 TO: All individuals arriving in Newfoundland and Labrador from within Atlantic Canada WHEREAS: A. While a declaration of a public health emergency is in effect, the Chief Medical Officer of Health may do one or more of the special measures authorized under section 28 of the Public Health Protection and Promotion Act for the purpose of protecting the health of the population and preventing, remedying or mitigating the effects of the pubHc health emergency; B. On March 18, 2020, the Minister of Health and Community Services, on the advice of the Chief Medical Officer of Health, declared: (I) a public health emergency as a result of the CO VI D-19 pandemic; (H) the public health emergency is in effect for the entire province of Newfoundland and Labrador; and (iii) the public health emergency is in effect for a period of 14 days effective immediately; C. The public health emergency has been extended for 14-day intervals and is currently still in effect. D. The Chief Medical Officer of Health, pursuant to subsection 28(2) of the Public Health Protection and Promotion Act, may provide notice in any manner that can reasonably be expected to give actual notice; E. The Chief Medical Officer of Health, pursuant to section 28 of the Public Health Protection and Promotion Act, made Special Measures Orders (Travel) dated May 15, 2020, Special Measures Order (Updated Self-Isolation Exemption Order) dated November 27, 2020, Special Measures Order (Rotational Workers — Self-Isolation Order) dated March 12, 2021, Special Measures Order (Essential Worker Work-Isolation Order) dated April 23, 2021 and Special Measures Order (Traveler COVID-1 9 Testing) dated May 15, 2021; F.
    [Show full text]
  • Premiers' Performance: the Year of COVID-19 Draws to a Close With
    Premiers’ Performance: The year of COVID-19 draws to a close with most, but not all holding majority approval Amid worsening situations in their provinces, Jason Kenney, Brian Pallister receive worst approval ratings December 1, 2020 – Canada’s second wave of the coronavirus continues to challenge Canadians – and their premiers – from coast to coast. With infections on the rise, more deaths are recorded daily, restrictions continue to hamper the economy and families are making difficult choices over how they’ll spend the holidays. Against this backdrop, the latest data from the non-profit Angus Reid Institute finds Canadians generally continue to hold positive views of their respective premiers’ job performance. But the trend line also indicates the days of provincial leaders appearing incapable of doing wrong politically – as they did in the spring and summer – are long gone. For full size image click here Horgan maintains METHODOLOGY: British Columbia Premier John Horgan and his New Democrats gambled with The Angus Reid Institute conducted an online survey from an early election call in October and – November 24 – 30, 2020 among a representative randomized amid record low voter turnout – won a sample of 5,003 Canadian adults who are members of Angus Reid majority mandate. Forum. For comparison purposes only, a probability sample of this size would carry a margin of error of +/- 1.4 percentage points, 19 times out of 20. Discrepancies in or between totals are due to For many, the move was a cynical rounding. The survey was self-commissioned and paid for by ARI. attempt at concentrating power in a Detailed tables are found at the end of this release.
    [Show full text]
  • AFN Alberta COVID-19 Bulletin
    AFN Alberta COVID-19 Bulletin Thursday, January 14, 2021 AFN Alberta is summarizing updates and information we are receiving on our website. All our previous bulletins can be found on this page as well: http://www.afnab.ca/News-and-Events/Coronavirus. The next bulletin will be sent Thursday, January 21, 2021. HIGHLIGHTS January 6 January 13 Change* Tests Completed 2,873,566 2,950,446 +76,880 Total Positive 107,501 112,743 +5,242 Active 13,450 13,220 -230 Fatalities 1,193 1,345 +152 Recoveries 92,858 98,178 +5,320 COVID-19 Regional Data for Alberta COVID-19 in Indigenous Peoples (both on and off reserve) Calgary zone - 43,140 Edmonton zone - 47,798 (As of January 06) Central zone - 7,834 Total - 8,716 On-Reserve only - 3,754 Active - 2,066 South zone - 5,300 North zone - 8,494 Current Hospital - 127 Current ICU - 33 Unidentified zone - 177 Recovered - 5,776 Deaths - 61 FN Cases by Zone (both on and off reserve) North - 2,298 Central - 2,045 South - 428 Calgary - 1,441 Edmonton - 2,485 Feedback Wanted! ● As we enter the new year, we appreciate how you have all supported your Nations in combating COVID-19. We hope that our weekly bulletin has helped to inform and guide you along the way. We’ve received some good feedback on the value of this bulletin as an informational tool, and we are looking to make it even better! ● Please send your suggestions for the kinds of information you would like to see in the bulletin or focus areas going forward to p [email protected] New Measures ● *NEW* P rovincial restrictions on gathering and other enhanced public health restrictions remain in effect until at least January 21, 2021.
    [Show full text]
  • Evidence of the Standing Committee on Health
    43rd PARLIAMENT, 2nd SESSION Standing Committee on Health EVIDENCE NUMBER 007 Friday, November 20, 2020 Chair: Mr. Ron McKinnon 1 Standing Committee on Health Friday, November 20, 2020 ● (1305) are available for this meeting. You have the choice at the bottom of [English] your screen of either “Floor”, “English” or “French”. The Chair (Mr. Ron McKinnon (Coquitlam—Port Coquit‐ Before speaking, click on the microphone icon to activate your lam, Lib.)): I call this meeting to order. own mike. When you are done speaking, please put your mike on mute to minimize any interference. Welcome, everyone, to meeting number 7 of the House of Com‐ mons Standing Committee on Health. The committee is meeting I will give a reminder that all comments by members and wit‐ again today to discuss the supplementary estimates (B) for 2020-21. nesses should be addressed through the chair. Should members I want to thank the witnesses for appearing again today. need to request the floor outside of their designated time for ques‐ We have as witnesses the Honourable Patty Hajdu, Minister of tions, they should activate their mike and state that they have a Health. We have, from the Department of Health, Deputy Minister point of order. Stephen Lucas and Les Linklater, federal lead for COVID-19 test‐ ing, contract tracing and data management strategies. If a member wishes to intervene on a point of order that has been raised by another member, they should use the “raise hand” func‐ With us from the Public Health Agency of Canada are Dr. There‐ tion. This will signal to the chair your interest in speaking and cre‐ sa Tam, chief public health officer, and Iain Stewart, president.
    [Show full text]